Refractory Carbides for Hydrogen Erosion Resistance in Carbon Tubes for Nuclear Thermal Propulsion
As crewed travel becomes more common to the Moon and beyond, space nuclear propulsion-based craft offer reduced travel times and double the specific impulse compared to conventional chemical rockets. The nuclear core and its integral hydrogen propellant channels will require advanced refractory carbide coatings over a carbon/carbon substrate for hydrogen resistance. Using ab initio and other computational techniques, we studied select (Zr/Ta/Nb)C mixed carbide systems for erosion resistance and hydrogen diffusion using realistic levels of carbon vacancies and experimentally obtainable stoichiometries. Various contributions to the formation and hydrogen erosion free energies were calculated, including configurational, electronic, and vibrational terms. Our calculations indicate that ZrC is less likely to lose carbon than NbC or TaC, providing an explanation for heritage NERVA data on ZrC and NbC mass loss performance. Additionally, binary mixtures show compositions that are more stable than their end-member counterparts. Hydrogen diffusion in stoichiometric ZrC was found to be slightly higher than previously theorized, with the caveat that hydrogen saturation of carbon vacancies will hinder further hydrogen diffusion through the bulk, while hydrogen diffusion in ZrNbC is slightly enhanced over ZrC. And finally, we show that as carbon is depleted, the deformation mechanism of ZrC changes from brittle to ductile. Though many questions still remain as to the bulk performance of these materials, these trends and results are important in terms of materials selection efforts for hydrogen-resistant coatings on carbon/carbon substrates.