Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “REFINERY”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 343 records · Page 19

A Theoretical Investigation of the Structure and Reactivity of the Molecular Constituents of Oil Sand and Oil Shale

We used a variety of small organic models of asphaltenes to investigate the molecular mechanism for the high temperature decomposition that would take place as part of the oil refinery process. We determined that the decomposition is initiated via four different types of hydrogen migration reactions. According to the energetics of the reactions, the dominant 1,2-H shift mechanism involves two competitive product channels, namely, C 2 H 2 + CH 2 CS and CS + CH 3 CCH. The minor channels include the formation of CS + CH 2 CCH 2 , H 2 S + C 4 H 2 , HCS + CH 2 CCH, CS + CH 2 CHCH, H + C 4 H 3 S, and HS + C 4 H 3 . We also investigated the alkyl substitution effect by exploring the decomposition pathways of models with alkyl arms. The energetics of such systems were very similar to that for unsubstituted model compounds, which suggests that asphaltene alkylation may not play a significant role in the decomposition of asphaltene compounds. This work was published in the Journal of Physical Chemistry A 2011, 115, 2882-2891. A MECHANISTIC STUDY OF THE 2-THIENYLMETHYL + HO2 RADICAL RECOMBINATION REACTION Radicals are molecules which contain single electrons. They are very reactive. Radical recombination reactions are important in the combustion of fuel oils. Shale oil contains radicals. We used quantum mechanics to explore the reactivity of shale oil model radical compounds. Seventeen product channels corresponding to either addition/elimination or direct hydrogen abstraction were characterized. Direct hydrogen abstraction proceeds via a weakly bonded complex, which leads to 2-methylthiophene, 2-methylene-2,3-dihydrothiophene or 2-methylene-2,5-dihydrothiophene depending upon the 2-thienylmethyl radical reaction site. The addition pathway for the two radical reactants is barrierless with the formation of three adducts, as distinguished by HO 2 reaction at three different sites on the 2-thienylmethyl radical. The addition is exothermic by 37 ~ 55 kcal mol-1 relative to the entrance channel. These excess energies are available to promote further decomposition or rearrangement of the adducts that lead to nascent products such as H, OH, H 2 O and CH 2 O. The reaction surfaces are characterized by relatively low barriers (most are lower than 10 kcal mol-1). Based upon a careful analysis of the overall barrier heights and reaction exothermicities, the formation of O2, OH and H2O is likely to be an important pathway in the radical recombination reactions of 2-thienylmethyl + HO 2 . This work was published in the Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 2011, 115, 14546-14557. REACTION OF THIOPHENE AND METHYLTHIOPHENE WITH SINGLET AND TRIPLET MOLECULAR OXYGEN Mechanisms for the reaction of thiophene and 2-methylthiophene with molecular oxygen on both the triplet and singlet potential energy surfaces (PESs) were investigated using ab initio methods. Thiophene and 2-methylthiophene where shown to react with O 2 via two types of mechanisms; namely, direct hydrogen abstraction and addition/elimination. The barriers for reaction with triplet oxygen are all significantly large (i.e., > 30 kcal mol-1), which indicates that the direct oxidation of thiophene by ground state oxygen might be important only in high temperature processes. Reaction of thiophene with singlet oxygen via a 2+4 cycloaddition leading to endoperoxides is the most favorable channel. Moreover, it was found that alkylation of the thiophene ring (i.e., methyl-substituted thiophene) is capable of lowering the barrier height for the addition pathway. The implication of the current theoretical results may shed new light on the initiation mechanisms for combustion of asphaltenes. This work was published in the Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 2012 116, 4934-4946. JAHN-TELLER STABILIZATION IN POSS CATIONS We have a long standing interest in polyoligomeric silsesquioxane (POSS) molecules. 1-2 These molecules have recently been used as advanced surface coatings for photovoltaic devices and have potential as molecular-based energy storage devices as well as magnetically controllable liquid marbles. 3-5 We have been investigating the small molecule encapsulation properties of POSS and discovered some interesting symmetry breaking processes that need to be better understood in order to use POSS in advanced materials. We have investigated this symmetry breaking mechanism in POSS monocations Si8O12(C(CH3)3)8+ and Si8O12Cl8+, using density functional theory (DFT) and group theory. Under Oh symmetry, these ions possess 2T2g and 2Eg electronic states, respectively, and undergo different symmetry breaking mechanisms. The ground states of Si 8 O 12 (C(CH 3 ) 3 ) 8 + and Si 8 O 12 Cl 8 + belong to the C 3v and D 4h point groups and are characterized by Jahn-Teller stabilization energies of 3959 and 1328 cm-1, respectively, at the B3LYP/def2-SVP level of theory. The symmetry distortion mechanism in Si 8 O 12 Cl 8 + is Jahn-Teller type, whereas in Si 8 O 12 (C(CH 3 ) 3 ) 8 + the distortion is a combination of both Jahn-Teller and pseudo-Jahn-Teller effects. The distortion force acting in Si 8 O 12 (C(CH 3 ) 3 ) 8 + is mainly localized on one Si-(tert-butyl) group while in Si 8 O 12 Cl 8 + it is distributed over the oxygen atoms. The main distortion forces acting on the Si8O12 core arise from the coupling between the electronic state and the vibrational modes; identified as 9t 2g +1e g +3a 2u for the Si 8 O 12 (C(CH 3 ) 3 ) 8 + and 1e g +2e g for Si 8 O 12 Cl 8 + . This work was published in the Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 2015, 119, 4237-4243.

04 OIL SHALES AND TAR SANDS↗

California Power-to-Gas and Power-to-Hydrogen Near-Term Business Case Evaluation

Flexible operation of electrolysis systems represents an opportunity to reduce the cost of hydrogen for a variety of end-uses while also supporting grid operations and thereby enabling greater renewable penetration. California is an ideal location to realize that value on account of growing renewable capacity and markets for hydrogen as a fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV) fuel, refineries, and other end-uses. Shifting the production of hydrogen to avoid high cost electricity and participation in utility and system operator markets along with installing renewable generation to avoid utility charges and increase revenue from the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) program can result in around $2.5/kg (21%) reduction in the production and delivery cost of hydrogen from electrolysis. This reduction can be achieved without impacting the consumers of hydrogen. Additionally, future strategies for reducing hydrogen cost were explored and include lower cost of capital, participation in the Renewable Fuel Standard program, capital cost reduction, and increased LCFS value. Each must be achieved independently and could each contribute to further reductions. Using the assumptions in this study found a 29% reduction in cost if all future strategies are realized. Flexible hydrogen production can simultaneously improve the performance and decarbonize multiple energy sectors. The lessons learned from this study should be used to understand near-term cost drivers and to support longer-term research activities to further improve cost effectiveness of grid integrated electrolysis systems.

33 ADVANCED PROPULSION SYSTEMS↗

Nuclear Hybrid Energy Systems FY16 Modeling Efforts at ORNL

A nuclear hybrid system uses a nuclear reactor as the basic power generation unit. The power generated by the nuclear reactor is utilized by one or more power customers as either thermal power, electrical power, or both. In general, a nuclear hybrid system will couple the nuclear reactor to at least one thermal power user in addition to the power conversion system. The definition and architecture of a particular nuclear hybrid system is flexible depending on local markets needs and opportunities. For example, locations in need of potable water may be best served by coupling a desalination plant to the nuclear system. Similarly, an area near oil refineries may have a need for emission-free hydrogen production. A nuclear hybrid system expands the nuclear power plant from its more familiar central power station role by diversifying its immediately and directly connected customer base. The definition, design, analysis, and optimization work currently performed with respect to the nuclear hybrid systems represents the work of three national laboratories. Idaho National Laboratory (INL) is the lead lab working with Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and Oak Ridge National Laboratory. Each laboratory is providing modeling and simulation expertise for the integration of the hybrid system.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Sweet Sorghum Alternative Fuel and Feed Pilot Project

The University of Arizona undertook a “pilot” project to grow sweet sorghum on a field scale (rather than a plot scale), produce juice from the sweet sorghum, deliver the juice to a bio-refinery and process it to fuel-grade ethanol. We also evaluated the bagasse for suitability as a livestock feed and as a fuel. In addition to these objectives we evaluated methods of juice preservation, ligno-cellulosic conversion of the bagasse to fermentable sugars and alternative methods of juice extraction.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

CREST: Center for Renewable Energy Science and Technology

The DOE project addressed an approach to the hydrogen economy by researching hydrogen generation from low cost domestic fossil fuel sources. Specifically, the CREST research team developed new processes for extracting hydrogen from southwestern lignite for the production of clean synthetic fuels such as synthetic crude oil that is free of sulfur, carbon dioxide and other pollutants that can be shipped to nearby Texas refineries and power plants for development of transportation fuels and power generation. Research was also undertaken to convert any potential by-products of this process such as CO 2 to useful chemicals and gases which may be recycled and used as feedstock to the synthetic fuel process. Finally, to ensure the proposed process is functional beyond bench scale, a detailed design of a pilot plant was completed. The overall project was divided into five tasks including a management task as outlined below.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

Integrated Biomass Refining Institute at North Carolina State University

The overall objective of the Integrated Biomass Refining Institute (IBRI) is to advance the fundamental understanding of novel biomass conversion technologies leading to the production of biofuels and bioproducts, expanding the range of feedstock that can be utilized and compounds produced from a biomass refinery. The outcomes of this project will be new analytical facilities for biofuels and bioproducts research at North Carolina State University (NCSU), establishment of the capabilities of a cellulosic ethanol screening pilot facility to monitor and control processes, and publications in the open literature and presentations at public conferences regarding novel crops and technologies for cost-effective biomass processing.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Nuclear Hybrid Energy System Model Stability Testing

A Nuclear Hybrid Energy System (NHES) uses a nuclear reactor as the basic power generation unit, and the power generated is used by multiple customers as combinations of thermal power or electrical power. The definition and architecture of a particular NHES can be adapted based on the needs and opportunities of different localities and markets. For example, locations in need of potable water may be best served by coupling a desalination plant to the NHES. Similarly, a location near oil refineries may have a need for emission-free hydrogen production. Using the flexible, multi-domain capabilities of Modelica, Argonne National Laboratory, Idaho National Laboratory, and Oak Ridge National Laboratory are investigating the dynamics (e.g., thermal hydraulics and electrical generation/consumption) and cost of a hybrid system. This paper examines the NHES work underway, emphasizing the control system developed for individual subsystems and the overall supervisory control system.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Impact of Expanded North Slope of Alaska Crude Oil Production on Oil Flows in the Contiguous United States (Summary)

Crude oil produced on the North Slope of Alaska (NSA) is primarily transported on the Trans-Alaska Pipeline System (TAPS) to in-state refineries and the Valdez Marine Terminal in southern Alaska. From the Terminal, crude oil is loaded onto tankers and is transported to export markets or to three major locations along the U.S. West Coast: Anacortes-Ferndale area (Washington), San Francisco Bay area, and Los Angeles area. North Slope of Alaska production has decreased about 75% since the 1980s, which has reduced utilization of TAPS.

02 PETROLEUM↗

Direct Coal -to-Liquids (CTL) for Jet Fuel Using Biomass-Derived Solvents

Battelle has demonstrated a novel and potentially breakthrough technology for a direct coal-to-liquids (CTL) process for producing jet fuel using biomass-derived coal solvents (bio-solvents). The Battelle process offers a significant reduction in capital and operating costs and a substantial reduction in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, without requiring carbon capture and storage (CCS). The results of the project are the advancement of three steps of the hybrid coal/biomass-to-jet fuel process to the technology readiness level (TRL) of 5. The project objectives were achieved over two phases. In Phase 1, all three major process steps were explored and refined at bench-scale, including: (1) biomass conversion to high hydrogen-donor bio-solvent; (2) coal dissolution in biomass-derived bio-solvent, without requiring molecular H 2 , to produce a synthetic crude (syncrude); and (3) two-stage catalytic hydrotreating/hydrogenation of syncrude to jet fuel and other distillates. In Phase 2, all three subsystems of the CTL process were scaled up to a pre-pilot scale, and an economic analysis was carried out. A total of over 40 bio-solvents were identified and prepared. The most unique attribute of Battelle’s bio-solvents is their ability to provide much-needed hydrogen to liquefy coal and thus increase its hydrogen content so much that the resulting syncrude is liquid at room temperature. Based on the laboratory-scale testing with bituminous coals from Ohio and West Virginia, a total of 12 novel bio-solvent met the goal of greater than 80% coal solubility, with 8 bio-solvents being as good as or better than a well-known but expensive hydrogen-donor solvent, tetralin. The Battelle CTL process was then scaled up to 1 ton/day (1TPD) at a pre-pilot facility operated in Morgantown, WV. These tests were conducted, in part, to produce enough material for syncrude-upgrading testing. To convert the Battelle-CTL syncrude into a form suitable as a blending stock for jet turbine fuel, a two-step catalytic upgrading process was developed at laboratory scale and then demonstrated at pre-pilot scale facility in Pittsburg, PA. Several drums of distillate products were produced, which were then distilled into unblended (neat) synthetic jet fuel and diesel products for a detailed characterization. Based on a detailed characterization of the synthetic jet fuel, a 20% synthetic, 80% commercial jet fuel blend was prepared, which met all specifications. An analysis of the synthetic diesel product showed that it has the promise of being a drop-in fuel as super-low (less than 15 ppm)-sulfur diesel fuel. A detailed economic analysis showed that the Battelle liquefaction process is economical at between 1000 metric tons/day (MT/day) and 2000 MT/day. The unit capital cost for Battelle CTL process for making jet fuel is 50K USD/daily bbl compared to 151K USD/daily bbl for indirect CTL, based on 2011 dollars. The jet-fuel selling cost at the refinery, including a 12% capital cost factor (which included profit), for the Battelle CTL process is 61USD/bbl (1.45 USD/gallon). This is competitive with crude oil price of 48 USD/bbl. At the same time, the GHG emissions of 3.56 MT CO 2 /MT fuel were lower than the GHG emissions of 3.79 MT CO 2 /MTfuel for petroleum-based fuels and 7.77 MT CO 2 /MT fuel for indirect CTL. Thus, the use of bio-solvents completely eliminates the need for carbon capture in the case of Battelle CTL process. The superior economics and low GHG emissions for the Battelle CTL process has thus sparked worldwide interest and some potential commercialization opportunities are emerging.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

California-Specific Power-to-Hydrogen and Power-to-Gas Business Case Evaluation

Flexible operation of electrolysis systems represents an opportunity to reduce the cost of hydrogen for a variety of end-uses while also supporting grid operations and thereby enabling greater renewable penetration. California is an ideal location to realize that value on account of growing renewable capacity and markets for hydrogen as a fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV) fuel, refineries, and other end-uses. Shifting the production of hydrogen to avoid high cost electricity and participation in utility and system operator markets along with installing renewable generation to avoid utility charges and increase revenue from the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) program can result in around $2.5/kg (21%) reduction in the production and delivery cost of hydrogen from electrolysis. This reduction can be achieved without impacting the consumers of hydrogen. Additionally, future strategies for reducing hydrogen cost were explored and include lower cost of capital, participation in the Renewable Fuel Standard program, capital cost reduction, and increased LCFS value. Each must be achieved independently and could each contribute to further reductions. Using the assumptions in this study found a 29% reduction in cost if all future strategies are realized. Flexible hydrogen production can simultaneously improve the performance and decarbonize multiple energy sectors. The lessons learned from this study should be used to understand near-term cost drivers and to support longer-term research activities to further improve cost effectiveness of grid integrated electrolysis systems.

30 DIRECT ENERGY CONVERSION↗

A Templated Approach for Multi-Physics Modeling of Hybrid Energy Systems in Modelica

A prototypical hybrid energy system (HES) couples a primary thermal power generator (i.e., nuclear power plant) with one or more additional subsystems beyond the traditional balance of plant electricity generation system. The definition and architecture of an HES can be adapted based on the needs and opportunities of a given local market. For example, locations in need of potable water may be best served by coupling a desalination plant to the HES. A location near an oil refinery may have a need for emission-free hydrogen production. The flexible, multidomain capabilities of Modelica are being used to investigate the dynamics (e.g., thermal hydraulics and electrical generation/consumption) of such a hybrid system. This paper examines the simulation infrastructure created to enable the coupling of multiphysics subsystem models for HES studies. A demonstration of a tightly coupled nuclear hybrid energy system implemented using the Modelica based infrastructure is presented for two representative cases. An appendix is also included providing a step-by-step procedure for using the template-based infrastructure.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

NETL Upstream Dashboard Version 3

In recent years, the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) has been using life cycle analysis (LCA) as a new and innovative way to analyze and compare different power production and transportation fuel production pathways. By using LCA, NETL has integrated a holistic approach to comparing energy production pathways instead of solely considering combustion emissions at energy conversion facilities (i.e., power plant or fuels refinery).

29 ENERGY PLANNING, POLICY, AND ECONOMY↗

Demonstration of Carbon Capture and Sequestration of Steam Methane Reforming Process Gas Used for Large-Scale Hydrogen Production

The large-scale, on-purpose production of hydrogen in the United States (i.e., ~4600 million standard cubic feet per day) represents one of the most significant industrial sources of CO 2 emissions within the chemical industry. Most of the hydrogen is produced by the steam methane reforming (SMR) process, through which methane and water are converted to H 2 and CO 2 , and virtually all of the co-produced CO 2 is emitted to the atmosphere. However, the process streams in the SMR plants contain CO 2 at concentrations that are amenable to utilization of conventional adsorption and emerging CO 2 capture technologies. If implemented commercially, these technologies could represent an early and sizeable impact in reducing industrial CO 2 emissions. Therefore, Air Products, working closely with the Department of Energy, has conducted a carbon capture and sequestration (CCS) project to demonstrate a first-of-a-kind retrofit system to capture CO 2 from large-scale industrial SMR plants. Working with the support of Denbury Onshore, LLC (“Denbury Onshore”) and its affiliate, Denbury Green Pipeline-Texas, LLC (“Denbury Green Pipeline”), Air Products designed, constructed and continues to operate a state-of-the-art system located at the Valero Port Arthur Refinery in Port Arthur, TX. This system concentrates the CO 2 from two SMR waste streams and delivers it into the Green Pipeline-Texas for transport to and use in the West Hastings Unit enhanced oil recovery (EOR) project. The CO 2 removal units were designed by Air Products and utilize vacuum swing adsorption (VSA) units that were retrofitted into each of the SMR trains upstream of existing pressure swing adsorption (PSA) units. This project is unique because the site has two large-scale, highly integrated SMRs located in proximity to one another. The CO 2 from this project is concentrated from 15% in the SMR waste stream to at least 98%, then flowed into the Green Pipeline-Texas along the eastern Gulf Coast. The Green Pipeline collects CO 2 from a variety of sources that is utilized for tertiary oil recovery in Texas. This project alone can prevent over 1 million tons per year of CO 2 from being emitted into the atmosphere, and thus play a major role in significantly reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Liquefaction of Forest Biomass to "Drop-in" Hydrocarbon Biofuels

The overall goal of the project was to demonstrate solvent liquefaction as a viable path to stable intermediates for subsequent upgrading to fuel blendstocks. Iowa State University (ISU) utilized technology developed by Chevron to produce “green crude” via continuous biomass liquefaction to bio-oil without catalyst or reducing gas, then upgraded the crude to drop-in hydrocarbon liquid transportation fuels. Original benchmarks for the project included conversion of biomass to bio-oil at a yield of 50% or more, produce bio-oil with oxygen content below 20 wt%, and recycle a portion of the bio-oil product for use as solvent, displacing initial hydrocarbon solvent. Initial testing and technology development was completed by Chevron using a custom Small Continuous Liquefaction Unit (SCLU) operated in “once-through” mode. In this system, liquid product and solid residual/char was collected together and required both off-line solids removal and product separation. This unit was disassembled and major components incorporated into a redesigned solvent liquefaction system at ISU capable of processing biomass at rates up to 1 kg/h. Online, continuous solids separation and bio-oil recovery/separation systems were successfully implemented. Online solids removal using an acetone injection to aid in separation achieved over 99% solids removal efficiency, and acetone recovery of greater than 97% was achieved. The gas stripping system developed for the separation of medium wood oil (MWO) for the recycle stream from the heavy wood oil (HWO) product stream was also successful in recovering approximately 93 wt% of the initial solvent from the biomass-derived products. Due to the generation of fine particulate and the high molecular weight of the HWO which both negatively affect the ability to separate the product oil, solvent recycle was not fully implemented in the system. The biomass used in this project is loblolly pine forest residue. The solvent was a blend of two hydrocarbon liquids. The majority of the solvent was comprised of commercially available naphthalene-depleted heavy aromatic solvent. The hydrogen donor solvent was a proprietary cut of light cycle oil (LCO) that was hydrotreated. As much as 25 wt% of the solvent mixture was comprised of the hydrotreated LCO. Higher blend ratios were limited by the economics of providing hydrogen to the process in this manner. Two cases were evaluated for technical feasibility on the SCLU. These are 1. Simulated phenolic solvent recycle and 2. Hydrocarbon-rich solvent processing. The simulated phenolic solvent recycle case was based on an idealistic solvent mixture where only 5% makeup or hydrogen donor solvent entered the system. The resulting solvent mixture at steady state was estimated to be 75 wt% depleted hydrogen donor, 20 wt% biomass derived phenolic monomers, and 5 wt% HLCO. This case resulted in the highest bio-oil organic yield observed in the project of 66.7 wt% on a solvent-less, dry biomass basis and relatively low oxygen content of 12%. Additionally, these conditions deconstructed the biomass so well, that extremely fine particulate was generated such that 5 micron barrier filters were unable to remove the material. Offline addition of acetone, centrifugation and acetone removal were required in order to remove the particulate prior to fractionation with the stripping column. The resulting HWO had a high molecular weight and was therefore very viscous in nature, remaining solid at room temperature. Additionally, the column was unable to sustainably strip enough MWO to close the recycle loop balance while maintaining flowability of product oil exiting the column. It was determined that additional HLCO would be required at the front of the process to decrease product viscosity both by dilution and additional hydrogen transfer into the HWO product oil. The hydrocarbon rich mixture was the preferred mixture for a majority of the project and featured a 25% donor or HLCO content and 75% depleted hydrogen donor mix. A series of three tests were conducted using this mixture and serve as the basis for a paper detailing the system. While the online acetone injection system for high pressure solids removal was demonstrated early on using this mixture, difficulty controlling process flows led to the use of an atmospheric stirred tank filtration system. At these high donor solvent levels, the product stream easily partitioned with sufficient MWO to close the recycle loop balance. Additionally, this mixture produced HWO product oil at just over 55% yield, <5% oxygen content, and a reasonable viscosity at room temperature. A 56 hour campaign was conducted with the ISU pilot to produce a large enough batch of HWO product oil to conduct upgrading experiments at Chevron’s Richmond, CA facility. Benchtop hydrotreating units were used to conduct long-duration hydrogenation/hydrogenolysis reactions in order to provide yield data and help validate assumptions made in the TEA model. Resulting products featured an oxygen content of <1%, near the detectability limit. Hydrocracking simulations were also performed, and a distribution of heavy wood oil to refinery products was determined. These distributions are based on a database of commercial and pilot plant operation used by Chevron to estimate product yield from novel inputs based on the input physical and chemical characteristics. While multi-week benchtop hydrotreating tests were successfully conducted without fouling, analysis and testing of the heavy wood oil suggest it may be better suited for hydrocracking. Metals content in the heavy wood oil would likely create catalyst fouling over time and reduce lifetime of hydrotreating catalysts. Yields and product partitioning were also more favorable from hydrocracking compared to those from hydrotreating.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Central Appalachian Basin CarbonSAFE Integrated Pre-Feasibility Project (Final Technical Report)

The Central Appalachian Basin-Carbon Storage Assurance Facility Enterprise (CarbonSAFE) (CAB-CS) Integrated Prefeasibility Project identified several “Selected Areas” in eastern Ohio where the Cambrian-Ordovician age sandstones and carbonates show the most promising reservoir potential for carbon capture and storage (CCS). These selected areas are located near depleted oil and gas fields where oil recovery could be improved with enhanced oil recovery. This region has many large carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) point sources that represent a diverse array of industries, including coal-fired power plants, natural gas processing, refineries, chemical plants, and natural gas power. In a carbon-constrained future, one of the most promising ways to make coal a viable fuel option for power generation or industrial processes is to capture and store CO 2 emissions. The project is a pre-feasibility study to mitigate the emissions from 1.67 million metric tons CO 2 per year by developing a storage complex capable of storing 50 million metric tons. The pre-feasibility study identified two candidate locations for a carbon storage hub in the Appalachian Basin, analyzed six source-sink scenarios in the CAB-CS study area with analysis of capture and transport, defined infrastructure needs for a CCS project in the area, conducted an economic, liability, and social assessment, and built a team to evaluate CCS options in the CAB-CS study area. The project was an important step in implementing CCS in the CAB-CS study area. Major accomplishments include experience in investigating CCS projects in the area (learning by doing), adding to National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) best practices tools and tool sets, and building the elements of the CCS road map for the region.

20 FOSSIL-FUELED POWER PLANTS↗

Integrated pre-feasibility study for CO 2 geological storage in the Cascadia Basin, offshore Washington State, British Columbia

The Cascadia CarbonSAFE project conducted a pre-feasibility study to evaluate technical and nontechnical aspects of storing 50 million metric tons (MMT) of carbon dioxide in a safe, ocean basalt reservoir offshore Washington State and British Columbia. Sub-seafloor basalts are very common on Earth and enable geological mineralization as a long-term storage mechanism, permanently sequestering the carbon in solid rock form. This project evaluated the offshore storage complex, developed potential industrial source/transport scenarios, built an inventory of existing geophysical/geological data and environmental monitoring capabilities, conducted laboratory studies and reservoir modeling to determine storage capacity, and analyzed economic factors, regulatory requirements, and project management risks. Our team included researchers at Columbia University in New York, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) in Washington, University of Victoria in British Columbia, University of California at Santa Cruz, and GHG Underground in Maine, as well as collaborators at University of Iceland in Reykjavik and University of Washington in Saint Louis. In the study region, large emitters (>100,000 MT/year) generate a total of approximately 40 MMT annually from stationary sources, such as power plants, refineries, ammonia production, and mineral processing plants. Five potential industry source/transport scenarios were identified (three in U.SA S. and two in Canada) to potentially provide 50 MMT of carbon dioxide to the offshore reservoir. One scenario included net carbon-negative sources that would reduce atmospheric levels. The inventory of existing data illustrated that basalt properties in the region are potentially beneficial for long-term storage. Permeability is on the order of 0.1 to 1 Darcies within the uppermost 600 m of ocean crust and density-derived porosity reaches 10–20% in thin layers that provide act as flow channels and provide access to porous and permeable basalt. Fine-grained sediments overlying basalt provide a low-permeability barrier separating the storage reservoir from the overlying ocean. Subsurface monitoring of the storage complex benefits from a unique opportunity close proximity of to the nearby NEPTUNE cabled seafloor observatory, which actively transmits data to shore and could be used to monitor reservoir properties. Injection pressure changes, reservoir chemistry, seismicity, well head corrosion, and potential leakage monitoring would be feasible in real time. Using existing data and published models, the STOMP-CO 2 modeling code developed at PNNL was used to simulate carbon dioxide injection, storage, and mineralization in the reservoir. Preliminary simulations indicate that a 50 MMT carbon dioxide plume injected over a 20-year period remains well within the reservoir area, both laterally and vertically, for at least a 50-year period of post-injection monitoring. Laboratory studies on core samples from Cascadia measured dissolution rates in CO 2 –basalt–seawater mixtures and indicated large variability in rates with the potential for complete mineralization. Compared to published data, the dissolution rate measured in these samples is faster, decreasing the time until full conversion to carbonate minerals would occur. Adding geochemical reactivity in the STOMP-CO 2 model indicates that carbon dioxide would be fully converted to carbonate minerals in 135 years or less after injection ceases. The project assessed the viability and costs for the five scenarios using either dedicated offshore pipelines or shipping vessels. Carbon dioxide capture costs were not considered. Shipping incurred lower upfront CAPEX costs, and because most viable sources were located near the shore and waterways, shipping is preferred; no dedicated carbon dioxide pipelines exist in the region. The project also considered potential risks from mixed-use impacts on surrounding lands and ocean areas, such as active use by commercial and recreational fisherman, and other community considerations in planning for public engagement in the future. Other project risks were identified, including project management, permitting and compliance, and financing, as well as technical issues such as long-term instrumentation, plume migration, and model development. Geological concerns like reservoir permeability, seal, and induced seismicity held relatively low risk. The regulatory framework for offshore storage in the U.S. and Canada may be covered by general legal/regulatory programs, but is not yet fully defined. Existing programs appear to restrict the transportation of carbon dioxide across national boundaries (e.g., Canada to U.S.) and its sub-seabed disposal in some circumstances. Our assessment suggests that developing specific and separate pilot projects will help to advance the technical feasibility and regulatory requirements in each country, and lessons learned from such activities may be transferable elsewhere around the globe.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Understanding the Opportunities of Biofuels for Marine Shipping

This report examines the potential benefits, feasibility, and barriers to the use of biofuels in place of heavy fuel oil (HFO) and marine gas oil for marine vessels. More than 90% of world’s shipped goods travel by marine cargo vessels powered by internal combustion (diesel) engines using primarily low-cost residual HFO, which is high in sulfur content. Recognizing that marine shipping is the largest source of anthropogenic sulfur emissions and is a significant source of other pollutants including particulates, nitrogen oxides, and carbon dioxide (CO 2 ), the International Maritime Organization enacted regulations to lower the fuel sulfur content from 3.5 wt.% to 0.5 wt.% in 2020. These regulations require ship operators either to use higher-cost, low-sulfur HFO or to seek other alternatives for reducing sulfur emissions (i.e., scrubbers, natural gas, distillates, and/or biofuels). The near-term options for shipowners to comply with regulations include fueling with low-sulfur HFO or distillate fuels or installing emissions control systems. However, few refineries are equipped to produce low-sulfur HFO. Likewise, the current production rates of distillates do not allow the necessary expansion required to fuel the world fleet of shipping vessels (which consume around 330 million metric tons). This quantity is more than twice that used in the United States for cars and trucks. The other near-term option is to install emission control systems, which also requires a significant investment. All of these options significantly increase operational costs. Because of such costs, biofuels have become an attractive alternative since they are inherently low in sulfur and potentially also offer greenhouse gas benefits. Based on this preliminary assessment, replacing HFO in large marine vessels with minimally processed, heavy biofuels appears to have potential as a path to reduced emissions of sulfur, CO 2 , and criteria emissions. Realizing this opportunity will require deeper knowledge of (1) the combustion characteristics of biofuels in marine applications, (2) their compatibility for blending with conventional marine fuels (including HFO), (3) needs and costs for scaling up production and use, and (4) a systems assessment of their life cycle environmental impacts and costs. It is recommended that a research program investigating each of these aspects be undertaken to better assess the efficacy of biofuels for marine use.

09 BIOMASS FUELS↗

Monitoring of Actinide Concentrations in Molten LiCl-KCl Salt using Alpha Spectroscopy: Final Progress Report

This project addresses the need for real time monitoring of actinide concentrations for spent fuel reprocessing utilizing alpha spectroscopy. This project specifically focuses on spent fuel reprocessing with the pyroprocessing technique that uses high temperature molten salt. Pyroprocessing uses molten salt such as lithium chloride and potassium chloride to separate out uranium and plutonium from spent fuel. To prevent any possible diversion of high purity plutonium in this process, monitoring of the actinide concentrations within the refinery are essential for safeguards and non-proliferation efforts. Alpha spectroscopy enables the identification and quantification of actinide isotopic concentrations. However, current assay methods involving intrusive sampling and ex-suit measurement require weeks to provide accurate information. A near real-time and in-situ measurement system is required to quickly quantify actinide isotopic concentrations within the salt. Semiconductor radiation detectors provide a compact, high energy resolution option for completing these measurement needs. Silicon carbide (SiC) has been shown to operate effectively at high temperatures and high chemical stability in the molten salt environment. 4H-SiC Schottky diode alpha particle detectors were fabricated and tested to determine their alpha spectroscopy capabilities. The detectors need to operate at the elevated temperatures, survive the molten salt environment, be radiation hard, and have sufficient energy resolution under all these conditions to determine isotopic concentrations. Along with the detector, a method of producing samples of the actinides in the salt is required. To produce a thin film of the actinides on the detector, which is a necessity for alpha spectroscopy, electrodeposition can be used. Electrodeposition uses an electric potential difference to selectively deposit uranium or other actinides from the salt using an anode and cathode. Deposition of the material directly onto the sensor would produce a thin film of material that would enable materials accountability measurements to be taken in real time.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗