Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “observables”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 469 records · Page 26
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2020

Direct Observation of Electron Beam-Induced Phase Transition in MgCrMnO 4

Irreversible structural transformation in intercalation-type cathode materials, which has been frequently observed, has been perceived as a principal cause of capacity fading and voltage decay in (uni) multivalent batteries. Herein, we explored the electron beam-induced spinel to defective rocksalt phase transitions in MgCrMnO 4 , a potential multivalent cation intercalation cathode, using atomic-resolution imaging and spectroscopy in an aberration-corrected scanning transmission electron microscope. This dynamic electron beam irradiation study of specific structural transformations provides an atomistic understanding of the structural evolution observed in transition-metal oxide spinels during electrochemical cycling using multivalent cations, such as Mg 2+ . By combining an imaging study with first-principles modeling, we demonstrate that the mechanism of the spinel to defective rocksalt transformation in MgCrMnO 4 nanostructures is enabled by the presence of oxygen vacancies and is, therefore, very similar to that observed in transition-metal oxide spinels upon Li intercalation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Observations of Nocturnal Sulfuric Acid Formation in Pittsburgh, PA

Measurements of sulfuric acid (H 2 SO 4 ) and sulfur trioxide (SO 3 ) were conducted in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, during field campaigns in Fall 2023 and Fall 2024. These measurements identified nocturnal concentrations of H 2 SO 4 comparable to those of daytime values. Nocturnal H 2 SO 4 concentrations were observed to increase by 5 × 10 5 to 5 × 10 7 molecules cm –3 above background on 16 of the 31 measurement nights. The median peak concentration during events was 6.5 × 10 6 molecules cm –3 , with a maximum of 1.0 × 10 8 molecules cm –3 , exceeding previously reported nighttime concentrations. Increases in H 2 SO 4 concentrations were positively correlated with the anomalously high SO 3 concentrations and condensation sink rates, indicating that the formation of H 2 SO 4 increased to overcome the loss rates to particles. Increases in particulate mass and the mass fraction of metals commonly emitted from coal combustion and steel production were also observed. The air masses were traced back to the southeast of Pittsburgh, a region home to a steel mill, coke plant, and a steel processing plant. The observations indicate a previously unrecognized nighttime formation pathway for H 2 SO 4 , potentially from heterogeneous catalysis with metal or black carbon, originating from steel and coke plant emissions. Further measurements are needed to identify key compounds and chemical processes driving these increases in nocturnal H 2 SO 4 concentrations.

aerosols↗
DOE OSTI2025

Direct Observation of 2DEG States in Shallow Si:Sb δ-Layers

We investigate the electronic structure of high-density layers of Sb dopants in a silicon host, so-called Si:Sb δ-layers. We show that, in spite of the known challenges in producing highly confined Sb δ-layers, sufficient confinement is created such that the lowest conduction band states (Γ states, studied in depth in other silicon δ-layers), become occupied and can be observed using angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy. The electronic structure of the Si:Sb δ-layers closely resembles that of Si:P systems, where the observed conduction band is near-parabolic and slightly anisotropic in the k ∥ plane. The observed Γ state extends ∼1 nm in the out-of-plane direction, which is slightly wider than the 1/3 monolayer thick dopant distribution. This is caused by a small segregation of the dopant layer, which is nevertheless minimal when comparing with earlier published attempts. Our results serve to demonstrate that Sb is still a feasible dopant alternative for use in the semiconductor δ-layer platform, providing similar electronic functionality to Si:P systems. Additionally, it has the advantages of being less expensive, more controllable, safer to handle, and more compatible with industrial patterning techniques. Si:Sb is therefore a viable platform for emerging quantum device applications.

Deposition↗
DOE OSTI2021

Observation of Conformational Simplification upon N-methylation on Amino Acid Iodide Clusters

This work reports a surprising observation that methylation of glycine-iodide cluster leads to less conformations and spectroscopic simplicity. We used cryogenic “iodide-tagging” negative ion photoelectron spectroscopy (NIPES) to probe specific binding sites of three N-methylated glycine derivatives, i.e., N-methylglycine (sarcosine, Sar), N,N-dimethylglycine (Dmg), and N,N,N-trimethylglycine (glycine betaine, Bet). NIPES reveals a progressive spectral simplification of the iodide clusters with increasing methylation due to the presence of fewer contributing structures, a reduction in the number of NH and OH hydrogen bond donating sites, and an increase in the basicity of the amine. Low energy conformers and tautomers of each cluster are computationally identified, and those observed in the experiments are assigned based on excellent agreement between the NIPE spectra and theoretical simulations. Clusters with zwitterionic structures for Gly, Sar, and Dmg are found to be less stable than their canonical forms and do not contribute to the observed spectra. This work demonstrates the power of “iodide-tagging” NIPES in probing conformational and tautomeric structures of amino acid-iodide clusters and provides a molecular level understanding on the effect of methyl substitution on the active binding sites of amino acids.

Cao, Wenjin↗
DOE OSTI2022

Observation of Core-Excited Dipole-Bound States

Polar molecules can bind an electron in a diffuse orbital due to the charge-dipole interaction. Electronic excited states of polar molecules can also bind an electron to form core-excited dipole-bound states (DBSs), analogous to core-excited Rydberg states. However, core-excited DBSs have not been observed because of the complicated electronic structure of molecular systems. Here we report the observation of a core-excited DBS in the pyrazolide anion as a result of the favorable electronic structure of the neutral pyrazolyl core, which has a low-lying excited state ($\tilde{A}$ 2 B 1 ) only 266 cm -1 above its ground state ($\tilde{X}$ 2 A 2 ). The binding energy of the DBS associated with the ground state is measured to be 221 cm -1 , while that of the core-excited DBS is 276 cm -1 , which is still a bound state relative to the detachment threshold. Furthermore, vibrational Feshbach resonances are observed for both DBSs and their autodetachment behaviors are studied by resonant photoelectron imaging.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Direct Observation of the ππ* to nπ* Transition in 2-Thiouracil via Time-Resolved NEXAFS Spectroscopy

The photophysics of nucleobases has been the subject of both theoretical and experimental studies over the past decades due to the challenges posed by resolving the steps of their radiationless relaxation dynamics, which cannot be described in the framework of the Born–Oppenheimer approximation (BOA). In this context, the ultrafast dynamics of 2-thiouracil has been investigated with a time-resolved NEXAFS study at the Free Electron Laser FLASH. Near Edge X-ray Absorption Fine Structure spectroscopy (NEXAFS) can be used to observe electronic transitions in ultrafast molecular relaxation. We performed time-resolved UV-pump/X-ray probe absorption measurements at the sulfur 2s (L1) and 2p (L2/3) edges. We are able to identify absorption features corresponding to the S2 (ππ*) and S1 (nπ*) electronic states. We observe a delay of 102 ± 11 fs in the population of the nπ* state with respect to the initial optical excitation and interpret the delay as the time scale for the S2 → S1 internal conversion. We furthermore identify oscillations in the absorption signal that match a similar observation in our previous X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy study on the same molecule.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Observation of a Symmetry-Forbidden Excited Quadrupole-Bound State

In this paper, we report the observation of a symmetry-forbidden excited quadrupole-bound state (QBS) in the tetracyanobenzene anion (TCNB - ) using both photoelectron and photodetachment spectroscopies of cryogenically-cooled anions. The electron affinity of TCNB is accurately measured as 2.4695 eV. Photodetachment spectroscopy of TCNB - reveals selected symmetry-allowed vibronic transitions to the QBS, but the ground vibrational state was not observed because the transition from the ground state of TCNB - (A u symmetry) to the QBS (Ag symmetry) is triply-forbidden by the electric and magnetic dipoles, and the electric quadrupole. The binding energy of the QBS is found to be 0.2206 eV, which is unusually large due to strong correlation and polarization effects. A centrifugal barrier is observed for near-threshold autodetachment, as well as relaxations from the QBS vibronic levels to the ground and a valence excited state of TCNB - . The current study shows a rare example where symmetry selection rules, rather than the Franck-Condon principle, govern vibronic transitions to a non-valence state in an anion.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Photo-scanning Electrochemical Microscopy Observation of Overall Water Splitting at a Single Aluminum-Doped Strontium Titanium Oxide Microcrystal

Particulate photocatalysts for the overall water-splitting (OWS) reaction offer promise as devices for hydrogen fuel generation. Even though such photocatalysts have been studied for nearly five decades, much of the understanding of their function is derived from observations of catalyst ensembles and macroscopic photoelectrodes. This is because the sub-micrometer size of most OWS photocatalysts makes spatially resolved measurements of their local reactivity very difficult. Here we employ photo-scanning electrochemical microscopy (photo-SECM) to quantitatively measure hydrogen and oxygen evolution at individual OWS photocatalyst particles for the first time. Micrometer-sized Al-doped SrTiO 3 /Rh 2-y Cr y O 3 photocatalyst particles were immobilized on a glass substrate and interrogated with a chemically modified SECM nanotip. The tip simultaneously served as a light guide to illuminate the photocatalyst and as an electrochemical nanoprobe to observe oxygen and hydrogen fluxes from OWS. Local O 2 and H 2 fluxes obtained from chopped light experiments and photo-SECM approach curves using a COMSOL Multiphysics finite-element model confirmed stoichiometric H 2 /O 2 evolution of 9.3/4.6 μmol cm -2 h -1 with no observable lag during chopped illumination cycles. Additionally, photoelectrochemical experiments on a single microcrystal attached to a nanoelectrode tip revealed a strong light intensity dependence of the OWS reaction. Here these results provide the first confirmation of OWS at single micrometer-sized photocatalyst particles. The developed experimental approach is an important step towards assessing the activity of photocatalyst particles at the nanometer scale.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2023

In Situ Structural Observation of a Substrate- and Peroxide-Bound High-Spin Ferric-Hydroperoxo Intermediate in the P450 Enzyme CYP121

The P450 enzyme CYP121 from Mycobacterium tuberculosis catalyzes a carbon–carbon (C–C) bond coupling cyclization of the dityrosine substrate containing a diketopiperazine ring, cyclo(l-tyrosine-l-tyrosine) (cYY). An unusual high-spin (S = 5/2) ferric intermediate maximizes its population in less than 5 ms in the rapid freeze-quenching study of CYP121 during the shunt reaction with peracetic acid or hydrogen peroxide in acetic acid solution. Here, we show that this intermediate can also be observed in the crystalline state by EPR spectroscopy. By developing an on-demand-rapid-mixing method for time-resolved serial femtosecond crystallography with X-ray free-electron laser (tr-SFX-XFEL) technology covering the millisecond time domain and without freezing, we structurally monitored the reaction in situ at room temperature. After a 200 ms peracetic acid reaction with the cocrystallized enzyme–substrate microcrystal slurry, a ferric-hydroperoxo intermediate is observed, and its structure is determined at 1.85 Å resolution. The structure shows a hydroperoxyl ligand between the heme and the native substrate, cYY. The oxygen atoms of the hydroperoxo are 2.5 and 3.2 Å from the iron ion. The end-on binding ligand adopts a near-side-on geometry and is weakly associated with the iron ion, causing the unusual high-spin state. This compound 0 intermediate, spectroscopically and structurally observed during the catalytic shunt pathway, reveals a unique binding mode that deviates from the end-on compound 0 intermediates in other heme enzymes. The hydroperoxyl ligand is only 2.9 Å from the bound cYY, suggesting an active oxidant role of the intermediate for direct substrate oxidation in the nonhydroxylation C–C bond coupling chemistry.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Observation of Slow Eigen-Zundel Interconversion in H + (H 2 O) 6 Clusters upon Isomer-Selective Vibrational Excitation and Buffer Gas Cooling in a Cryogenic Ion Trap

The formation of isomers when trapping floppy cluster ions in a temperature-controlled ion trap is a generally observed phenomenon. This involves collisional quenching of the ions initially formed at high temperature by buffer gas cooling until their internal energies fall below the barriers in the potential energy surface that separate them. Here we explore the kinetics at play in the case of the two isomers adopted by the H + (H 2 O) 6 cluster ion that differ in the proton accommodation motif. One of these is most like the Eigen cation with a tricoordinated hydronium motif (denoted E), and the other is most like the Zundel ion with the proton equally shared between two water molecules (denoted Z). After initial cooling to about 20 K in the radiofrequency (Paul) trap, the relative populations of these two spectroscopically distinct isomers are abruptly changed through isomer-selective photoexcitation of bands in the OH stretching region with a pulsed (~6 ns) infrared laser while the ions are in the trap. We then monitor the relaxation of the vibrationally excited clusters and reformation of the two cold isomers by recording infrared photodissociation spectra with a second IR laser as a function of delay time from the initial excitation. The latter spectra are obtained after ejecting the trapped ions into a time-of-flight photofragmentation mass spectrometer, thus enabling long (~0.1 s) delay times. Excitation of the Z isomer is observed to display long-lived vibrationally excited states that are collisionally cooled on a ms time scale, some of which quench into the E isomer. These excited E species then display spontaneous interconversion to the Z form on a ~10 ms time scale. Furthermore, these qualitative observations set the stage for a series of experimental measurements that can provide quantitative benchmarks for theoretical simulations of cluster dynamics and the potential energy surfaces that underlie them.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Observations of Greenhouse Gas Changes across Summer Frontal Boundaries in the Eastern United States

Our knowledge about synoptic-scale variations of atmospheric CO2 produced by interactions between mid-latitude cyclones and regional-scale surface fluxes remains limited by scarcity of observations. We synthesize observations of greenhouse gases (GHG) with respect to frontal passages to understand how GHG distributions change vertically and horizontally during a synoptic event. We use the airborne in-situ measurements of GHGs collected during the first Atmospheric Carbon and Transport–America (ACT) summer field campaign across three regions of the eastern US. We find that frontal structures are consistently and clearly associated with spatially coherent, significant changes in GHG composition. Warm sector CO2 mole fractions (henceforth, [CO2]) are significantly higher than those in the cold sector. The CO2 frontal differences (5-30 ppm) are largest in the atmospheric boundary layer (ABL) with smaller differences (3-5 ppm) in the free troposphere (FT). Bands of elevated CO2 (5-20 ppm enhancement compared to warm-sector mean [CO2]) repeatedly occurred in the ABL adjacent to the frontal boundary. Analyses of 84 vertical profiles reveal higher [CO2] in the FT than in the ABL in the cold-sector, the opposite pattern in the warm-sector. Average ABL-to-FT [CO2] differences are 12 ppm and -6 ppm in the warm and cold sectors, respectively. The same analysis for CH4 shows higher [CH4] in the ABL than in the FT in both warm and cold sectors with at least 30-ppb higher ABL-to-FT [CH4] differences in the warm-sector than in the cold-sector. The observational analyses presented here define new metrics for model evaluation of GHG transport.

Pal, Sandip↗
DOE OSTI2020

Fine-Scale Variability of Observed and Simulated Surface Albedo Over the Southern Great Plains

Surface albedo can be highly variable in both space and time. The Department of Energy’s Holistic Interactions of Shallow Clouds, Aerosols, and Land-Ecosystems (HI-SCALE) field study provides a unique opportunity to characterize the variability over the Southern Great Plains of the United States using integrated tower, aircraft, and satellite observations of the surface albedo and Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI). The primary advantage of the aircraft and satellite observations is the ability to examine the spatial distribution of surface albedo and NDVI over a large area, while the tower measurements have the ability to examine both diurnal and day-to-day variability at a single location. In general, consistency was found between both the broadband (BB) albedo and NDVI measured from the surface, air and space. There was a small increase from 0.186 to 0.194 in the aircraft BB surface albedo between May and September (about 4% change), while the MODIS black-sky BB surface albedo increased from 0.151 to 0.166 over the same period (about 10% change) while the standard deviations in the aircraft and MODIS BB albedo were similar. The largest seasonal differences in both the aircraft BB albedo and NDVI were found for areas with winter wheat or forest, while areas with pasture or grasses showed a smaller seasonal diversity. The Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) model was used to simulate the BB surface albedo. In comparison with the aircraft and satellite observations, the WRF-simulated BB surface albedo had no seasonal change and a much narrower distribution.

Berg, Larry K.↗
DOE OSTI2020

Infrasound and Gravity Waves Over the Andes Observed by a Pressure Sensor on Board a Stratospheric Balloon

The study of infrasound (acoustic) and gravity waves sources and propagation in the atmosphere of a planet gives us precious insight on atmosphere dynamics, climate, and even internal structure. The implementation of modern pressure sensors with high rate sampling on stratospheric balloons is improving their study. In our work we analyzed the data from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration Ultra Long Duration Balloon mission (16 May to 30 June 2016). Here, we focus on the balloon's transit of the Andes Mountains. We detected gravity waves that are associated to troposphere convective activity and mountain waves. An increase of the horizontal wavelengths from 50 to 70 km with increasing distance to the mountains is favoring the presence of mountain waves. We also report on the detection of infrasounds generated by the mountains in the 0.01–0.1 Hz range with a pressure amplitude increase by a factor 2 relative background signal. Besides, we characterized the decrease of microbaroms power when the balloon was flying away from the ocean coast. These observations suggest, in a way similar to microseisms for seismometers, that microbaroms are the main background noise sources recorded in the stratosphere even far from the ocean sources. Finally, we observed a broadband signal above the Andes, between 0.45 and 2 Hz, probably associated with a thunderstorm. The diversity of geophysical phenomena captured in less than a day of observation stresses the interest of high rate pressure sensors on board long-duration balloon missions.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2021

Observations of Density Cavities and Associated Warm Ion Flux Enhancements in the Inner Magnetosphere

We present a statistical study of density cavities observed in the inner magnetosphere by the Van Allen Probes during four one-month periods: February 2013, July 2013, January 2014, and June 2014. These periods were chosen to allow the survey of all magnetic local times. We find that density cavities are a recurrent feature of the density profiles of in situ measurements in the inner magnetosphere. We further investigate the correlation between the density cavities and the enhancement of fluxes of warm ions with energies of 10–100 eV. The results show that warm ion flux enhancements associated with the density cavities were observed more frequently for H + , then for He + and the least frequently for O + . The occurrences of the associated flux enhancements were increased when considering only the cavities inside the plasmasphere. Possible mechanisms responsible for the observed warm ion flux enhancements and the role of density cavities on these ion flux enhancements are discussed.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2020

Anisotropic Electron Fluid Closure Validated by in Situ Spacecraft Observations in the far Exhaust of Guide-field Reconnection

Anisotropic electron heating predictions of the equations of state of Le et al. (2009); https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.102.085001 (“the EoS”) are applied to reconnection in the Earth's magnetosheath. The model is applicable to open systems where electrons are streaming along magnetic field lines into the reconnection region, sourced by fixed external reservoirs of plasma ambient to the reconnection region. While spacecraft observations have previously shown the EoS to hold in the region near the X-line, we find that for an event observed far downstream (~100 d i ) from the X-line both inflows and the exhaust follow the predictions of the EoS. Furthermore, the model underlying the EoS is extended to include additional perpendicular heating terms relevant to the considered event undergoing active magnetic compression with local electron trapping. Finally, the agreement between the spacecraft observations and the EoS emphasizes the roles of the ambient plasma sources and the dynamics of trapped and passing electrons in setting and controlling the anisotropic electron heating at large scale in naturally occurring plasma configurations.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2021

Close Observation of Hydraulic Fracturing at EGS Collab Experiment 1: Fracture Trajectory, Microseismic Interpretations, and the Role of Natural Fractures

Abstract Despite the wide application of hydraulic fracturing in enhanced geothermal system (EGS) development and unconventional hydrocarbon production, our understanding of the many factors affecting the propagation of hydraulic fractures has relied on circumstantial evidence. This is partly due to the scarcity of direct observations in the subsurface. The EGS Collab project attempts to address these issues in the context of EGS research by performing intermediate‐scale (∼10 m) hydraulic stimulation experiments in a thoroughly characterized and heavily instrumented underground testbed. This paper analyzes the data collected from the first suite of hydraulic fracturing tests in this testbed, consisting of seven stimulation episodes. High‐quality microseismic data delineate five planar features very clearly. Combining fracture‐wellbore intersection observations from distributed temperature sensing (DTS) and visual observations from an open‐hole well, as well as prior in‐situ stress measurements, we conclude with high certainty that the four larger planes were hydraulic fractures. The growth of the hydraulic fractures was temporarily halted by a prominent, open natural fracture in the testbed but they eventually crossed and slightly reoriented under continued stimulation. Mineral‐filled (i.e., healed) natural fractures, though prevalent in the testbed, did not have perceivable effects on hydraulic fracture propagation. The high‐quality, mutually corroborating data sets allowed conclusions to be drawn with high confidence and attests to the advantage of intermediate‐scale experiments in subsurface research.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2022

Reconciling Observed and Predicted Tropical Rainforest OH Concentrations

We present OH observations made in Amazonas, Brazil during the Green Ocean Amazon campaign (GoAmazon2014/5) from February to March of 2014. The average diurnal variation of OH peaked with a midday (10:00–15:00) average of 1.0 × 10 6 (±0.6 × 10 6 ) molecules cm -3 . This was substantially lower than previously reported in other tropical forest photochemical environments (2–5 × 10 6 molecules cm -3 ) while the simulated OH reactivity was lower. The observational data set was used to constrain a box model to examine how well current photochemical reaction mechanisms can simulate observed OH. We used one near-explicit mechanism (MCM v3.3.1) and four condensed mechanisms (i.e., RACM2, MOZART-T1, CB05, CB6r2) to simulate OH. A total of 14 days of analysis shows that all five chemical mechanisms were able to explain the measured OH within instrumental uncertainty of 40% during the campaign in the Amazonian rainforest environment. Future studies are required using more reliable NO x and VOC measurements to further investigate discrepancies in our understanding of the radical chemistry in the tropical rainforest.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2021

Comparing Satellite- and Ground-Based Observations of Cloud Occurrence Over High Southern Latitudes

The 2B-CLDCLASS-LIDAR R05 (2BCL5) and the raDAR/liDAR (DARDAR) satellite retrievals of cloud occurrence are compared as a function of altitude and latitude. The largest disparities are observed at low altitudes over high southern latitudes. These data sets are cross referenced to ground-based measurements from the Atmospheric Radiation Measurement (ARM) West Antarctic Radiation Experiment (AWARE) campaign at McMurdo Station, Antarctica. Compared with AWARE observations, both 2BCL5 and DARDAR underestimate cloud occurrence below 1.5 km, with 2BCL5 and DARDAR distinguishing roughly one third of cloud occurrences observed by AWARE at 0.5 km. While DARDAR identifies greater cloud occurrences than 2BCL5 below 1.5 km, cloud occurrence values for the two data sets have similar differences relative to ground-based measurements. Therefore, the DARDAR retrievals of greater cloud occurrence at low altitudes are likely due to a larger quantity of false positives associated with radar ground clutter or attenuated lidar retrievals. DARDAR cloud occurrences match better with AWARE than 2BCL5 above 5 km. However, the likely underestimation of ground-based measurements at higher altitudes suggests DARDAR may underestimate high level cloud occurrence. Finally, both data sets indicate the presence of liquid containing clouds at temperatures within the homogeneous freezing regime, despite the fact that the ECMWF-AUX data set implemented in their processing clearly indicates temperatures below -38°C. Finally, using AWARE radiosonde (ECMWF-AUX) temperature data, we find that 2BCL5 detects 13.3% (13.8%) of mixed phase clouds below -38°C, while DARDAR detects 5.7% (6.6%) of mixed phase and 1.1% (1.3%) of liquid phase clouds below -38°C.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗