Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Muon Tomography”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 55 records · Page 3

Enhanced material identification via momentum-integrated muon scattering tomography

Cosmic ray muons, originating from interactions in the upper atmosphere, possess high energy and unique penetrative capabilities suitable for non-traditional radiographic inspection. This study explores their application in various fields such as nuclear fuel cask monitoring, nuclear reactor imaging, and archaeology, leveraging the principle of multiple Coulomb scattering for imaging dense materials. While muon scattering tomography has shown promise, accurately measuring muon momentum remains challenging. This research introduces the Momentum Integrated Point-of-Closest Approach (mPoCA) algorithm, integrating muon momentum data into the traditional Point-of-Closest Approach (PoCA) framework. Utilizing the Cherenkov muon spectrometer, renowned for precise muon momentum estimation, the mPoCA algorithm offers a novel imaging approach. Simulations conducted with GEANT4 evaluate the mPoCA algorithm’s performance against the standard PoCA method, demonstrating superior image resolution and enhanced material identification capabilities, particularly in distinguishing materials like uranium and lead. These findings underscore the potential of the mPoCA algorithm for advancing muon scattering tomography applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Muon Tracing and Image Reconstruction Algorithms for Cosmic Ray Muon Computed Tomography

Cosmic ray muon-computed tomography (μCT) is a new imaging modality with unique characteristics that could be particularly important for diverse applications including nuclear nonproliferation, spent nuclear fuel monitoring, cargo scanning, and volcano imaging. The strong scattering dependence of muons on atomic number Z in combination with high penetration range could offer a significant advantage over existing techniques when dense, shielded containers must be imaged. However, μCT reconstruction using conventional filtered back-projection is limited due to the overly simple assumptions that do not consider the curved path caused by multiple Coulomb scattering prompting the need for more sophisticated approaches to be developed. Here, we argue that the use of improved muon tracing and scattering angle projection algorithms as well as an algebraic reconstruction technique should produce muon tomographic images with improved quality–or require fewer muons to produce the same image quality–compared to the case where conventional methods are used. We report on the development and assessment of three novel muon tracing methods and two scattering angle projection methods for μCT. Simulated dry storage casks with single and partial missing fuel assemblies were used as numerical examples to assess and compare the proposed methods. The reconstructed images showed an expected improvement in image quality when compared with conventional techniques, even without muon momentum information, which should lead to improved detection capability, even for partial defects.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Multimodal Nondestructive Dry Cask Basket Structure and Spent Fuel Evaluation

This NEUP-IRP assembled a team from diverse institutions and a diverse set of expertise to examine the problem of assessing the structural health of dry nuclear fuel storage casks, specifically the TN-32 design. With no physical access designed into these storage casks and the high cost and risk associated with opening casks for direct inspection, the technical difficulty of structural assessment of the basket structure and fuel assemblies is high. In response to this challenge, this IRP brought together experts in both traditional and novel NDE methodologies: active acoustics (University of Mississippi), emissions tomography (University of Florida), muon tomography (Oregon State University), and passive-active ultrasonics (University of South Carolina). Further, our industry partners in the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) and AREVA provided invaluable insight into technical design details for the cask, practical knowledge of operating parameters at a storage facility, and key relationships that enabled activities unforeseen at the time of the proposed work but were critical in guiding the path of the research. The team decided early in the project that we had a collective goal of laying the technical ground work for practical solutions that could be implemented in the field with reasonable cost, time, and reliability. A fortunate opportunity arose early in this IRP project to obtain access to a new TN-32 cask at Columbiana High Tech. Both acoustics teams were given access for testing concepts in the first year of the project. This ended up providing critical guidance in the design of subsequent laboratory experiments. Specifically, it became clear that the only reliable acoustic pathways to the interior were through the trunnions, base plate, and top ring of the cask. Based on these field tests and discussions about what would be of practical interest, the team as a whole decided a realistic goal was to detect catastrophic failure of a single fuel assembly, or one that was missing. It is clear from this work that the active acoustics / resonance and muon tomography methodologies would be capable of detecting interior structural integrity problems at this level. The other two areas of investigation (emissions tomography and passive/active ultrasonics) would need more testing to determine a successful implementation, but each may also have other applications such as long term monitoring and monitoring during transportation. This IRP project resulted in technical advances with applications that extend beyond the problem at hand, supported the training of 10 graduate students + 1 post doc, 21 publications, and 13 conference presentations. The remainder of this summary highlights significant activities and achievements in each of the methodologies and a brief discussion on how they can be combined to leverage strengths. Active Acoustics The active acoustics team at UM used both linear and non-linear structural resonance methods to infer information about the internal structure of a cask. Significant activities were a set of four field test measurements on a full scale TN-32 cask at the Columbiana Hi Tech facility in Greensboro, NC and the design and fabrication of a 1/6th scale model TN-32 cask for laboratory measurements. A significant set of acoustic data has been acquired on both the full scale and laboratory scale casks. It was determined early in the project that mechanical resonance techniques were not going to be sensitive to small scale (centimeter) cracks and structural defects in the basket structure or fuel assemblies. We were able to ascertain that both the energy and complexity of the resonance spectra were sensitive to “bulk state” of the fuel assemblies – an intact assembly versus a severely degraded assembly. By developing a novel combination of metrics, we are able to measure a statistically significant shift due to one out of the 32 fuel assemblies being either missing or degraded to a point of complete loss of structural coherence (i.e. “rubble”). We believe this combination of resonance metrics is new to the field and will have applications beyond the fuel storage problem. Emissions Tomography The Emissions Tomography team at the University of Florida explored the concept of using scattering of radiation emissions from the stored fuel as method of evaluating the internal structural health of the cask. Due to the need for emissive fuel assemblies and the difficulties of gaining access to storage facilities, this team primarily relied on simulations to inform feasibility. A key question was the flux estimates of neutrons with a small enough number of scattering events to retain spatial information. Some key conclusions from the transmission component of this work are that the number of scattering events falls rapidly with energy – setting a 11MeV threshold, the average number of scattering events is 8∓4. Rough estimates of scanning times using an ideal detector array would be 1 week. The team also explored the case of significant structural failure resulting in a shift of the source material (fuel). The result is that a +/- 2% mass shift results in a detectable (5.13%) shift in the correlated 2 neutron emission counts and thus may be a candidate as an initial survey. Finally, simulations for predicting the azimuthal dependence of the flux based on specific loading patterns were conducted. Due to self-shielding effects of the assemblies, a periodic pattern results and could potentially be used to identify missing or severely degraded assemblies. This work forms a basis for proper detector placement with the goal of optimizing sensitivity. Muon Tomography Muon tomography (MT) is a relatively novel method of interrogating interior structure on a large scale. One of the advantages of this technique is that the exciting energy source (cosmic muons) is ubiquitous and relatively stable in time. Challenging aspects are relatively low flux rates and appropriate detector technologies. The efforts of the muon group at Oregon State University focused on two areas: (1) simulation of various combinations of muon scattering events and detection schemes to assess sensitivities and time scales for image construction and (2) building a prototype muon detection system applicable to the dry storage cask problem as well as many other similar systems. Significant accomplishments in this area are: (1) demonstration that MT is a viable method for detecting missing or severely degraded rod assemblies, (2) a scintillation based detector with 4 panels and 32 channels of position data each were constructed, tested, and calibrated. Testing of the panels using natural muon background and no scattering objects yielded largely expected results – a straight line path for the muon through the four panels. However some anomalies (paths deviating from a line) were also detected. A redesign of the board improved the signal which greatly improved the muon tracking through the panels. Testing with lead bricks as scattering bodies showed a reduction in the coincidence rate with increasing bricks indicating increased scattering events. A refinement of the scintillator detector design resulted in a spatial image resolution of around 2 cm based on lead brick spacing tests lasting 24 hours. Passive/Active Ultrasonics This team at the University of South Carolina investigated the feasibility of combining passive ultrasonics, in which an elastic pulse is generated by a degradation process (such as a crack extending), and active ultrasonics, in which a known excitation is introduced into the structure and detected by an array of transducers. Significant accomplishments in this area include the development of elastic wave propagation simulation in relevant materials, development of diagnostic algorithms, and laboratory testing and validation using laser doppler vibrometry. This group demonstrated the applicability of various non-contact vibration detection methodologies such as air-coupled ultrasonic transducers and scanning laser doppler vibrometry. While passive acoustic emissions monitoring will likely have a role during the transportation of a fuel storage cask, the level of detailed information about the defect generating the event which can be ascertained from the detections in a complex structure remains for future work. Thermography The EPRI team contributed early in the project a series of thermography measurements in which various levels of water pooled in a mock-up canister were analyzed using commercially available infrared imaging technologies. While large levels of water (100 L, ~10 cm deep) were observable in the thermograms, more realistic levels of pooled water (1 L) were not detectable whether localized or distributed.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Muon-Computed Tomography using POCA Trajectory for Imaging Spent Nuclear Fuel in Dry Storage Casks

Cosmic ray muon-computed tomography (μCT) is a new imaging modality with unique characteristics that can be particularly important for applications in nuclear proliferation detection and international treaty verification. Using cosmic ray muons for nuclear security presents several potential advantages. Among others, muons are generated naturally in the atmosphere, can penetrate high-density materials, and are freely available. No radiological sources are required and consequently there is no associated radiological dose. Recently, the feasibility of using muons for imaging spent nuclear fuel stored in shielded casks has been explored and has been proved beneficial. However, challenges in μCT imaging include low muon flux of ~10,000 muons/m2/min, the effects of multiple Coulomb scattering (MCS) blurring the image, and inefficiency in being able to use all recorded muons for imaging. In this paper, we argue that the use of muon tracing should produce tomographic muon images with improved quality – or more quickly for the same image quality – compared to the case where conventional methods are used. In our paper, we report on the development and assessment of a novel muon tracing method for μCT. The proposed method back projects the muon’s scattering angle into each pixel crossed by its PoCA trajectory then forward projects the variance of the scattering angle in each pixel to detector bins along the muon’s incident horizontal direction. Two scenarios were simulated to assess the expected detection capability of this proposed method. GEANT4 was used to model the main characteristics of 1-60 GeV muons through matter. The simulated images showed an expected improvement in resolution and a reduced the reliance on the muon momentum information compared to a more conventional muon tomography method.

Liu, Zhengzhi↗

Historical Building Stability Monitoring by Means of a Cosmic Ray Tracking System

Cosmic ray radiation is mostly composed, at sea level, by high energy muons, which are highly penetrating particles capable of crossing kilometers of rock. The ubiquitous and steady presence at the Earth's surface and the high penetration capability have motivated the use of cosmic ray radiation also in fields beyond particle physics, from geology, archaeology, speleology to industrial applications and homeland security. In particular, in recent years, the novel technique of muon tomography has been proposed, with the aim of performing non invasive inspection of large non accessible volumes, material atomic number Z and density discrimination, and three dimension image reconstruction of the inspected volume. In the present paper, after a short recall of the physical principles and mathematical formalism on which muon tomography is based, a number of examples of application of the novel technique in industry and homeland security issues is given. Moreover, a new application of cosmic rays detection techniques in the field of civil engineering is proposed. The aim is the monitoring of the stability of large structures, in particular the static monitoring of historical buildings, where conservation constraints are more severe and the time evolution of the deformation phenomena under study may be of the order of months or years. The new technique may be seen, in some way, as the reverse problem of muon tomography. As a significant case study, the monitoring of the wooden vaulted roof of the Palazzo della Loggia in the town of Brescia, in Italy, has been considered. The feasibility as well as the performances and limitations of a monitoring system based on cosmic ray tracking have been studied by Monte Carlo simulation and discussed in comparison with more traditional monitoring systems. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Momentum informed muon scattering tomography for monitoring spent nuclear fuels in dry storage cask

Development of an effective monitoring method for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) in a dry storage cask (DSC) is important to meet the increasing demand for dry storage investigations. The DSC investigation should provide information about the quantity of stored SNF, and quality assurance of materials should be possible without opening the cask. However, traditional nondestructive examination (NDE) methods such as x-rays are difficult to deploy for DSC investigation because a typical DSC is intentionally designed to shield against radiation. To address this challenge, cosmic ray muons (CRMs) are used as an alternative NDE radiation probe because they can easily penetrate an entire DSC system; however, a wide application of muons is often hindered due to the naturally low CRM flux (~10 4 muons/m 2 /min). This paper introduces a newly proposed imaging algorithm, momentum-informed muon scattering tomography (MMST) , and presents how a limitation of the current muon scattering tomography technique has been addressed by measuring muon momentum. To demonstrate its functionality, a commercial DSC with 24 pressurized light water reactor fuel assemblies (FAs) and the MMST system were designed in GEANT4. Three noticeable improvements were observed for MMST system as a DSC investigation tool: (1) a signal stabilization, (2) an enhanced capability to differentiate various materials, and (3) statistically increased precision to identify and locate missing FAs. The results show that MMST improves the investigation accuracy from 79 to 98% when one FA is missing and 51% to 88% when one-half FA is missing. The advancement of the NDE technique using CRM for DSC verification is expected to resolve long-standing problems in increasing demand for DSC inspections and nuclear security.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

A new method for imaging nuclear threats using cosmic ray muons

Muon tomography is a technique that uses cosmic ray muons to generate three-dimensional images of volumes using information contained in the Coulomb scattering of the muons. Advantages of this technique are the ability of cosmic rays to penetrate significant overburden and the absence of any additional dose delivered to subjects under study beyond the natural cosmic ray flux. Disadvantages include the relatively long exposure times and poor position resolution and complex algorithms needed for reconstruction. Furthermore, we demonstrate a new method for obtaining improved position resolution and statistical precision for objects with spherical symmetry.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Cosmic ray muon computed tomography of spent nuclear fuel in dry storage casks

Radiography with cosmic ray muon scattering has proven to be a successful method of imaging nuclear material through heavy shielding. Of particular interest is monitoring dry storage casks for diversion of plutonium contained in spent reactor fuel. Using muon tracking detectors that surround a cylindrical cask, cosmic ray muon scattering can be simultaneously measured from all azimuthal angles, giving complete tomographic coverage of the cask interior. This article describes the first application of filtered back projection algorithms, typically used in medical imaging, to cosmic ray muon scattering imaging. The specific application to monitoring spent nuclear fuel in dry storage casks is investigated via GEANT4 simulations. With a cylindrical muon tracking detector surrounding a typical spent fuel cask, simulations indicate that missing fuel bundles can be detected with a statistical significance of ~18σ in less than two days exposure and a sensitivity at 1σ to a 5% missing portion of a fuel bundle. Finally, we discuss potential detector technologies and geometries.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Measurement of Gas Bubbles Encased in Bitumen Nuclear Waste Drums with Muon Scattering Tomography - 18237

In some countries low and intermediate level nuclear waste is stored in steel containers with either pure bitumen added to fill the free volume, or after mixing of the waste with bitumen. Oxidation of the bitumen by interacting with the nuclear waste results in the production of hydrogen. Since pure bitumen is impermeable to water and gases, this hydrogen can assemble in bubbles, possibly resulting in bitumen overflowing out of the waste containers. It is necessary to develop ways of measuring the gas bubbles present in nuclear waste without intervening and compromising the container. We show that this can be done using muon scattering tomography, by applying an analysis method, first developed to find high-Z materials in a lower Z background of concrete, to data from a low-Z material in a higher Z background. The performance of this method is shown, by implementing it on Monte Carlo simulation data. A resolution on the total gas volume of 1.6±0.8% has been achieved for bubbles of 2 liters or more. It is also shown that the method can determine if the gas is located in separate bubbles or concentrated in a bigger one. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

A Prototype Large Area Detector Module for Muon Scattering Tomography

Abstract-Shielded special nuclear materials (SNM) are of concern as some fissile isotopes have low gamma and neutron emission rates. These materials are also easily shielded to the point where their passive emissions are comparable to background. Consequently, shielded SNM is very challenging for passive radiation detection portals which scan cargo containers. One potential solution for this is to utilise the natural cosmic ray muon background and examine how these muons scatter from materials inside the container volume, terms; the muon scattering tomography (MST) technique measures the three-dimensional localised scattering at all points within a cargo container, providing a degree of material discrimination. There is the additional benefit that the MST signal increases with the presence of more high density shielding materials, in contrast to passive radiation detection. Simulations and calculations suggest that the effectiveness of the technique is sensitive to the tracking accuracy amongst other parameters, motivating the need to develop practical detector systems that are capable of tracking cosmic ray muons. To this end, we have constructed and tested a 2 m by 2 m demonstration module based on gaseous drift chambers and triggered by a large area scintillator-based detector, which is readout by wavelength shifting fibres. We discuss its design, construction, characterisation and operational challenges. (authors)

42 ENGINEERING↗

Imaging Shielded Configurations Using Near-Horizontal and Near-Vertical Trajectory Cosmic-Ray Muons

This work will describe the proof-of-concept research applying muon tomography technologies based on drift tube systems to create images using near–horizontal trajectory muons. To date, the majority of imaging studies using cosmic-ray muons have used near–vertical trajectory muons. This work compares imaging results using near–vertical trajectory muons with results using near–horizontal trajectory muons. The muon flux is much lower for the near–horizontal trajectory muons, so requiring longer imaging times, but the average muon energy is higher, so the horizontal results are expected to better differentiate high-Z materials. The muon tracking system is easily configurable and can be oriented to capture near–vertical trajectory or near– horizontal trajectory cosmic-ray muons. The software can track each muon passing through the system, and generate 3-D images of the scene. The experimental design and preliminary results will be presented, including the comparisons of detection efficiency, image resolution, and integration times.

muon, passive, imaging, tomography, cosmic↗

Simulations of muon imaging with the LANL GMT detector for spent nuclear fuel cask content verification

Atmospheric muons are typically high energy, highly penetrating charged particles. They interact with matter primarily through multiple Coulomb scatterings. Muon scattering intensities can be used to characterize the density and atomic number of the matter that they pass through. Previously, the Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) muon tomography team performed muon imaging of the partially filled MC-10 spent nuclear fuel (SNF) cask at Idaho National Laboratory (INL). This experiment demonstrated the feasibility of muon imaging for the verification of spent fuel container contents. That original effort used the mini muon tracker array, consisting of two arrays of drift tubes on either side of the SNF cask. The reconstructed image quality was limited by statistics, largely due to low muon flux at high zenith angles. A LANL led team will perform new measurements with a larger array, the Giant Muon Tracker (GMT), to improve data collection rates and statistics. In this work, simulations were performed with the GMT near the partially filled INL MC-10 cask. For more general fuel diversion detection, a full MC-10 cask and casks with a singular missing fuel bundle were also simulated. To understand minimum measurement times needed for missing bundle identification, 100 000 to millions of tracked muons (corresponding to 1.4 days to several weeks measurement time) were analyzed. Simulated images were then analyzed visually and numerically to explore techniques designed to minimize the collection time needed to identify the diversion of fuel in each scenario.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Muon Borehole Detector Design for Use in 4-D Density Overburden Monitoring

The increase of atmospheric CO2 concentrations has initiated research into carbon sequestration methods. One possibility is to store CO2 in subsurface porous reservoirs. The monitoring of the injected CO2 plume is vital because escaping CO2 poses health and environmental risks. Typically, seismic reflection methods are used to determine the change in density due to the replacement of brine by CO2 in the reservoir, but this is expensive and not continuous. A potential alternative is to use cosmic muon tomography to measure density changes in the reservoir as a function of time. This paper describes the development of a muon detector that will be capable of being deployed in boreholes. The detector has the required dimensions, an angular resolution of approximately 2 degrees, and is robust. The design is based on alternating layers of scintillating rods, which can provide 4-D tomographic data to detect small changes in density at depths up to approximately 2 km. Geant4, a Monte Carlo simulation code, is being used to develop models to guide the design of the physical configuration. Preliminary testing and measurements have been performed to validate the simulation predictions and optimize the performance of the system. The simulation and preliminary experimental results are presented here.

Borehole Detector, CO¬2 Sequestration, Geant4, Muo↗

Securing the metal recycling chain for the steel industry by detecting orphan radioactive sources in scrap metal

Experimental tests are reported for the detection of the heavy metal shielding of orphan sources hidden inside scrap metal by using a recently developed muon tomography system. Shielded sources do not trigger alarm in radiation portal commonly employed at the entrance of steel industry using scrap metal. Future systems integrating radiation portals with muon tomography inspection gates will substantially reduce the possibility of accidental melting of radioactive sources securing the use of recycled metal.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Characteristics of Muon Computed Tomography of Used Fuel Casks Using Algebraic Reconstruction

Cosmic raymuons passing through matter lose energy from inelastic collisions with electrons and are deflected from nuclei due to multiple Coulomb scattering (MCS). The recent developments in position sensitive muon detectors that can measure incoming and outgoing trajectories of individual muons indicate that MCS could be an excellent candidate for spent nuclear fuel imaging. The main purpose of this paper is to evaluate tomographic scanning of spent nuclear fuel stored within vertical and horizontal dry storage casks. A quantitative analysis of the characteristics of images obtained with filtered back projection (FBP) and algebraic reconstruction techniques (ART) are presented herein, as such a comparison has not been carried out in the past. FBP is a fast tool to determine object boundaries. ART can include muon path models and prior knowledge that can improve resolution and reduce measurement time. The results demonstrate that missing fuel assemblies can be identified with more than 5 projections and that use of muon momentum significantly increases image resolution. It is expected that MCS can be used to successfully reconstruct the dry cask contents and allow identification of all described scenarios in hours. It is also expected that when total variation minimization and a non-local mean filter are applied, ART may yield much better image quality than FBP.

Liu, Zhengzhi↗

Los Alamos, Toshiba probing Fukushima with cosmic rays

Los Alamos National Laboratory has announced an impending partnership with Toshiba Corporation to use a Los Alamos technique called muon tomography to safely peer inside the cores of the Fukushima Daiichi reactors and create high-resolution images of the damaged nuclear material inside without ever breaching the cores themselves. The initiative could reduce the time required to clean up the disabled complex by at least a decade and greatly reduce radiation exposure to personnel working at the plant. Muon radiography (also called cosmic-ray radiography) uses secondary particles generated when cosmic rays collide with upper regions of Earth's atmosphere to create images of the objects that the particles, called muons, penetrate. The process is analogous to an X-ray image, except muons are produced naturally and do not damage the materials they contact. Muon radiography has been used before in imaginative applications such as mapping the interior of the Great Pyramid at Giza, but Los Alamos's muon tomography technique represents a vast improvement over earlier technology.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗