Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “COMPARATIVE TESTING”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 361 records · Page 20

Integrated Mecical Model (IMM) 4.0 Verification and Validation (VV) Testing (HRP IWS 2016)

Timeline, partial treatment, and alternate medications were added to the IMM to improve the fidelity of this model to enhance decision support capabilities. Using standard design reference missions, IMM VV testing compared outputs from the current operational IMM (v3) with those from the model with added functionalities (v4). These new capabilities were examined in a comparative, stepwise approach as follows: a) comparison of the current operational IMM v3 with the enhanced functionality of timeline alone (IMM 4.T), b) comparison of IMM 4.T with the timeline and partial treatment (IMM 4.TPT), and c) comparison of IMM 4.TPT with timeline, partial treatment and alternative medication (IMM 4.0).

risk assessment↗

Analysis of GMO Plum Plant Culture in System Operations Failure

GMO plum trees are being evaluated at the Kennedy Space Center as a possible candidate for future space crops. Previously conducted horticultural testing compared the performance of several plum genotypes in controlled environment chambers, resulting in a down-selection to the NASA-11 genotype. Precursory studies determined the water use requirements to sustain the plants as well as the feasibility of grafting non-GMO plum scions onto GMO plum rootstocks of NASA-5, NASA-10, and NASA-11 genotypes. This study follows the growth and horticultural progress of plum trees and in-vitro cultures from August 2017 to November 2017, and provides supplemental support for future GMO plum studies. The presence of Hurricane Irma in early September 2017 resulted in the plants undergoing material deterioration from major changes to their overall horticultural progress.

life support↗

Nutrient Stability in NASA Spaceflight Experiment Rodent Food Bars

Nutrient-upgraded Rodent Food Bars are the standard diet for mice involved in spaceflight experiments aboard the International Space Station as part of NASA’s Rodent Research Project. These Food Bars are a twin-screw extruded AIN-93G based product with nutrient additives to preserve a healthy and complete diet for the animals, and the bar form factor is necessary for use in the microgravity environment. Due to the nature of NASA flight projects and the lengthy production process of these Food Bars, a shelf-life assessment was undertaken to determine nutrient stability over an extended storage time. To assess palatability and stability over an extended duration, a panel of lipid oxidation markers and both fat- and water-soluble vitamins were assessed under various time and temperature conditions via AOAC International standardized methodology. Thiamine was the least stable vitamin at room temperature. Bars that had been continually kept at 4C (t=6, 12, 27 months) showed significantly higher levels of thiamine (via Student’s t-test) compared to all other bars that underwent some degree of ambient temperature storage. This suggests that refrigeration is a key component in maintaining adequate nutrient levels in these relatively high moisture (average 29.3%) food bars. Also of note was the level of Vitamin A in the form of retinol. There was no correlation to storage temperature, but rather the only factor having an effect on retinol levels was time. As low, yet consistent decrease in retinol was observed over the course of the experiment, though at no time did the retinol levels drop below the rodent Nutrient Requirements for Laboratory Animals (NRC). In conclusion, over the 27-month time course, all analyzed vitamins and lipid oxidation factors remained relatively stable and at levels which provide fully sufficient nutrition to rodents during spaceflight. Some groups however, displayed higher-than-expected aerobic and anaerobic bacteria colony forming units, which is believed to stem from a since-revised handling technique.

Food↗

An Approach to Shape Parameterization Using Laboratory Hypervelocity Impact Experiments

NASA’s Orbital Debris Program Office relies on laboratory-based impact tests to supplement the measurement data of on-orbit events that defines the orbital debris environment. These experiments provide information that is essential to interpreting the radar and optical measurements of orbital fragmentation events into useful metrics, such as characteristic size of the debris, and to providing a better understanding of the distributions of fragment populations in terms of their masses, material constituents, fragment densities, cross-sectional areas, area-to-mass ratios, shapes, etc. The Satellite Orbital Debris Characterization Impact Test (SOCIT) was a notable laboratory impact experiment conducted in 1992 using a surplus U.S. Navy Transit navigation satellite of the 1960s. The data from this ground-based experiment were combined with on-orbit measurements to develop the NASA Standard Satellite Breakup Model (SSBM). To account for advancements in satellite design and construction since, a new impact test series – DebriSat – was conducted in 2014. This test utilized a high-fidelity mock-up spacecraft that better represents the materials and construction techniques used to design and manufacture modern spacecraft. Together, these tests offer valuable data to model an orbital debris environment composed of legacy and modern spacecraft. This paper presents an overview of the two laboratory impact tests, comparing their fragment parameter distributions with each other and with relevant distributions from the NASA SSBM. The categorization and descriptions of fragment shapes are of significant interest for future work, yet there are marked differences in the definitions of shape categories between each dataset. The categorizations of constituent materials, and the measurement techniques employed to populate these two datasets, are also different. New rubrics simplify and equate the categorizations between datasets to aid comparative analyses and to facilitate the potential use of both datasets in tandem with future environmental debris models. A preferred approach to classifying shape across disparate datasets uses the characteristic-length dimensions, and a simplified shape classification based on physical, solid-body dimensions, to mathematically construct an encapsulating right-circular cylinder that represents the fragment. The ratio of cylinder length-to-diameter (L:D) then provides a single continuum value for shape that is strongly correlated with its designated shape and size. This metric can then be used to further assess the distribution of shape with populations of other fragment characteristics within these datasets. The shape parameterization using the L:D ratios of right-circular cylinders is discussed.

John H. Seago↗

An Approach to Shape Parameterization Using Laboratory Hypervelocity Impact Experiments

NASA’s Orbital Debris Program Office relies on laboratory-based impact tests to supplement the measurement data of on-orbit events that defines the orbital debris environment. These experiments provide information that is essential to interpreting the radar and optical measurements of orbital fragmentation events into useful metrics, such as characteristic size of the debris, and to providing a better understanding of the distributions of fragment populations in terms of their masses, material constituents, fragment densities, cross-sectional areas, area-to-mass ratios, shapes, etc. The Satellite Orbital Debris Characterization Impact Test (SOCIT) was a notable laboratory impact experiment conducted in 1992 using a surplus U.S. Navy Transit navigation satellite of the 1960s. The data from this ground-based experiment were combined with on-orbit measurements to develop the NASA Standard Satellite Breakup Model (SSBM). To account for advancements in satellite design and construction since, a new impact test series – DebriSat – was conducted in 2014. This test utilized a high-fidelity mock-up spacecraft that better represents the materials and construction techniques used to design and manufacture modern spacecraft. Together, these tests offer valuable data to model an orbital debris environment composed of legacy and modern spacecraft. This paper presents an overview of the two laboratory impact tests, comparing their fragment parameter distributions with each other and with relevant distributions from the NASA SSBM. The categorization and descriptions of fragment shapes are of significant interest for future work, yet there are marked differences in the definitions of shape categories between each dataset. The categorizations of constituent materials, and the measurement techniques employed to populate these two datasets, are also different. New rubrics simplify and equate the categorizations between datasets to aid comparative analyses and to facilitate the potential use of both datasets in tandem with future environmental debris models. A preferred approach to classifying shape across disparate datasets uses the characteristic-length dimensions, and a simplified shape classification based on physical, solid-body dimensions, to mathematically construct an encapsulating right-circular cylinder that represents the fragment. The ratio of cylinder length-to-diameter (L:D) then provides a single continuum value for shape that is strongly correlated with its designated shape and size. This metric can then be used to further assess the distribution of shape with populations of other fragment characteristics within these datasets. The shape parameterization using the L:D ratios of right-circular cylinders is discussed.

John H Seago↗

Modified Autogenic Feedback Training Produces Effect on Motion Sickness

Motion sickness is a common physiological reaction to provocative motion and is characterized by a constellation of symptoms, including stomach awareness, nausea, emesis, pallor, sweating, hypersalivation, and fatigue. The emergence of these symptoms can pose a significant threat to safety, particularly in the context of aviation. Given its prevalence among aviators and its detrimental impact on performance, researchers have endeavored to identify effective countermeasures for motion sickness. Currently, many of the existing interventions are pharmacological in nature and while effective, they present a problem due to their associated adverse side effects. A modified two-hour version of Autogenic Feedback Training Exercise (AFTE) could be an effective countermeasure to motion sickness without adverse side effects. AFTE combines principles of autogenic therapy, biofeedback, and learning to teach individuals to control their own internal physiological reactions through a series of relaxation and arousal exercises. AFTE was administered over six days. On the first day, participants were exposed to provocative motion via a rotating chair test to collect baseline physiological data. AFTE sessions were conducted on four consecutive days and lasted approximately 30 minutes each session. Participants were exposed to the rotating chair again on the 6th day. Results: Participants (n = 16) were evaluated on the number of rotations experienced and cumulative minutes spun in the chair. Participants tended to ride longer (M = 21.0 min, SD = 16.56) and tolerated more rotations (M = 244.8 rotations, SD = 310.62) on their second rotating chair test compared to baseline (M = 14.0 min, SD = 9.35; M = 125.8 rotations, SD = 124.08; t(15) = 2.21, p = .02). A moderate effect size was recorded (Hedges’s g = 0.44). A modified two-hour version of the AFTE is effective at increasing tolerance of symptoms associated with motion sickness.

motion sickness↗

Multi-Dimensional Compliance of Soft Grippers Enables Gentle Interaction with Thin, Flexible Objects

In this paper, we discuss the role of gripper compliance in successful grasping and manipulation of thin, flexible materials. We show, both conceptually and empirically, that each axis of compliance in a planar gripper provides unique benefits in this domain. Vertical compliance allows robust grasping of thin materials in the presence of large uncertainty in positioning. Lateral compliance increases opportunity to respond to unexpected snags by increasing the time window over which tensile forces are applied. Rotational compliance avoids damage to objects by decreasing the maximum tensile forces applied during snags. We explore these three benefits through empirical tests comparing a rigid gripper to a soft gripper, evaluating the level of vertical uncertainty each can handle for prehensile and non-prehensile manipulation, as well as the forces and displacements incurred during snags. The results show how a soft gripper’s three-axis compliance provides a passive ability to prevent damage to delicate materials.

Clark B. Teeple↗

ConnectX-2 CORE-Direct Enabled Asynchronous Broadcast Collective Communications

This paper describes the design and implementation of InfiniBand (IB) CORE-Direct based blocking and nonblocking broadcast operations within the Cheetah collective operation framework. It describes a novel approach that fully ofFLoads collective operations and employs only user-supplied buffers. For a 64 rank communicator, the latency of CORE-Direct based hierarchical algorithm is better than production-grade Message Passing Interface (MPI) implementations, 150% better than the default Open MPI algorithm and 115% better than the shared memory optimized MVAPICH implementation for a one kilobyte (KB) message, and for eight mega-bytes (MB) it is 48% and 64% better, respectively. Flat-topology broadcast achieves 99.9% overlap in a polling based communication-computation test, and 95.1% overlap for a wait based test, compared with 92.4% and 17.0%, respectively, for a similar Central Processing Unit (CPU) based implementation.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗

Neutron Damage in Mechanically-Cooled High-Purity Germanium Detectors for Field-Portable Prompt Gamma Neutron Activation Analysis (PGNAA) Systems

Prompt Gamma Neutron Activation (PGNAA) systems require the use of a gamma-ray spectrometer to record the gamma-ray spectrum of an object under test and allow the determination of the object’s composition. Field-portable systems, such as Idaho National Laboratory’s PINS system, have used standard liquid-nitrogen-cooled high-purity germanium (HPGe) detectors to perform this function. These detectors have performed very well in the past, but the requirement of liquid-nitrogen cooling limits their use to areas where liquid nitrogen is readily available or produced on-site. Also, having a relatively large volume of liquid nitrogen close to the detector can impact some assessments, possibly leading to a false detection of explosives or other nitrogen-containing chemical. Use of a mechanically-cooled HPGe detector is therefore very attractive for PGNAA applications where nitrogen detection is critical or where liquid-nitrogen logistics are problematic. Mechanically-cooled HPGe detectors constructed from p-type germanium, such as Ortec’s trans-SPEC, have been commercially available for several years. In order to assess whether these detectors would be suitable for use in a fielded PGNAA system, Idaho National Laboratory (INL) has been performing a number of tests of the resistance of mechanically-cooled HPGe detectors to neutron damage. These detectors have been standard commercially-available p-type HPGe detectors as well as prototype n-type HPGe detectors. These tests compare the performance of these different detector types as a function of crystal temperature and incident neutron fluence on the crystal.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

A Collimated CZT Detector for Quantitative Gamma Assays - 17250

Cadmium-Zinc-Telluride [CZT] detectors for gamma spectroscopic measurements and room-temperature operation have had a long history of promising good performance. Very small detectors [0.05-0.5 cm{sup 3}] have been commercially available for many years, but their small size creates problems for spectroscopy because of very low photopeak efficiency, especially at medium and high energies. Large CZT [4-6 cm{sup 3}] detectors have been shown to work nicely in a research environment when complicated electronic and data processing algorithms are applied. We report here test results from a commercially available 1 cubic centimeter CZT detector housed in a portable custom Tungsten shield with a set of collimators with different apertures. The detector has 2-2.5% FWHM resolution at Cs-137 energies, and near-Gaussian shaped peaks. Efficiency calibrations can be quickly made for a wide variety of geometries using the ISOCS mathematical efficiency software. We show successful validation tests comparing accuracy of measurements on reference calibration point sources, line sources, and 200 liter drums. The low weight of the device [9 kg including the shield and collimator] and low power [powered via USB from the PC] makes these devices particularly suitable for human-deployed in-situ measurements of large objects containing medium levels of activity - e.g. characterization of objects encountered during decommissioning, emergency response, truck alarm investigation, or waste being shipped to a disposal facility. (authors)

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗

Fabrication and Properties of Advanced Ceramic Technetium Waste Forms - 17311

Technetium-99 (Tc, t{sub 1/2} = 2.13 x 10{sup 5} years) is a challenge from a nuclear waste perspective and is one of the most abundant, long-lived radioisotopes found in used nuclear fuel (UNF). Within the Hanford Tank Waste Treatment and Immobilization Plant, technetium volatilises at typical glass melting temperature, is captured in the off-gas treatment system and recycled back into the feed to eventually increase Tc-loadings of the glass. In this research we are providing a technical solution for continuously depleting the Tc-content of the glass melter feed by precipitating Tc from the off-gas effluents and effectively immobilizing {sup 99}Tc as durable ceramic waste form. We have developed a wet-chemical coprecipitation-based synthesis route to fabricate gram-size Tc-based pyrochlores with the model composition Sm{sub 2}(Tc{sub 0.5-x}Ru{sub x}Ti{sub 0.5}){sub 2}O{sub 7}. These ceramic Tc waste forms exhibit better technetium retention and corrosion resistance in ASTM C1220-10 based testing compared with technetium-containing LAWE4-type borosilicate glass, combined with optimal waste loading. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Effect of low-level radioactive waste leachate on antioxidant depletion in HDPE geo-membranes - 15135

Low-level radioactive waste (LLW) and mixed waste (MW) disposal facilities in the US are required to have a service life in excess of 1000 yr. Understanding the rate of degradation of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) geo-membranes (GMs) used in barriers of LLW and MW facilities is necessary to assess their service life. HDPE GMs undergo degradation in three stages: antioxidant depletion (Stage I), induction time (stage II), and polymer degradation (Stage III). For LLW and MW facilities, these degradation mechanisms must be assessed with the GM in contact with leachates representative of LLW or MW. This paper focuses on antioxidant depletion in LLW leachate. HDPE GM coupons (2-mm thick) were immersed in radioactive synthetic leachate (RSL) with chemistry representative of leachate in LLW disposal facilities operated by the US Department of Energy's environmental restoration programs. Depletion was assessed at four temperatures (25, 50, 70, and 90 deg.C). Comparative tests were conducted with non-radioactive synthetic leachate (NSL), which has the same chemistry as RSL except radionuclides are excluded. Control tests were conducted with deionized (DI) water. Specimens were removed periodically and tested to determine their mechanical and chemical properties. Antioxidant depletion was measured by both standard and high-pressure oxidative induction time (OIT) tests. The rate of antioxidant depletion in RSL is statistically no different than depletion in NSL. Extrapolating the laboratory data at elevated temperatures to a typical LLW liner at 15 deg.C via Arrhenius modeling showed that the time for antioxidant depletion for a GM in a composite liner is approximately 650 yr when exposed to LLW leachate. Actual service life of the GM will be longer. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Comparative Evaluation of Four Presumptive Tests for Blood to Detect Epithelial Injury on Fish

Current methods of fish epithelial injury detection are limited to gross macroscopic examination that has a subjective bias as well as an inability to reliably quantify the degree of injury. Fluorescein, a presumptive test for blood, has been shown to have the capability to detect and quantify fish epithelial injury. However, there are several other presumptive tests for blood (Bluestar*, phenolphthalein, and HemastixH) that may have benefits over the use of fluorescein, particularly for field research on wild fish. This study investigated the capabilities of these four tests to detect and quantify a variety of injuries commonly encountered by fish (abrasion, cuts, fin frays, and punctures) using the freshwater bluegill Lepomis macrochirus as a model. Fluorescein was consistently found to be the most reliable (i.e., detected the highest proportion of true positive results and rarely detected false positive reactions) of the four presumptive tests for blood compared. Further testing was conducted to examine the reliability of fluorescein. By 24 h after an injury was inflicted, the injury was no longer detectable by fluorescein, and when fluorescein was applied to an injured fish, the fluorescein was no longer detectable 3 h after application. In a comparison of two common anaesthetics used in fisheries research, there was no significant difference in the proportion of injury detected when 3- aminobenzoic acid ethyl ester methanesulfate (tricaine) was used compared with a clove oil and ethanol (1:9) solution. In summary, fluorescein was the most reliable presumptive test for blood examined in this study for the detection and quantification of recent (hours) fish epithelial injury.

Fluorescein, fish, epithelial damage↗

Progressive Failure Analysis Correlation with Notched Composite Laminate Test Data

Testing of small and intermediate laminate panels with notches was performed and Progressive Failure Analyses (PFA) models were developed for aid in test planning and for correlation with the test data. Two progressive damage failure models were included in the study: the commercially available Abaqus built-in damage model and COmplete STress Reduction (COSTR) damage model developed at NASA Langley Research Center (LaRC). The finite elements models used for the analysis were developed using shell elements. The pre-test PFA results obtained from the two damage models were compared to test data. Then a post-test PFA with updated material properties based on additional available material property data was executed with the COSTR damage model and compared to the test data. The panels tested in compression all exhibited less scatter in the failure load with self-similar failure behavior. The panels tested in tension exhibited more scatter in the failure load with a failure mode that included delamination of plies. However, a self-similar crack path was also observed as the overall failure mode for all panels tested. When comparing test data to the pre-test analysis results, both damage models with shell element models were considered adequate for predicting the behavior and failure load of both the small and intermediate panels when tested in compression. However, for the tension load cases, larger differences were observed between the test and analysis results. When comparing test data to the post-test analysis performed using the COSTR damage model, better correlation was observed. However, large discrepancies were still observed for the tension load cases. Consequently, a higher fidelity finite element model including solid elements for sub-laminates and the modeling of cohesive layers between sub-laminate layers is recommended for tension loading of notched composite laminates.

Damage Model,Progressive Failure Analysis,Open Hol↗

Statistical correlation analysis for comparing vibration data from test and analysis

A theory was developed to compare vibration modes obtained by NASTRAN analysis with those obtained experimentally. Because many more analytical modes can be obtained than experimental modes, the analytical set was treated as expansion functions for putting both sources in comparative form. The dimensional symmetry was developed for three general cases: nonsymmetric whole model compared with a nonsymmetric whole structural test, symmetric analytical portion compared with a symmetric experimental portion, and analytical symmetric portion with a whole experimental test. The theory was coded and a statistical correlation program was installed as a utility. The theory is established with small classical structures.

Butler, T. G.↗

Comparing the effectiveness of software testing strategies

This study compares the results of code reading, functional testing, and structural testing in three aspects of software testing: fault detection effectiveness, fault detection cost, and classes of faults detected. Thirty two professional programmers and 42 advanced students applied the three techniques to four unit-sized programs in a fractional experimental design. The major results of this study are the following: (1) With the professional programmers, code reading detected more software faults and had a higher detection rate than did functional or structural testing, while functional testing detected more faults than did structural testing, but functional and structural testing were not different in fault detection rate. (2) In one advanced student subject group, code reading and functional testing were not different in faults found, but were superior to structural testing, while in the other advanced student subject group there was no difference among the techniques. (3) With the advanced student subjects, the three techniques were not different in fault deteciton rate. (4) Number of faults observed, fault detection rate, and total effort in detection depended on the type of software tested. (5) Code reading detected more interface faults than did the other methods. (6) Functional testing detected more control faults than did the other methods. (7) When asked to estimate the percentage of faults detected, code readers gave the most accurate estimates while functional testers gave the least accurate estimates. Appendix B includes the source code for the word.

Basili, Victor R.↗

Comparisons of CFD Simulations of Icing Wind Tunnel Clouds with Experiments Conducted at the NASA Propulsions Systems Laboratory

This paper evaluates simulation predictions against experimental test data of icing clouds that were produced during 2018 ice crystal icing physics tests conducted at the NASA Propulsion Systems Laboratory icing wind tunnel. Aero-thermal and cloud parameters are set and known upstream at the tunnel inlet and spray system, but change as the cloud and air thermodynamically interact as the flowing masses reach the tunnel test section. Utilizing the ANSYS Fluent Discrete Phase Model function, 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations were performed, capturing the thermodynamic interactions between the test parameters, and providing predictions of the aero thermal and cloud conditions at the tunnel test section. Simulation predictions were compared with test data that were measured at the tunnel exit plane. Evaluations focused on the cloud concentration (total water content), humidity content, and air temperature. CFD simulation predictions showed areas of agreement and disagreement. Simulations showed that cloud concentration profiles at the test section are strongly related to the initial spray nozzle pattern used at the tunnel inlet. Experimental data suggest that greater dispersion of the cloud occurred as the simulated cloud predicted areas of high and low cloud concentration compared to test data profiles. Simulations, however, captured the magnitude and location of the change in humidity content and the change in air temperature due to the presence of the cloud reasonably well, when compared to test data. This result would suggest that while the ANSYS simulation did not fully predict the spreading of the cloud as measured during experiment, it did capture evaporation and the molecular movements of air and vapor relatively well.

CFD↗

Comparisons of CFD Simulations of Icing Wind Tunnel Clouds with Experiments Conducted at the NASA Propulsions Systems Laboratory

This paper evaluates simulation predictions against experimental test data of icing clouds that were produced during 2018 ice crystal icing physics tests conducted at the NASA Propulsion Systems Laboratory icing wind tunnel. Aero-thermal and cloud parameters are set and known upstream at the tunnel inlet and spray system, but change as the cloud and air thermodynamically interact as the flowing masses reach the tunnel test section. Utilizing the ANSYS Fluent Discrete Phase Model function, 3D computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations were performed, capturing the thermodynamic interactions between the test parameters, and providing predictions of the aero thermal and cloud conditions at the tunnel test section. Simulation predictions were compared with test data that were measured at the tunnel exit plane. Evaluations focused on the cloud concentration (total water content), humidity content, and air temperature. CFD simulation predictions showed areas of agreement and disagreement. Simulations showed that cloud concentration profiles at the test section are strongly related to the initial spray nozzle pattern used at the tunnel inlet. Experimental data suggest that greater dispersion of the cloud occurred as the simulated cloud predicted areas of high and low cloud concentration compared to test data profiles. Simulations, however, captured the magnitude and location of the change in humidity content and the change in air temperature due to the presence of the cloud reasonably well, when compared to test data. This result would suggest that while the ANSYS simulation did not fully predict the spreading of the cloud as measured during experiment, it did capture evaporation and the molecular movements of air and vapor relatively well.

CFD↗