Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Benchmarks”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 433 records · Page 24

Benchmark Evaluation of Fuel Effect and Material Worth Measurements for a Beryllium-Reflected Space Reactor Mockup

The critical configuration of the small, compact critical assembly (SCCA) experiments performed at the Oak Ridge Critical Experiments Facility (ORCEF) in 1962-1965 have been evaluated as acceptable benchmark experiments for inclusion in the International Handbook of Evaluated Criticality Safety Benchmark Experiments. The initial intent of these experiments was to support the design of the Medium Power Reactor Experiment (MPRE) program, whose purpose was to study "power plants for the production of electrical power in space vehicles." The third configuration in this series of experiments was a beryllium-reflected assembly of stainless-steel-clad, highly enriched uranium (HEU)-O 2 fuel mockup of a potassium-cooled space power reactor. Reactivity measurements cadmium ratio spectral measurements and fission rate measurements were measured through the core and top reflector. Fuel effect worth measurements and neutron moderating and absorbing material worths were also measured in the assembly fuel region. The cadmium ratios, fission rate, and worth measurements were evaluated for inclusion in the International Handbook of Evaluated Criticality Safety Benchmark Experiments. The fuel tube effect and neutron moderating and absorbing material worth measurements are the focus of this paper. Additionally, a measurement of the worth of potassium filling the core region was performed but has not yet been evaluated Pellets of 93.15 wt.% enriched uranium dioxide (UO 2 ) were stacked in 30.48 cm tall stainless steel fuel tubes (0.3 cm tall end caps). Each fuel tube had 26 pellets with a total mass of 295.8 g UO 2 per tube. 253 tubes were arranged in 1.506-cm triangular lattice. An additional 7-tube cluster critical configuration was also measured but not used for any physics measurements. The core was surrounded on all side by a beryllium reflector. The fuel effect worths were measured by removing fuel tubes at various radius. An accident scenario was also simulated by moving outward twenty fuel rods from the periphery of the core so they were touching the core tank. The change in the system reactivity when the fuel tube(s) were removed/moved compared with the base configuration was the worth of the fuel tubes or accident scenario. The worth of neutron absorbing and moderating materials was measured by inserting material rods into the core at regular intervals or placing lids at the top of the core tank. Stainless steel 347, tungsten, niobium, polyethylene, graphite, boron carbide, aluminum and cadmium rods and/or lid worths were all measured. The change in the system reactivity when a material was inserted into the core is the worth of the material.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Analysis Capability and Data Needs Identified During the Evaluation of the SILENE CAAS Benchmarks

In October 2010, a series of benchmark experiments was conducted at the Commissariat à l’Énergie Atomique et aux Énergies Alternatives (CEA) Valduc SILENE facility. These experiments were a joint effort between the US Department of Energy (DOE) and the French CEA to create three benchmarks for verification and validation of radiation transport codes, as well as evaluated nuclear data, used to analyze criticality accident alarm systems (CAASs). Many preliminary details of these experiments and their evaluation have been discussed in previous publications. The first benchmark evaluation was published in 2015, and the second and third evaluations will be published at the end of 2016.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

A ONE-WAY COUPLED FAST BURST REACTOR BENCHMARK THROUGH LAPLACE TRANSFORM

In several previous publications, a slab Fast Burst Reactor (FBR), characterized by four non-linear coupled transient conservation equations for the neutron flux ?, material density and displacement ?, u and temperature T, is considered. In this work, before addressing a simplified benchmark version, we revisit the consistency of the four conservation equations. We then develop a One-Way Coupled (OWC) high precision linear benchmark in preparation for full FBR non-linear multiphysics. As will be shown, the importance of the OWC benchmark enables a direct comparison with a MOOSE? based simulation.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Bare, Complex, and Potassium-Filled HEU Oralloy Annuli Benchmark Experiments

Hundreds of critical experiments were constructed from Oak Ridge Alloy (oralloy) during the 1960s and 1970s at the Oak Ridge Critical Experiments Facility (ORCEF) in support of criticality safety operations at the Y-12 Plant. The purpose of these experiments included the evaluation of storage, casting, and handling limits and providing data for verification of calculation methods and cross sections for nuclear criticality safety applications. Recent contributions to the International Handbook of Evaluated Criticality Safety Benchmark Experiments (ICSBEP Handbook) include bare, complex, and potassium-filled annuli comprising multiple stacked units of highly enriched uranium (HEU), ~93.2 wt.% 235U, annuli, discs, and parallelepipeds. Prior contributions to the ICSBEP Handbook include bare (unreflected and unmoderated) cylinders; configurations of cylinders and annuli reflected with polyethylene, beryllium, or thin-graphite reflectors; GROTESQUE; and ORSphere. The newest contributions include a bare HEU 11-7 (11 inch outer diameter and 7 inch inner diameter) annulus capped at the top and bottom; bare HEU 13-7, 15-7, and 15-9 annuli; bare HEU complex annuli consisting of a 15-9 annulus containing either an off-center 7-inch-diameter cylinder, 5 × 5 inch parallelepiped, or split parallelepiped; and an HEU 13-7 annulus containing either empty stainless steel cans or potassium-metal-filled cans. The purpose of this latter pair of annulus configurations was to test the fast neutron cross sections of potassium as it was a candidate for coolant in some early space power reactor designs. A total of nine new configurations were evaluated as acceptable benchmark experiment measurements. Additional ORCEF oralloy experiments have also been identified for future benchmark evaluation.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

DEVELOPMENT OF A VERIFICATION BENCHMARK SUITE FOR THE ATR REACTOR PHYSICS UPGRADE

The result of a numerical algorithm is only as good as the effort made toward its verification. Comprehensive computer codes, especially for application to nuclear reactors, require in-depth assessment of the numerical methods used and their computational implementation. This presentation describes a suite of semi-analytical benchmarks for the ATR Reactor Physics Upgrade as part of the ATR Life Extension Project (LEP). Several neutron transport codes including deterministic codes HELIOS, NEWT and probabilistic codes MCNP6, SERPANT and MC21 are upgrade candidates. To properly evaluate code performance capabilities, code verification is an essential element. A credible verification program requires education to guide proper application, training in proper input preparation and output expectation and verification to instill confidence in the coded numerical procedures. The subset of the benchmark suite to be described here is primarily of the 1D transport variety (however, a 2D case does indeed exist) with the intent to provide unquestionably high order accurate semi-analytical numerical solutions to the transport equation. We base the analytical solutions on analytical Fourier series and discrete ordinates representations. Here we present two 1D benchmarks based on Fourier series.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Preliminary Chlorine Worth Study Benchmark Evaluation

The Chlorine Worth Studies (CWS) experiments with polyvinyl chloride (PVC with chemical formula (C 2 H 3 Cl) n ), chlorinated polyvinyl chloride (CPVC with chemical formula (C 9 H 11 Cl 7 ) n ), and high density polyethylene (HDPE with chemical formula (CH 2 ) n ) were a series of measurements performed at the National Criticality Experiments Research Center (NCERC). The purpose of the CWS experiments was to perform integral experiments that were highly sensitive to the thermal 35 Cl(n,γ) reaction and matched the sensitivities of aqueous chloride operations at the plutonium facility at Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL). The CWS experiments were performed on the Planet critical assembly machine at NCERC and utilized weapons grade plutonium (WGPu) plates as fuel. The design process and design of the CWS experiment were discussed previously. This paper discusses the benchmark evaluation of the experiment, intended for the International Criticality Safety Benchmark Evaluation Project (ICSBEP). Criticality calculations were performed with MCNP version 6.3. Results presented here are preliminary, as the benchmark has not yet been submitted to the ICSBEP.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

VENUS-F: A fast lead critical core for benchmarking

The zero-power thermal neutron water-moderated facility VENUS at SCK-CEN has been extensively used for benchmarking in the past. In accordance with GEN-IV design tasks (fast reactor systems and accelerator driven systems), the VENUS facility was modified in 2007-2010 into the fast neutron facility VENUS-F with solid core components. This paper introduces the projects GUINEVERE and FREYA, which are being conducted at the VENUS-F facility, and it presents the measurement results obtained at the first critical core. Throughout the projects other fast lead benchmarks also will be investigated. The measurement results of the different configurations can all be used as fast neutron benchmarks. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Experimental power density distribution benchmark in the TRIGA Mark II reactor

In order to improve the power calibration process and to benchmark the existing computational model of the TRIGA Mark II reactor at the Josef Stefan Inst. (JSI), a bilateral project was started as part of the agreement between the French Commissariat a l'energie atomique et aux energies alternatives (CEA) and the Ministry of higher education, science and technology of Slovenia. One of the objectives of the project was to analyze and improve the power calibration process of the JSI TRIGA reactor (procedural improvement and uncertainty reduction) by using absolutely calibrated CEA fission chambers (FCs). This is one of the few available power density distribution benchmarks for testing not only the fission rate distribution but also the absolute values of the fission rates. Our preliminary calculations indicate that the total experimental uncertainty of the measured reaction rate is sufficiently low that the experiments could be considered as benchmark experiments. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Whole-core comet solutions to a 3-dimensional PWR benchmark problem with gadolinium

A pressurized water reactor (PWR) benchmark problem with gadolinium was used to determine the accuracy and computational efficiency of the coarse mesh radiation transport method COMET. The benchmark problem contains 193 square fuel assemblies. The COMET solution (eigenvalue, assembly averaged and fuel pin averaged fission density distributions) was compared with those obtained from the corresponding Monte Carlo reference solution using the same 2-group material cross section library. The comparison showed that both the core eigenvalue and fission density distribution averaged over each assembly and fuel pin predicated by COMET agree very well with the corresponding MCNP reference solution if the incident flux response expansion used in COMET is truncated at 2nd order in the two spatial and the two angular variables. The benchmark calculations indicate that COMET has Monte Carlo accuracy. In, particular, the eigenvalue difference between the codes ranged from 17 pcm to 35 pcm, being within 2 standard deviations of the calculational uncertainty. The mean flux weighted relative differences in the assembly and fuel pin fission densities were 0.47% and 0.65%, respectively. It was also found that COMET's full (whole) core computational speed is 30,000 times faster than MCNP in which only 1/8 of the core is modeled. It is estimated that COMET would have been about over 6 orders of magnitude faster than MCNP if the full core were also modeled in MCNP. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Verification of the shift Monte Carlo code with the C5G7 reactor benchmark

Shift is a new hybrid Monte Carlo/deterministic radiation transport code being developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. At its current stage of development, Shift includes a parallel Monte Carlo capability for simulating eigenvalue and fixed-source multigroup transport problems. This paper focuses on recent efforts to verify Shift's Monte Carlo component using the two-dimensional and three-dimensional C5G7 NEA benchmark problems. Comparisons were made between the benchmark eigenvalues and those output by the Shift code. In addition, mesh-based scalar flux tally results generated by Shift were compared to those obtained using MCNP5 on an identical model and tally grid. The Shift-generated eigenvalues were within three standard deviations of the benchmark and MCNP5-1.60 values in all cases. The flux tallies generated by Shift were found to be in very good agreement with those from MCNP. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Benchmark specifications for EBR-II shutdown heat removal tests

Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) is hosting an IAEA-coordinated research project on benchmark analyses of sodium-cooled fast reactor passive safety tests performed at the Experimental Breeder Reactor-II (EBR-II). The benchmark project involves analysis of a protected and an unprotected loss of flow tests conducted during an extensive testing program within the framework of the U.S. Integral Fast Reactor program to demonstrate the inherently safety features of EBR-II as a pool-type, sodium-cooled fast reactor prototype. The project is intended to improve the participants' design and safety analysis capabilities for sodium-cooled fast reactors through validation and qualification of safety analysis codes and methods. This paper provides a description of the EBR-II tests included in the program, and outlines the benchmark specifications being prepared to support the IAEA-coordinated research project. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

TRACG benchmark study: 2015 Fermi thermal-hydraulic instability event

On March 19, 2015, the Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) Fermi 2 (referred to hereafter as Fermi), located in Michigan, U.S., experienced a scram initiated by the Oscillation Power Range Monitor (OPRM) system. The plant had been operating in Single Loop Operation (SLO) for approximately 10 minutes before the scram occurred. During this time, the plant operating conditions reached a region within the power/flow (P/F) map susceptible to coupled neutronic/thermal-hydraulic (T-H) instabilities. Limited code benchmarking is available in literature for T-H Instability (THI) transients occurring in plants operating at SLO conditions due to scarce plant data for this type of operational condition. This study aims to model and benchmark the THI event at SLO conditions using TRACG, the GE Hitachi (GEH) proprietary best-estimate transient system code. The TRACG model was benchmarked by comparing the results with measured plant data, such as the total reactor power and core flow, from the event. Additionally, to evaluate the inherent stability of the plant at different P/F points, Decay Ratio (DR) calculations were performed. The capability of TRACG for calculating DRs is well documented, and it has also been approved by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) as part of ESBWR TRACG stability licensing topical reports. The results of TRACG DRs were compared to the GEH best-estimate frequency domain code ODYSY, which is the current Fermi licensing basis code for reload analysis DR calculations.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Mox powder calculation improvement: OECD Benchmark proposal and cristal - Rib results - 14228

In the framework of the WPNCS Expert Group on Uncertainty Analysis for Criticality Safety Assessment, we propose a blind numerical benchmark. Since the WPNCS Expert Group on Experimental Needs had highlighted the poor database of representative experiments of low-moderated MOX powders, this blind benchmark is focused on MOX wet powders Three PuO{sub 2} contents are proposed: 100%, 30% and 12.5%. Two Pu isotopic vectors are considered: a conservative one (0%, 71%, 17%, 11%, 1% for {sup 238}Pu up to {sup 242}Pu) and a realistic one obtained from reprocessed LWR 30 GWd/T fuels. For these 6 cases the powder moisture rate is 3%. The MOX fissile medium is a sphere surrounded by 20 cm water reflector. The required results are the calculated k{sub eff} and the associated prior uncertainty. Using benchmarks experiments, contributors should provide the projected-k{sub eff} and the corresponding posterior uncertainty. CRISTAL-V2 results based on JEFF3.1.1 nuclear data are presented. As an example, in the 30% PuO{sub 2} challenging case, the calculation uncertainty is decreased from 1160 pcm (1 σ) down to 450 pcm using EOLE and MASURCA critical Pu experiments. This uncertainty depends slightly on 'conservative' or 'realistic' Pu because the representativity factor does not vary significantly with the Pu vector. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Reassessment of uncertainties for the PU-MET-INTER-002 benchmark - 14432

Uncertainty for the PU-MET-INTER-002 benchmark of ZPR-6/10 was unusually large for a ZPR assembly and was dominated by the uncertainties in matrix tube pitch and composition uncertainties for plutonium, graphite and stainless steel plates. The original uncertainty analysis for PU-MET-INTER-002 was limited by computer resources, software and the nuclear data available in 2002, all of which have been improved since. An as-built Monte Carlo model of ZPR-6/10 was used to quantify components of the transformation from the detailed model to a simplified RZ benchmark in 2002. Compositional uncertainties were estimated based upon TWODANT calculations of the RZ benchmark model (20 group, S{sub 8} - P{sub 1}). MC{sup 2}-2 was used with END/B-V.2 data to generate homogenized cross section data for TWODANT. The MC{sup 2}-2 calculations did not account for lattice cell spatial heterogeneity which was driven by the manual process required to generate ∼80 modifications to the deterministic model and by the software limitations of MC{sup 2}-2. Improvements to DIF3D-VARIANT, development of the MC{sup 2}-3 and BuildZPRModel codes, and better computer resources make accurate 3D transport calculations of reactivity changes practical today. BuildZPRModel imports the as-built geometry and creates a 'drawer' homogenized DIF3D model where each radial DIF3D mesh is the exact size of a single ZPR matrix tube and drawer. A MC{sup 2}-3 input is constructed for each drawer to produce homogenized cross section data where the spatial cell heterogeneity is captured by solving a 1D MOC transport calculation on the ultrafine energy group level. Collapsing 3D drawers into 1D MC{sup 2}-3 drawer models follows conventional procedures and is done by BuildZPRModel. MCNP6 was used to re-compute relevant geometry components of the uncertainty using ENDF/B-VII.0 data with the as-built model. Changes in the geometry components compared with earlier results are insignificant. DIF3D calculations of the compositional uncertainties were performed using 33, 70, 116, 230, 425, and 703 group energy structures and selectively combined with P{sub 3}-P{sub 7} transport approximations and P{sub 1} and P{sub 3} scattering kernels. 3D diffusion theory calculations were also performed for comparison. Many composition uncertainty components were essentially unchanged with the updated methodology. However, the dominant experimental uncertainty for PU-MET-INTER-002 is the composition of stainless steel. The new calculations reduce the stainless steel uncertainty from ∼115 pcm to ∼70 pcm which significantly reduces the total uncertainty for PU-MET-INTER-002. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Investigation of the OECD/NEA PWR MOX/UO{sub 2} core transient benchmark using a coupled whole core pin-by-pin route in WIMS

This paper investigates the new CAMELOT coupling route developed in WIMS, which uses prepared tabulated cross-sections combined with the flux solver MERLIN module and the integrated sub-channel thermal hydraulics solver ARTHUR module to solve for the coupled core state. This coupling route is applied to the OECD/NEA pressurized water reactor (PWR) core transient benchmark exercise, involving 3-D neutronics and thermal-hydraulics analysis of a full-sized PWR core featuring MOX fuel at various core states, as well as simulating a control rod ejection transient. Analysis of the results for each part of the benchmark demonstrate that the high-resolution pin-by-pin analysis used in WIMS closely matches the other participants in the benchmark, with differences of between 20-200 pcm for k-effective, 1-2.5% RMS difference for assembly-averaged powers, 2-8% difference in rod worth calculations, < 200 ppm for calculations of critical boron concentration, zero difference in delayed neutron fraction calculation and a very close match for power response to the rod ejection transient. This is the first application of the WIMS-CAMELOT approach for the transient analysis of a full-sized reactor and as such further improvements such as reducing computational cost through parallelization, optimisation and memory reduction, are currently in active development. This paper demonstrates the accuracy and flexibility of the CAMELOT coupling route, providing a straightforward and consistent user image that can be easily used for a variety of modelling problems involving coupled neutronics and thermal-hydraulics. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

The HTR-Proteus Benchmark: Analysis and Use as a Verification and Validation Case

This presentation outlines the evaluation and application of the HTR-Proteus benchmark as a verification and validation (V&V) case for advanced reactor modeling tools. The work supports the U.S. Department of Energy’s HALEU Availability Program (HAP) and the joint DOE/NRC DNCSH project, which aims to reduce criticality safety uncertainties in commercial-scale HALEU fuel cycle and transportation systems. The HTR-Proteus experiments, conducted at the Paul Scherrer Institute, provide high-fidelity data for TRISO-fueled, graphite-moderated pebble bed reactors with high neutron leakage—conditions relevant to HALEU transport scenarios. This study focuses on Cores 4.2 and 4.3 of the HTR-Proteus benchmark, analyzing key sources of uncertainty including pebble packing, TRISO particle positioning, and core height. Using Project Chrono for realistic pebble geometries and Serpent, SHIFT, and MCNP for neutronics simulations, the study quantifies the impact of these uncertainties on the effective multiplication factor (keff). Results show that a sample size of 110 pebble configurations is sufficient to converge keff, with ±30 pcm uncertainty due to packing randomness. TRISO positioning and core height variations also significantly influence keff, highlighting the importance of detailed modeling in V&V efforts. The benchmark serves as a valuable test case for validating the Griffin reactor physics code and improving confidence in HALEU system simulations.

73 - NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Performance Evaluation and Benchmarking of Next Intelligent Systems

Performance Evaluation and Benchmarking of Intelligent Systems presents research dedicated to the subject of performance evaluation and benchmarking of intelligent systems by drawing from the experiences and insights of leading experts gained both through theoretical development and practical implementation of intelligent systems in a variety of diverse application domains. This contributed volume offers a detailed and coherent picture of state-of-the-art, recent developments, and further research areas in intelligent systems. The chapters cover a broad range of applications, such as assistive robotics, planetary surveying, urban search and rescue, and line tracking for automotive assembly. Subsystems or components described in this book include human-robot interaction, multi-robot coordination, communications, perception, and mapping. Chapters are also devoted to simulation support and open source software for cognitive platforms, providing examples of the type of enabling underlying technologies that can help intelligent systems to propagate and increase in capabilities. Performance Evaluation and Benchmarking of Intelligent Systems serves as a professional reference for researchers and practitioners in the field. This book is also applicable to advanced courses for graduate level students and robotics professionals in a wide range of engineering and related disciplines including computer science, automotive, healthcare, manufacturing, and service robotics.

42 ENGINEERING↗

An international land-biosphere model benchmarking activity for the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report (AR5)

The need to capture important climate feedbacks in general circulation models (GCMs) has resulted in efforts to include atmospheric chemistry and land and ocean biogeochemistry into the next generation of production climate models, called Earth System Models (ESMs). While many terrestrial and ocean carbon models have been coupled to GCMs, recent work has shown that such models can yield a wide range of results (Friedlingstein et al., 2006). This work suggests that a more rigorous set of global offline and partially coupled experiments, along with detailed analyses of processes and comparisons with measurements, are needed. The Carbon-Land Model Intercomparison Project (C-LAMP) was designed to meet this need by providing a simulation protocol and model performance metrics based upon comparisons against best-available satellite- and ground-based measurements (Hoffman et al., 2007). Recently, a similar effort in Europe, called the International Land Model Benchmark (ILAMB) Project, was begun to assess the performance of European land surface models. These two projects will now serve as prototypes for a proposed international land-biosphere model benchmarking activity for those models participating in the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report (AR5). Initially used for model validation for terrestrial biogeochemistry models in the NCAR Community Land Model (CLM), C-LAMP incorporates a simulation protocol for both offline and partially coupled simulations using a prescribed historical trajectory of atmospheric CO2 concentrations. Models are confronted with data through comparisons against AmeriFlux site measurements, MODIS satellite observations, NOAA Globalview flask records, TRANSCOM inversions, and Free Air CO2 Enrichment (FACE) site measurements. Both sets of experiments have been performed using two different terrestrial biogeochemistry modules coupled to the CLM version 3 in the Community Climate System Model version 3 (CCSM3): the CASA model of Fung, et al., and the carbon-nitrogen (CN) model of Thornton. Comparisons of the CLM3 offline results against observational datasets have been performed and are described in Randerson et al. (2009). CLM version 4 has been evaluated using C-LAMP, showing improvement in many of the metrics. Efforts are now underway to initiate a Nitrogen-Land Model Intercomparison Project (N-LAMP) to better constrain the effects of the nitrogen cycle in biosphere models. Presented will be new results from C-LAMP for CLM4, initial N-LAMP developments, and the proposed land-biosphere model benchmarking activity.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗