Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Small molecule donors”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 55 records · Page 3

Evolution of Chain Dynamics and Oxidation States with Increasing Chain Length for a Donor–Acceptor-Conjugated Oligomer Series

While it is known that the chain length strongly affects the properties of π-conjugated polymers, the effects of chain length on the molecular structure, chain conformation, and oxidation state properties in donor–acceptor-type conjugated structures remain unclear. This limits our understanding of how the polymer molecular weight impacts material properties. Here, a discrete and monodisperse oligomer series (n = 3, 5, 7, 9, 15, and 21) and polymers (nPB), composed of the donor 3,4-propylenedioxythiophene (ProDOT), the acceptor benzothiadiazole (BTD), and methylthio end-capping groups, are synthesized by C–H-activated cross-coupling. The molecular structure, molecular weight, and dispersity of each oligomer/polymer are thoroughly characterized by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, and gel permeation chromatography. This series reveals a rod-to-coil transition at n = 15 and coil formation at polymer length scales of ~28 units via solution small-angle neutron scattering characterization. The oxidation states are deciphered via cyclic voltammetry, differential pulse voltammetry, spectroelectrochemistry, and density functional theory calculations. Oligomers 3–9 undergo successive one-electron oxidation steps, while 15 and higher undergo multielectron oxidations per step in CH 2 Cl 2 –TBAPF6 at a Pt ultramicroelectrode. The electronic transition of each oxidation state (1+, 2+, 3+, etc.) is tracked by absorption spectroscopy, revealing a “bipolaron to di-polaron” transition at n = 7 at which shorter oligomers prefer bipolaron formation and longer oligomers prefer di-polaron formation in their dication states. Furthermore, oxidized 15 has a lower electronic transition energy compared to its polymer homologue, as shown by spectroelectrochemistry, revealing a synergy between the chain length and the oxidation state properties. This study proves that the convergence limit between small molecule and polymer behavior occurs at approximately 15 units and highlights the property transitions that occur as a function of chain length for a donor–acceptor class of conjugated organic materials.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

General Method for Determining Redox Potentials without Electrolyte

A novel method to determine redox potentials without electrolyte is presented here. The method is based on a new ability to determine the dissociation constant, $K°_d$, for ion pairs formed between any radical anion and any inert electrolyte counterion. These dissociation constants can be used to determine relative shifts of redox potential as a function of electrolyte concentration, connecting referenced potentials determined with electrochemistry (with 0.1 M electrolyte) to electrolyte-free values. Pulse radiolysis created radical anions enabling determination of equilibrium constants for electron transfer between anions of donor and acceptor molecules as a function of electrolyte concentration in THF. The measurements determined “composite equilibrium constants”, $K_{eqC}$, which contain information about the dissociation constant for the electrolyte cations, X + , with the radical anions of both the donor, $K°_d$(D –• ,X + ) and the acceptor, $K°_d$(A –• ,X + ). Dissociation constants were obtained for a selection of radical anions with tetrabutylammonium (TBA + ). The electrolyte was found to shift the reduction potentials of small molecules 1-methylpyrene and trans-stilbene by close to +130 mV whereas oligo-fluorenes and polyfluorenes experienced shifts of only (+25 ± 6) mV due to charge delocalization weakening the ion pair. These shifts for reduction of aromatic hydrocarbon molecules are smaller than shifts of +232 and +451 mV seen previously for benzophenone radical anion with TBA + and Na + respectively where the charge on the radical anion is localized largely on one C=O bond, thus forming a more tightly bound ion pair.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Efficient and mechanically-robust organic solar cells based on vertical stratification modulation through sequential blade-coating

Mechanically durable organic solar cells (OSCs) with high efficiency are deemed as the ideal candidate for the power source of the next generation wearable electronic devices. However, the brittle nature of small molecules in most high-efficiency OSCs consisting of polymer and small molecule encourages easy formation of cracks in the photoactive film under deformation. Here, the vertical composition distribution of the active layer has been well optimized through sequential blade coating to realize highly deformable while efficient OSC. The optimized morphology exhibits distinct donor-rich and homogenous region distributed along the vertical direction in the bulk. The donor-rich region provides sufficient chain entanglements and strong interfaces beneficial for mechanical robustness of film, while homogeneously mixed region offers continuous interpenetrating network to maintain high device through-put, resulting in superior efficiency of 14.4% with high crack-onset strain (COS) of 30.5%. This efficiency versus COS combination is much higher than the best combination reported in all polymer systems (COS of 15.9% and efficiency of 11.1%). To the best of our knowledge, it is the highest COS value achieved in polymer-small molecule systems. As a result, the rational control over vertical stratification demonstrated here would guide researchers in the development of innovative wearable electronics.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Efficient, Thermally Stable, and Mechanically Robust All-Polymer Solar Cells Consisting of the Same Benzodithiophene Unit-Based Polymer Acceptor and Donor with High Molecular Compatibility

All-polymer solar cells (all-PSCs) are a highly attractive class of photovoltaics for wearable and portable electronics due to their excellent morphological and mechanical stabilities. Recently, new types of polymer acceptors (P A s) consisting of non-fullerene small molecule acceptors (NFSMAs) with strong light absorption have been proposed to enhance the power conversion efficiency (PCE) of all-PSCs. However, polymerization of NFSMAs often reduces entropy of mixing in PSC blends and prevents the formation of intermixed blend domains required for efficient charge generation and morphological stability. One approach to increase compatibility in these systems is to design P A s that contain the same building blocks as their polymer donor (P D ) counterparts. Here, a series of NFSMA-based P A s [P(BDT2BOY5-X), (X = H, F, Cl)] are reported, by copolymerizing NFSMA (Y5-2BO) with benzodithiophene (BDT), a common donating unit in high-performance P D s such as PBDB-T. All-PSC blends composed of PBDB-T PD and P(BDT2BOY5-X) P A show enhanced molecular compatibility, resulting in excellent morphological and electronic properties. Specifically, PBDB-T:P(BDT2BOY5-Cl) all-PSC has a PCE of 11.12%, which is significantly higher than previous PBDB-T:Y5-2BO (7.02%) and PBDB-T:P(NDI2OD-T2) (6.00%) PSCs. Additionally, the increased compatibility of these all-PSCs greatly improves their thermal stability and mechanical robustness. For example, the crack onset strain (COS) and toughness of the PBDB-T:P(BDT2BOY5-Cl) blend are 15.9% and 3.24 MJ m -3 , respectively, in comparison to the PBDB-T:Y5-2BO blends at 2.21% and 0.32 MJ m -3 .

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Integrated linker-regulation and ring-fusion engineering for efficient additive-free non-fullerene organic solar cells

The rational molecular design and structural modification of quasi-two-dimensional fused perylene diimide (quasi-2D FPDI) acceptors have received growing attention for application in non-fullerene organic solar cells (NF-OSCs). Herein, we designed and synthesized two pairs of FPDI acceptors, one in the form of FPDI–π-bridge–FPDI with the π-bridge being either an axisymmetric thiophene (T) or a centrosymmetric thienothiophene (TT) unit, and the other being the corresponding ring-fusion counterpart. Additionally, four small molecule acceptors, namely T-FPDI, TT-FPDI, FT-FPDI and FTT-FPDI, were paired with a common PTB7-Th polymeric electron donor as active materials for a comparative study of the effects of linkers and ring fusion on their photovoltaic performances. The T-FPDI-based NF-OSC exhibited a decent power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 5.50%, while a higher PCE of 7.17% with a simultaneous enhancement in the open circuit voltage ( V oc ), the short-circuit current density ( J sc ) and the fill factor (FF) was achieved for the TT-FPDI-based solar cells. The solar cells based on the ring-fused FT-FPDI and FTT-FPDI acceptors displayed PCEs of 6.75% and 7.66%, respectively, both higher than those of the corresponding non-fused counterparts. Notably, the trade-off between the J sc and V oc , commonly observed in fullerene OSCs, is alleviated in these systems. It is also worth noting that the NF-OSCs based on these FPDI acceptors do not need any solvent additives. Overall, this successful molecular engineering based on novel quasi-2D FPDI building blocks may inspire the development of emergent electron acceptors for high performance additive-free NF-OSCs.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

p -Azaquinodimethane: A Versatile Quinoidal Moiety for Functional Materials Discovery

The past 50 years of discovery in organic electronics have been driven in large part by the donor–acceptor design principle, wherein electron-rich and electron-poor units are assembled in conjugation with each other to produce small band gap materials. While the utility of this design strategy is undoubtable, it has been largely exhausted as a frontier of new avenues to produce and tune novel functional materials to meet the needs of the ever-increasing world of organic electronics applications. Its sister strategy of joining quinoidal and aromatic groups in conjugation has, by comparison, received much less attention, to a great extent due to the categorically poor stability of quinoidal conjugated motifs. In 2017 though, the p-azaquinodimethane (AQM) motif was first unveiled, which showed a remarkable level of stability despite being a close structural analogue to p-quinodimethane, a notably reactive compound. In contrast, dialkoxy AQM small molecules and polymers are stable even under harsh conditions and could thus be incorporated into conjugated polymers. When polymerized with aromatic subunits, these AQM-based polymers show notably reduced band gaps that follow reversed structure–property trends to some of their donor–acceptor polymer counterparts and yield organic field-effect transistor (OFET) hole mobilities above 5 cm 2 V –1 s –1 . Additionally, in an ongoing study, these AQM-based compounds are also showing promise as singlet fission (SF) active materials due to their mild diradicaloid character. An expanded world of AQMs was accessed through their ditriflate derivatives, which were first used to produce ionic AQMs (iAQMs) sporting two directly attached cationic groups that significantly affect the AQM motif’s electronics, producing strongly electron-withdrawing quinoidal building blocks. Conjugated polyelectrolytes (CPEs) created with these iAQM building blocks exhibit optical band gaps stretching into the near-infrared I (NIR-I) region and showed exemplary behavior as photothermal therapy agents. In contrast to these stable AQM examples, the synthetic exploration of AQMs also produced examples of more typical diradicaloid reactivity but in forms that were controllable and produced intriguing and high-value products. With certain substitution patterns, AQMs were found to dimerize to form highly substituted [2.2]paracyclophanes in distinctly more appreciable yields than typical cyclophane formation reactions. Certain AQM ditriflates, when crystallized, undergo light-induced topochemical polymerization to form ultrahigh molecular weight (>10 6 Da) polymers that showed excellent performances as dielectric energy storage materials. These same AQM ditriflates could be used to produce the strongly electron-donating redox-active pentacyclic structure: pyrazino[2,3-b:5,6-b']diindolizine (PDIz). Importantly, the PDIz motif allowed for the synthesis of exceedingly small band gap (0.7 eV) polymers with absorbances reaching all the way into the NIR-II region that were also found to produce strong photothermal effects. Both as stable quinoidal building blocks and through their controllable diradicaloid reactivity, AQMs have already proven to be versatile and effective as functional organic electronics materials.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Materials for controlling the epitaxial growth of photoactive layers in photovoltaic devices

There is disclosed ultrathin film material templating layers that force the morphology of subsequently grown electrically active thin films have been found to increase the performance of small molecule organic photovoltaic (OPV) cells. There is disclosed electron-transporting material, such as hexaazatriphenylene-hexacarbonitrile (HAT-CN) can be used as a templating material that forces donor materials, such as copper phthalocyanine (CuPc) to assume a vertical-standing morphology when deposited onto its surface on an electrode, such as an indium tin oxide (ITO) electrode. It has been shown that for a device with HAT-CN as the templating buffer layer, the fill factor and short circuit current of CuPc:C60 OPVs were both improved compared with cells lacking the HAT-CN template. This is explained by the reduction of the series resistance due to the improved crystallinity of CuPc grown onto the ITO surface.

Forrest, Stephen R.↗

16.52% Efficiency All-Polymer Solar Cells with High Tolerance of the Photoactive Layer Thickness

All-polymer solar cells (all-PSCs) have drawn growing attention and achieved tremendous progress recently, but their power conversion efficiency (PCE) still lags behind small-molecule-acceptor (SMA)-based PSCs due to the relative difficulty on morphology control of polymer photoactive blends. Here, in this work, low-cost PTQ10 is introduced as a second polymer donor (a third component) into the PM6:PY-IT blend to finely tune the energy-level matching and microscopic morphology of the polymer blend photoactive layer. The addition of PTQ10 decreases the π–π stacking distance, and increases the π–π stacking coherence length and the ordered face-on molecular packing orientation, which improves the charge separation and transport in the photoactive layer. Moreover, the deeper highest occupied molecular orbital energy level of the PTQ10 polymer donor than PM6 leads to higher open-circuit voltage of the ternary all-PSCs. As a result, a PCE of 16.52% is achieved for ternary all-PSCs, which is one of the highest PCEs for all-PSCs. In addition, the ternary devices exhibit a high tolerance of the photoactive layer thickness with high PCEs of 15.27% and 13.91% at photoactive layer thickness of ≈205 and ≈306 nm, respectively, which are the highest PCEs so far for all-PSCs with a thick photoactive layer.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

LDRD Macromolcule Radiolysis Poster

Moving toward a circular carbon economy depends on enabling reuse of carbon-based macromolecules and increased recycling of waste products into higher value products. Macromolecules are challenging to valorize into products easily converted into liquid fuel or chemical feedstocks, due to their large and sometimes heterogeneous network of polymeric bonds. The novel aspect of this project is to show a proof of principle that radiolysis of macromolecules using “waste” radiation from energy production in the presence of radical capping donors presents an attractive opportunity to break down complex macromolecules into smaller molecules while controlling re-polymerization. This approach offers a new, cost-efficient way to utilize “waste” radiation and heat byproducts of nuclear energy production to convert a simple mixture of complex molecules into a complex mixture of small molecules, to be utilized as an energy source by the fuel industry, or to create value-added feedstocks for new polymers or commodity chemicals. Ionizing radiation can be harnessed to convert energy to molecules, adding value to low-value macromolecules as they are broken down into smaller, more easily separated feedstocks or fuels to be converted to a value-added product. This project will test 2 hypotheses. Hypothesis 1: Macromolecular materials that comprise biomass and coal or other macromolecules can be infused with radical capping donors (RCDs), and gamma irradiation of the resulting mixtures will produce ensembles of lower-molecular weight chemicals that can be more easily separated. If this expectation is realized, the conversion chemistry can be optimized by adjusting the feedstock composition, irradiation time, and choice of RCD.

02 - PETROLEUM↗

meso -Ethynyl-extended push–pull type porphyrins for near-infrared organic photodetectors

We report natural porphyrins play a key role in a range of vital functions such as oxygen transport in the bloodstream and the conversion of light to chemical energy in plants. Likewise, synthetic porphyrin derivatives can be used to detect light and convert it into an electrical current in photodiodes. The versatility of porphyrinoid chemistry allows to extend the absorptivity (and hence detectivity) to the near-infrared while maintaining good solubility, suitable electrochemical properties, and compatibility with the electron acceptor molecules required to achieve a reasonable photocurrent. Here, our efforts on the design and synthesis of novel push–pull type meso-ethynyl-extended porphyrin compounds, both of A–D–A and D–A–D type (D = donor, A = acceptor), and their evaluation in prototype near-infrared organic photodetector devices are presented. The push–pull design with strongly electron-deficient building blocks results in absorption onsets up to 1200 nm, translating in an optical gap approaching 1 eV. Both A–D–A and D–A–D small molecules show good photodetector performance, with a peak specific detectivity near 2 x 10 11 and 4 x 10 11 Jones at 1000 nm (at -2 V bias), respectively. These values are among the best reported so far for small molecule based near-infrared organic photodetectors.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Hydrazine Energy Storage: Displacing N 2 H 4 from the Metal Coordination Sphere

Hydrogen carriers, such as hydrazine (N 2 H 4 ), may facilitate long duration energy storage, a vital component for resilient grids by enabling more renewable energy generation. Lanthanide coordination chemistry with N 2 H 4 as well as efforts to displace N 2 H 4 from the metal coordination sphere to develop an efficient catalytic production cycle were detailed. Modeling the equilibrium of different ligand coordination, it was predicted that strong sigma donor molecules would be required to displace N 2 H 4 . Monitoring competition experiments with nuclear magnetic resonance confirmed that trimethyl phosphine oxide, dimethylformamide, and dimethyl sulfoxide displaced N 2 H 4 in large or small lanthanide complexes.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Stabilization of reactive rare earth alkyl complexes through mechanistic studies

Rare earth tris(alkyl) complexes such as M(CH 2 SiMe 3 ) 3 (sol) n are widely used as precursors for many compounds and as homogeneous catalysts for alkene polymerization and alkane functionalization. However, the thermal instability of those most conveniently made from the commercially available lithium salt of the neosilyl anion, LiCH 2 SiMe 3 , Li(r), restricts their utility. We present a new range of synthetically useful, more kinetically stable rare earth neosilyl solvates, derived from a full kinetic study of the various possible decomposition mechanisms of 7 known and 12 new solvated rare earth neosilyl complexes M(CH 2 SiMe 3 ) 3 (sol) n M = Sc(III), Y(III), Lu(III), Sm(III), and sol = THF; TMEDA; DMPE; diglyme ((CH 3 ) 2 (OCH 2 CH 2 ) 2 O, G 2 ), triglyme ((CH 3 ) 2 (OCH 2 CH 2 ) 3 O, G 3 ). Surprisingly, simply using higher-denticity donors to sterically disfavor neosilyl γ-H elimination is not effective. While Sc(r) 3 ((CH 3 ) 2 (OCH 2 CH 2 ) 2 O) has a half-life, t 1/2 , of 258.1 h, six times longer than for Sc(r) 3 (C 4 H 8 O) 2 (t 1/2 = 43 h), Lu(r) 3 ((CH 3 ) 2 (OCH 2 CH 2 ) 2 O) and Y(r) 3 ((CH 3 ) 2 (OCH 2 CH 2 ) 2 O) do not show the expected, analogous increased t 1/2 . This is because new decomposition pathways appear for poorly fitting donors. Finally, kinetic studies demonstrate the impact of small, and increasing amounts of LiCl on the kinetics of the reactivity of the smaller alkyls Y(r) 3 (THF) 2 and Lu(r) 3 (THF) 2 ; molecules used in hydrocarbon chemistry and catalysis for fifty years. A new route to pure Y(r) 3 (THF) 2 , which avoids the traditional use of Li(r), is presented.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

A predictive theoretical model for electron tunneling pathways in proteins

A practical method is presented for calculating the dependence of electron transfer rates on details of the protein medium intervening between donor and acceptor. The method takes proper account of the relative energetics and mutual interactions of the donor, acceptor, and peptide groups. It also provides a quantitative search scheme for determining the important tunneling pathways (specific sequences of localized bonding and antibonding orbitals of the protein which dominate the donor-acceptor electronic coupling) in native and tailored proteins, a tool for designing new proteins with prescribed electron transfer rates, and a consistent description of observed electron transfer rates in existing redox labeled metalloproteins and small molecule model compounds.

Onuchic, Jose Nelson↗

BODIPY based A-D-A molecules: Effect of CF3 group substitution at meso phenyl group

Two pairs of A-D-A molecules have been created with fluorene and benzodithiophene as the central donor subunits and terminal BODIPY units, functionalized with either a 4-methylphenyl or 4-trifluoromethylphenyl group at the meso position. The effect of the para substituent of the meso phenyl group on the photophysical properties of these molecules is studied through steady state absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy as well as femtosecond transient absorption and time resolved fluorescence spectroscopy techniques. Applicability of these molecules as donors in solution processed solar cell active layers was investigated through time resolved microwave conductivity measurements on blends with PC60BM acceptor, which shows a varying yield of charge transfer with choice of substituent. Transient absorption spectroscopy is then employed to investigate the role of the 4-trifluoromethylphenyl group in altering the efficiency of charge transfer from these A-D-A molecules to PC60BM. The results show a consistent picture of picosecond charge transfer and a component of a few hundred ps geminate recombination that results in a small yield of long-lived free charges optimized for the methylphenyl derivatives.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Small molecule dye for molecular imaging and photothermal therapy

Disclosed is a small molecule dye for use in imaging in the near-infrared window, namely between 1000 nm-1700 nm wavelength. The present dyes are also useful for photoacoustic imaging and photothermal therapy. The dyes have a structure of a D-A-D (donor-acceptor-donor) fluorescent compound core and side chains rendering the compounds water soluble and easily conjugated to hydrophilic polymers and/or targeting ligands. Further disclosed is compound, CH1055 that can be PEGylated, conjugated to a targeting ligand, or conjugated to taurine. Key steps utilized to assemble the core structure of the target included a cross-Suzuki coupling reaction, iron reduction and N-thionylaniline induced ring closure. Four carboxylic acid groups were introduced into the donor-acceptor-donor (D-A-D) type fluorescent compound to impart a certain aqueous solubility and to allow facile conjugation to targeting ligands.

Cheng, Zhen↗

Cost-Efficiency balanced polymer acceptors based on lowly fused Dithienopyrrolo[3, 2b]benzothiadiazole for 16.04% efficiency All-Polymer solar cells

All-polymer solar cells (All-PSCs) attracted increasing attention due to the outstanding thermal stability and mechanical properties. The current prevailing polymer acceptors for most efficient All-PSCs are polymerized high-performance small molecule acceptor of Y6, i.e. the dithienothiopheno[3,2-b]-pyrrolobenzothiadiazole (BTTP) based polymers. However, the BTTP-based polymers often show relatively shallow highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) energy level and high figure of merit (FOM), which limit the rational selection of paring donor polymers. Herein, we presented two low-cost polymer acceptors, namely as BTP-T2F and BTP-2T2F, based on lowly fused dithienopyrrolo[3,2b]benzothiadiazole (BTP, removing two thiophene cycles from BTTP). Here the BTP-based polymers exhibited deeper HOMO levels around –5.90 eV, which could match variable donor polymers with low-lying HOMO levels, such as low-cost PTQ10. Additionally, the synthesis was significantly simplified compared to BTTP-based polymers. A power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 14.32% was achieved in binary blend device containing PTQ10:BTP-2T2F. By adding a miscibility-enhancing PBDTCl-TPD as a third component, the top PCE of 16.04% was obtained in ternary blend All-PSCs. Combining the high device performance and low estimated cost, extraordinary cost-efficiency balance was realized within these BTP-based polymer acceptors.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Self-compensation of group-V acceptors in CdTe

Cadmium Telluride is at the core of an important thin-film technology for photovoltaics that is already commercially available, yet the CdTe-based solar cell efficiency remains limited at 22%, well below the theoretical limit of ~30%. Increasing the hole concentration is crucial for higher efficiency, and group-V elements such as As, P, and Sb are potential dopants as they are shallow acceptors. Nevertheless, group-V doped p-type CdTe often exhibits low doping activation, and the compensation source remains debated. Here, we performed hybrid density functional calculations with spin-orbit coupling to investigate possible sources of hole compensation in group-V doped CdTe. First, regarding possible self-compensation of the group-V dopants, we find that the formation of AX centers is unlikely since they are found to be unstable relative to the shallow acceptor forms. However, if the group-V dopants come in during growth (such as dimer molecules As2, P2, and Sb2), we find that the impurity atoms, which would occupy nearest neighbor sites, maintain the V-V bonds, limiting the hole density. For the native defects, our study reveals that Cd interstitial is the lowest energy donor defect in p-type CdTe. Still, it has a small migration barrier of 0.5 eV, making it highly mobile and unstable at room temperature. The Te vacancy is the next lowest formation energy donor. The migration barrier of 1.4 eV indicates that the Te vacancy is stable at room temperature. The antisite CdTe is also a donor, with low formation energy and stable at room temperature, potentially limiting the hole concentration. Our results, therefore, shed light on possible compensation centers and some guidance on how to avoid them.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗