Engineering PapersSearch

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Membranes”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 55 records · Page 3

Nanofiltration Membranes for Li + /Mg 2+ Separation: Materials and Mechanisms

Nanofiltration (NF) membranes have garnered significant interest for Li + /Mg 2+ separation, a crucial step in lithium extraction from brines. The state-of-the-art commercial LiNE-XD membrane exhibits a Li + /Mg 2+ separation factor (SF Li/Mg ) of 42 at pH 3.3, due to the positive charges on the membrane surface and its strong size-sieving ability. Membranes with higher separation factors at a broad pH range are being pursued to improve separation efficiency. This work aims to provide a timely and comprehensive assessment of advanced NF membranes with superior Li + /Mg 2+ separation properties, as well as their structure and property relationships for designing next-generation membranes. We describe transport mechanisms for ions in NF membranes and discuss governing parameters and models employed to quantify the Li + /Mg 2+ separation. High-performance membrane materials are exhaustively introduced, including commercial and modified polyamides, two-dimensional materials, metal–organic frameworks, crown ethers, and their blends. Finally, we critically compare these membranes in an upper bound plot and highlight the opportunities and challenges of NF membranes for practical Li + /Mg 2+ separations.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH

Surface engineering of polymeric membranes with metal oxides for improved fouling resistance and superior oil-water separation

Rapid industrial growth has increased the need for efficient membranes to separate oil-water emulsions. Polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) membranes, although widely used due to their chemical inertness and favorable mechanical properties, suffer from fouling due to their intrinsic hydrophobicity. Modifying these membranes after fabrication offers a practical solution as it easily fits into existing large-scale manufacturing processes. Atomic layer deposition (ALD), an atomically-precise vapor phase surface modification technique, can create ultrathin metal oxide layers that greatly improve membrane hydrophilicity without significantly affecting the original pore size. However, PVDF's lack of reactive chemical moieties makes ALD challenging. Here, in this study, we present a simple alkali treatment that greatly enhances ALD nucleation and growth on PVDF membranes. This treatment imparts exceptional oil-water emulsion separation capabilities and antifouling behavior in PVDF membranes after just a few ALD cycles, surpassing the performance of PVDF membranes coated with hundreds of ALD cycles. This dramatic reduction in the number of ALD cycles required could enable cost-effective modification of commercial PVDF membranes at scale using spatial, roll-to-roll ALD. These modified membranes outperform reported modified PVDF membranes, with >99 % permeance recovery and <1 % irreversible loss of permeance and >98 % oil rejection from oil-water emulsions over 100 h continuous operation, making them promising for advanced water purification technologies.

Atomic layer deposition

Single‐Step Recovery of Water from Stable Crude Oil‐Water Emulsion Using Surface Engineered Hybrid Inorganic‐Polymer Membranes

ABSTRACT Separating crude oil from water remains one of the most stubborn challenges in environmental remediation, especially for surfactant‐stabilized emulsions that resist conventional demulsification methods. Here, we report a scalable strategy for achieving near‐zero‐discharge separation of crude oil emulsions using a single superhydrophilic membrane. By applying low‐temperature atomic layer deposition (ALD) of various metal oxides onto activated polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) membranes, we create atomically precise surface‐engineered (SE) membranes that maintain an exceptionally strong hydration layer at the membrane‐feed interface, even at high oil loadings. Among the various metal oxides, TiO 2 ‐modified SE membranes exhibit superior interfacial water stability, enabling sustained dewatering of complex crude oil‐water emulsions with >98% separation efficiency and >97% water recovery, compared to only 24.6% water recovery for the pristine membrane. This separation performance surpasses conventional hydrophilic membranes and is comparable to complex Janus channel membrane systems, demonstrating near‐complete emulsion separation using a single membrane. This low‐temperature membrane surface engineering process with atomic‐level precision and potential for scalability via roll‐to‐roll fabrication is promising for industrial‐scale, energy‐efficient water treatment and oil spill remediation applications.

Sengupta, Bratin [Applied Materials Division Argon

Designing a Block Copolymer Membrane for Selective Transport of Lactic Acid from Aqueous Mixtures

We report the design and synthesis of a triblock copolymer-based membrane for enabling selective transport of lactic acid from aqueous solutions. This is relevant to the production of polylactic acid, one of the few biodegradable and biobased polymers with sufficient mechanical strength for practical applications. The end blocks are positively charged with negatively charged lactate counterions. The middle block is polybutadiene (PBD). Due to microphase separation, the charged blocks form channels for transporting lactic acid. The mechanical integrity of the membrane is controlled by cross-linking the PBD block. Transport of lactic acid and water across the membrane was studied by placing the membrane between two chambers, a feed chamber containing aqueous lactic acid solutions, and a receiving chamber containing pure water. The lactic acid concentration in the receiving chamber was monitored as a function of time using conductivity, HPLC, and NMR. The corresponding flux of water from the receiving chamber to the feed chamber was measured using an NMR-based approach. The lactic acid and water permeabilities through our membrane were (1.12 ± 0.05) × 10–8 and (8.58 ± 0.75) × 10–9 cm2 s–1. To our knowledge, there are no reports of lactic acid permeabilities through any membrane in the literature. The separation factor of our membrane, αLA/water, 1.305 ± 0.123, is comparable to that of membranes used for selective transport of ethanol, despite the fact that lactic acid is a much larger molecule than ethanol. Selective transport of lactic acid in our membrane is governed mainly by differences in solubility; lactic acid is 18 times more soluble in the membrane than water.

Jana, Rounak

Vacuum-assisted carbon molecular sieve membrane reactor for non-oxidative ethane dehydrogenation

Non-oxidative ethane dehydrogenation (EDH) is equilibrium-limited and endothermic. Selective hydrogen removal using a gas-permeable membrane within the EDH reaction zone can overcome the thermodynamic equilibrium, enabling higher ethane conversions. Employing vacuum as the permeation driving force, rather than a sweep gas, enhances the industrial viability of membrane reactors by eliminating additional post-reaction separation units. This study presents a membrane reactor that integrates H 2 -permeable carbon molecular sieve (CMS) hollow fiber membranes embedded in a fixed bed of cobalt in a dealuminated beta zeolite (Co@DeAl-BEA) catalyst, utilizing a vacuum to remove hydrogen efficiently. The CMS membrane exhibits high hydrogen permeance and an excellent H 2 /C 2 H 6 separation factor. The membrane reactor significantly enhanced the ethane conversion under reaction conditions comparable to those reported in the literature. A Langmuir-Hinshelwood kinetic rate expression was developed and incorporated into a one-dimensional steady-state reactor model. The experimentally validated model indicates that increasing the number of hollow fibers improves ethane conversion, although ethane loss to the permeate limits the benefit. The contact area between the catalyst and the membrane limits the reactor performance more than the catalytic throughput. Furthermore, we find that the location of the catalyst packing relative to the hollow fiber membranes influences ethane loss and conversion. Higher reactor pressures and inlet ethane flow rates improve space-time yield at the expense of lower ethane conversion. Increasing reactor temperature or packing length promotes both performance metrics. The EDH membrane reactor demonstrated durability over 200 h of continuous operation, maintaining record-low deactivation rates and high ethylene selectivity. Protocols for catalyst regeneration were developed.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI

A computational investigation of high-flux, plate-and-frame membrane modules for industrial carbon capture

In this work, we study the application of membrane-based separation systems for carbon capture, considering plate-and-frame membrane modules. The successful deployment of membrane CO 2 capture system relies on high-performing membranes as well as effective membrane modules that can fully exploit the developed membranes. A plate-and-frame membrane module is especially attractive for CO 2 capture from industrial flue gas due to its lower pressure drop compared to its counterparts such as spiral wound modules and hollow fiber modules. To design better plate-and-frame modules, we investigate their basic unit - a single membrane stack through a combination of computational modeling and experimental investigations. The modeling approach is based on Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to represent a multiphysics problem, including the fluid flow and diffusion processes within a membrane module. We use experimental data collected under different operating conditions to validate the CFD model. Numerical results suggest a good agreement between experiments and model outputs for the CO 2 recovery, CO 2 mole fraction in the retentate and permeate, and stage-cut. The CFD model is able to predict accurately the flow behavior, providing valuable insights on the effects of fluid dynamics on mass transfer of CO 2 . We also carry out a sensitivity analysis to identify the effect of key parameters on the CO 2 recovery and the CO 2 purity of the outlet streams.

CFD simulation

Investigating intermolecular interactions among CO 2 , water and PEEK-ionene membrane using cryo ToF-SIMS and isotopic labeling

Cryogenic time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (cryo ToF-SIMS) has emerged as a powerful tool for investigating molecular interactions, speciation, and dynamics in materials for CO 2 capture. In this study, we apply cryo ToF-SIMS to probe interactions between CO 2 , water, and PEEK-ionene membranes—a promising material for direct CO 2 capture due to its selectivity, durability, and efficiency. Despite this potential, the mechanisms governing CO 2 diffusion and the influence of water vapor on CO 2 behavior remain unclear. To address this, we loaded PEEK-ionene membranes with 13 CO 2 and D 2 O and employed cryo ToF-SIMS to visualize the 3D distribution of CO 2 and water within the membrane. While prior studies suggest that 13 CO 2 is absorbed under ambient conditions, our cryo ToF-SIMS analysis revealed no enhancement of the 13 C/ 12 C ratio, suggesting weak CO 2 -membrane interactions. As a result, CO 2 vaporizes even at low temperatures (−140°C) under vacuum conditions. In contrast, D 2 O displayed a relatively homogeneous distribution in the membrane, suggesting stronger water-membrane interactions via hydrogen bonding (18–20 kJ/mol). Interestingly, CO 2 was not detected in D 2 O-loaded membranes, indicating minimal interference from water vapor on CO 2 diffusion. As a comparison, the cryo ToF-SIMS data show that 13 CO 2 can readily react with a basic Na 2 CO 3 aqueous solution to form NaH 13 CO 3 . These findings demonstrate cryo ToF-SIMS as a critical technique for understanding gas-water-membrane interactions, offering insights for membrane functionalization to improve CO 2 capture efficiency.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH

Pillared Laminar Vermiculite Membranes with Tunable Monovalent and Multivalent Ion Selectivity

Effective membrane separation of Li + from Na + and Mg 2+ is crucial for lithium extraction from water yet challenging for conventional polymeric membranes. Two dimensional (2D) membranes with ordered laminar structures and tunable physicochemical properties offer distinctive ion-sieving capabilities promising for lithium extraction. Recently, phyllosilicates are introduced as abundant and cost-effective source materials for such membranes. However, their water instability and low inherent ion transport selectivity hinder practical applications. Herein, a new class of laminar membranes with excellent stability and tunable ion sieving is reported by incorporating inorganic alumina pillars into vermiculite interlayers. Crosslinking vermiculite flakes with alumina pillars significantly strengthens interlamellar interactions, resulting in robust water stability. Doping of Na + before the pillaring process reverses the membrane's surface charge, substantially boosting Li + separation from multivalent cations via electrostatic interactions. Lithium extraction is often complicated by the presence of co-existing monovalent cations (e.g., Na + ) at higher concentrations. Here, by introducing excess Na + into the membrane after the pillaring process, the separation of Li + from monovalent cations is enhanced through steric effects. This work realizes both monovalent/multivalent and monovalent/monovalent selective ion sieving with the same membrane platform. A separation mechanism is proposed based on Donnan exclusion and size exclusion, providing new insights for membrane design for resource recovery applications.

2D materials

Specific iron binding to natural sphingomyelin membrane induced by non-specific co-solutes

Sphingomyelin (SPM), a crucial phospholipid in the myelin sheath, plays a vital role in insulating nerve fibers. We hypothesize that iron ions selectively bind to the phosphatidylcholine (PC) template within the SPM membrane under near-physiological conditions, resulting in disruptions to membrane organization. These interactions could potentially contribute to the degradation of the myelin sheath, thereby playing a role in the development of neurodegenerative diseases. We utilized synchrotron-based X-ray spectroscopy and diffraction techniques to study the interaction of iron ions with a bovine spinal-cord SPM monolayer (ML) at the liquid-vapor interface under physiological conditions. The SPM ML serves as a model system, representing localized patches of lipids within a more complex membrane structure. The experiments assessed iron binding to the SPM membrane both in the presence of salts and with additional evaluation of the effects of various ion species on membrane behavior. Grazing incidence X-ray diffraction was employed to analyze the impact of iron binding on the structural integrity of the SPM membrane. Furthermore, our results demonstrate that iron ions in dilute solution selectively bind to the PC template of the SPM membrane exclusively at near-physiological salt concentrations (e.g., NaCl, KCl, KI, or CaCl 2 ) and are pH-dependent. In-significant binding was detected in the absence of these salts or at near-neutral pH with salts. The surface adsorption of iron ions is correlated with salt concentration, reaching saturation at physiological levels. In contrast, multivalent ions such as La 3+ and Ca 2+ do not bind to SPM under similar conditions. Notably, iron binding to the SPM membrane disrupts its in-plane organization, suggesting that these interactions may compromise membrane integrity and contribute to myelin sheath damage associated with neurological disorders.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES

Curvature Memory in Electrically Stimulated Lipid Membranes

Here, we demonstrate, using non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations, that lipid membrane capacitance varies with surface charge accumulation linked to membrane shape and curvature changes. Specifically, we show that lipid membranes exhibit a hysteretic response when exposed to oscillatory electric fields. The electromechanical coupling in these membranes leads to hysteretic buckling, in which the membrane can spontaneously buckle in one of two distinct directions along the electric field, even for the same ionic charge accumulation at the water–membrane interface. In this regard, these binary buckled membrane states suggest potential applications in neuromorphic computing. Their bistable nature, characterized by two distinct and stable configurations, could serve as a foundation for implementing memory storage systems and logic operations. Furthermore, we introduce a circuit model that captures these dynamic effects, offering insights into emergent memory effects in electrically stimulated lipid membranes. Finally, this work presents lipid bilayers as dynamic, adaptable elements and suggests a new platform for exploring energy storage, information processing, and memory encoding at the lipid membrane level.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES

Performance and Durability Investigation of Thin, Low Crossover Proton Exchange Membranes for Water Electrolyzers

The goal of this project was to fabricate and study the performance and durability implications of thin, mechanically reinforced membranes containing gas recombination catalysts (GRCs) for advanced proton exchange membrane water electrolysis (PEMWE) systems. The thinner membranes, optimized for a PEMWE environment, dramatically reduced the proton transport resistance across the membrane, improving the overall efficiency of the PEMWE system. At the same time, the GRC technology was deployed to recombine crossover hydrogen from the cathode with oxygen from the anode to form water within the membrane. This reaction mitigated the buildup of hydrogen in the oxygen stream, ensuring safe operation of the PEMWE system. Capabilities to measure the gas crossover in both an ex-situ screening cell and in operando application testing were developed over the course of the project to track membrane progress and quantify deliverables. State of the art roll to roll manufacturing technologies were leveraged to fabricate the membranes on a commercial scale, where the membrane structure was precisely tuned and GRC distributed within the membrane structure.

08 HYDROGEN

Transformational Nano-confined Ionic Liquid Membrane for Greater than or Equal to 97 Percent Carbon Dioxide Capture from Natural Gas Combined Cycle Flue Gas

A transformational process based on nano-confined ionic liquid (NCIL) membranes was developed for capturing ≥97% CO 2 from natural gas combined cycle (NCCC) flue gas. The NCIL membranes were prepared by loading amino acid ionic liquid into a framework composed of single-walled carbon nanotube mesh filled with graphene oxide quantum dots. The membranes exhibited CO 2 permeance as high as 2,000 GPU with a CO 2 /N2 selectivity of 2,300 for a typical NGCC flue gas composition. When H 2 O vapor sweep was applied in the permeate side, 96.6% CO2 dry-basis purity and 97.6% CO 2 capture rate were achieved for a simulated NGCC flue gas with single stage. In the process design, a highly H 2 O-selective membrane would be needed to recover majority of the H 2 O vapor, and the recovered H 2 O vapor could be recycled to the permeate side of the NCIL membrane. Sulfonated poly(ether ether ketone) membranes were successfully developed for this purpose. These membranes exhibited H 2 O permeance great than 11,000 GPU and H 2 O/CO 2 selectivity greater than 1,000 at 70ºC for a feed mixture consisting of 14.5 vol% H2O and balanced CO 2 . A standalone membrane model using MATLAB platform was developed for process simulation. The model was validated with experimental data. Techno-economic analysis based on the testing data collected during the current program suggests this transformational membrane process can achieve 97% CO 2 capture efficiency with a cost of $47.8/tonne of CO 2 , which is a 21% reduction versus DOE’s reference case B31B.97.

03 NATURAL GAS

Final Technical Report: Transport of Complex Mixtures in Ion-Containing Polymer Membranes

Permselective ion-containing membranes are an integral component for many applications from water treatment, fuel cells, and solar fuels devices where the selective transport of molecules and ions is desired. In solar fuels devices, ion-containing polymer membranes are responsible for permitting selective transport of ions between electrodes to maintain overall charge neutrality yet limit transport of reaction products produced at the electrodes. While the transport of single solutes through such membranes has been fairly well described, binary and multicomponent transport is poorly understood due to the myriad of interactions that occur in these systems (i.e. between co-permeants and between permeants and the membrane). Solar fuels devices are just one example of an application where understanding the transport of multiple simultaneous species is critically important to improving device performance as product crossover leads to reductions in overall device performance. The objectives of this research was to improve our understanding of the complex array of factors that influence transport behavior of multiple solutes within ion-containing polymer membranes. This experimental project addressed the lack of fundamental understanding of multicomponent transport behavior by synthesizing ion exchange membranes with varied incorporation of comonomers (ionic and neutral moieties) to investigate fundamental relationships between membrane structure, membrane physiochemical properties, and transport behavior of solutes and complex solute mixtures through dense, hydrated membranes.

25 ENERGY STORAGE

A Pro‐Angiogenic Immunoprotective Membrane for Cell Therapies

Abstract Immunoisolation strategies that rely on porous membranes play an important role in cell transplantation therapies to protect cells from the host's immune system. These membranes must possess immunoprotective properties while facilitating the transport of nutrients and cell products to maintain the functional integrity of encapsulated cells. An easy and scalable process is described to fabricate a dual function porous polymeric membrane that shields cells against immune cell attack and promotes vascularization to address the nutritional and oxygen requirements of transplanted cells. The fabrication process results in a membrane cross‐section with a gradient of nanopores to micropores that support cell immunoisolation and interfacial vascularization requirements, respectively. The membranes demonstrate excellent cell compatibility and effectively prevent T cell transmigration without compromising glucose diffusion and oxygen permeability. In a murine subcutaneous implantation model, membranes are stable for 60 days and exhibit significantly reduced fibrous capsules, with enhanced vascularization near the membrane. These porous polymeric membranes can potentially be used as pro‐angiogenic immunoprotective membranes for cell transplantation applications where maximizing cell viability and function is of critical importance.

Engineering

Optimization of Membrane-based Carbon Capture using Dimensional Analysis, CFD and Process System Engineering

Carbon capture is a promising option to mitigate CO2 emissions from existing coal-fired power plants, cement and steel industries, and petrochemical complexes. Among the available technologies, membrane-based carbon capture presents the lowest energy consumption, operating costs, and carbon footprint. In addition, membrane processes have important operational flexibil-ity and response times. On the other hand, the major challenges to widespread application of this technology are related to reducing capital costs and improving membrane stability and durability.To upscale the technology into stacked flat sheet configurations, high fidelity computational fluid dynamics (CFD) that describes the separation process accurately are required. High fidelity simulations have been shown to be effective in studying the complex transport phenomena in membrane systems. In addition, obtaining high CO2 recovery percentages and product purity requires a multi-stage membrane process, where the optimal network configuration of the membrane modules must be studied in a systematic way. In order to address the design problem at process scale, we formulate a superstructure for the membrane-based carbon capture, including up to three separation stages. In the formulation of the optimization problem, we include reduced models, based on rigorous CFD simulations of the membrane modules. Numerical results indicate that the optimal design includes three membrane stages, and the capture cost is 45.4 $/t-CO2.

Pedrozo, Hector A.

CFD modeling of high-flux plate-and-frame membrane modules for industrial carbon capture

In this work, we study the application of membrane-based separation systems for carbon capture, considering plate-and-frame membrane modules. The successful deployment of membrane CO2 capture system relies on high-performing membranes as well as effective membrane modules that can fully exploit the developed membranes. A plate-and-frame membrane module is especially attractive for CO2 capture from industrial flue gas due to its lower pressure drop compared to its counterparts such as spiral wound modules and hollow fiber modules. To design better plate-and-frame modules, we investigate their basic unit - a single membrane stack through a combination of computational modeling and experimental investigations. The modeling approach is based on Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to represent a multiphysics problem, including the fluid flow and diffusion processes within a membrane module. We use experimental data collected under different operating conditions to validate the CFD model. Numerical results suggest a good agreement between experiments and model outputs for the CO2 recovery, CO2 mole fraction in the retentate and permeate, and stage-cut. The CFD model is able to predict accurately the flow behavior, providing valuable insights on the effects of fluid dynamics on mass transfer of CO2. We also carry out a sensitivity analysis to identify the effect of key parameters on the CO2 recovery and the CO2 purity of the outlet streams.

Dosso, Cheick

Membrane-based carbon capture process optimization using CFD modeling

Carbon capture is a promising option to mitigate CO2 emissions from existing coal-fired power plants, cement and steel industries, and petrochemical complexes. Among the available technologies, membrane-based carbon capture presents the lowest energy consumption, operating costs, and carbon footprint. In addition, membrane processes have important operational flexibility and response times. On the other hand, the major challenges to widespread application of this technology are related to reducing capital costs and improving membrane stability and durability. To upscale the technology into stacked flat sheet configurations, high fidelity computational fluid dynamics (CFD) that describes the separation process accurately are required. High fidelity simulations have been shown to be effective in studying the complex transport phenomena in membrane systems. In addition, obtaining high CO2 recovery percentages and product purity requires a multi-stage membrane process, where the optimal network configuration of the membrane modules must be studied in a systematic way. In order to address the design problem at process scale, we formulate a superstructure for the membrane-based carbon capture, including up to three separation stages. In the formulation of the optimization problem, we include reduced models, based on rigorous CFD simulations of the membrane modules. Numerical results indicate that the optimal design includes three membrane stages, and the capture cost is 45.4 $/t-CO2.

Pedrozo, Hector A.

Gaseous contaminant transfer in membrane-based air-to-air energy exchangers

Membrane-based air-to-air energy exchangers (M–AAEEs) transfer heat and moisture between building exhaust air and fresh ventilation air streams through a membrane, thereby reducing the energy required for conditioning the fresh ventilation air. Energy exchangers are typically used in buildings with relatively clean building exhaust air, such as office buildings and schools. Recently interest in using energy exchangers in a wider range of buildings has grown, to reduce the energy consumption associated with the heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems in these buildings. However, if the building exhaust air is not clean, as would be the case for laboratories or factories, new risks are encountered when using energy exchangers. It is possible that gaseous contaminants in the exhaust air may also transfer along with the moisture through the membranes, contaminating the incoming fresh ventilation air. Current test standards provide a test procedure to determine the contamination of the fresh ventilation air by measuring the transfer of an inert tracer gas in an energy exchanger. However, the tracer gas test may not represent the transfer of common indoor air contaminants due to differences in their transport properties. Therefore, in this study, an experimental facility is developed to determine the transfer of seven different contaminants through two membranes (porous and dense) at different flow rates. Contaminant transfer is quantified using a parameter called the exhaust contaminant transfer ratio (ECTR), which gives the fraction of the contaminants transferred from the exhaust air to the fresh ventilation air. A theoretical model based on the effectiveness-number of transfer units (ε-NTU) correlation and moisture transfer resistance of the membrane is presented to determine transfer through porous membranes and validated with experimental results. The major contribution of this paper is that it presents a simple method to predict the transfer of different contaminants through a porous membrane based on the moisture transfer resistance of the membrane at different operating conditions. It is found that as contaminant diffusivity decreases, ECTR generally also decreases, and as the flow rate increases, ECTR decreases, which is consistent with the predictions from the correlation.

42 ENGINEERING