Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Fuel Rod Simulation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 55 records · Page 3

CYRANO3 the EDF fuel code performance: Global overview and recent developments on MOX fuel

CYRANO3 is the thermal mechanical industrial code developed and used by EDF to simulate the nuclear fuel rod performance in pile, and during the disposal storage period as well. This code has already been used successfully for the last ten years by the EDF engineering teams in justifying the overall reloading options covering various fuels: UO{sub 2}, UO{sub 2} + gadolinium, MOX, UO{sub 2} plus additives, and various cladding as well proposed by the nuclear fuel suppliers. Its particularity is related to a construction around a standard one-dimensional thermal and mechanical finite elements kernel with an appropriate architecture to plug in any new functionalities or models. Since the beginning it is developed as a module able integrating within a core calculation chain. Other constrain is to always guaranty a running time consistent with the calculation of a core within a reasonable time. The objective is to provide the EDF designers with a convivial and qualified code, with robust algorithms and able to quickly evolve with computer performances. Algorithms are able to account for adiabatic transients and are robust enough to avoid any undesirable overflows. The permanent challenge is indeed to provide with the more descriptive simulations not degrading to much the running time. Developments are obviously performed within the strict Quality Insurance rules. The code is then associated to a large documentation base, including model specification, realization, validation and test procedures. Maintenance is managed through a system of anomaly and improvement forms. Computers are still evolving quickly. Therefore, after an architecture adaptation, the CYRANO3 code is now integrated in the PLEIADES platform as a PWR industrial application. The platform is an exchange space allowing sharing functionalities, models and properties. In this paper, we will give a global overview of the capabilities of CYRANO3 code to simulate the thermomechanical behavior of fuel rods, and we will focus on recent developments realized on MOX fuel. In CYRANO3 code, heterogeneous models (neutronic model, micromechanical behavior law and fission gas model) are developed for MOX fuels and integrated in order to account for differential evolutions between phases under irradiation. The methodology and these models are presented in this paper. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

A multidimensional and multiphysics approach to nuclear fuel behavior simulation

Important aspects of fuel rod behavior are inherently multidimensional in addition to being complicated multiphysics problems. However, many current fuels modeling tools are strictly 2D axisymmetric or even 1.5D. This paper outlines the capabilities of a new fuel modeling tool able to analyze either 2D axisymmetric or fully 3D models. The need for multiphysics, multidimensional modeling is then demonstrated through a set of example problems. The first, a 10-pellet rodlet, demonstrates the viability of the solution method employed. This example highlights the effect of our smeared cracking model and also shows the multidimensional nature of discrete fuel pellet modeling. The second example relies on our multidimensional, multiphysics approach to analyze a missing pellet surface problem. As a final example, we show a 5-pellet rodlet simulation coupled to lower-length-scale simulations of bubble growth. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Simulating the Effect of Fracture Connectivity on Repository Performance with GDSA Framework - 18589

This work examines the possible migration of radionuclides from a deep geologic nuclear waste repository sited in fractured crystalline host rock. The key safety concern is the potential effect on waste isolation of the inter-connectivity of the fracture network, which is primarily established by the temporal evolution of the temperature and stress fields at the time of original rock intrusion and cooling. Two end members are considered in these simulations, one with a high degree of connectivity to the biosphere, such that advective transport through the fracture and fault network controls radionuclide migration, and the other with a low degree of connectivity, such that slow diffusive transport through the crystalline rock matrix is the controlling process for radionuclide migration to the biosphere. Both end members have several areally extensive, high-transmissivity deformation zones, whose distance to the repository is an important factor for waste isolation capability. Uncertainties in fracture properties (transmissivity, orientation, radius) and fracture distribution also give rise to uncertainty in waste isolation capability (i.e., the overall connectivity of the repository with the surface biosphere). These types of natural system uncertainties are generally present in any geologic site-characterization program and thus represent an important factor in assessing repository performance in hard rock environments. The waste considered in these simulations are spent fuel rod assemblies from the U.S. commercial nuclear reactor fleet. Thermal output of the waste must be considered in the simulations and can influence the rate and timing of waste package failure, waste form degradation, and fluid flux due to thermal expansion around the repository horizon. To achieve a high-fidelity representation of radionuclide transport in fractures and rock matrix, combined with thermal energy transport and fluid flow in fractures and matrix, the mathematical model is solved numerically in a parallel high-performance computing (HPC) environment on a finite volume unstructured grid consisting of approximately 5 million cells, using Geologic Disposal Safety Assessment (GDSA) Framework (https://pa.sandia.gov), an open-source performance assessment tool for deep underground disposal of nuclear waste. GDSA Framework uses PFLOTRAN to solve the balance equations on a three-dimensional grid with heterogeneous properties, using multiple processors in a parallel configuration based on domain decomposition. The fracture networks in these simulations are originally generated as discrete fracture networks (DFNs), which are sets of two-dimensional planes distributed in a three-dimensional domain. The method used in GDSA Framework maps the stochastically generated DFN to an equivalent continuous porous medium (ECPM) domain that allows for the simulation of coupled heat flow, fluid flow, and radionuclide transport, including heat conduction through the matrix of the fractured rock, which is a process not easily modeled in a DFN representation. Computational efficiency is also greatly enhanced using the ECPM method, allowing for a realistic representation and analysis of uncertainties in a multi-realization performance assessment of a deep geologic repository. The effect of fracture connectivity on the waste isolation safety function, as brought to light by these GDSA Framework simulations, points to the importance of including a realistic representation of uncertainties in fracture properties and distribution (effectively, uncertainty in spatial heterogeneity) in repository safety assessment simulations. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Computational and Experimental Examination of Simulated Core Damage and Relocation Dynamics of a BWR Fuel Assembly - 16013

The Japan Atomic Energy Agency (JAEA) plans a large-scale test to evaluate damage and relocation behavior of Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) core materials consisting of fuel rods (zirconia as fuel simulant), channel boxes, control blade assemblies as well as lower core-support structures. Its purpose is to contribute to the understanding of the core material relocation behavior in the event of severe accidents with the BWR design conditions for which existing experimental database is quite limited. Prior to large-scale testing anticipated at JAEA in the future, JAEA desires preliminary investigations to examine melting test pieces, being composed of a mixture of zirconia and metals by a non-transferred thermal plasma heating system. The purpose of such tests is to verify the materials and test piece will be heated by plasma as a primary heat source to the target temperature of ca. 2900 K and to collect data about the relocation behavior of the high-temperature materials. This paper describes the first in a series of tests demonstrating the effective use of thermal plasma technology to recreate the dynamics of a typical fuel core bundle channel assembly section. Results from preliminary computational simulations of simplified fuel bundle assemblies are presented illustrating the effectiveness of a 150 kW, non transferred (NTR) configuration of a thermal plasma argon jet to heat the assembly within a highly-insulated containment vessel. An experimental test program using the computational analyses as a basis and a Phoenix Solutions Co (PSC) commercial model PT150, 150 kW plasma torch is described and the test results are presented illustrating the time versus temperature history of the fuel bundle assembly melting dynamics. Details on plasma operation are discussed including: power requirements, current flow, voltage levels achieved, argon gas flow rates, processing times and standoff distances of the torch discharge from the top of the fuel bundle assembly (achieved with remote control of the axial (vertical) translation of the torch within the containment processing chamber). Photos taken from the top of the processing chamber are presented illustrating the various phases of melting characteristics of the zircaloy-clad, zirconium oxide filled fuel tubes, all within a stainless steel tube bundle channel centered within an insulated zirconia crucible. Based on lessons learned from this initial test campaign, a brief discussion of the requirements and features of a follow-on Phase II test program is provided. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

A coupled TH/Neutronics/CRUD framework in prediction of CIPS phenomenon

A coupled TH/Neutronics/CRUD framework, which is able to simulate the CRUD deposits impact on CIPS phenomenon, was described in this paper. The coupling among three essential physics, thermal-hydraulics, CRUD and neutronics described in the framework was implemented by using CFD software STAR-CCM+, developing CRUD module, and using the neutronics code DeCART. The coupling among these codes was implemented by exchanging data between them using intermediate exchange files. A typical 3 by 3 PWR fuel pin problem was solved under this framework and the results were presented. Time-dependent solutions were provided for a 12-month simulation, including CRUD deposits inventory and their distributions on fuel rods, boron hideout amount inside CRUD deposits, as well as power shape changing over time. The results clearly showed the power shape suppression in regions where CRUD deposits exist, which is a clear indication of CIPS phenomenon. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Updates to Relevance Vector Machine: Multiclass Classification, Variable Selection, and Proof-of-Concept Application to Safeguards Fresh Fuel Verification using List-Mode Neutron Collar Data

To expand the capabilities of safeguards authorities to verify the integrity of fresh fuel assemblies, Oak Ridge National Laboratory has retrofit the existing electronics of the JCC-71 uranium neutron coincidence collar, which contains 18 3 He neutron detectors and an external 241 AmLi(α, n) neutron interrogation source arranged to surround a fresh nuclear fuel assembly. The new electronics system allows analysts to record list-mode neutron multiplicity data in addition to the singles and doubles rates that are currently measured. Based on previous proof-of-concept research, analysis of these new data will identify off-normal fuel configurations in an assembly and characterize or localize the specific partial fuel defects. The purpose of this report it to document the analysis algorithm development and then to demonstrate its capability for the safeguards verification of fresh fuel assemblies using list mode neutron collar data. To analyze the complex list-mode data collected with the upgraded uranium neutron collar, multivariate classification algorithms are being developed using a novel classification method, the relevance vector machine. This approach may be applied to multiclass problems to estimate the probability that test data belongs to one of many possible classes of data. In addition, our method identifies the most useful variables/channels for making predictions, which illuminates the basis for the model’s predictions, and this interpretability is largely unique among data analytics methods. Variable selection occurs during model training and parameter tuning and does not need any external hyperparameter tuning routines. Finally, we apply the modified relevance vector machine to a simulated dataset of list-mode neutron collar data generated with the radiation transport code MCNP. The method can correctly identify off-normal fuel configurations, categorize the data according to four fuel defect scenarios, and rank the channels in the data according to prediction utility. For nuclear safeguards applications, it is concluded that this method has the potential to increase the sensitivity and reliability to detect missing fuel rods from a standard 17 x 17 Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) fresh fuel assembly. Within this analysis, “off-normal” (i.e., missing fuel rods) were correctly classified in 17 simulated test scenarios with one quarter (25%) of the fresh fuel rods missing using a training data set of 58 simulated measurements.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Emergency response and solutions for damaged fuel assembly handling events - Lessons learned from a 2013 fuel positioning issue

In 2013, during the refueling of a French 1300 MWe reactor, a fuel assembly (FX3599) was damaged by a fuel assembly positioning tool in the reactor vessel. The upper part of a corner rod of the fuel assembly was twisted and the top end grid was torn off. Because of the protruding fuel rod, the assembly could not be easily transferred for repair to the fuel storage pool via the transfer tube. This unexpected and rarely encountered situation was assessed jointly by EDF and AREVA NP. The chosen option was to directly perform the field service inside the reactor building in cells generally used for intermediate storage during refueling. This operation, performed by EDF and AREVA, involved removing the twisted rod and positioning it in a special-purpose canister by means of a gripper-type tool for removal (KIPCI gripper) and a gripper for holding the rod in place. The special-purpose canister was designed, ordered and supplied by a sub-supplier within one week. The operation went through 3 phases. First a preparation step in the fuel building: The stripper was disassembled and technical checks carried out to ensure correct operation. The gripper tightening force was checked in real-life conditions with the gripper suspended from auxiliary crane. The fuel rod removal was simulated several times by trained operators. Second, the equipment was installed in the reactor building. And third, the operation took place in the reactor cavity: the special-purpose canister was opened, the radioactive waste canister placed in the special-purpose canister, the twisted fuel rod was then grasped by the KIPCI gripper and removed from the fuel assembly. The twisted fuel rod was positioned above the canister and dropped into it. Once the fuel rod had been removed, the canister and fuel assembly FX3599 were transferred to the fuel building and refueling resumed. The canister containing the fuel rod is currently in interim storage in the reactor pool until appropriate action is taken for it to be shipped and eventually reprocessed. EDF has performed improvement in its handling procedures and in its handling tools to avoid a similar new event.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

BISON Simulation of MARVEL Fuel Performance

BISON simulation of MARVEL fuel rod performance was conducted for normal operation. Fuel temperatures, plenum pressures and cumulative damage factors were calculated for five core zones. This report presents the results. BISON simulation for transient cases are planned. When the results are available, this report will be updated.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

BISON Fuel Performance Analysis of IFA-796 Rod 3 & 4 and Investigation of the Impact of Fuel Creep

In order to improve the accident tolerance of light water reactor (LWR) fuel, alternative cladding materials have been proposed to replace the currently used zirconium (Zr)-based alloys. Of these materials, there is a particular focus on iron-chromiumaluminum (FeCrAl) alloys because they exhibit slower oxidation kinetics in high-temperature steam than Zr-alloys. This should decrease the energy release due to oxidation and slow cladding consumption in the presence of high temperature steam. These alloys should also exhibit increased “coping time” in the event of an accident scenario by improving the mechanical performance at high temperatures, allowing greater flexibility to achieve core cooling. As a continuation of the development of these alloys, in-reactor irradiation testing of FeCrAl cladded fuel rods has started. In order to provide insight on the possible behavior of these fuel rods as they undergo irradiation in the Halden Boiling Water Reactor, engineering analysis has been performed using FeCrAl material models implemented into the BISON fuel performance code. This milestone report provides an update on the ongoing development of modeling capability to predict FeCrAl cladding fuel performance and to provide an early look at the possible behavior of planned in-reactor FeCrAl cladding experiments. In particular, this report consists of two separate analyses. The first analysis consists of fuel performance simulations of IFA-796 rod 4 and two segments of rod 3. These simulations utilize previously implemented material models for the C35M FeCrAl alloy and UO2 to provide a bounding behavior analysis corresponding to variation of the initial fuel cladding gap thickness within the fuel rod. The second analysis is an assessment of the fuel and cladding stress states after modification of the fuel creep model that is currently implemented in the BISON fuel performance code. Effects from modifying the fuel creep model were identified for the BISON simulations of the IFA-796 rod 4 experiment, but show that varying the creep model (within the range investigated here) only provide a minimal increase in the fuel radius and maximum cladding hoop stress. Continued investigation of fuel behavioral models will include benchmarking the modified fuel creep model against available experimental data, as well as an investigation of the role that fuel cracking will play in the compliance of the fuel. Correctly calculating stress evolution in the fuel is key to assessing fuel behavior up to gap closure and the subsequent deformation of the cladding due to PCMI. The inclusion of frictional contact should also be investigated to determine the axial elongation of the fuel rods for comparison with data from this experiment.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

VERA and VERA-EDU 3.5 Release Notes

The Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications components included in this distribution include selected computational tools and supporting infrastructure that solve neutronics, thermal-hydraulics, fuel performance, and coupled neutronics-thermal hydraulics problems. The infrastructure components provide a simplified common user input capability and provide for the physics integration with data transfer and coupled-physics iterative solution algorithms. Neutronics analysis can be performed for 2D lattices, 2D core and 3D core problems for pressurized water reactor geometries that can be used to calculate criticality and fission rate distributions by pin for input fuel compositions. MPACT uses the Method of Characteristics transport approach for 2D problems. For 3D problems, MPACT uses the 2D/1D method which uses 2D MOC in a radial plane and diffusion or SPn in the axial direction. MPACT includes integrated cross section capabilities that provide problem-specific cross sections generated using the subgroup methodology. The code can be executed both 2D and 3D problems in parallel to reduce overall run time. A thermal-hydraulics capability is provided with CTF (an updated version of COBRA-TF) that allows thermal-hydraulics analyses for single and multiple assemblies using the simplified VERA common input. This distribution also includes coupled neutronics/thermal-hydraulics capabilities to allow calculations using MPACT coupled with CTF. The VERA fuel rod performance component BISON calculates, on a 2D or 3D basis, fuel rod temperature, fuel rod internal pressure, free gas volume, clad integrity and fuel rod waterside diameter. These capabilities allow simulation of power cycling, fuel conditioning and deconditioning, high burnup performance, power uprate scoping studies, and accident performance. Input/Output capabilities include the VERA Common Input (VERAIn) script which converts the ASCII common input file to the intermediate XML used to drive all of the physics codes in the VERA Core Simulator (VERA-CS). VERA component codes either input the VERA XML format directly, or provide a preprocessor which can convert the XML into native input. VERAView is an interactive graphical interface for the visualization and engineering analyses of output data from VERA. The python-based software is easy to install and intuitive to use, and provides instantaneous 2D and 3D images, 1D plots, and alpha-numeric data from VERA multi-physics simulations. Testing within CASL has focused primarily on Westinghouse four-loop reactor geometries and conditions with example problems included in the distribution.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Multidimensional modeling of fuel-cladding friction in an LWR fuel rod

Solving finite element problems with friction often increases the level of difficulty to obtain properly converged solutions. This type of challenge becomes more salient when advanced, possibly multiscale, material models are employed to capture the thermomechanical behavior of fuel and cladding materials. Here the present work details our recent developments in a nuclear fuel performance finite element code for the systematic consideration of friction in nuclear reactor finite element simulations. We show the application of friction and its effects on the mechanics of light-water reactor rods accounting for various fuel constitutive modeling techniques, model dimensionalities, pellet assumed geometries, and power conditions. In particular, we focus on the fuel rod mechanical behavior as it relates to fuel constitutive models, sensitivity to the coefficient of friction, pellet states of stress, and rod elongation. We discuss the trade-offs between the various multidimensional modeling options and highlight the relevance of frictional effects in the prediction of the fuel rod deformation and interfacial stresses. To relate our modeling results with actual reactor operation, simulations including frictional effects are compared with fuel rod elongation experimental data and some challenges for carrying out a full validation of the axial mechanics are discussed.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Statistical and sensitivity analysis of failing rods in EPR LBLOCA

A statistical fuel failure analysis procedure has been developed, and is now applied in full scale to a large break loss-of-coolant accident (LBLOCA) scenario in EPR-type nuclear power plant. The goal is to statistically determine the number of failing fuel rods. It is also important to bring out the underlying causes for rod failures, and therefore a sensitivity analysis procedure for the preceding complex calculation chain is outlined and adopted. In order to produce a statistically reliable estimation on the number of failing rods, a large number of simulations are required. In the analysis, single rods are simulated with the coupled fuel performance - thermal hydraulics code FRAPTRAN-GENFLO. The statistically varied factors are divided into global and local by their range of influence. Transient thermal hydraulic and power history boundary conditions and model parameters are global and affect all the rods. Fuel rod manufacturing parameters and other rod position related factors are local and are related to a certain rod. The number of global scenarios is 59 as dictated by the Wilks' formula, and 1000 randomly sampled rods are simulated in each scenario. The thermal hydraulic and transient power boundary conditions for the fuel performance code are calculated with a statistical version of the system code APROS. The steady-state irradiation histories are simulated with FRAPCON, and the steady-state power histories used as boundary conditions for FRAPCON are obtained from SIMULATE calculations. Thus, a multistage calculation chain is required to consolidate the procedure. As an outcome, in the worst global scenario, 1.4% of the simulated rods failed. It can be concluded that the Finnish safety regulations, i.e. max. 10% of the rods allowed to fail, are met. In order to find out which input parameters have significance to the outcome of the analysis, a sensitivity analysis is done. At the moment, only the worst global scenario is considered but later on it is possible to include also the sensitivities of the global factors. Due to complexity of the existing data, first the relevant input parameters for the sensitivity analysis have to be specified. Data visualization with a cobweb graph is used for the screening. Then, selected sensitivity measures are calculated between the chosen input and output parameters. The sensitivity indices calculated are the Borgonovo's delta measure, the first order Sobol sensitivity index, and squared Pearson correlation coefficients. The first mentioned is a novelty in this context. As an outcome, the most relevant parameters with respect to the cladding integrity were determined to be the decay heat power during the transient, the thermal hydraulic conditions in the rod's location in the reactor, and the steady-state irradiation history of the rod as represented in this analysis by the rod burnup. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Modernizing the active neutron collar poison rod correction using simulations to enhance PWR fresh fuel verification

The declared inventory of 235 U in fresh, low enriched uranium, nuclear fuel assemblies is routinely verified by nuclear safeguards inspectorates using the UNCL (Uranium Neutron Collar – Light Water Reactor Fuel) nondestructive assay instrument. The trend in modern fuels is towards higher initial enrichment, which in turn requires a larger number of burnable poison pins with higher Gadolinia concentration to hold down the initial reactivity. UNCL assay error for modern fuel assemblies typically exceeds 10%. The traditional algorithm used to correct the response for burnable poison content needs revision to achieve accuracy comparable to the $\sigma_\text{R}$ of 4.5% expected for poison-free assemblies. Here we review the problem and use a large set of 287 Monte Carlo simulations based on an experimentally benchmarked model corresponding to the 16×16 PWR array used in Brazilian Angra type II and III fuel. Simulated relative responses are used to evaluate the functional form of the poison correction and determine parameters optimal for 16×16 PWR assemblies. This update is conducted using between 4–24 Gadolinia pins ranging 2–11 wt% Gd 2 O 3 with assemblies having mean enrichments ranging 2.5%–5%. Experimental validation of the updated coefficients using seven measurements shows bias is reduced by an order of magnitude and $\sigma_\text{R}$R reduced from 10% to less than 2%. Two updated sets of coefficients are provided, the most accurate of which is directly useable in the existing analysis code (INCC) in use by inspectorate at fuel fabrication facilities.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Experimental Study for Effects of Ballooning and Power Peak on a Coolability of Fuel Rod Bundle

For a large break loss-of-coolant accident (LB LOCA) in a pressurized water reactor, the clad temperature increases until the reflood phase. This causes ballooned fuel rods and fuel relocation, thereby reducing flow passage area of sub-channel and redistributing the flow and heat transfer in sub-channels. The fuel relocation increase the power at the ballooned region and temperature on the fuel rod. The research on the coolability of the deformed fuel and fuel relocation is very important for a prevention and mitigation of the severe accidents. In the present study, the reflood experiments were performed to investigate the coolability in the ballooned geometry and fuel relocation condition during the LB LOCA for Korean nuclear power plant, APR1400. The coolability experiments were carried out using three kinds of test sections. The first experiments using 6x6 intact rod bundle were performed as a base case. The second experiments simulated the coolability in the deformed fuel using 5x5 ballooned rod bundle. The last experiments were performed using another ballooned 5x5 rod bundle with local power increase to simulate fuel relocation. The fuel relocation phenomena increase the peak cladding temperatures compared with intact and ballooned only rod bundles.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Uncertainty and sensitivity analysis of fission gas behavior in engineering-scale fuel modeling

The role of uncertainties in fission gas behavior calculations as part of engineering-scale nuclear fuel modeling is investigated using the BISON fuel performance code and a recently implemented physics-based model for the coupled fission gas release and swelling. Through the integration of BISON with the DAKOTA software, a sensitivity analysis of the results to selected model parameters is carried out based on UO2 single-pellet simulations covering different power regimes. The parameters are varied within ranges representative of the relative uncertainties and consistent with the information from the open literature. The study leads to an initial quantitative assessment of the uncertainty in fission gas behavior modeling with the parameter characterization presently available. Also, the relative importance of the single parameters is evaluated. Moreover, a sensitivity analysis is carried out based on simulations of a fuel rod irradiation experiment, pointing out a significant impact of the considered uncertainties on the calculated fission gas release and cladding diametral strain. The results of the study indicate that the commonly accepted deviation between calculated and measured fission gas release by a factor of 2 approximately corresponds to the inherent modeling uncertainty at high fission gas release. Nevertheless, higher deviations may be expected for values around 10% and lower. Implications are discussed in terms of directions of research for the improved modeling of fission gas behavior for engineering purposes.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

VERA Benchmarking Results for Watts Bar Nuclear Plant Unit 1 Cycles 1-12

Among the most important accomplishments during Phase 1 of the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) is the development and deployment of what is known as VERA-CS, the steady-state nuclear reactor core simulation capability of the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications, VERA. With this product CASL now has the ability to perform and support analyses relating to common evolutions of operating commercial pressurized water reactors (PWRs), including startup testing, power escalation, fuel cycle depletion, and fuel assembly discharge, reinsert, and shuffling. VERA-CS is a high-fidelity, multi-physics engineering tool that utilizes modest high-performance computing (HPC) systems and engineering-scale clusters to simultaneously simulate the local fuel rod neutronics and coolant channel thermal-hydraulics over the life of the reactor. Though it is still under development, the results demonstrated in this report provide encouraging evidence that VERA-CS will become highly acclaimed for industrial, scientific, and educational applications alike.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Initial 1.5D BISON Simulation Verification and Validation CASL FY17 Letter Report

This milestone report describes the current efforts to improve the usability of the recently developed 1.5 dimensional capability in BISON, the initial verification of this BISON capability, and initial validation of the 1.5 dimensional models against existing 2 dimensional axisymmetric full length light water reactor (LWR) fuel rods. The 1.5 dimensional (1.5D) capability in BISON was developed to enable the simulation of LWR fuel rods in a less computationally demanding simulation formulation while retaining key physics of interest. BISON was originally developed to solve 2D axisymmetric and 3D models, and this original development focus allows BISON to examine a wider range of fuel types and geometrically complexity than can be solved with lower dimensional frameworks. As the set of problems which BISON is used to solve expands, the software design requirements continue to evolve. Coupling physics in a higher dimensional geometry is not always required to resolve the physics of interest, such as the modeling of radial heat transfer and radial displacement. BISON, built on the dimension-agnostic MOOSE framework, is able to solve problems in 3D, 2D, and 1D with only minor modifications to the material definition code so that the appropriate geometrical representation can be applied in different problems of interest. The motivation for the development and validation of the BISON 1.5D capability is the CASL program's need for a simplified and computationally efficient version of BISON for use in the large multi-physics VERA simulations which include hundreds of individual fuel rods. The original development of the BISON 1.5D simulation capability is described in the CASL FY17 Letter Report from January 2017, and this report documents the continuing work identified in the previous report. The improvements to the usability of the 1.5D capability through input file simplifications, the results of the verification simulations, the results of the initial validation against the 2D assessment cases in BISON, and the future development needs are included within this report.

1.5D Capability↗

Uncertainty Quantification and Sensitivity Analysis for Coupled VERA-CS and FRAPCON

The current nuclear power plant fleet in the U.S. is facing numerous challenges economically ranging from low natural gas price to the rapidly growing renewable energy sources such as wind and solar power. In order for the nuclear industry to keep the viability of its operating fleet, new innovations have to be introduced to lower the costs to operate the fleet. One area that could contribute to the cost reduction is to lower the fuel cycle cost and improve the plant safety through initiatives such as higher burnup fuel and accident tolerant fuel. At the same time, the nuclear industry has to address future challenges on the horizon such as load following and other flexible operating strategies as well as those associated with new regulations such as 10 CFR 50.69 and 10 CFR50.46c etc. All these require coupled analysis of core neutronics, thermal hydraulics and fuel performance, which necessitates the development of a multi-physics toolkit. Since different models, assumptions, and fidelities have gone into various computer codes, how to consistently propagate uncertainties in a multi-physics environment warrants careful evaluation. The U.S. DOE's Light Water Reactor Sustainability (LWRS) Program initiated a project to develop analytical capabilities to support the industry to address these challenges. The general idea behind the initiative was the development of an integrated multiphysics evaluation model. This integrated evaluation model is called LOTUS which stands for LOCA Toolkit for the U.S. Light Water Reactors. The focus of LOTUS is to establish the automation of the interface between the five disciplines. LOTUS framework ensures that uncertainties can be easily propagated to solve the problems forward and backward (inverse) with large numbers of simulations. The objective of this work is to perform uncertainty quantification (UQ) and sensitivity analysis (SA) on a coupling of CASL's Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications-Core Simulator (VERA-CS) and NRC's fuel performance code FRAPCON. The work presented herein is a subset of the overall LOTUS framework. The figures of merit (FOM) selected for analysis are minimum departure from nucleate boiling ratio (MDNBR), maximum fuel centerline temperature (MFCT), and the gap conductance at peak power (GCPP). All FOM are obtained at the end of the of a depletion case for a half cycle lasting 263 days. The minimum is taken over all spatial location for each pin at the end of the half cycle. This value is calculated in VERACS alone and has been analyzed in previous work by Brown and Zhang. The MFCT is available in both VERA-CS and FRAPCON, but is calculated via different methods (see Model Inconsistencies section for more details). For this work, only the FRAPCON values are reported due to the code's maturity from extensive validation in fuel performance. Previous work includes SA on a standalone nuclear fuel performance code VTT-modified FRAPCON- 3.4 by Ikonen. The GCPP is the gap conductance at the location corresponding to maximum power in the fuel rod. This value is available in FRAPCON alone and highlights the capability of LOTUS to obtain unique fuel performance metrics for each pin in a core simulation.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗