Altering Ligand Fields in Single-Atom Sites through Second-Shell Anion Modulation Boosts the Oxygen Reduction Reaction
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The spin-state energetics of six Fe(II) molecular complexes are computed using the linear-response Hubbard U approach within DFT. The adiabatic energy differences, ΔE H-L , between the high-spin (S = 2) and the low-spin (S = 0) states are computed and compared with accurate-coupled cluster-corrected CASPT2 results. We show that DFT+U fails in correctly capturing the ground state for strong-field ligands yielding ΔE H-L that are almost constant throughout the molecular series. This bias toward high spin together with the metal/ligand charge transfer upon U correction are here quantified and explained using molecular orbital diagrams involving both σ- and π-bonding interactions. Furthermore, with increasing ligand-field strengths this bias also increases owing to the stronger molecular character of the metal/ligand Kohn–Sham orbitals thus resulting in large deviations from the reference larger than 4 eV. Smaller values of U can be employed to mitigate this effect and recover the right energetics.
Transition-metal complexes featuring metal-centered excited states have recently emerged as mechanistically distinct platforms for selective photochemistry, including photoredox catalysis. Among these, Co(III) complexes have demonstrated productive photoinduced electron transfer via the 3 T 1 metal-centered state. In contrast, photoreactivity from the 5 T 2 metal-centered state in Fe(II) polypyridyl complexes remains limited. Building on our prior report concerning reactivity associated with the 5 T 2 state in [Fe(tren(py) 3 )] 2+ (tren(py) 3 = tris(2-pyridylmethyliminoethyl)-amine), we introduced stronger-field ligands in an effort to increase excited-state energies of Fe(II) polypyridyl complexes and enhance reactivity. Despite achieving nanosecond-scale excited-state lifetimes and favorable thermodynamic driving forces, no photoreactivity was observed. Reinvestigation of the observations previously reported for [Fe(tren(py) 3 )] 2+ revealed interactions between the metal complex and the substrate in their respective ground states that mimicked dynamic quenching of the chromophore, prompting a reassessment of mechanistic considerations inherent in leveraging reductive chemistry from the 5 T 2 excited state of Fe(II). Our analysis indicates that electron transfer from the 5 T 2 excited state of a low-spin d6 metal is subject to significant barriers both in terms of reorganization energies and spin conservation that undermines its ability to act as an electron donor for photoredox catalysis. In contrast, ligand fields that are sufficient to stabilize the 3 T 1 excited state have available to them numerous spin-allowed and, in certain cases, near-barrierless pathways to engage in excited-state electron transfer (both oxidative and reductive depending on the identity of the metal). These results highlight the critical role of spin-state changes and their associated reorganization energy requirements in metal-centered photoredox catalysis.
Controlling the rate of electron spin relaxation in paramagnetic molecules is essential for contemporary applications in molecular magnetism and quantum information science. However, the physical mechanisms of spin relaxation remain incompletely understood, and new spectroscopic observables play an important role in evaluating spin dynamics mechanisms and structure–property relationships. Here, we use cryogenic magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) spectroscopy and pulse electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) in tandem to examine the impact of ligand field (d–d) excited states on spin relaxation rates. We employ a broad scope of square-planar Cu(II) compounds with varying ligand field strength, including CuS 4 , CuN 4 , CuN 2 O 2 , and CuO 4 first coordination spheres. An unexpectedly strong correlation exists between spin relaxation rates and the average d–d excitation energy (R 2 = 0.97). The relaxation rate trends as the inverse 11th power of the excited-state energies, whereas simplified theoretical models predict only an inverse second power dependence. These experimental results directly implicate ligand field excited states as playing a critical role in the ground-state spin relaxation mechanism. Furthermore, ligand field strength is revealed to be a particularly powerful design principle for spin dynamics, enabling formation of a spectrochemical series for spin relaxation.
Highly covalent Ni bis(dithiolene) and related complexes provide an ideal platform for investigating the effects of metal–ligand orbital hybridization on excited state character and dynamics. In particular, we focus on the ligand field excited states that dominate the photophysics of first-row transition metal complexes. Here, we investigate if they can be significantly delocalized off the metal center, possibly yielding photochemical reactivity more similar to charge transfer excited states than metal-centered ligand field excited states. Here [Ni(mpo) 2 ] (mpo = 2-mercaptopyridine- N-oxide) provides a representative example for the larger chemical class and is an active electro- and photo-catalyst for proton reduction. A detailed characterization of the excited state electronic structure, dynamics, and photochemistry of [Ni(mpo) 2 ] is presented based on ultrafast transient X- ray absorption spectroscopy at the Ni and S 1s core absorption K-edges. By comparing the ultrafast Ni K-edge absorption to ab initio calculations, we identify an excited state relaxation mechanism where an initial ligand-to-metal charge transfer excitation results in both excited state electron transfer (generating a catalytically relevant reduced photoproduct [Ni(mpo) 2 ] − ) and relaxation to a pseudo-tetrahedral triplet ligand field excited state. From the ultrafast S K-edge absorption, the ligand field excited state is found to be highly delocalized onto the thiolate ligands and a tetrahedral structural distortion is shown to substantially influence the degree of delocalization. The results identify a significant structural coordinate to target when aiming to control the excited state covalency in square planar complexes.
Earth-abundant Cr(III) polypyridines chromophores feature long-lived doublet ligand-field excited states. The thermally equilibrated 2 T 1 / 2 E ligand-field excited state manifold produces broad, structured UV-Vis-NIR absorption bands. Although ubiquitous across pseudo-octahedral Cr(III) diimine complexes, the dynamics and individual electronic transitions underlying these spectra have remained elusive. Here, we combine time-resolved spectroscopy and multiconfigurational calculations to assign ground- and excited-state absorption spectra of Cr(III) tris(1,10-phenanthroline), [Cr(phen) 3 ] 3+ , as a prototypical example for this class of complexes. Excited-state kinetics reveal a rapid biexponential decay of the initially prepared intraligand/ligand-to-metal charge transfer [ 4 ( 1 IL)/ 4 LMCT] excited state into the lowest 2 T 1 / 2 E state within 10 picoseconds, assigned to intersystem crossing and vibrational relaxation. Calculations identify broad excited-state absorption features associated with metal-centered ligand-field states ( 2 MC) mixed with intraligand ( 2 IL) transitions within the doublet manifold. These results provide detailed spectral assignments and highlight the need to include multiconfigurational ligand-based orbitals when modeling the spectral properties of Cr(III) coordination complexes.
Substituted dysprosocenium complexes of the type [Dy(Cp R ) 2 ] + exhibit slow magnetic relaxation at cryogenic temperatures and have emerged as top-performing single-molecule magnets. The remarkable properties of these compounds derive in part from the strong axial ligand field afforded by the cyclopentadiene anions, and the design of analogous compounds with even stronger ligand fields is one promising route toward identifying new single-molecule magnets that retain a magnetic memory at even higher temperatures. Here, we report the synthesis and characterization of a dysprosium bis(borolide) compound, [K(18-crown-6)][Dy(BC 4 Ph 5 ) 2 ] (1), featuring the dysprosocenate anion [Dy(BC 4 Ph 5 ) 2 ] - with a pseudoaxial coordination environment afforded by two dianionic pentaphenyl borolide ligands. Variable-field magnetization data reveal open magnetic hysteresis up to 66 K, establishing 1 as a top-performing single-molecule magnet among its dysprosocenium analogues. Ac magnetic susceptibility data indicate that 1 relaxes via an Orbach mechanism above ~80 K with U eff = 1500(100) cm -1 and τ 0 = 10 -12.0(9) s, whereas Raman relaxation and quantum tunneling of the magnetization dominate at lower temperatures. Compound 1 exhibits a 100 s blocking temperature of 65 K, among the highest reported for dysprosium-based single-molecule magnets. Ab initio spin dynamics calculations support the experimental U eff and τ 0 values and enable a quantitative comparison of the relaxation dynamics of 1 and two representative dysprosocenium cations, yielding additional insights into the impact of the crystal field splitting and vibronic coupling on the observed relaxation behavior. Importantly, compound 1 represents a step toward the development of alternatives to substituted dysprosocenium single-molecule magnets with increased axiality.
Modeling actinides with electronic structure theories is challenging because these systems present a strong ligand field and metal–ligand covalency. Here, we systematically investigate the effectiveness of pair-density functional theory (PDFT) for the calculation of vertical excitation energies in An(III), [An III Cl 6 ] 3– , and [An VI O 2 ] 2+ (An = U, Np, Pu, and Am). We compare the performance of PDFT, hybrid PDFT, and multistate PDFT with traditional active-space methods followed by perturbation theory, like multistate CASPT2, and with experimental data. Overall, multistate PDFT gives quantitative agreement with multistate CASPT2 at a significantly reduced computational cost.
To fully harness the potential of abundant metal coordination complex photosensitizers, a detailed understanding of the molecular properties that dictate and control the electronic excited-state population dynamics initiated by light absorption is critical. In the absence of detectable luminescence, optical transient absorption (TA) spectroscopy is the most widely employed method for interpreting electron redistribution in such excited states, particularly for those with a charge-transfer character. The assignment of excited-state TA spectral features often relies on spectroelectrochemical measurements, where the transient absorption spectrum generated by a metal-to-ligand charge-transfer (MLCT) electronic excited state, for instance, can be approximated using steady-state spectra generated by electrochemical ligand reduction and metal oxidation and accounting for the loss of absorptions by the electronic ground state. However, the reliability of this approach can be clouded when multiple electronic configurations have similar optical signatures. Using a case study of Fe(II) complexes supported by benzannulated diarylamido ligands, we highlight an example of such an ambiguity and show how time-resolved X-ray emission spectroscopy (XES) measurements can reliably assign excited states from the perspective of the metal, particularly in conjunction with accurate synthetic models of ligand-field electronic excited states, leading to a reinterpretation of the long-lived excited state as a ligand-field metal-centered quintet state. Furthermore, a detailed analysis of the XES data on the long-lived excited state is presented, along with a discussion of the ultrafast dynamics following the photoexcitation of low-spin Fe(II)-N amido complexes using a high-spin ground-state analogue as a spectral model for the 5 T 2 excited state.
High-valent Fe IV =O species are common intermediates in biological and artificial catalysts. Heme and nonheme S=1 Fe IV =O sites have been synthesized and studied for decades but little quantitative experimental comparison of their electronic structures has been available, due to the lack of direct methods focused on the iron. This study allows a rigorous determination of the electronic structure of a nonheme Fe IV =O center and its comparison to an Fe IV =O heme site using 1s2p resonant inelastic X-ray scattering (RIXS) and Fe L-edge X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS). Further, variable temperature magnetic circular dichroism (VT-MCD) of the ligand field transitions, combined with nuclear resonance vibrational spectroscopy of the two S=1 Fe IV =O systems show that the equatorial ligand field decreases from a nonheme to a heme Fe IV =O site. Alternatively, RIXS and Fe L-edge XAS combined with MCD show that the Fe dπ orbitals are unperturbed in the Fe IV =O heme relative to the nonheme site because the strong axial Fe-O bond uncouples the Fe dπ orbitals from the porphyrin π-system. As a consequence, the thermodynamics and kinetics of the H-atom abstraction reactions are actually very similar for heme compound II and nonheme Fe IV =O active sites.
Tuning metal–ligand covalency offers promising design strategies to tailor the photoluminescence (PL) emission energies of metal-centered, spin-flip excited states. Herein, we report a series of tris(quinolinolate) chromium(III) complexes that exhibit record-low near-infrared II emission energies in a fluid solution at room temperature, afforded by their strong metal–ligand covalencies. Appending π-conjugated arylethynyl substituents to quinolinolate ligands resulted in minimal changes to metal–ligand bond lengths, facilitating nearly indiscriminate metal–ligand covalencies for each tris(quinolinolate) chromium(III) complex. As a result, near-infrared II emission was observed across the series, while simultaneously affording careful tuning of the 4 LMCT/ 4 ( 1 ILCT) electronic transition energies across the visible region. Here, detailed analyses of ground-state electronic structures and excited-state electronic transitions revealed that PL arises from a ligand-field, 2 E excited state, admixed with charge-transfer character. This assignment was supported by solvent-dependent near-infrared emission energies and long excited-state lifetimes, consistent with spin-forbidden relaxation (ranging from 115 ± 5 to 123 ± 1 ns across the series). Utilizing spectroscopic data, ligand-field parameters were quantified, further rationalizing the role of strong metal–ligand covalency in enabling near-infrared II emission. Supported by these results, this study presents a new class of ligands that enable room-temperature near-infrared II emission in chromium(III)-based spin-flip excited states.
In this study, the question of whether one can use information from quantum coherence as a means of identifying vibrational degrees of freedom that are active along an excited-state reaction coordinate is discussed. Specifically, we are exploring the notion of whether quantum oscillations observed in single-wavelength kinetics data exhibiting coherence dephasing times that are intermediate between that expected for either pure electronic or pure vibrational dephasing are vibronic in nature and therefore may be coupled to electronic state-to-state evolution. In the case of a previously published Fe(ιι) polypyridyl complex, coherences observed subsequent to 1 A 1 → 1 MLCT excitation were linked to large-amplitude motion of a portion of the ligand framework; dephasing times on the order of 200–300 fs suggested that these degrees of freedom could be associated with ultrafast (~100 fs) conversion from the initially formed MLCT excited state to lower-energy, metal-centered ligand-field excited state(s) of the compound. Incorporation of an electronically benign but sterically restrictive Cu(ι) ion into the superstructure designed to interfere with this motion yielded a compound exhibiting a ~25-fold increase in the compound’s MLCT lifetime, a result that was interpreted as confirmation of the initial hypothesis. However, new data acquired on a different chemical system – Cr(acac') 3 (where acac' represents various derivatives of acetylacetonate) – yielded results that call into question this same hypothesis. Coherences observed subsequent to 4 A 2 → 4 T 2 ligand-field excitation on a series of molecules implicated similar vibrational degrees of freedom across the series, but exhibited dephasing times ranging from 340 fs to 2.5 ps without any clear correlation to the dynamics of excited-state evolution in the system. Taken together, the results obtained on both of these chemical platforms suggest that while identification of coherences can indeed point to degrees of freedom that should be considered as candidate modes for defining reaction trajectories, our understanding of the factors that determine the interplay across coherences, dephasing times, and electronic and geometric structure is insufficient at the present time to view this parameter as a robust metric for differentiating active versus spectator modes for ultrafast dynamics.
Despite its enormous utility in structural characterization, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy is inherently limited by low spin polarization. One method to address the low polarization is para-hydrogen (p-H 2 ) induced polarization (PHIP) which uses the singlet spin isomer of H 2 to generate disparate nuclear spin populations to amplify the associated NMR signals. PHIP often relies on thermal catalysis or, more infrequently, UV-activated catalytic hydrogenation. Light-activated hydrogenation enables direct and timed control over the hyperpolarization of target substrates, critical for identifying short-lived intermediates. Here, we use an established Ir(III) triplet photosensitizer (PS) to visible light sensitize the triplet ligand-field states in the d6-transition metal dihydride Ru(CO)(PPh 3 ) 3 (H) 2 (1). Excitation inside a 9.4 T NMR spectrometer with the PS and a 420 nm blue LED, under 3 atm of p-H 2 , successfully photosensitized hyperpolarization in 1 and in a range of unsaturated substrates at and below room temperature, up to 1630-fold. In otherwise identical experimental conditions without light activation, no polarization was realized in 1 or the substrates evaluated. We believe triplet-sensitized PHIP (Trip- PHIP) represents a facile experimental means for probing triplet sensitized light activation in transition metal catalysts possessing low-lying triplet ligand-field states, providing mechanistic insight of potentially tremendous value in chemical catalysis.
Abstract Understanding the electronic structures of high‐valent metal complexes aids the advancement of metal‐catalyzed cross coupling methodologies. A prototypical complex with formally high valency is [Cu(CF 3 ) 4 ] − (1), which has a formal Cu(III) oxidation state but whose physical analysis has led some to a Cu(I) assignment in an inverted ligand field model. Recent examinations of1by X‐ray spectroscopies have led previous authors to contradictory conclusions, motivating the re‐examination of its X‐ray absorption profile here by a complementary method, resonant diffraction anomalous fine structure (DAFS). From analysis of DAFS measurements for a series of seven mononuclear Cu complexes including1, here it is shown that there is a systematic trifluoromethyl effect on X‐ray absorption that blue shifts the resonant Cu K‐edge energy by 2–3 eV per CF 3 , completely accounting for observed changes in DAFS profiles between formally Cu(III) complexes like1and formally Cu(I) complexes like (Ph 3 P) 3 CuCF 3 (3). Thus, in agreement with the inverted ligand field model, the data presented herein imply that1is best described as containing a Cu(I) ion with d n count approaching 10.
Transition metal-based charge-transfer complexes represent a broad class of inorganic compounds with diverse photochemical applications. Charge-transfer complexes based on earth-abundant elements have been of increasing interest, particularly the canonical [Fe(bpy) 3 ] 2+ . Photoexcitation into the singlet metal–ligand charge transfer ( 1 MLCT) state is followed by relaxation first to the ligand-field manifold and then to the ground state. While these dynamics have been well-studied, processes within the MLCT manifold that facilitate and/or compete with relaxation have been more elusive. We applied ultrafast two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2DES) to disentangle the dynamics immediately following MLCT excitation of this compound. First, dynamics ascribed to relaxation out of the initially formed 1 MLCT state was found to correlate with the inertial response time of the solvent. Second, the additional dimension of the 2D spectra revealed a peak consistent with a ~20 fs 1 MLCT → 3 MLCT intersystem crossing process. These two observations indicate that the complex simultaneously undergoes intersystem crossing and direct conversion to ligand-field state(s). Resolution of these parallel pathways in this prototypical earth-abundant complex highlights the ability of 2DES to deconvolve the otherwise obscured excited-state dynamics of charge-transfer complexes.
Solar energy conversion requires the working compositions to generate photoinduced charges with high potential and the ability to deliver charges to the catalytic sites and/or external electrode. These two properties are typically at odds with each other and call for new molecular materials with sufficient conjugation to improve charge conductivity but not as much conjugation as to overly compromise the optical band gap. In this work, we developed a semiconducting metal-organic framework (MOF) prepared explicitly through metal-carbodithioate"(-CS 2 ) n M" linkage chemistry, entailing augmented metal-linker electronic communication. The stronger ligand field and higher covalent character of metal-carbodithioate linkages-when combined with spirofluorene-derived organic struts and nickel-(II) ion-based nodes-provided a stable, semiconducting 3D-porous MOF, Spiro-CS 2 Ni. This MOF lacks long-range ordering and is defined by a flexible structure with non-aggregated building units, as suggested by reverse Monte Carlo simulations of the pair distribution function obtained from total scattering experiments. The solvent-removed "closed pore"material recorded a Brunauer-Emmett-Teller area of similar to 400m 2 /g, where the "open pore" form possesses90 wt % solvent-accessible porosity. Electrochemical measurements suggest that Spiro-CS 2 Ni possesses a band gap of 1.57 eV(sigma = 10 -7 S/cm at -1.3 V bias potential),which can be further improved by manipulating the d-electron configuration through an axial coordination (ligand/substrate), the latter of which indicates usefulness as an electrocatalyst and/or a photoelectrocatalyst(upon substrate binding). Transient-absorption spectroscopy reveals a long-lived photo-generated charge-transfer state (τ CR = 6.5 mu s) capable of chemical transformation under a biased voltage. Spiro-CS 2 Ni can endure a compelling range of pH(1-12 for weeks) and hours of electrochemical and photoelectrochemical conditions in the presence of water and organic acids. We believe this work provides crucial design principles for low-density, porous,light-energy-conversion materials.
Abstract The use of organometallic triplet emitters in organic light emitting diodes (OLEDs) is motivated by the premise of efficient intersystem crossing leading to unit internal quantum efficiencies. However, since most devices are based on solid‐state components, an inherent limitation to square‐planar platinum(II) phosphors is their tendency toward aggregation‐based quenching. Here, a new class of emissive, four‐coordinate Pt II species based on the bisimidazolyl carbazolide (BIMCA) ligand is introduced, which displays highly efficient, long‐lived solid‐state phosphorescence at room temperature. A set of four BIMCAPt phenyl acetylides were synthesized that emit in the green ( λ max =507–540 nm) with >60 % quantum yield and millisecond lifetimes. The structures of the resulting species reveal a non‐planar structure imposed by steric clashes between BIMCA and the iodo or alkynyl co‐ligand. Ground‐state and photophysical characterization are presented. Density functional theory calculations indicate that the BIMCA ligand dominates the frontier orbitals along with the first Franck–Condon singlet and triplet excited states.
A solar-driven conversion of CO 2 into fuels by artificial photosynthesis would not only mitigate the greenhouse effect but also provide an alternative to obtain fuels in a renewable fashion. To this end, the new iron polypyridine catalyst [Fe(bpy NHEt PY2Me)L 2 ] 2+ (L = H 2 O, CH 3 CN) was recently developed for the electrochemical reduction of CO 2 to CO. Here, we performed density functional theory (DFT) electronic structure calculations to shed light on a possible pathway for CO 2 reduction and the origin of the selectivity between CO 2 reduction versus the hydrogen evolution reaction. The metal center remains Lewis acidic throughout the reduction process due to ligand loss and mainly ligand-based reduction stabilized by antiferromagnetic coupling to a high-spin Fe(II) center. This results in a high barrier for hydride formation but a facile addition and activation of CO 2 via an η 2 coordination and stabilizing hydrogen bonding by the amine group. The second unoccupied equatorial coordination site opens up the possibility for an intramolecular protonation with a coordinated water ligand. This facilitates protonation because not only CO 2 but also the proton source H 2 O is activated and properly aligned for a proton transfer due to the Fe-OH 2 bond; consequently, both protonation steps are facile. The moderate ligand field allows a rapid ligand exchange for a second intramolecular protonation step and facilitates an exergonic CO release. The lower selectivity of the related [Fe(bpy OH PY2Me)L 2 ] 2+ complex can be related to its more acidic second coordination sphere, which enables an intramolecular proton transfer that is kinetically competitive with CO 2 addition.