Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Analog computation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 505 records · Page 28
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2021

Exploring Explicit Uncertainty for Binary Analysis (EUBA)

Reverse engineering (RE) analysts struggle to address critical questions about the safety of binary code accurately and promptly, and their supporting program analysis tools are simply wrong sometimes. The analysis tools have to approximate in order to provide any information at all, but this means that they introduce uncertainty into their results. And those uncertainties chain from analysis to analysis. We hypothesize that exposing sources, impacts, and control of uncertainty to human binary analysts will allow the analysts to approach their hardest problems with high-powered analytic techniques that they know when to trust. Combining expertise in binary analysis algorithms, human cognition, uncertainty quantification, verification and validation, and visualization, we pursue research that should benefit binary software analysis efforts across the board. We find a strong analogy between RE and exploratory data analysis (EDA); we begin to characterize sources and types of uncertainty found in practice in RE (both in the process and in supporting analyses); we explore a domain-specific focus on uncertainty in pointer analysis, showing that more precise models do help analysts answer small information flow questions faster and more accurately; and we test a general population with domain-general sudoku problems, showing that adding "knobs" to an analysis does not significantly slow down performance. This document describes our explorations in uncertainty in binary analysis.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2022

Cyber-Informed Engineering for Nuclear Reactor Digital Instrumentation and Control

As nuclear reactors transition from analog to digital technology, the benefits of enhanced operational capabilities and improved efficiencies are potentially offset by cyber risks. Cyber-Informed Engineering (CIE) is an approach that can be used by engineers and staff to characterize and reduce new cyber risks in digital instrumentation and control systems. CIE provides guidance that can be applied throughout the entire systems engineering lifecycle, from conceptual design to decommissioning. In addition to outlining the use of CIE in nuclear reactor applications, this chapter provides a brief primer on nuclear reactor instrumentation and control and the associated cyber risks in existing light water reactors as well as the digital technology that will likely be used in future reactor designs and applications.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2024

A Particle-in-Cell Method for Plasmas with a Generalized Momentum Formulation, Part II: Enforcing the Lorenz Gauge Condition

In a previous paper Christlieb et al. (A particle-in-cell method for plasmas with a generalized momentum formulation, part I: Model formulation, 2024), we developed a new particle-in-cell (PIC) method for the relativistic Vlasov–Maxwell system in which the electromagnetic fields and the equations of motion for the particles were cast in terms of scalar and vector potentials through a Hamiltonian formulation. This new method evolved the potentials under the Lorenz gauge using integral equation methods. New methods to construct spatial derivatives of the potentials that converge at the same rates as the fields were also presented. The new particle method was compared against standard explicit discretizations, including the well-known FDTD-PIC method, for a range of applications involving sheaths and particle beams. Here, this paper extends this new class of methods by focusing on the enforcement the Lorenz gauge condition in both exact and approximate forms using co-located meshes. A time-consistency property of the proposed field solver for the vector potential form of Maxwell’s equations is established, which is shown to preserve the equivalence between the semi-discrete Lorenz gauge condition and the analogous semi-discrete continuity equation. Using this property, we present three methods to enforce a semi-discrete gauge condition. The first method introduces an update for the continuity equation that is consistent with the discretization of the Lorenz gauge condition. Both the finite difference and spectral implementations satisfy this discrete gauge condition to machine precision. The second approach we propose enforces a semi-discrete continuity equation using the boundary integral solution to the field equations. The potential benefit of this approach is that it eliminates spatial derivatives that appear on the particle data, namely the current density, which is often calculated by linear combinations of low-order spline basis functions. This method is ideally suited to boundary integral equation methods that invert multi-dimensional operators without dimensional splitting techniques and will be the subject of future work. The third approach introduces a gauge correcting method that makes direct use of the gauge condition to modify the scalar potential and uses local maps for both the charge and current densities. This results in a gauge error, as the maps do not enforce the continuity equation. The vector potential coming from the current density is taken to be exact, and using the Lorenz gauge, we compute a correction to the scalar potential that makes the two potentials satisfy the gauge condition. This method also enforces the gauge condition to machine precision. We demonstrate two of the proposed methods in the context of periodic domains. Problems defined on bounded domains, including those with complex geometric features remain an ongoing effort. However, this work shows that it is possible to design computationally efficient methods that can effectively enforce the Lorenz gauge condition in a non-staggered PIC formulation.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2023

Nearly Periodic Maps and Geometric Integration of Noncanonical Hamiltonian Systems

Abstract M. Kruskal showed that each continuous-time nearly periodic dynamical system admits a formal U (1)-symmetry, generated by the so-called roto-rate. When the nearly periodic system is also Hamiltonian, Noether’s theorem implies the existence of a corresponding adiabatic invariant. We develop a discrete-time analog of Kruskal’s theory. Nearly periodic maps are defined as parameter-dependent diffeomorphisms that limit to rotations along a U (1)-action. When the limiting rotation is non-resonant, these maps admit formal U (1)-symmetries to all orders in perturbation theory. For Hamiltonian nearly periodic maps on exact presymplectic manifolds, we prove that the formal U (1)-symmetry gives rise to a discrete-time adiabatic invariant using a discrete-time extension of Noether’s theorem. When the unperturbed U (1)-orbits are contractible, we also find a discrete-time adiabatic invariant for mappings that are merely presymplectic, rather than Hamiltonian. As an application of the theory, we use it to develop a novel technique for geometric integration of non-canonical Hamiltonian systems on exact symplectic manifolds.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2025

Structure of the Majorana Clifford group

In quantum information science, Clifford operators and stabilizer codes play a central role for systems of qubits (or qudits). In this study, we study their analogs for systems composed of Majorana fermions. In this case, a crucial role is played by fermion parity symmetry, which is an unbreakable symmetry present in any system with fundamentally fermionic degrees of freedom. We prove that the subgroup of parity-preserving Majorana Cliffords can be represented by the orthogonal group over the binary field 𝔽 2 , and we show how it can be generated by braiding operators and used to construct any (even-parity) Majorana stabilizer code. We also analyze the frame potential for this so-called p-Clifford group when acting on a fixed-parity sector of the Hilbert space, proving that it is equivalent to the frame potential of the ordinary Clifford group acting on the same sector.

Computational complexity↗
DOE OSTI2020

Extended families of critical and stationary droplets for nonequilibrium phase transitions in spatially discrete bistable systems

Bistable nonequilibrium systems are realized in catalytic reaction-diffusion processes, biological transport and regulation, spatial epidemics, etc. Behavior in spatially continuous formulations, described at the mean-field level by reaction-diffusion type equations (RDEs), often mimics that of classic equilibrium van der Waals type systems. When accounting for noise, similarities include a discontinuous phase transition at some value, p eq , of a control parameter, p , with metastability and hysteresis around p eq . For each p , there is a unique critical droplet of the more stable phase embedded in the less stable or metastable phase which is stationary (neither shrinking nor growing), and with size diverging as p → p eq . Spatially discrete analogs of these mean-field formulations, described by lattice differential equations (LDEs), are more appropriate for some applications, but have received less attention. It is recognized that LDEs can exhibit richer behavior than RDEs, specifically propagation failure for planar interphases separating distinct phases. Herein, we show that this feature, together with an orientation dependence of planar interface propagation also deriving from spatial discreteness, results in the occurrence of entire families of stationary droplets. The extent of these families increases approaching the transition and can be infinite if propagation failure is realized. In addition, there can exist a regime of generic two-phase coexistence where arbitrarily large droplets of either phase always shrink. Such rich behavior is qualitatively distinct from that for classic nucleation in equilibrium and spatially continuous nonequilibrium systems.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2021

Creation of an unexpected plane of enhanced covalency in cerium(III) and berkelium(III) terpyridyl complexes

Abstract Controlling the properties of heavy element complexes, such as those containing berkelium, is challenging because relativistic effects, spin-orbit and ligand-field splitting, and complex metal-ligand bonding, all dictate the final electronic states of the molecules. While the first two of these are currently beyond experimental control, covalent M‒L interactions could theoretically be boosted through the employment of chelators with large polarizabilities that substantially shift the electron density in the molecules. This theory is tested by ligating Bk III with 4’-(4-nitrophenyl)-2,2’:6’,2”-terpyridine (terpy*), a ligand with a large dipole. The resultant complex, Bk(terpy*)(NO 3 ) 3 (H 2 O)·THF, is benchmarked with its closest electrochemical analog, Ce(terpy*)(NO 3 ) 3 (H 2 O)·THF. Here, we show that enhanced Bk‒N interactions with terpy* are observed as predicted. Unexpectedly, induced polarization by terpy* also creates a plane in the molecules wherein the M‒L bonds trans to terpy* are shorter than anticipated. Moreover, these molecules are highly anisotropic and rhombic EPR spectra for the Ce III complex are reported.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Imaging nanoscale carrier, thermal, and structural dynamics with time-resolved and ultrafast electron energy-loss spectroscopy

Time-resolved and ultrafast electron energy-loss spectroscopy (EELS) is an emerging technique for measuring photoexcited carriers, lattice dynamics, and near-fields across femtosecond to microsecond timescales. When performed in either a specialized scanning transmission electron microscope or ultrafast electron microscope (UEM), time-resolved and ultrafast EELS can directly image charge carriers, lattice vibrations, and heat dissipation following photoexcitation or applied bias. Yet, recent advances in theoretical calculations and electron optics are often required to realize the full potential of ultrafast EEL spectrum imaging. Here, in this review, we present a comprehensive overview of the recent progress in the theory and instrumentation of time-resolved and ultrafast EELS. We begin with an introduction to the technique, followed by a physical description of the loss function. We outline approaches for calculating and interpreting ground-state and transient EEL spectra spanning low-loss plasmons to core-level excitations analogous to x-ray absorption. We then survey the current state of time-resolved and ultrafast EELS techniques beyond photon-induced near-field electron microscopy, highlighting abilities to image carrier and thermal dynamics. Finally, we examine future directions enabled by emerging technologies, including electron beam monochromation, in situ and operando cells, laser-free UEM, and high-speed direct electron detectors. These advances position time-resolved and ultrafast EELS as a critical tool for uncovering nanoscale dynamic processes in quantum materials and solar energy conversion devices.

Computational methods↗
DOE OSTI2020

Improvements to the New CTH Code Verification & Validation Test Suite (FY2020)

The CTH multiphysics hydrocode, which is used for a wide range of important calculations, has undertaken in recent years to overhaul its software quality and testing processes. A key part of this effort entailed building a new, robust V&V test suite made up of traditional hydrocode verification problems, such as those listed in the ASC Tri-Lab Test Suite and the Enhanced Tri-Lab Test Suite, as well as validation problems for some of CTHs most frequently used equations of state, materials models, and other key capabilities. Substantial progress towards this goal was made in FY19. In FY20, this test suite has been expanded to include verification and validation tests of the Sesame and JWL equation of state models as well as the Mader verification problem from the Tri-Lab Test Suite and the Blake verification problem - a linear elastic analog to the Hunter problem from the Enhanced Tri-Lab Test Suite. This report documents CTH performance on the new test suite problems. Verification test results are compared to analytic solutions and, for most tests, convergence results are presented. Validation test results are compared to experimental data and mesh refinement studies are included. CTH performs well overall on the new test problems. Convergence rates for the Blake and Mader problems are comparable to those for similar ASC codes. The JWL and Sesame verification tests show good agreement with analytic solutions. Likewise, CTH simulation results show good agreement with experimental validation data for the Sesame and JWL equations of state for the materials tested. Future V&V work will focus on adding tests for other key capabilities like fracture and high explosive models.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗
DOE OSTI2025

Computational Investigation of the Chemical Bond between An(III) Ions and Soft-Donor Ligands

The chemical bonding of actinide ions with arene and borohydride ligands is explored via quantum chemical methods to understand how the transuranium elements interact with softdonor ligands. Specifically, the [An(C 6 Me 6 )(BH 4 ) 3 ] complexes (An = U, Np, and Pu) and their reduced congeners are studied. Density functional theory (DFT) shows that the metal–ligand interactions in the neutral complexes are governed by electrostatic interactions. Both DFT and complete active space (CASSCF) results show that as one moves from U to Pu, the 5f-orbitals are stabilized leading to a poorer energy match with the ligand orbitals. This contributes to progressively weaker metal-arene and metal-borohydride interactions across the series due to a decrease in energy-driven covalency. A reduction in orbital contributions to bonding is obtained for the transuranium-arene interactions as well. Upon reduction, the arene is reduced, forming a δ-bond. This causes the An–arene distances to contract by 0.1–0.2 Å compared to the neutral complexes. The ground state is assigned as the intermediate-spin state where the arene radical is antiferromagnetically coupled to the metal-centered f-electrons in Np and Pu. On the other hand, the ferromagnetically and antiferromagnetically coupled states are close in energy in the uranium complex, but do not mix when spin– orbit coupling is included using a state-interaction approach (SO-CASPT2). The population of the CASSCF δ*-antibonding natural orbital increases from U to Pu consistent with the increased An–arene distances, weaker interactions, and decreasing covalency across the series. Although the An–B distance increases by ca. 0.06 Å upon reduction, both the neutral and reduced species involve an An(III)–borohydride bond and as such are qualitatively similar. The Np complexes can be assigned to have slightly weaker bonding than the uranium analogs but are overall “uranium-like”. The Pu complexes are predicted to have less covalent contributions to bonding in both the Pu–arene and Pu–borohydride interactions; however, the Pu–arene interaction is predicted to be particularly weak.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

Structural Aspects of Neutron Survival Probabilities

The neutron survival probability (and related quantities including probabilities of extinction and initiation) is a central element of the broader stochastic theory of neutron populations and finds application in fields including reactor start-up, analysis of reactor power bursts and criticality accidents, and safeguards. In a full neutron transport formulation, the equation governing the single-neutron survival probability is a backward or adjoint-like integro-partial differential equation with the added complexity of being highly nonlinear. Analogous formulations of this equation exist in the context of many approximate theories of neutron transport, with the point kinetics formulation having received significant theoretical attention since the 1940s. This work continues this tradition by providing a novel analysis of the single-neutron survival probability equation using the tools of boundary layer theory. The analysis reveals that the “fully dynamic” solution of the single-neutron survival probability equation—and some key probability distributions derived from it—may be cast as a singular perturbation around the underlying quasi-static single-neutron probability of initiation. In this perturbation solution, the expansion parameter is the ratio of the neutron generation time to a macroscopic time scale characterizing the overall system evolution; this interpretation illuminates some of the fundamental structural aspects of neutron survival phenomena.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2024

Asymptotic-preserving gyrokinetic implicit particle-orbit integrator for arbitrary electromagnetic fields

We extend the asymptotic preserving and energy conserving time integrator for charged-particle motion developed in Ricketson and Chacón (2020) to include finite Larmor-radius (FLR) effects in the presence of electric-field length-scales comparable to the particle gyro-radius (the gyro-kinetic limit). We introduce two modifications to the earlier scheme. The first is the explicit gyro-averaging of the electric field at the half time-step, along with an analogous modification to the current deposition, which we show preserves total energy conservation in implicit PIC schemes. The number of gyrophase samples is chosen adaptively, ensuring proper averaging for large timesteps and the recovery of full-orbit dynamics in the small time-step limit. The second modification is an alternating large and small time-step strategy that ensures the particle trajectory samples gyrophases evenly. We show that this strategy relaxes the time-step restrictions on the scheme, allowing even larger speed-ups than previously achievable. We demonstrate the new method with several single-particle motion tests in a variety of electromagnetic field configurations featuring gyro-scale variation in the electric field. Finally, the results demonstrate the advertised ability to capture FLR effects accurately even when significantly stepping over the gyration time-scale.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2025

Chiral population analysis: a real space visualization of X-ray circular dichroism

The microscopic understanding of probing and controlling molecular chirality is of considerable interest. Numerous spectroscopic techniques are capable of monitoring molecular asymmetry and its consequences, ranging from the infrared to the X-ray regime. Resonant X-rays have long been used to investigate local atomic sites within molecules thanks to the localized nature of core electronic transitions. These techniques can be used to determine the extent to which chirality is a local versus a delocalized property. However, how to systematically partition dichroic contributions from the point of view of electronic structure simulations remains an open question. Here, we introduce the concept of chiral population analysis that connects chirality to the atomic orbital picture. In analogy with Mulliken population analysis, which assigns charges to atomic orbitals, chiral populations allow the dichroic response to be distributed among the participating atomic orbitals. This decomposition can be further visualized in real space by representing it in terms of isosurface plots, providing an intuitive way to connect the dichroic response to its origins. Thus chiral population analysis can be particularly useful to assess the extent to which a given electronic transition is sensitive to chirality as a local or global feature of the molecular geometry.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Advanced Reactor Safeguards & Security Program: Cybersecurity Scenarios

The use of digital control systems and automation in advanced nuclear power systems introduces different types of vulnerabilities compared to legacy (i.e. analog) control systems that cyber adversaries can exploit. These vulnerabilities pose a challenge to reactor operators and cyber operations staff due to the dynamic nature of the event in which a human response or a lack of response can potentially evolve into a worsening plant condition. Using the Department of Homeland Security Cyber and Infrastructure Security Agency’s (CISA) critical infrastructure exercise framework, this document presents several cyber security scenarios typical of digital control systems that could be used in advanced reactor designs. These scenarios can be used in tabletop exercises to evaluate cyber security posture or conduct training on different aspects of cyber security, including detection, threat hunting using indicators of compromise, evaluating incident response, risk mitigation, incident reporting, information sharing and recovery.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2023

Importance of Dispersion in the Molecular Geometries of Mn(III) Spin-Crossover Complexes

The computational investigation of the molecular geometries of a pair of manganese(III) spin-crossover complexes is reported. For the geometry of the quintet high-spin state, density functionals significantly overestimate Mn–Namine bond distances, although the geometry for the triplet intermediate-spin state is well described. Here, comparisons with several wave function-based methods demonstrate that this error is due to the limited ability of commonly used density functionals to recover dispersion beyond a certain extent. Among the methods employed for geometry optimization, restricted open-shell Møller–Plesset perturbation theory (MP2) appropriately describes the high-spin geometry but results in a slightly shorter Mn–O distance in both spin states. On the other hand, extended multistate complete active space second-order perturbation theory (XMS-CASPT2) provides a good description of the geometry for the intermediate-spin state but also sufficiently recovers dispersion, performing well for the high-spin state. Despite the fact that the electronic structure of both spin states is dominated by one-electron configuration, XMS-CASPT2 offers a balanced approach, leading to molecular geometries with much better agreement with experiment than MP2 and DFT. A scan along the Mn–N amine bond demonstrates that for these complexes coupled cluster methods (i.e., DLPNO-CCSD(T)) also yield bond distances in agreement with experiment while multiconfiguration pair density functional theory (MC-PDFT) is unable to recover dispersion well enough, analogous to single-reference DFT.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2021

Low-order preconditioning of the Stokes equations

A well-known strategy for building effective preconditioners for higher-order discretizations of some PDEs, such as Poisson's equation, is to leverage effective preconditioners for their low-order analogs. In this work, we show that high-quality preconditioners can also be derived for the Taylor–Hood discretization of the Stokes equations in much the same manner. In particular, we investigate the use of geometric multigrid based on the Q 1 iso Q 2 /Q 1 discretization of the Stokes operator as a preconditioner for the Q 2 /Q 1 discretization of the Stokes system. We utilize local Fourier analysis to optimize the damping parameters for Vanka and Braess–Sarazin relaxation schemes and to achieve robust convergence. Furthermore, these results are then verified and compared against the measured multigrid performance. While geometric multigrid can be applied directly to the Q 2 /Q 1 system, our ultimate motivation is to apply algebraic multigrid within solvers for Q 2 /Q 1 systems via the Q 1 iso Q 2 /Q 1 discretization, which will be considered in a companion paper.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2020

Losses of CO and CO 2 upon collision-activated dissociation of substituted 2-methoxyphenoxides after methyl radical loss

Some deprotonated, substituted 2-methoxyphenols fragment by methyl radical loss followed by competing losses of CO and CO 2 upon collisional activation in linear quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometers. These reactions were examined experimentally and computationally in order to determine their mechanisms. For deprotonated vanillin, the CO loss was found to involve ring contraction, with the highest free energy barrier of 58.0 kcal mol -1 (for the syn rotamer; here, syn refers to the relationship between the aldehyde oxygen atom and the oxygen atom of the methoxy group) for the entire process. The atoms lost in this fragmentation are the oxygen atom that was bound to the first eliminated methyl group and the aromatic carbon atom bound to this oxygen. Examination of carbon-13 labeled vanillin supports these assignments. Examination of several model compounds revealed that this reaction requires the presence of an electron-withdrawing substituent in the para-position relative to the phenol moiety. In contrast, the CO 2 loss from deprotonated vanillin occurs via ring opening followed by re-cyclization and then ring contraction, leading to the loss of CO 2 in a process wherein the highest free energy barrier is 84.5 kcal mol -1 (for the syn isomer). The atoms lost in this fragmentation are the carbon and oxygen atoms from the phenoxide group and the oxygen atom that was bound to the first eliminated methyl group, which is supported by examination of carbon-13 labeled vanillin. Despite the higher total free energy requirement, the CO 2 loss is competitive with CO loss, possibly due to favorable entropy and low activation energy (free energy barrier of 48.9 kcal mol -1 ) for the first reaction step (the analogous value for CO loss is 58.0 kcal mol -1 ). The extent of CO 2 loss is strongly affected by substituents – it either is not observed or is very slow for the other compounds studied here. For example, it is substantially less favorable than CO loss (highest free energy barrier 60.9 kcal mol -1 ) for deprotonated acetovanillone for which the first reaction step for CO 2 loss has a substantially greater free energy barrier (60.6 kcal mol-1) than for vanillin.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗
DOE OSTI2026

Itinerant Magnetism in Hydride-Synthesized CaCo 12 B 6

A new compound in the underexplored Ca–Co–B phase space has been discovered, validating high-throughput computations from the Open Quantum Materials Database, which predicted thermodynamic stability for CaCo 12 B 6 in the SrNi 12 B 6 structure type. The synthetic effects of different boron precursors and the advantages of using CaH 2 instead of Ca metal were demonstrated by the short synthesis duration and high purity of CaCo 12 B 6 , in contrast with traditional synthesis routes. Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) confirmed that CaCo 12 B 6 shares the SrNi 12 B 6 structure ( R $\bar{3}$m (#166), a = 9.469(4) Å, c = 7.468(2) Å, Z = 3) and is water- and air-stable. High-temperature in situ PXRD indicates that CaCo 12 B 6 is stable below 1050 K under vacuum in a silica capillary. CaCo 12 B 6 decomposes between 693 and 773 K during spark-plasma sintering. Density functional theory calculations indicate that CaCo 12 B 6 is metallic with a ferromagnetic ground state. X-ray absorption near-edge spectroscopy and Bader charge analysis indicate that Co atoms in CaCo 12 B 6 lack ionic character. Magnetometry reveals room-temperature paramagnetism with μ eff = 1.7(1)μ B per Co atom and a Weiss constant of +190(10)K. Ferromagnetic ordering occurs below 172(1)K, resulting in a saturation moment of 0.46 μ B per Co atom. Our findings demonstrate that the hydride route is a viable strategy for discovery of new ternary alkaline-earth-transition metal borides analogous to rare-earth-containing counterparts.

diffraction↗