Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “DNS”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 523 records · Page 29

Development of a Perfectly Matched Layer Technique for a Discontinuous-Galerkin Spectral-Element Method

The numerical simulation of many aerodynamic non-periodic flows of practical interest involves discretized computational domains that often must be artificially truncated. Appropriate boundary conditions are required at these truncated domain boundaries, and ideally, these boundary conditions should be perfectly "absorbing" or "nonreflecting" so that they do not contaminate the flow field in the interior of the domain. The proper specification of these boundaries is critical to the stability, accuracy, convergence, and quality of the numerical solution, and has been the topic of considerable research. The need for accurate boundary specification has been underscored in recent years with efforts to apply higher-fidelity methods (DNS, LES) in conjunction with high-order low-dissipation numerical schemes to realistic flow configurations. One of the most popular choices for specifying these boundaries is the characteristics-based boundary condition where the linearized flow field at the boundaries are decomposed into characteristic waves using either one-dimensional Riemann or other multi-dimensional Riemann approximations. The values of incoming characteristics are then suitably modified. The incoming characteristics are specified at the in flow boundaries, and at the out flow boundaries the variation of the incoming characteristic is zeroed out to ensure no reflection. This, however, makes the problem ill-posed requiring the use of an ad-hoc parameter to allow small reflections that make the solution stable. Generally speaking, such boundary conditions work reasonably well when the characteristic flow direction is normal to the boundary, but reflects spurious energy otherwise. An alternative to the characteristic-based boundary condition is to add additional "buffer" regions to the main computational domain near the artificial boundaries, and solve a different set of equations in the buffer region in order to minimize acoustic reflections. One approach that has been used involves modeling the pressure fluctuations as acoustic waves propagating in the far-field relative to a single noise-source inside the buffer region. This approach treats vorticity-induced pressure fluctuations the same as acoustic waves. Another popular approach, often referred to as the "sponge layer," attempts to dampen the flow perturbations by introducing artificial dissipation in the buffer region. Although the artificial dissipation removes all perturbations inside the sponge layer, incoming waves are still reflected from the interface boundary between the computational domain and the sponge layer. The effect of these refkections can be somewhat mitigated by appropriately selecting the artificial dissipation strength and the extent of the sponge layer. One of the most promising variants on the buffer region approach is the Perfectly Matched Layer (PML) technique. The PML technique mitigates spurious reflections from boundaries and interfaces by dampening the perturbation modes inside the buffer region such that their eigenfunctions remain unchanged. The technique was first developed by Berenger for application to problems involving electromagnetic wave propagation. It was later extended to the linearized Euler, Euler and Navier-Stokes equations by Hu and his coauthors. The PML technique ensures the no-reflection property for all waves, irrespective of incidence angle, wavelength, and propagation direction. Although the technique requires the solution of a set of auxiliary equations, the computational overhead is easily justified since it allows smaller domain sizes and can provide better accuracy, stability, and convergence of the numerical solution. In this paper, the PML technique is developed in the context of a high-order spectral-element Discontinuous Galerkin (DG) method. The technique is compared to other approaches to treating the in flow and out flow boundary, such as those based on using characteristic boundary conditions and sponge layers. The superiority of the current PML technique over other approaches is demonstrated for a range of test cases, viz., acoustic pulse propagation, convective vortex, shear layer flow, and low-pressure turbine cascade flow. The paper is structured as follows. We first derive the PML equations from the non{linear Euler equations. A short description of the higher-order DG method used is then described. Preliminary results for the four test cases considered are then presented and discussed. Details regarding current work that will be included in the final paper are also provided.

Spectral↗

Acoustic Radiation From a Mach 14 Turbulent Boundary Layer

Direct numerical simulations (DNS) are used to examine the turbulence statistics and the radiation field generated by a high-speed turbulent boundary layer with a nominal freestream Mach number of 14 and wall temperature of 0:18 times the recovery temperature. The flow conditions fall within the range of nozzle exit conditions of the Arnold Engineering Development Center (AEDC) Hypervelocity Tunnel No. 9 facility. The streamwise domain size is approximately 200 times the boundary-layer thickness at the inlet, with a useful range of Reynolds number corresponding to Re 450 􀀀 650. Consistent with previous studies of turbulent boundary layer at high Mach numbers, the weak compressibility hypothesis for turbulent boundary layers remains applicable under this flow condition and the computational results confirm the validity of both the van Driest transformation and Morkovin's scaling. The Reynolds analogy is valid at the surface; the RMS of fluctuations in the surface pressure, wall shear stress, and heat flux is 24%, 53%, and 67% of the surface mean, respectively. The magnitude and dominant frequency of pressure fluctuations are found to vary dramatically within the inner layer (z/delta 0.< or approx. 0.08 or z+ < or approx. 50). The peak of the pre-multiplied frequency spectrum of the pressure fluctuation is f(delta)/U(sub infinity) approx. 2.1 at the surface and shifts to a lower frequency of f(delta)/U(sub infinity) approx. 0.7 in the free stream where the pressure signal is predominantly acoustic. The dominant frequency of the pressure spectrum shows a significant dependence on the freestream Mach number both at the wall and in the free stream.

Zhang, Chao↗

Pressure Fluctuations Induced by a Hypersonic Turbulent Boundary Layer

Direct numerical simulations (DNS) are used to examine the pressure fluctuations generated by a spatially-developed Mach 5.86 turbulent boundary layer. The unsteady pressure field is analyzed at multiple wall-normal locations, including those at the wall, within the boundary layer (including inner layer, the log layer, and the outer layer), and in the free stream. The statistical and structural variations of pressure fluctuations as a function of wall-normal distance are highlighted. Computational predictions for mean velocity pro les and surface pressure spectrum are in good agreement with experimental measurements, providing a first ever comparison of this type at hypersonic Mach numbers. The simulation shows that the dominant frequency of boundary-layer-induced pressure fluctuations shifts to lower frequencies as the location of interest moves away from the wall. The pressure wave propagates with a speed nearly equal to the local mean velocity within the boundary layer (except in the immediate vicinity of the wall) while the propagation speed deviates from the Taylor's hypothesis in the free stream. Compared with the surface pressure fluctuations, which are primarily vortical, the acoustic pressure fluctuations in the free stream exhibit a significantly lower dominant frequency, a greater spatial extent, and a smaller bulk propagation speed. The freestream pressure structures are found to have similar Lagrangian time and spatial scales as the acoustic sources near the wall. As the Mach number increases, the freestream acoustic fluctuations exhibit increased radiation intensity, enhanced energy content at high frequencies, shallower orientation of wave fronts with respect to the flow direction, and larger propagation velocity.

Lian Duan↗

Shed Vortex Structure and Phase-Averaged Velocity Statistics in Symmetric/Asymmetric Turbulent Flat Plate Wakes

The near wake of a flat plate is investigated via direct numerical simulations (DNS). Many earlier experimental investigations have used thin plates with sharp trailing edges and turbulent boundary layers to create the wake. This results in large theta divided by D (sub TE) values (theta is the boundary layer momentum thickness towards the end of the plate and D (sub TE) is the trailing edge thickness). In the present study the emphasis is on relatively thick plates with circular trailing edges (CTE) resulting in theta divided by D values less than one (D is the plate thickness and the diameter of the CTE), and vigorous vortex shedding. The Reynolds numbers based on the plate length and D are 1.255 x 10 (sup 6) and 10,000, respectively. Two cases are computed; one with turbulent boundary layers on both the upper and lower surfaces of the plate (statistically the same, symmetric wake, Case TT) and, a second with turbulent and laminar boundary layers on the upper and lower surfaces, respectively (asymmetric case, Case TL). The data and understanding obtained is of considerable engineering interest, particularly in turbomachinery where the pressure side of an airfoil can remain laminar or transitional because of a favorable pressure gradient and the suction side is turbulent. Shed-vortex structure and phase-averaged velocity statistics obtained in the two cases are compared here. The upper negative shed vortices in Case TL (turbulent separating boundary layer) are weaker than the lower positive ones (laminar separating boundary layer) at inception (a factor 1.27 weaker in terms of peak phase-averaged spanwise vorticity at first appearance of a peak). The upper vortices weaken rapidly as they travel downstream. A second feature of interest in Case TL is a considerable increase in the peak phase-averaged, streamwise normal intensity (random component) with increasing streamwise distance (x divided by D) that occurs nears the positive vortex cores. This behavior is observed for a few diameters in the near wake. This is counter to Case TT where the peak value essentially decreases with increasing x divided by D. Both these effects are examined in detail and the important contributors are identified.

direct numerical simulations↗

Direct Numerical Simulation of Acoustic Noise Generation from the Nozzle Wall of a Hypersonic Wind Tunnel

The acoustic radiation from the turbulent boundary layer on the nozzle wall of a Mach 6 Ludwieg Tube is simulated using Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS), with the flow conditions falling within the operational range of the Mach 6 Hypersonic Ludwieg Tube, Braunschweig (HLB). The mean and turbulence statistics of the nozzle-wall boundary layer show good agreement with those predicted by Pate's correlation and Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) computations. The rms pressure fluctuation P'(rms)/T(w) plateaus in the freestream core of the nozzle. The intensity of the freestream noise within the nozzle is approximately 20% higher than that radiated from a single at pate with a similar freestream Mach number, potentially because of the contributions to the acoustic radiation from multiple azimuthal segments of the nozzle wall.

Huang, Junji↗

Characterization of Freestream Disturbances in Conventional Hypersonic Wind Tunnels

While low disturbance ("quiet") hypersonic wind tunnels are believed to provide more reliable extrapolation of boundary layer transition behavior from ground to flight, the presently available quiet facilities are limited to Mach 6, moderate Reynolds numbers, low freestream enthalpy, and subscale models. As a result, only conventional ("noisy") wind tunnels can reproduce both Reynolds numbers and enthalpies of hypersonic flight configurations, and must therefore be used for flight vehicle test and evaluation involving high Mach number, high enthalpy, and larger models. This article outlines the recent progress and achievements in the characterization of tunnel noise that have resulted from the coordinated effort within the AVT-240 specialists group on hypersonic boundary layer transition prediction. New Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) datasets elucidate the physics of noise generation inside the turbulent nozzle wall boundary layer, characterize the spatiotemporal structure of the freestream noise, and account for the propagation and transfer of the freestream disturbances to a pitot-mounted sensor. The new experimental measurements cover a range of conventional wind tunnels with different sizes and Mach numbers from 6 to 14 and extend the database of freestream fluctuations within the spectral range of boundary layer instability waves over commonly tested models. Prospects for applying the computational and measurement datasets for developing mechanism-based transition prediction models are discussed.

Duan, Lian↗

Nonlinear Evolution and Breakdown of Azimuthally Compact Crossflow Vortex Pattern over a Yawed Cone

Hypersonic boundary-layer flows over a circular cone at moderate angle of incidence can support strong crossflow instability in between the windward and leeward rays on the plane of symmetry. Due to the more efficient excitation of stationary crossflow vortices by surface roughness, a possible path to transition in such flows corresponds to rapid amplification of the high-frequency secondary instabilities of finite amplitude stationary crossflow vortices. In the present paper, the previous analyses of crossflow instability over a 7- degree half-angle, yawed circular cone in a Mach 6 free stream have been extended to the nonlinear evolution of azimuthally localized crossflow vortex packets and the amplification characteristics and nonlinear breakdown of high-frequency secondary instabilities associated with those packets. A comparison between plane marching PSE and direct Navier-Stokes simulations (DNS) reveals favorable agreement in regard to mode shapes, most amplified disturbance frequencies, and N-factor evolution. In contrast, the quasi-parallel predictions are found to result in severe underprediction of the N-factors. The direct numerical simulations also indicate that the breakdown of secondary instabilities in a 3D hypersonic boundary layer shares certain common features with the previous computations of crossflow transition over subsonic swept wings.

Vortex structure↗

Numerical Study of the Effect of Mean Three-Dimensionality on Turbulence in Adverse-Pressure-Gradient Boundary Layers

Direct numerical simulation (DNS) is used to isolate the influence of sweep on a separating turbulent boundary layer. Attention here is limited to the behavior of the turbulence within the adverse-pressure-gradient (APG) region upstream of separation. Other regions and quantities are considered in Coleman, Rumsey & Spalart. The mean three-dimensionality and outer-layer inviscid skewing have only a slight effect upon the structure of the turbulence (measured by the relationship of the components of the Reynolds-stress tensor and the efficiency of the turbulence energy transfer) compared with that of the adverse pressure gradient, which dominates both the skewed and unskewed layers.

Coleman, G. N.↗

Instability Wave–Streak Interactions in a High Mach Number Boundary Layer at Flight Conditions

The interaction of stationary streaks undergoing nonmodal growth with modally unstable instability waves in a hypersonic boundary-layer flow is studied using numerical computations. The geometry and flow conditions are selected to match a relevant trajectory location from the ascent phase of the HIFiRE-1 flight experiment; namely, a 7 degree half-angle, circular cone with 2.5 mm nose radius, freestream Mach number equal to 5.30, unit Reynolds number equal to 13.42 m -1 , and wall-to-adiabatic temperature ratio of approximately 0.35 over most of the vehicle. This paper investigates the nonlinear evolution of initially linear optimal disturbances that evolve into finite-amplitude streaks, followed by an analysis of the modal instability characteristics of the perturbed, streaky boundary-layer flow. The investigation is performed with stationary direct numerical simulations (DNS) and plane-marching parabolized stability equations (PSE), in conjunction with partial-differential-equation-based planar eigenvalue analysis. The overall effect of streaks is to reduce the peak amplification factors of instability waves, indicating a possible downstream shift in the onset of laminar-turbulent transition. The present study confirms previous findings that the mean flow distortion of the nonlinear streak perturbation reduces the amplification rates of the Mack-mode instability. More importantly, however, the present results demonstrate that the spanwise varying component of the streak can produce a larger effect on the Mack-mode amplification. The study with selected azimuthal wavenumbers for the stationary streaks reveals that a wavenumber of approximately 1.4 times larger than the optimal wavenumber is more effective in stabilizing the planar Mack-mode instabilities. In the absence of unstable first-mode waves for the present cold-wall condition, transition onset is expected to be delayed until the peak streak amplitude increases to nearly 35 percent of the freestream velocity, when intrinsic instabilities of the boundary-layer streaks begin to dominate the transition process. For streak amplitudes below that limit a significant net stabilization is achieved, yielding a potential transition delay that can exceed 100 percent of the length of the laminar region in the uncontrolled case.

Boundary layer stability↗

Direct Simulation of Flow over A Wall-Mounted Hump

Simulating separated flows at high Reynolds numbers using Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) modeled equations remains a challenge in aeronautics. The main hindrance to progress stems from the lack of extended de- tailed data pertinent to the root cause of failure of RANS models, as well as the little progress in RANS modeling innovations in the past several decades. The goal of the current effort is to generate data for separated flow at a Reynolds numbers where conventional models are challenged. We use Direct Numerical Simulations to model turbulent flow over the wall-mounted hump configuration to investigate the physics of flow separation and boundary layer recovery, as well as provide data relevant to the modeling community. A chord-based Reynolds number of Re(sub c) = 47,500 is considered with a turbulent inflow profile of Re(sub θ) = 1,400 (θ /c = 3%). We use FDL3DI, a code that solves the compressible Navier-Stokes equations using high-order compact-difference scheme and filter, with the standard re- cycling/rescaling method of generating turbulent boundary layers as inflow to the computational domain. Two differ- ent configurations of the upper-wall are analyzed for two sets of boundary conditions (slip and no-slip). The results are compared with the available higher Re(sub c) (= 936,000, Re(sub θ) = 7,200, θ /c = 0.77%) experiment for major flow features. The simulated lower Rec allows for DNS-like mesh resolutions, and adequately wide spans. The results from these simulations show earlier separation and delayed reattachment compared to Re(sub c) = 936,000, and significantly higher skin friction in the forebody of the hump. We also find that the upper-wall shape and boundary condition influence pressure distribution over the hump, whereas skin friction is only influenced by the boundary condition.

Wall-Mounted↗

The Intermediate Wake of a Thick Flat Plate with a Circular Trailing Edge

The intermediate wake region of a thick flat plate with a circular trailing edge (TE) is investigated with a direct numerical simulation (DNS). The upper and lower separating boundary layers are both turbulent and are statistically identical; the resulting wake is symmetric in the mean. Earlier research dealt with the near/very-near wake of the same plate (x/D < 13.0, x is the streamwise distance from the center of the circular TE and D is the plate-thickness/TE-diameter). In the present investigation the emphasis is on the evolution of shed-vortex structure and turbulence intensity distributions with increasing x; the focus is on the region 20.0 < x/D < 40.0. Profile similarity in wake velocity statistics is explored.

Rai, Man Mohan↗

Streak Instabilities on HIFiRE-5 Elliptic Cone

The Hypersonic International Flight Research and Experimentation (HIFiRE) 5 flight experiment by the Air Force Research Laboratories and Australian Defense Science and Technology Organization yielded inflight, hypersonic transition data for a canonical, 3D configuration in the form of an elliptic cone at various combinations of angle-of-attack and yaw. Previous analysis has shown that boundary-layer stability calculations for the as-flown, zero-yaw flight conditions are able to capture the second mode dominated transition along the attachment line as well as the crossflow induced transition in between the attachment line and the minor axis symmetry plane. However, there is still a need to understand the transition in the vicinity of the minor axis plane of symmetry, where the boundary layer thickness exhibits an azimuthally compact bulge due to the collision of the secondary flow approaching from the attachment lines on both sides. This paper reports a computational analysis of the stability of the boundary layer flow along the bulge regions on both the leeward and windward sides of the vehicle surface. At a representative flight condition corresponding to a time instant of t = 514.813 seconds, computations are performed to identify several different unstable modes within the bulge regions, with the eventual goal of developing a linear stability correlation for the transition onset near the minor axis symmetry plane. The most amplified flow instabilities in the pretransitional region correspond to a “stem” mode that is concentrated within a pair of nearly vertical shear layers below the cap of the mushroom shaped bulge in the mean velocity contours. An excellent agreement is found between the predictions of instability amplification based on the plane marching parabolized stability equations (PSE) and the direct numerical solutions (DNS). Given the large number of unstable modes within the bulge region, the observed agreement demonstrates, for first time, that the PSE can provide accurate predictions for the development of flow instabilities in streak-like flow features over three-dimensional bodies. The peak N-factor of approximately 15 at the transition location estimated from the thermocouple measurements along the leeward centerline is close to the transition N-factor for Mack mode transition during the HIFiRE-1 circular cone flight experiment with nearly zero degrees angle of attack.

Meelan Choudhari↗

Streak Instability Analysis for BOLT Configuration

The BOLT configuration designed for an upcoming flight experiment exemplifies the complexities of hypersonic boundary layer transition in the presence of multiple and potentially interacting instability mechanisms. A numerical study of the boundary layer instabilities over this configuration has been performed with the goal of applying state-of-the-art tools in multidimensional stability analysis that complement the other ongoing research related to the BOLT flight campaign. Specifically, the paper outlines modal instability characteristics of the boundary layer streaks adjacent to the minor-axis symmetry plane of a 1/3 rd scale BOLT configuration that was tested in the low-disturbance hypersonic wind tunnel at Purdue University and both quiet and conventional tunnels at Texas A&M University (TAMU). The basic state computations agree well with the heat flux measurements in the Purdue quiet tunnel as well as with the off-body velocity field described in a previous DNS study at the University of Minnesota. The encouraging agreement between the predicted frequency spectra of the streak instability in the region of increased boundary layer thickness and the surface pressure spectra measured during the TAMU experiments suggests that these streak instabilities may play an important role during the transition process near the symmetry plane. The modest value of the predicted peak N-factor (N max ≈ 5) for the streak instabilities provides a potential explanation for why transition is not observed under quiet flow conditions, but may occur in a noisy wind tunnel. Similar instability analyses are performed for the flight configuration at two selected flow conditions from the ascent portion of the planned flight trajectory. The predicted values of the peak N-factor suggest that transition onset in the vicinity of the center plane is possible at the ascent time of t = 26.98 seconds (N max ≈ 12.5 at X/L = 0.77), but the streak instabilities weaken sufficiently at the later time of t = 28.88 seconds (N max ≈ 11.5 at X/L ≈ 1.00) and are less likely to cause transition at that time.

Laminar turbulent transition↗

Laminar to Turbulence Transition in Boundary Layers due to Tripping Devices

Direct numerical simulations (DNS)and linear stability analysis were performed to identify the mechanisms by which two-and three-dimensional trips promote early transition in subsonic boundary layers over a flat plate. Investigations were conducted for two boundary layer transition trip configurations: one is a two-dimensional rectangular-shaped rod and the other is a three-dimensional zigzag tape. Reynolds numbers based on the trip heights are 683 and 300 for the two-and three-dimensional trips, respectively. Simulations with the two-dimensional trip showed that the flow separates at the top of the trip and forms a long recirculation zone downstream. However, the flow remains steady in the simulation without any external disturbances. Linear stability analysis showed that the inflectional profile in the recirculation zone is strongly unstable to frequencies in the range of 100-300 Hz. Simulations with the external disturbances forced at the frequency of 200 Hz showed that disturbances grow strongly inside the recirculation zone as observed in the Klebanoff1 experiment.

Transition↗

WMLES of Boundary-Layer Transition

An analysis of the potential for the accurate prediction of laminar-turbulent transition by Wall-Modeled Large-Eddy Simulation (WMLES) indicates that satisfactory prediction of transition by WMLES is possible, provided a) a sufficiently accurate wall model for the initial stage of transition is employed, b) a satisfactory transition is made between this initial-stage wall model and the wall model for the downstream fully-developed turbulence, and c) limitations on temporal and spatial resolution, and on the thickness of the wall-modeled region, imposed by the need to accurately resolve the disturbance waves and the transition region are observed. This is illustrated with WMLES computations of subharmonic transition in a flat-plate boundary layer that yield reasonable agreement with DNS results. However, the wall-modeled region thickness, and thus the cost savings, is less than is typical for WMLES of fully developed turbulence.

wall-modeled large-eddy simulation↗

Laminar to Turbulence Transition in Boundary Layers due to Tripping Devices

Direct numerical simulations (DNS)and linear stability analyses were performed to identify the mechanisms by whichtwo-and three-dimensional trips promote early transition in subsonic boundary layers over a flat plate. Investigations were conducted for threeboundary-layer transition trip configurations:a two-dimensional smooth hump,a two-dimensional rectangular-shapedrod and a three-dimensional zig-zagtape. The smooth hump was used by Park et al.1in the linear and nonlinear parabolized stability (PSE) computations. Reynolds numbersbased on the tripheights are 710, 683,and 300 for the two-and three-dimensional trips, respectively. Simulations withthe smooth hump showed that the flow becomes stable upstream and strongly unstable downstream of the hump. Simulations with the two-dimensional rectangular trip showed that the flow separates at the top of the trip and forms a long recirculation zonedownstream. However, the flow remains steady in the simulation without any external disturbances. Linear stability analysis showed that the inflectional profile in the recirculation zone is strongly unstable to frequencies in the range of 100-300 Hz. Simulations with the external disturbances forced at the frequency of 200 Hz showed that disturbances grow strongly inside the recirculation zone as observed in the Klebanoff2 experiment. Three-dimensional simulations with secondary disturbances of fundamental, subharmonic, and oblique types produced turbulent flows shortlydownstream. The three-dimensional zig-zag trip with a small roughness Reynolds number lead to early breakdown to a turbulent flow.

Stability↗

WMLES of Boundary-Layer Transition

An analysis of the potential for the accurate prediction of laminar-turbulent transition by Wall-Modeled Large-Eddy Simulation (WMLES) indicates that satisfactory prediction of transition by WMLES is possible, provided a) a sufficiently accurate wall model for the initial stage of transition is employed, b) a satisfactory transition is made between this initial-stage wall model and the wall model for the downstream fully-developed turbulence, and c) limitations on temporal and spatial resolution, and on the thickness of the wall-modeled region, imposed by the need to accurately resolve the disturbance waves and the transition region are observed. This is illustrated with WMLES computations of subharmonic transition in a flat-plate boundary layer that yield reasonable agreement with DNS results. However, the wall-modeled region thickness, and thus the cost savings, is less than is typical for WMLES of fully developed turbulence.

Wall-modeled large-eddy simulation↗

A Priori Subgrid Analysis of Temporal Mixing Layers with Evaporating Droplets

Subgrid analysis of a transitional temporal mixing layer with evaporating droplets has been performed using three sets of results from a Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) database, with Reynolds numbers (based on initial vorticity thickness) as large as 600 and with droplet mass loadings as large as 0.5.

subgrid↗