Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Reactive intermediates”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 523 records · Page 29

Room-Temperature Methane Oxidation to Formaldehyde Mediated by CoMoO + Gas-Phase Cations

Formaldehyde (HCHO) is a fundamental chemical feedstock with widespread industrial applications. The direct oxidation of methane by oxygen to formaldehyde (CH 4 + 1/2O 2 → H 2 + HCHO) under mild conditions represents an attractive but challenging transformation, as it requires both activation of the inert C–H bonds of CH 4 and suppression of overoxidation to products such as carbon dioxide. In this work, mass spectrometry experiments combined with theoretical calculations reveal that CoMoO + cations can efficiently mediate this transformation at room temperature. The unique electronic structure of CoMoO + facilitates the formation of a crucial CoMoOCH 2 + intermediate during the reaction with CH 4 and prevents methanol formation. In the subsequent oxidation reaction, the Mo atom in CoMoO + serves as the active site for O 2 adsorption, and both Mo and Co atoms act as electron donors to activate O 2 , leading to the formation of the C–O bond in formaldehyde. This work reports the first gas-phase example of achieving conversion of CH 4 to HCHO and its radical derivatives by O 2 at room temperature using heteronuclear non-noble metal cations. Remarkably, the CoMoOCH 2 + cation maintains high reactivity after adsorbing one or two CH 4 molecules. Finally, these findings provide new mechanistic insights into selective methane activation and conversion.

aldehydes↗

Applying the core-satellite species concept: Characteristics of rare and common riverine dissolved organic matter

Introduction: Dissolved organic matter (DOM) composition varies over space and time, with a multitude of factors driving the presence or absence of each compound found in the complex DOM mixture. Compounds ubiquitously present across a wide range of river systems (hereafter termed core compounds) may differ in chemical composition and reactivity from compounds present in only a few settings (hereafter termed satellite compounds). Here, we investigated the spatial patterns in DOM molecular formulae presence (occupancy) in surface water and sediments across 97 river corridors at a continental scale using the “Worldwide Hydrobiogeochemical Observation Network for Dynamic River Systems—WHONDRS” research consortium. Methods: We used a novel data-driven approach to identify core and satellite compounds and compared their molecular properties identified with Fourier-transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS). Results: In this work, we found that core compounds clustered around intermediate hydrogen/carbon and oxygen/carbon ratios across both sediment and surface water samples, whereas the satellite compounds varied widely in their elemental composition. Within surface water samples, core compounds were dominated by lignin-like formulae, whereas protein-like formulae dominated the core pool in sediment samples. In contrast, satellite molecular formulae were more evenly distributed between compound classes in both sediment and water molecules. Core compounds found in both sediment and water exhibited lower molecular mass, lower oxidation state, and a higher degree of aromaticity, and were inferred to be more persistent than global satellite compounds. Higher putative biochemical transformations were found in core than satellite compounds, suggesting that the core pool was more processed. Discussion: The observed differences in chemical properties of core and satellite compounds point to potential differences in their sources and contribution to DOM processing in river corridors. Overall, our work points to the potential of data-driven approaches separating rare and common compounds to reduce some of the complexity inherent in studying riverine DOM.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Insights into Stress Corrosion Cracking and Dissolution of Metal Oxides

Oxide phases such as α-Fe2O3 (hematite) and α-Al2O3 (corundum) are highly insoluble in water; however, subcritical crack growth has been observed in humidity nonetheless. Chemically induced bond breaking at the crack tip appears unlikely due to sterically hindered molecular transport. The molecular mechanics of a crack in corundum with a reactive force field reveal minimal lattice trapping, leading to bond breaking before sufficient space opens for water transport. To address this, we model a pre-built blunt crack with space for H2O molecule adsorption at the tip and show that it reduces fracture toughness by lowering the critical J-integral. Then, we explore stress-enhanced dissolution to understand the mechanism of crack tip blunting in the oxide/water system. Density functional theory combined with metadynamics was employed to describe atomic dissolution from flat hematite and corundum surfaces in pure water. Strain accelerates dissolution, stabilizing intermediate states with broken bonds before full atom detachment, while the free energy profile of unstrained surfaces is almost monotonic. The atomistic calculations provided input for a kinetic model, predicting the shape evolution of a blunt crack tip, which displays three distinct regimes: (i) dissolution primarily away from the tip, (ii) enhanced blunting near but not at the apex, and (iii) sharpening near the apex. The transition between regimes occurs at a low strain, highlighting the critical role of water in the subcritical crack growth of oxide scales, with dissolution as the fundamental microscopic mechanism behind this process.

Chemistry↗

The Role of Alkalis in Orchestrating Uranyl-Peroxide Reactivity Leading to Direct Air Capture of Carbon Dioxide

Spectator ions have known and emerging roles in aqueous metal-cation chemistry, respectively directing solubility, speciation, and reactivity. Here, in this work, we isolate and structurally characterize the last two metastable members of the alkali uranyl triperoxide series, the Rb + and Cs + salts (Cs-U 1 and Rb-U 1 ). We document their rapid solution polymerization via small-angle X-ray scattering, which is compared to the more stable Li + , Na + and K + analogues. To understand the role of the alkalis, we also quantify alkali-hydroxide promoted peroxide deprotonation and decomposition, which generally exhibits increasing reactivity with increasing alkali size. Cs-U 1 , the most unstable of the uranyl triperoxide monomers, undergoes ambient direct air capture of CO 2 in the solid-state, converting to Cs 4 [U VI O 2 (CO 3 ) 3 ], evidenced by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, transmission electron microscopy, and Raman spectroscopy. We have attempted to benchmark the evolution of Cs-U 1 to uranyl tricarbonate, which involves a transient, unstable hygroscopic solid that contains predominantly pentavalent uranium, quantified by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy. Powder X-ray diffraction suggests this intermediate state contains a hydrous derivative of CsU V O 3 , where the parent phase has been computationally predicted, but not yet synthesized.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

In Situ Strong Metal–Support Interaction (SMSI) Affects Catalytic Alcohol Conversion

Strong metal–support interactions (SMSIs) and catalyst deactivation have been heavily researched for decades by the catalysis community. The promotion of SMSIs in supported metal oxides is commonly associated with H 2 treatment at high temperature (>500 °C), and catalyst deactivation is commonly attributed to sintering, leaching of the active metal, and overoxidation of the metal, as well as strong adsorption of reaction intermediates. Alcohols can reduce metal oxides, and thus here we have hypothesized that catalytic conversion of alcohols can promote SMSIs in situ . In this work we show, via IR spectroscopy of CO adsorption and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS), that during 2-propanol conversion over Pd/TiO 2 coverage of Pd sites occurs due to SMSIs at low reaction temperatures (as low as ~ 190 °C). The emergence of SMSIs during the reaction ( in situ ) explains the apparent catalyst deactivation when the reaction temperature is varied. A steady-state isotopic transient kinetic analysis (SSITKA) shows that the intrinsic reactivity of the catalytic sites does not change with temperature when SMSI is promoted in situ ; rather, the number of available active sites changes (when a TiO x layer migrates over Pd NPs). SMSI generated during the reaction fully reverses upon exposure to O 2 at room temperature for ~15 h, which may have made their identification elusive up to now.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

PCET‐Driven Reactivity of Neptunyl(VI) Yields Oxo‐Bridged Np(V) and Np(IV) Species

Two unconventional polynuclear complexes of neptunium (Np) featuring mono-mathematical equation -oxo motifs have been accessed by proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactivity involving the dissolution of neptunyl(VI) diacetate dihydrate (NpO 2 (OAc) 2 (H 2 O) 2 ∙ HOAc) in methanol followed by addition of a pentadentate Schiff-base ligand. One complex is a mixed-valent [Np V ,Np IV , Np V ] trimer with two bridging mathematical equation μ 2 -oxos and the other is a [Np V , Np V ] dimer featuring a single mathematical equation μ 2 -oxo. In both complexes the outer Np centers are capped with terminal oxo ligands. Spectroscopic and spectrokinetic studies aimed at elucidating mechanistic details of complex formation in this system show that intermediate multinuclear [Np V O 2 (OAc)] n species form prior to metal chelation by the ligand; electrolysis experiments demonstrate that production of Np(V) gives rise to asynchronous proton transfer that does not occur otherwise (in the Np(VI) state) as well as condensation with loss of H 2 O and formation of the polynuclear complexes. We attribute the oxo-deficient nature of these products, with respect to conventional actinyl ([AnO 2 ] m+ ) species, to the reduction/condensation reaction sequence of PCET.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Pd3Ag(111) as a Model System for Hydrogen Separation Membranes: Combined Effects of CO Adsorption and Surface Termination on the Activation of Molecular Hydrogen

Abstract The co-adsorption of hydrogen and carbon monoxide on Pd 3 Ag(111) alloy surfaces has been studied as a model system for Pd-Ag alloys in membrane and catalysis applications using periodic density functional theory calculations (PW91-GGA). We explored the effects of Pd–Ag surface composition, since segregation of silver towards and away from the surface has been suggested to explain the experimentally observed changes in H 2 activation, CO inhibition and reactivity. We found that CO pre-adsorbed on the surface weakens the adsorption of H on Pd 3 Ag(111) alloy surfaces irrespective of whether the surface termination corresponds to the bulk Pd 3 Ag composition, or is purely Pd-terminated. A higher coverage of H with CO present is obtained for the Pd-terminated surface; this surface also exhibits a larger range of chemical potentials for co-adsorbed hydrogen and CO. The barrier for H 2 activation increases with increasing CO coverage, but the surface composition has the largest impact on H 2 activation at intermediate CO coverage. The results imply that Pd-based membranes with typically ~ 23 wt% Ag are less prone to CO poisoning if the surface becomes Pd-terminated.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Intermediate Temperature Solid Oxide Cell with a Barrier Layer Free Oxygen Electrode and Phase Inversion Derived Hydrogen Electrode

High-temperature solid oxide cells (SOCs) have fundamental advantages in efficiency and product rate over their low-temperature counterparts. However, the commercial development of SOCs is hindered by cost and reliability. To solve the issues, lowering the operating temperature of SOCs is deemed the best solution. Here we report on our effort toward intermediate temperature (IT) SOCs by developing a barrier layer free high-performance oxygen electrode and open structured hydrogen electrode. The results show that the new oxygen electrode provides reasonably good oxygen electrocatalytic activity at IT range for oxygen reduction and evolution reactions and the open structured hydrogen electrode provides low gas diffusion path for H 2 /H 2 O. However, at high electrolysis current density such as 1 A cm −2 and 650 °C, the present oxygen electrode delaminates after 200 h. The phase-inversion derived open structured hydrogen electrode helps gas diffusion but, in the meantime, reduces reactive sites. A proper balance of porosity and number of reactive sites is still needed for future hydrogen electrode development.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Direct conversion of Light Hydrocarbons to Olefins (Final report)

Reaction35 is developing a new industrial process that is substantially different from the traditional standalone dehydrogenation process practiced in industry such as Oleflex® and Catofin®. Those processes have substantial energy consumption and loss of feed constraints. The Reaction35 process is based on using molecular bromine to activate the alkane (e.g., nbutane) by forming highly reactive butyl bromides. The butyl bromides are easily converted to nbutylenes (final product) and hydrogen bromide. The hydrogen bromide generated in bromination and dehydrobromination is oxidized with air, recovering the molecular bromine which is reused. The overall result is a process with a favorably low energy consumption and less than 1 % overall loss of feed compared to more than 5 % for the direct dehydrogenation processes. During the grant period, several important aspects of the technology have been developed further. The major effort was the hydrogenation catalyst step development. The hydrogenation catalyst is used for recovery of the polybromobutanes to the bromobutanes intermediates. The scientific field regarding dibromo- and polybromoalkanes has not been extensively studied, which necessitated that Reaction35 performs a full study of a number of catalysts and the various experimental conditions that influence the hydrogenation reaction. Currently, Reaction35 has completed its catalyst selection and preliminary experimental parameters optimization. This will allow for the construction of an engineering model for a pilot unit testing.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Catalytic Promotion of Transition-Metal-Doped Graphene Cathodes in Li-CO 2 Batteries

The Li-CO 2 battery is a promising energy storage system with impressive theoretical specific energy and discharge capacity. Graphene-based single-atom catalysts (SACs) provide high surface area and long-term electrochemical reactivity and stability, making SACs among the most promising cathode catalysts for these batteries. However, current Li-CO 2 systems have high reaction barriers, slowing the reaction and greatly increasing the overpotential. Improvement of the discharge/charge energetics requires atomic-level innovations in cathode design, such as alterations to the catalyst chemical structure. In this paper, we propose enhancing the SAC by using a Ti metal center, which is found to deliver the highest electrochemical Li + CO 2 activity among 3d transition metal candidates. Furthermore, we propose cathode surface coating with ionic liquids, since these environments promote the formation of reaction intermediates in the electrochemical conversion process. Here, our work provides insights to optimize electrode design for high-performance Li-CO 2 batteries, which can open new avenues to recycle greenhouse gases and achieve enhanced renewable energy storage.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

TEX-Hf: Integral Experiment Execution of Thermal/Epithermal eXperiments using Highly Enriched Uranium with Polyethylene and Hafnium (IER-532 CED-3b Report)

This report documents the experimental configurations and measurements for IER-532, Thermal/Epithermal eXperiments (TEX) with highly enriched uranium (HEU) fuel and interstitial hafnium (Hf), moderated and reflected by polyethylene. TEX-Hf is a variation of and based on the TEX-HEU (IER-297) design, with the inclusion of hafnium. These configurations provide integral experiments for validation of hafnium in the thermal, intermediate, and fast neutron energy regimes by maximizing the sensitivity in k eff to the hafnium isotope cross sections. The experiment campaign was completed over seven weeks during the end of FY22 and beginning of FY23 at the National Critical Experiments Research Center at the Nevada National Security Site. The campaign produced seven experimental configurations, four reproducibility measurements, and many additional dimensional measurements that will be of use to the future benchmark evaluation of this experiment and other experiments using the same HEU fuel. Table 1 summarizes the TEX-Hf experimental configurations, including their physical parameters, calculated fission fractions, and estimated excess reactivities.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

LX-17 Thermal Decomposition-Characterization of Solid Residues from Cook-Off in a Small-Scale Vessel Under Confinement

Concerns surround whether insensitive (or any) energetic materials are more dangerous to handle when exposed to abnormal thermal environments. This study characterizes the residual material remaining after LX-17 (92.5 % 1,3,5-triamino 2,4,6-trinitro benzene (TATB) and 7.5 % Kel-F) is exposed to various thermal environments in a sealed small-scale vessel cook-off test reactor (heated at 0.1 to 100 °C/min until the reactor opened at 3000 psi (20.7 MPa)). Previous work has shown no additional sensitivity of these residues as evaluated by small-scale safety analysis, but characterization on the molecular scale indicates the TATB is transformed to more reactive compounds as well as the residue could be precursors to toxic gases. The solids and chars were characterized by various analytical methods. Heat-flow measurements indicated exothermic release is due to a mixture of residual TATB and related decomposition products (which may be more energetic). The N/C and O/N ratios indicated a material much more degraded than TATB. Primarily, the solids were a network of amorphous C inter-dispersed with N and O. Types of bonding include C–C, C–N, N–H, N–C, N=C, N≡C, C–O=, and –OH. Solvent extracts of the solids showed TATB decomposition intermediates benzo-furazans and benzo-furoxans, substituted TATB (mono-nitroso, hydroxyl, and chlorinated) along with several unidentified smaller molecules. These results indicate thermal treatment produces an amorphous carbon residue with heteroatoms incorporated through differing functionality, varying depending upon the thermal severity of exposure. These structures also could further decompose producing toxic light gases (such as cyanide).

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Structural basis for proficient oxidized ribonucleotide insertion in double strand break repair

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) oxidize cellular nucleotide pools and cause double strand breaks (DSBs). Non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ) attaches broken chromosomal ends together in mammalian cells. Ribonucleotide insertion by DNA polymerase (pol) μ prepares breaks for end-joining and this is required for successful NHEJ in vivo. We previously showed that pol μ lacks discrimination against oxidized dGTP (8-oxo-dGTP), that can lead to mutagenesis, cancer, aging and human disease. Here we reveal the structural basis for proficient oxidized ribonucleotide (8-oxo-rGTP) incorporation during DSB repair by pol μ. Time-lapse crystallography snapshots of structural intermediates during nucleotide insertion along with computational simulations reveal substrate, metal and side chain dynamics, that allow oxidized ribonucleotides to escape polymerase discrimination checkpoints. Abundant nucleotide pools, combined with inefficient sanitization and repair, implicate pol μ mediated oxidized ribonucleotide insertion as an emerging source of widespread persistent mutagenesis and genomic instability.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

Electro-activated indigos intensify ampere-level CO 2 reduction to CO on silver catalysts

The electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) to carbon monoxide (CO) is challenged by a selectivity decline at high current densities. Here we report a class of indigo-based molecular promoters with redox-active CO 2 binding sites to enhance the high-rate conversion of CO 2 to CO on silver (Ag) catalysts. Theoretical calculations and in situ spectroscopy analyses demonstrate that the synergistic effect at the interface of indigo-derived compounds and Ag nanoparticles could activate CO 2 molecules and accelerate the formation of key intermediates (*CO 2 – and *COOH) in the CO pathway. Indigo derivatives with electron-withdrawing groups further reduce the overpotential for CO production upon optimizing the interfacial CO 2 binding affinity. By integrating the molecular design of redox-active centres with the defect engineering of Ag structures, we achieve a Faradaic efficiency for CO exceeding 90% across a current density range of 0.10 − 1.20 A cm –2 . The Ag mass activity toward CO increases to 174 A mg –1 Ag . This work showcases that employing redox-active CO 2 sorbents as surface modification agents is a highly effective strategy to intensify the reactivity of electrochemical CO 2 reduction.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Intramolecular hydrogen bonding analysis

The quasi-atomic orbital (QUAO) bonding analysis is used to study intramolecular hydrogen bonding (IMHB) in salicylic acid and an intermediate that is crucial to the synthesis of aspirin. The bonding analysis rigorously explores IMHB through directly accessing information that is intrinsic to the molecular wave function, thereby bypassing the need for intrinsically biased methods. The variables that affect the strength of IMHB are determined using kinetic bond orders, QUAO populations, and QUAO hybridizations. Important properties include both the interatomic distance between hydrogen and oxygen participating in the IMHB and the hybridization on the oxygen. The bonding analysis further shows that each intramolecular hydrogen bond is a four-electron three-center bond. Here, the bonding analysis is used to understand how aromatic reactivity changes due to the effect of functional groups on the aromatic ring.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Deciphering decomposition pathways of high explosives with cryogenic X-ray Raman spectroscopy

We employed cryogenic X-ray Raman spectroscopy to investigate the early-stage decomposition of the high explosive molecule hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane (CL-20). By systematically varying the radiation dose under cryogenic conditions, we induced the decomposition of the molecule using ionizing radiation and observed the evolution of spectral features at the carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen K edges. Through extensive first-principles calculations, we identified key intermediates in the early stages of the decomposition process, resulting from C–C and C–N bond cleavage which leads to the opening of the internal cage structure. A detailed analysis of spectral trends and fingerprints provided evidence supporting N–NO 2 homolytic cleavage as the primary initial decomposition pathway. The combination of advanced core-level spectroscopy methods and state-of-the-art theoretical calculations enabled a comprehensive characterization of the molecular changes induced by controlled radiation dose exposures. In conclusion, our findings establish a benchmark for understanding the decomposition chemistry of high-explosive materials, offering important insights into their stability and reactivity under extreme conditions.

X-ray Raman spectroscopy↗

Molecular Design of Al(II) Intermediates for Small Molecule Activation

Promoting societally important small molecule activation processes with earth-abundant metals is foundational for a sustainable chemistry future. In this context, mapping new reaction pathways that would enable abundant main-group elements to mimic the behaviors of d- and f-block elements is facilitated by exploring unusual oxidation states. The most abundant metal on earth, aluminum, has been well studied in the Lewis acidic +III and Lewis basic +I oxidation states but rarely in the potentially biphilic +II oxidation state until recently, when a renaissance of Al(II) chemistry emerged from a range of research groups. In this Perspective, we review the chemistry of mononuclear Al radicals, including both Al-centered radicals (i.e., Al(II) compounds) and redox non-innocent systems (i.e., formally Al(II) species that are physically Al(III) with ligand-centered radicals), with an emphasis on small molecule reactivity. We also provide a meta-analysis of the Al(II) literature to summarize how different design strategies (e.g., redox non-innocence, strained coordination geometries) have been shown to impart biphilic character to Al radicals and tune their behavior, thus allowing Al radicals to mimic the chemistry of certain d- and f-block metal ions such as Ti(III) and Sm(II). We expect these molecular design concepts to inform future Al(II) studies as the chemistry of this unusual oxidation state of Al continues to grow.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Unraveling the CO Oxidation Mechanism over Highly Dispersed Pt Single Atom on Anatase TiO 2 (101)

Catalysts with noble metals deposited as single atoms on metal oxide supports have recently been studied extensively due to their maximized metal utilization and potential for performing difficult chemical conversions owing to their unique electronic properties. Understanding of the reaction mechanisms on supported single-metal atoms is still limited but is highly important for designing more efficient catalysts. In this study, we report the complexity of the CO oxidation reaction mechanism on Pt single atoms supported on anatase TiO 2 (Pt SA /a-TiO 2 ) by coupling density functional theory (DFT) calculations and microkinetic analysis with kinetic measurements, in situ/operando infrared, and X-ray absorption spectroscopies. Starting from the adsorbed Pt SA occupying an O vacancy induced by reductive pretreatment, we show that CO oxidation follows a complex mechanism consisting of initiation steps to reorganize the active site and multibranch reactive cycles, with the Pt SA /a-TiO 2 catalyst not returning to its initial configuration. The initiation step consists of CO and O 2 adsorption healing the O vacancy, followed by CO oxidation using gas-phase CO to form Pt(CO). The reactive cycle alternates O 2 adsorption and dissociation to oxidize the catalyst to Pt(O)(O)(CO) and branching pathways of competing Langmuir–Hinshelwood (LH)- or Eley–Rideal (ER)-type CO oxidation steps to reduce it again to Pt(CO). In situ/operando infrared experiments, including cryogenic CO adsorption and isotopic CO exchange, confirm the combined involvement of strongly adsorbed CO and gas-phase CO in an Eley–Rideal step along the reaction cycle. Microkinetic modeling shows that Pt single atoms are present in a mixture of Pt(CO), Pt(CO)(O 2 ), Pt(O)(CO)(O 2 ), and Pt(CO)(CO 3 ) structures as the main intermediates during steady-state CO oxidation, all having the C–O vibrational stretch close to the experimentally observed value of 2115 cm –1 . Microkinetic modeling also shows that the fractional orders of CO and O 2 measured experimentally originate from multiple steps with a high degree of rate control and not from a simple competitive adsorption. The results demonstrate the complex reaction pathways that even CO oxidation on a simple single-atom system can follow, providing mechanistic insights for designing efficient Pt-based single-atom catalysts. Here, we further show that microkinetic modeling results are sensitive to changes in energies of intermediate and transition states within errors of density functional theory, which can ultimately lead to incorrect conclusions regarding the reaction pathways and most abundant reaction intermediates if not accounted for by experiments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗