Tribology Induced Water Pump Bearing Failure
NASA’s In-Space Propulsion facility experienced two infant mortality water pump bearing failures during a recent refurbishment campaign, the cause or causes of which were unclear. A forensic failure study was undertaken that included site visits, collection and examination of physical evidence and a bearing and pump design review. The pumps are large (2000 hp) vertical turbine design machines that utilize metallic sleeve bearings cooled and lubricated by the pumped fluid (water). Though initial possible root cause for the failures were attributed to improper fabrication and debris contamination, detailed examination of failure surfaces combined with bearing design revealed that the failure mode was thermal seizure brought on by inadequate cooling flow. An unusual contributing factor was that the use of grease as an assembly lubricant, as opposed to a fluid like oil, appears to have exacerbated the rather than alleviated the thermal runaway by blocking water flow. Resolution of the problem was achieved through the design and installation of dedicated bearing lubrication water feed system.