Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “performance study”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 397 records · Page 22

MO-FG-CAMPUS-JeP1-04: Evaluating DECT Vs SECT Range Differences in Proton Therapy Using Clinical Data

Purpose: Range uncertainty from X-ray CT number conversion to stopping power ratio (SPR) is one of the key factors limiting the potential of proton therapy. The large margins required for deep seated tumors degrade the organ sparing achievable with the technology. Of interest is the application of dual energy CT (DECT) to SPR estimation. In this planning study proton range differences between SECT and DECT have been quantified for brain cases. Methods: A last generation dual source DECT scanner was used to acquire SECT (150 kVp with Sn filtration) and DECT (additionally 90 kVp) scans of phantoms and 5 head trauma patients, acting as surrogate cancer patients. Phantom materials were characterized in terms of SPR in a particle beam to obtain reference values. IMPT treatment plans were generated on the basis of SECT and DECT SPR images for hypothetical brain tumors using a short and a long beam path. Range differences between SECT and DECT from plan recalculations were evaluated in beam-eye-view (BEV) by comparing the 80% isodose. Results: For the 18 phantom materials the SECT RMS SPR errors were 2.6% compared to 1.1% for DECT. Group median relative range differences between SECT and DECT plans were −1.0% for the short beam path over the 5 patients investigated in this study. For the long beam path the median difference was −1.4%. These relative range differences corresponded to −0.5 mm and −1.4 mm shifts respectively. Conclusion: This is the first study performing proton therapy treatment planning on DECT patient images. Important range differences of more than 1 mm were observed between SECT and DECT treatment plans, and DECT SPR accuracy was found superior on the basis of phantom measurements. While the patients investigated in this study did not have brain tumors, the findings we observed should apply to cancer patients. Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (MAP); Bundesministerium fur Bildung und Forschung (01IB13001)

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

CTBT infrasound network performance to detect the 2013 Russian fireball event

The explosive fragmentation of the 2013 Chelyabinsk meteorite generated a large airburst with an equivalent yield of 500 kT TNT. It is the most energetic event recorded by the infrasound component of the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty-International Monitoring System (CTBT-IMS), globally detected by 20 out of 42 operational stations. This study performs a station-by-station estimation of the IMS detection capability to explain infrasound detections and nondetections from short to long distances, using the Chelyabinsk meteorite as global reference event. Investigated parameters influencing the detection capability are the directivity of the line source signal, the ducting of acoustic energy, and the individual noise conditions at each station. Findings include a clear detection preference for stations perpendicular to the meteorite trajectory, even over large distances. Only a weak influence of stratospheric ducting is observed for this low-frequency case. As a result, a strong dependence on the diurnal variability of background noise levels at each station is observed, favoring nocturnal detections.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

Cytogenetic follow-up studies on humans with internal and external exposure to ionizing radiation

Cells exposed to ionizing radiation have a wide spectrum of DNA lesions that include DNA single-strand breaks, DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), oxidative base damage and DNA-protein crosslinks. Among them, DSB is the most critical lesion, which when mis-repaired leads to unstable and stable chromosome aberrations. Currently, chromosome aberration analysis is the preferred method for biological monitoring of radiation-exposed humans. Here, stable chromosome aberrations, such as inversions and balanced translocations, persist in the peripheral blood lymphocytes of radiation-exposed humans for several years and, therefore, are potentially useful tools to prognosticate the health risks of radiation exposure, particularly in the hematopoietic system. In this review, we summarize the cytogenetic follow-up studies performed by REAC/TS (Radiation Emergency Assistance Center/Training site, Oak Ridge, USA) on humans exposed to internal and external radiation. In the light of our observations as well as the data existing in the literature, this review attempts to highlight the importance of follow-up studies for predicting the extent of genomic instability and its impact on delayed health risks in radiation-exposed victims.

61 RADIATION PROTECTION AND DOSIMETRY↗

Comparative Energetics of Various Membrane Distillation Configurations and Guidelines for Design and Operation

This paper presents a comparative performance study of single-stage desalination processes with major configurations of membrane distillation (MD) modules. MD modules covered in this study are (a) direct contact MD (DCMD), (b) vacuum MD (VMD), (c) sweeping gas MD (SGMD), and (d) air gap MD (AGMD). MD-based desalination processes are simulated with rigorous theoretical MD models supported by molecular thermodynamic property models for the accurate calculation of performance metrics. The performance metrics considered in MD systems are permeate flux and energy efficiency, i.e., gained output ratio (GOR). A general criterion is established to determine the critical length of these four MDs (at fixed width) for the feasible operation of desalination in a wide range of feed salinities. The length of DCMD and VMD is restricted by the feed salinity and permeate flux, respectively, while relatively large AGMD and SGMD are allowed. The sensitivity of GOR flux with respect to permeate conditions is investigated for different MD configurations. AGMD outperforms other configurations in terms of energy efficiency, while VMD reveals the highest permeate production. With larger MD modules, utilization of thermal energy supplied by the hot feed for evaporation is in the order of VMD > AGMD > SGMD > DCMD. Simulation results highlight that energy efficiency of the overall desalination process relies on the efficient recovery of spent for evaporation, suggesting potential improvement in energy efficiency for VMD-based desalination.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Combustion chemistry and an evolving transportation fuel environment.

The world currently faces tremendous energy challenges stemming from the need to curb potentially catastrophic anthropogenic climate change. In addition, many nations, including the United States, recognize increasing political and economic risks associated with dependence on uncertain and limited energy sources. For these and other reasons the chemical composition of transportation fuels is changing, both through introduction of nontraditional fossil sources, such as oil sands-derived fuels in the US stream, and through broader exploration of biofuels. At the same time the need for clean and efficient combustion is leading engine research towards advanced low-temperature combustion strategies that are increasingly sensitive to this changing fuel chemistry, particularly in the areas of pollutant formation and autoignition. I will highlight the new demands that advanced engine technologies and evolving fuel composition place on investigations of fundamental reaction chemistry. I will focus on recent progress in measuring product formation in elementary reactions by tunable synchrotron photoionization, on the elucidation of pressure-dependent effects in the reactions of alkyl and substituted alkyl radicals with O{sub 2}, and on new combined efforts in fundamental combustion chemistry and engine performance studies of novel potential biofuels.

33 ADVANCED PROPULSION SYSTEMS↗

Probing substrate water access through the O1 channel of Photosystem II by single site mutations and membrane inlet mass spectrometry

Abstract Light-driven water oxidation by photosystem II sustains life on Earth by providing the electrons and protons for the reduction of CO 2 to carbohydrates and the molecular oxygen we breathe. The inorganic core of the oxygen evolving complex is made of the earth-abundant elements manganese, calcium and oxygen (Mn 4 CaO 5 cluster), and is situated in a binding pocket that is connected to the aqueous surrounding via water-filled channels that allow water intake and proton egress. Recent serial crystallography and infrared spectroscopy studies performed with PSII isolated fromThermosynechococcus vestitus(T. vestitus) support that one of these channels, the O1 channel, facilitates water access to the Mn 4 CaO 5 cluster during its S 2 →S 3 and S 3 →S 4 →S 0 state transitions, while a subsequent CryoEM study concluded that this channel is blocked in the cyanobacteriumSynechocystis sp.PCC 6803, questioning the role of the O1 channel in water delivery. Employing site-directed mutagenesis we modified the two O1 channel bottleneck residues D1-E329 and CP43-V410 (T. vestitusnumbering) and probed water access and substrate exchange via time resolved membrane inlet mass spectrometry. Our data demonstrates that water reaches the Mn 4 CaO 5 cluster via the O1 channel in both wildtype and mutant PSII. In addition, the detailed analysis provides functional insight into the intricate protein-water-cofactor network near the Mn 4 CaO 5 cluster that includes the pentameric, near planar ‘water wheel’ of the O1 channel.

Plant Sciences↗

Geometric Scale-up Experiments on Fluidization of Geldart B Glass Beads

The objective of this work is to provide a valuable database from controlled experiments for validating computational models. Recently, coarse-grained techniques such as particle-in-cell (PIC) or coarse-grained discrete element modeling (DEM) have gained popularity due to their computational efficiency while modeling large-scale systems; however, the influence of model parameters and their sensitivities at different geometric scales and flow conditions remain to be analyzed. These datasets are critical for the multiphase flow research community to assess predictive capability of modeling techniques as well as elucidate the hydrodynamic behavior in these systems. This study performed fluidization experiments using three different test sections with internal diameters of 2.5, 4, and 6 in. The operating conditions, bed material, and range of flow velocities at the inlet were constant in all the units, which were not hydrodynamically scaled. Glass beads having a Sauter Mean Diameter of 332 μm were used. Superficial velocity was varied from 2.97 to 5.35 times the minimum fluidization velocity and the initial static bed height was 0.1524 m. The order in which the experiments were performed was randomized and replicates were included to provide uncertainty in measurements. Statistics of differential pressure and bed height from these tests were reported. Future plans include validating PIC methodology in the open-source software, MFiX (Multiphase Flow with Interphase Exchanges) using results from this study. This could further be extended to determine optimal model parameters using inverse techniques such as deterministic calibration or Bayesian inference.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Geometric Scale-up Experiments on Fluidization of Geldart B Glass Beads

The objective of this work is to provide a valuable database from controlled experiments for validating computational models. Recently, coarse-grained techniques such as particle-in-cell (PIC) or coarse-grained discrete element modeling (DEM) have gained popularity due to their computational efficiency while modeling large-scale systems; however, the influence of model parameters and their sensitivities at different geometric scales and flow conditions remain to be analyzed. These datasets are critical for the multiphase flow research community to assess predictive capability of modeling techniques as well as elucidate the hydrodynamic behavior in these systems. This study performed fluidization experiments using three different test sections with internal diameters of 2.5, 4, and 6 in. The operating conditions, bed material, and range of flow velocities at the inlet were constant in all the units, which were not hydrodynamically scaled. Glass beads having a Sauter Mean Diameter of 332 μm were used. Superficial velocity was varied from 2.97 to 5.35 times the minimum fluidization velocity and the initial static bed height was 0.1524 m. The order in which the experiments were performed was randomized and replicates were included to provide uncertainty in measurements. Statistics of differential pressure and bed height from these tests were reported. Future plans include validating PIC methodology in the open-source software, MFiX (Multiphase Flow with Interphase Exchanges) using results from this study. This could further be extended to determine optimal model parameters using inverse techniques such as deterministic calibration or Bayesian inference.

42 ENGINEERING↗

A Glimpse into Photodetachment Spectra of Giant and Nested Fullerene Anions

We focus on the study of the photodetachment of bare, i.e., single-cage (CN)− as well as nested (multi-cage) (CN@CM@…)− singly charged fullerene anions. We calculate the attached electron’s wavefunctions, energies, oscillator strengths and photodetachment cross sections of the C60−, C240−, C540−, (C60@C240)−, (C60@C540)−, (C240@C540)− and (C60@C240@C540)− fullerene anions, where the attached electron is captured into the ground s-state by the resultant external field provided by all fullerene cages in the anion. The goal is to gain insight into the changes in behavior ofphotodetachment of this valence electron as a function of the different geometries and potentials of the various underlying fullerenes or nested fullerenes (fullerene onions) both due to their increasing size and due to “stuffing” of a larger bare fullerene with smaller fullerenes. To meet this goal, we opt for a simple semi-empirical approximation to this problem: we approximate each individual fullerene cage by a rigid potential sphere of a certain inner radius, thickness and potential depth, as in numerous other model studies performed to date. The results reveal a number of rather significant differences in the wavefunctions, oscillator strengths and photodetachment cross sections among these fullerene anions, some of which are completely counter-intuitive. The results obtained can serve as a “zeroth-order-touchstone” for future studies of single-cage and nested fullerene anions by more rigorous theories and/or experiments to build upon this work to assess the importance of interactions omitted in the present study.

Dolmatov, Valeriy K.↗

Iodine recombination in xenon solvent: Clusters in the gas to liquid-like state transition

Supercritical fluids (SCFs) have attracted significant attention as solvents for chemical reactions due to their unique properties, such as high diffusivity, low viscosity, and tunable solvation properties. These properties profoundly influence reaction kinetics and are often attributed to the formation of molecular clusters within SCFs. To study the effect of supercritical solvent on chemical reactivity and dynamics of reactions, one needs to understand the dynamics of clusters in supercritical fluid. Extensive experiments on the photodissociation and recombination of iodine in supercritical fluids served as a model system for understanding these effects. Experimental studies have been complemented by theoretical and computational investigations, which mostly employ Monte Carlo or empirical molecular dynamics simulations. However, computational studies using non-reactive force fields and ab initio approaches present challenges in capturing reactive processes at larger scales within supercritical fluids. Here, in this work, we developed the ReaxFF parameters by training against quantum mechanics data. ReaxFF reactive force field based molecular dynamics simulations were performed, studying the dynamics of a xenon solvent and cage effect at different thermodynamic conditions for the iodine recombination reaction. We show that the conditions near the critical point are the optimal conditions to study the cage effect. We show that the average lifetime of xenon clusters ranging between 5 and 11 ps is comparable to iodine geminate recombination. Our simulation results of iodine recombination in xenon solvent demonstrate the higher probability of iodine molecule formation in the presence of xenon clusters. Finally, we show that the supercritical condition exhibits the highest recombination rate for iodine atoms.

Cage effect↗

Hydrogen underground storage for grid electricity storage: An optimization study on techno-economic analysis

Here, this study performs a techno-economic analysis of hydrogen underground storage systems for grid electricity storage, evaluating their economic viability at the plant scale using dynamic optimization. It explores the feasibility of various system configurations and revenue models in the context of volatile electricity prices and the necessity for multiple revenue streams. The hypothesis tested is that large-scale hydrogen storage, despite its low round-trip efficiency, can be economically viable with the right mix of revenue streams. This study uses scenario-based analysis to assess the impacts of different system configurations, including engaging in time-shifting arbitrage, ancillary service markets and blending hydrogen with natural gas. Results indicate potential annual net cash flows of up to $\$$1.5 million from ancillary services integration and $\$$5.2 million from natural gas blending, contingent on specific system sizes. The study concludes that hydrogen underground storage for grid electricity storage can be profitable, and emphasizes that proper system design and precise electricity price forecasting are crucial for optimizing system performance and economic returns. This research sets the stage for further investigations into the scalability of hydrogen storage systems and their broader implications for grid electricity storage and energy market dynamics.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

(U) Status of Trinity and Crossroads Systems

(U) This paper provides a general overview of current and future plans for the Advanced Simulation and Computing (ASC) Advanced Technology (AT) systems fielded by the New Mexico Alliance for Computing at Extreme Scale (ACES), a collaboration between Los Alamos Laboratory and Sandia National Laboratories. Additionally, this paper touches on research of technology beyond traditional CMOS. The status of Trinity, ASCs first AT system, and Crossroads, anticipated to succeed Trinity as the third AT system in 2020 will be presented, along with initial performance studies of the Intel Knights Landing Xeon Phi processors, introduced on Trinity. The challenges and opportunities for our production simulation codes on AT systems will also be discussed. Trinity and Crossroads are a joint procurement by ACES and Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory as part of the Alliance for application Performance at EXtreme scale (APEX) http://apex.lanl.gov.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Space Charge Forces analytical model for emittance compensation

Space charge forces represent main induced effects in an RF-injector that degrade the beam quality. In this scenario the laser distribution sent on the photocathode acquires an important role in the emittance compensation process, as the slice analysis shows. Starting from the preliminary studies performed on [1], a novel semi-analytical model of space charge forces is proposed in detail for bunch with arbitrary charge distribution to derive expressions of self-induced forces. The performance of the fields at low energy regime (as the field has not expired RF forces) is under present analysis, we can investigate use of this model in low charge regime. Further, the model has been bench-marked with the behavior of the distributions present in the literature and studied for new ones. It has also been applied for the study of the optimization of a C-band hybrid photoinjector now being commissioned, thus explaining the factor two reduction of the emittance observed at the exit of the gun by changing the initial distribution at the cathode.

Carillo, M.↗

Overview of Collaborative Research Between UNICAMP in Brazil and Fermilab in Cryogenics

The Long-Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF) situated at the Sanford Underground Research Facility (SURF) in Lead, South Dakota, serves as the host for the Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE), employing cryostats with nearly 70,000 metric tons of high purity liquid argon (LAr). The integrity of LAr quality is pivotal in determining the electron lifetime within DUNE, directly impacting its signal-to-noise ratio. Specifically, Far Detector 1 (FD-1) in cryostat 1 requires an electron lifetime over 3 ms within its 3.5 m drift, corresponding to less than 100 parts-per-trillion (ppt) Oxygen equivalent contamination. Far Detector 2 (FD-2) in cryostat 2 demands over 6 ms electron lifetime within its 6.0 m drift, corresponding to less than 50 ppt Oxygen equivalent contamination. Nitrogen (N2) absorption of LAr scintillation light, known as quenching, necessitates N2 contamination in LAr to remain below 1 ppm to minimize photon loss and enhance energy reconstruction. Studies indicate that at 1 ppm N2, approximately 20% of scintillation light is lost, highlighting the importance of minimizing N2 contamination. Brazil State University of Campinas's (UNICAMP) contribution to LBNF focuses on developing argon purification and regeneration for DUNE FD-1 and FD-2. To that effect, they constructed a test facility to perform studies on LAr purification at a smaller scale, the Purification Liquid Argon Cryostat (PuLArC) with approximately 90 liters of LAr. One of the filtration materials was considered and tested Li-FAU molecular sieve. Value engineering on argon purification media was conducted, leading to the identification of Li-FAU zeolite's ability to effectively capture N2 impurities during LAr circulation. Testing at UNICAMP's PuLArC facility demonstrated that 1 kg of Li-FAU is capable of reducing N2 contamination from 20-50 ppm to 0.1-1.0 ppm within 1-2 hours of circulation. In October 2023, testing at the Iceberg cryostat in Fermilab's Noble Liquid Test Facility (NLTF), with approximately 2,625 liters of LAr, confirmed the efficacy of 3 kg of Li-FAU in reducing N2 contamination from ~ 5 ppm of injected N2 down to less than 1 ppm over 96-hour cycles, showcasing its potential for larger-scale LAr cryostats. Further tests are planned to validate Li-FAU's use as a possible alternative to Molecular Sieve 4A in LBNF-DUNE and related liquid argon experiments. This contribution will describe how the research was performed and present the test setups and results in detail. This advancement not only has the potential to enhance DUNE's precision but also to elevate liquid argon experiments globally, showcasing the power of international scientific collaboration.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Experimental Data Sets for CFD Calculations of Flow and Heat Transfer in Deformed Fuel Assemblies

Liquid-metal fast-breeder reactors (LMFBRs) have traditionally used fuel assemblies consisting of a hexagonal array of pins enclosed in a hexagonally shaped duct. Each fuel pin is surrounded by a wire that is wrapped in a helical configuration, which is used to separate the pins sufficiently to allow sodium coolant to flow through the assembly. The helical wire wrap also promotes mixing of the coolant. Experience with these assemblies has shown that they begin to deform with time during normal operation leading to significant changes in core thermal-hydraulics. For example, deformations of assemblies in the Experimental Breeder Reactor-2 and the Fast Flux Test Facility led to pin overheating resulting from pin-to-duct and pin-to-pin contact. This problem is well known and was investigated extensively in the 1970's and early 1980's. This was a period, however, before the development of modern Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) computer codes. Therefore, the experiments performed at the time did not record their results in sufficient detail to be useful for compiling validation datasets for CFD codes. Most of the experiments focused only on bulk measurements, such as the pressure drop across the bundle. When the effects of deformation of the fuel assembly were investigated, the studies performed to quantify these effects considered only bare pins without the wire wrap. With the resurgence of interest in LMFBRs in recent years, particularly in designs that leverage long-life performance of the fuel, the need has arisen for data that are suitable for the validation and benchmarking of CFD codes to predict the thermal-hydraulic behavior of flow in wire-wrapped fuel bundles. Such data must include high-resolution, transient, full-field measurements of the fluid velocity and temperature and an accurate record of the test conditions, including a precise description of the geometry. This paper describes a project to produce a validation-quality set of data that can be used to benchmark CFD codes for modeling flow and thermal performance in wire-wrapped fuel assemblies of the kind used by LMFBR designs. In addition, this effort investigates the changes to the flow and other phenomena that occur in the deformed geometries that can form later in a fuel assembly's life. This work is a joint effort of four organizations. The experimental work is being performed by AREVA and Texas A and M University. The computational work, both to support the experiments and to perform blind benchmark calculations, is being done by TerraPower, LLC, and Argonne National Laboratory (ANL). The experiments use a geometry that consists of a complete assembly of 61 wire-wrapped pins, which is surrounded by a hexagonal duct. This configuration is considered the minimum size necessary to adequately capture the important results of interest, such as the thermal gradients across the assembly and the velocity field effects in the assembly resulting from the surrounding duct. These types of effects cannot be captured by a geometry consisting of only a small group of fuel pins. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Helium bubble evolution in a Zr–Sn–Nb–Fe–Cr alloy during post-annealing: An in-situ investigation

The formation of helium bubbles is considered to be detrimental to the mechanical performance of the nuclear materials. The growth behaviors of helium bubbles in a helium ion implanted Zr–Sn–Nb–Fe–Cr alloy with respect to the helium fluence and subsequently annealing procedure were investigated by in-situ transmission electron microscopy. In the as-implanted sample, the measured size distributions of the helium bubbles are consistent with the simulated helium concentrations. Moreover, the mean size of the helium bubbles increases with the increase of the irradiation temperatures and the helium fluence. The in-situ heating study performed in a transmission electron microscope indicates that the mean size of the helium bubbles increase slowly below 923 K and dramatically above 923 K. The coarsening mechanism of the helium bubbles in the alloy is suggested based on the study. - Highlights: • Helium bubble growth in zirconium with annealing was in-situ investigated in TEM. • The mean helium bubble size increase with helium fluence and annealing temperature. • Helium bubble size distribution is same as that of helium concentration by SRIM. • Mean bubble size increases slowly and quickly with temperature below and above 923 K. • The growth mechanism of the helium bubbles in Zr alloy has been discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

COMPARATIVE STUDY OF ASYMMETRY ORIGIN OF GALAXIES IN DIFFERENT ENVIRONMENTS. II. NEAR-INFRARED OBSERVATIONS

In this second paper of two analyses, we present near-infrared (NIR) morphological and asymmetry studies performed in a sample of 92 galaxies found in different density environments: galaxies in compact groups (CGs; HCGs in the Hickson Catalog of Compact Groups of Galaxies), isolated pairs of galaxies (KPGs in Karachentsev's list of isolated pairs of galaxies), and isolated galaxies (KIGs in Karachentseva's Catalog of Isolated Galaxies). Both studies have proved useful for identifying the effect of interactions on galaxies. In the NIR, the properties of the galaxies in HCGs, KPGs, and KIGs are more similar than they are in the optical. This is because the NIR band traces the older stellar populations, which formed earlier and are more relaxed than the younger populations. However, we found asymmetries related to interactions in both KPG and HCG samples. In HCGs, the fraction of asymmetric galaxies is even higher than what we found in the optical. In the KPGs the interactions look like very recent events, while in the HCGs galaxies are more morphologically evolved and show properties suggesting they suffered more frequent interactions. The key difference seems to be the absence of star formation in the HCGs; while interactions produce intense star formation in the KPGs, we do not see this effect in the HCGs. This is consistent with the dry merger hypothesis; the interaction between galaxies in CGs is happening without the presence of gas. If the gas was spent in stellar formation (to build the bulge of the numerous early-type galaxies), then the HCGs possibly started interacting sometime before the KPGs. On the other hand, the dry interaction condition in CGs suggests that the galaxies are on merging orbits, and consequently such system cannot be that much older either. Cosmologically speaking, the difference in formation time between pairs of galaxies and CGs may be relatively small. The two phenomena are typical of the formation of structures in low-density environments. Their formation represents relatively recent events.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗