High-Temperature Irradiation-Resistant Thermocouple (HTIR-TC) Qualification Work
HTIR-TC Qualification work newsletter article for the FY22 ASI Spring Newsletter.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Results for “Nuclear Thermocouples”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Preliminary Calibration System Report for High-Temperature Irradiation-Resistant Thermocouples
An established calibration procedure is presented for the high-temperature irradiation-resistant thermocouple (HTIR-TC). Standard calibration curves for both an individual (i.e. case by case basis) and common calibrations is shown. The error limits within ±3 σ are ±1% for the individual calibrations and ±2% for the common calibration.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
Qualification Test Requirements Report for High-Temperature Irradiation-Resistant Thermocouples
The qualification of f high-temperature irradiation-resistant thermocouples (HTIR-TCs) is set forth utilizing the Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) 5/6/7 test in the Advanced Test Reactor located at the Idaho National Laboratory (INL). The requirements to achieve the qualification are appropriate design, construction, and calibration followed by proper installation and performance parameters.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
High-temperature irradiation-resistant thermocouple instability model for in-pile reactor use
This article presents an instability model for the high-temperature irradiation-resistant thermocouple (HTIR-TC). Here the term instability defines the superposition of both drift and inhomogeneity of TC thermoelements occurring simultaneously. The HTIR-TC is an advanced thermocouple (TC) that uses the refractory metals niobium and molybdenum as sensing thermoelements for generating electromotive force (EMF) in a field of neutrons and at temperatures upward of 1,600°C. In the Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) 5/6/7 tests conducted at Idaho National Laboratory’s Advanced Test Reactor (ATR), the HTIR-TCs showed low to moderate instability throughout the life of the test. The instability model reveals that HTIR-TCs can, when the operating temperature of the reactor fuel is normal, maintain performance throughout an 18-month refueling cycle typical of nuclear power plants, reflecting an instability of less than ±1%. The HTIR-TC is also qualified for incorporation into a test fixture during the testing of new fuels.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
Development and Test Results of Thermocouples Used in the TRISO-Fuel Irradiation Experiment AGR-5/6/7
High-temperature gas reactor irradiation experiments create unique challenges for thermocouple-based temperature measurements. High-temperature industrial thermocouples suffer rapid decalibration due to transmutation of the thermoelements from neutron absorption. For lower-temperature applications, Type K and Type N thermocouples are affected by neutron irradiation only to a limited extent. But until recently, the use of these nickel-based thermocouples was limited when the temperature exceeded 1050°C due to drift related to phenomena other than nuclear irradiation. Certain portions of the AGR-5/6/7 experiment experienced temperatures higher than any of the previous AGR tests, up to 1500°C. Recognizing the limitations of existing thermometry to measure such high temperatures, the sponsor of the AGR-5/6/7 test supported a development and testing program for thermocouples capable of low-drift operation at temperatures above 1100°C. This program included additional development of high-temperature irradiation-resistant thermocouples based on molybdenum/niobium thermoelements, which have been studied at Idaho National Laboratory since circa 2004. A step change in accuracy and long-term stability of this thermocouple type was achieved as part of the AGR-5/6/7 thermometry development program. Additionally, long-term testing (7000+ h) at 1250°C of Type N thermocouples utilizing a customized sheath developed at the University of Cambridge has been completed with excellent low-drift results. The results of this testing as well as testing of the improved high-temperature irradiation-resistant design are reported herein. Both the improved high-temperature irradiation-resistant and the Cambridge Type N thermocouple types were incorporated into the AGR-5/6/7 test, which began irradiation in February 2018 and was completed in July 2020. Finally, a summary of the performance of the thermocouples incorporated into the AGR-5/6/7 test is included herein.
In-pile instrumentation↗
Space Nuclear Power Autonomous Control Algorithm and Control Element Test Bed
Nuclear thermal rockets are currently NASA’s preferred option for use in a manned mission to Mars in the 2040s. The communication delay between an Earth ground station and a spacecraft heading toward Mars can be up to 20 min. Therefore, controlling the nuclear rocket engine would require either a full-time reactor operator on the mission or an autonomous control system for the reactor. The latter idea of making space nuclear reactors fully autonomous has drawn more interest from stakeholders, but such an autonomous control system must be rigorously tested and validated before it is certified for human use. The cost of a full ground test for a space nuclear reactor is tremendous, so a nonnuclear mock reactor test bed was created to test and validate control elements and control algorithms for space nuclear reactors. The test bed consists of control element hardware that inputs physical measurement data into a reactor emulator to produce the reactor’s performance under steady-state, transient, and fault conditions. The control element hardware consists of six full-sized control drums equipped with servo drives and motors and is instrumented with optical encoders, resolvers, and torque sensors for drum movement characterization. In addition to the drums, a two-phase flow loop was designed and built to mimic the valves and turbomachinery associated with the propellant flow through a nuclear thermal rocket engine; components such as pressure sensors, flow meters, thermocouples, and tachometers are instrumented throughout the loop to characterize the fluid flow, valve, and turbomachinery behavior of the system. The data from the physical hardware (e.g., drum position, propellant flow rates) are input to a nuclear reactor simulator to determine the actual nuclear reactor parameters, and the data are sent back to a control algorithm to complete the control loop. The ability to conduct numerous tests of the control systems and autonomous algorithms can help validate the instrumentation and control aspects for a space nuclear reactor for every possible fault situation.
Wilson, Brandon↗
Ultrasonic thermometry using pulse techniques.
Ultrasonic pulse techniques have been developed which, when applied to inert gases, provide temperature measurements up to 8000 K. The response time can be less than 1 msec. This is a significant feature in studying shock-heated or combusting gases. Using a momentary contact coupling technique, temperature has been measured inside steel from 300 to 1500 K. Thin-wire sensors have been used above 2000 K in nuclear and industrial applications where conditions preclude the use of thermocouples, resistance devices, or optical pyrometers. At 2500 K, temperature sensitivity of 0.1% is obtained in Re wire sensors 5 cm long by timing five round trips with an electronic instrument that resolves the time interval between selected echoes to 0.1 microsec. Sensors have been operated at rotational speeds over 2000 rpm and in noisy environments. Temperature profiling of up to ten regions using only a single guided path or beam has also been accomplished.
Lynnworth, L. C.↗
High Temperature Irradiation Resistant Thermocouple Drift Model Application to Commercial Thermocouples
The Advance Sensors and Instrumentation fiscal year report on the direct application of the HTIR-TC drift model on other commercial thermocouples. The Type N and K thermocouples are useful in irradiation environments up to 1100°C (or 1290°C for short bursts and/or single use), but over temperature and high fluence can cause the TCs to drift. The HTIR-TC drift model predicts the end use environment of temperature and irradiation and the total time scale to show the amount of drift a thermocouple will undergo. The model predicts that HTIR-TCs at full temperature range and fluence of 10^21 N/cm^2 will exhibit a drift of under -1%. The type N and K TCs will see a drift of -0.5% at the same fluence, but temperatures below 1100°C. Above this temperature the Type N and K TCs quickly de-calibrate and will give erroneous temperatures measurements.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
Demonstrate HTIR performance in flowing autoclave for fuel center line temperature measurement in PWR conditions [Slides]
The results from the ATF-2 fuel pin mockup test in the INL's flowing autoclave system (FAS) is presented. By instrumenting the fuel pins with high-temperature, irradiation-resistant thermocouples, the fuel center line can be measured directly. This test shows performance of the compression seals and leak tightness of the temperature probes.
42 ENGINEERING↗
Summary of Thermocouple Performance in the Advanced Gas Reactor Experiment AGR-5/6/7 During Irradiation in the Advanced Test Reactor
The Advanced Gas Reactor -5/6/7 (AGR-5/6/7) experiment was the fourth and final experiment in the AGR experiment series and completed irradiation in July 2020. It serves as the formal fuel qualification test for the TRISO fuels under development by the US Department of Energy. This experiment was designed to irradiate fuel particles at temperatures ranging from 800°C ? 1500°C. The high end of the range created unique challenges for thermocouple-based temperature measurements. Commercially available high-temperature platinum-rhodium thermocouples (Types S, R, and B) and tungsten-rhenium thermocouples (Type C) suffer rapid decalibration due to transmutation of the thermoelements from neutron absorption. A special low neutron cross-section thermocouple system based on molybdenum/niobium thermoelements called High Temperature Irradiation Resistant thermocouple (HTIR-TC) has been under development at INL since circa 2004. Several examples of this thermocouple type were incorporated into regions of the test operating above 1200°C. For regions in the test operating in the 1000°C ? 1200°C range, high-performance versions of Type N thermocouples recently developed at Cambridge University were installed. Standard Type N thermocouples were used in regions of the test operating below 1000°C. A total of 54 thermocouples were incorporated into the test. A report of the performance of this large heterogenous set of thermocouples over the first third of the irradiation was previously provided (ANIMMA 2019). This follow-on paper discusses results from the balance of the experiment (Feb 2019 - July 2020). Special attention is focused on potential drift of thermocouples operating in the higher temperature regions.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
Summary of Thermocouple Performance in the Advanced Gas Reactor Experiment AGR-5/6/7 During Irradiation in the Advanced Test Reactor
This is a conference presentation ppt file. The following abstract is for the entire conference paper - which will later be the subject of a PRS artifact The Advanced Gas Reactor -5/6/7 (AGR-5/6/7) experiment was the fourth and final experiment in the AGR experiment series and completed irradiation in July 2020. It serves as the formal fuel qualification test for the TRISO fuels under development by the US Department of Energy. This experiment was designed to irradiate fuel particles at temperatures ranging from 800°C ? 1500°C. The high end of the range created unique challenges for thermocouple-based temperature measurements. Commercially available high-temperature platinum-rhodium thermocouples (Types S, R, and B) and tungsten-rhenium thermocouples (Type C) suffer rapid decalibration due to transmutation of the thermoelements from neutron absorption. A special low neutron cross-section thermocouple system based on molybdenum/niobium thermoelements called High Temperature Irradiation Resistant thermocouple (HTIR-TC) has been under development at INL since circa 2004. Several examples of this thermocouple type were incorporated into regions of the test operating above 1200°C. For regions in the test operating in the 1000°C ? 1200°C range, high-performance versions of Type N thermocouples recently developed at Cambridge University were installed. Standard Type N thermocouples were used in regions of the test operating below 1000°C. A total of 54 thermocouples were incorporated into the test. A report of the performance of this large heterogenous set of thermocouples over the first third of the irradiation was previously provided (ANIMMA 2019). This follow-on paper discusses results from the balance of the experiment (Feb 2019 - July 2020). Special attention is focused on potential drift of thermocouples operating in the higher temperature regions.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
Cylindricity Sensitivity Thermal Model of the AGR-5/6/7 Experiment in the Advanced Test Reactor
The AGR-5/6/7 experiment is currently being irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) at the Idaho National Laboratory and is approximately 70% complete. Several fuel and material irradiation experiments have been planned for the U.S. Department of Energy Advanced Gas Reactor Fuel Development and Qualification Program, which supports the development and qualification of tristructural isotropic (TRISO) coated particle fuel for use in high-temperature gas-cooled reactors. The goals of these experiments are to provide irradiation performance data to support fuel process development, qualify fuel for normal operating conditions, support development of fuel performance models and codes, and provide irradiated fuel and materials for post-irradiation examination and safety testing. Originally planned and named as separate fuel experiments, but subsequently combined into a single test train, AGR-5/6/7 is testing low-enriched uranium oxycarbide TRISO fuel. The AGR-5/6/7 test train has 5 capsules with thermocouples and independent gas control mixtures. Unique to this paper is a sensitivity study concerning the cylindricity of the graphite holders containing the fuel compacts and their eccentricity in relation to the stainless-steel capsule walls. Each capsule has small nubs on the outside used for centering the graphite holder inside the stainless-steel capsule with a small gas gap used to control temperature. Due to machining tolerances of these nubs and vibration wearing the nubs down when the experiment is running in the reactor, the possibility exists that the holder may move around radially. Each capsule is equipped with several thermocouples placed at various radii and depths within each graphite holder. This paper will show the sensitivity of offsetting the graphite holder for various radii in 45-degree increments around the circle with the objective of minimizing the difference between the measured thermocouples and the modeled thermocouple temperatures. Separate gas mixtures of helium/neon are introduced into this gas gap between the holder and capsule wall and changed as necessary to maintain the desired thermocouple temperatures to keep the fuel compacts at constant temperature as the nuclear reactor conditions change. The goal of the sensitivity study is to find a radius and an angle to offset the holder from perfectly centered for each of the five capsules separately. The complex thermal model includes fission heating, gamma heating, radiation heat transfer, and heat transfer via conduction and radiation across the control gaps. Subroutines linked to the thermal model offer an easy method to offset the graphite holder from the capsule walls without remeshing the entire model.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Material and Design Optimization of Printed Melt Wire Arrays
Recent work conducted by the Advanced Sensors and Instrumentation (ASI) program at Idaho National Laboratory resulted in the establishment of in-house capabilities for fabricating and testing new advanced manufactured sensors for measuring irradiation temperatures inside a nuclear test reactor. Though current methods of real-time temperature monitoring (e.g., thermocouples) can still be used, the complexity of the feedthroughs and attachments needed for collecting real time measurements greatly increases the experiment-related costs. On the other hand, passive monitoring techniques can be used for collecting post irradiation temperature measurements by inferring reactor temperatures, based on the melting points of well-characterized materials (i.e., standard melt wires). However, challenges have arisen due to the limited space available for including instrumentation in experiments. To resolve this issue, the ASI program expanded its temperature detection capabilities to include advance manufactured melt wires for post-irradiation temperature measurements. These melt wires can determine reactor temperatures while also accommodating space limitations in irradiation experiments. To improve performance reliability and enhance melt wire readability following irradiation, FY-22 efforts have focused on optimizing the materials used in the encapsulation and printed melt wire array. This report details the design and fabrication tasks, along with the subsequent x ray computed tomography (XCT) evaluation process. The melt wire array consisted of indium with a melting point of 157°C, indium/silver (96/4 at%) with a melting point of 219°C, and tin with a melting point of 230°C. The encapsulation disc was made of vanadium due to its low activation properties and radiation resistance when deployed in nuclear reactors. Additionally, the melt wire design consisted of a ceramic sublayer (alumina disc) to further enhance the XCT post melting images of the printed melt wires. However, when sealing the vanadium container, all three melt wires melted, reflecting the temperature limitations that must be considered when employing metal containers in the sealing process.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
Design Optimization for Printed Melt Wire Arrays Encapsulation
As part of the Nuclear Energy Enabling Technology (NEET) Advanced Sensor and Instrumentation (ASI) Program, Idaho National Laboratory (INL) has recently established in-house capabilities to fabricate and test new advanced-manufactured sensors for measuring peak irradiation temperature within a nuclear test reactor. Although methods of real-time temperature monitoring, such as thermocouples, may be used, the complexity of feedthroughs and attachments to collect real-time measurements greatly increases the cost of the experiment. Instead, passive monitoring techniques may be used for peak- temperature measurement that exploit the melting point of well-characterized materials (standard melt wires) to infer peak reactor temperatures. However, limited available space for instrumentation during experiments introduces an additional challenge. To accommodate this, INL has expanded its temperature- detection instrumentation capabilities to include advanced manufactured (AM) melt wires for peak irradiation temperature measurements. These melt wires can determine peak temperatures while also accommodate space limitations in irradiation experiments. In an effort to improve performance reliability of AM meltwire capabilities, a process was developed and tested to identify the significance of entrapping a high purity inert atmosphere within the packaging of printed melt wire arrays. The materials used in this study were aluminum, zinc, and tin encapsulated in high purity helium within a stainless steel (SS) 316 container. Tin, with a low melting point of approximately 230°C, Zn with a mid-melting point of approximately 420°C, and Al with a high melting point of approximately 660°C. This report describes the design, fabrication process, furnace testing and X-ray Computed Tomography (XCT) evaluation. Results show a successful outcome in creating an inert gas encapsulation and high-resolution evaluation methods.
46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
AGR-5/6/7 Raw Thermocouple Data
This is temperature data from the AGR-5/6/7 experiment. This data will support a conference paper (INL/CON-20-60776) and needs to be shared with co-authors and other collaborators.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Flash Diffusivity Measurement of Semi-Porous Insulation Material Intended for Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generators
This research involves the analysis of flash-heating data pursuant to find the thermal diffusivity of a semi-porous insulation material (Min-K) that is being considered for use in a radioisotope thermoelectric generator (RTG). An RTG uses radioactive nuclear fuel to produce electricity through a temperature difference imposed on a bimetallic thermocouple. Insulation is required to protect sensitive equipment from high temperatures and to conserve heat in the fuel. Using flash diffusivity temperature data, various simulations were fitted in order to find the most appropriate heat transfer model for the experiments. Four models were allowed to compete and the standard deviation of the residuals were compared for each model in evaluating model performance. The residuals are simply the difference in temperatures between the measurements and the mathematical models at each measurement point.
McMasters, Robert L.↗
Thin Film Sensors for Fission Surface Power
Physical sensors fabricated with thin films could result a significant savings in space and weight with improved reliability for monitoring the long-term operation of fission surface power systems. Thin film sensors of 1 µm or less are attractive for FSP applications because they can be incorporated onto component surfaces with minimal machining and the additional weight to a system is minimal compared to thick film-, wire-, or foil-based sensors. The thin, surface fabrication of the sensors is also expected to make them less susceptible to deep dose effects that affect thicker sensors. An overview of thin film sensors using thermocouples and resistive elements designed, fabricated, and demonstrated at GRC for aerospace applications exceeding 900°C is presented.
Fission Surface Power↗
Development, validation, and verification of multi-pass thermo-mechanical welding simulations using the open-source MOOSE framework: NeT TG4 benchmark weldment
This study develops and validates a sequentially coupled thermo-mechanical welding simulation for the three-pass 316L stainless steel NeT TG4 benchmark weldment using the open-source Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) and the Nuclear Engineering Material model Library (NEML). A diffused ellipsoidal heat source was calibrated against thermocouple data and weld macrographs to accurately model the fusion zone geometry and transient thermal fields. Material hardening is represented using the Lemaitre-Chaboche mixed isotropic-kinematic hardening model, while four annealing models - no annealing, single-stage at 1050 °C and 1300 °C, and two-stage at 800 °C/1300 °C - were implemented to assess the impact of annealing models on the accuracy of the predicted welding-induced plasticity, distortions, and residual stresses. The predictions were validated against experimental measurements and benchmarked against results from commercial software, demonstrating that thermo-mechanical MOOSE welding simulations achieve comparable accuracy with enhanced computational efficiency. This work highlights the potential of using open-source finite element frameworks like MOOSE for advanced manufacturing simulations.
Ji, Wendy [Australian Nuclear Science and Technolo↗