Deciphering the Conflict Between Ion and Electron Percolating Networks in Solid-State Battery Cathodes
High-energy- and power-density solid state batteries require an optimal cathode composition and microstructural arrangement of cathode active material, solid-state electrolyte, conductive carbon, and binder to simultaneously support lithium-ion transport, electron conduction, and storage capacity. The ion and electron conducting phases in solid-state cathodes counteract each other's percolating networks as their mass ratios increase or decrease relative to each other. Here, we investigate targeted mass ratio variations of argyrodite solid electrolyte and two different types of conductive carbon (particles and fibers) in composite LiNi0.8Mn0.1Co0.1O2 (NMC811) solid-state cathodes to ascertain the ionic-electronic tradeoffs in cathode performance. Through ionic and electronic conductivity measurements on composite cathodes, as well as rate-testing and cycling performance in full cells, it is shown that the conductive carbon fibers form a percolative electronic network within the composite at a lower mass ratio (3-5 wt%) than particulate carbon (>5 wt%). The threshold to achieve electronic percolation coincides with higher accessible capacity in the cathode as the active material particles become electronically connected. However, carbon loadings beyond this percolation threshold lead to increased ion transport resistance, arising from disruptions to ionic conduction pathways and degraded contact at the interface between the electrolyte and active materials. Imaging, spectroscopy, and physics-based models quantitatively describe the relationship between carbon and electrolyte compositions and the cell's capacity and rate performance through percolation theory. This work demonstrates the importance of quantitatively understanding percolating networks in solid-state cells and that strategic engineering of conductive carbon morphologies can further increase the energy- and power-density of solid-state cells.