Strategies to Recover Easily-Extractable Rare Earth Elements and Other Critical Metals from Coal Waste Streams and Adjacent Rock Strata Using Citric Acid
Maximum rare earth element (REE) extractability from a sample of Middle Kittanning coal seam underclay was previously demonstrated at ~30% of the total REE content with a citric acid solution (Montross et al., 2020). This report further refines the mechanisms of citrate application for leaching of coal seam underclays using an organic acid lixiviant and evaluates strategies to begin to scale this process to industrially relevant volumes. This study evaluates the suitability of citrate leaching solutions for downstream recovery and separation of the REEs via oxalic acid precipitation. The applicability of citric acid solutions to recover ion-adsorbed metals from clay surfaces was evaluated by leaching a prepared sample of kaolinite with known amounts of ion-adsorbed lanthanum. Citrate systematics was further defined through experiments varying the solution pH. Up-scaling investigations proceeded with percolation leaching columns and stirred tank reactors. Two embodiments were run in percolation leaching: a continuous flow-through process and a multi-stage saturated process. The results showed that in certain limited scenarios, low pH citrate solutions could be used to target REEs mineralized within secondary calcium phosphate minerals. Results from the upscaling attempts encountered difficulties in extraction efficiencies. For the percolation columns, hydrodynamic flow was insufficient to recover the extractable REE content fully. For the stirred barrels, mixing inefficiencies likely inhibited the extractability of the REEs. Oxalic acid precipitation experiments also highlighted difficulties in downstream operations. The REEs were removed from the citrate solution with high efficiency, but were accompanied by equally efficient removal of calcium in orders of magnitude of greater amounts. Overall, for citrate leaching to be effective, future studies will have to: 1) carefully consider the feedstock application (i.e., likely better suited for secondary mineralization of calcium phosphate minerals), and 2) overcome the technical barriers of large-scale processing, such as inefficient hydrodynamic regimes due to small crush sizes needed and difficulties in downstream separation and purification. Alternatively, citrate solutions may be better recommended as leaching amendments to other leaching solutions to enhance REE complexation in the solution.