Analysis of the extraterrestrial life detection problem
Analysis of extraterrestrial life detection problem
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Analysis of extraterrestrial life detection problem
Extraterrestrial life detection studied from knowledge of major and trace components of atmospheres
Organic decontamination of sampling and storage devices are crucial steps for life-detection, habitability, and ecological investigations of extremophiles living in the most inhospitable niches of Earth, Mars and elsewhere. However, one of the main stumbling blocks for Mars-analogue life-detection studies in terrestrial remote field-sites is the capability to clean instruments and sampling devices to organic levels consistent with null values. Here we present a new seven-step, multi-reagent cleaning and decontamination protocol that was adapted and tested on a glacial ice-coring device and on a rover-guided scoop used for sediment sampling both deployed multiple times during two field seasons of the Arctic Mars Analog Svalbard Expedition AMASE). The effectiveness of the protocols for both devices was tested by (1)in situ metabolic measurements via APT, (2)in situ lipopolysacchride (LPS) quantifications via low-level endotoxin assays, and(3) laboratory-based molecular detection via gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. Our results show that the combination and step-wise application of disinfectants with oxidative and solvation properties for sterilization are effective at removing cellular remnants and other organic traces to levels necessary for molecular organic- and life-detection studies. The validation of this seven-step protocol - specifically for ice sampling - allows us to proceed with confidence in kmskia4 analogue investigations of icy environments. However, results from a rover scoop test showed that this protocol is also suitable for null-level decontamination of sample acquisition devices. Thus, this protocol may be applicable to a variety of sampling devices and analytical instrumentation used for future astrobiology missions to Enceladus, and Europa, as well as for sample-return missions.
On Earth, light microscopy is commonly used in microbiology to identify organisms and observe their interactions with the environment; this makes it an attractive technique for in situ life detection methods on ocean worlds. As a standalone technique, brightfield microscopy, while able to provide important contextual information, has limited usefulness as a life detection technique because it is often challenging to differentiate between abiotic and biotic particles based solely on their size and shape, which may introduce risks of false positive or false negative interpretations. However, these risks can be reduced by combining brightfield microscopy with fluorescence microscopy to provide a method that correlate sample chemistry with sample morphology. In this work, we have used the Luminescence Imager for Exploration (LIfE), a brightfield and epifluorescence microscope with an integrated sample processing system (matured under the Concepts for Ocean worlds Life Detection Technology and Instrument Concepts of Europa Exploration programs) to develop methods that increase the fidelity of in situ microscopy life detection measurements through two main approaches. First, native fluorescence is excited in molecules that contain aromatic moieties such as proteins (using deep UV excitation), and energy carrying molecules and endogenous chromophores (using visible-light excitation), to correlate the location of these species with cell-like structural features (brightfield imaging). Second, fluorescent stains are used to selectively image cells and cell fragments by targeting proteins, lipids, and nucleic acids. We discuss the results of tests, obtained using ocean world analog samples, that have examined trades associated with implementing these methods autonomously in planetary missions, including the intrinsic properties of candidate fluorescence dyes and long-term storage and radiation stability.
On Earth, light microscopy is commonly used in microbiology to identify organisms and observe their interactions with the environment; this makes it an attractive technique for in situ life detection methods on ocean worlds. As a standalone technique, brightfield microscopy, while able to provide important contextual information, has limited usefulness as a life detection technique because it is often challenging to differentiate between abiotic and biotic particles based solely on their size and shape, which may introduce risks of false positive or false negative interpretations. However, these risks can be reduced by combining brightfield microscopy with fluorescence microscopy to provide a method that correlate sample chemistry with sample morphology. In this work, we have used the Luminescence Imager for Exploration (LIfE), a brightfield and epifluorescence microscope with an integrated sample processing system (matured under the Concepts for Ocean worlds Life Detection Technology and Instrument Concepts of Europa Exploration programs) to develop methods that increase the fidelity of in situ microscopy life detection measurements through two main approaches. First, native fluorescence is excited in molecules that contain aromatic moieties such as proteins (using deep UV excitation), and energy carrying molecules and endogenous chromophores (using visible-light excitation), to correlate the location of these species with cell-like structural features (brightfield imaging). Second, fluorescent stains are used to selectively image cells and cell fragments by targeting proteins, lipids, and nucleic acids. We discuss the results of tests, obtained using ocean world analog samples, that have examined trades associated with implementing these methods autonomously in planetary missions, including the intrinsic properties of candidate fluorescence dyes and long-term storage and radiation stability.
"This study report summarizes technological developments in science-required contamination control for cost-capped, life-detection missions in the Solar System. Technology advances focus on developing implementable strategies to restrict contamination of the spacecraft and instruments by the launch vehicle hardware. Secondary bake out operations during cruise further reduce molecular contaminants down to femtomolar levels in the sample path. The study validated a full-spacecraft, deployable barrier design as an effective strategy to isolate the spacecraft from the pre-launch processing and launch environment (e.g., fairing acoustic materials). It accommodates late mounting of RTGs and other required prelaunch activities. A new, high-fidelity physics, contamination-transport model for particles (including cells and their parts) and science-relevant molecules (e.g., possible biomolecules) was developed to validate the barrier concept. Importantly, this model takes into account the physics of extremely clean surfaces achieved by the best traditional contamination engineering. The ability to deal with very low levels of particulate and molecular contamination makes this model unique among standard contamination modeling approaches. Modeling also demonstrated that a high-temperature bake out during interplanetary cruise of the sample collector that comprises the largest surface area in the sample path for an Enceladus orbiter reference mission, was extremely effective. This study included the evaluation of other details necessary for an effective contamination control strategy for life detection missions including feasibility of achieving parts per trillion level cleanliness for semi-volatile hydrocarbons in nitrogen purge gas, identification of launch vehicle services required for the baseline contamination control, and defining additional contamination control measures to be taken during launch operations. Key results of the study are: • New spacecraft barrier design that accommodates RTGs is readily cleanable and repairable. Deployment of a 1/3 scale model was successfully demonstrated. • The barrier reduces particle contamination (likely biological) from fairing to spacecraft by 1e-2 to 1e-3. • On-cruise bake-out of critical surfaces significantly reduced molecular contamination (by as much as 1e-12). Subsequently, the probability of a surface contamination particle being transported to an instrument by an ice particle is less than 5.1e-5 (for microbes specifically, 4.39e-10). The report concludes that a full-spacecraft barrier designed specifically for life-detection missions that require stringent control of particulate and molecular contaminates is an effective means of mitigating risks of false positive and negative results for life signature investigations. Further, secondary cleaning steps for critical sections of the sample path can be highly effective at reducing molecular contaminants to low femtomolar levels."
"This study report summarizes technological developments in science-required contamination control for cost-capped, life-detection missions in the Solar System. Technology advances focus on developing implementable strategies to restrict contamination of the spacecraft and instruments by the launch vehicle hardware. Secondary bake out operations during cruise further reduce molecular contaminants down to femtomolar levels in the sample path. The study validated a full-spacecraft, deployable barrier design as an effective strategy to isolate the spacecraft from the pre-launch processing and launch environment (e.g., fairing acoustic materials). It accommodates late mounting of RTGs and other required prelaunch activities. A new, high-fidelity physics, contamination-transport model for particles (including cells and their parts) and science-relevant molecules (e.g., possible biomolecules) was developed to validate the barrier concept. Importantly, this model takes into account the physics of extremely clean surfaces achieved by the best traditional contamination engineering. The ability to deal with very low levels of particulate and molecular contamination makes this model unique among standard contamination modeling approaches. Modeling also demonstrated that a high-temperature bake out during interplanetary cruise of the sample collector that comprises the largest surface area in the sample path for an Enceladus orbiter reference mission, was extremely effective. This study included the evaluation of other details necessary for an effective contamination control strategy for life detection missions including feasibility of achieving parts per trillion level cleanliness for semi-volatile hydrocarbons in nitrogen purge gas, identification of launch vehicle services required for the baseline contamination control, and defining additional contamination control measures to be taken during launch operations. Key results of the study are: • New spacecraft barrier design that accommodates RTGs is readily cleanable and repairable. Deployment of a 1/3 scale model was successfully demonstrated. • The barrier reduces particle contamination (likely biological) from fairing to spacecraft by 1e-2 to 1e-3. • On-cruise bake-out of critical surfaces significantly reduced molecular contamination (by as much as 1e-12). Subsequently, the probability of a surface contamination particle being transported to an instrument by an ice particle is less than 5.1e-5 (for microbes specifically, 4.39e-10). The report concludes that a full-spacecraft barrier designed specifically for life-detection missions that require stringent control of particulate and molecular contaminates is an effective means of mitigating risks of false positive and negative results for life signature investigations. Further, secondary cleaning steps for critical sections of the sample path can be highly effective at reducing molecular contaminants to low femtomolar levels."
Experiment for the detection of life of an aqueous, carbonaceous nature on mars /gulliver/
Gulliver radioisotopic biochemical probe to detect extraterrestrial life
Macroscopic and microscopic visual detection of life on Mars noting telemetry, photometry, data processing, etc
Life detection instrument incorporating metabolism and growth experiments including detection of metabolism of radioactive substrates, photosynthesis, etc
Ubiquitous across terrestrial life is cellular machinery that allows chemical energy flow by facilitating and regulating electron-transfer and chemical modification pathways. Key classes of energy transport molecules enable this movement of electrons for a variety of biological purposes. Additionally, biological enzymes function to add or remove functional groups such asphosphate moieties to redox biomolecules. Presumably, extraterrestrial life is likely to rely on similar energy transport mechanisms. With the search for life in our solar system focused on the icy satellites of Jupiter and Saturn, Europa and Enceladus, developing instrumentation capable of measuring electrochemical redox signatures representative of biomolecules or enzymatic activity in seawater appears a promising and novel means of life detection. Here, we report our adaptation of the Mars Phoenix Wet Chemistry Laboratory (WCL) electroanalytical voltammetry capabilities to assay life-critical redox molecules in synthetic seawater representative of a saline alkaline solution similar to what has been predicted from the Cassini mission data of Enceladus’ sub-surface ocean. In addition, we employ a well-established electrochemical assay that indicates phosphatase activity by comparing substrate and product redox signatures. Our study demonstrated a 10 nM limit of detection for biological redox molecules and a 3 aM limit of detection for alkaline phosphatase in seawater. Incorporation of these methods into next generation WCL payloads aimed at ocean world life detection will enable the search for biological redox-active species and enzymatic activity as indicators of life.
Sequential analyses of planetary surface sample for extraterrestrial life detection, discussing chemistry, morphology, growth and metabolism for life attributes
Pyrolysis gas chromatography method for life detection and chemical identification of microorganisms
Extraterrestrial life detection based on catalysis of oxygen exchange between labeled oxyanions and water, noting equipment
Extraterrestrial life detection method based on catalysis of isotopic oxygen exchange between water and oxygen-containing anions
Extraterrestrial life detection based on catalysis of oxygen exchange between labeled oxyanions and water, noting equipment
Sample acquisition from planetary surface by unmanned probes in life detection experiments