Chrysler Upset Protrusion Joining Techniques for Joining Dissimilar Metals
The project goal was to develop and demonstrate a robust, cost effective, and versatile joining technique, known as Upset Protrusion Joining (UPJ), for joining challenging dissimilar metal com-binations, especially those where one of the metals is a die cast magnesium (Mg) component. Since two of the key obstacles preventing more widespread use of light metals (especially in high volume automotive applications) are 1) a lack of robust joining techniques and 2) susceptibility to galvanic corrosion, and since the majority of the joint combinations evaluated in this project include die cast Mg (the lightest structural metal) as one of the two materials being joined, and since die casting is the most common and cost effective process for producing Mg components, then successful project completion provides a key enabler to high volume application of lightweight materials, thus potentially leading to reduced costs, and encouraging implementation of lightweight multi-material vehicles for significant reductions in energy consumption and reduced greenhouse gas emissions. Eco-nomic benefits to end-use consumers are achieved primarily via the reduction in fuel consumption. Unlike currently available commercial processes, the UPJ process relies on a very robust mechanical joint rather than intermetallic bonding, so the more cathodic material can be coated prior to joining, thus creating a robust isolation against galvanic attack on the more anodic material. Additionally, since the UPJ protrusion is going through a hole that can be pre-drilled or pre-punched prior to coating, the UPJ process is less likely to damage the coating when the joint is being made. Further-more, since there is no additional cathodic material (such as a steel fastener) used to create the joint, there is no joining induced galvanic activity beyond that of the two parent materials. In accordance with its originally proposed plan, this project has successfully developed process variants of UPJ to enable joining of Mg die castings to aluminum (Al) and steel sheet components of various thicknesses, strengths and coating configurations. While most development focused on the simpler round boss version of the process, an additional phase of the work focused on devel-opment of an oval boss version to support applications with narrow flanges, while yet another vari-ant of the process, known as Upset Cast Riveting (UCR), was developed and evaluated for joining mixed metals that may not necessarily include Mg or Al die cast components. Although each varia-tion posed unique challenges described later in the report, all variations were successfully produced and evaluated, and each could be further developed for specific types of commercial applications. In this project, UPJ performed favorably against the benchmark self-pierce riveting (SPR) process in Mg AM60B to Al 6013 combinations although significant corrosion challenges were observed in both processes, especially for the bare Mg to bare Al configurations. Additional challenges were observed in joining Mg to steel with the UPJ process (SPR was not evaluated for this combination as it was not considered viable). To pass FCA’s specified corrosion tests with Mg/steel combina-tions, new steel treatments were evaluated, as well as adhesives and sealed edges. These showed significant improvement. In general, UPJ performed very well in Mg to Al 6016 combinations, even in corrosion evaluation of the bare Mg to bare Al configuration (again, SPR was not evaluated for this material combination as the 1.1 mm thick Al6016 sheet thickness was considered too thin for the SPR process). The improvement in corrosion performance of the Mg to Al 6016 combina-tion over the Mg to Al 6013 combination was thought to be a result of the lower copper content in the Al 6016 alloy. Oval boss joints showed substantial improvement in all joint strength criteria compared to 8.0-mm diameter round boss joints but were not evaluated for corrosion performance. The improved joint strength is likely a result of larger shear area. Cosmetic corrosion performance of all test assemblies (UPJ, UCR and SPR) was a challenge due to exposed edges and crevices al-lowing undercutting of the coatings. In real world component applications, the exposed edges, so prevalent on the joining test coupons, would be less prevalent and easier to protect.