Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “reaction”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 307 records · Page 17
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2021

Intercalation–exfoliation processes during ionic exchange reactions from sodium lepidocrocite-type titanate toward a proton-based trititanate structure

Topochemical reactions involving ionic exchange have been used to assess a large number of metastable compositions, particularly in layered metal oxides. This method encompasses complex reactions that are poorly explored, yet are of prime importance to understand and control the materials’ properties. In this work, we embark on investigating the reactions involved during the ionic exchange between a layered Na-titanate (lepidocrocite-type structure) and an acidic solution (HCl), leading to a protonic (H 3 O + ) titanate (trititanate structure). The reactions involve an ionic exchange provoking a structural change from the lepidocrocite-type to the trititanate structure as shown by real-space refinements of ex situ pair distribution function data. Mobile Na + ions are exchanged by hydronium ions inducing high proton mobility in the final structure. Moreover, the reaction was followed by ex situ 23 Na and 1 H solid-state MAS NMR which allowed, among other things, confirming that the Na + ions are in the interlayer space and specifying their local environment. Strikingly, the ionic exchange reaction induces progressive exfoliation of the Na-titanate particles leading to 2–5 nm thin elongated crystallites. To further understand the different steps associated with the ionic exchange, the evolution of the electrolytic conductivity, using conductimetric titration, has been monitored upon HCl addition, enabling characterization of the intercalation(H + )/de-intercalation(Na + ) reactions and assessing kinetic parameters. Accordingly, it is hypothesized that the exfoliation of the particles is due to the accumulation of charges at the particle level in relation to the rapid intercalation of protons. This work provides novel insights into ionic exchange reactions involved in layered oxide compounds.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

Thermodynamic insight into AnO 2 + bonding from ThH + /UH + reactions studied by inductively coupled plasma tandem mass spectrometry

The bonding mechanisms of actinides have been a focus of fundamental research over the past few decades. In the present study, reactions of the simplest actinide-containing species, ThH + and UH + , with O 2 and CO 2 are investigated by inductively coupled plasma tandem mass spectrometry. The reactions of ThH + and UH + with O 2 are efficient, and the reactions of ThH + and UH + with CO 2 display reduced reaction efficiencies. For both reactions involving CO 2 , ThO 2 + and UO 2 + are observed; however, there is a clear barrier to ThO 2 + formation whereas UO 2 + forms through an exothermic, barrierless process. The experimental observations and available thermodynamic information are used to predict the outcomes of reactions involving the later AnH + . The anticipated reaction enthalpies for Pa–Am display a clear correlation with the promotion energy of An + to a 6d 2 electronic configuration, E p (6d 2 ), although a shift in the slope of the correlation of reaction enthalpies and E p (6d 2 ) suggests that there is likely a change in bonding mechanism that starts with Np + . Similar shifts have also been noted in previous studies. Beginning with Np + , the 6d orbitals become less accessible than they are for the earlier An + as measured by E p (6d 2 ), and this accessibility of the 6d orbitals may drive actinide bonding.

5f orbitals↗
DOE OSTI2022

A matrix completion algorithm for efficient calculation of quantum and variational effects in chemical reactions

This work examines the viability of matrix completion methods as cost-effective alternatives to full nuclear Hessians for calculating quantum and variational effects in chemical reactions. The harmonic variety-based matrix completion (HVMC) algorithm, developed in a previous study (https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0018326), exploits the low-rank character of the polynomial expansion of potential energy to recover, using a small sample, vibrational frequencies (square roots of nuclear Hessian eigenvalues) constituting the reaction path. Furthermore, these frequencies are essential for calculating rate coefficients using variational transition state theory with multidimensional tunneling (VTST-MT). HVMC performance is examined for four SN2 reactions and five hydrogen transfer reactions, with each H-transfer reaction consisting of at least one vibrational mode strongly coupled to the reaction coordinate. HVMC is robust and captures zero-point energies, vibrational free energies, zero-curvature tunneling, and adiabatic ground state and free energy barriers as well as their positions on the reaction coordinate. For medium to large reactions involving H-transfer, with the exception of the most complex Ir catalysis system, less than 35% of total eigenvalue information is necessary for accurate recovery of key VTST-MT observables.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2022

Mirror nucleon removal reactions in p-shell nuclei

Nucleon removal reactions have been shown to be an effective tool for studying the single particle structure of nuclei. This work continues efforts to experimentally probe and benchmark the reaction and structure models used to calculate the removal reaction cross sections when using microscopic nuclear structure inputs. Here, three different single nucleon removal reactions were performed, from p -shell nuclei with masses A = 7, 9, and 10. The residual nuclei from the reactions were detected in coincidence with γ rays to determine partial cross sections to individual final states. The eikonal direct-reaction model is combined with overlap functions and residual nucleus densities from microscopic, variational Monte Carlo calculations to provide consistent nuclear structure input to the partial cross section calculations. Comparisons of measured and calculated cross sections, including for mirror reactions, are presented. The analysis of the partial cross sections leading to the ground states shows a similar behavior to the one observed from analyses of inclusive cross sections using shell model nuclear structure input: the theoretical description of the removal process is in better agreement with the data when removing weakly bound nucleons, than when removing well-bound ones. The two mirror reaction pairs presented here show consistent results between the respective members of the pairs. The results obtained for the population of the excited states, however, show a systematically different trend that appears connected to the structure part of the calculation. Additional cases are needed to better understand the respective roles of structure and dynamical effects in the deviations.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2025

Domain Wall Reactions in Multiple-Order Parameter Ferroelectrics

The motion of domain walls is crucial for ferroelectric switching. Conventionally, the switching dynamics is believed to be determined by the motion of one or a few low-energy domain wall types of dominant population. Here, we challenge this conventional idea in multiple-order-parameter ferroelectrics. Using hafnia as example, we show that the multiple-order-parameter nature not only provides various mobile domain walls and defectlike immobile domain walls, but also enables the domain wall reactions. In analogy with chemical reactions where substances react to form new substances, domain walls could also react to form other domain walls during switching. We identify several elementary domain wall reaction types including synthesis, decomposition, and exchange reactions. Domain walls are continually changed by these reactions during switching so that the switching behavior reflects the statistical average of many domain wall types with distinct mobility and stability. These reactions also lead to phenomenon like remanent nuclei and defect-site nucleation that facilitate switching and lower coercive field. Finally, the concept of domain wall reaction is not limited to hafnia but can be generalized to any multiple-order-parameter ferroelectric. As a result, this Letter conceptualizes domain wall reaction, expands the theory of ferroelectric switching, and suggests a practical way for defect engineering to control switching behavior.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Thermodynamic Origin of Reaction Non-Uniformity in Battery Porous Electrodes and Its Mitigation

The development of non-uniform reaction current distribution within porous electrodes is a ubiquitous phenomenon during battery charging/discharging and frequently controls the rate performance of battery cells. Reaction inhomogeneity in porous electrodes is usually attributed to the kinetic limitation of mass transport within the electrolyte and/or solid electrode phase. In this work, however, we reveal that it is also strongly influenced by the intrinsic thermodynamic behavior of electrode materials, specifically the dependence of the equilibrium potential on the state of charge: the electrode reaction becomes increasingly non-uniform when the slope of the equilibrium potential curve is reduced. We employ numerical simulations and equivalent circuit model to elucidate such a correlation and show that the degree of reaction inhomogeneity and the resultant discharge capacity can be predicted by a dimensionless reaction uniformity number. For electrode materials that have equilibrium potentials insensitive to the state of charge and exhibit significant reaction non-uniformity, we demonstrate several approaches to spatially homogenizing the reaction current inside porous electrodes, including matching the electronic and ionic resistances, introducing graded electronic conductivity and reducing the surface reaction kinetics.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Dynamics of Product Branching from Radical Intermediates in Elementary Combustion Reactions (Final Technical Report)

While the total rate constant for many elementary reactions is well-characterized, understanding the product branching in complex reactions presents a formidable challenge. To gain an incisive probe of such reactions, our experiments investigate the dynamics of the product channels that arise from transient radical intermediates along the bimolecular reaction coordinates. Our recent published work uses the methodology developed in my group in the last fifteen years, using both imaging and scattering apparatuses. The experiments generate a particular isomeric form of an unstable radical intermediate along a bimolecular reaction coordinate and study the branching between the ensuing product channels of the energized radical as a function of its internal rotational and vibrational energy under collision-less conditions. The experiments use a combination of: 1) measurement of product velocity and angular distributions in a crossed laser-molecular beam apparatus, with electron bombardment detection in my lab in Chicago or 2) with tunable vacuum ultraviolet photoionization detection at Taiwan's National Synchrotron Radiation Research Center (NSRRC), and 3) velocity map imaging using state-selective REMPI and single photon VUV ionization of radical intermediates and reaction products. We also employ tunable VUV photoionization detection in our imaging apparatus, using difference frequency four-wave mixing to produce photoionization light tunable from 8 to 10.8 eV. This year of support funded our work to photolytically generate the radical intermediate important in the OH + propene reaction when OH adds to an end carbon. Our other major result this past year was on the photoionization detection of vinoxy radicals. Our experiments at the NSRRC definitively show that vinoxy dissociatively ionizes to both CH 3 + and HCO + , and establishes the absolute partial photoionization cross section of vinoxy to CH 3 + at 10.5 and 11.44 eV. This should allow experimentalists detecting vinoxy radicals produced in bimolecular reactions such as OH + propene to get good branching fractions to that product channel. Finally we initiated studies of the photodissociation of 1-bromo-2-chloroethane and 1,1-bromochloroethane at 193 nm at the NSRRC.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Incorporating new evaluation on angular distributions and energy spectra of neutron-induced charged particle reactions into the next ENDF library release (Technical Progress Report)

This project aims to provide the improved Evaluated Nuclear Data File (ENDF) using the newly measured data as well as the latest nuclear reaction model for calculating angular distributions and energy spectra on neutron-induced charged particle reactions through the collaboration of Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI) and Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL). The LANL group will provide the experimental data for angular distributions and spectra of (n,p) and (n,α) on several structural materials such as Fe, Ni and Zn isotopes using the Low Energy Neutron-induced Charged-particle (Z) Chamber (LENZ) instrument at Los Alamos Neutron Science Center (LANSCE). The KAERI group will provide the improved evaluated nuclear library which is based on the LANL experimental data, and further will predict angular distributions and spectra of (n,p) and (n,α) reactions on unmeasured nuclides, such as Cr, Mn, Co, Cu and so on. For the first year of this project, we planned to analyze (n,p) and (n,α) reactions for 54,56 Fe and perform new measurements on those reactions for 58,60 Ni isotopes with the LENZ instrument at LANSCE. For improving our evaluation quality, we have studied reaction models to reproduce LANL’s experimental angular distributions and energy spectra using the full Hauser-Feshbach model code, CoH3 with no approximations used. As the first year’s deliverables, we provided the experimental (n,p) and (n,α) reaction cross sections for 54,56 Fe and incorporate new evaluation on angular distributions and energy spectra of neutron-induced charged particle reactions into the current ENDF/B-VIII.0.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2020

Carbon Nanotube Formation on Cr-Doped Ferrite Catalyst during Water Gas Shift Membrane Reaction: Mechanistic Implications and Extended Studies on Dry Gas Conversions

A nanocrystalline chromium-doped ferrite (FeCr) catalyst was shown to coproduce H2 and multiwalled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) during water gas shift (WGS) reaction in a H2-permselective zeolite membrane reactor (MR) at reaction pressures of ~20 bar. The FeCr catalyst was further demonstrated in the synthesis of highly crystalline and dimensionally uniform MWCNTs from a dry gas mixture of CO and CH4, which were the apparent sources for MWCNT growth in the WGS MR. In both the WGS MR and dry gas reactions, the operating temperature was 500 °C, which is significantly lower than those commonly used in MWCNT production by chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method from CO, CH4, or any other precursor gases. Extensive ex situ characterizations of the reaction products revealed that the FeCr catalyst remained in partially reduced states of Fe3+/Fe2+ and Cr6+/Cr3+ in WGS membrane reaction while further reduction of Fe2+ to Fe0 occurred in the CO/CH4 dry gas environments. The formation of the metallic Fe nanoparticles or catalyst surface dramatically improved the crystallinity and dimensional uniformity of the MWCNTs from dry gas reaction as compared to that from WGS reaction in the MR. Reaction of the CO/CH4 mixture containing 500 ppmv H2S also resulted in high-quality MWCNTs similar to those from the H2S-free feed gas, demonstrating excellent sulfur tolerance of the FeCr catalyst that is practically meaningful for utilization of biogas and cheap coal-derived syngas.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

The 2025 Evaluation of Experimental Thermonuclear Reaction Rates (ETR25)

This work describes the formalism for estimating thermonuclear reaction rates for astrophysical applications, emphasizing modern statistical approaches such as Monte Carlo sampling and Bayesian models. We discuss related topics including the calculation of resonance energies from nuclear Q values, indirect estimates of particle partial widths, and matching of reaction rates at elevated temperatures to statistical model results. We have evaluated available experimental data on cross sections, resonance energies and strengths, partial widths, lifetimes, spin-parities, and spectroscopic factors. Based on these results, we have estimated numerical values of 78 experimental charged-particle thermonuclear reaction rates for target nuclei in the A = 2–40 mass region, for temperatures ranging from 1 MK to 10 GK. For each reaction, three rate values are provided: low, median, and high, corresponding to the 16th, 50th, and 84th percentiles, respectively, of the cumulative reaction rate probability density distribution. Additionally, we present the factor uncertainty of each rate at each temperature grid point. These results enable users to sample the reaction rate probability density in nucleosynthesis calculations, facilitating uncertainty estimates of nuclidic abundances. The rates presented here refer to their laboratory values. For use in stellar model simulations, these values need to be corrected for the effects of thermal excitations of the interacting nuclei. For each reaction, we include graphs that illustrate the fractional contributions to the overall reaction rate along with the associated uncertainty. These visuals are designed to assist both stellar modelers and nuclear experimentalists by identifying the primary sources of rate uncertain=^texttx);ty at specific stellar temperatures. A graphical comparison with earlier Monte Carlo rates is also provided.

Nuclear astrophysics↗
NASA NTRS1976

Crossed beam studies of ion-molecule reactions in methane and ammonia

A crossed-beam apparatus is used to measure the product ion velocity and angular distributions for the following ion-molecule reactions in the relative energy range from 2 to 9 eV: CH4(+) + NH3 yields NH4(+) + CH3; CH4(+) + NH3 yields CNH5(+) + H2; NH2(+) + CH4 yields CNH4(+) + H2 (or 2H); and CH3(+) + NH3 yields CNH4(+) + H2 (or 2H). These reactions are also studied by means of deuterium labeling as a further probe of the detailed reaction dynamics. Probability contour plots for the four reactions are constructed in Cartesian velocity space, and product peaks in the plots are discussed. Relative cross sections and Q values are computed for two of the reactions as well as for the corresponding deuterium-labelled reactions. The results show that the present ion-neutral condensation reactions are highly exothermic with a deep well for the internal complex, that little hydrogen scrambling occurs, and that the energy of the reactions is released mainly as internal energy, even to the extent of producing two hydrogen atoms in some cases rather than one hydrogen atom or molecule.

Smith, G. P. K.↗
NASA NTRS1990

High temperature reactions of ceramics and metals with chlorine and oxygen

The reactions of chlorine and oxygen with solids are complex and quite dependent on material and reaction conditions. However, there are four reaction schemes that describe many of these reactions. These are direct reaction of chlorine with the oxide layer, penetration of the oxide layer by chlorine, paralinear behavior where oxidation and chlorination are of comparable rates, and finally, gas phase reactions where the volatile chlorides react with oxygen. Examples of chlorine and oxygen reactions with cobalt, nickel, chromium, molybdenum, and silicon carbide illustrate each of these four reaction schemes.

Jacobson, N. S.↗
NASA NTRS1991

Photosynthetic reaction center complexes from heliobacteria

The goal of this project is to understand the early evolutionary development of photosynthesis by examining the properties of reaction centers isolated from certain contemporary organisms that appear to contain the simplest photosynthetic reaction centers. The major focus of this project is the family of newly discovered strictly anaerobic photosynthetic organisms known as Heliobacteria. These organisms are the only known photosynthetic organisms that are grouped with the gram-positive phylum of bacteria. The properties of these reaction centers suggest that they might be the decendants of an ancestor that also gave rise to Photosystem 1 found in oxygen-evolving photosynthetic organisms. Photoactive reaction center-core antenna complexes have been isolated from the photosynthetic bacteria Heliobacillus mobilis and Heliobacterium gestii. The absorption and fluorescence properties of membranes and reaction centers are almost identical, suggesting that a single pigment-protein complex serves as both antenna and reaction center. Experiments in progress include sequence determination of the 48,000 Mr reaction center protein, and evolutionary comparisons with other reaction center proteins.

Trost, J. T.↗
NASA NTRS1993

Development of a molecular beam technique to study early solar system silicon reactions

Silicon monoxide is one of the major gas phase silicon bearing components observed in astronomical environments. Silicon oxide serves as the major rock forming material for terrestrial and meteoritic bodies. It is known that several gas phase reactions produce mass independent isotopic fractionations which possess the same delta(O-17)/delta(O-18) ratio observed in Allende inclusions. The general symmetry dependence of the chemically produced mass independent isotopic fractionation process suggests that there are several plausible reactions which could occur in the early solar system which may lead to production of the observed meteoritic oxygen isotopic anomalies. An important component in exploring the role of such processes is the need to experimentally determine the isotopic fractionations for specific reactions of relevance to the early solar system. It has already been demonstrated that atomic oxygen reaction with CO, a major nebular oxygen bearing species, produces a large (approximately 90 percent), mass independent isotopic fractionation. The next hurdle regarding assessing the involvement of symmetry dependent isotopic fractionation processes in the pre-solar nebula is to determine isotopic fractionation factors associated with gas phase reactions of metallic oxides. In particular, a reaction such as O + SiO yields SiO2 is a plausible nebular reaction which could produce a delta(O-17) is approximately delta(O-18) fractionation based upon molecular symmetry considerations. While the isotopic fractionations during silicate evaporation and condensation have been determined, there are no isotopic studies of controlled, gas phase nucleation processes. In order to carefully control the reaction kinetics, a molecular beam apparatus has been constructed. This system produces a supersonic, collimated beam of SiO molecules which is reacted with a second beam of oxygen atoms. An important feature of molecular beams is that they operate at sufficiently low pressures and high temperatures in the jet that avalanche nucleation and clustering processes may be avoided.

Dong, Q. W.↗
NASA NTRS1994

Residents' reactions to long-term sonic boom exposure: Preliminary results

This presentation is about residents' reactions to sonic booms in a long-term sonic boom exposure environment. Although two phases of the data collection have been completed, the analysis of the data has only begun. The results are thus preliminary. The list of four authors reflects the complex multi-disciplinary character of any field study such as this one. Carey Moulton is responsible for Wyle Laboratories' acoustical data collection effort. Robert Baumgartner and Jeff Thomas of HBRS, a social science research firm, are responsible for social survey field work and data processing. The study is supported by the NASA Langley Research Center. The study has several objectives. The preliminary data addresses two of the primary objectives. The first objective is to describe the reactions to sonic booms of people who are living where sonic booms are a routine, recurring feature of the acoustical environment. The second objective is to compare these residents' reactions to the reactions of residents who hear conventional aircraft noise around airports. Here is an overview of the presentation. This study will first be placed in the context of previous community survey research on sonic booms. Next the noise measurement program will be briefly described and part of a social survey interview will be presented. Finally data will be presented on the residents' reactions and these reactions will be compared with reactions to conventional aircraft. Twelve community studies of residents' reactions to sonic booms were conducted in the United States and Europe in the 1960's and early 1970's. None of the 12 studies combined three essential ingredients that are found in the present study. Residents' long-term responses are related to a measured noise environment. Sonic booms are a permanent feature of the residential environment. The respondents' do not live on a military base. The present study is important because it provides the first dose/response relationship for sonic booms that could be expected to apply to residents in civilian residential areas.

Fields, James M.↗
NASA NTRS1994

The reaction probability of N2O5 with sulfuric acid aerosols at stratospheric temperatures and compositions

We have measured the rate of reaction of N2O5 with H2O on monodisperse, submicrometer H2SO4 particles in a low-temperature flow reactor. Measurements were carried out at temperatures between 225 K and 293 K on aerosol particles with sizes and compositions comparable to those found in the stratosphere. At 273 K, the reaction probability was found to be 0.103 +/- 0.0006, independent of H2SO4 composition from 64 to 81 wt%. At 230 K, the reaction probability increased from 0.077 for compositions near 60% H2SO4 to 0.146 for compositions near 70% H2SO4. Intermediate conditions gave intermediate results except for low reaction probabilities of about 0.045 at 260 K on aerosols with about 78% H2SO4. The reaction probability did not depend on particle size. These results imply that the reaction occurs essentially at the surface of the particle. A simple model for this type of reaction that reproduces the general trends observed is presented. the presence of formaldehyde did not affect the reaction rate.

Fried, Alan↗
NASA NTRS2001

Reaction Kernel Structure of a Slot Jet Diffusion Flame in Microgravity

Diffusion flame stabilization in normal earth gravity (1 g) has long been a fundamental research subject in combustion. Local flame-flow phenomena, including heat and species transport and chemical reactions, around the flame base in the vicinity of condensed surfaces control flame stabilization and fire spreading processes. Therefore, gravity plays an important role in the subject topic because buoyancy induces flow in the flame zone, thus increasing the convective (and diffusive) oxygen transport into the flame zone and, in turn, reaction rates. Recent computations show that a peak reactivity (heat-release or oxygen-consumption rate) spot, or reaction kernel, is formed in the flame base by back-diffusion and reactions of radical species in the incoming oxygen-abundant flow at relatively low temperatures (about 1550 K). Quasi-linear correlations were found between the peak heat-release or oxygen-consumption rate and the velocity at the reaction kernel for cases including both jet and flat-plate diffusion flames in airflow. The reaction kernel provides a stationary ignition source to incoming reactants, sustains combustion, and thus stabilizes the trailing diffusion flame. In a quiescent microgravity environment, no buoyancy-induced flow exits and thus purely diffusive transport controls the reaction rates. Flame stabilization mechanisms in such purely diffusion-controlled regime remain largely unstudied. Therefore, it will be a rigorous test for the reaction kernel correlation if it can be extended toward zero velocity conditions in the purely diffusion-controlled regime. The objectives of this study are to reveal the structure of the flame-stabilizing region of a two-dimensional (2D) laminar jet diffusion flame in microgravity and develop a unified diffusion flame stabilization mechanism. This paper reports the recent progress in the computation and experiment performed in microgravity.

Takahashi, F.↗
NASA NTRS2002

Quantum Dynamics Study of the Isotopic Effect on Capture Reactions: HD, D2 + CH3

Time-dependent wave-packet-propagation calculations are reported for the isotopic reactions, HD + CH3 and D2 + CH3, in six degrees of freedom and for zero total angular momentum. Initial state selected reaction probabilities for different initial rotational-vibrational states are presented in this study. This study shows that excitations of the HD(D2) enhances the reactivities; whereas the excitations of the CH3 umbrella mode have the opposite effects. This is consistent with the reaction of H2 + CH3. The comparison of these three isotopic reactions also shows the isotopic effects in the initial-state-selected reaction probabilities. The cumulative reaction probabilities (CRP) are obtained by summing over initial-state-selected reaction probabilities. The energy-shift approximation to account for the contribution of degrees of freedom missing in the six dimensionality calculation is employed to obtain approximate full-dimensional CRPs. The rate constant comparison shows H2 + CH3 reaction has the biggest reactivity, then HD + CH3, and D2 + CH3 has the smallest.

Wang, Dunyou↗