The role of breakup and coalescence in fine-scale bubble-induced turbulence. I. Dynamics
We study the effect of bubble breakup and coalescence on fine-scale dynamics of bubbly turbulent flows using direct numerical simulations. We perform two different simulations of dilute bubbly flows of void fraction 0.5%: one with bubbles breaking up and coalescing and the other without these physical processes. The volume of the fluid method is used for simulating bubbles undergoing breakup and coalescence while the bubbles are treated as rigid spheres in the immersed boundary method simulation. The energy spectrum in both types of simulation, consistent with previous studies, exhibits a -3 slope. We follow a single infinitesimal fluid element as it evolves to understand velocity gradient dynamics using conditional mean trajectories. We note finite-time divergence when the fluid element evolves under the action of inertial and pressure dynamics. The inertial, pressure, and viscous velocity gradient dynamics, when considered individually, produce the same results for bubble-induced turbulence (BIT) as with the classical homogeneous isotropic turbulence (HIT). Yet when the overall velocity gradient dynamics is considered, BIT results in non-cyclic trajectories moving toward stable node and unstable saddle while classical HIT shows cyclic behavior in their trajectories that move toward the origin. Interestingly, both the volume of fluid and immersed boundary simulations produce similar results. Therefore, there are two main takeaways from this research. First, new velocity gradient models are needed for BIT as their velocity gradients behavior is entirely different from the HIT. Second, we can neglect the bubble topology, breakup, and coalescence while studying or modeling the fine-scale dynamics of BIT.