Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “NaCl”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 37 records · Page 2

Thermodynamic properties of ZrCl 4 with LiCl, NaCl, KCl, CsCl, MgCl 2 , and UCl 3 for molten salt reactor applications

Here, a set of self-consistent Gibbs energy functions has been developed to describe the thermochemical behavior of the major reactive fission product ZrCl 4 with key components in chloride molten salt reactors (MSRs): LiCl–ZrCl 4 , NaCl–ZrCl 4 , KCl–ZrCl 4 , CsCl–ZrCl 4 , MgCl 2 –ZrCl 4 and UCl 3 –ZrCl 4 . Low ZrCl 4 concentration phase equilibria most relevant to MSR applications have been confirmed via differential scanning calorimetry for NaCl–ZrCl 4 , and X-ray diffraction analysis performed on equilibrated samples of NaCl–ZrCl 4 , KCl–ZrCl 4 , MgCl 2 –ZrCl 4 , and UCl 3 –ZrCl 4 . Within the framework of the modified quasi-chemical model in the quadruplet approximation, extrapolations of pseudo-binary models were generated to represent KCl–MgCl 2 –ZrCl 4 , KCl–NaCl–ZrCl 4 , and MgCl 2 –NaCl–ZrCl 4 , which show agreement with phase equilibria data where available without the use of ternary interaction parameters. The optimized thermodynamic descriptions for these systems and others are available in the open-source compendium Molten Salt Thermal Properties Database – Thermochemical (MSTDB–TC).

CALPHAD↗

Synthesis and Thermophysical Property Determination of NaCl-PuCl3 Salts

Currently, a knowledge gap exists in the available data and understanding of thermophysical properties relating to fresh fuel salts, especially those containing plutonium. Determination of this data is necessary for the design and construction of test reactors, as well as the licensing of future commercial molten salt reactors. Thermophysical properties such as melting temperature, salt stability, density, and heat capacity were determined on synthesized eutectic NaCl-PuCl3 and a more sodium rich composition containing 25 mol% PuCl3. These measurements document the baseline properties of the salt as a function of temperature for future experiments on irradiated fuel salt which will provide a holistic perspective on the change of thermophysical properties during reactor operations. It was determined that the NaCl-PuCl3 ingot synthesized for this study contained 63.4 mol% NaCl, 36.3 mol% PuCl3, and was 99.7% pure. Upon heating it was shown that the NaCl- PuCl3 eutectic was stable at temperatures of 800°C. The onset of melting occurred at 541°C and the enthalpy of fusion was determined to be 140.7 ± 8.4 J/g. Specific heat capacity measurements showed a slightly decreasing trend with respect to temperature in the liquid phase ranging from 0.67 to 0.57 J/g·K, with an average value of 0.637 ± 0.03 J/g·K (104 ± 5 J/mol·K) between 500 to 720°C. Three independent trials of the molten NaCl-PuCl3 eutectic salt found the density to be ?(T) = 3.8589 – 9.5342·10-4 T(°C), validated between 500 to 800°C. In addition to salt synthesis and experimentally determining thermodynamic properties, Ab Initio molecular dynamic (AIMD) simulations were used to calculate density and heat capacity values.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Deliquescence of eutectic LiCl-KCl diluted with NaCl for interim waste salt storage

Molten eutectic LiCl-KCl salt is a widely used electrolyte for electrorefining uranium from spent nuclear fuel. Due to the hygroscopic nature of this salt, careful handling and storage of solidified waste electrorefiner (ER) salt is required to avoid deliquescence and corrosion of container materials. This study investigated a potential processing path for reducing the deliquescence through dilution with NaCl. The hydration behavior of LiCl-KCl salts diluted with NaCl was evaluated in terms of mass gain due to mass of water absorption, visual evidence of deliquescence, and visual evidence of corrosion to stainless steel containers in a humid air environment. Pure eutectic LiCl-KCl exhibited a 50 mass% increase due to water absorption and showed signs of deliquescence after 24 hours. 89 mass% NaCl was required in order to prevent deliquescence. Dilution with 89% NaCl was also found to protect corrosion to stainless steel crucibles. Corrosion, thus, appears to require deliquescence. While NaCl dilution greatly decreases steady state hydration and eliminated deliquescence, storage volume is increased ~10x.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Molecular beam epitaxy of GaAs templates on water soluble NaCl thin films

Expensive III-V substrates are cost limiting for the adoption of many technologies. Consequently, being able to reuse the original substrate is highly desirable. Existing substrate reuse techniques have significant drawbacks, but this work discusses a new method using molecular beam epitaxy deposition of water soluble NaCl thin films on commonly employed (0 0 1) GaAs substrates. Single-crystal GaAs templates are grown on continuous NaCl layers utilizing careful exposure of the NaCl to an in-situ electron beam and a low temperature nucleation layer. The template layers can be quickly removed from the substrate via dissolution of the NaCl. After liftoff, the original wafer shows an increase in rms surface roughness of only 0.2 nm.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

An ab initio molecular dynamics investigation of the thermophysical properties of molten NaCl-MgCl 2

Molten salts have many applications in the nuclear and solar energy industries for thermal storage and heat transfer applications. However, there is a knowledge gap in molten salt thermophysical properties which hinders the technical readiness level of molten salt applications, especially in the nuclear industry. A common method of investigating new materials is through ab initio Molecular Dynamics (AIMD) simulations which is an effective tool to investigate structural and thermophysical properties at realistic temperatures. NaCl-MgCl 2 is an inexpensive salt that is a good candidate for use as a heat transfer medium in solar power applications or in the secondary loop of a nuclear reactor. In this article, the thermophysical properties of NaCl-MgCl 2 are computed via AIMD calculations to supplement the limited experimental studies in the literature. Here a wide range of compositions and temperatures for the pseudo-binary NaCl-MgCl 2 were used to calculate the density, heat capacity, compressibility, enthalpy of mixing, and volumetric thermal expansion coefficient. AIMD is shown to accurately model the densities of molten NaCl-MgCl 2 as there is good agreement with the available literature. This work observed a transition to a monotonic increase of the density with respect to MgCl 2 composition occurring above 1100 K. The heat capacity values increase uniformly with respect to concentration of MgCl 2 at a rate of 2.85 J/mol-K per 10 mol% of MgCl 2 . Select thermophysical properties are fit to a Redlich-Kister expansion for utilization in multiphysics simulations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Thermophysical Properties of NaCl–UCl 3 –PuCl 3 Molten Salts: A Combined Computational and Experimental Study

Actinide-bearing molten salts for use as fuels are an essential part of next generation molten salt reactors. Yet, numerous multicomponent salt mixtures are underdeveloped or have not been investigated. Here, this study, based on a combination of experimental and modeling techniques, is dedicated to determining and understanding a variety of properties of the ternary system of NaCl–UCl 3 –PuCl 3 , which represents a scenario for burnup of NaCl–UCl 3 fuel, at two compositions (∼10 and 5 mol % PuCl 3 in eutectic NaCl–UCl 3 pseudobinary) and a range of temperatures. Evaluation of the heat flow and mass loss data showed the 0.61NaCl–0.30UCl 3 –0.09PuCl 3 salt had a melting temperature of 551 ± 5 °C. Two additional thermal effects were observed occurring at approximately 410 and 494 °C. The transition occurring at 410 °C may be due to the presence of oxide in the salt. Extrapolation of thermodynamic data indicates the transition occurring at 494 °C is due to the formation of a liquid phase. Experimental testing determined the density of this system is a linear function of temperature and can be represented by the equation ρ = 4.014–0.0010T(°C), R 2 = 0.992. Additionally, by using atomistic modeling, we found that increasing the PuCl 3 content from 5 to 10 mol % led to the formation of larger Pu 3+ clusters and slower transport of ions.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Sodium doping of solution-processed amine-thiol based CIGS solar cells by thermal evaporation of NaCl

Poor crystallinity, high degree of porosity and rough surfaces are the main drawbacks of solution-processed CIGS absorbers resulting in lower power conversion efficiencies when compared to vacuum-based CIGS solar cells. Therefore, promoting absorber grain growth is key to further improve solution-based solar cell performance. The effect of alkali elements such as Na in CIGS absorbers is generally recognised to have beneficial effects not only on the absorber opto-electronic properties but also on the grain growth. In this work, thermal evaporation of a thin layer of NaCl prior to selenisation resulted in absorbers with significantly larger CIGS grains than previously seen with Na diffusing directly from the from soda-lime glass substrate. NaCl is non-toxic, abundant and readily available compound that has not been typically used as an evaporation source, but rather as an additive into CIGS precursor solution. The effect of Na on these solution-processed CIGS devices was primarily observed in the spectacular morphological changes leading to improved carrier collection and minority carrier lifetimes, but less on the absorber doping. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) revealed voids forming around large CIGS grains upon NaCl addition and these had a negative effect on inter-grain carrier transport. Nonetheless, the resulting device performance doubled from 5% to 10% with addition of Na using this doping approach; however, a compromise between the optimum grain growth and optimum electronic properties had to be made. This study demonstrates a novel, simple and effective Na-doping strategy for CIGS absorbers and reveals the current limitations of the Na-doping in solution-processed atmospherically deposited cells.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Dry Deactivation of Sodium Metal in a Molten LiCl-KCl-CsCl-NaCl System

An experimental study was performed with the objective of investigating and characterizing a dry technique for deactivation of sodium metal in a molten salt system. The study was performed in three parts. First, proof-of-principle testing of the technique was performed at bench scale. It involved loading and melting tens of grams of clean sodium metal atop a pool of LiCl-KCl-CsCl eutectic at ∼300°C and then adding ammonium chloride particles while mixing. The ammonium chloride reacted with sodium to form sodium chloride and nitrogen/hydrogen off-gases. The sodium chloride assimilated into the salt pool, forming a quaternary salt mixture of LiCl-KCl-CsCl-NaCl. The proof-of-principle testing repeatedly exhibited complete deactivation of the loaded sodium metal. Second, characterization of a LiCl-KCl-CsCl-NaCl system was performed using differential scanning calorimetry to produce a partial phase diagram of LiCl-KCl-CsCl eutectic versus NaCl, which identified the liquidus, solidus, and two-phase regions of the quaternary system. Third, the dry deactivation technique was demonstrated at kg-scale in an inert atmosphere radiological glovebox with sodium metal that was previously separated in the same glovebox from uranium metal in unirradiated blanket elements for the Fermi-1 nuclear reactor. The quaternary salt product at the end of the demonstration was sampled and showed complete deactivation of the sodium metal. Here, in short, this study qualified a technique to completely deactivate batches of sodium metal in the absence of air or water. While this study focused on the deactivation of sodium metal, including bond sodium from unirradiated blanket elements, the technique is applicable to other sources of sodium metal, such as sodium metal from batteries. Furthermore, the technique could also be extended to other alkali metal systems, including lithium, sodium, potassium, rubidium, cesium, and mixtures thereof.

11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Electric Field’s Dueling Effects through Dehydration and Ion Separation in Driving NaCl Nucleation at Charged Nanoconfined Interfaces

Investigating nucleation in charged nanoconfined environments under electric fields is crucial for many scientific and engineering applications. Here we study the nucleation of NaCl from aqueous solution near charged surfaces using machine-learning-augmented enhanced sampling molecular dynamics simulations. Our simulations successfully drive phase transitions between the liquid and solid phases of NaCl. The solid phase is stabilized under electric fields, particularly at an intermediate surface charge density. We examine which physical characteristics drive the nucleation of NaCl from aqueous solutions and find that the removal of solvent water from Cl– at the solid precursor surface plays a more critical role than the accumulation of ions. Our simulations reveal the competing effects of electric fields on nucleation processes: they facilitate the removal of water, promoting nucleation, but also promote the separation of ion pairs, thereby hindering nucleation. Here, this work provides a framework for studying nucleation processes in nanoconfined environments under electric fields and provides physical insights for the design of electrochemistry materials.

Electric fields↗

Simultaneous compression of NaCl, Au, and ruby: toward mutually consistent pressure scales

Here, we evaluate pressure consistency of equations of state (EOS) for NaCl and Au at 300 K. The simultaneous measurements of unit-cell volumes (V) with ruby R1 line shifts (Δλ) in a helium (He) loaded diamond cell effectively remove potential systematic errors. Compression and decompression data were automatically collected at 1 sec interval, yielding a dense dataset with >8,000 (V, Δλ) pairs each for NaCl and Au. Solidification of He has noticeable effects on both V and Delta lambda (hence P). Only data up to similar to 14 GPa, or 6000 (V, P) pairs, can be considered hydrostatic within the resolution. The P-V data are fitted to the Rydberg-Vinet and the 3 rd order Birch-Murnaghan EOS. Predicted pressures of these EOSs agree with those given by the Ruby2020 ruby scale to within +/- 0.05 GPa. Overall, pressures predicted by the Rydberg-Vinet EOS are in better agreement with the average of commonly used NaCl and Au pressure scales.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗

Influence of NaCl concentration on the optical scattering properties of water-based aerosols

We present the characterization of several atmospheric aerosol analogs in a tabletop chamber and an analysis of how the concentration of NaCl present in these aerosols influences their bulk optical properties. Atmospheric aerosols (e.g., fog and haze) degrade optical signal via light–aerosol interactions causing scattering and absorption, which can be described by Mie theory. This attenuation is a function of the size distribution and number concentration of droplets in the light path. These properties are influenced by ambient conditions and the droplet’s composition, as described by Köhler theory. It is therefore possible to tune the wavelength-dependent bulk optical properties of an aerosol by controlling droplet composition. We present experimentation wherein we generated multiple microphysically and optically distinct atmospheric aerosol analogs using salt water solutions with varying concentrations of NaCl. The results demonstrate that changing the NaCl concentration has a clear and predictable impact on the microphysical and optical properties of the aerosol.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Gamma Irradiation of NaCl-UCl 3 Salt for the Molten Chloride Fast Reactor

This report documents the results of the gamma ray irradiation of NaCl-UCl 3 eutectic salt in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) spent fuel pool gamma tube and subsequent analysis of capsules utilizing the Gas Assay Sample and Recharge (GASR) system. NaCl-UCl 3 salt capsules at four different temperatures, 75C, 150C, 300C and 600C, were irradiated shortly after the core internal changeout (CIC) of the ATR, beginning April 28 th of 2021, and ending on August 18 th of 2021. Re-positioning of the fuel elements in the spent fuel pool to move more fresh fuel elements around the gamma tube occurred on May 11 th of 2021, resulting in an approximate 20% increase in the dose rate and consequently the total absorbed dose. In total, the salt-filled capsules underwent 2638 hours of gamma irradiation from the adjacent freshly discharged ATR spent fuel. Capsule internal pressure measurements were taken via the Gas Assay Sample and Recharge (GASR) system in the INL Hot Fuels Examination Facility (HFEF) following completion of the irradiation. Based on the GASR analysis results, the primary conclusion from this experiment to-date is that radiolytic generation of chlorine gas is insignificant for the dose rates and total absorbed dose that these samples experienced. To elucidate more detailed effects of radiolysis on NaCl-UCl 3 eutectic salts and reach a more definitive conclusion, further advanced analyses such as electron microscopy, simultaneous thermal analysis, and electron paramagnetic resonance are recommended to analyze the capsule wall and salt samples.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Property Measurements of NaCl-UCl 3 and LiF-NaF-KF Molten Salts Doped with Surrogate Fission Products

Knowing thermophysical and thermochemical property values of salts over the expected range of operating temperatures is essential to modeling and simulation efforts that support the commercialization of molten salt reactor (MSR) technologies. Salt properties being measured at Argonne include thermal transitions, phase behavior, heat capacity, density, surface tension, volumetric thermal expansion, thermal diffusivity, thermal conductivity, and viscosity. The properties of several salts of interest including NaCl-UCl 3 and LiF-NaF-KF (FLiNaK) have been measured at Argonne and reported previously. These property measurements are suitable for use in evaluating reactor performance during startup and the early operating life of the reactor. The physical and chemical behavior of the fuel salt is altered by the buildup of fission products and the resulting changes in heat transfer and other properties must be understood by reactor developers. This report summarizes melting behavior, heat capacity, and thermal diffusivity values that were measured for mixtures of FLiNaK and NaCl-UCl 3 salts that have been doped with surrogate fission products. Additional heat capacity measurements were also performed on a separate mixture of FLiNaK without dopants. Measured properties are suitable for incorporation into the Molten Salt Thermal Properties Database–Thermochemical (MSTDB–TC) and the Molten Salt Thermal Properties Database–Thermophysical (MSTDB–TP) to support the development of MSRs. Salts were prepared by doping eutectic mixtures of NaCl-UCl 3 and FLiNaK with surrogate fission products. These salts were prepared for use in salt spill experiments being performed at Argonne and were subsequently used for thermal property measurements. Thermal transitions and heat capacities were measured by using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and thermal diffusivity was measured by using laser flash analysis (LFA) at temperatures spanning the typical MSR operating range. The measured property values of the doped salts were compared to measured property values of salts without fission products to quantify the effects of the doped fission products.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

NaCl aggregation in water at elevated temperatures and pressures: Comparison of classical force fields

The properties of water vary dramatically with temperature and density. This can be exploited to control its effectiveness as a solvent. Thus, supercritical water is of keen interest as solvent in many extraction processes. The low solubility of salts in lower density supercritical water has even been suggested as a means of desalination. The high temperatures and pressures required to reach supercritical conditions can present experimental challenges during collection of required physical property and phase equilibria data, especially in salt-containing systems. Molecular simulations have the potential to be a valuable tool for examining the behavior of solvated ions at these high temperatures and pressures. However, the accuracy of classical force fields under these conditions is unclear. We have, therefore, undertaken a parametric study of NaCl in water, comparing several salt and water models at 200 bar–600 bar and 450 K–750 K for a range of salt concentrations. We report a comparison of structural properties including ion aggregation, hydrogen bonding, density, and static dielectric constants. All of the force fields qualitatively reproduce the trends in the liquid phase density. An increase in ion aggregation with decreasing density holds true for all of the force fields. The propensity to aggregate is primarily determined by the salt force field rather than the water force field. This coincides with a decrease in the water static dielectric constant and reduced charge screening. While a decrease in the static dielectric constant with increasing NaCl concentration is consistent across all model combinations, the salt force fields that exhibit more ionic aggregation yield a slightly smaller dielectric decrement.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Ab-initio molecular dynamics study of eutectic chloride salt: MgCl2–NaCl–KCl

Ionic liquid materials are viable candidates as a heat transfer fluid (HTF) in a wide range of applications, notably within concentrated solar power (CSP) technology and molten salt reactors (MSRs). For next-generation CSP and MSR technologies that strive for higher power generation efficiency, a HTF with wide liquid phase range and energy storage capabilities is crucial. Studies have shown that eutectic chloride salts exhibit thermal stability at high temperatures, high heat storage capacity, and are less expensive than nitrate and carbonate salts. However, the experimental data needed to fully evaluate the potential of eutectic chloride salts as a HTF contender are scarce and entail large uncertainties. Considering the high cost and potential hazards associated with the experimental methods used to determine the properties of ionic liquids, molecular modeling can be used as a viable alternative resource. In this study, the eutectic ternary chloride salt MgCl 2 –NaCl–KCl is modeled using ab-initio molecular dynamics simulations (AIMDs) in the liquid phase. Using the simulated data, the thermophysical and transport properties of eutectic chloride salt can be calculated: density, viscosity, heat capacity, diffusion coefficient, and ionic conductivity. For an initial model validation, experimental pair-distribution function data were obtained from X-ray total scattering techniques and compared to the theoretical pair-distribution function. Additionally, theoretical viscosity values are compared to experimental viscosity values for a similar system. The results provide a starting foundation for a MgCl 2 –NaCl–KCl model that can be extended to predict other fundamental properties.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗

Thermodynamic description of molten salt systems: KCl-LiCl-NaCl and KCl-LiCl-NdCl 3

The mixture of KCl and LiCl has been used as electrolyte in the electrorefining process to recover uranium from used nuclear fuels due to the low melting point. However, lanthanides and sodium in the reactor waste continuously dissolve into it and thus alter its thermodynamic properties. To understand the thermodynamic behavior evolution of the electrolyte with the accumulation of impurities, thermodynamic modeling for KCl-LiCl-NaCl and KCl-LiCl-NdCl 3 and four constituent binary systems in the entire composition space was performed using the CALPHAD (CALculation of PHAse Diagrams) approach. The ionic liquid was described by the two-sublattice model, where neutral species were introduced to consider short-range ordering (SRO) within the melt, whereas the solid solution was modeled based on the Compound Energy Formalism. Literature data on phase equilibria and thermochemical properties were critically evaluated and used during the optimization of thermodynamic parameters for KCl-LiCl-NaCl and KCl-LiCl-NdCl 3 and their subsystems. The calculated phase diagrams and mixing enthalpies are in good agreement with the experimental data. The thermodynamic modeling for the KCl-LiCl-NdCl 3 system was carried out for the first time. To fill the gap in experimental measurement, enthalpy of mixing for the KCl-LiCl-NdCl 3 melt was estimated using the surrounded-ion model. These data then served as critical inputs for thermodynamic optimization. Furthermore, the present study can provide insights into thermodynamic property evolution of the electrolyte and solubility limit of various impurities during the electrorefining process.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Predicting thermophysical properties of molten salts in the MgCl 2 -NaCl-KCl-LiCl system with a shell-model potential

Ternary eutectic salts composed of MgCl 2 , NaCl, and KCl, referred to as MNK salts, have recently emerged as promising candidates as high-temperature heat transfer fluids and thermal energy storage media. Here we performed classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to predict the densities, specific heat capacities, viscosities, and ionic self-diffusivities for MNK salts over a wide temperature range. The impact of LiCl additive on their thermophysical properties was also investigated. To capture the electronic polarization of Cl anions by neighboring cations, we developed a novel shell-model potential using the force-matching method and a dataset of ab initio calculated interatomic forces. Our extensive MD simulations predict structure and properties for pure salts and binary/ternary salt mixtures in the MgCl 2 -NaCl-KCl-LiCl system in overall good agreement with available experimental and theoretical data, which corroborates the accuracy and reliability of our developed potential.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Development and demonstration of a rolling ball viscometer for molten salts with near-minimum liquidus NaCl–KCl

The thermophysical characterization of molten chloride and fluoride salts is a key interest for the development of advanced molten salt nuclear reactors. Viscosity is one thermophysical property of interest; a high-accuracy understanding of this property is necessary for modeling the thermal energy transfer and mass flow rate for a given molten salt system. Only a few methods have consistently been used to measure the viscosity of molten chloride and fluoride salt systems, and large discrepancies have been observed in the literature between independent studies of nearly identical salt systems. As such, exploration of novel measurement methods or implementations may allow for further validation, improved measurement accuracy, and overall improved understanding about optimal approaches for measuring molten salt viscosity. Here, in this study, a novel implementation of the rolling ball viscometry method was used to measure the viscosity of a 44/56 mol % mixture of NaCl–KCl within a temperature range of 714–838 °C, with the intent to demonstrate the feasibility of this technique for molten salt viscosity measurement cross-validation. The purity of this salt was confirmed through laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy. Measured viscosities were approximately 1.3–1.0 cP within this temperature range, and the overall uncertainty was 10.8%, which was determined through Gaussian error propagation. The results agree reasonably well with measured viscosities of similar NaCl–KCl mixtures in the literature (within 2%–20% depending on the temperature and study), although the experimental error in some of these comparative studies may be significant.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗