SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
This is a presentation delivered at the 2024 FECM/NETL Spring Project Review Meeting as part of the Reversible Solid Oxide Fuel Cell track. The presentation highlights recent progress made in the system analysis efforts as part of the NETL SOFC Field Work Proposal in 2023-2024.
Among the various fuel cells, solid oxide cells (SOCs) are the unique type that can principally operate reversibly as either fuel cells to produce electricity or as an electrolyser to split water and produce green hydrogen (H 2 ). Nevertheless, the SOCs' reversibility presents enormous challenges that are manifested by the fast degradation through the cycling between fuel cell and electrolysis mode. While the La 0.8 Sr 0.2 MnO 3 /yttria-stabilized zirconia (LSM/YSZ) air electrode possesses significant advantages in terms of high electrical conductivity and high thermal stability under fuel cell mode, the SOCs with the LSM/YSZ air electrode experience rapid performance degradation with catastrophic electrode delamination shortly after switching from fuel cell to electrolysis mode. To prevent such catastrophic delamination and enable the electrolysis H 2 production, a chemical solution with the designed chemistry of SrFe 2 O 4-d was infiltrated into the LSM/YSZ air electrode. The infiltration immediately mitigates the catastrophic delamination, and the infiltrated cells exhibit significantly improved reversibility upon the electrochemical operation. Nanostructure examination reveals nanoscale cracks and second-phase nanograins formed in the air electrode from the baseline cell. By contrast, no delamination was observed at either the micron or the nanoscale for the infiltrated cell, which is attributed to the increased ion conductivity of the Fe-doped LSM mixed conductor induced by the significant interdiffusion between the LSM backbone and infiltrates. Here, this study presents a viable method for preventing electrode delamination while enhancing the durability of H 2 production and power generation for reversible fuel cell/electrolysis cell operation. It further opens new research directions of modifying the electrochemical activity of the electrode of inherently functional cells through the infiltration of the solutions with different chemistry.
National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) provides system-level process, cost, and market analyses on solid oxide cell (SOC) based technologies. Specifically, techno-economic analyses (TEA), market assessments, and other technology evaluations serve to guide the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management (FECM) Reversible Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (R-SOFC) Program technology goals and objectives. These studies are key to describing how the technologies contribute to improving domestic energy infrastructure in a clean, efficient manner. This effort focuses on hydrogen generation technologies, which have received recent attention due to their potential role in economy-wide decarbonization. In particular, the study is part of a series of investigations at NETL that seek to understand the techno-economic impacts of including SOC technology in energy production, hydrogen production, and/or storage configurations. The objective of this study is to establish a detailed TEA to assess the effectiveness of incremental technology improvements needed for solid oxide electrolysis cell (SOEC) technology to achieve the U.S. DOE’s Hydrogen Shot goal of hydrogen production at less than $1 per kilogram. To take advantage of the benefits of economies of scale, the SOEC hydrogen facilities are sized to produce ≈250,000 metric tons of hydrogen annually with an electrolysis load of one gigawatt (direct current). Some additional critical assumptions include stacks that operate near the thermo-neutral voltage of 1.28 V to avoid adverse thermal gradients, all necessary steam and heat is generated by electric boilers and heaters to enable green hydrogen production, and an air sweep is used to control the oxygen concentration in the air electrode exhaust stream. System efficiency and levelized costs of hydrogen (LCOH) for each case are presented.
The performance of reversible solid oxide electrochemical cells (R-SOECs) is largely hindered by the insufficient electroactivity and poor durability of the bifunctional air electrodes, where the oxygen reduction and evolution reactions (ORR and OER) occur. Here, we report our findings in boosting the electrochemical activity and durability of an air electrode with Pr 0.2 Ba 0.2 Sr 0.2 La 0.2 Ca 0.2 CoO 3-δ (PBSLCC) via an A-site entropy engineering. The PBSLCC electrode shows enhanced oxygen reaction activity and excellent durability compared to binary and ternary double perovskites (PrBaCo 2 O 5+δ and Pr 0.8 Ba 0.8 Ca 0.4 Co 2 O 5+δ , respectively). A low and nearly unchanged area-specific resistance of 0.042Ωcm 2 is achieved at 750 °C during the 225-h stability test. La 0.9 Sr 0.1 Ga 0.8 Mg 0.2 O 3-δ electrolyte-supported cells with the PBSLCC air electrode show remarkable performance at 800 °C, demonstrating a peak power density of 1.2Wcm -2 in the fuel cell mode, and a current density of -1.1 Acm -2 at 1.3 V in the electrolysis mode while maintaining the excellent cycling durability of 228 h at ±0.5 Acm -2 under humidified H 2 (10% H 2 O). A bulk oxygen p-band center model is applied to verify that tailoring of the A-site entropy strongly influences the surface exchange coefficients (k* chem ), leading to higher oxygen reaction activity of PBSLCC than the binary and ternary perovskites. Finally, this study opens a new class of high-entropy perovskites for the rational design of air electrodes for R-SOECs with high activity and durability.
The project objective was to demonstrate a solid oxide cell-based steam electrolysis stack that exhibits robustness, reliability, endurance, hydrogen purity, and produces hydrogen at elevated pressure of 2 to 3 bar. Innovative materials and processing methods were evaluated to improve degradation characteristics. Performance improvement focused on nearly all layers involved in the cell and stack assembly. Primary attention was paid to zirconia-ceria interface resistance control via sintering optimization and decrease in degradation from the oxygen electrode by evaluating low strontium (Sr) or Sr-free composition for both the oxygen electrode and current collection layer. Stack robustness was addressed by validating redox tolerance of fuel electrode, confirming capability of cells to survive repeated thermal cycles, studying the effect of pressure on performance and degradation, evaluating the effect of contamination on fuel and oxygen electrode performance and degradation, and identifying mitigation strategies to improve performance. The characterization included evaluation of electrochemical performance and stability followed by microstructural analysis. At the cell level, performance and stability improvements were achieved by incorporating a Sr-free oxygen electrode and a denser oxygen electrode barrier layer. At the stack level, pressurized operation reduces demand on first stage compression, the redox tolerant fuel electrode mitigates risk from service interruptions, and improvements to interconnect coating alleviate chromium (Cr) contamination effects. The denser barrier layer was achieved by adding a sintering aid to the samaria-doped ceria (SDC) composition that reduced sintering temperature by 150 °C. The resulting density was on par with the baseline SDC barrier layer density and the lower sintering temperature resulted in less resistive phase formation during sintering. Button cell tests did not demonstrate a change in performance when exposed to silicon (Si) or manganese (Mn) impurities to the fuel electrode and Cr impurity to the oxygen electrode. More detailed study however is warranted. The project addressed SOEC performance and stability at the cell and stack levels through a systematic approach to known sources of degradation that were combined and tested in three stack tests using an electrolyte supported cell design to allow for evaluation of a variety of fuel and oxygen electrode compositions. STK-82 and STK-83 had identical compositions. STK-100 incorporated the best materials and processing variables developed under this and concurrent projects, and was tested at elevated pressure in steam electrolysis. • STK-82 recovered performance after redox and thermal cycling, demonstrating the robustness of the stack and seals. It exhibited stable performance in testing for 500 hours in SOEC mode, followed by 300 hours of cycling between SOEC and SOFC tests. Degradation during SOEC operation was 1.8 %/ 1,000 hours. • STK-83 generated hydrogen at >80% steam conversion, and oxygen above 98.5 % purity during pressurized operation. Both hydrogen and oxygen were generated at 3 barg pressure without the use of a pressure vessel. In addition to balanced pressure, electrolysis operation at 1 bar differential pressure across anode and cathode was also demonstrated to substantial the robustness of the cell and seal. • STK-100 measured at initial ambient pressure conditions showed an area specific resistance of 1.1 ohm-cm 2 , and STK-83 had 1.3 ohm-cm 2 .
The pursuit of clean, secure, and sustainable energy has sparked significant interest in fuel cells for power generation and electrolyzer cells for hydrogen production. Among all types of fuel and electrolyzer cells, solid oxide cells (SOCs) have emerged as promising candidates due to their high efficiency and versatility. However, conventional oxygen-ion conductive SOCs face several challenges related to their performance and durability associated with their high-temperature operation (≥ 800 ºC). This has led to a growing interest in intermediate-temperature (≤ 650 ºC) proton-conducting solid oxide cells (p-SOCs) as potential alternatives. In collaboration between Phillips 66 and Georgia Tech, this project aims to achieve a 1 kW p-SOCs system to demonstrate the commercial viability of efficient SOC systems. This report addresses four primary areas and key challenges we overcame: (1) development of efficient and durable proton-conducting electrolyte (e.g., BaHf 0.1 Ce 0.7 Yb 0.2 O 3-δ ) and electrode/catalyst materials, (2) large area cell fabrication (10 x 10 cm 2 ), (3) scalable stack design and building (250 W and 1 kW), and (4) demonstration of a 1 kW prototype system. Notably, significant challenges faced during the large area cell fabrication process were addressed by achieving cell flatness, improving fabrication yield, and ensuring electrode/electrolyte interfacial adhesion. Stack designs were also developed, focusing on reducing contact resistance and optimizing stack components (e.g., sealants). These efforts resulted in the achievement of high performance and durability with promising outputs of 250 W and 1 kW. Furthermore, the integration of these stacks into a fuel-powered system was explored, with refinements made to heat management, as well as to pressure and heating conditions. The results demonstrated the potential applicability of our p-SOC technology in commercial energy storage and power generation systems. Additionally, the report discusses techno-economic analysis and a market transformation plan, aiming to evaluate and advance the commercial feasibility of this technology.
The overall purpose of this project was to reduce the Reversible-Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (R-SOFC) system cost by developing two technologies, an improved cell design and the incorporation of an ejector in the fuel recycle loop instead of a blower. A Simulink model of the baseline SOFC system was developed and calibrated with experimental test data. The R-SOFC system model was built by integrating GT Suite developed models of the steam generation components into the baseline Simulink SOFC system model. The ability to run the stack in SOEC operating mode was also added to the model. The system model was used to explore the ability of the R-SOFC system to meet operational constraints on Steam/Carbon ratio and H2 concentration on the fuel side electrode. A CFD ejector model was developed and used to explore a range of ejector design parameters, leading to the final ejector design that was prototyped for testing. A prototype steam ejector was first tested in a laboratory environment using room temperature air. The steam ejector was subsequently tested using the full hot recycle loop with all relevant heat exchangers and steam generation components. The test conditions utilized temperatures, pressures, and flow rates expected in an R-SOFC application. Throughout the experimental testing work, ejector performance test data was used to improve and then validate the CFD ejector model. A CFD cell model was developed and used to optimize thermal gradients, voltage, and cost of a new cell substrate design. A CFD comparison of co-flow and cross-flow cell designs informed the decision to use a co-flow design for the new cell substrate. Multiple rounds of CFD simulation were used to improve the cell design to minimize the variation in air and fuel distribution across cell channels and to minimize the variation in air and fuel distribution across different cells in the stack. A few prototypes of the new cell substrate design were produced and validated in a laboratory environment by thermally spraying and verifying that they met established manufacturing specifications. The cell manufacturing process was adjusted in order to bring these metrics within acceptable tolerances. Cummins’ internal calculations show that the new cell design reduces cost ~50% compared to the baseline cell, while the ejector + superheater/boiler concept reduces cost of the recycle loop by ~40%. The impact of these cost reductions on the cost of producing H2 will depend on the specific system where they are applied. Therefore, a Techno-Economic Analysis was completed using system cost as a variable, and showing how the NREL Current and Future system costs translate into H2 production cost.
The solid oxide metal-air redox batteries (SOMARB), composed of reversible solid oxide fuel cell (RSOFC) and energy storage unit (ESU), is an emerging technology for large-scale energy storage owing to its advantages in high energy density, high rate capability, decoupled energy and power components, all solid state structure, high safety and scalability. Starting with introducing the working principle of this battery, thermodynamics and kinetics, and battery chemistries based on Fe, Mo, and Wo of SOMARB are illustrated. The strategies to improve the performance of Fe-based SOMARB via optimizing RSOFC and ESU are discussed in detail. Finally, several high temperature metal-air batteries derived from SOMARB are introduced. The comparison with other batteries shows that SOMARB is expected to play an important role in future grid and renewable energy storage with concurrent advances in SOFC stack and system design.
23rd Annual Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (SOFC) Project Review Meeting, Pittsburgh, PA, October 25-27, 2022
Modular pressurized hotbox for use and substitution in a variety of pressurized electrochemical applications to include reversible solid oxide electrolyzer and fuel cells, energy storage systems, renewable fuel production, solid-state hydrogen pumping and liquefaction, and oxygen transport membranes. This is enabled by mixed electronic and ionic conducting compositions of vanadia-yttria and vanadia-calcia stabilized zirconia and a dry powder method of manufacture for ceramic core stacks.
National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) provides system-level process, cost, and market analyses on solid oxide cell (SOC) based technologies. Specifically, techno-economic analyses (TEA), market assessments, and other technology evaluations serve to guide the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Fossil Energy and Carbon Management (FECM) Reversible Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (R-SOFC) Program technology goals and objectives. These studies are key to describing how the technologies contribute to improving domestic energy infrastructure in a clean, efficient manner. This effort seeks to elucidate the potential integration opportunities between reversible SOCs and industrial systems which would aid in SOC commercialization and deployment. These preliminary screening-level results show what opportunities exist for power generating SOFCs, hydrogen producing SOECs, and point-source carbon capture. Improvements can be seen through changes in cost of electricity, cost of hydrogen, and cost of carbon capture.
The commercial product resulting from this R&D project will enable cost-effective synthesis of the Carbon Neutral Liquid Fuel (CNLF) ammonia, a common chemical, at a small scale for energy and industrial applications using only intermittent renewable energy, water, and air as feedstocks. These products are also capable of producing electrical energy from the CNLF in a fuel cell mode of operation. Thus, the eventual commercial product enables both single direction production of either CLNF or electricity, or alternatively functions as a fully reversible, self-contained energy storage device. The renewed interest in developing electrolysis systems is driven, in part, by the burgeoning renewable, solar, and wind industries and the need for an energy conversion and storage technology that can convert intermittent solar and wind energy into the production of hydrogen. Electrolysis systems integrated into both distributed and central renewable power plants would utilize solar and wind energy as their primary power source to produce renewably generated hydrogen for local energy storage or chemical feedstock purposes. Ammonia is an excellent surrogate for hydrogen transportation. NH3 presents an attractive alternative to hydrogen as a working fluid in reversible devices towards a sustainable green energy-oriented future. Ammonia can be easily liquefied at room temperature at about 8 bar or at -33°C at ambient pressure. In contrast, the liquefaction temperature of hydrogen is -253°C at ambient pressure. NH3 has a significantly higher volumetric energy density (12.7 MJ/L) than compressed hydrogen (4.5 MJ/L at ~70 MPa) or liquefied hydrogen (8.5 MJ/L). Additionally, ammonia is a widely used raw material for agriculture fertilizer and thus has well-established storage, transport, and handling processes (about 180 million tons of ammonia are produced annually). Techno-economic analysis suggests ammonia is the least expensive fuel among hydrogen, gasoline, natural gas, liquefied petroleum gas, and methanol.
Solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) can directly convert the chemical energy in fuel to electrical energy with fuel flexibility; however, the conventional nickel-based anodes face great challenges due to coking upon direct oxidation of hydrocarbon fuels and redox instability. Thus, developing new anode materials which can provide high coking resistance as well as redox stability is crucial. In this work, Ba 0.6 La 0.4 Fe 0.8 Mo 0.1 Ni 0.1 O 3-δ (BLFMN) has been synthesized in air using a sol–gel combustion method, resulting in a dual phase consisting of a cubic BLFMN main phase and scheelite BaMoO 4 (BMO 4 ) secondary phase. By heat-treating the BLFMN dual phase in H 2 at 800 °C for 5 h, a metallic nanoparticle-decorated BLFMN triple phase compound comprising cubic BLFMN, cubic BaMoO 3 (BMO 3 ) and in situ exsolved FeNi 3 alloy was obtained. BLFMN was subsequently investigated as an electrode material for La 0.8 Sr 0.2 Ga 0.83 Mg 0.17 O 3-δ (LSGM) electrolyte (300 μm) supported SOFCs. Symmetrical cells using BLFMN as electrodes with the cell configuration of BLFMN//LSGM//BLFMN showed excellent redox reversibility and a peak power density (PPD) of 1.32 W cm -2 at 850 °C when using H 2 as fuel. Single cell with the cell configuration of BLFMN//LSGM//LSCF (La 0.6 Sr 0.4 Co 0.2 Fe 0.8 O 3-δ ) reached PPD of 1.61 and 0.41 W cm -2 at 850 °C when operating with H 2 and CH 4 fuel, respectively. Moreover, the single cell exhibit excellent stability (over 300 h) upon direct oxidation of hydrocarbon fuels of CH 4 and C 3 H 8 . This study indicates that BLFMN is a promising redox reversible and coking resistant anode for SOFCs.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This report was generated based upon work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy’s Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) under the Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies Office, H2@Scale Initiative, Award Number DE-EE0008847. In this project, FuelCell Energy studied the design and performance of a system rated for 15kWe Charge/3 kWe Discharge energy storage system based on reversible solid-oxide technology.
Solid oxide fuel cells (SOFC) and solid oxide electrolysis cells (SOEC) have received great interest due to their highly effective reversibility as power generation and H2 production system without releasing any greenhouse gases into environment. The LSCF electrode exhibits a higher structural and performance stability under both SOFC and SOEC operation due to its mixed ionic and electronic conductivity, and there is no immediate delamination taking place during the initial several hundred hours operation. However, the LSCF based air electrode still presents significant performance degradation (with the increased resistance) over the prolonged operation, such as over 1000 hours of operation under SOFC and SOEC. The influence factors for the cell’s performance and stability need to be optimized to improve the power generation for SOFC and H2 production for SOEC. The effects of operational temperature on the performance and durability for both SOFC and SOEC are electrochemical operation dependent. The performance and performance durability for the first 1500h were currently studied under optimized operational temperature for reversible SOFC/SOEC.
Energy storage and production in space requires rugged, reliable hardware which minimizes weight, volume, and maintenance while maximizing power output and usable energy storage. These systems generally consist of photovoltaic solar arrays which operate during sunlight cycles to provide system power and regenerate fuel (hydrogen) via water electrolysis; during dark cycles, hydrogen is converted by the fuel cell into system. The currently preferred configuration uses two separate systems (fuel cell and electrolyzer) in conjunction with photovoltaic cells. Fuel cell/electrolyzer system simplicity, reliability, and power-to-weight and power-to-volume ratios could be greatly improved if both power production (fuel cell) and power storage (electrolysis) functions can be integrated into a single unit. The Technology Management, Inc. (TMI), solid oxide fuel cell-based system offers the opportunity to both integrate fuel cell and electrolyzer functions into one unit and potentially simplify system requirements. Based an the TMI solid oxide fuel cell (SOPC) technology, the TMI integrated fuel cell/electrolyzer utilizes innovative gas storage and operational concepts and operates like a rechargeable 'hydrogen-oxygen battery'. Preliminary research has been completed on improved H2/H2O electrode (SOFC anode/electrolyzer cathode) materials for solid oxide, regenerative fuel cells. Improved H2/H2O electrode materials showed improved cell performance in both fuel cell and electrolysis modes in reversible cell tests. ln reversible fuel cell/electrolyzer mode, regenerative fuel cell efficiencies (ratio of power out (fuel cell mode) to power in (electrolyzer model)) improved from 50 percent (using conventional electrode materials) to over 80 percent. The new materials will allow the TMI SOFC system to operate as both the electrolyzer and fuel cell in a single unit. Preliminary system designs have also been developed which indicate the technical feasibility of using the TMI SOFC technology for space applications with high energy storage efficiencies and high specific energy. Development of small space systems would also have potential dual-use, terrestrial applications.