Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Safety Case”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 325 records · Page 18

Evaluation of the first version of the new RFPI system dedicated to PIP-II project accelerator

The Low-Level Radio Frequency (LLRF) control system is one of the most critical superconducting linac infrastructures responsible for the parameters of the beam acceleration. The LLRF system mainly focuses on the electromagnetic field parameters inside the cavity. While it incorporates fast feedback algorithms to optimize energy transfer to the passing particle beam it does not follow other cryomodule or cavity parameter changes. The Radio Frequency Protection Interlock (RFPI) system closely monitors various factors (like cryomodule vacuum, beamline vacuum, field emission probe current level, temperature, RF signal leakage, etc). Its simple but reliable logic has to provide an instant decision about the LLRF system or high-power amplifier output signal blocking in case of safety region excitation. This contribution presents a new version of the RFPI system which logic is implemented in the FPGA chip. The initial work on the prototype of the new system design resulted in the PoC (Proof of Concept) device. The PoC offers the possibility of various protection logic configurations, input signals parameters evaluation, and modularity aspects verification. The structure and test results from the device evaluation are summarized and discussed in this contribution.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

The PIP-II dedicated RFPI system final design

The Radio Frequency Protection Interlock (RFPI) system main responsibility is to collect predefined set of signals and to protect each RF station. In case of safety limits violations from any of this input signals the RFPI has to instantenously drop permits for the LLRF or RF amplifier (eq. Solid State Amplifier - SSA or klystron) operation.This paper presents an overview of the final design of the RFPI system dedicated for Proton Improvement Plan II (PIP-II) at Fermilab.

Cichalewski, Wojciech [Lodz, Tech. U.; Lodz U.]↗

Methodology for Estimating Safe Charge Limits of Flammable Refrigerants in HVAC&R Applications - Part 1

Refrigerant flammability introduces new challenges to the usage of low global warming potential (Low GWP) refrigerants in real life applications. Those challenges are centered around the deflagration risk associated with their use and its implications on personal safety. Standards have been developed to systematically set maximum allowable flammable refrigerant charges to ensure safety in case of refrigerant leakage. These standards were initially based on limited testing and numerical analyses of refrigerant leakage into confined spaces.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Safety Analysis and Technical Basis for Establing an Interim Burnup Limit for Mark-V and Mark-VA Fuel Subassemblies in EBR-II

This document describes the technical basis and safety analysis for introduction of the Mark-V and Mark-VA fuel subassemblies into the core of EBR-II. An interim burnup limit of 10 at. % is specified for the Mark-V and Mark-VA fuel pins in driver subassemblies. As more information on fuel pin lifetime and hexcan behavior is gathered a final burnup limit will be sought.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Drag reduction - Jet breakup correlation with kerosene-based additives

The drag-reduction effectiveness of a number of high-polymer additives dissolved in aircraft fuel has been measured in a turbulent-flow rheometer. These solutions were further subjected to high elongational stress and breakup forces in a jet discharging in air. The jet was photographed using a high-resolution camera with special lighting. The object of the work was to study the possible spray-suppression ability of high-polymer additives to aircraft fuel and to correlate this with the drag-reducing properties of the additives. It was found, in fact, that the rheometer results indicate the most effective spray-suppressing additives. Using as a measure the minimum polymer concentration to give a maximum friction-reducing effect, the order of effectiveness of eight different polymer additives as spray-suppressing agents was predicted. These results may find application in the development of antimisting additives for aircraft fuel which may increase fire safety in case of crash or accident.

Hoyt, J. W.↗

Aircraft Canopy Lock

Mechanism easy to open intentionally but resists accidental opening. Locking or Unlocking occurs when pull pin enters or leaves conical base. Pushing ejection pin or pulling knob unlocks mechanism. Unintentional release unlikely since accidental pilot motions push on knob in most cases. This safety feature, coupled with simplicity and reliability of mechanism, useful for emergency exits for land vehicles or even buildings.

Nichols, G. H.↗

Importance of helium-3 for the future

Relevant plasma physics principles of thermonuclear research; the state of plasma physics as it pertains to the D-He(3) cycle; the technological benefits of the D-He(3) fuel cycle; the availability of He(3); and its location, methods of extraction and cost are discussed. A perspective on the rate of progress toward the goal of heating the confined plasma fuel to sufficiently high temperatures at high enough densities and for long enough times to cause substantial fusion of the atoms to take place is given in graphical form. The main technological advantages resulting from the D-He(3) fuel cycle, when compared with the DT cycle, are as follows: (1) increased electrical conversion efficiency; (2) reduced radiation damage to reactors; (3) reduced radioactive waste; (4) an increased level of safety in case of an accident; (5) the lower cost of electricity; and (6) the shorter time to commercialization. An account is given of mining He(3) on the Moon.

Kulcinski, Gerald L.↗

Unsymmetrical forces in an airplane cell

This paper calls attention to the desirability of expanding airplane building regulations to include proof of safety for cases of unsymmetrical loading, at least in the structural members which are thereby specially stressed.

WINGS - STRESSES & ANALYSIS↗

Assessment of lumen degradation and remaining useful life of LEDs using particle filter

With the development of light-emitting diode (LED) technology, light emitting diodes system is becoming a popular light source in daily life and industry area. It has shown that Led from same factory and work under same working condition, may have significantly different behavior. Therefore, it is very important to learn the fail mechanisms, especially in the case of safety critical and harsh environment application. This paper focus on a prognostic health management (PHM) method based on the measurement of forward voltage and forward current of bare LED under harsh environment. In this paper, experiment has been done with ten samples. Ten pristine bare LEDs have been tested at 85°C while simultaneously being subjected to 85% humid environment. Pulse width modulation (PWM) control method has been employed to drive the bare LED in order to reduce the heat effect caused by forward current and high frequency (300HZ) data acquisition has been used to measure the peak forward voltage and forward current. Test to failure (lumen drops to 70 percent) data has been measured to study the effects of high temperature and humid environment loadings on the bare LED. Also, solid state cooling method with peltier cooler has been used to control the temperature of LED in the integrating sphere when take the measurement of lumen flux. The shift of forward voltage forward current curve and lumen degradation has been recorded to help build the fail model and predicted the remaining useful life. In this method, particle filter has been employed to predict the remaining useful life (RUL) of the bare LED and give us a whole picture how Led system fails. Result shows that predication of remaining useful life of Led, made by the particle filter model works under reasonable limit, and hence this method can be employed to predict the failure of Led caused by thermal and humid stress under harsh environment.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Impact of lump characteristics on self-shielding corrections of active neutron interrogation on fissile material in waste - 15405

Non-destructive active neutron assay techniques such as active neutron coincidence counting, differential die away analysis or the californium shuffler method rely on the interrogation of fissile nuclear materials by an external neutron source. Whether it is a spontaneous fission or (α,n) neutron source, like {sup 252}Cf or AmLi; or a fusion neutron generator, all of these techniques rely on induced secondary fission events to provide prompt or delayed neutron signals that serve as the basis for the fissile material quantification. The accuracy of these fissile mass measurements is therefore dependent on the neutron interrogation efficiencies determined for calibration reference standards and whether the measured items are comparable to the calibration condition. In such favorable conditions, it is possible to establish a reliable empirical non-linear relationship between apparent (uncorrected) and real or true fissile mass. However, in waste measurements, this is unlikely to be the case; thus a calibration approach that takes account of the neutron self-shielding effect is required. By incorporating the Self-Shielding Factor (SSF) of the calibration reference standards, a linear mass calibration factor [s{sup -1}. {sup 239}Pu{sub eq} g{sup -1}] can be found; this calibration is accurate for waste in which the fissile material is 'infinitely dilute' i.e. the waste exhibits no self-shielding; this is assumed to be representative of dispersed material. The self-shielding correction and its systematic uncertainty are then left to be treated as part of the Total Measurement Uncertainty (TMU) evaluation associated with the assay result. The derivation of the TMU contribution associated with the self-shielding effect in nuclear waste is a complex problem for which a reliable evaluation has to be performed. This is usually based on assuming 'worst case scenarios' for the distribution of material that can arise in a particular waste stream. Such an approach is conservative, but often very penalizing, especially if one considers larger lumps (those containing grams of fissile material); for such lumps, the self-shielding correction becomes very significant, potentially altering the mass of {sup 239}Pu{sub eq} by over an order of magnitude. A worst case 'nuclear safety value' may not be the most appropriate choice for building a consignment best estimate or repository sentencing value for an item. In the present work the authors describe a numerical approach to study the variability of neutron self-shielding factors associated with distributions of a wide range of lump characteristics in terms of size, shape, chemical composition, density and isotopic composition. The described novel calculation tool is capable of accurately predicting the real impact of random distribution of lumps in a waste material, and allowed to show that given reasonable, defensible, assumptions on the composition of the lumps in waste stream, the systematic error component of the DDA TMU can be significantly reduced. (authors)

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗

Analysis of, and defense against, spurious actuations and other incorrect behaviors of digital control systems - 390

Modern digital instrumentation and control (I and C) systems offer nearly unlimited functional capability. However, the complexity of their design (including their system software and application software) is significantly higher than that of conventional, hardwired systems, to the point that it is generally impossible to demonstrate that there are no residual design errors, even when the best development and verification techniques have been applied. When activated by specific conditions, design errors could result in systematic failures, i.e., failures that occur deterministically each time and wherever an activating condition is present. Redundancy could be defeated when the same design error affects multiple channels or systems, and the activating condition affects several of these channels or systems. In the case of safety I and C systems, most of the functions are poised protection functions that must be actuated when and only when a demand situation occurs in the plant. In nuclear power plants, the most dangerous failure mode for such functions generally is failure to actuate, and many measures are taken to protect from such failure mode. This paper considers the other failure modes of safety I and C functions, and also the failure modes of the other I and C functions that are less important to safety. It is not limited to poised functions, and considers other types of functions such as regulation functions or human interface functions. It proposes a framework for analyzing and providing defense against spurious actuations and other incorrect behaviors from digital I and C systems directly interacting with the plant process or with operators: these might be useful for example to justify that design bases for reactor protection are adequate, or to ensure plant performance and availability. (authors)

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Verification of the sensitivity and uncertainty-based criticality safety validation techniques: ORNL’s SCALE case study

The use of sensitivity and uncertainty-based techniques has been well-developed in the neutronic community for criticality safety applications. Sensitivity techniques calculate the first-order relative variations in keff due to relative cross-section variations by isotope, reaction type, and incident neutron energy. The result is a vector of sensitivity coefficients which is folded with prior cross-section uncertainties to calculate the so-called similarity indices. Similarity indices are integral quantities which serve as useful mathematical measures for assessing the relevance of existing or new experiments to given application conditions, representing design systems for which the models are to be validated. Despite their importance for a wide range of validation activities, the peer-reviewed literature is non-existent on the development of rigorous verification analysis for their calculated values. Thus, this manuscript proposes a simple non-intrusive method to calculate similarity indices, serving as an independent verification tool for their evaluation. The manuscript derives the theoretical basis for the proposed verification analysis. Next, the verification analysis is applied to the ORNL’s SCALE code suite which employs adjoint-based methods to calculate similarity indices. Numerical experiments using a number of well-known benchmark experiments are employed to verify the calculation of the similarity indices.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

The Development and Implementation of Ground Safety Requirements for Project Orion Abort Flight Testing - A Case Study

A rigorous set of detailed ground safety requirements is required to make sure that ground support equipment (GSE) and associated planned ground operations are conducted safely. Detailed ground safety requirements supplement the GSE requirements already called out in NASA-STD-5005. This paper will describe the initial genesis of these ground safety requirements, the establishment and approval process and finally the implementation process for Project Orion. The future of the requirements will also be described. Problems and issues encountered and overcame will be discussed.

Kirkpatrick, Paul D.↗

The Friendly Argument Notation (FAN): 2023 Version

This document constitutes the official description of the current iteration of the Friendly Argument Notation (FAN). This new version provides several enhancements to the original 2020 instantiation, while maintaining essential compatibility with it. Specifically, the new version enables distinguishing between deductive and non-deductive arguments, removes the requirement for always providing an explicit statement of reasoning, and relaxes the rules for when labels may be used. The primary intended use of FAN is unchanged: creating and evaluating arguments about safety-critical systems, specifically the types of arguments common within safety and assurance cases.

language↗

Argument-Based Airworthiness Assurance of Small UAS

Presently, there are three avenues by which Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) operations are authorized in the U.S. National Airspace System (NAS): obtaining either (i) a certificate of authorization (COA), or (ii) a special airworthiness certificate (SAC) in either the experimental, or the restricted category, or (iii) an exemption from an airworthiness certificate together with a civil COA. The first is meant primarily for public entities, such as NASA; the remaining two are the only available means for civil UAS operations. Recently, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has also proposed a regulatory framework targeted for certain small UAS, specifically those weighing 55 pounds or less, although final rulemaking remains pending. We have previously shown how an assurance case can aggregate heterogeneous reasoning and safety evidence, with application to UAS safety. In this paper, we describe how assurance cases can serve as a common framework to justify overall system safety, unifying both operational aspects and airworthiness, in particular system design assurance. We also show how this approach can coexist with, and augment, existing safety analysis processes and best-practices, by transforming the artifacts they produce into structured assurance arguments. To illustrate the applicability and utility of our approach, we have been applying it for the design assurance of an unmanned rotorcraft system, intended for precision agriculture operations, as part of the NASA Unmanned Aircraft System (UAS) Integration in the National Airspace System (NAS) project.

Rotocraft↗

Development of a Thin Film Primary Surface Heat Exchanger for Advanced Power Cycles

This project objective is to develop a high-temperature design upgrade for an existing primary surface heat exchanger so that the redesigned hardware is capable of operation in CO 2 at temperatures up to 1,510°F (821°C) and pressure differentials up to 130 psi (9 bar). The heat exchanger is proposed for use as a recuperator in an advanced low-pressure oxy-fuel Brayton cycle that is predicted to achieve over 50% thermodynamic efficiency, although the heat exchanger could also be used in other high-temperature, low-differential pressure cycles. This report describes the progress to date, which includes continuing work performed to select and test new candidate materials for the recuperator redesign, final mechanical and thermal performance analysis results of various redesign concepts, and the preliminary design of a test loop for the redesigned recuperator including a budgetary estimate for detailed test loop design, procurement, and test operation. A materials search was performed in order to investigate high-temperature properties of many candidate materials, including high-temperature strength and nickel content. These properties were used to rank the candidate materials, resulting in a reduced list of nine materials for corrosion testing. Multiple test rigs were considered and analyzed for short-term corrosion testing and Thermal Gravimetric Analysis (TGA) was selected as the most cost-effective option for evaluating corrosion resistance of the candidate materials. In addition, tantalum, niobium, and chromium coatings were identified as potential options for increased corrosion resistance. The test results show that many materials exhibit relatively low weight gain rates, and that niobium and tantalum coatings may improve corrosion resistance for many materials, while chromium coatings appear to oxidize and debond quickly. Metallurgical analysis of alloys was also performed, showing evidence of intergranular attack in 282 that may cause long-term reliability problems in CO 2 service at these temperatures. However, long-term testing in a flowing environment is recommended in order to understand accurately the severity of the attack. Detailed economic modeling of the existing air cycle recuperator and CO 2 cycle recuperator options was also completed, including costs for material, fabrication, fuel, maintenance, and operation. The analysis results show that the increased capital cost for high-temperature materials may be offset by higher cycle efficiencies, decreasing the overall lifetime cost of the system. The economic analysis also examines costs associated with increased pressure drop and material changes for two redesign options. These results show that, even with slightly reduced performance and/or higher material costs, the lifetime cost per energy production may still be reduced by over 12%. The existing recuperator design information was provided by Solar Turbines, Inc. via several models, drawings, and design handoff meetings. Multiple fluid/thermal and structural models were created in order to analyze critical recuperator performance and mechanical strength in critical areas throughout the redesign process. These models were analyzed for a baseline condition (consistent with current Mercury 50 operation) for validation purposes. Results are presented for heat transfer coefficients and pressure drops, matching well with the existing operational data. Simulation of higher-temperature CO 2 conditions was also performed, showing a slight expected increase in both heat transfer and pressure drop. Mechanical analysis results for critical areas on the cross-flow and counter-flow sheets have also been obtained for air and CO 2 cases. These results show similar stresses in both cases but significantly reduced safety factors for the CO 2 case due to reduced yield and creep rupture strengths of alloy 625 at the higher temperatures. A concept brainstorm session and initial down-selection were completed in order to identify promising redesign options for further analysis. Detailed analysis of all promising redesign options was performed via finite element and computational fluid dynamic simulations in order to characterize mechanical and thermal-fluid performance of each option. These options included material change, various sheet thickness configurations, pitch and phasing of cross-flow and counter-flow sheets, and separator sheets. The analysis results have identified two viable redesign options that maintain existing safety margins optimally through a material change to Haynes 282 and (A) sheet thickness increases of 40% on the counter-flow sheet and 75% on the hot side cross-flow corrugation sheet or (B) addition of a separator sheet in the counter-flow section while maintaining the original counter-flow sheet thickness and increasing the cross-flow corrugation sheet thickness by 90% to account for the increase in cell height. While both options satisfy mechanical stress constraints, the separator sheet design has a higher part count, slightly reduced heat transfer, and slightly higher pressure drop than the first option and is not preferred. Finally, several test loop concepts have been developed for different full-scale and reduced-scale recuperator testing options. For each option, various loop components, such as heat exchangers, valves, heaters, and compressors, were evaluated in an effort to maximize utilization of existing resources. All concepts utilize an existing 3-MW CO 2 compressor, heater, and loop coolers, but the concepts vary by incorporating different amounts of new equipment for achieving various flow rates (all concepts operate at design pressure and temperature). The third concept achieves a 1 kg/s test without purchasing any costly equipment (coolers, heaters, blowers, etc.). Since the stacked cell design of the recuperator results in the same flow conditions at each core cell (even for a reduced-scale test). Thus, test loop Concept #3 was selected for the preliminary design. This loop design is detailed within the report, culminating in a budgetary estimate of $1,013,000.00 for the detailed design, construction, commissioning, and operation of a high-temperature recuperator test loop.

03 NATURAL GAS↗

UO 2 -liquid metal suspension fuel concept for enhanced passive safety of LWRs: A heat pipe case study

This work proposes a novel fuel concept for use in light-water type reactors (LWRs): UO 2 particles suspended in a low-melting-point liquid metal (LM). This new fuel form offers lower energy density and higher thermal conductivity, thus enhancing the fuel’s thermal performance compared to sintered UO 2 pellets. Two candidate alloys for the LM are proposed based on previous studies into accident-tolerant fuels: Bi-Pb-Sn and Pb-Sn. Ten research questions are provided to guide future development of this fuel. A simple heat pipe model was constructed by coupling a reactor physics code to a heat transport code and other physics modules. Scoping calculations were performed on this model core as a preliminary investigation into five of the research questions. A fuel with 13 wt% UO 2 was shown to maintain a steady-state peak coolant channel wall temperature below 400 °C, and maintain criticality via self-regulating reactivity feedback. Shortcomings of the present model are discussed in this work, along with proposed future model improvements and fuel development. The appendix provides an example of a reactor concept that could be developed to utilize this fuel, but more modeling and experimental work are needed before a full reactor concept can be developed.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗