Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “EOR”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 469 records · Page 26

Risk Assessment using Certification Framework (SECARB Phase III Work Product 3.1.1b)

The Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership (SECARB) Phase III 1.5 million tonne CO 2 sequestration project is taking place on the eastern side of an oilfield in southwestern Mississippi in the so-called High Volume Injection Test area (HiVIT). The source of CO 2 for the project is the natural CO 2 reservoir at Jackson Dome, Mississippi. We apply the Certification Framework (CF) approach to assess the risk of CO 2 and brine leakage from the deep reservoir to various compartments where impacts could occur. The large depth (~10,000 ft, 3,050 m) of the Tuscaloosa Formation reservoir, presence of extensive thick marine mudstone confining zone, and well-known geology, among other factors, tend to minimize the likelihood of leakage. On the other hand, the large number of plugged and abandoned (P&A) wells provides potential flow paths for leakage upward to potable aquifers and potentially to the ground surface. A review of site characteristics relevant to leakage risk, simulation of the CO 2 injection, and modeling of performance of P&A wells is presented to demonstrate the application of the Certification Framework (CF) for leakage risk assessment in the context of an enhance Oil Recovery (EOR) project.

02 PETROLEUM↗

SECARB Phase III Anthropogenic Test Project Environmental Information Volume

The Southern State Energy Board (SSEB) manages the Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership (SECARB) and acknowledges the support of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) in a field demonstration project that is the subject of this Environmental Information Volume (EIV). SECARB is proposing to conduct a large-scale demonstration of the technology to sequester carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) originating from anthropogenic sources, referred to as the “Phase III Anthropogenic Test Characterization Project” (SECARB Phase III Project or Project). Federal funding will be committed by the DOE-NETL for the field work contemplated and, therefore, the SECARB team is providing information contained in this EIV as technical support information. The Project, as proposed by SSEB, will be located within the Southeast Unit of the Citronelle Oilfield (Citronelle Field) in Mobile County, Alabama. This oilfield unit is ideally suited for the study because no CO 2 enhanced oil recovery (EOR) floods have occurred locally and it has exceptional geologic containment strata. Additionally the study participants have the resources and expertise necessary to manage this type of injection and related downhole technology. The proposed Project will consist of the installation of a new injection well and a new characterization well, and the use of four previously installed wells that will be retrofitted for monitoring activities. Two shallow (600 foot) groundwater monitoring wells will also be drilled on existing well pads.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Install or Extend Additional Infrastructure (SECARB Work Product 6.1.b)

Infrastructure needs at the SECARB “early” Cranfield test are different from many other CCS sites, because this test is strongly supported by the commercial activities of site host Denbury Onshore LLC. Commercial development by Denbury provided the substantive cost-share required to make the project viable. Denbury contributions fundamental for the project included the retrofit of the former Sonat natural gas pipeline from the Jackson Dome CO 2 source to the center of Cranfield Field, construction of distributory pipelines to take CO 2 to injection wells, and construction of roads and well pads that allowed access for drilling and maintenance of injection wells. In addition, as part of the EOR operations, Denbury constructed a CO 2 separation plant to increase pressure from pipeline pressure to field pressure and support CO 2 recycle, construction of production lines to bring oil, water, CO 2 and gas to the separation plant, and worked over plugged and abandoned (P&A) wells to retrofit them as producers. Producers were used by the SECARB project as monitoring points to observe flood. Denbury’s well test facility allowed monthly quantification of the volumes of fluids produced and reinjected.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership (SECARB) Revised Monitoring Plan

This report summarizes the revisions made after attainment of project metrics of monitoring 1.5 million metric tons stored which occurred at 1 ½ years and after the end of the period of accelerated injection rate (February 2011) to reach project metrics. Denbury continues downdip injection because of its impact on production, but has modified the rate of injection to meet its EOR objectives. Therefore this project will not have a post-injection “closure” period. Injected CO 2 is being recycled and the flow field is substantively controlled by production. However, a period of observation of this long duration storage has value to the program in terms of showing no impact on near-surface environments and monitoring any changes in the reservoir over the long term. In addition, observations made during the first two years of injection have raised a number of significant questions that can be addressed during the next stages of research. Lastly, budget readjustment is needed, as some tasks have gone over budget and some have been completed under budget, leaving some opportunities to address remaining issues. This report provides an overview of the revisions and supplements proposed to the modeling and monitoring plan to complete the project.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

SECARB Semi-Annual Field Review Reports - Early Test

The Southern States Energy Board (SSEB) managed the overall Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership (SECARB) Phase III project and The Bureau of Economic Geology (BEG), at the University of Texas at Austin, managed all activities associated with the Early Test field site near Cranfield, Mississippi (the Early Test or Cranfield Project). BEG was assisted in the management of site activities by Sandia Technologies (Sandia). BEG and Sandia implemented reporting procedures that included monthly and quarterly technical progress reports, as well as periodic reporting on key field activities. Subsequent sections of this report catalog the field activities and are organized in a semiannual chronology. The Cranfield Project was located approximately 12 miles east of Natchez, Mississippi. Denbury Onshore, LLC, began operating a commercial CO 2 flood of the field (using the subsurface injection of CO 2 for EOR) in June 2008. Carbon dioxide from the Jackson Dome, a natural source near Jackson, Mississippi, was delivered to the Cranfield oilfield via pipeline. Beginning in October 2008, the SECARB Early Test team characterized the surface and subsurface of the Cranfield site. During the field test CO 2 was injected into the lower Tuscaloosa Formation, a regionally extensive saline formation with the potential to hold millions of tons of CO 2 emissions. By January 2015, the team injected more than 11 million metric tons of CO 2 and monitored a total stored CO 2 mass of 5,326,975 metric tons. SECARB’s study operations occurred in four integrated research program areas within Cranfield field: (1) the High Volume Injection Test area (HiVIT); (2) the Detailed Area of Study (DAS); (3) the Geomechanical area; and (4) the near-surface observatory, also called the “P-site.” Carbon dioxide injection activities were conducted at the HiVIT and the DAS. Figure 1.1-1 provides a depiction of the DAS.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Information Products & Communications Materials including Presentations [Slides]

Contents include the following: 1) Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership (SECARB), Carbon Capture and Storage Conference, November 13, 2007; 2) Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership (SECARB) Eighth Annual Conference, May 5, 2009; 3) Evaluating CO 2 Storage Options in the Southeast, April 8, 2010; 4) Tenth Annual Conference on Carbon Capture and Sequestration, May 4, 2011; 5) Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership Presented to Research Experience in Carbon Sequestration, June 4, 2012; 6) Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership Highlights and Recent Developments, December 4, 2012; 7) Experience from Major CCUS Projects in the USA, August 13, 2013; 8) The SECARB Integrated CO 2 Capture, Transportation and Storage Project, November 17, 2014; 9) Geophysical Methods for CO 2 Leak Detection and Plume Monitoring at the SECARB Anthropogenic Test Site Near Citronelle, Alabama, December 15, 2015; 10) Southeast Regional Carbon Sequestration Partnership (SECARB) 2017 Partnership Update, September 20, 2017; 11) SSEB Perspectives on Carbon Management Policies, Regulatory Issues, and Projects, December 4, 2017; and 12) Expanding a process-based soil gas method to identify industrial signals at CO 2 -EOR sites, October 23, 2018.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Using Machine Learning to Identify Optimum Prospects for Offshore Geologic CO 2 Storage and Enhanced Oil Recovery in the Gulf of Mexico

The SECARB Offshore Partnership is a government-industry partnership focused on assembling the knowledge base required for secure, long-term, large-scale CO 2 subsea storage in saline formations and mature oil reservoirs. The SECARB Offshore Partnership is evaluating potential storage opportunities in the Central and Eastern planning areas of the outer continental shelf (OCS) of the Gulf of Mexico. The evaluation focuses on active and depleted oil and gas fields and potentially associated CO 2 -enhanced oil recovery (CO 2 -EOR), as well as, deep saline storage resources. As part of Subtask 3.0 (Offshore Storage Resources Characterization) and Subtask 4.0 (Risk Assessment, Simulation, and Modeling), Oklahoma State University (OSU) is developing a machine learning system that employs the SAS Institute’s Viya platform with visual data mining and machine learning to identify and characterize optimum prospects for enhanced oil recovery and stacked storage in saline reservoirs. This report summarizes this effort to date and discusses the many variables that can be used to characterize these storage objectives, as well as, the design vision of the Viya machine learning system.

02 PETROLEUM↗

CO 2 Storage Site Screening Platform Development and CO 2 Storage Resource Analysis in SECARB Offshore Reservoirs Using SAS Viya

A major goal of the SECARB Offshore Partnership (DE-FE0031557) is to screen deep saline aquifers and hydrocarbon reservoirs in the central Gulf of Mexico for CO 2 sequestration and CO 2 -enhanced oil and gas recovery (EOR/EGR) and estimate the corresponding CO 2 storage resources for select reservoirs. CO 2 storage potential associated with offshore CO 2 -EOR is considerable and likely represents “low hanging fruit” for near-term CO 2 storage given the in-place infrastructure in the region. It is for these reasons that this assessment focuses on oil and gas fields. To this end, three major objectives have been completed and include (1) managing geological data derived from different sources, (2) building a reservoir screening platform for CO 2 storage, and (3) ranking the reservoirs based on the estimated CO 2 storage resources. The SAS ® Viya platform was used for data management and analytics. The Viya platform is a cloud service platform that provides data integration, data management, quick analytics, data visualization, machine learning functions, and application programming interfaces (APIs) for multi-programming languages. Different sources of data containing geologic information, reservoir properties, and EOR/EGR information were collected, cleaned, formatted, and loaded into the SAS ® Viya platform for evaluation. The major geological characteristics of both shelf and deep-water areas of the central Gulf were examined and compared to define the appropriate reservoir screening criteria. Next, a CO 2 storage site screening system was built in the SAS ® Viya platform with the pre-defined criteria. Finally, the CO 2 storage resources of the screened reservoirs were calculated and reported at the BOEM field level to identify fields with the highest estimated CO 2 storage resource. The fields with the largest total estimated CO 2 storage resource are located in the Mississippi Canyon protraction area. Due to proximity to the Mississippi Delta (indicative of less infrastructure) and large estimated CO 2 storage resources, future development activities may wish to focus efforts in the Mississippi Canyon protraction area.

02 PETROLEUM↗

SECARB-USA: A Sub-Basin Framework for Future CO 2 Infrastructure Development

Task 4 of the SECARB-USA Project is designed to evaluate the regional needs and challenges for the development of a safe and environmentally sound CO 2 transport infrastructure. This infrastructure would transport CO 2 capture from power generating plants and/or industrial sources and distribute it to oil fields for associated storage in EOR operations, saline storage, and/or other suitable storage sites. The objective of this report on Sub-Basin Prospective Areas (Deliverable 4.1.a), is to provide the framework for understanding how regional infrastructure development could occur. The sub-basin prospective areas, in conjunction with the locations of CO 2 sources and pipeline infrastructure (for source-sink matching networks), form the basis for the analysis that will be performed in the Techno-Economic Analysis of Infrastructure Buildout Scenarios (Deliverable 4.1.b).

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Review of Analogous Basins

Sedimentary basins comprise extensive porous sandstone and carbonate reservoirs capable of hosting economically significant greenfield and brownfield residual oil zones (ROZs). Several basins in the United States, including the intracratonic Illinois Basin (ILB), have stacked, predominantly siliciclastic ROZs that are potential targets for tertiary recovery of petroleum and for storing large volumes of anthropogenic carbon in the subsurface. The rocks in these basins share facies and depositional settings with many reservoirs that have already been major producers in primary production and, in some cases, as carbon dioxide enhanced oil recovery (CO 2 -EOR)targets. The lessons learned from field data collection and testing of these intervals in a basin like the ILB have broad applications to analogous basins with potential ROZs.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Devising a framework to Couple Electromagnetic Geophysical Measurements with Reservoir Simulations to Monitor CO2 Plume Movement

Monitoring CO2 plume movement and extent is critical to any CO2 utilization and storage (CCUS) project but can present significant challenges. Downhole measurements (such as cross-well seismic) can give the resolution needed to track the CO2 plume. That resolution comes at a significant expense in equipment and lost production time, and the resolution is only in the vicinity of that well. Surface seismic is less expensive but has decreasing resolution with depth and may not be sensitive to changes in the CO2 plume. Conversely, electrical conductivity has been shown to be correlated with changes in phase saturation associated with CCUS operations. A novel approach for subsurface monitoring that can be applied with minimal expense and operation disruption is charged wellbore casing controlled-source electromagnetics (CWC-CSEM). This technique injects electrical current into two legacy wells. Surface measurements of the induced electric and magnetic fields are obtained with distributed data loggers. Time-lapse measurements are sensitive to changes in CO2 plume movement, but inversion requires the application of prior knowledge from prior characterization efforts. We propose a methodology where simulations are used to inform CWC-CSEM inversion while simultaneously being validated. As such, uncertainty is reduced, and more robust flow models can be devised. A three-year study is underway at the Bell Creek Field in southeast Montana (DOE-NETL Project DE-FE0028320) to evaluate the effectiveness of CWC-CSEM on an active CO2-EOR operation. Determining the relationship between electrical resistivity and phase saturations, and coupling that to a reservoir model is the thrust of this project. Initially, the relative permeability/capillary pressure relationship and the compositional oil model were identified as model parameters with high uncertainty. To elucidate the impact of these uncertain parameters, simulations were run for ten years with a single five-spot pattern. Final water saturation distributions were converted into resistivity using Archie’s Law and available fluid sampling data to provide an exploration of the time lapse electromagnetic anomaly which can be anticipated using CWC-CSEM methods. This technique has promise as an inexpensive and accurate way to monitor CO2 injection in a CCUS site.

Moodie, Nathan↗

Bell Creek Test Site: 3-D Seismic and Characterization Report

The Plains CO 2 Reduction (PCOR) Partnership, led by the Energy & Environmental Research Center (EERC), is working with Denbury Onshore (Denbury) to evaluate the effectiveness of large-scale injection of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) into the Bell Creek oil field for CO 2 enhanced oil recovery (EOR) and to study long-term incidental CO 2 storage. A technical team that includes Denbury, the EERC, and others are conducting activities to determine the baseline reservoir characteristics for development of a geologic model for predictive simulations and to serve as a comparison to time-lapse data as they are acquired. One of the activities was the acquisition and interpretation of a baseline three-dimensional (3-D) surface seismic survey acquired over a major portion of the field which is the subject of this report. The interpretation will be used to advance the field characterization effort. The geophysical data will be integrated with the EERC’s geologic model to improve its accuracy. In the future, when paired with at least one subsequent 3-D surface seismic survey, the data difference will provide a direct indication of where the CO 2 has migrated within the reservoir and aid in monitoring, verification, and accounting goals.

02 PETROLEUM↗

CO 2 Intermediate Storage (CIS) Concept Overview

The objective of this overview is to provide a comprehensive set of qualitative considerations to inform future quantitative technical and economic CIS analyses. This overview focuses on CO 2 EOR as the end-user for CCUS supply chains that might implement CIS.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Intermountain West Energy Sustainability & Transitions Initiative: CO 2 Transport and Geologic Storage Modeling Results

This report and its associated Excel spreadsheet file provide the results of technoeconomic modeling of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) pipeline transport modeling, CO 2 storage in deep saline subsurface formations, and CO 2 enhanced oil recovery (EOR). This report provides the methodology, describes the models and summarizes results for the three aspects of the analysis done for the Intermountain West Energy Sustainability and Transition (I-WEST) Initiative.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Improving Subsurface Stress Characterization for Carbon Dioxide Storage Projects by Incorporating Machine Learning Techniques

The overall objective of this project is to develop a framework for reliable characterization and prediction of the state of stress in the overburden and underburden (including the basement) in CO 2 storage reservoirs using machine learning and integrated geomechanics and geophysical methods. Specifically, we propose to develop workflow encompassing of technologies and/or methods to predict stress and pressure changes due to CO 2 injection in an active tertiary recovery site and their impacts on subtle fault activation, fractures and occurrence of microseismic events and compare responses to field observations. In this project, we anticipate using dataset from the Farnsworth field Unit (FWU) which is operated by Purdure Petroleum. A novel elastic-waveform VSP inversion technique will be used to estimate high-resolution spatial and temporal changes of elastic moduli in CO 2 storage reservoirs, which will be combined with velocity-stress relationship derived from laboratory tests to obtain subsurface pressure and stress. Clustered microseismic data will be jointly inverted for improved focal mechanisms. Least-squares reverse-time migration of microseismic waveform data will be performed to directly image fracture/fault zones. Additionally, a deep neural network machine learning technique with convolutional and recurrent layers will be used for learning the spectro-temporal structures in microseismic waveforms. The results of this geotechnical data analysis will be integrated to develop a high-resolution 3D mechanical earth model extending from the overburden sealing formations to the underburden including the basement. Mechanical properties will be derived through integration of mechanical logs, tests, available results from chemo-mechanical laboratory tests, and elastic inversion of seismic data using a combination of Bayesian and stochastic methods as well as machine learning technique. Failure features (faults/fractures) will be represented and/or modeled based on seismic and core data analysis. A transient hydrodynamic-geomechanical model will be developed through coupling with the calibrated FWU reservoir simulation model. The full physics coupled model will be used to train a reduced order proxy model using machine learning algorithm for estimating stress which will then be used with appropriate constitutive relationships and forward seismological models to simulate pressure changes and induced microseismicity. An advanced optimization framework will be developed to perform a history match to minimize error between field observations and simulated. The history matched proxy model will be verified against the full-physics equivalent. The field observations that will be used in the coupled model calibration process include pressure/stress inverted from VSP, moment magnitude from microseismic analysis, real time downhole pressure measurements, production and injection data. Parameter sensitivity and uncertainty analysis will be performed to characterize the impact of model parameter uncertainty on stress estimates. The proposed project will have significant impact on future field implementation of the proposed technology. Because the project field site is an ongoing CO 2 EOR development, the value of the new technology will be demonstrated in an operational context and evaluated as a viable risk mitigation strategy. Cost/benefit will be evaluated together with the various commercial incentives for CO 2 sequestration available to oil and gas operators. The extensive available dataset and ongoing data acquisition under the SWP Phase III work plan provides flexibility for investigation of multiple approaches and reduces technical risk.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Front-End Engineering and Design: Project Tundra Carbon Capture System (Final Report)

As the next phase of Project Tundra, Minnkota Power Cooperative (MPC) completed a front-end engineering and design (FEED) study to install a post-combustion CO 2 capture system (CCS) at the MPC operated (Square Butte Electric Cooperative-owned) Milton R. Young Station (MRYS) Unit 2 (MRY2), a 477-MW power plant fueled by North Dakota lignite. The project team completed the FEED with Fluor’s Econamine FG Plus℠ (EFG+) technology and is taking the next steps leading up to start of construction. Team members included FEED technical lead Fluor Enterprises (Fluor); owner’s engineer and balance of plant (BOP) engineer Burns & McDonnell (BMcD); leading carbon capture consultants (David Greeson Consulting, Hunt International Energy Services); environmental consultants (AECOM, Agora Environmental), other BOP engineering consultants (Golder Associates, Nels); cost-share funding agency, the North Dakota Industrial Commission (NDIC); and the Energy & Environmental Research Center (EERC). Project Tundra’s goal is to implement carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) in North Dakota, while preserving the use of lignite. Future options could lead to revitalizing legacy oil fields and creating a new CO 2 enhanced oil recovery (EOR) industry. The topic of this report is the FEED study for the carbon dioxide capture portion of Project Tundra. Building on the findings of a pre-FEED study for MRY2, the key deliverables contained in this FEED study are: a) design, costing, and performance data needed to commence project financing activities; b) engineering and material balances required to file for all project permits; and c) a final project schedule. Based on the results of the previous pre-FEED study, MPC and its team evaluated two options to provide the large amount of steam needed to operate the CCS: 1) installation of new natural gas package boilers and a new pipeline to supply natural gas to the facility and 2) extraction of steam from the existing MRYS steam turbine generator. The FEED study was performed using the package boilers option, as it was deemed to have the lowest technical risk, overall cost, and cost uncertainty. A key feature of the design, however, was the mixing the natural gas boilers’ flue gas with the MRY2 flue gas. This increased the size of the CCS system. This design also enabled the tie-in of Unit 1 flue gas for times when Unit 2 is offline. The CCS was designed to capture a combined 12,978 short tons per day (STPD) of CO 2 from the flue gases produced by the existing MRY Unit 2 along with flue gas produced by the new boiler package within the CCS. The 12,978 STPD CO 2 capture is achieved by normally processing 100% of the total available MRY Unit 2 flue gas (considering full load operation) and 100% of the boiler package flue gas, then removing 90% of the CO 2 available from the processed flue gas streams.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Onshore U.S. Carbon Pipeline Deployment: Siting, Safety, and Regulation

Carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) technology has significant potential to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and mitigate the impact of climate change, particularly in hard to decarbonize industrial and commercial sectors. CCUS involves capturing carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) from industrial processes or power generation and utilizing it for other purposes, such as enhanced oil recovery (EOR), or storing the captured CO 2 underground. CCUS technology can reduce the environmental impact of continued fossil fuel use while smoothing the transition to a low-carbon economy. CCUS can create new economic opportunities, such as the development of new industries and job creation, and can enhance energy security by diversifying energy sources. For these reasons, enabling CCUS has become a key objective of the Biden-Harris administration’s clean energy policy and has received bipartisan support. Despite its environmental and economic potential, CCUS faces multiple barriers to widespread deployment. One of the main challenges is the high cost and technical difficulty of implementing and operating large-scale CCUS infrastructure. CCUS remains a relatively expensive way to reduce carbon emissions (e.g., compared to solar photovoltaic technology’s displacement of coal generation). Additionally, financial incentives and supportive policies like those enacted to support solar photovoltaic development, especially at the state level, are inconsistent or nonexistent, which can discourage investment in CCUS projects. There are also technical challenges associated with safe and secure underground CO 2 storage and the development of new carbon utilization technologies. Public opposition to various aspects of CCUS technologies, ranging from concerns that CCUS will extend reliance on fossil fuels to CCUS infrastructure being sited in disadvantaged communities, is a growing challenge. This paper focuses on another significant barrier to broad CCUS deployment: the need for considerable expansion of the dedicated land-based CO 2 pipeline network in the United States to meet CCUS goals and the unique regulatory challenges to its development. To reach carbon emissions targets in the United States by 2050, CCUS technology will need to be supported by tens of thousands of miles of CO 2 pipelines. Estimates range from a minimum of roughly 29,000 pipeline miles (according to a 2020 Great Plains Institute study) to 66,000 pipeline miles (as per a 2021 Princeton University–led study). As of October 2022, however, the U.S. Department of Transportation (U.S. DOT) reports fewer than 5,400 miles of U.S. pipelines carrying CO 2 . This deficit—and what it means for the prospect of moving substantially larger quantities of CO 2 from source to use or storage—threatens to stifle the development of CCUS projects and technologies identified as an important tool to meet emissions targets. The current regulatory landscape facing CO 2 pipeline development can best be described as uncertain. At the federal level, the U.S. DOT Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) oversees safety regulation of pipelines transporting hazardous materials, including CO 2 upon commencement of operation. However, PHMSA’s definition of CO 2 as “a fluid consisting of more than 90 percent CO 2 molecules compressed to a supercritical state” has not been updated since its 1991 addition to the Federal Register. Because CO 2 can be transported in a gaseous, liquid, or supercritical state (indeed, the physical state of CO 2 can fluctuate within a single pipeline due to environmental changes), doubts persist about the extent of PHMSA’s purview—and raise questions about what, if anything, states should do to address this apparent gap. PHMSA has begun a major revision of its existing rules, but the agency does not expect a first draft before 2024. Economic oversight of CO 2 pipelines is even less clear. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) and Surface Transportation Board (STB)—which regulate the rates of interstate oil/natural gas and non-energy pipelines, respectively—have both declined jurisdiction over interstate CO 2 pipelines. This presumably leaves economic regulation to state and/or local governments, but few if any states have the laws or resources in place to oversee just and reasonable rates. Further, the interstate nature of CO 2 pipeline development creates questions around how different states should align their rate-making decisions. Onshore U.S. Carbon Pipeline Deployment: Siting, Safety, and Regulation Currently, regulatory responsibilities regarding CO 2 pipeline siting and permitting fall to state and local governments. The variety of laws and regulations across the country, however, creates a maze of requirements for pipeline developers to navigate. To secure necessary permits, most states require pipeline companies to be “common carriers” that provide transport service to the public at uniform rates. However, the specific definition of that term varies. Some states require clear evidence that a pipeline services the public, while others automatically deem any pipeline company transporting energy products or hazardous materials to be a “common carrier”—with little consideration for accessibility to third parties. Other states have eschewed common-carrier terminology entirely, placing private and publicly accessible pipelines on equal footing. Much like the variation in common-carrier requirements, laws governing eminent domain authority to secure rights-of-way (ROW) to commence construction on a planned pipeline route differ by state. Several states have no laws or rules governing CO 2 pipelines. In addition to creating questions about whether long-standing rules for other pipelines (e.g., natural gas or petroleum products) apply to CO 2 , this policy vacuum leaves local governments as the sole authority over sections of pipe within their boundaries. With dozens of counties along a given route, the probability of inconsistent regulation of the same pipeline is significant. Even in states with CO 2 pipeline laws in place, local regulatory attempts to address rising concerns over pipeline routing and safety have triggered lawsuits by pipeline companies seeking to delimit areas of federal, state, and local government responsibility. Meanwhile, legislators across the country have introduced bills to restrict the application of eminent domain to CO 2 pipeline projects, which could threaten a key means of securing ROW that companies cannot secure through negotiation with landowners. Taken separately, any of these regulatory issues—the narrow federal definition of CO 2 , FERC’s and STB’s decisions that CO 2 pipelines are not within their jurisdiction, and the considerable variation in state and local governments’ laws regulating CO 2 pipeline technologies—are extremely difficult to resolve. Adding the required scale of CO 2 pipeline expansion and the currently identified narrow window of time in which to reach climate target goals, the task becomes even more difficult—and raises a host of urgent questions for regulators. How should CO 2 be defined in federal regulations to ensure consistent safety standards across the country? What is the potential impact radius of a CO 2 pipeline rupture, and how should that inform local emergency response? In the absence of centralized federal oversight, what should state legislatures do to increase alignment for interstate CO 2 pipeline projects? This paper intends to serve as a primer for regulators and stakeholders who seek to better understand the regulatory challenges and opportunities facing this critical infrastructure.

42 ENGINEERING↗