Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “SYMMETRY BREAKING”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 55 records · Page 3
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2021

Symmetry-breaking in double gyroid block copolymer films by non-affine distortion

Soft-matter bicontinuous networks find a double gyroid structure from block copolymer (BCP) self-assembly. A gyroid structure composed of dissimilar blocks has proven its potential as a soft crystal capable of tuning structural periodicity and symmetry, of which the lattice dimension is variable with molecular weight of the polymer. Using an asymmetric polystyrene- b -poly(methyl methacrylate) (PS- b -PMMA), in this study we show that the self-assembled gyroid films formed via a solvent vapor annealing (SVA) process undergo unique structural distortion due to directional deformation immediately upon deswelling. During the SVA process with PS- b -PMMA films, transient cylinders developed from the as-cast morphology transform into a cubic gyroid structure in a swollen state. Rapid and spontaneous deswelling processes -the manners in which the films contract along the z-direction while retaining an enlarged lateral dimension of the cubic form -lead to triclinic gyroid structures with z-directional contraction ratios ( C z ) of 2.5 and 2.0, respectively. Our X-ray analysis reveals that the deswelling process of the swollen gyroid films produces a notable symmetry-breaking in non-affine gyroid structure that elicits several forbidden reflections such as {110} and {200} reflections. For further characterization of the symmetry-breaking, we delineate the structural features of noncubic gyroid films by computing electron-density difference maps assisted with X-ray measurements. Level-set approach is accordingly developed to quantitate the structural characteristics of the maps in terms of inversion symmetry-breaking, suggesting its possible application to optical Weyl photonic crystals.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Spontaneous and explicit parity-time-symmetry breaking in drift-wave instabilities

A method of parity-time- (PT) symmetry analysis is introduced to study the high-dimensional, complicated parameter space of drift-wave instabilities. Here, we show that spontaneous PT-symmetry breaking leads to the ion temperature gradient instability of drift waves, and the collisional instability is the result of explicit PT-symmetry breaking. A new unstable drift wave induced by finite collisionality is identified. It is also found that gradients of ion temperature and density can destabilize the ion cyclotron waves when PT symmetry is explicitly broken by a finite collisionality.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2021

Sequential Symmetry-Breaking Events as a Synthetic Pathway for Chiral Gold Nanostructures with Spiral Geometries

Symmetry-breaking synthetic controls allow for nanostructure geometries that are counter to the underlying crystal symmetry of a material. If suitably applied, such controls provide the means to drive an isotropic metal along a growth pathway yielding a three-dimensional chiral geometry. In this work, we present a light-driven solution-based synthesis yielding helical gold spirals from substrate-bound seeds. The devised growth mode relies on three separate symmetry-breaking events ushered in by seeds lined with planar defects, a capping agent that severely frustrates early-stage growth, and the Coulombic repulsion that occurs when identically charged growth fronts collide. Together they combine to advance a growth pathway in which planar growth emanates from one side of the seed, advances to encircle the seed from both clockwise and counterclockwise directions, and then upon collision of the two growth fronts, sees one front rise above the other to realize a self-perpetuating three-dimensional spiral structure.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Symmetry Breaking Charge Transfer in DNA-Templated Perylene Dimer Aggregates

Molecular aggregates are of interest to a broad range of fields including light harvesting, organic optoelectronics, and nanoscale computing. In molecular aggregates, nonradiative decay pathways may emerge that were not present in the constituent molecules. Such nonradiative decay pathways may include singlet fission, excimer relaxation, and symmetry-breaking charge transfer. Singlet fission, sometimes referred to as excitation multiplication, is of great interest to the fields of energy conversion and quantum information. For example, endothermic singlet fission, which avoids energy loss, has been observed in covalently bound, linear perylene trimers and tetramers. In this work, the electronic structure and excited-state dynamics of dimers of a perylene derivative templated using DNA were investigated. Specifically, DNA Holliday junctions were used to template the aggregation of two perylene molecules covalently linked to a modified uracil nucleobase through an ethynyl group. The perylenes were templated in the form of monomer, transverse dimer, and adjacent dimer configurations. The electronic structure of the perylene monomers and dimers were characterized via steady-state absorption and fluorescence spectroscopy. Initial insights into their excited-state dynamics were gleaned from relative fluorescence intensity measurements, which indicated that a new nonradiative decay pathway emerges in the dimers. Femtosecond visible transient absorption spectroscopy was subsequently used to elucidate the excited-state dynamics. A new excited-state absorption feature grows in on the tens of picosecond timescale in the dimers, which is attributed to the formation of perylene anions and cations resulting from symmetry-breaking charge transfer. Given the close proximity required for symmetry-breaking charge transfer, the results shed promising light on the prospect of singlet fission in DNA-templated molecular aggregates.

77 NANOSCIENCE AND NANOTECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2025

Symmetry breaking forms split-off flat bands in quantum oxides controlling metal versus insulator phases

The crystal structure used as input to electronic structure calculation of conventionally bonded solids consists primarily of the standard crystallographic degrees of freedom. Quantum solids sometimes have additional microscopic degrees of freedom (m-DOF) nested within the crystallographic structure. These might include local motifs including positional (Peierls dimers, deformed octahedra, Jahn-Teller distortions), magnetic (local moment configurations) and dipolar (local ferroelectric configurations). Such motifs can be observed experimentally via local probes that avoid averaging, and theoretically as distinct total energy lowering features relative to more simplified “average crystallographic structures”. Here we examine the ability of electronic structure methods independent of strong correlation physics to explain the broad phenomenology of metal-insulator selectivity in quantum oxides by energy-lowering symmetry breaking. We do this by avoiding the restriction of considering only (i) electron-electron interactions in a fixed unresponsive lattice—as done in Mott strong correlation explanations—allowing, however, (ii) local positional and magnetic motifs that coexist within a crystallographic landscape. We find in a broad range of quantum oxides with different symmetry breaking modes the formation of split-off flat bands that can also control metallic versus insulating characteristics. The split-off band effect is common to magnetic and non-magnetic materials, including both binary and ternary oxides. One finds that when such local symmetry breaking motifs are considered in mean-field-like (e.g. density functional theory) electronic structure calculations of quantum oxides, they explain many of the observed trends in metal vs insulator phases discussed otherwise in prior literature via strong correlation in symmetry unbroken view.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2024

Symmetry Breaking and Ascending in the Magnetic Kagome Metal FeGe

Spontaneous symmetry breaking—the phenomenon in which an infinitesimal perturbation can cause the system to break the underlying symmetry—is a cornerstone concept in the understanding of interacting solid-state systems. In a typical series of temperature-driven phase transitions, higher-temperature phases are more symmetric due to the stabilizing effect of entropy that becomes dominant as the temperature is increased. However, the opposite is rare but possible when there are multiple degrees of freedom in the system. Here, we present such an example of a symmetry-ascending phenomenon upon cooling in a magnetic kagome metal FeGe by utilizing neutron Larmor diffraction and Raman spectroscopy. FeGe has a kagome lattice structure with simple A-type antiferromagnetic order below Néel temperature T N ≈ 400 K and a charge density wave (CDW) transition at T CDW ≈ 110 K , followed by a spin-canting transition at around 60 K. In the paramagnetic state at 460 K, we confirm that the crystal structure is indeed a hexagonal kagome lattice. On cooling to around T N , the crystal structure changes from hexagonal to monoclinic with in-plane lattice distortions on the order of 10 − 4 and the associated splitting of the double-degenerate phonon mode of the pristine kagome lattice. Upon further cooling to T CDW , the kagome lattice shows a small negative thermal expansion, and the crystal structure gradually becomes more symmetric upon further cooling. A tendency of increasing the crystalline symmetry upon cooling is unusual; it originates from an extremely weak structural instability that coexists and competes with the CDW and magnetic orders. These observations are against the expectations for a simple model with a single order parameter and hence can only be explained by a Landau free energy expansion that takes into account multiple lattice, charge, and spin degrees of freedom. Thus, the determination of the crystalline lattice symmetry as well as the unusual spin-lattice coupling is a first step towards understanding the rich electronic and magnetic properties of the system, and it sheds new light on intertwined orders where the lattice degree of freedom is no longer dominant. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗
DOE OSTI2024

Symmetry breaking and self-interaction correction in the chromium atom and dimer

Density functional approximations to the exchange–correlation energy can often identify strongly correlated systems and estimate their energetics through energy-minimizing symmetry-breaking. In particular, the binding energy curve of the strongly correlated chromium dimer is described qualitatively by the local spin density approximation (LSDA) and almost quantitatively by the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof generalized gradient approximation (PBE-GGA), where the symmetry breaking is antiferromagnetic for both. Here, we show that a full Perdew–Zunger self-interaction-correction (SIC) to LSDA seems to go too far by creating an unphysical symmetry-broken state, with effectively zero magnetic moment but non-zero spin density on each atom, which lies ~4 eV below the antiferromagnetic solution. A similar symmetry-breaking, observed in the atom, better corresponds to the 3d↑↑4s↑3d↓↓4s↓ configuration than to the standard 3d↑↑↑↑↑4s↑. For this new solution, the total energy of the dimer at its observed bond length is higher than that of the separated atoms. In conclusion, these results can be regarded as qualitative evidence that the SIC needs to be scaled down in many-electron regions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Simultaneous Development of Antiferromagnetism and Local Symmetry Breaking in a Kagome Magnet (Co 0.45 Fe 0.55 )Sn

CoSn and FeSn, two kagome-lattice metals, have recently attracted significant attention as hosts of electronic flat bands and emergent physical properties. However, current understandings of their physical properties are limited to knowledge of the average crystal structure. Here, we report the Fe-doping induced coemergence of the antiferromagentic (AFM) order and local symmetry breaking in (Co 0.45 Fe 0.55 )Sn. Rietveld analysis on the neutron and synchrotron X-ray diffraction data indicates A-type antiferromagnetic order with the moment pointing perpendicular to the kagome layers, associated with the anomaly in the MSn(1) 2 Sn(2) 4 (M = Co/Fe) octahedral distortion and the lattice constant c. Reverse Monte Carlo (RMC) modeling of the synchrotron X-ray total scattering results captured the subtle local orthorhombic distortion involving off-axis displacements of Sn(2). Our results indicate that the stable hexagonal lattice above T N becomes unstable once the A-type AFM order is formed below T N . Here we argue that the local symmetry breaking has a magnetic origin, since the spatially varied M–Sn(2) bond lengths arise from out-of-plane magnetic exchange coupling J c via the exchange pathway M–Sn(2)–M. Our study provides comprehensive information on the crystal structure in both long-range scale and local scale, unveiling unique coupling between AFM order, octahedral distortion, and hidden local symmetry breaking.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Cascading from $\mathscr{N}$ = 2 supersymmetric Yang–Mills theory to confinement and chiral symmetry breaking in adjoint QCD

We argue that adjoint QCD in 3 + 1 dimensions, with any SU(N) gauge group and two Weyl fermion flavors (i.e. one adjoint Dirac fermion), confines and spontaneously breaks its chiral symmetries via the condensation of a fermion bilinear. We flow to this theory from pure $\mathscr{N}$ = 2 SUSY Yang–Mills theory with the same gauge group, by giving a SUSY-breaking mass M to the scalars in the $\mathscr{N}$ = 2 vector multiplet. This flow can be analyzed rigorously at small M, where it leads to a deconfined vacuum at the origin of the $\mathscr{N}$ = 2 Coulomb branch. The analysis can be extended to all M using an Abelian dual description that arises from the N multi-monopole points of the $\mathscr{N}$ = 2 theory. At each such point, there are N −1 hypermultiplet Higgs fields h$^{i=1,2}_m$, which are SU(2) R doublets. We provide a detailed study of the phase diagram as a function of M, by analyzing the semi-classical phases of the dual using a combination of analytic and numerical techniques. The result is a cascade of first-order phase transitions, along which the Higgs fields h i m successively turn on, and which interpolates between the Coulomb branch at small M, where all h$^{i}_m$ = 0, and a maximal Higgs branch, where all h$^{i}_m$ ≠ 0, at sufficiently large M. We show that this maximal Higgs branch precisely matches the confining and chiral symmetry breaking phase of two-flavor adjoint QCD, including its broken and unbroken symmetries, its massless spectrum, and the expected large-N scaling of various observables. The spontaneous breaking pattern SU(2) R → U(1) R , consistent with the Vafa–Witten theorem, is ensured by an intricate alignment mechanism for the h$^{i}_m$ in the dual, and leads to a CP 1 sigma model of increasing radius along the cascade.

D’Hoker, Eric [Univ. of California, Los Angeles, C↗
DOE OSTI2023

Impact of Chiral Symmetry Breaking on Spin-Texture and Lone Pair Expression in Chiral Crystals of Hybrid Antimony and Bismuth Halides

Chiral organic building blocks can be incorporated into hybrid organic-inorganic metal-halide crystalline semiconductors so as to control and impact the interconversion between light, charge, and spin. Here, we report a series of hybrid antimony and bismuth halide materials of the general formula MBA 4 B 2 X 10 (B = Sb 3+ , Bi 3+ ; X = Br - , I - ) and study how chiral symmetry breaking imposed by the templating organic chiral methylbenzylammonium (MBA) cations induces symmetry breaking within the inorganic sublattice and leads to a unique spin-texture. The chiral MBA cations introduce two structural modifications to the metal-halide sublattice that consists of isolated edge-sharing dimers of B 2 X 10 octahedra: (1) the dimers have a chiral spatial arrangement with respect to one another and (2) there is an asymmetric distortion of the two subunits within the individual dimers with a higher distortion caused by strong stereochemical activity of the Sb 5s 2 lone pair electrons. The structural distortions and chiral arrangement result in circular dichroism (CD) at the band edge of the inorganic framework with dissymmetry factors in the range of 10 -4 . Chiral spin-splitting of the inorganic states, caused by breaking of the inversion symmetry and large spin-orbit coupling, is studied via density functional theory (DFT), and a multiband effective mass theory was developed that links the DFT-derived spin-splitting of helical character (i.e., spin expectation value not perpendicular to the crystal momentum) to the observed CD. Furthermore, we also find broad red photoluminescence from the MBA 4 Sb 2 Br 10 compounds, which we attribute to self-trapped excitonic emission driven by the large distortion due to the lone pair expression.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
NASA NTRS1996

Chiral Symmetry Breaking in Crystal Growth: Is Hydrodynamic Convection Relevant?

The effects of mechanical stirring on nucleation and chiral symmetry breaking have been investigated for a simple inorganic molecule, sodium chlorate (NaClO3). In contrast to earlier findings, our experiment suggests that the symmetry breaking may have little to do with hydrodynamic convection. Rather the effect can be reasonably accounted for by mechanical damage to incipient crystals. The catastrophic events, creating numerous small 'secondary' crystals, produce statistical domination of one chiral species over the other. Our conclusion is supported by a number of observations using different mixing mechanisms.

Martin, B.↗
DOE OSTI2023

Spontaneous Symmetry–Breaking of Nonequilibrium Steady–States Caused by Nonlinear Electrical Transport

Negative differential resistance (NDR) in certain materials has been attributed to spontaneous emergence of symmetry-breaking electrical current density localization from a previously homogeneous distribution, which is postulated to occur due to the nonequilibrium thermodynamic force of minimization of entropy production. However, this phenomenon has not been quantitatively predicted based on intrinsic material properties and an applied electrical stimulus. Herein an instability criterion is derived for localization of current density and temperature from a thermal fluctuation in a parallel conductor model of a thin film that is subject to Newton's law of cooling. The conditions for steady–state electro-thermal localization is predicted, verifying a decrease in entropy production upon localization. Electro-thermal localization accompanied by a decrease of entropy production is confirmed in a multiphysics simulation of current flow in a thin film. The instability criterion predicts conditions for spontaneous current density localization, relating symmetry breaking fundamentally to dynamical instability via Local Activity theory.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Symmetry-Breaking Design of an Organic Iron Complex Catholyte for a Long Cyclability Aqueous Organic Redox Flow Battery

The limited availability of a high-performance catholyte has hindered development of aqueous organic redox flow batteries (AORFB) that are environmentally benign, have tunable structures, and are safer than their traditional transition metal ion-based counterparts for large-scale energy storage. In this paper, a symmetry-breaking design of iron complexes with 2,2’-bipyridine-4,4’-dicarboxylic (Dcbpy) acid and cyanide ligands is described. By introducing two ligands to the metal center, the complex compounds (M4[FeII(Dcbpy)2(CN)2], M = Na, K) exhibited 4.2 times higher solubility (1.22 M, 33 Ah/L) and a 50% increase in potential compared with the widely used ferrocyanide. The symmetry-breaking, iron complex catholyte-based AORFBs were demonstrated at a concentration near the solubility limit (1.02 M Na4[FeII(Dcbpy)2(CN)2]) with a 1:1 catholyte:anolyte electron ratio. The AORFBs achieved a cell voltage of 1.2 V and a demonstrated energy density of 12.5 Wh/L. This symmetry-breaking design paves the way for development of metal complexes for high-energy-density AORFBs.

Li, Xiang↗
DOE OSTI2024

Manipulating symmetry-breaking charge separation employing molecular recognition

The exploration of symmetry-breaking charge separation (SB-CS) is imperative when designing functional light-harvesting materials. Past explorations, however, have been confined to covalent systems, more often than not requiring complicated/demanding syntheses and facing inconvenient regulation of charge transfer processes. Here, in this work, we present a concept that regulates the efficiency of SB-CS through molecular recognition utilizing a pyridinium-based cyclophane as a host. This host undergoes photo-driven excited-state SB-CS. By employing different guests with distinct frontier molecular orbital energy levels, we have achieved comprehensive control of electron transfer pathways in the cyclophane, modulating between accelerated (>10-fold) intramolecular SB-CS involving superexchange and direct intermolecular electron transfer between the host and guest. The improvement in SB-CS efficiency results in catalytic activity for the photo-oxidation of a sulfur-mustard simulant. This research offers an opportunity for tuning SB-CS by utilizing molecular recognition, which holds the potential for achieving precise regulation without complicated organic syntheses.

charge transfer↗
DOE OSTI2023

Insulating band gaps both below and above the Néel temperature in d -electron LaTi O 3 , LaV O 3 , SrMn O 3 , and LaMn O 3 perovskites as a symmetry-breaking event

Metal d-electron oxides having an odd number of electrons per cell should exhibit band degeneracy at the Fermi energy, making them, in band theory, formally metallic. In many cases, however, these are “false metals”, as evidenced by the observation that many ABO 3 oxide perovskites with a magnetic 3d B-atom are observed to be insulators both below and above the Néel temperature. These inconsistencies between experimental observation and expectation have historically been resolved by invoking degeneracy-breaking physics, based largely on -pure electron effects, such as strong interelectronic correlation for d-electron compounds (the Mott mechanism). Such explanations generally consider microscopic lattice or magnetic degrees of freedom (m-DOF) as largely passive spectators, not a cause of the formally metallic being an insulator. Yet, it has long been known that ABO 3 perovskites can manifest an arrangement of m-DOFs in the form of octahedral tilting, bond dimerization, Jahn-Teller distortions, and ordering of local magnetic moments. It appears reasonable that such structural and magnetic local degrees of freedom need to be allowed to compete with purely electronic strong correlation. To answer this question, we explored a range of d-electron oxide perovskites exemplified by the archetypes LaTiO 3 , LaVO 3 , SrMnO 3 , and LaMnO 3 with 1, 2, 3, or 4 d -electrons, respectively. Using a mean-field-like electronic structure method (here, density functional theory), we find that a combination of magnetic symmetry breaking with structural distortions can account for insulating band gaps in this series while at the same time correctly predicting for the control case an intrinsic paramagnetic metal in SrVO 3 as symmetry-breaking is insufficiently strong to remove the degeneracy. Finally, this indicates that calculating quantitatively local magnetic and positional symmetry-breaking motifs in unit cells that avoid averaging at the outset over the low symmetry motifs can provide consistent trends in a Mott transition without Mott U.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

The connection between nonzero density and spontaneous symmetry breaking for interacting scalars

We consider U(1)-symmetric scalar quantum field theories at zero temperature. At nonzero charge densities, the ground state of these systems is usually assumed to be a superfluid phase, in which the global symmetry is spontaneously broken along with Lorentz boosts and time translations. We show that, in d > 2 spacetime dimensions, this expectation is always realized at one loop for arbitrary non-derivative interactions, confirming that the physically distinct phenomena of nonzero charge density and spontaneous symmetry breaking occur simultaneously in these systems. We quantify this result by deriving universal scaling relations for the symmetry breaking scale as a function of the charge density, at low and high density. Moreover, we show that the critical value of μ above which a nonzero density develops coincides with the pole mass in the unbroken, Poincaré invariant vacuum of the theory. The same conclusions hold non-perturbatively for an O(N) theory with quartic interactions in d = 3 and 4, at leading order in the 1/N expansion. We derive these results by computing analytically the zero-temperature, finite-μ one-loop effective potential, paying special attention to subtle points related to the iε terms. We check our results against the one-loop low-energy effective action for the superfluid phonons in λΦ 4 theory in d = 4 previously derived by Joyce and ourselves, which we further generalize to arbitrary potential interactions and arbitrary dimensions. As a byproduct, we find analytically the one-loop scaling dimension of the lightest charge-n operator for the λΦ 6 conformal superfluid in d = 3, at leading order in 1/n, reproducing a numerical result of Badel et al. For a λΦ 4 superfluid in d = 4, we also reproduce the Lee-Huang-Yang relation and compute relativistic corrections to it. Finally, we discuss possible extensions of our results beyond perturbation theory.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗
DOE OSTI2023

Visualizing symmetry-breaking electronic orders in epitaxial Kagome magnet FeSn films

Abstract Kagome lattice hosts a plethora of quantum states arising from the interplay of topology, spin-orbit coupling, and electron correlations. Here, we report symmetry-breaking electronic orders tunable by an applied magnetic field in a model Kagome magnet FeSn consisting of alternating stacks of two-dimensional Fe 3 Sn Kagome and Sn 2 honeycomb layers. On the Fe 3 Sn layer terminated FeSn thin films epitaxially grown on SrTiO 3 (111) substrates, we observe trimerization of the Kagome lattice using scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy, breaking its six-fold rotational symmetry while preserving the translational symmetry. Such a trimerized Kagome lattice shows an energy-dependent contrast reversal in dI/dV maps, which is significantly enhanced by bound states induced by Sn vacancy defects. This trimerized Kagome lattice also exhibits stripe modulations that are energy-dependent and tunable by an applied in-plane magnetic field, indicating symmetry-breaking nematicity from the entangled magnetic and charge degrees of freedom in antiferromagnet FeSn.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Perspective on Kramers symmetry breaking and restoration in relativistic electronic structure methods for open-shell systems

Without rigorous symmetry constraints, solutions to approximate electronic structure methods may artificially break symmetry. In the case of the relativistic electronic structure, if time-reversal symmetry is not enforced in calculations of molecules not subject to a magnetic field, it is possible to artificially break Kramers degeneracy in open shell systems. This leads to a description of excited states that may be qualitatively incorrect. Despite this, different electronic structure methods to incorporate correlation and excited states can partially restore Kramers degeneracy from a broken symmetry solution. For single-reference techniques, the inclusion of double and possibly triple excitations in the ground state provides much of the needed correction. Formally, however, this imbalanced treatment of the Kramers-paired spaces is a multi-reference problem, and so methods such as complete-active-space methods perform much better at recovering much of the correct symmetry by state averaging. Using multi-reference configuration interaction, any additional corrections can be obtained as the solution approaches the full configuration interaction limit. A recently proposed “Kramers contamination” value is also used to assess the magnitude of symmetry breaking.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗