SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Goal is to add functionality to MAMMOTH to perform depletion calculations. The purpose of this is to allow the use of the same mesh for fuel elements depleted in commercial reactors or the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) before being placed in the Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) for further experimentation.
SRS analysis and testing to SRS is known to be conservative since SRS is generated from maxi-max shock transient data, maximum peaks are assumed to occur for each mode simultaneously, and the structural dynamics are not accounted for between the shock source and the test article. Knowing the structural dynamics of a shock test setup it is possible to subscribe a force shock transient applied at a particular strike location and direction to achieve a desired shock transient at a test reference accelerometer. The SRS at this test accelerometer reference location can be used to compare to the reference SRS, but the key reference is the shock transient not the SRS, which should lead to more realistic shock testing that better matches operational shock transient data and reduces artificial test failures that don’t occur in operational usage. The desired test shock transient should match operational shock transients. As such, the test shock transient should look similar to the operational shock transient and have similar positive and negative peaks, the same shape, and the same duration. Many shock transients can be created that satisfy an SRS, but better control of these shock transient parameters is needed to better match operational shock transients so that more realistic and less conservative shock testing can be performed. Three different shock transients are presented that satisfy a given SRS and the results are compared for an electronic board (test article) attached to a circular shock resonance test plate.
The NEUP funded project, NEUP-3496, aims to experimentally investigate two-phase natural circulation flow instability that could occur in Small Modular Reactors (SMRs), especially for natural circulation SMRs. The objective has been achieved by systematically performing tests to study the general natural circulation instability characteristics and the natural circulation behavior under start-up or design basis accident conditions. Experimental data sets highlighting the effect of void reactivity feedback as well as the effect of power ramp-up rate and system pressure have been used to develop a comprehensive stability map. The safety analysis code, RELAP5, has been used to evaluate experimental results and models. Improvements to the constitutive relations for flashing have been made in order to develop a reliable analysis tool. This research has been focusing on two generic SMR designs, i.e. a small modular Simplified Boiling Water Reactor (SBWR) like design and a small integral Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) like design. A BWR-type natural circulation test facility was firstly built based on the three-level scaling analysis of the Purdue Novel Modular Reactor (NMR) with an electric output of 50 MWe, namely NMR-50, which represents a BWR-type SMR with a significantly reduced reactor pressure vessel (RPV) height. The experimental facility was installed with various equipment to measure thermalhydraulic parameters such as pressure, temperature, mass flow rate and void fraction. Characterization tests were performed before the startup transient tests and quasi-steady tests to determine the loop flow resistance. The control system and data acquisition system were programmed with LabVIEW to realize the realtime control and data storage. The thermal-hydraulic and nuclear coupled startup transients were performed to investigate the flow instabilities at low pressure and low power conditions for NMR-50. Two different power ramps were chosen to study the effect of startup power density on the flow instability. The experimental startup transient results showed the existence of three different flow instability mechanisms, i.e., flashing instability, condensation induced flow instability, and density wave oscillations. In addition, the void-reactivity feedback did not have significant effects on the flow instability during the startup transients for NMR-50. ii Several initial startup procedures with different power ramp rates were experimentally investigated to eliminate the flow instabilities observed from the startup transients. Particularly, the very slow startup transient and pressurized startup transient tests were performed and compared. It was found that the very slow startup transients by applying very small power density can eliminate the flashing oscillations in the single-phase natural circulation and stabilize the flow oscillations in the phase of net vapor generation. The initially pressurized startup procedure was tested to eliminate the flashing instability during the startup transients as well. The pressurized startup procedure included the initial pressurization, heat-up, and venting process. The startup transient tests showed that the pressurized startup procedure could eliminate the flow instability during the transition from single-phase flow to two-phase flow at low pressure conditions. The experimental results indicated that both startup procedures were applicable to the initial startup of NMR. However, the pressurized startup procedures might be preferred due to short operating hours required. In order to have a deeper understanding of natural circulation flow instability, the quasi-steady tests were performed using the test facility installed with preheater and subcooler. The effect of system pressure, core inlet subcooling, core power density, inlet flow resistance coefficient, and void reactivity feedback were investigated in the quasi-steady state tests. The experimental stability boundaries were determined between unstable and stable flow conditions in the dimensionless stability plane of inlet subcooling number and Zuber number. To predict the stability boundary theoretically, linear stability analysis in the frequency domain was performed at four sections of the natural circulation test loop. The flashing phenomena in the chimney section was considered as an axially uniform heat source. And the dimensionless characteristic equation of the pressure drop perturbation was obtained by considering the void fraction effect and outlet flow resistance in the core section. The theoretical flashing boundary showed some discrepancies with previous experimental data from the quasi-steady state tests. In the future, thermal non-equilibrium was recommended to improve the accuracy of flashing instability boundary. As another part of the funded research, flow instabilities of a PWR-type SMR under low pressure and low power conditions were investigated experimentally as well. The NuScale reactor design was selected as the prototype for the PWR-type SMR. In order to experimentally study the natural circulation behavior of NuScale iii reactor during accidental scenarios, detailed scaling analyses are necessary to ensure that the scaled phenomena could be obtained in a laboratory test facility. The three-level scaling method is used as well to obtain the scaling ratios derived from various non-dimensional numbers. The design of the ideally scaled facility (ISF) was initially accomplished based on these scaling ratios. Then the engineering scaled facility (ESF) was designed and constructed based on the ISF by considering engineering limitations including laboratory space, pipe size, and pipe connections etc. PWR-type SMR experiments were performed in this well-scaled test facility to investigate the potential thermal hydraulic flow instability during the blowdown events, which might occur during the loss of coolant accident (LOCA) and loss of heat sink accident (LOHS) of the prototype PWR-type SMR. Two kinds of experiments, normal blowdown event and cold blowdown event, were experimentally investigated and compared with code predictions. The normal blowdown event was experimentally simulated since an initial condition where the pressure was lower than the designed pressure of the experiment facility, while the code prediction of blowdown started from the normal operation condition. Important thermal hydraulic parameters including reactor pressure vessel (RPV) pressure, containment pressure, local void fraction and temperature, pressure drop and natural circulation flow rate were measured and analyzed during the blowdown event. The pressure and water level transients are similar to the experimental results published by NuScale [51], which proves the capability of current loop in simulating the thermal hydraulic transient of real PWR-type SMR. During the 20000s blowdown experiment, water level in the core was always above the active fuel assemble during the experiment and proved the safety of natural circulation cooling and water recycling design of PWR-type SMR. Besides, pressure, temperature, and water level transient can be accurately predicted by RELAP5 code. However, the oscillations of natural circulation flow rate, water level and pressure drops were observed during the blowdown transients. This kind of flow oscillations are related to the water level and the location upper plenum, which is a path for coolant flow from chimney to steam generator and down comer. In order to investigate the transients start from the opening of ADS valve in both experimental and numerical way, the cold blow-down experiment is conducted. For the cold blowdown event, different from setting both reactor iv pressure vessel (RPV) and containment at high temperature and pressure, only RPV was heated close to the highest designed pressure and then open the ADS valve, same process was predicted using RELAP5 code. By doing cold blowdown experiment, the entire transients from the opening of ADS can be investigated by code and benchmarked with experimental data. Similar flow instability observed in the cold blowdown experiment. The comparison between code prediction and experiment data showed that the RELAP5 code can successfully predict the pressure void fraction and temperature transient during the cold blowdown event with limited error, but numerical instability exists in predicting natural circulation flow rate. Besides, the code is lack of capability in predicting the water level related flow instability observed in experiments.
TREAT is an experimental nuclear reactor designed to produce high neutron flux transients for the testing of reactor fuels and other materials. After more than 20 years of non-operational standby, TREAT has been restarted under the U.S. Department of Energy’s Resumption of Transient Testing Program. The conversion of TREAT from its current highly enriched uranium fuel to a low enriched uranium fuel is being pursued in keeping with the mission of the Department of Energy National Nuclear Security Administration’s Material Management and Minimization Reactor Conversion Program. This report documents additional analyses performed over the timeframe of 2016 to early 2018 to evaluate the LEU Conceptual Design for the TREAT reactor, following the initial design studies documented in the 2016 Conceptual Design Report. The analyses documented in this report include neutronic and thermal hydraulic sensitivity studies to evaluate the effect of key design parameters on predicted core behaviors, as well as a simple investigation into the effect of fuel thermal expansion.
This study investigated how heat demand and fuel loading affect the emissions from outdoor wood-fired hydronic heaters by testing two such appliances using an integrated-duty cycle test method. This test included transient operating conditions, such as cold and hot-starts and modulation between 15 and 100% of maximum rated output. Emission values indicate transient operating conditions produce higher emissions than steady state operation. Cold starts resulted in elevated particulate matter emission factors for both appliances; in one case the particulate matter emission factor for this period was >3500 mg/MJ, which represented emissions 20 times the average value. Additionally, when heat demand was cycled—elevated CO emission factors were measured, with values >5000 mg/MJ for both appliances and more than 3 times the appliance averages, respectively. It follows that the appliance average particulate matter emission factors and CO emission factors were not representative of the actual EF values during these transient periods. In contrast, methane emission factors were relatively stable throughout all tested combustion conditions; however, they were much higher than oil-fired appliances are therefore should not be ignored. These findings demonstrate that wood-fired hydronic heater emissions during transient operating conditions can be significantly greater than emissions during steady-state test conditions, such as those used in typical certification tests. Consequently, certification test values for particulate matter and CO emission factors may significantly underestimate the actual emissions of these appliances when operated in a home. Use of integrated duty-cycle test protocols that capture cold-starts and reloading are better for representing in-use operations of wood-fired hydronic heaters and provide more realistic emissions and delivered efficiency measurements.
The imminent restart of the Transient Reactor Testing Facility (TREAT) at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) has brought significant attention to the development of transient reactor modeling. TREAT was designed to subject fuels and other reactor components to various degrees of neutron pulses, from minor transients to accident scenario. Inherently, this task requires predicting pulse responses due to various control rod movements; which is a complicated endeavor. Originally, this was done using an iterative process of rod movements and measuring the resulting response. With the advances in computer modeling, the current goal, preceding the restart, is to use simulation to characterize responses before experiments take place. However, neutron transient modeling is extremely computationally expensive due to the required implicit time-stepping. Therefore, methods that mitigate computation time, with minimal detriment to accuracy, are highly desired. This paper will describe the improved quasi-static method (IQS), which hopes to decrease computation time significantly from traditional 'brute force' transient methods. IQS is a spatial kinetics method that involves factorizing the flux solution into time-dependent amplitude and space- and time-dependent shape. The impetus of the method is the assumption that shape is weakly time-dependent, so expensive space-dependent evaluations are only required on large time steps. While inexpensive amplitude evaluations are performed on much smaller time steps to retain accuracy. IQS has been tested extensively on kinetics benchmarks with constant time steps. However, to test it's viability for TREAT simulations, evaluating IQS's performance with time adaptation is required. The rest of this paper will briefly describe the derivation of IQS, the time adaptation technique used, and results from a kinetic benchmarks. (authors)
Development of advanced nuclear fuels requires testing of fuel specimens under various power-cooling mismatch conditions. The Transient Reactor Test (TREAT) facility at the Idaho National Laboratory will be used to provide transient nuclear heating of fuel specimens. Experiments will be conducted to support assessment of accident tolerant fuel designs being proposed for light water reactor applications. The experiments to be conducted at TREAT will provide data for the assessment of advanced, multi-physics computer codes. However, before the experiments can be performed, calculations are required to demonstrate that they will meet program objectives and that they can be performed safely in TREAT in the event of an unplanned reactivity insertion accident that occurs during the experiment. The safety calculations for the first experiments need to be performed in the next year and therefore will be performed with an existing computer code, RELAP5-3D. A point kinetics model of TREAT was developed for RELAP5-3D. The purpose of the model is to calculate the reactor power during experiments and to support the accident analyses of those experiments. The RELAP5-3D model was validated using data from nine TREAT experiments conducted previously. The RELAP5-3D model generates results that are in reasonable agreement with measured values of maximum core power, energy deposition, and maximum fuel temperature for a wide range of reactivity insertions.
This document is a report summarizing FY2017 efforts related to the Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) Fuel Motion Monitoring System, "hodoscope," refurbishment campaign. TREAT is an air-cooled, graphite-moderated, heterogeneous test facility designed to evaluate reactor fuels and structural materials under conditions that simulate various types of transient overpower and under-cooling situations in a nuclear reactor. Fuel meltdowns, metal-water reactions, thermal interaction between overheated fuel and coolant, and the transient behavior of ceramic fuel for high-temperature systems can be studied. A key instrument that monitors fuel motion as these events take place is the fast neutron hodoscope. The hodoscope is designed to allow for pre-, during-, and post- transient imaging of fuel within a test loop in the center of the reactor core. The preferred technique for imaging is detection of fast neutrons produced by fission in the test fuel, travelling unmoderated through an empty row of core fuel assemblies and then through a multi-slot collimator to a 360-detector array. Due to the age of the instrument, a refurbishment of the hodoscope’s fast neutron detection capability is necessary to support real-time, fuel-position experimental data collection. One particular challenge in this regard is related to the refurbishment of the fast-neutron-sensing detector elements in the detector array. This report summarizes major activities and accomplishments related to the FMMS refurbishment in FY2017. Of particular note was work related to identifying options for new proton recoil scintillator wafer and initial examination of the TREAT proton recoil proportional counter detectors.
Heavy ion, focused x-ray, and pulsed laser single event transient experiments are performed on a silicon epitaxial diode. Collected charge, transient rise times, and transient fall times are calculated and compared between the different sources. It is observed that these transient shape characteristics depend on the source (ion, x-ray, or laser), even when similar amounts of charge are generated. Finally, the observed differences are examined and explained in terms of basic charge collection mechanisms.
A resistive heater capable of delivering heat loads on the same order as those produced by in-pile nuclear fuel experiments. The heater rod provides the energy for high-temperature steady-state testing, as well as the power needed to simulate the transient pulse in the Transient Reactor Test Loop (TRTL) system. The resistive heater includes a removable housing, two or more thermal conductors in the housing; and one or more stabilizers coupled to the two or more thermal conductors to keep the two or more thermal conductors separated to avoid shorting, wherein the two or more thermal conductors are coupled to the housing via an inert gas (e.g., Helium). The two or more thermal conductors comprise a material with substantially zero infrared spectrum (e.g., sapphire, silica, or glass).
When the Halden Boiling Water Reactor closed down in 2018, a need to restore the capability for in-reactor power ramp testing arose. Such testing is valuable for studying pellet-clad interaction phenomena in nuclear fuels. The data from these studies is of great interest to a number of research programs, including the accident-tolerant fuel (ATF) program at Idaho National Laboratory (INL). In 2022, Woolstenhulme et al. proposed several power ramp testing ideas using facilities at INL, including irradiation in the Transient Reactor Test Facility (better known as TREAT) and the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) [1]. Worrall et al. [2] and Labossiere-Hickman et al. [3] subsequently performed feasibility studies for the ATR testing options in 2023. This summary further investigates the three-pin trefoil design (Fig. 1) for the proposed ATF-2Ramp Experiment discussed in Labossiere-Hickman et al. [3]. ATF-2Ramp is designed to operate in the center flux trap (CFT) of the ATR during a powered axial locator mechanism (PALM) cycle: a short, variable-powered cycle with an asymmetric power distribution. Previously, it was shown that tailoring the thickness of the hafnium (Hf) neutron shields (“mini-shrouds”) surrounding each pin offered a degree of control sufficient to achieve the programmatic linear heat generation rate (LHGR) targets for ATF-2Ramp during the high-power period of a PALM cycle. New work involves shortening the experiment test train for consistency with the fuel pins in ATF-2D [4] and then shaping the axial power profile of the three test pins.
In the near future, experiments on HBu fuel under loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) and reactivity-initiated accident (RIA) conditions will be performed within the Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) at Idaho National Laboratory (INL). These experiments will be performed using the Transient Water Irradiation System for TREAT (TWIST) experiment vehicle. To support these experiments, analysis of fuel-coolant interaction (FCI) energetics is underway. This paper discusses FCIs in the context of light water reactor (LWR) safety, differentiating between the severe accident focus of commercial reactors and experimental RIA test programs where FCIs have occurred. However, it is highlighted that as the nuclear industry aims for increased burnup limits, the FCI events observed in RIA test programs may become relevant to commercial LWR safety analysis. The paper then presents developments to the UW-FCI computer program to enable simulation of FCIs initiated by solid fuel particles dispersing into the coolant during RIAs.
The Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) serves a vital role in nuclear fuel safety research, enabling transient experiments that simulate reactivity excursions and accident scenarios. Central to these operations is the transient control rod drive system (TCRDS), which drives rapid motion of the transient control rods such that TREAT can simulate rapid power changes typical of reactor accidents. The reliability and performance of this system are critical for protecting both fuel specimens and reactor infrastructure. This study presents the initial phase of a two-year investigation into the dynamics and reliability of the TREAT hydraulic TCRDS. Conducted in collaboration with INL, the research employs a combined computational and experimental approach to analyze the system's response time, pressure transients, and potential failure modes. Emphasis is placed on understanding how fluid characteristics influence the TCRDS’s ability to achieve both rapid power changes and mechanical stability. The TRDS and the skid that powers it will be analyzed throughout this investigation. Computational modeling using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) will simulate the hydraulic response under varying conditions. In parallel, experimental testing planned at INL will validate these models and capture key performance metrics. This paper outlines the system design, analytical framework, and modeling strategies that form the foundation for later testing. Ultimately, this work aims to support improvements to the TCRDS’s design and reliability, contributing to the broader goal of enhancing nuclear fuel safety and sustaining TREAT’s mission as a premier nuclear fuel test facility.
This report conclude our efforts at INL to make Rattlesnake, the MOOSE-based radiation multigroup transport application, fully support the multischeme transport capability. Specifically, it details all five types of interface condition with upwinding method for coupling eight available discretization schemes within Rattlesnake. These discretization schemes include SN (discrete ordinates method), PN (spherical harmonics expansion method) and diffusion for angular discretization, and continuous finite element method (CFEM) and discontinuous finite element method (DFEM) for spatial discretization. The other type of method based on Lagrange multipliers for coupling schemes based on CFEM has been studied in the past. Besides simple test problems, a more realistic application of multischeme transport for TREAT (transient reactor test facility) experiment modeling are presented. Several enhancements are reviewed at the end which could potentially be useful in the future.
A clearer understanding of the interactions of the hot gas flow with the structure in the duct system, the flow passages of the rotating machinery, and the thrust chamber nozzle is sought for the purpose of finding ways and means to increase the life and performance of the systems. The objective of the transient nozzle test is to understand the shock-boundary layer interactions during transient flow and the resulting large side forces acting on the nozzle skirt. The Fluctuating Pressures in Ducts study deals mainly with the fluid-structural interactions of the lox post tube banks in the injector. The Ablative Nozzle Insert Study (H4) has as its goal the performance improvement of the space shuttle main engine.
The Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) is a graphite-reflected, graphitemoderated, and air-cooled reactor fueled with 93.1% enriched UO2 particles dispersed in graphite, with a carbon-to-235U ratio of ~10000:1. TREAT was used to simulate accident conditions by subjecting fuel test samples placed at the center of the core to high energy transient pulses. The transient pulse production is based on the core’s selflimiting nature due to the negative reactivity feedback provided by the fuel graphite as the core temperature rises. The analysis of the conversion of TREAT to low enriched uranium (LEU) is currently underway. This paper presents the analytical methods used to calculate the transient performance of TREAT in terms of power pulse production and resulting peak core temperatures. The validation of the HEU neutronics TREAT model, the calculation of the temperature distribution and the temperature reactivity feedback as well as the number of fissions generated inside fuel test samples are discussed.
Pellet-cladding mechanical interaction due to thermal expansion of nuclear fuel pellets during a reactivity-initiated accident (RIA) is a potential mechanism for failure of nuclear fuel cladding. To investigate the mechanical behavior of cladding during an RIA, we developed a mechanical pulse-controlled modified burst test instrument that simulates transient events with a pulse width from 10 to 300 ms. This paper includes validation tests of unirradiated and prehydrided ZIRLO cladding tubes. A ZIRLO cladding sample with a hydrogen content of 168 wt. ppm showed ductile behavior and failed at the maximum limits of the test setup with hoop strain to failure greater than 9.2%. ZIRLO samples showed high resistance to failure even at very high hydrogen contents (1,466 wt. ppm). When the hydrogen content was increased to 1,554 wt. ppm, brittle-like behavior was observed at a hoop strain of 2.5%. Preliminary scoping tests at room temperature with FeCrAl tubes were conducted to imitate the pulse behavior of transient test reactors during integral tests. The preliminary FeCrAl tests are informative from the perspective of characterizing the test rig and supporting the design of integral tests for current and potentially accident tolerant cladding materials.
An experimental study of plate buckling induced by spatial temperature gradients is described. A rectangular Hastelloy-X panel is subjected to local line heating by a focused quartz heat lamp. Two parallel panel edges are maintained at constant temperature by coolant flow. Point supports provide well-defined thermal-structural boundary conditions. Test results from transient elastic and inelastic tests demonstrate that substantial panel bending occurs due to initial panel warpage and thermally induced membrane compressive stresses.