Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Phase change”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 523 records · Page 29
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2020

Experimental and theoretical study of the restrained shrinkage cracking of early age well cement

The shrinkage cracking occurring in oil & gas well cement material is a major factor that reduces the cement sheath integrity and impairs the durability of an underground well. Shrinkage mainly takes place in the early hydration period of the cement, and the resulting restrained shrinkage cracking can form a leaking network for oil & gas or carbon dioxide stored in an underground reservoir. It is thus important to understand the early age behavior of well cement and the leaking pathway formation in the well. This study describes the application of the digital image correlation (DIC) method as a tool to measure the strain development and crack distributions of well cement in the lab during early phase changes. A theoretical model is presented to calculate the stress distribution built up in the cement sheath during early ages of well cement hydration, which helps to interpret the experimental observations and determine the major factors influencing the cracking sequences. This study presents the whole hydration – drying shrinkage – and cracking mechanism of early age well cement under restrained ring conditions experimentally and theoretically. Finally, the results offer useful insights on the key material and geometric parameters which control the fracture of a well cementing structure.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

MFC 5.0: An exascale many-physics flow solver

Many problems of interest in engineering, medicine, and the fundamental sciences rely on high-fidelity flow simulation, making performant computational fluid dynamics solvers a mainstay of the open-source software community. Previous work MFC 3.0 was made a published, documented, and open-source solver via Bryngelson et al. Comp. Phys. Comm. (2021) with numerous physical features, numerical methods, and scalable infrastructure. MFC 5.0 is a significant update to MFC 3.0, featuring a broad set of well-established and novel physical models and numerical methods, as well as the introduction of GPU and APU (or superchip) acceleration. Here, we exhibit state-of-the-art performance and ideal scaling on the first two exascale supercomputers, OLCF Frontier and LLNL El Capitan. Combined with MFC’s single-accelerator performance, MFC achieves exascale computation in practice, and achieved the largest-to-date public CFD simulation at 200 trillion grid points as a 2025 ACM Gordon Bell Prize finalist. New physical features include the immersed boundary method, N-fluid phase change, Euler–Euler and Euler–Lagrange sub-grid bubble models, fluid-structure interaction, hypo- and hyper-elastic materials, chemically reacting flow, two-material surface tension, magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), and more. Numerical techniques now represent the current state-of-the-art, including general relaxation characteristic boundary conditions, WENO variants, Strang splitting for stiff sub-grid flow features, and low Mach number treatments. Weak scaling to tens of thousands of GPUs on OLCF Summit and Frontier and LLNL El Capitan achieves efficiencies within 5% of ideal to over 90% of their respective system sizes. Strong scaling results for a 16-times increase in device count show parallel efficiencies over 90% on OLCF Frontier. MFC’s software stack has undergone further improvements, including continuous integration, which ensures code resilience and correctness through over 300 regression tests; metaprogramming, which reduces code length while maintaining performance portability; and code generation for computing chemical reactions

Computational fluid dynamics↗
DOE OSTI2020

Novel structured Sm 0.5 Sr 0.5 CoO 3-δ cathode for intermediate and low temperature solid oxide fuel cells

The performance of solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) can be significantly enhanced using nanostructured cathode obtained by infiltration/impregnation method. However, this method has been limited due to multi-step preparation process and instability of the obtained nanoscale catalyst under long-term operation. We report here a simple, cost-effective and reproducible approach to fabricate nanostructured Sm 0.5 Sr 0.5 CoO 3-δ (SSC) cathode with enhanced performance and stability. The SSC powders were prepared by a freeze-drying method through a combustion route using Pluronic F-127 as the template. The SSC freeze-drying powders have unique morphology and a significant phase change at 750 °C. The oxygen non-stoichiometry (δ) of the SSC powders is 0.18 at room temperature, while the δ values are 0.66, 0.75 and 0.90 at 600 °C, 700 °C and 800 °C, respectively. The novel structured SSC cathode was prepared by screen-printing and one-step sintering process using the freeze-drying SSC powders. Maximum cell power densities of 0.83 and 1.13 W cm -2 are achieved at 550 °C and 600 °C, respectively for single cells with the novel structured SSC cathode. Moreover, single cells show excellent stability at 600 °C under a current density of 600 mA cm -2 over 250 h. This work expands opportunities to exploit nanotechnology in a wide range of intermediate and low temperature energy conversion devices.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Optimizing PCM-integrated walls for potential energy savings in U.S. Buildings

Buildings in the United States account for nearly half of total U.S. energy use. The energy used for space conditioning can be reduced by utilizing thermal energy storage, such as phase change materials (PCMs), into building envelopes; however, the energy savings of PCM-integrated building envelopes reported in the literature vary widely. In the absence of established guidelines, thermophysical requirements of an optimal PCM, its method of application into the building envelope, and the corresponding energy savings under various climates remain unknown. Here, we perform an extensive numerical investigation on the integration of PCM into building walls to establish the key conditions required for effective utilization of PCM in reducing heat gains in the cooling season and heat losses in the heating season. We also determine the optimal transition temperature, optimal PCM location in the wall, and the energy-saving potential of the PCM-integrated building walls in five U.S. cities located in different International Energy Conservation Code climate zones. Results show that employing PCMs in building walls does not always lead to an improvement; in fact, incorrect applications of PCMs can substantially increase energy use in the buildings. In the climates we studied, PCMs were found effective in reducing heat gains during the cooling season while mostly ineffective in managing heat losses during heating season. Depending on the climate, optimized PCMs in U.S. building walls can provide reduction in the annual heat gain in the range of 3.5% to 47.2% and the annual heat loss in the range of -2.8% to 8.3%. Future consideration of buildings with substantial solar gains in winter may lead to more reduction in heat losses by PCMs.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
DOE OSTI2026

Design and performance assessment of a dual-mode latent thermal storage integrated heat pump across multiple climate zones

The electrification of space cooling and heating systems risks overloading the existing electrical grid during peak hours. Heat pumps integrated with thermal energy storage (HP-TES) offer a promising solution by shifting peak loads to off-peak hours, reducing grid strains. This work presents the design and assessment of a dual-mode HP-TES that uses a single 22°C phase-change material (PCM) as a heat source or sink in heating and cooling modes, respectively. Performance assessment was conducted using Modelica-based transient models, and full-year simulations were conducted across eight US climate zones using typical weather data. Two HP-TES performance metrics: peak energy reduction and recharge energy increases, were defined by comparing HP-TES energy consumption with base HP peak consumptions. Annual heating demand reductions (40–65%) exceeded cooling demand reductions (15–20%) due to the elimination of peak-hour backup heating. Cooling mode recharge energy requirements (0–10%) were reduced in locations with lower summer nighttime temperatures, while heating recharge requirements were lower than the high base-peak energy demand from backup heating. Simplified rapid methods that were 10 7 times faster than annual simulations were developed to predict seasonal cooling and heating energy reductions, and recharge energy requirements, with maximum deviations of ±2.5% and ±3.5% points. These methods enabled rapid parametric studies that identified optimal location-specific PCM temperatures between 22°C and 27°C, highlighting the need to consider both discharge and recharge energy requirements to achieve sustainable, energy-efficient peak load shifting across various climate zones.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2023

THESEUS: A techno-economic design, integration and downselection framework for energy storage

Optimal selection of energy storage technologies is critical to ensure reliable integration of intermittent and often uncertain renewable energy in electricity grids. The consideration of a diverse set of energy storage technologies is required for a more sustainable deployment of energy storage. We present THESEUS (TecHno-Economic framework for Systematic Energy storage Utilization and downSelection), which is a comprehensive framework for the optimal selection, design and operation of energy storage systems. THESEUS includes rigorous models of major energy storage technologies at different maturity levels, such as thermal storage using phase-change materials or molten salt, cryogenic storage, mechanical storage in the form of compressed air and pumped hydro storage, chemical storage using hydrogen, and electrochemical storage in the form of lithium-ion, sodium sulfur and vanadium flow batteries. An illustrative case study on state-wide prospective energy storage shows that storage integration with fossil power plants could reduce the cost of meeting the grid energy demand by 20%, with mechanical storage as the best suited technology. Although high-temperature thermal storage has low storage efficiency, it is optimal for integration with renewable energy plants. In addition, Li-ion batteries are optimal for high ramping but low storage duration requirements. Furthermore, such insights can enable the deployment of both existing and emerging energy storage technologies to facilitate a smooth transition to a clean energy future.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

A first principles framework to predict the transient performance of latent heat thermal energy storage

Thermal energy storage (TES) is increasingly recognized as an essential component of efficient Combined Heat and Power (CHP), Concentrated Solar Power (CSP), Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning (HVAC), and refrigeration as it reduces peak demand while helping to manage intermittent availability of energy (e.g., from solar or wind). Latent Heat Thermal Energy Storage (LHTES) is a viable option because of its high energy storage density. Parametric analysis of LHTES in terms of dimensionless numbers is highly desired as a tool to model LHTES systems. One approach is to develop a model equation so as to minimize the error between the model and data obtained from experiments or simulations. While this approach can produce an accurate correlation applicable within the range of data used for its creation, it does not provide physical understanding of the rate-limiting process controlling the transient behavior of the device. In this paper we present an alternative approach whereby the potential rate-limiting processes are identified from first principles and then the key process is determined as a function of time as a LHTES device is charged. For example, in a simple geometry, the melt-fraction can be expected to vary linearly in time if the heat transfer rate is limited by natural convection of the phase changing material and we show it scales with the PCM Grashof number as $Gr^1_p$ and PCM Prandtl number as $Pr_p^{(1/3)}$. On the other hand, if surface area of solid PCM limits the heat transfer rate, the melt fraction increases asymptotically to reach full melting. The existence of these linear and asymptotic regions and the $Gr^1_pP r^{1/3}_p$ shape of the melt fraction curve is verified using our database of 64 simulations. Of practical importance in designing LHTES devices is the melt fraction at which the heat transfer rate ceases to be limited by convection, after which the heat storage rate deteriorates. For our geometry, this is found to be about 90%. This test case of our methodology shows the value of our approach, that predicting heat storage rate based on the rate-limiting physical phenomenon as a function of time is an effective approach to modeling LHTES devices.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Dynamic modeling of heat pipe integrated thermal battery latent heat storage system experiment validation

A heat pipe integrated thermal battery system has been constructed to investigate a high-temperature latent heat thermal energy storage technology that takes advantage of near isothermal operation of latent heat storage and heat pipes to potentially enable high-energy isothermal heat storage. A dynamic model constructed in Modelica has been validated, showing errors between 2.5 °C–39.7 °C across 10-h to 47-h simulations against experiment results, showing good prediction capability of experiment output, especially against phase change time. Model calibrations showing vessel heat-up capability of 3 kW and heat pipes combining to provide 600 W each during experiment operation validate experiment circumstances including reduced material loading and reduced power capability. The experiment configuration uses an Al-Mg-Zn eutectic metal as the storage material, heated via heat tape wrapped around the vessel and guide tubes to bring the system to operation range (>400 °C) and to simulate charging heat exchange, respectively, with heat rejection occurring through the surfaces of the material and facilitated via guide tubes with less insulation wrapping. The model is available in the open-source repository HYBRID on Github.

25 - ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Unraveling the Synergistic effects of La and Al co-doping on Ni/Co-free P2-type Na 0.67 Mn 0.67 Fe 0.33 O 2 layered oxide cathodes for sodium-ion batteries

Recent developments in high-performance cathodes for sodium-ion batteries (SIBs) tend to mitigate use of critical Ni and Co active species to satisfy sustainability. P2-type layered oxide cathodes based on Mn and Fe promise high capacity, sustainability, and low cost on account of the abundance and multiple redox characteristics of Mn and Fe. However, their commercialization is still challenged due to poor cycling stability caused by phase changes emanating from inherent Jahn-Teller distortions. Herein, we propose a novel strategy of trivalent La and Al co-doping to alleviate the drawbacks, innovating a new cathode of Na 0.67 Mn 0.62 Al 0.05 Fe 0.31 La 0.02 O 2 (AlLa). The co-doped cathode delivers an impressive capacity of 128.7 mAh/g at 1C and 106.5 mAh/g at high rate of 5C with a good capacity retention of 85% after 100 cycles. These are superior to the unmodified material, whose specific capacity was 118.6 mAh/g at 1C and 61.1 mAh/g at 5C with a retention of only 65% after 100 cycles. The synergistic contribution from La and Al associated with their improved oxygen bonding, pillaring, and local electronic structural modification stemming from rigid Lasingle bondO and Alsingle bondO bonding resulted in the observed structural and electrochemical improvement. Overall, this research offers novel strategies for designing high-performance cathode materials for sodium-ion batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Mechanistic modeling of CO 2 well leakage in a generic abandoned well through a bridge plug cement-casing gap

Both known and unmapped plugged and abandoned wells are potential leakage pathways for CO 2 from geologic carbon sequestration (GCS) sites. Although many abandoned wells have cement bridge plugs installed to prevent leakage, the seal between the cement and the inner casing wall is subject to failure. In this study, we carried out detailed T2Well simulations of cases of sudden non-Darcy flow of CO 2 and brine leakage up the gap between a cement plug and the inner steel casing wall that becomes a fully connected flow path during the post-injection period. The goal of our study was two-fold: (1) to understand the dynamics, rates, and the characteristic temporal signals associated with the onset of leakage through various gap-aperture sizes, and (2) to suggest potential monitoring strategies based on the findings. Simulation results show that the leakage of CO 2 and brine upward is transient with interesting phase interference behavior. Time-dependent oscillatory flows with varying pressure, temperature, and flow rates of CO 2 and brine show strong dependence on gap aperture. Phase-change and decompression lead to very low temperatures at the top of the well for gap apertures larger than 4 mm suggesting that remote thermal monitoring at the ground surface may be an effective way of monitoring even if well locations are not known a priori. Pressure in the well is also indicative of CO 2 leakage. The temporal patterns of changing temperature and pressure may be useful diagnostic signals for leakage detection. Finally, these transient leakage signals may provide information on the cause of leakage and/or characteristics of the flow path that could inform effective remediation design and execution approaches.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2022

Thermal and solubility effects on fault leakage during geologic carbon storage

Geologic carbon storage (GCS) is a promising method for reducing anthropogenic CO 2 emissions to the atmosphere. To safely deploy GCS in the field, it is necessary to assess risks and the effect of uncertainty on safe storage. The effect of uncertainty can be quantified using batches of simulations, but the high computational costs of high-resolution simulations necessitate use of reduced-order models (ROMs). Previous work involves ROMs for quantifying the risk of different potential leakage paths from storage reservoirs to shallow formations. However, previous studies on development of fault-leakage ROMs have limited numbers of uncertain parameters and do not explicitly examine impacts of CO 2 solubility and thermal stresses on fault reactivation, which can generate high-permeability pathways and compromise CO 2 storage. Here, we analyze an ensemble of simulations considering CO 2 leakage from a storage reservoir to a shallow aquifer through a fault while varying a number of uncertain parameters related to thermo-hydro-mechanical properties and CO 2 injection. We show the effects of solubility on: free-phase CO 2 -leakage rates, brine-leakage rates, and poroelastic fault destabilization. We find that CO 2 solubility is more important for estimating free-phase CO 2 -leakage rates compared to brine-leakage rates or poroelastic fault destabilization. We also find that thermal stresses and overpressures have different spatial distributions within the fault, indicating that the spatial variability of overpressures due to variation in flow parameters does not necessarily make the spatial variability of thermal stresses negligible. We suggest the use of the CO 2 phase-change path as a variable in future fault-leakage ROMs.

03 NATURAL GAS↗
DOE OSTI2020

A thermally-limited bubble growth model for the relaxation time of superheated fuels

Here, we propose a novel approach to evaluate the relaxation time of vapor bubble growth in the context of the flash boiling of a superheated liquid. In alternative to the empirical correlation derived from superheated water experiments almost fifty years ago, the new model describes the thermally-dominated growth of vapor bubbles in terms that are dependent on the local Jakob number (the ratio of sensible heat to latent heat during phase change) and the number density of vapor bubbles. The model is tested by plugging the resulting relaxation time into the Homogenous Relaxation Model (HRM). Flash-boiling simulations carried out with HRM are compared with n-pentane (C 5 H 12 ) injection and boil-off experiments conducted with a real-size, axial-hole, transparent gasoline injector discharging into a constant-pressure vessel. The long-distance microscopy images from the experiments, processed to derive the projected liquid volume (PLV) of the spray, provide a unique set of time-resolved validation data for direct fuel injection simulations. At conditions ranging from flaring to mild and minimal flash boiling, we show that switching to the new relaxation time improves the agreement with the measured PLV profiles with respect to the standard empirical model. Particularly at flaring conditions, the predicted increase in gas cooling caused by rapid vapor production is shown to be more consistent with the observed boil-off.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2021

A fast reduced model for a shell-and-tube based latent heat thermal energy storage heat exchanger and its application for cost optimal design by nonlinear programming

Numerical simulation of latent heat thermal energy storage (LHTES) systems plays a fundamental role in studying the physical process and guiding the engineering design. Discretization of the PDEs describing the nonlinear solidification/melting process of phase change materials (PCMs) leads to a large-scale complex dynamics system, where the system behavior depends on a set of parameters. In a design setting, repeated model evaluations are required over the set of parameters results in significant computational burden. In this paper, an explicit analytic solution was built for the propagation of the solidification front in a cylindrical coordinate. The analytic solution approach is further employed to develop a low computational reduced model (RM) as a module for a shell-and-tube based LHTES heat exchanger. The levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) is used as a design metric and the RM model is used to apply system-level constraints in the nonlinear programming formulation that facilitates efficient global optimal design of the PCM properties, flow conditions and tube geometries. The use of LCOE as the design metric prevents over design of the heat transfer rate and also establishes a fair ground for evaluation of different thermal storage technologies and their integrated applications with other systems. Optimal results showed that a higher effectiveness results in a higher LCOE; the velocity of the HTF and the length of the channel are highly correlated with each other; both larger PCM latent energy and conductivity result in lower LCOE.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

A remarkable CHF of 345W/cm 2 is achieved in a wicked-microchannel using HFE-7100

Boiling heat transfer of dielectric fluids is a promising cooling technique for thermal management of microelectronic systems. However, the critical heat flux achievable is generally low, because of the poor thermophysical properties of these fluids. Here, to address this dilemma, we propose a new cooling concept to substantially enhance global liquid supply during phase-change process using enhanced capillary-driven force. Additionally, dedicated vapor pathways are designed among a bank of micro-pillars to facilitate vapor removal. In this work, new wicks comprised of silicon micro-pinfin arrays are explored to significantly enhance the flow boiling heat transfer performance. To examine the functionalities of this wick, experiments on HFE-7100 were carried out with mass velocities varying from 247 to 3,465 kg/m 2 s. To explore the enhancement mechanisms and to analyze the capillary-assisted flow boiling process, visualization studies were conducted. The results indicate that sustainable evaporation induced by wick microstructures and efficient liquid supply are the enhancement mechanisms compared to parallel microchannels with solid walls. It is found that the overall heat transfer coefficient is substantially increased up to 75%. Remarkably, a high critical heat flux (CHF) of approximately 345 W/cm 2 is recorded at G = 3,465 kg/m 2 s at coolant inlet temperature of ~20 °C. Equally importantly, this noticeable enhancement of CHF value is associated with drastically decreased pressure drops compared to microchannels decorated with μ-pinfin fences.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Enhanced internal condensation of R1233zd(E) on micro- and nanostructured copper and aluminum surfaces

In-tube condensation of refrigerants is an important process which affects thermal efficiency in many applications, ranging from refrigeration and air conditioning to electronics thermal management. In-tube heat transfer and pressure drop are important to heat exchanger sizing and design. Here, in this work, micro- and nanostructured surfaces are applied to the internal wetted areas of copper and aluminum mini-channels to enhance the condensation heat transfer coefficient of hydrofluorocarbon R1233zd(E) refrigerant. To achieve scalable nanomanufacturing, surfaces were uniformly structured by relying on hydrochloric acid etching of aluminum and chemical oxidation of copper. The etched aluminum surfaces exhibited a 150% increase in heat transfer coefficient compared to smooth aluminum channels at specific qualities, with a 66% heat transfer coefficient improvement for complete phase change from saturated vapor to saturated liquid. Copper oxide structures showed no discernable difference in thermal-hydraulic performance when compared to smooth copper channels. Critical dimensionless parameters governing the heat transfer enhancement were identified by varying the tube internal diameter (2.3 mm to 4.7 mm), refrigerant mass flux (50 to 300 kg/(m 2 ·s)), and refrigerant quality (0 to 1). The dimensionless parameters include the Bond number normalized to the condensate film thickness, and the Weber number modified by the vapor friction factor. The relatively small increase in pressure drop (< 10%) associated with these surface enhancements further supports the promise of this method. The scalable and cost-effective techniques used to create these aluminum microstructures may reduce manufacturing cost when compared with current enhancement approaches such as extrusion, drawing, and welding.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2024

Influence of alloy solidification path on melt pool behavior in additive manufacturing

Numerical models used to study transport phenomena in laser-powder bed fusion processes often rely on assumptions and simplifications to reduce their computational expense. One common simplification is in the description of latent heat evolution during the solid-liquid phase change (i.e., the solidification pathway), justified by the fact that the mushy zone thickness is similar to the numerical grid spacing used for continuum transport models. The lack of resolution of transport phenomena in the mushy zone motivates the use of computationally convenient solidification paths such as linear or sigmoidal relationships over pathways derived from fundamental solidification theory such as equilibrium or Scheil models. In the present work, an uncertainty quantification (UQ) framework is used to analyze the influence of solidification pathway selection on the solidification dynamics and melt pool geometries in laser based additive manufacturing (AM) of IN625. Results show the solidification pathway has a quantifiable influence on the cooling rate at the liquidus isotherm, mushy zone thickness, and solidification time. Due to similarities in the latent heat evolution at the beginning of solidification, the equilibrium and Scheil models predict similar cooling rates near the liquidus isotherm, however the wider freezing range of Scheil leads to a wider mushy zone compared to equilibrium. The non-physical latent heat release profiles of sigmoidal and linear paths lead to significant overpredictions of cooling rates at the liquidus isotherm compared to equilibrium and Scheil. Finally, these results indicate that careful consideration should be given to the choice of solidification pathway to ensure reliable model predictions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Nitrogen: A promising doping strategy for high-performance ovonic threshold switching selectors

The Ovonic Threshold Switching (OTS) selector serves as an essential component in the development of three-dimensional high-density memory integration technology. Nevertheless, the state-of-the-art high-performance OTS materials usually contain toxic elements such as arsenic (As), posing significant risks to both environmental and human health. Nitrogen (N), which belongs to the same group as arsenic (As), has emerged as a highly promising alternative for As doping. However, the underlying mechanisms that govern N-based OTS materials have not yet been extensively investigated. In this study, we delve into the effects of N doping on the structural, bonding, and electronic properties of amorphous GeSe (a-GeNSe) by ab initio molecular dynamics simulations to bridge the knowledge gap. Our findings indicate that upon N doping in a-GeSe, the formation of robust Ge-N bonds, along with N-centered tetrahedral and triangular structures, resulting in the sluggish atomic movement that enhances the thermal stability and endurance of a-GeNSe. The OTS characteristics are significantly influenced by the material’s electronic band structure, and thus the relatively slow performance drift can be attributed to the stabilization of mid-gap states, a result of N doping which effectively slows down the aging process of chalcogenide glass. Moreover, the increased mobility gap in a-GeNSe raises the threshold voltage (V th ), making it more compatible with commercially available phase-change memory materials. Furthermore, our findings reveal the extensive impact of the N element on a typical OTS material and offer valuable perspectives for alternative doping strategies that could potentially supplant As practices.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗