The Principal Hugoniot of Kinetic and Plasma Sprayed Metallic Deposits Up to 10 GPa
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Abstract not provided.
The motivation of the present study is to gain insights into the evolution of elastic properties of cemented tungsten carbides (WC) shock compressed to 100 GPa. Seven plate impact experiments—two front surface impact and five release wave overtake—are conducted to make simultaneous measurements of Hugoniot states and longitudinal sound speeds in shocked WC with 3.7wt.% cobalt binder. The sound speeds along with estimates for bulk sound speeds, obtained using the Birch–Murnaghan EoS, are analyzed to determine the elastic moduli—longitudinal, bulk, and shear—as a function of Hugoniot stress. The longitudinal and bulk sound speeds at Hugoniot states of interest are found to increase linearly with longitudinal stress. Consistent with the increase in sound speeds, the longitudinal and bulk moduli also increase with Hugoniot stress; however, the increase in longitudinal modulus is modest when compared to predictions of theoretical models that account for pressure and temperature dependence of elastic moduli, but with no damage. The shear moduli remain nearly constant at ~318 GPa over the range of Hugoniot states investigated. These values are, however, much lower than those predicted by the Steinberg–Guinan model with no damage. Poisson’s ratio decreases initially from its ambient value of 0.208 to ~0.199 for Hugoniot stress ≤10 GPa indicating consolidation of the WC microstructure with low initial stress; however, with an increase in Hugoniot stress to ~100 GPa, Poisson’s ratio increases to ~0.317, indicating degradation of shear moduli with increasing stress. The product of density and Grüneisen parameter (ρΓ), after an initial spike, remains nearly constant for volumetric strains ≥0.07. The maximum average temperature rise is estimated to be ~286°C at the highest Hugoniot stress employed in the study.
The shock Hugoniot of heterogenous mixtures of discrete particles has been experimentally investigated for porous agglomerates and fluids, while the study of full-density solids has been primarily limited to compressed powders and high-dimensional composites. By dispersing ceria nanoparticles in a polyethylene matrix, we are able to examine the hydrodynamic behavior of a nonporous, heterogenous solid in thermal equilibrium during weak shock compression. Phase-driven discontinuities in the Hugoniot particle velocity–shock velocity (u−D) relationship of pure polyethylene are replicated in the nanocomposites but are shifted to lower velocity and to higher pressure with higher particle concentration. The results are explained using an isothermal, two-velocity fluid model under the hydrodynamic approximation. The model, which assumes a theoretical equation-of-state for ceria and either a low-order or high-order fit to the measured polyethylene Hugoniot, reasonably predicts the Hugoniot for two different polyethylene/ceria nanocomposites. Using the model, the mixture Hugoniot is shown to be insensitive to the Hugoniot of the stiffer constituent when the moduli are sufficiently disparate, while dependence on particle density and volume fraction is preserved through fluid-like motion.
Single pulse (~100 ps duration) extended x-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) measurements were obtained in laser shocked Pt to examine atomic vibrational properties and to determine temperatures for shock pressures from 72-325 GPa. Pt x-ray absorption spectra were recorded while a planar shock wave was propagating through the Pt sample. The absorption spectrum corresponding to the shocked Pt was obtained by subtracting the ambient Pt contribution from the measured absorption spectrum. Fits to the shocked state EXAFS data provided Pt lattice parameters consistent with the known Pt Hugoniot and the mean squared relative displacements (MSRDs) for nearest neighbor Pt atoms. Pt temperatures in the shocked state, estimated from the MSRDs using the correlated Debye model and correlated Einstein models, were consistent with both the Hugoniot temperatures calculated by integration along the Hugoniot and with the Hugoniot temperatures from published first-principles calculations. However, the agreement between the Hugoniot temperatures from EXAFS measurements and the calculated Hugoniot temperatures is not as good above 200 GPa, likely due to anharmonic effects. Furthermore, the present results demonstrate that single-pulse synchrotron EXAFS measurements in laser-shocked solids are useful for quantitative temperature determination and for examination of vibrational properties, including anharmonicity, at extreme pressure-temperature conditions.
In the present study, shock wave experiments are conducted on General Carbide cemented tungsten carbides with 3.7 wt.% and 6.0 wt.% cobalt binder to determine their shock compression response up to 100 GPa. A three-stage particle velocity profile is observed in the experiments -- an initial elastic-rise to the Hugoniot elastic limit (HEL), an elastic-plastic ramp indicating post-yield hardening, and finally a rise to the peak shocked Hugoniot state. The results of the experiments are used to determine the HEL, shock velocity (U s ) vs. particle velocity (u p ) Hugoniot relationship, and the longitudinal stress vs. specific volume Hugoniot relationship for the two samples. Here, the HEL for the WC 3.7wt% Co and WC 6.0wt% Co samples was determined to be ~4.45 GPa and 3.72 GPa, respectively. The U s – u p relation was determined to be U s = 4.97(0.006)+1. 446 (0.018) u p for WC 3.7 wt.% Co and U s = 4.93(0.006)+1. 454(0.017)u p for the WC 6.0 wt.% Co sample at peak particle velocities>0.75 km/s. For both WC grades, in the particle velocity regime less than ~0.75 km/s, the measured shock wave velocities were found to be larger than those predicted by the linear U s –u p Hugoniot relationship, indicating the two WC samples to preserve substantial strength in the post-yield deformation regime. Both WC grades show a catastrophic drop in shear stress carrying capacity when shocked to longitudinal stresses greater than ~70 GPa.
In this work, to determine crystal anisotropy effects at high stresses, peak states behind the plastic shock waves were examined in BCC single crystals. Using plate impact experiments, molybdenum (Mo) single crystals were shock compressed up to 190 GPa elastic impact stress along [100], [110], and [111] orientations. Laser interferometry was used to measure wave velocities and particle velocity profiles at the Mo–LiF window interface. These data were analyzed to obtain in-material quantities in the peak states. The Hugoniots for [100] and [110] orientations were comparable, but the Hugoniot for the [111] orientation was different from the other two orientations. Also, these Mo single crystal Hugoniots display differences from the polycrystalline Mo Hugoniots. Although none of the differences can be considered large, the present results demonstrate that, unlike FCC metal single crystals (Cu, Al), some anisotropy is preserved in Mo single crystal Hugoniots even at high stresses.
Gas gun and other shock compression experiments often produce shock wave velocity measurements that are linearly associated with particle velocity. Traditionally, this empirical relationship is quantified with a single Hugoniot curve that is estimated using least squares regression. However, for downstream modeling and simulation tasks, it is often more useful to have multiple Hugoniot curves in the pressure–volume plane that are consistent with the data. We employ Bayesian uncertainty quantification methods as a framework for propagating measurement uncertainty through to model parameters and predictions. Specifically, this Tutorial shows how to sample multiple Hugoniot curves in the pressure–volume plane that are consistent with the shock wave-particle velocity measurements in a two-step Bayesian approach. First, we obtain an analytical expression for the posterior distribution of the linear model parameters using Bayesian linear regression. Second, we propagate samples from the posterior distribution through the Rankine–Hugoniot equations to yield Hugoniot curves in the pressure–volume plane. The procedure is demonstrated with publicly available data on argon, copper, and nickel, and compared against bootstrapping and linear regression. The Bayesian procedure is shown to be interpretable, computationally inexpensive, and less sensitive than an alternative bootstrapping approach to the removal of the point in the copper dataset that has the largest particle velocity. As a Tutorial on Bayesian methodology for the shock compression community, we provide several derivations and explanations that make this paper self-contained, and make all code and data available at github.com/llnl/BALSCD.
Recent examination of the cerium Hugoniot with pyrometry and x-ray diffraction (XRD) has revealed a narrow solid-liquid two-phase region. It has been suggested that nonequilibrium melting may be occurring along the Ce Hugoniot, with either melt kinetics or a sluggish α-ε transition impeding the transition. In particular, the kinetics of the α-ε is unknown and the location of the phase boundary is in dispute. Static measurements suggest a nearly vertical phase boundary that intersects the Hugoniot at 6–7 GPa. This lies in direct conflict with dynamic measurements along the Hugoniot observing α-Ce through incipient melt. This work presents dynamic experiments using XRD to examine the behavior of the α-ε phase transition. The results show that the α-ε phase transition occurs through a tetragonal distortion, with the transition beginning at temperatures below the solid Hugoniot. Following the initial deviation from an ideal fcc structure, the c/a ratio is found to gradually increase with no steady value observed in the ε phase within the range of these experiments (below 17 GPa). Multiple diffraction patterns captured during the peak stress state show no significant change in c/a ratio prior to uniaxial release, upon which Ce reverts to an fcc structure. Furthermore, the results indicate that the α-ε transition occurs rapidly, both on loading and release. An examination of the c/a ratio with increasing temperatures suggests 11.5 GPa as a lower bound for the location of the α-ε-liquid triple point.
Sapphire (Al 2 O 3 ), known for its remarkable incompressibility at ambient conditions, plays a pivotal role in both static and dynamic compression research. Accurately characterizing its equation of state (EoS) is essential for these applications. Here, we present a complete Hugoniot of Al 2 O 3 as locus of experimentally assessed, high-precision, pressure, density and temperature states up to 14 Mbar and 43 kK. The Hugoniot is established with single shock experiments using magnetically launched hyper velocity flyers on the Z Accelerator at Sandia National Laboratories. We explore principal Hugoniot states at very high shock 𝑇 and 𝑝 in the solid phase, tracking the solid-liquid boundary and culminating at 2.4-fold compression, where data provides a direct constraint on the liquid phase. Corresponding shock release data probe thermodynamic states complementary to the Hugoniot and place additional constraints on tabular EoS models. Our findings indicate a significant deviation from existing tabular EoS models for Al 2 O 3 dictating a comprehensive overhaul. We develop two advanced EoSs for Al 2 O 3 the SESAME 97412 model, featuring an extensive phase diagram that includes three solid phases and the liquid phase, and the updated LEOS 2200m2 model. EoS development is assisted with Quantum Molecular Dynamics simulations. Our experimental data allows for stringent testing of our EoSs. Both models accurately capture the Hugoniot of Al 2 O 3 up to the highest pressures and temperatures. Rigorous experimental determination of extreme pressures and temperatures, paired with sophisticated models, advances the frontier of EoS development beyond 1 terapascal.
In this study, shock wave experiments are conducted on General Carbide cemented tungsten carbide with 3.7wt.% cobalt binder to determine its shock-induced compression behavior up to 100 GPa. The measured wave profiles indicate the cemented tungsten carbide to undergo elastic-plastic deformation during shock compression. A three-stage particle velocity profile is observed in the experiments -- an initial elastic-rise to the Hugoniot Elastic Limit (HEL), an elastic-plastic ramp indicating substantial post-yield hardening, and finally a rise to the peak shocked Hugoniot state. The results of the experiments are used to determine the HEL, the shock velocity (U s ) vs. particle velocity (u p ) Hugoniot relation, and the longitudinal stress (σ x ) vs. specific volume (V) curve for the samples. The HEL of the material was determined to lie between 4.41 GPa and 4.58 GPa. The U s - u p relation was determined to be U s = 4.97 + 1. 457u p for particle velocities greater than 0.75 km/s. The measured plastic shock velocities for particle velocities less than 0.7 km/s were found to be larger than those predicted using the linear U s - u p Hugoniot relationship, indicating the cemented WC samples to preserve substantial shear strength in the post-yield deformation region. No phase transformation was observed up to 100 GPa.
We measured the Hugoniot, Hugoniot elastic limit (HEL), and spallation strength of laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) AlSi10Mg via uniaxial plate-impact experiments to stresses greater than 13 GPa. Despite its complex anisotropic microstructure, the LPBF AlSi10Mg did not exhibit significant orientation dependence or sample-to-sample variability in these measured quantities. We found that the Hugoniot response of the LPBF AlSi10Mg is similar to that of other Al-based alloys and is well approximated by a linear relationship: u s = 5.49 + 1.39u p . Additionally, the measured HELs ranged from 0.25 to 0.30 GPa and spallation strengths ranged from 1.16 to 1.45 GPa, consistent with values reported in other studies of LPBF AlSi10Mg and Al-based alloys. Furthermore, strain-rate and stress dependence of the spallation strength were also observed.
We present a series of plate-impact experiments on 17-4 stainless steel to study the effect of manufacturing method and heat treatment on the Hugoniot elastic limit (HEL), Hugoniot, phase transformation stress, and spallation strength. Two traditional manufacturing methods were considered, wrought processing and casting, as well as two additive manufacturing methods, laser powder-bed fusion (LPBF) and wire-fed electron beam (EBAM). For both LPBF and EBAM 17-4 stainless steel variants, two billets were printed, enabling the application of two unique heat treatments. The HEL stress depended heavily on the thermal history, with the HEL increasing after the formation of Cu-rich precipitates via heat treatment. The Hugoniot response both below and above the phase transition was unaffected by the manufacturing method or heat treatment. The phase transition stress depended heavily on the thermal history, with its variation being attributed to the presence of various microstructural features. This is supported by a marked increase in the phase transition stress after precipitation hardening. These results suggest that the notion of the phase transition stress being dictated by bulk composition is an oversimplification and the stress fields generated by the meso-scale structure are a dominant force. The spallation strength was lower in the cast material compared to all other 17-4 stainless steel variants due to the presence of brittle δ-ferrite inclusions. Additionally, a drop in the tensile strain-rate was observed in the spallation response above the phase transition stress, which was hypothesized to stem from the kinetics of the reversion to the low-pressure phase during spall.
Experiments were performed on grooved Sn and Cu samples to study the temporal evolution of microjets. Jets were generated by the impact of gun-launched flyer plates against the back of grooved targets made from either Cu or Sn (groove depth of ~250 μm). The Hugoniot states in the various Sn targets encompassed conditions where solid phases are maintained throughout (7 and 16 GPa) and also conditions where melting occurs upon the release of compression (25 and 34 GPa); the transition occurs near a Hugoniot pressure of 23 GPa. Cu targets at 27 and 56 GPa provide comparisons in which the jets move at similar speeds but remain solid. In all cases, the spatial distribution of mass within the microjets was measured using high-speed synchrotron radiography. The result is a time history of the jet thickness profile from which quantities like total jet mass and jet velocity can be derived. In both the solid and liquid states, we generally observe that an increase in the shock strength leads to an increase in jet mass. However, this trend breaks down for Hugoniot states near the transition from continuously solid to melted-on-release. This is evidenced by the observation that there was no difference in the rate of mass flow in Sn jets at 16 and 25 GPa, while similar pressure jumps on either side of this range caused substantial changes in the jet mass. This contrasts with the behavior of smaller polishing defects that were present on the same samples (~1 μm deep). From these, no ejecta mass was detected below the melt boundary, but obvious microjets were generated once melting occurred. This indicates that crossing the bulk melt-on-release threshold can alternately promote or inhibit the flow of mass into microjets based on the amplitude of the initial perturbation.
Hydrocarbon polymers are used in a wide variety of practical applications. In the field of dynamic compression at extreme pressures, these polymers are used at several high energy density (HED) experimental facilities. One of the most common polymers is poly(methyl methacrylate) or PMMA, also called Plexiglass® or Lucite®. Here, we present high-fidelity, hundreds of GPa range experimental shock compression data measured on Sandia’s Z machine. We extend the principal shock Hugoniot for PMMA to more than threefold compression up to 650 GPa and re-shock Hugoniot states up to 1020 GPa in an off-Hugoniot regime, where experimental data are even sparser. These data can be used to put additional constraints on tabular equation of state (EOS) models. The present results provide clear evidence for the need to re-examine the existing tabular EOS models for PMMA above ~120 GPa as well as perhaps revisit EOSs of similar hydrocarbon polymers commonly used in HED experiments investigating dynamic compression, hydrodynamics, or inertial confinement fusion.