DOE OSTI2016
The objective of this paper is to ascertain the existence of a specimen size threshold, below which the material no longer exhibits bulk mechanical behavior when tested using in situ transmission electron microscopic (TEM) micro-compression pillars. In this work, sub-micron sized pillars of a model Fe-9Cr oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) alloy were compressed in TEM in situ at room temperature, and attempts have been made to quantify the resulting data. Results are compared to mechanical property values in the archival literature, and a discussion on the validity of quantitative in situ TEM micro-compression data for ODS steel is included. In situ TEM mechanical testing is a relatively new technique enabling concurrent TEM imaging and mechanical testing of sub-micron-sized electron-transparent specimens. Due to limited sample volume of many nuclear materials, in situ TEM mechanical testing holds great promise for advancing our understanding of deformation phenomena. But it is well known that the dramatically reduced specimen size required for in situ testing can affect quantitative and qualitative deformation behaviors. However, Kiener, et al. used in situ TEM micro-compression pillars on irradiated and unirradiated single-crystal copper. They observed size independence in the irradiated material, while the unnirradiated material displayed a size threshold below which the mechanical properties deviated from those of bulk Cu. They assert that the more densely-spaced obstacles in irradiated Cu allow it to display bulk properties even in specimens having ∼ 100 nm dimensions. Similar to Kiener's findings, we hypothesize that unirradiated ODS will demonstrate a size threshold, but the in situ TEM micro-compression technique can be extended from single crystal materials to engineering alloys. An Fe-9Cr model ODS alloy was chosen for this study because of the broad interest in ODS for advanced nuclear reactors. ODS alloys exhibit high irradiation tolerance and high temperature creep resistance. New insight into deformation processes gained through in situ TEM mechanical testing could be valuable for the validation of ODS alloys for next generation nuclear reactors. The fact that the compressive yield stress and elastic modulus do not follow distinct trends as a function of specimen size is likely due to the high density of obstacles to dislocation motion. The ODS microstructure contains such obstacles as oxide nanoparticles, a fine grain structure, a high density of dislocation lines, and carbide precipitates. Since the deformation behavior is governed by the minimum separation distance between obstacles [1], it is plausible that the high obstacle density enables ODS alloy micropillars to exhibit bulk-like mechanical properties even prior to irradiation. Future work will focus on: (1) developing finite element models to help explain the difference in elastic moduli between bulk and micropillar tests, (2) understanding the spread in yield stress measurements at fixed micropillar volumes, and (3) extending this study to irradiated ODS. (authors)