Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “thermal flexibility”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 415 records · Page 23
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2024

Scaling methodologies and similarity analysis for thermal hydraulics test facility development for water-cooled small modular reactor

Small modular reactors (SMRs) represent a promising option for providing clean and sustainable energy due to their potential for enhanced safety, reduced capital costs, and increased siting flexibility. However, new reactor systems require the development and operation of representative scaled-down test facilities to support the verification and validation of system computer codes and models. Here this study reviews the research on scaling methodologies and similarity principles pivotal in developing non-nuclear integral effects test and separate effects test facilities for water-cooled SMRs. The study focuses on a review of the scaling methods, similarity approaches, and possible challenges posed by the unique and compact design features of integral-pressurized water reactor-type SMRs, and their representative test facilities. This study also reviews previous research related to scaling and similarity methodologies and provides insights into design considerations for achieving prototypic conditions in test facilities. The findings and recommendations emphasize the broader impact of appropriate scaling and similarity principles to ensure meaningful and transferable results from non-nuclear test facilities to accelerate the safe and efficient deployment of next-generation water-cooled SMRs.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗
DOE OSTI2021

Phenomenon Identification and Ranking Table Analysis for Thermal Energy Storage Technologies Integration with Advanced Nuclear Reactors

This report provides an overview of the Phenomena Identification and Ranking Table (PIRT) analysis of thermal energy storage (TES) systems for possible integration with various types of advanced nuclear power plants (NPPs). Advanced NPPs will potentially need to operate in environments where power generation flexibility is more highly valued than the stability or baseload generation capability for conventional demand curves. TES systems would enable NPPs to respond nimbly to market variability and could also position advanced NPPs to participate differently in restructured markets, thus further enhancing their economic competitiveness. TES systems could also benefit the electric grid by eliminating the need for peaking plants, as well as by improving the economic performance of baseload NPPs. While TES technologies afford a unique opportunity to address many of these challenges, the applicability of these systems is also complicated by the fact that various advanced NPPs are designed differently, each with its own temperature range, size, operating fluids, and operating conditions. Hence, TES systems face significant barriers to investment, as more information on their compatibility and performance metrics is needed to quantify the advantages provided by each, as well as the challenges these technologies might face if coupled with a particular type of advanced NPP. This report explores the possibility of integrating a wide variety of TES technologies with various categories of advanced NPPs, based on their operating characteristics. To help users and developers decide which TES technology is best suited to a particular category of advanced NPPs, this research developed a PIRT of 10 TES systems that could potentially be coupled with advanced NPPs, which themselves are divided into nine categories based on their operating conditions. Each advanced NPP category is evaluated for compatibility with the 10 TES systems by assembling and discussing a database of information concerning 10 engineering questions (defined herein in as figures of merit [FOMs]), such as: technology readiness level (TRL), temperature compatibility, energy density, size, cycle frequency, ramp time, realignment frequency, geographic needs, environmental impact, and interventions. By assembling a database of information concerning the TES technologies’ compatibility with various advanced NPP systems, this study can help developers acquaint themselves with a particular TES technology before choosing to build a new integrated installation.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2024

THM: the MOOSE thermal hydraulics module

The MOOSE Thermal Hydraulics Module (THM) is designed to facilitate the development of thermal hydraulic system models. It provides the capability to assemble networks of coupled components such as pipes, junctions, valves, turbomachinery, and heat exchangers. Its library of components supports a single-phase, compressible flow model based on a variable-area formulation of the Euler equations of gas dynamics and discretized using a finite volume scheme. THM offers a flexible system for specifying closures such as friction factors or heat transfer coefficients, allowing the user to choose from built-in correlations or define their own in the input file. A control logic system can be used to control input parameters, necessary for implementing transient scenarios and mirroring real control systems in thermal hydraulic systems. THM can be coupled with other MOOSE-based applications for multiphysics calculations. This talk will give an introduction to the capabilities of THM and provide some examples of its usage and validation.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2025

MOOSE Thermal-Hydraulics Module - MOOSE workshop

The MOOSE Thermal Hydraulics Module (THM) is designed to facilitate the development of thermal hydraulic system models. It provides the capability to assemble networks of coupled components such as pipes, junctions, valves, turbomachinery, and heat exchangers. Its library of components supports a single-phase, compressible flow model based on a variable-area formulation of the Euler equations of gas dynamics and discretized using a finite volume scheme. THM offers a flexible system for specifying closures such as friction factors or heat transfer coefficients, allowing the user to choose from built-in correlations or define their own in the input file. A control logic system can be used to control input parameters, necessary for implementing transient scenarios and mirroring real control systems in thermal hydraulic systems. THM can be coupled with other MOOSE-based applications for multiphysics calculations. This training will give an introduction to the capabilities of THM and provide some examples of its usage and validation.

97 - MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2025

Conductive Liquid Metal Vitrimer Composites for Reconfigurable and Recyclable Flexible Electronics

Liquid metal (LM) elastomer composites exhibit excellent functionality for stretchable electronics and wearables, but limited recycling and reuse pathways constrain their sustainable use. Here, to address these challenges amid growing concerns over electronic waste, a conductive LM–vitrimer composite is presented that enables recyclable and reconfigurable electronics. This soft and stretchable composite features uniformly distributed LM inclusions that enhance thermal conductivity by 6.53× and enable the formation of conductive traces with electrical self-healing, while the vitrimer provides structural restoration. The dynamic covalent bonds of the vitrimer matrix are leveraged for both reprocessing the composite and chemically recovering 94% of the LM. This liquid-state filler slightly reduces the vitrimer's stiffness to 2.63 MPa (≈20% lower), while maintaining its high stretchability (>135% strain) and thermal stability. It is further examined how ultrasonicated LM inclusions interact with the vitrimer matrix and demonstrate the composite's self-healing and recyclability through two distinct approaches: 1) thermomechanical reprocessing, which restores fragmented composites under heat and compression for circuit reconfiguration; and 2) chemical recycling, which recovers the embedded LM for reuse in fabricating new composites and redesigned circuitry. With the integration of recyclability and diverse functional capabilities, LM–vitrimer composites emerge as a promising material platform for sustainable, flexible electronics.

Han, Youngshang [Univ. of Washington, Seattle, WA ↗
DOE OSTI2020

An expanded kinetics model describing injector region desorption

During the initial stages of electron beam injection, absorbed or entrained material can be released into the nascent beam pulse by thermal desorption or electron beam impact. These processes, and subsequent ionization and dissociation, are examined assuming a prototypical temporal beam pulse. An expanded set of kinetic equations that includes thermal desorption, electron-stimulated ion emission, electron impact dissociation, electron impact ionization, and thermal decomposition of adsorbed water molecules is developed. Estimates of the three most important ionized species H 2 O + , H + and OH + are provided for typical injector conditions. Electron impact dissociative ionization of neutral H 2 O is the dominant source of H + under these conditions. Since the abundance of thermally desorbed neutral H 2 O has an exponential rate, the production of H+ is likewise controlled by this exponential desorption rate. Thus thermal management of the confining walls could suppress proton production in the injector region. Thermal decomposition of H 2 O will not be a contributing physical process in the injector region on time scales less than a μs. The formalism is sufficiently flexible to include entrained hydrogen.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2024

End-Use Savings Shapes Measure Documentation: Thermostat Control for Load Shedding in Large Offices

This documentation focuses on a single End-Use Savings Shape measure - thermostat control for load shedding. The thermostat control for load shedding measure applies heating and cooling temperature setpoint offsets for reducing the heating and cooling load during peak window. The measure takes daily peak load schedule inputs generated by the method "Dispatch Schedule Generation" described in the "Supplemental Documentation: Dispatch Schedule Generation for Demand Flexibility Measures" to determine the start and end times of the peak window, and then adjusts the thermostat cooling and/or heating setpoints by an offset value from original schedules during the peak window to reduce the HVAC or whole building daily peak load. The measure is flexible and allows users to adjust the heating and cooling offset values respectively, but for this study, the adjustment for heating and cooling setpoints are set to -2 degrees Celsius and +2 degrees Celsius by default. The measure provides options of adding rebound control period (default 2 hours) after peak windows for the setpoints to be ramped back to default values, to prevent the system from generating higher peak demand with step changes of setpoints in post-peak periods . This measure is applicable t o large offices equipped with electric HVAC system (either electric cooling only or both electric heating and cooling), which account for approximately 8.72% of the ComStock floor area. The thermostat control for load shedding measure demonstrates 2-5% daily peak demand reduction and 0.068% total site energy savings (3 trillion British thermal units [TBtu]) for the U.S. commercial building stock modeled in ComStock.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
DOE OSTI2020

Anomalous absorption of electromagnetic waves by 2D transition metal carbonitride Ti 3 CNT x (MXene)

Lightweight, ultrathin, and flexible electromagnetic interference (EMI) shielding materials are needed to protect electronic circuits and portable telecommunication devices and to eliminate cross-talk between devices and device components. Here, we show that a two-dimensional (2D) transition metal carbonitride, Ti 3 CNT x MXene, with a moderate electrical conductivity, provides a higher shielding effectiveness compared with more conductive Ti 3 C 2 T x or metal foils of the same thickness. This exceptional shielding performance of Ti 3 CNT x was achieved by thermal annealing and is attributed to an anomalously high absorption of electromagnetic waves in its layered, metamaterial-like structure. These results provide guidance for designing advanced EMI shielding materials but also highlight the need for exploring fundamental mechanisms behind interaction of electromagnetic waves with 2D materials.

Science & Technology - Other Topics↗
DOE OSTI2020

Advanced Anode for Internal Reforming and Thermal Management in Solid Oxide Fuel Cells

Solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) is an efficient and clean electrical power generation system compared to conventional combustion based technologies with energy efficiency reaching as high as 85-90% in co-generation mode (electricity and heat). Other advantages of SOFCs are hybridization, modularity of construction, small CO 2 foot print per kWh of generated electricity and fuel flexibility. Hydrocarbons present in the gaseous fuel is utilized in SOFCs by internal or external reforming. There are two different internal reforming concepts: Direct Internal Reforming (DIR) and Indirect Internal Reforming (IIR). For DIR operation, the endothermic reforming reaction and the exothermic reaction from the oxidation reaction are operated together in the single unit eliminating the requirement for a separate fuel reformer. This configuration also simplifies the overall system design, making SOFC more attractive and efficient means of producing electrical power. The main advantage of the DIR type of operation is that the H 2 or CO consumption by the electrochemical reaction could directly promote the conversion of methane at the anode side of the fuel cell resulting in high conversion and high efficiency. The DIR operation, however, requires an anode material that has desired dual catalytic (hetero and electro) properties for reforming reaction and electrochemical reactions. The anode materials also need to remain resistant to carbon formation at the operating temperature and atmosphere with stable cell performance. Another requirement is to match the reforming reactions and electrochemical reactions to avoid local cooling or overheating, which can result in mechanical failure due to thermally induced stresses. Direct internal reforming (DIR) of hydrocarbon fuels simplifies the overall SOFC system design making it more attractive and efficient for producing electrical power. Low cost alloy anodes for distributed internal reforming of methane and other hydrocarbon fuels offer increased fuel-flexibility, reliability, and long term performance stability of solid oxide fuel cells (SOFC). The research program examined modification of the chemical compositions and microstructure of high entropy alloy (HEA) anode materials using thermochemical calculations and process simulation and modeling to achieve distributed reforming over the entire anode to eliminate hot zones. Cell fabrication and testing of the HEA anodes using button cell configuration has been performed to demonstrate the advantages of new anode over traditional Ni-YSZ anodes for distributed reforming and carbon free operation. Technical accomplishments include identification and synthesis of HEA carbon-resistant anode, demonstration of reduction in reforming rate confirmed by GC and modelling data validating effectiveness for thermal management in cell/stacks, electrochemical testing of HEA anode in single cell (HEA-GDC||YSZ||LSM-YSZ) and Characterization of pretest and posttest anode materials by TEM and SEM-EDS confirming carbon-free operation.

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗
DOE OSTI2024

Modeling and Analysis of a Heat Pump Clothes Dryer with Thermal Energy Storage

Clothes drying is an energy-intensive process that causes significant electricity consumption and carbon emissions in the US. Approximately 83% of Households in the US own a tumble clothes dryer at home and 80% of dryers are electrical resistance dryers with low energy efficiency. Heat pump technology makes it possible for highly efficient and clean drying. Additionally, the ventless design of heat pump clothes dryers (HPCD) provides more installation flexibility. HPCD involves three primary mediums: wet clothes, a closed air loop, and a refrigerant circuit. The evaporator is used to dehumidify the wet air and the condenser is used to re-heat the dry air. One of the critical technological barriers to HPCD market penetration is its long drying time, primarily due to the relatively low discharging temperature and the slow response during the warm-up period. In this study, the thermal energy storage (TES) technology is adopted to address this challenge by providing pre-heating of air prior to the condenser to increase the operating temperature of the process air. The heat pump will charge the phase change material (PCM) in the TES device with heating energy during clothes washing and the PCM will discharge the stored heat to facilitate air heating during clothes drying. To analyze the optimal design and potential for energy saving and drying time reduction, a mathematical model of the HPCD system was developed. The HPCD is a highly dynamic system with a coupled heat and mass transfer and heat pumping cycle. This paper provides solutions to simulate the transient behavior of the system while maintaining low computational cost. The modeling result indicates reduced energy consumption and drying time by integrating TES with HPCD, as compared to electrical resistance dryers. The study can provide significant insights into improving building flexibility with TES and smart appliances.

Liu, Xiaoli↗
DOE OSTI2025

Additive Manufacturing of Thermal Energy Storage Composites with Microencapsulated Phase Change Materials Supported in a Multipolymer Matrix

Additive manufacturing (AM) techniques to directly integrate phase change materials (PCMs) are of interest for efficient thermal energy storage (TES) architectures. Complex, high surface-to-volume ratio composites embedded with PCM can improve thermal management with reduced material waste for customizable device fabrication. Reducing feature sizes of TES-integrated heat exchangers using AM can increase heat transfer without thermal conductivity enhancement. Here, composite AM materials containing 60 wt% microencapsulated phase change materials (MEPCM) are fabricated using off-the-shelf printers at common speeds and resolutions. High MEPCM loading in filaments is achieved with powder extrusion using two polymers, thermoplastic-polyurethane (TPU) and polycaprolactone (PCL), that mediate flexibility and rigidity for effective extrusion and printing without filament fracture or buckling. Furthermore, with PCL and TPU at 20 wt% each and 60 wt% MEPCM (P 20 T 20 M 60 ), smooth, form-stable filaments are consistently printed. Powder-based extrusion displays negligible damaging effects on the MEPCM. Printed P 20 T 20 M 60 demonstrates 105 J/g of energy storage with no degradation through 250 thermal cycles, within 5% of the theoretical storage enthalpy. Combining PCL/TPU shows good interfacial adhesion between print layers and produces high surface area objects, like 15% gyroids, and dense, 100% infilled pucks. Prints are also scalable to a 900 cm 3 honeycomb heat exchanger with an estimated 9 Wh energy storage.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Operating Reserves in ReEDS

This presentation provides an overview of the formulation for operating reserves in the Regional Energy Deployment System (ReEDS), a capacity expansion model. It describes the three reserve products modeled in ReEDS--regulation, spinning (contingency), and flexibility--and highlights recent updates to the modeling approach, including modifications to how storage provides reserves, the constraints on commitment for generators that provide reserves, and the costs for thermal units to provide spinning reserve. The presentation benchmarks operating reserve provision in ReEDS against comparable simulations in PLEXOS, finding that the improved formulation is different but yields results that are holistically similar to those in production cost modeling. In this presentation we also investigate the impact of different reserve options in the model (e.g., allowing wind and solar to provide operating reserves) on the solution. The results thus far indicate that most switches related to operating reserves exert little influence on the outcome on the results. Future work will continue to explore operating reserves in capacity expansion models, particularly for models with different temporal resolution.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2020

Dynamic optimization and economic evaluation of flexible heat integration in a hybrid concentrated solar power plant

Hybridization of concentrated solar power (CSP) plants provides flexibility in operation that can drastically improve the solar-to-electric (STE) efficiency and levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) relative to standalone CSP plants. Flexible heat integration (FHI) is a novel concept where the collection and integration of CSP within a power plant is modified relative to the amount of solar energy available. FHI improves the thermal efficiency of a hybrid solar tower steam Rankine cycle power plant but leads to increased pumping needs due to continuously elevated molten salt flow rates through the collection system, which can negatively impact STE efficiency. The present work is carried out to maximize the STE efficiency of a hybrid CSP plant utilizing FHI by employing a dynamic optimization framework where a genetic algorithm optimizes the operation of the plant over a given solar irradiance profile. The study concerns a plant hypothetically located in Salt Lake City, Utah. Here, the optimization results confirm the accuracy of a predictive heuristic where the preferred operation of the plant can be estimated relative to local peaks in the incident power generated by the heliostat collection field. The optimized FHI operation demonstrates a yearly STE efficiency of 13.8%, whereas the equivalent base-level hybrid and solar-only plants exhibit solar efficiencies of 13.4% and 11.2%, respectively. Economic analysis shows that FHI reduces yearly natural gas costs, leading to a $\$0.5$/MWh reduction in LCOE relative to the base-level hybrid configuration. Overall, the results show that hybrid FHI schemes exhibit economic benefits along with observed thermodynamic improvements.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2024

Polydiallylammonium-Polysulfone Multiblock Copolymers for Moisture-Swing Direct Air Capture of Carbon Dioxide

Polysulfones are an important class of materials for a variety of applications due to their excellent strength and thermal stability. Quaternary ammonium polymers are also useful materials due to their ion exchange properties, and such materials with alkaline counterions have been used to capture carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) from ambient air through a moisture-driven mechanism. Herein, we design sulfone-based multiblock copolymers containing ammonium functionalities and demonstrate their potential for CO 2 capture. Specifically, a series of multiblock copolymers containing both polydiallyldimethylammonium (PDADMA) and polysulfone (PSf) blocks were synthesized. PSf blocks provide mechanical integrity, while the PDADMA blocks enable the direct air capture of CO 2 . Multiblock copolymers were synthesized at high yield, and PDADMA(OH)-PSf copolymer films with good flexibility and strength were formed with IECs of 424 μmol/g (17 mol % PDADMA(OH)), 1407 μmol/g (44 mol % PDADMA(OH)), and 1726 μmol/g (50 mol % PDADMA(OH)). Thermogravimetric analysis was used to determine that all films are thermally stable up to 345 °C. Differential scanning calorimetry revealed that the 17 and 44 mol % functionalized PDADMA(OH)-PSf multiblock copolymers showed one T g at 185 °C and 50 mol % PDADMA(OH)-PSf polymer showed a T g at 183 °C and a second T g at 16 °C. Atomic force microscopy showed that the multiblock polymers exhibit disordered phase separation. Furthermore, the copolymer materials displayed moisture-swing direct air capture of CO 2 , opening up pathways to utilize polymer architecture and chemistry to tailor the properties of promising sorbents.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2021

Operating a commercial building HVAC load as a virtual battery through airflow control

Virtual battery (VB) is an innovative method to model flexibility of building loads and effectively coordinate them with other resources at a system level. Unlike a real battery with a dedicated power conversion system for charging control, methods are required for operating building loads to deviate from the baseline to respond to grid signals. This paper presents a VB control for a commercial heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) system to follow the desired power consumption in real-time by adjusting zonal airflow rates. The proposed method consists of two parts. At the system level, a mixed feedforward and feedback control is used to estimate the desired total airflow rate. At the zone level, two priority-based algorithms are then proposed to distribute the total airflow rate to individual zones. In particular, a zonal airflow limit estimation method is proposed using machine-learning techniques, in contrast to physics-based thermal models in existing studies, to more accurately capture zonal thermal dynamics and improve temperature control performance. An office building on the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory campus is implemented in EnergyPlus, and used to illustrate and validate the proposed control.

Wang, Jiyu↗
DOE OSTI2022

Validation of material models for puncture of 7075-T651 aluminum plate

Plate puncture simulations are challenging computational tasks that require advanced material models including high strain rate and thermal-mechanical effects on both deformation and failure, plus finite element techniques capable of representing large deformations and material failure. The focus of this work is on the material issues, which require large sets of experiments, flexible material models and challenging calibration procedures. In this study, we consider the puncture of 12.7 mm thick, 7075-T651 aluminum alloy plates by a cylindrical punch with a hemispherical nose and diameter of 12.7 mm. The plasticity and ductile failure models were isotropic with calibration data obtained from uniaxial tension tests at different temperatures and strain rates plus quasi-static notched tension tests and shear-dominated tests described here. Sixteen puncture experiments were conducted to identify the threshold penetration energy, mode of puncture and punch acceleration during impact, The punch was mounted on a 139 kg mass and dropped on the plates with different impact speeds. Since the mass was the same in all tests, the quantity of interest was the impact speed. The axis and velocity of the punch were perpendicular to the plate surface. The mean threshold punch speed was 3.05 m/s, and the mode of failure was plugging by thermal-mechanical shear banding accompanied by scabbing fragments. Application of the material models in simulations of the tests yielded accurate estimates of the threshold puncture speed and of the mode of failure. Time histories of the punch acceleration compared well between simulation and test. Remarkably, the success of the simulations occurred in spite of even the smallest element used being larger than the width of the shear bands.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Carbon Fiber and Polymer Composites

Tooling is an integral part of composites manufacturing. Composite tools, also called ‘soft’ tools, are more easily constructed than ‘hard’ metal tools and, because they are made from materials similar to the manufactured composite part, they can be made in-house and have a good co-efficient of thermal expansion match. However, as the ‘soft’ designation suggests, they are more vulnerable to wear and typically find application in relatively low-volume production. Additive manufacturing of thermoplastics has proven to be a lucrative option that can help improve the tooling functionalities, as it offers more design flexibility. Owing to the inherent nature of additive manufacturing, the possibility of printing sensors within the tool material and at proximity to otherwise inaccessible areas of the tool become a reality. Continuous carbon fiber (CCF)-reinforced three-dimensional (3D) printing of engineering thermoplastics has proven to be a viable option to strengthen a part well beyond the ideal moduli of unmodified thermoplastic. Furthermore, adding nanotubes or graphene to the thermoplastic matrix will also improve both the thermal conductivity and interlaminar shear strength within the tool. Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) and carbon fibers (CFs) are microwave susceptors; exploiting the physics of Joule heating to increase the energy efficiency of tool hardening and cure rates is a core goal of this project. Because of the rapid volumetric heating enabled by the absorption of microwave or radio frequency energy and electromagnetic (EM) annealing presents an attractive opportunity to significantly reduce manufacturing cycle times while improving part performance.

Craps, Matthew G.↗
DOE OSTI2024

Boron‐polymer composites engineered for compression molding, foaming, and additive manufacturing

Abstract Boron (specifically 10 B) is the element of choice to shield thermal neutrons due to its large (n, α) cross‐section; however, very few polymer composites containing high boron concentrations are available. This study aimed to determine the maximum possible amount of boron that could be introduced into a polymer matrix. Diverse manufacturing techniques, ranging from additive manufacturing to compression molding, were employed to fabricate inks and filaments for 3D printing, foams, and flexible pads. Composites using siloxanes, poly(lactic acid), and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene containing up to 80 wt% boron were sucessufully fabricated. The addition of known plasticizers (polyethylene glycol) and reinforcing agents (carbon nanofibers and fumed silica) helped to overcome fabrication problems such as clogging of the printing nozzle or crumbling of compression molded parts. In addition, the thermal‐mechanical properties of these novel boron composites were determined and shown to vary according to boron concentration, presence of additives, and fabrication techniques utilized.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗