Cooperation between bound waters and hydroxyls in controlling isotope-exchange rates
Exposed and bound waters on minerals differ from aqueous ions in that they are often structurally separated from one another rather than being close packed as in octahedral aquo ions [e.g., Al(H 2 O) 6 3+ ]. Thus, the bulk of the literature on rates of ligand substitution in aqueous ions may be a poor guide to the reactions of geochemical interest. To understand how separation of the reactive functional groups affects the rates of simple water exchange reactions, we synthesized two similar Rh(III) complexes, [Rh(phen) 2 H 2 O) 2 ] 3+ [1] and [Rh(phen) 2 (H 2 O)Cl] 2+ [2] (phen=1,10-phenanthroline) that differ in the number and proximity of bound waters. The complex [1] has two adjacent water molecules and [2] has a single water adjacent to a bound chloride ion. We employed Rh(III) as a trivalent metal rather than a more geochemically relevant metal like Fe(III) or Al(III) to slow the rate of reaction and dissociation of the molecules, which makes for simple measurement of the rates of isotopic substitution by mass spectrometry of the ions themselves as a function of time. We prepared isotopically unique versions of the molecules dissolved them in isotopically dissimilar solvent and measured the rates of exchange from the extents of 18 O and 16 O exchange at the bound waters. The rates differ enormously depending upon the protonation state of adjacent functional groups. Values of k298 when the molecules are nearly fully protonated are $k$$^{298}_{0}$ = 5·10 -8 s -1 for [1] and $k$$^{298}_{0}$ = 7.3·10 -9 for [2]. Enthalpy and entropy activation parameters (ΔH ‡ and ΔS ‡ ) were measured to be 121.1± 3 kJ mol -1 , and 22±10 J mol -1 K -1 , respectively for [1]. The corresponding parameters for the mono-aquo complex, [2], are 134.6± 3 kJ mol -1 and 50±5 J mol -1 K -1 . These compare well to other metals and nanometer-size clusters. Here, rates increase by many orders of magnitude upon deprotonation of one of the bound waters, but in a way that can be understood for geochemical systems at oxides. Key is the close proximity of a transferable proton that can convert the bound hydroxyl to a bound water and accelerate exchange for a bulk water. Thus, structural information about the location of bound waters relative to one another is a key piece of information to reconstruct rates of reactions at oxides surfaces.