Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “US NRC”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 55 records · Page 3

Development of an Updated Societal-Risk Goal for Nuclear Power Safety

This report briefly summarizes work done in FY 2013 on the subject LDRD. The working hypothesis is that societal disruption should be addressed in a safety goal. This is motivated by the point that the Fukushima disaster resulted in very little public dose, but enormous societal disruption; a goal that addressed societal disruption would fill a perceived gap in the US NRC safety goal structure. This year's work entailed analyzing the consequences of postulated accidents at various reactor sites in the US, specifically with a view to quantifying the number of people relocated and the duration of their relocation, to see whether this makes sense as a measure of societal disruption.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Comparisons of Wilks’ and Monte Carlo Methods in Response to the 10CFR50.46(c) Proposed Rulemaking

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) is proposing a new rulemaking on emergency core system/loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) performance analysis. In the proposed rulemaking, designated as 10CFR50.46(c), the US NRC put forward an equivalent cladding oxidation criterion as a function of cladding pre-transient hydrogen content. The proposed rulemaking imposes more restrictive and burnup-dependent cladding embrittlement criteria; consequently nearly all the fuel rods in a reactor core need to be analyzed under LOCA conditions to demonstrate compliance to the safety limits. New analysis methods are required to provide a thorough characterization of the reactor core in order to identify the locations of the limiting rods as well as to quantify the safety margins under LOCA conditions. With the new analysis method presented in this work, the limiting transient case and the limiting rods can be easily identified to quantify the safety margins in response to the proposed new rulemaking. In this work, the best-estimate plus uncertainty (BEPU) analysis capability for large break LOCA with the new cladding embrittlement criteria using the RELAP5-3D code is established and demonstrated with a reduced set of uncertainty parameters. Both the direct Monte Carlo method and the Wilks’ nonparametric statistical method can be used to perform uncertainty quantification. Wilks’ method has become the de-facto industry standard to perform uncertainty quantification in BEPU LOCA analyses. Despite its widespread adoption by the industry, the use of small sample sizes to infer statement of compliance to the existing 10CFR50.46 rule, has been a major cause of unrealized operational margin in today’s BEPU methods. Moreover the debate on the proper interpretation of the Wilks’ theorem in the context of safety analyses is not fully resolved yet, even more than two decades after its introduction in the frame of safety analyses in the nuclear industry. This represents both a regulatory and application risk in rolling out new methods. With the 10CFR50.46(c) proposed rulemaking, the deficiencies of the Wilks’ approach are further exacerbated. The direct Monte Carlo approach offers a robust alternative to perform uncertainty quantification within the context of BEPU analyses. In this work, the Monte Carlo method is compared with the Wilks’ method in response to the NRC 10CFR50.46(c) proposed rulemaking.

10CFR50.46(c)↗

Sensitivity Analysis of Lbloca In Response To 10 Cfr50.46c New Rulemaking

The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) is proposing a new rulemaking on emergency core system/loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) performance analysis. In the proposed rulemaking, designated as 10 CFR 50.46c, the US NRC puts forward an equivalent cladding oxidation criterion as a function of cladding pre-transient hydrogen content. The proposed rulemaking imposes more restrictive and burnupdependent cladding embrittlement criteria; consequently more fuel rods need to be analyzed under LOCA conditions to maintain the safety margin, in contrast to the current practice with which only one hot rod needs to be analyzed. New multi-physics analysis methods are required to provide a thorough characterization of the reactor core in order to identify the locations of the limiting rods and quantify safety margins under LOCA conditions. The U.S. DOE’s Light Water Reactor Sustainability (LWRS) Program has initiated a project to develop multi-physics analytical capabilities, called LOTUS, to support the industry in the transition to the proposed rule. An approach to uncertainty quantification and sensitivity analysis with LOTUS was developed. A typical four-loop PWR plant model was developed and simulated by RELAP5-3D with inputs generated from core design and fuel performance analyses, and uncertainty quantification and sensitivity analysis were performed with seventeen uncertain input parameters. The maximum equivalent cladding reacted ratio (ECRR) and peak clad temperature ratio (PCTR) were selected as the figures of merit (FOM). Pearson, Spearman, partial correlation coefficients, and Sobol indices were considered for all of the figures of merit in the sensitivity analysis.

10CFR50.46c↗

U.S. implementation of Q12{sup TM} zirconium alloy for improved stability of structural components

AREVA NP undertook the Q12{sup TM} research and development program to optimize the contribution to fuel assembly dimensional stability of structural components fabricated from ultra-low tin Zr-1Nb-Sn-Fe quaternary alloys. Because Q12{sup TM} is an evolutionary development of the current M5 alloy metallurgy, it benefits from the extensive industrial experience already gained with the latter. The Q12{sup TM} alloy is processed in the same way as M5, with slight increases in tin (Sn) and iron (Fe) contents. For structural components, these chemistry modifications provide higher irradiation creep strength and improved corrosion performance over Zircaloy-4. Fuel assemblies with quaternary alloy guide tubes are thus expected to increase robustness with respect to fuel assembly bow, improve growth characteristics, and maintain high burnup capability. The basic material properties have been determined through various in-core and out-of-core test programs. Components made from Q12{sup TM} have undergone irradiation in lead assemblies and in batch fuel for 13 Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) units worldwide. Fuel with Q12{sup TM} guide tubes and grids has achieved a fuel assembly average burnup of 60 GWd/tU. Post irradiation examinations of these components have demonstrated that Q12{sup TM} performs in a stable, predictable manner. AREVA NP has submitted a topical report (TR) for Q12{sup TM} as a structural material to the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission (US-NRC). This TR outlines the material behavior and performance of Q12{sup TM} for both guide tubes and grids. Once approved, implementation of Q12{sup TM} material throughout US PWR fuel designs will enhance dimensional stability of structural components. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Transient Safety Analysis of Fast Spectrum TRU Burning LWRs with Internal Blankets

The objective of this proposal was to perform a detailed transient safety analysis of the Resource-Renewable BWR (RBWR) core designs using the U.S. NRC TRACE/PARCS code system. This project involved the same joint team that has performed the RBWR design evaluation for EPRI and therefore be able to leverage that previous work. And because of their extensive experience with fast spectrum reactors and parfait core designs, ANL was also part the project team. The principal outcome of this project was the development of a state-of-the-art transient analysis capability for GEN-IV reactors based on Monte Carlo generated cross sections and the US NRC coupled code system TRACE/PARCS, and a state-of-the-art coupled code assessment of the transient safety performance of the RBWR.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Source Term Reduction for Advanced and Small Modular Boiling Water Reactors

The United States Department of Energy (US DOE) is currently supporting the development of various advanced and small modular reactor (SMR) designs. Several of these designs have commenced license application with the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (US NRC). These reactors have improved safety features that may significantly reduce radiological source terms in the event of design and beyond-design basis accidents. Specifically, some reactors feature a smaller containment volume relative to the available fission product depositional surface area, which supports increased fission product retention in the containment vessel. Pressurized water reactors (PWR) and boiling water reactors (BWR) with this feature include the integral pressurized water reactor (iPWR) and the BWRX-300 design by General Electric. A prior research program supported by the US DOE quantified the source term reduction associated with light water iPWRs and developed iPWR-specific theoretical models for fission product deposition rates. This program included a sequence of research projects that started with a feasibility study, development of theoretical models that predict higher deposition rates, and finally, development of empirical data for verification and validation of the theoretical models. The current project, which is a feasibility study, is the first step in a similar program to quantify the source term reduction associated with small and advanced light water BWRs.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Estimated External Doses to Members of the Public from Patients with {sup 131}I Treatment - Paper 143

To protect individuals from the radiation emitted by a patient receiving {sup 131}I treatment a licensee must estimate the maximum likely effective dose to members of the public. Under current guidance by the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), a licensee may authorize the release of the patient if the effective dose is unlikely to exceed 5 mSv. NRC provides guidance to its licensees, in NRC Regulatory Guide 8.39, on acceptable methods that may be used to calculate the dose to a member of the public that may result from releasing the patient. To further assist licensees in implementing the regulation, NRC used conservative assumptions to estimate the activity of radionuclide in a patient, and the dose rate at 1 meter from the patient, that would be indicators of a potential dose to a member of the public of 5 mSv. Licensees may use these tables as operational criteria for releasing a patient if the conservative assumptions are considered acceptable. Licensees may also perform their own calculations, using case-specific assumptions, to show compliance with 5 mSv release criterion. The scope of this work is to provide dose coefficients for a variety of plausible public exposure scenarios that could be used by licensees to to show compliance. In the patient-specific calculations, the licensee is free to consider factors such as occupancy factor, effective half-life of the radionuclide in the patient's body, and tissue shielding. A conservative method of calculating the maximum likely dose to members of the public is provided in NRC Reg. Guide 8.39, which assumes no tissue attenuation of by the patient's body, no biological component that reduces the effective half-life of the radionuclide, and the patient's body burden is a point source. The assumption of no biological removal from the body introduces some conservatism into dose estimates for {sup 131}I. Also, it has been shown that the assumption of a point source with no tissue attenuation substantially overestimates the dose rate to nearby persons. The current method for calculating the maximum dose rate to members of the public from a nuclear medicine patient provided in US-NRC Regulatory Guide 8.39 assumes the patient's body burden is a point-source. Lack of consideration of tissue attenuation by the patient's body and biological removal of the radionuclide leads to a substantial overestimate of the actual external dose rate to a nearby member of the public. However, use of these assumptions in estimating potential dose to a member of the public simplifies the calculations considerably and, although generally conservative, the calculations serve as a useful screening tool. Many, if not most patients, could be released on that basis. If not, then refined calculations may be used, and the coefficients described in this paper provide one of the means for refining the calculations in cases where the screening calculations were not adequate. (authors)

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Organ S values and effective doses for family members exposed to adult patients following I-131 treatment: A Monte Carlo simulation study

Purpose: To calculate organ S values (mGy/Bq-s) and effective doses per time-integrated activity (mSv/Bq-s) for pediatric and adult family members exposed to an adult male or female patient treated with I-131 using a series of hybrid computational phantoms coupled with a Monte Carlo radiation transport technique.Methods: A series of pediatric and adult hybrid computational phantoms were employed in the study. Three different exposure scenarios were considered: (1) standing face-to-face exposures between an adult patient and pediatric or adult family phantoms at five different separation distances; (2) an adult female patient holding her newborn child, and (3) a 1-yr-old child standing on the lap of an adult female patient. For the adult patient model, two different thyroid-related diseases were considered: hyperthyroidism and differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) with corresponding internal distributions of {sup 131}I. A general purpose Monte Carlo code, MCNPX v2.7, was used to perform the Monte Carlo radiation transport.Results: The S values show a strong dependency on age and organ location within the family phantoms at short distances. The S values and effective dose per time-integrated activity from the adult female patient phantom are relatively high at shorter distances and to younger family phantoms. At a distance of 1 m, effective doses per time-integrated activity are lower than those values based on the NRC (Nuclear Regulatory Commission) by a factor of 2 for both adult male and female patient phantoms. The S values to target organs from the hyperthyroid-patient source distribution strongly depend on the height of the exposed family phantom, so that their values rapidly decrease with decreasing height of the family phantom. Active marrow of the 10-yr-old phantom shows the highest S values among family phantoms for the DTC-patient source distribution. In the exposure scenario of mother and baby, S values and effective doses per time-integrated activity to the newborn and 1-yr-old phantoms for a hyperthyroid-patient source are higher than values for a DTC-patient source.Conclusions: The authors performed realistic assessments of {sup 131}I organ S values and effective dose per time-integrated activity from adult patients treated for hyperthyroidism and DTC to family members. In addition, the authors’ studies consider Monte Carlo simulated “mother and baby/child” exposure scenarios for the first time. Based on these results, the authors reconfirm the strong conservatism underlying the point source method recommended by the US NRC. The authors recommend that various factors such as the type of the patient's disease, the age of family members, and the distance/posture between the patient and family members must be carefully considered to provide realistic dose estimates for patient-to-family exposures.

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Analysis of attenuation data from the decommissioned ZIon unit 1 reactor pressure vessel beltline weld

In order to examine the attenuation of radiation damage through the thickness of an irradiated reactor pressure vessel (RPV), four segments were acquired from the Zion Unit 1 power plant RPV after the plant was decommissioned. The Zion Unit 1 RPV Beltline Weld Segment 1 was cut into seven blocks, consisting of five base metal and two beltline welds from the high fluence region of the segment. Through-wall test specimens were machined and tested. Specimens included those used for Charpy impact, Master Curve fracture toughness testing, and chemical analysis. The observed through-thickness ductile-to-brittle transition temperatures in the beltline weld deviated significantly from the expected behavior based on the attenuation of fast fluence as a function of depth into the RPV. Beginning at the inside surface, the 41-J Charpy transition temperature was either flat or slightly increasing until the ¾ -T location. The results of a simple, model-based analysis of the Zion beltline weld material that included the irradiation conditions and material chemistry were generally consistent with industry trend curves and the standard attenuation model, rather than the observed data. Although there was no archive material from the RPV available to permit measurement of the unirradiated properties, fracture toughness specimens fabricated from archive surveillance weld were used to obtain an estimate of the initial through-thickness values of the Charpy transition temperature. The Charpy shifts obtained using this approach were similarly in disagreement with the predictions of the US NRC Regulatory Guide 1.99, Rev. 2. However, testing of irradiated Charpy specimens taken from the RPV following post-irradiation annealing (10 hr. at 500 °C) provided a quite different estimate of the unirradiated properties which improved the agreement between the inferred through-thickness Charpy shifts and exponential attenuation model included in Regulatory Guide 1.99/2. In conclusion, the analysis of the Zion data and data obtained in previous post-mortem examinations of decommissioned RPVs indicates that more work is needed to understand the through-thickness properties of RPV materials in order to properly assess through-wall damage attenuation.

Charpy impact↗

Full-scale 3-D finite element modeling of a two-loop pressurized water reactor for heat transfer, thermal–mechanical cyclic stress analysis, and environmental fatigue life estimation

This paper discusses a system-level finite element model of a two-loop pressurized water reactor (PWR). Based on this model, system-level heat transfer analysis and subsequent sequentially coupled thermal-mechanical stress analysis were performed for typical thermal-mechanical fatigue cycles. The in-air fatigue lives of example components, such as the hot and cold legs, were estimated on the basis of stress analysis results, ASME in-air fatigue life estimation criteria, and fatigue design curves. Furthermore, environmental correction factors and associated PWR environment fatigue lives for the hot and cold legs were estimated by using estimated stress and strain histories and the approach described in US-NRC report: NUREG-6909.

Full-scale 3-D finite element model, Pressurized w↗

Evaluation of Sampling Inlets for Continuous Air Monitors in Calm Air Conditions

The Canberra NetCAM (networked continuous air monitor) can be operated with a radial inlet attachment from the manufacturer. Sampled aerosol can be transported through large diameter tubing from a desired location to the NetCAM sampler. In this assessment, the effect of the addition of the radial inlet was investigated. Also, a sampling system consisting of a vertical sample tube and a 90-degree elbow (to the horizontal plane) was evaluated by empirical calculations with the DEPO software. Generalized aspiration ratio calculations were done with the empirical model from Vincent. Three different sample probe types were also experimentally tested. In summary: (1) For typical room air conditions, the addition of the Canberra inline adapter to the NetCAM has no discernible effect on system performance. This was determined by literature search with a previously published study. (2) The DEPO software (US NRC / Texas A&M University) was used to show the effect of adding a 2-meter high vertical tube and a ninety-degree tube bend to a sampling inlet. In this example, there was a total penetration of 97.7% of 10-micron diameter aerosol particles for an air flowrate of 2.0 ACFM (actual cubic feet per minute). (3) Calculations of nozzle aspiration ratio (for general, non-specific situations) were performed using the Vincent empirical model. For example, in typical room air, where the average velocity is less than 0.5 m/sec, an aerosol inlet probe has a calculated aspiration ratio (or penetration efficiency) value between 98 and 100%, depending on the angle of the probe inlet compared to the direction of the incoming air velocity vector. A table of nozzle aspiration ratios was generated for a range of different room air velocities and probe inlet angles. (4) Three different candidate probe geometries were tested, (A) a probe with a vertical entry and vertical transport tube, (B) a probe with a horizontal entry and vertical transport tube, and (C) a ‘widemouth’ probe with a vertical entry and vertical transport tube. The experimentally determined values were 98%, 102%, and 100%, respectively, for the aerosol penetration into these inlets. In conclusion, the addition of a complete sampling system with probe inlet, a short length of sampling lines and the radial inlet would still be able to deliver about 95% of the sampled aerosol from the sampling location to the Canberra NetCAM.

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Risk and Cost Analysis of Utilizing FLEX Equipment for O&M Cost Reduction in Nuclear Power Plants

Several Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) operators in USA have announced to close their plants despite there are remaining years on their operating licenses. The cause of these closures is because the plant operators suffer financial losses. Approximately 80% of USA NPPs would have undergone financial losses if they were situated in a deregulated electricity market. In a deregulated market, electricity generators are independent entities separate from the transmission companies and Independent System Operator (ISO) which manages the market. NPPs in this market are termed merchant NPPs, and their profitability is determined solely from electricity generation revenues. Meanwhile, regulated and public power nuclear units’ profitability is determined by the regulatory process in place for each unit. Due to the complexity of differentiating each regulated and public power NPP’s regulations 36 NPPs are at an immediate risk of retiring early to stop losses, while 27 units will likely to follow in the long run. Today, cost is well-recognized and important factor in NPP decision-making that cannot be ignored. Therefore, it is essential to consider risk and cost together in decision-making to strengthen the position of the nuclear industry in an economically challenging energy market. With operational and maintenance (O&M) cost at 70% of the total operating expenditure of an NPP and some plants closing prematurely despite excellent safety record, there is an urgent need to address the high O&M cost. One of the novel entities that provide additional safety resulting in reduced risk of nuclear power plants is Flex equipment. Flex strategies were postulated by the US NRC in the wake of Fukushima Dai-chi accident to address beyond design-basis accidents and improve plant flexibility. Flex strategy comprise both onsite and off-site component storage for the provision of additional materials and equipment. This work explored innovative ways of utilizing the onsite Flex equipment during regular plant operation, for purposes in addition to the intended use of beyond design basis accidents. This report describes the risk and cost analysis of using Flex equipment during regular or unplanned maintenance.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Measurements of fission gas release from nuclear fuel in support of BISON fuel performance analysis

This project established a fuel irradiation and fission gas release (FGR) loop that has been designed for implementation at the PULSTAR reactor of North Carolina State University (NCSU). The FGR loop is capable of analyzing various types of fuel samples including, e.g., uranium dioxide fuel (UO 2 ) and uranium silicide (U 3 Si 2 ) samples. The fuel samples were produced and characterized at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) and shipped NCSU. The samples are ready for irradiation in the FGR loop to a given total thermal neutron fluence and under controlled temperature conditions. An innovative high resolution gamma-ray spectrometry approach and instrumentation have been established to monitor the loop’s sweep gas and perform high accuracy measurements of the gas release rates relative to predicted birth rates to establish the release-to-birth ratio (R/B) for a given radionuclide. In addition, uncertainty minimization is achieved through the formulation of the measurement observables into relative release-to-birth indicators for selected radionuclides. The experimental findings will be utilized to enhance and validate the fission gas release models that are currently implemented in the BISON fuel performance code. The experimentally deduced physical parameters will be incorporated in BISON’s fission gas release models. Atomistic simulations of fuel behavior have been performed to investigate the mechanisms of fission gas migration in the fuel. At this stage, performance of the fuel irradiation experiments awaits licensing approval by the US NRC.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Software Verification and Validation Guidelines for Non-Linear Soil-Structure Interaction Analysis

Seismic analysis of structures, systems, and components (SSCs), including the consideration of soil-structure interaction (SSI) effects, is an important and required step in the design and licensing of nuclear power plant SSCs important to safety. Historically, the SSI analysis of nuclear structures has been performed using equivalent linear methods. However, there has been considerable industry investment in alternative seismic design and analysis approaches to reduce the construction cost of new reactors. Toward that goal and in alignment with the Licensing Modernization Project (LMP) framework, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (US NRC) has proposed a risk-informed, performance-based approach to seismic design that allows inelastic response in those nuclear plant structures not required for confinement. As a complementary effort, reactor designers are exploring nonlinear seismic analysis methods to optimize structural designs and reduce construction costs.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Predicting Rupture Pressure and Leak Rate of Alloy 600 U-bend Tubes with PWSCC and Comparing with Test Results (Technical Letter Report)

This report summarizes structural integrity work performed for the US NRC that predicts the structural integrity of steam generator (SG) tubes with flaws in the U-bend. The work covers model development and validation for U-bend tubes containing lab-induced primary water stress corrosion cracks (PWSCC). Limit load models for plastic collapse predicting ligament rupture pressure and leak rate of cracked U-bend tubes were developed and validated with pressure tests and finite element analyses (FEAs). Failure pressure and leak rate tests were conducted at room temperature on Alloy 600 U-bend tubes containing flaws located at various locations around the U-bend. Existing models for predicting structural integrity of straight tubes with well defined, rectangular, electro-discharge-machined (EDM) flaws were modified and used to predict the ligament rupture and unstable burst pressures as well as leak rates for the PWSCC flaws in the U-bend section.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Extending Sensor Calibration Intervals in Nuclear Power Plants

Currently in the USA, sensor recalibration is required at every refueling outage, and it has emerged as a critical path item for shortening outage duration. International application of calibration monitoring, such as at the Sizewell B plant in UK, has shown that sensors may operate for eight years, or longer, within calibration tolerances. Online monitoring can be employed to identify those sensors which require calibration, allowing for calibration of only those sensors which need it. The US NRC accepted the general concept of online monitoring for sensor calibration monitoring in 2000, but no plants have been granted the necessary license amendment to apply it. This project addresses key issues in advanced recalibration methodologies and provides the science base to enable adoption of best practices for applying online monitoring, resulting in a public domain standardized methodology for sensor calibration interval extension. Research to develop this methodology will focus on three key areas: (1) quantification of uncertainty in modeling techniques used for calibration monitoring, with a particular focus on non-redundant sensor models; (2) accurate determination of acceptance criteria and quantification of the effect of acceptance criteria variability on system performance; and (3) the use of virtual sensor estimates to replace identified faulty sensors to extend operation to the next convenient maintenance opportunity.

Calibration Extension↗

IDHEAS – A NEW APPROACH FOR HUMAN RELIABILITY ANALYSIS

This paper describes a method, IDHEAS (Integrated Decision-Tree Human Event Analysis System) that has been developed jointly by the US NRC and EPRI as an improved approach to Human Reliability Analysis (HRA) that is based on an understanding of the cognitive mechanisms and performance influencing factors (PIFs) that affect operator responses. The paper describes the various elements of the method, namely the performance of a detailed cognitive task analysis that is documented in a crew response tree (CRT), and the development of the associated time-line to identify the critical tasks, i.e. those whose failure results in a human failure event (HFE), and an approach to quantification that is based on explanations of why the HFE might occur.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Re-Evaluating the Current Safety Goals

The Safety Goals adopted by the US NRC consist of two qualitative safety goals (QSGs) backed up by two quantitative health objectives (QHOs). The QHOs establish risk limits for severe accidents in terms of their radiological consequences, in particular, the average individual health risks of early fatality and latent cancers from radiation exposure of members of the public living in the vicinity of a nuclear power plant. This paper is devoted to a re-examination of the coverage of the current safety goals in evaluating the actual risk posed by nuclear power plant operation. Experience of recent Level 3 PRAs suggests that given a high likelihood of evacuation of the close-in population before any release occurs, the current QHOs are satisfied by large margins. However, the experience of an actual severe accident at Fukushima showed that actual human health effects from released radiation were not the dominant consequences; there were no early fatalities and no measurable increases expected in cancer rates above the baseline rates in the Japanese population. Hence, regardless of accident probability, Fukushima-type accidents would satisfy the NRC’s health-related safety goals. However, there were very significant societal costs, in that large numbers of people were relocated for long periods. We argue that, in addition to the risks addressed in current safety goals, societal risk should also be evaluated. The paper discusses specific possibilities for a goal and an associated quantitative objective.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗