Acetate formation on metals via CH 4 carboxylation by CO 2 : A DFT study
Here, density functional theory calculations have been performed to investigate CH 4 activation and coupling to CO 2 forming C 2 carboxylates such as acetate on the close-packed (111) or (0001) surfaces of ten mid-to-late transition and coinage metals (Co, Ni, Cu, Ru, Rh, Pd, Ag, Ir, Pt, and Au). Consistent with the literature, the activation energy (E a ) for the initial C-H bond scission in CH 4 is mild, being ca. 1 eV or less on all but the coinage metals, of which Ag exhibits the highest E a at 2.13 eV, followed by Au and Cu. E a for the CH 3 -CO 2 coupling step is 0.8 ~ 1.1 eV on Co, Ru, Rh, and Ag, 1.2 ~ 1.5 eV on Ni, Cu, Pd, and Ir, and 1.8 ~ 2.1 eV on Pt and Au. While the two E a are comparable for several metals in terms of DFT total energies, free energy analysis indicates CH 3 -CO 2 coupling to be much more rate-limiting than CH 4 activation. Overcoming it would require over 800 K even on the most active of the metals considered, Ru, which makes the formation of acetate not feasible on the monometallic metal surfaces. Instead, we propose that single atom alloys based on early transition metals doped into a host metal such as Ni(111) could be viable catalysts. The dopant sites serve to stabilize the transition state of C-C coupling while Ni sites continue to activate CH 4 , thereby significantly lowering the required temperature for acetate formation.