Negative fluxes and cell-miss errors in the random ray method
The random ray method is a recently developed stochastic method for solving neutral particle transport problems based on the method of characteristics. Perhaps surprisingly for a characteristics-based method using flat sources, we note that the random ray method can produce negative fluxes which may be numerically troublesome in several situations. These occur most severely in fixed source problems where the source is in a region with a small cross section. Additionally, we briefly discuss another source of bias which can occur in similar situations, namely a ray missing a mesh with a strong source and small cross section, resulting in the entirety of the source being unphysically deposited locally. This paper describes the mechanism by which negative fluxes may occur and several different methods to mitigate their effects. These fixes are tested on an eigenvalue problem, a ‘fusion-like’ shielding problem, and a shielding problem featuring an adjoint calculation. Even when extremely coarse random ray quadratures are used such that 20%–30% of cells are missed during a given iteration, use of the preferred fix technique ensures local flux tally errors remain trivial (below 1%). The preferred fix is now the default option in SCONE and OpenMC.