Pd(II) and Rh(I) Catalytic Precursors for Arene Alkenylation: Comparative Evaluation of Reactivity and Mechanism Based on Experimental and Computational Studies
We combine experimental and computational investigations to compare and understand catalytic arene alkenylation using the Pd(II) and Rh(I) precursors Pd(OAc) 2 and [(η 2 -C 2 H 4 ) 2 Rh(µ-OAc)] 2 with arene, olefin and Cu(II) carboxylate at elevated temperature (> 120 °C). Under specific conditions, previous computational and experimental efforts have identified heterotrimetallic cyclic PdCu 2 (η 2 -C 2 H 4 ) 3 (μ-OPiv) 6 and [(η 2 -C 2 H 4 ) 2 Rh(µ-OPiv) 2 ] 2 (µ-Cu) (OPiv = pivalate) species as likely active catalysts for these processes. Further studies of catalyst speciation suggest a complicated equilibrium between Cu(II)-containing complexes containing one Rh or Pd atom with complexes containing two Rh or Pd atoms. At 120 °C, Rh catalysis produces styrene > 20-fold more rapidly than Pd. Also, at 120 °C, Rh is ~98% selective for styrene formation while Pd is ~82% selective. Furthermore, our studies indicate that Pd catalysis has a higher predilection toward olefin functionalization to form undesired vinyl ester, while Rh catalysis is more selective for arene/olefin coupling. However, at elevated temperatures, Pd converts vinyl ester and arene to vinyl arene, which is proposed to occur through low valent Pd(0) clusters that are formed in situ. Regardless of arene functionality, the regioselectivity for alkenylation of mono-substituted arenes with the Rh catalyst gives an approximate 2:1 meta:para ratio with minimal ortho C–H activation. In contrast, Pd selectivity is significantly influenced by arene electronics with electron-rich arenes giving an approximate 1:2:2 ortho:meta:para ratio while the electron deficient (α,α,α)-trifluorotoluene gives a 3:1 meta:para ratio with minimal ortho functionalization. Kinetic intermolecular arene ethenylation competition experiments find that Rh reacts most rapidly with benzene, and the rate of mono-substituted arene alkenylation does not correlate with arene electronics. In contrast, with Pd catalysis, electron-rich arenes react more rapidly than benzene while electron-deficient arenes react less rapidly than benzene. These experimental findings, in combination with computational results, are consistent with the arene C–H activation step for Pd catalysis involving significant η 1 -arenium character due to Pd-mediated electrophilic aromatic substitution character. In contrast, the mechanism for Rh catalysis is not sensitive to arene substituent electronics, which we propose indicates less electrophilic aromatic substitution character for the Rh-mediated arene C–H activation.