In-situ Characterization of Metal/Oxide Catalysts for CO2 Conversion: From Fundamental Aspects to Real Catalysts Design
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The 67th AVS International Symposium and Exhibition, Virtual, October 24-29, 2021.
The present disclosure relates to a composition that includes a core in the shape of a particle having a characteristic length between about one micron and about one millimeter, an active material that includes a noble metal deposited on a surface of the core, and a coating that includes a first metal-oxide, where the active material is positioned between the core and the coating, the active material has a diameter between about one nanometer and about 20 nanometers, and the coating has a thickness between greater than zero nanometers and about 20 nanometers.
Developing novel catalysts with high efficiency and selectivity is critical for enabling future clean energy conversion technologies. Interfaces in catalyst systems have long been considered the most critical factor in controlling catalytic reaction mechanisms. Interfaces include not only the catalyst surface but also interfaces within catalyst particles and those formed by constructing heterogeneous catalysts. The atomic and electronic structures of catalytic surfaces govern the kinetics of binding and release of reactant molecules from surface atoms. Interfaces within catalysts are introduced to enhance the intrinsic activity and stability of the catalyst by tuning the surface atomic and chemical structures. Examples include interfaces between the core and shell, twin or domain boundaries, or phase boundaries within single catalyst particles. In supported catalyst nanoparticles (NPs), the interface between the metallic NP and support serves as a critical tuning factor for enhancing catalytic activity. Surface electronic structure can be indirectly tuned and catalytically active sites can be increased through the use of supporting oxides. Additionally, tuning interfaces in catalyst systems has been identified as an important strategy in the design of novel catalysts. However, the governing principle of how interfaces contribute to catalyst behavior, especially in terms of interactions with intermediates and their stability during electrochemical operation, are largely unknown. This is mainly due to the evolving nature of such interfaces. Small changes in the structural and chemical configuration of these interfaces may result in altering the catalytic performance. These interfacial arrangements evolve continuously during synthesis, processing, use, and even static operation. A technique that can probe the local atomic and electronic interfacial structures with high precision while monitoring the dynamic interfacial behavior in situ is essential for elucidating the role of interfaces and providing deeper insight for fine-tuning and optimizing catalyst properties.Scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) has long been a primary characterization technique used for studying nanomaterials because of its exceptional imaging resolution and simultaneous chemical analysis. Over the past decade, advances in STEM, that is, the commercialization of both aberration correctors and monochromators, have significantly improved the spatial and energy resolution. Imaging atomic structures with subangstrom resolution and identifying chemical species with single-atom sensitivity are now routine for STEM. These advancements have greatly benefitted catalytic research. For example, the roles of lattice strain and surface elemental distribution and their effect on catalytic stability and reactivity have been well documented in bimetallic catalysts. In addition, three-dimensional atomic structures revealed by STEM tomography have been integrated in theoretical modeling for predictive catalyst NP design. Recent developments in stable electronic and mechanical devices have opened opportunities to monitor the evolution of catalysts in operando under synthesis and reaction conditions; high-speed direct electron detectors have achieved sub-millisecond time resolutions and allow for rapid structural and chemical changes to be captured. Investigations of catalysts using these latest microscopy techniques have provided new insights into atomic-level catalytic mechanisms. Further integration of new microscopy methods is expected to provide multidimensional descriptions of interfaces under relevant synthesis and reaction conditions.In this Account, we discuss recent insights on understanding catalyst activity, selectivity, and stability using advanced STEM techniques, with an emphasis on how critical interfaces dictate the performance of precious metal-based heterogeneous catalysts. The role of extended interfacial structures, including those between core and shell, between separate phases and twinned grains, between the catalyst surface and gas, and between metal and support are discussed. We also provide an outlook on how emerging electron microscopy techniques, such as vibrational spectroscopy and electron ptychography, will impact future catalysis research.
As fuel cells transition from the laboratory to industrial production for vehicles and other applications there is a need to understand how manufacturing processes impact the properties and, ultimately, the performance of materials. Roll-to-roll coating enables processing at meters per second speeds with physics that can be quite different from common laboratory coating methods. In this work, we have focused on the coating of catalyst layers for proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Commonly, laboratory samples are prepared using spray coating or hand painting, which effectively coat many thin layers to achieve the desired catalyst layer thickness. This creates catalyst layers with uniform distributions of materials throughout the thickness of the full catalyst layer. In contrast, roll-to-roll methods, like slot die and gravure, coat the catalyst layer as a single wet film. As the film dries, ink constituents are able to segregate, leading to a heterogeneous distribution of materials through the thickness of the layer. It is also known that solvent and drying rate can affect the morphology of the catalyst layer. Thus, there is a need to understand how ink formulation and the drying process influence the distribution of materials and catalyst layer morphology. Here, we have explored the influence of solvent and drying rate on morphology of roll-to-roll coated catalyst layers. We show the development of the Kelvin probe method as a rapid screening technique for qualitative analysis of ionomer distribution. We also utilize nano X-ray computed tomography to visualize electrode structure and to quantify particle-size and pore-size distributions, thickness-dependent ionomer distribution, tortuosity, and effective transport properties. We find that solvent has a strong influence on ionomer distribution, with less of an effect on porosity. Conversely, drying temperature has a strong influence on porosity, but less influence on ionomer distribution. Finally, we utilize in situ fuel cell performance testing and other advanced diagnostics to quantify the impact of catalyst layer properties on fuel cell performance and demonstrate that roll-to-roll coating is capable of coating high performance catalyst layers in multi-meter lengths. have focused on the coating of catalyst layers for proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Commonly, laboratory samples are prepared using spray coating or hand painting, which effectively coat many thin layers to achieve the desired catalyst layer thickness. This creates catalyst layers with uniform distributions of materials throughout the thickness of the full catalyst layer. In contrast, roll-to-roll methods, like slot die and gravure, coat the catalyst layer as a single wet film. As the film dries, ink constituents are able to segregate, leading to a heterogeneous distribution of materials through the thickness of the layer. It is also known that solvent and drying rate can affect the morphology of the catalyst layer. Thus, there is a need to understand how ink formulation and the drying process influence the distribution of materials and catalyst layer morphology. Here, we have explored the influence of solvent and drying rate on morphology of roll-to-roll coated catalyst layers. We show the development of the Kelvin probe method as a rapid screening technique for qualitative analysis of ionomer distribution. We also utilize nano X-ray computed tomography to visualize electrode structure and to quantify particle-size and pore-size distributions, thickness-dependent ionomer distribution, tortuosity, and effective transport properties. We find that solvent has a strong influence on ionomer distribution, with less of an effect on porosity. Conversely, drying temperature has a strong influence on porosity, but less influence on ionomer distribution. Finally, we utilize in situ fuel cell performance testing and other advanced diagnostics to quantify the impact of catalyst layer properties on fuel cell performance and demonstrate that roll-to-roll coating is capable of coating high performance catalyst layers in multi-meter lengths.
Fuel cell catalyst layers are a complex mixture of catalyst particles and ion-conducting polymers. The performance of catalyst layers is highly dependent on microstructure, which must balance proton and electron conduction with gas transport. As fuel cells transition from the laboratory to industrial production for vehicles and other applications, there is a need to understand how manufacturing processes impact the microstructure and, ultimately, the performance of catalyst layers. In this work, we have focused on the roll-to-roll coating of catalyst layers for proton exchange membrane fuel cells. The catalyst layers are responsible for the electrochemical reactions that enable power production. In these devices the catalyst is commonly a Pt nanoparticle supported on porous carbon blacks. The ion conducting polymer, or ionomer, is typically a perfluorosulfonic acid. The most common being Nafion. To fabricate the catalyst layer, the catalyst particles are dispersed in an ink with the ionomer and cast to form the catalyst layer. Commonly, laboratory samples are prepared using spray coating or hand painting, which effectively coat many thin layers to achieve the desired catalyst layer thickness. This creates catalyst layers with uniform distributions of materials throughout the thickness of the full catalyst layer. In contrast, roll-to-roll methods, like slot die, gravure or screen printing, coat the catalyst layer as a single wet film. As the film dries, ink constituents are able to segregate, leading to a heterogeneous distribution of materials through the thickness of the layer. It is also known that the choice of solvent and drying rate can affect the morphology of the catalyst layer. Thus, there is a need to understand how ink formulation and the drying process influence the distribution of materials and catalyst layer morphology. Here, we have explored the influence of solvent and drying rate on morphology of roll-to-roll coated catalyst layers. We show the development of the Kelvin probe method as a rapid screening technique for qualitative analysis of ionomer distribution. We also utilize nano X-ray computed tomography to visualize electrode structure and to quantify particle-size and pore-size distributions, thickness-dependent ionomer distribution, tortuosity, and effective transport properties. We find that solvent has a strong influence on ionomer distribution, with less of an effect on porosity. Conversely, drying temperature has a strong influence on porosity, but less influence on ionomer distribution. Finally, we utilize in situ fuel cell performance testing and other advanced diagnostics to quantify the impact of catalyst layer properties on fuel cell performance and demonstrate that roll-to-roll coating is capable of coating high performance catalyst layers in multi-meter lengths.
Rhenium and manganese bipyridyl tricarbonyl complexes have attracted intense interest for their promising applications in photocatalytic and electrocatalytic CO 2 reduction in both homogeneous and heterogenized systems. To date, there have been extensive studies on immobilizing Re catalysts on solid surfaces for higher catalytic efficiency, reduced catalyst loading, and convenient product separation. However, in order for the heterogenized molecular catalysts to achieve the combination of the best aspects of homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysts, it is essential to understand the fundamental physicochemical properties of such heterogeneous systems, such as surface-bound structures of Re/Mn catalysts, substrate–adsorbate interactions, and photoinduced or electric-field-induced effects on Re/Mn catalysts. For example, the surface may act to (un)block substrates, (un)trap charges, (de)stabilize particular intermediates (and thus affect scaling relations), and shift potentials in different directions, just as protein environments do. The close collaboration between the Lian, Batista, and Kubiak groups has resulted in an integrated approach to investigate how the semiconductor or metal surface affects the properties of the attached catalyst. Synthetic strategies to achieve stable and controlled attachment of Re/Mn molecular catalysts have been developed. Steady-state, time-resolved, and electrochemical vibrational sum-frequency generation (SFG) spectroscopic studies have provided insight into the effects of interfacial structures, ultrafast vibrational energy relaxation, and electric field on the Re/Mn catalysts, respectively. Various computational methods utilizing density functional theory (DFT) have been developed and applied to determine the molecular orientation by direct comparison to spectroscopy, unravel vibrational energy relaxation mechanisms, and quantify the interfacial electric field strength of the Re/Mn catalyst systems. This Account starts with a discussion of the recent progress in determining the surface-bound structures of Re catalysts on semiconductor and Au surfaces by a combined vibrational SFG and DFT study. The effects of crystal facet, length of anchoring ligands, and doping of the semiconductor on the bound structures of Re catalysts and of the substrate itself are discussed. This is followed by a summary of the progress in understanding the vibrational relaxation (VR) dynamics of Re catalysts covalently adsorbed on semiconductor and metal surfaces. The VR processes of Re catalysts on TiO 2 films and TiO 2 single crystals and a Re catalyst tethered on Au, particularly the role of electron–hole pair (EHP)-induced coupling on the VR of the Re catalyst bound on Au, are discussed. The Account also summarizes recent studies in quantifying the electric field strength experienced by the catalytically active site of the Re/Mn catalyst bound on a Au electrode based on a combined electrochemical SFG and DFT study of the Stark tuning of the CO stretching modes of these catalysts. Finally, future research directions on surface-immobilized molecular catalyst systems are discussed.
This project is to develop M (x) -N-C catalysts with dense multiple metal center (MMC) sites to meet the DOE 2025 activity target of 0.044 mA/cm 2 at 0.9 V IR-free ., as well as other goals such as durability. We have made important contributions to both catalyst development and fundamental understandings of the active sites in M-N-C catalysts in this project. We successfully made M (x) -N-C catalysts with some multiple metal center (MMC) sites by combining ionothermal carbonization with chemical vapor deposition (CVD). These catalysts, however, are not as active as the most active single-atom Fe-N-C catalysts made by the similar CVD process, owing likely to the low site density and the presence of inorganic Fe species such as iron carbides and nanoparticles. The most significant accomplishments we achieved in this project are: (1) we unraveled the formation pathway of Fe-N 4 sites during pyrolysis step-by-step and identified the trans-metalation mechanism, in collaboration with Deborah Myers and her colleagues at Argonne National Laboratory (ANL); (2) inspired by this finding, we pioneered the CVD synthesis of M-N-C catalysts (M = Mn, Fe, and Co), in which the Fe-N-C catalyst by CVD demonstrated an ORR activity of 33 mA/cm 2 at 0.9 V in H 2 -O 2 proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs), very close to the ultimate goal of 35 mA/cm 2 of our project. This catalyst is the first Fe-N-C catalyst that contains only D1 sites without the D2 sites; whereas D1 and D2 sites have been always identified by Mossbauer in previous Fe-N-C catalysts. This finding helps to understand what the D1 and D2 sites are and their roles in catalyzing the ORR. (3) by improving the mass transport of the carbon matrix prior to the CVD process, the revised Fe-N-C catalyst made by CVD delivered a maximum power density of 0.53 W/cm 2 in H 2 -air PEMFCs. The improvement strategy was partly inspired by the computational modeling work by Adam Weber from LBNL, the Co-PI of this project, by developing, coding, and exercising a continuum level model of transport phenomena within a PGM-free catalyst layer. The model demonstrated that local resistances combined with limited site density of the PGM-free catalyst can result in limiting currents and poor polarization performance. The model also gave design guidance for impact of ECSA and overall catalyst-layer thickness. However, both Fe-N-C and Co-N-C catalysts developed by CVD showed poor durability in PEMFCS, in comparison with the traditional M-N-C catalysts synthesized via regular pyrolysis process. Consequently, we did not achieve the proposed durability targets. Despite so, we believe the FeNC-CVD catalysts with the poor durability and D1 sites only provides an excellent platform to understand the degradation mechanism of Fe-N-C in PEMFCs, the most important challenge in the development of M-N-C catalysts.
During the past few years of our funding from DOE Basic Energy Sciences, we have focused on the catalytic conversion of biomass-derived 5-hydroxymethyl furfural (HMF) as a platform molecule for sustainable synthesis of value-added chemicals. The combination of the diene and aldehyde functionalities in HMF enables catalytic production of acetalized HMF derivatives with diol or epoxy reactants to allow reversible synthesis of norcantharimide derivatives upon Diels-Alder reaction with maleimides. Whereas the electron-withdrawing nature of aldehyde group inhibits the reactivity of diene group in HMF to undergo Diels-Alder reactions with dienophiles, by converting the aldehyde group in HMF to an electron-donating hydroxyl group, HMF can append maleimide-based chemicals through Diels-Alder coupling. Acetalization of HMF not only produces an electron-rich diene for Diels-Alder reaction, but it also alters the reversibility of acetal formation and thereby allows for the controlled release of chemicals by hydrolysis. Therefore, we synthesized various norcantharimide derivatives from biomass-derived HMF by acetalization over an acid catalyst, Amberlyst-15, followed by Diels-Alder reaction with maleimide. The norcantharimides release the starting materials by retro Diels-Alder reaction that is triggered by acetal hydrolysis under acidic (≤pH 3) conditions. In subsequent work, we explored the synthesis and properties of functional polyurethanes and polyesters with tunable properties from biomass-derived (HMF)-Acetone-HMF (HAH) monomers. HAH can be selectively hydrogenated over Cu and Ru catalysts to produce partially-hydrogenated HAH (PHAH) and fully-hydrogenated HAH (FHAH). HAH contains functional groups, including hydroxyl, furan, enone, and ketone functionalities, that can be exploited to further tune the polymer properties. The π-electron conjugation between the enone and furan groups in HAH monomer stabilizes the furan group to prevent the uncontrolled degradation of furans during reactions, such as etherification. Therefore, HAH is a renewable monomer that can be used to synthesize polymers, having high molecular weight, symmetric functionalities, an inexpensive production price, and being derived from renewable resources without competition with food resources. We demonstrated the synthesis of functional polyurethanes and a renewable polyester from HAH-derived monomers, and 4,4’-methylenebis(phenyl isocyanate) (MDI). We showed that it is essential to be able to selective hydrogenate C=C double bonds in HAH to be able to achieve effective Diels Alder reactions of the furan ring. Therefore, we studied the hydrogenation at temperatures from 313 – 393 K of HAH over Pd, Ru, and Cu based catalysts. HAH was selectively hydrogenated to produce partially-hydrogenated monomers (PHAH) over Cu and Ru catalysts and to fully-hydrogenated HAH monomers (FHAH) over the Ru catalyst. Pd based catalysts yielded a mixture of partially and fully hydrogenated monomers. Reaction kinetics models were employed to quantify the kinetic behavior for hydrogenation over Ru, Cu, and Pd catalysts. A 5-step pathway exhibited over Pd and Ru catalysts consists of both series and parallel reaction steps, where HAH is both converted to fully hydrogenated products sequentially via series reactions of partially hydrogenated intermediates, as well as converted directly in parallel reactions to form the fully hydrogenated products. In contrast, a 3-step pathway over the Cu catalyst consists only of the consecutive reaction steps, where the final product was formed via series reactions of intermediate products. Additionally, reaction over the Cu catalyst did not hydrogenate the furan rings of the HAH molecule and yielded a different final product than those hydrogenation over Pd and Ru catalysts. Using the results from our detailed reaction kinetics studies, we developed universal conditions for the maximum production of the various hydrogenated products for both batch and plug flow systems. In subsequent work, we employed reaction schemes to optimize the yields of products from selective hydrogenations of HAH in isopropanol solvent and in the presence of liquid water. Reaction schemes consisting of 7, 9, and 11 steps were examined to describe the rates of formation of the observed products and reaction intermediates for hydrogenation of HAH over Ru and Pd catalysts, and a 3-step scheme was studied over Cu catalysts. Rate constants and activation energies were calculated using these reaction schemes, and we then apply these reaction schemes to explore the effects of water addition on the hydrogenation pathways. The effects of water addition to isopropanol (IPA) solvents on the hydrogenation of HAH were markedly different over Pd, Ru, and Cu catalysts. Over the Pd catalyst, the addition of water to IPA increased hydrogenation rates and promoted hydrogenation of furan rings. The addition of water to IPA yielded significant carbon losses over the Ru catalyst, and slowed hydrogenation steps over Cu, while significantly inhibiting hydrogenation of the ketone group. This behavior opened routes toward increased production rates of PHAH=O (a partially hydrogenated form of HAH containing a C=O bond), a product in which the diene groups of the furan rings were not hydrogenated. Addition of water also allowed increased feed concentrations of HAH that were previously not possible in pure IPA solvents.
Two catalysts for the selective oxidation of trace amounts of contaminant gases in air have been developed for use aboard the International Space Station. These catalysts might also be useful for reducing concentrations of fumes in terrestrial industrial facilities especially facilities that use halocarbons as solvents, refrigerant liquids, and foaming agents, as well as facilities that generate or utilize ammonia. The first catalyst is of the supported-precious-metal type. This catalyst is highly active for the oxidation of halocarbons, hydrocarbons, and oxygenates at low concentrations in air. This catalyst is more active for the oxidation of hydrocarbons and halocarbons than are competing catalysts developed in recent years. This catalyst completely converts these airborne contaminant gases to carbon dioxide, water, and mineral acids that can be easily removed from the air, and does not make any chlorine gas in the process. The catalyst is thermally stable and is not poisoned by chlorine or fluorine atoms produced on its surface during the destruction of a halocarbon. In addition, the catalyst can selectively oxidize ammonia to nitrogen at a temperature between 200 and 260 C, without making nitrogen oxides, which are toxic. The temperature of 260 C is higher than the operational temperature of any other precious-metal catalyst that can selectively oxidize ammonia. The purpose of the platinum in this catalyst is to oxidize hydrocarbons and to ensure that the oxidation of halocarbons goes to completion. However, the platinum exhibits little or no activity for initiating the destruction of halocarbons. Instead, the attack on the halocarbons is initiated by the support. The support also provides a high surface area for exposure of the platinum. Moreover, the support resists deactivation or destruction by halogens released during the destruction of halocarbons. The second catalyst is of the supported- metal-oxide type. This catalyst can selectively oxidize ammonia to nitrogen at temperatures up to 400 C, without producing nitrogen oxides. This catalyst converts ammonia completely to nitrogen, even when the concentration of ammonia is very low. No other catalyst is known to oxidize ammonia selectively at such a high temperature and low concentration. Both the metal oxide and the support contribute to the activity and selectivity of this catalyst.
By directly resolving spatial and temporal species distributions within operating honeycomb monolith catalysts, spatially resolved capillary inlet mass spectrometry (SpaciMS) provides a uniquely enabling perspective for advancing automotive catalysis. Specifically, the ability to follow the spatiotemporal evolution of reactions throughout the catalyst is a significant advantage over inlet-and-effluent-limited analysis. Intracatalyst resolution elucidates numerous catalyst details including the network and sequence of reactions, clarifying reaction pathways; the relative rates of different reactions and impacts of operating conditions and catalyst state; and reaction dynamics and intermediate species that exist only within the catalyst. These details provide a better understanding of how the catalyst functions and have basic and practical benefits; e.g., catalyst system design; strategies for on-road catalyst state assessment, control, and on-board diagnostics; and creating robust and accurate predictive catalyst models. Moreover, such spatiotemporally distributed data provide for critical model assessment, and identification of improvement opportunities that might not be apparent from effluent assessment; i.e., while an incorrectly formulated model may provide correct effluent predictions, one that can accurately predict the spatiotemporal evolution of reactions along the catalyst channels will be more robust, accurate, and reliable. In such ways, intracatalyst diagnostics comprehensively enable improved design and development tools, and faster and lower-cost development of more efficient and durable automotive catalyst systems. Beyond these direct contributions, SpaciMS has spawned and been applied to enable other analytical techniques for resolving transient distributed intracatalyst performance. This chapter focuses on SpaciMS applications and associated catalyst insights and improvements, with specific sections related to lean NOx traps, selective catalytic reduction catalysts, oxidation catalysts, and particulate filters. The objective is to promote broader use and development of intracatalyst analytical methods, and thereby expand the insights resulting from this detailed perspective for advancing automotive catalyst technologies.
We investigate grafting of poly(methylhydrosiloxane) (PMHS) onto Ti/SiO 2 catalysts for improving their robustness to water, using olefin epoxidation catalysis with organic hydroperoxide as oxidant as a relevant probe reaction. Our approach involves triggering catalyst deactivation with added water in the reactants as a means to simulate catalyst deactivation, thereby causing grafted Ti-site aggregation. When using harsh aqueous Soxhlet extraction conditions as a trigger for this aggregation, significant differences are observed via diffuse-reflectance UV-Vis spectrscopy on samples before and after treatment, for Ti/SiO 2 catalysts containing grafted PMHS. Not only was there a lack of appearance of red-shifted bands in the UV-Vis spectrum following Soxhlet extraction, the batch catalytic activity for catalysts before and after PMHS grafting remained virtually unchanged. This was in stark contrast to an unmodified Ti/SiO 2 catalyst, which showed a more than 60% decrease in catalytic activity following Soxhlet extraction as a result of aggregation, as ascertained by red shifts in its UV-Vis spectrum after Soxhlet extraction. Similar red shifts were also observed for a hydrophobically modified TMS Ti/SiO 2 catalyst. However, when comparing these catalysts under more gentle olefin epoxidation catalysis conditions with added water in a flow reactor, it was more difficult to differentiate the TMS Ti/SiO2 and grafted PMHS catalysts. Both catalysts exhibited similar activity and selectivity after a prolonged time on stream, though the rate of initial deactivation in the latter was less pronounced. Altogether, our data demonstrate that grafted PMHS catalysts are positively differentiated from conventional catalysts based on either TMS surface modification or no surface modification, under conditions involving aggregation induced via extreme hydrothermal environmentst. Thus, we expect that PMHS grafting of Lewis acid catalysts can offer an alternative approach for endowing hydrolytic stability to such catalysts, as demonstrated here for Ti/SiO 2 epoxidation catalysts.
Proton-exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs) are efficient and clean hydrogen energy technologies for transportation and stationary applications. Highly active and durable low-cost cathode catalysts for the oxygen-reduction reaction (ORR) under challenging acidic environments are desperately needed to address the cost and durability issues of PEMFCs. The most promising platinum group metal (PGM)-free catalysts for the ORR in acidic media are atomically dispersed and nitrogen-coordinated metal site catalysts denoted as M–N–C, M = Fe, Co, or Mn. Due to significant efforts in the past few decades, these catalysts have demonstrated much-improved ORR activity and promising initial fuel cell performance approaching traditional Pt/C catalysts. However, the insufficient long-term stability (up to 5000 h) under PEMFC operation represents a primary technical barrier to making current PGM-free catalysts less viable yet in PEMFCs. In this Account, we highlight recent advances in synthesizing efficient PGM-free catalysts for the ORR in PEMFCs, emphasizing effective strategies to improve mass and intrinsic activity and the possible degradation mechanisms. In particular, a chemical doping method based on the zeolitic imidazolate framework (ZIF)-8 represents the key to developing efficient M–N–C catalysts containing atomically dispersed and nitrogen-coordinated single metal active sites (i.e., MN 4 ). The newly acquired understanding of the formation mechanism of MN 4 active sites during the thermal activation and its correlation to catalytic properties guide the rational catalyst design rather than relying on current trial-and-error approaches. Considerable efforts have further been invested in increasing the active site density and enhancing intrinsic activity by regulating carbon-phase structures and the local coordination environment. Furthermore, these highly active catalysts usually suffer from significant activity loss during the ORR. Therefore, breaking the activity–stability trade-off is the key to simultaneously achieving activity and stability in one catalyst, which is discussed on the basis of our recent successes in regulating local carbon structures surrounding active single metal sites. Significant research efforts toward understanding the degradation mechanisms and improving the lifetime of PGM-free catalysts are still crucial for viable applications in the future. Novel electrode designing strategies are needed to translate the PGM-free catalysts’ ORR activity to solid-state electrolyte-based membrane electrode assemblies (MEAs) with robust three-phase (i.e., gas–liquid–solid) interfaces for efficient charge and mass transports for performance improvement. On the basis of our effort at the University at Buffalo supported by ElectroCat Consortium associated with U.S. DOE’s Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies Office, we provide a perspective on PGM-free cathode catalysts concerning remaining bottlenecks and future opportunities, aiming to inspire the community in both mechanistic understanding and technological development.
PtM (M = 3d transition metals) alloys are known as the promising oxygen reduction reaction catalysts and have been considered as the replacement of pure Pt catalysts for the commercialization of proton exchange membrane fuel cells. Although great progress has been made in the past three decades, the performance and durability of PtM catalysts still face stringent challenges from practical applications. Functionalization of a catalyst carbon support with nitrogen-contained groups can add charges onto its surface, which can be utilized to build a more complete ionomer/catalyst interface, to reduce the catalyst particle size, and to improve particle size distribution. Nitriding of PtNi catalysts can effectively improve the catalyst activity and stability by the modification of lattice strain. Hereby, we propose a synergistic approach of combining polybenzimidazole-grafted Vulcan XC72 carbon as the catalyst carbon support and the nitriding of PtNi to develop PtNiN/XC72-polybenzimidazole catalysts. Such PtNiN/XC72-PBI catalysts exhibit the excellent performance of fuel cell membrane electrode assembly (i.e., mass activity, 440 mA mgPt –1 ; electrochemical surface area, 51 m 2 gPt –1 ; and rated power density, 836 mW cm –2 ) as well as promising catalyst stability. The developed PtNiN/XC72-PBI meets the US DOE 2020 targets of mass activity for the fuel cell catalysts. This work provides a novel approach and a promising pathway on the development of the catalyst using such a synergistic approach-modification of the catalyst structure by nitrogen doping and functionalization of carbon support by polybenzimidazole for both high performance and high durability.
Atmospheric pressure plasma has shown promise in improving thermally activated catalytic reactions through a process termed plasma-catalysis synergy. In this work, we investigated atmospheric pressure plasma jet (APPJ)-assisted CH 4 oxidation over a Ni/SiO 2 .Al 2 O 3 catalyst. Downstream gas-phase products from CH 4 conversion were quantified by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. The catalyst near-surface region was characterized by in-situ diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy. The catalyst was observed to be activated at elevated temperature (500 °C) if it was exposed to the APPJ operated at large plasma power. 'Catalyst activation' signifies that the purely thermal conversion of CH 4 using catalysts which had been pre-exposed to plasma became more intense and produced consistently CO product, even if the plasma was extinguished. Without the application of the APPJ to the Ni catalyst surface this was not observed at 500 °C. The study of different exposure conditions of the activated catalyst indicates that the reduction of the catalyst by the APPJ is likely the cause of the catalyst activation. We also observed a systematic shift of the vibrational frequency of adsorbed CO on Ni catalyst when plasma operating conditions and catalyst temperatures were varied and discussed possible explanations for the observed changes. Furthermore, this work provides insights into the plasma-catalyst interaction, especially catalyst modification in the plasma catalysis process, and potentially demonstrates the possibility of utilizing the surface CO as a local probe to understand the plasma-catalyst interaction and shed light on the complexity of plasma catalysis.
Platinum group metal (PGM) catalysts are the major electrocatalysts for oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) in the polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs). The cost becomes unaffordable if the PEMFC is in massive application. The PGM-Free catalyst shows very promising activity in rotation disk electrode (RDE) testing. The half-wave potential could reach 0.91 V versus standard hydrogen electrode (SHE). However, in a membrane electrode assembly (MEA), the performance of PGM-Free catalysts is not good enough to replace the PGM catalysts. Since the PGM-free catalysts are so different from the PGM catalysts in terms of catalytic activity, stability, surface conditions, particle size, etc., the fabrication of PGM-Free catalyst MEA cannot simply copy the method of making PGM MEA. Here we proposed a novel method of fabricating PGM-Free catalyst MEA, so that the intrinsic catalyst activity from RDE can be translated into MEA performance. The method is based on the catalyst coated membrane (CCM) method using optimized ionomer to carbon (I/C) ratio and solvent mixture of catalyst ink. Using this method, the PGM-free catalyst MEA achieved the current density 44.9 mA cm -2 at 0.9 V iR-free in H 2 /O 2 and 150 mA cm -2 at 0.8 V in H 2 /air, which surpassed the performance targets of US Department of Energy (DOE)for PGM-Free catalyst MEA. The property (solvent composition, dispersion of catalyst and ionomer in an ink), structure (pore structure) and the MEA performance have been characterized using, mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP), MEA testing. A property-structure-performance relationship has been established.
Stabilization and chemical control of transition metal centers is a critical problem in the advancement of heterogeneous catalysts to next-generation catalysts that exhibit high levels of selectivity, while maintaining strong activity and facile catalyst recycling. Supported metal nanoparticle catalysts typically suffer from having a wide range of metal sites with different coordination numbers and varying chemistry. This project is exploring new possibilities in catalysis by combining features of homogeneous catalysts with those of heterogeneous catalysts to develop new, bi-functional systems. The systems are more complex than traditional heterogeneous catalysts in that they utilize sequential active sites to accomplish the desired overall reaction. The interaction of metal—organic catalysts with surface supports and their interactions with reactants to enable the catalysis of critical reactions at lower temperatures are at the focus of this study. Our work targets key fundamental chemistry problems. How do the metal—organic complexes interact with the surface? Can those metal center sites be tuned for selectivity and activity as they are in the homogeneous system by ligand design? What steps are necessary to enable a cooperative chemistry to occur and open opportunities for bi-functional catalyst systems? Study of these systems will develop the concept of bringing together the advantages of heterogeneous catalysis with those of homogeneous catalysis, and take this a step further by pursuing the objective of a bi-functional system. The use of metal-organic complexes in surface catalysts is therefore of interest to create well-defined and highly regular single-site centers. While these are not likely to be stable in the high temperature environments (> 300 °C) typical of industrial heterogeneous catalysts, they could be applied in moderate temperature reactions (100-300 °C), made feasible by lowering reaction temperatures by better catalyst control. They also serve as easily tuned model systems for exploring the chemistry of single-site transition metals and tandem catalysts that could then be developed into a zeolite or other stable support structures. In this final technical report, three major advances our described that further these goals. The first is a study demonstrating the ability to tune the oxidation state of V single-site centers on a surface by design of the surrounding ligand field. The synthesis of the single-site centers was developed in a previous reporting period of this project and this new advance shows a distinct new ability of the systems to have a designed oxidation state of the metal center. Second, we demonstrate metal complexation at surfaces using vibrational spectroscopy and also show a metal replacement reaction on Ag surfaces. Third, we demonstrate a surface-catalyzed dehydrocyclization reaction important for metal-organic catalyst design at surfaces.
Catalysis on transition metal oxides is equivalently important in contrast to that on metal catalysts in chemical and energy transformations. Understanding of catalytic reactions on early transition metal oxide catalysts is fundamentally intriguing and of great practical interest in efficient production of chemical and fuel feedstocks. Fundamental understanding of catalysis on transition metal oxide-based catalysts has been lagged behind catalysis on metals due to the complexity of chemistry and structure of surface and bulk of oxide catalysts and their structural flexibility in reactive environment at high temperatures. The funded DOE project explored surface chemistry of a few reducible oxides including CeO 2 - based, Co 3 O 4 -based, and CoO-based which are significant for heterogeneous catalysis. Through in-situ studies using ambient pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and high pressure scanning tunneling microscopy, we revealed phase transformation, the accompanying changes of surface chemistry and structure, and uncovered their correlations with catalytic activity and selectivity in catalytic reactions including reduction of NO with CO, water-gas shift, and chemical transformations of methane to methanol and acetic acid under mild conditions. Driven by the following two facts, we propose to pursue fundamental understanding of oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane and oxidative coupling of methane on oxide catalysts through both in-situ studies of catalyst surfaces during catalysis and computational studies in the renewal proposal. One driving force is the significance of oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane and oxidative coupling of methane for utilization of earth-abundant, relatively inexpensive energy resource and the urgent needs of efficient chemical processes to generate ethylene from shale gas. The other is that exploration of surface chemistry of oxide catalysts during catalysis has remained challenging though it is critical in deeply understanding catalysis on oxide catalysts and developing oxide-based catalysts toward high selectivity and activity. Therefore, the overall objective of the renewal proposal is to mechanistically understand the oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane and oxidative coupling of methane at a molecular level through building correlations between surface chemistry of catalysts during catalysis and the corresponding catalytic performances, and thus design catalysts with high selectivity and activity for production of ethylene with the guidance achieved from these fundamental studies. Experiments were designed to explore the influences of electronic states of cations supported on substrate oxides, cations of surface of the substrate oxides, and surface lattice oxygen atoms of the substrate oxides on their catalytic selectivity and activity. Surface chemistry, including oxidation state of the surface monomers and cations of substrate oxides and density of oxygen vacancies during catalysis, will be tracked with AP-XPS during catalysis. A correlation between surface chemistry of these catalysts at different temperatures and their corresponding catalytic selectivity for production of ethylene and activity will be built. Computational studies will calculate adsorption energies of reactant molecules and their dissociated species and intermediates on the catalyst surface, search transition states, and simulate reaction pathway close to experimental studies. By integrating the computational studies into these correlations to be built from experimental studies, fundamental understanding of the catalytic mechanisms of oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane and oxidative coupling of methane at a molecular level will be achieved. With these insights, new catalysts with high selectivity and activity will be developed.