Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Vibrational Spectroscopy”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 307 records · Page 17

A ground-based technique for millimeter wave spectroscopic observations of stratospheric trace constituents

Recent concern over possible long term stratospheric changes caused by the introduction of man-made compounds has increased the need for instrumentation that can accurately measure stratospheric minor constituents. The technique of radio spectroscopy at millimeter wavelengths was first used to observe rotational transitions of stratospheric ozone nearly two decades ago, but has not been highly developed until recently. A ground-based observing technique is reported which employs a millimeter-wave superheterodyne receiver and multichannel filter spectrometer for measurements of stratospheric constituents that have peak volume mixing ratios that are less than 10 to the -9th, more than 3 orders of magnitude less than that for ozone. The technique is used for an extensive program of observations of stratospheric chlorine monoxide and also for observations of other stratospheric trace gases such as (O-16)3, vibrationally excited (O-16)3, (O-18)2(O-16), N2O, HO2, and HCN. In the present paper, analysis of the observing technique is given, including the method of calibration and analysis of sources of error. The technique is found to be a reliable means of observing and monitoring important stratospheric trace constituents.

Parrish, A.↗

The Use of Tribocharging in the Electrostatic Beneficiation of Lunar Simulant

Any future lunar base and habitat must be constructed from strong dense materials in order to provide for thermal and radiation protection. Lunar soil may meet this need. Lunar regolith has high concentrations of aluminum, silicon, calcium, iron, sodium, and titanium oxides. Refinement or enrichment of specific minerals in the soil before it is chemically processed may be more desirable as it would reduce the size and energy requirements required to produce the virgin material and it may significantly reduce the process' complexity. Also, investigations into the potential production of breathable oxygen from oxidized mineral components are a major research initiative by NASA. In this study. the objective was to investigate the use of tribocharging to charge lunar simulants and pass them through a parallel plate separator to enrich different mineral fractions. This technique takes advantage of the high Lunar vacuum in which much higher voltages can be used on the separation plates than in air. Additionally, the Lunar g1avity, only being 1/6 that of Earth, allows the particles more separation time between the plates and therefore enhances separation. For the separation studies, two lunar stimulants were used. The first simulant was created in-house, labeled KSC-1. using commercially supplied (sieved to 325 mesh) materials, and was composed of 40 wt. % feldspar ((Na,K,Ca)AlSi3O8;SiO2), 40 wt. % olivine ((Mg,Fe)2SiO4), 10 wt. % ilmenite (FeTiO3). and 10 wt. % spodumene (LiAlSi2O6) (pyroxene). The advantage of the in-house mixture is that the composition can he varied to simulate different soil compositions from different areas on the moon. This simulant was used to show proof-of-concept using the designed separator in air. The second stimulant was JSC-1. used for the vacuum experiments. JSC-1 is principally basalts, containing phases of plagioclase. pyroxene. olivine, and ilmenite. The JSC-1 was sieved to provide a 50-75 micron size range to correlate with the mean grain size found on the moon's surface [1]. Four different materials were investigated for the triboelectrification process; aluminum, copper. stainless steel, and PTFE. These materials were selected because they offer a wide variation in work functions (aluminum 4.28 eV, copper 4.65 eV. stainless steel 5.04 eV, and PTFE 5.75 eV). The difference between the work function of each material and the simulant influences the charge obtained by the grains. Each simulant was analyzed before and after separation using X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) to determine mineral surface composition. In addition. Raman spectroscopy was performed on the JSC-1 before and after separation in vacuum to determine the mineral composition. Charge-to-mass (Q/M) measurements were performed using a fluidizing bed in air and passing the simulant through a static mixer of a particular material and collecting it in a Faraday pail grounded through an electrometer. To measure the Q/M in vacuum, a special device was constructed consisting of a heater/shaker cup that fed into a solid block of material (either PTFE, copper, or aluminum) in which a channel composed of a "zig-zag" series of inclines greater than 50 degrees has been cut. The voltage to the vibrating motor can be varied to control the amount of simulant passing through the channel. Figure I shows the Q/M measurements for JSC-1 tribocharged using the static mixers and the incline plane chargers in air, and the incline plane chargers in vacuum.

Trigwell, S.↗

Three-micron spectroscopy of highly reddened field stars

Broad absorption features centered at 3.45 microns and at 3.0-3.0 microns towards a number of late-type supergiants in the vicinity of the galactic center were repeatedly reported. Here, 2.0 to 2.5 and 3.0 to 4.0 micron spectra are presented for field late-type highly reddened (A sub V is approximately 17-27) stars located in different regions of the galactic plane more than 20 deg away from the galactic center direction. The observations, made with the 3.6, 2.2, and 1.0 m ESO telescopes at La Silla, Chile, consists of CVF spectra with resolution lambda/delta lambda is approximately or equal to 100 and IRSPEC spectra with resolution lambda/delta lambda is approximately or equal to 700. In the direction of the most highly reddened stars, definitive detections of the 3.45 and the 3.0 to 3.1 micron absorption features are reported. The 3.45 micron feature was attributed to absorption arising in a vibrational transition resulting from the C-H stretching in organic compounds, while the 3.0 to 3.1 micron broader feature are tentatively attributed to O-H bonds. The observations strongly support that the agent producing the 3.45 micron feature, presumably organic molecules, is an important component of the diffuse interstellar medium and is not characteristic only of the galactic center environment.

Tapia, Mauricio↗

Infrared Spectroscopy of Matrix-Isolated Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon Cations: The Members of the Thermodynamically Most Favorable Series through Coronene - Part 2

Gaseous, ionized polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHS) are thought to be responsible for a very common family of interstellar infrared emission bands. Here the near- and mid-infrared spectra of the cations of the five most thermodynamically favored PAHs up to coronene: phenanthrene, pyrene, benzo[e]pyrene, benzo-[ghi]perylene, and coronene, are presented to test this hypothesis. For those molecules that have been studied previously (pyrene, pyrene-d(sub 10), and coronene), band positions and relative intensities are in agreement. In all of these cases we report additional features. Absolute integrated absorbance values are given for the phenanthrene, perdeuteriophenanthrene, pyrene, benzo[ghi]perylene, and coronene cations. With the exception of coronene, the cation bands corresponding to the CC modes are typically 2-5 times more intense than those of the CH out-of-plane bending vibrations. For the cations, the CC stretching and CH in-plane bending modes give rise to bands that are an order of magnitude stronger than those of the neutral species, and the CH out-of-plane bends produce bands that are 5-20 times weaker than those of the neutral species. This behavior is similar to that found in most other PAH cations studied to date. The astronomical implications of these PAH cation spectra are also discussed.

Hudgins, D. M.↗

The ultraviolet dayglow at solar maximum. 1 - Far UV spectroscopy at 3.5 A resolution

The earth's far ultraviolet dayglow (1080-1515 A) was observed at about 3.5 A resolution during a period of high solar activity near solar maximum om June 27, 1980. The observations were made at local noon by rocket-borne spectrometers viewing toward the earth's northern limb at 90 deg zenith angle (ZA) at altitudes between 100 and 245 km, and at 98 deg ZA between 245 and 260 km. The zenith angle was 8.9 deg. These spectra are compared with earlier lower-resolution dayglow data obtained during a period of lower solar activity and with auroral spectra. The brightness ratio of O I 1356 to the N2 Lyman-Birge-Hopfield (LBH) system, an indicator of the O to N2 density ratio, is lower than that previously measured at mid-latitudes and closer to the value found in aurorae. In the LBH system a depletion of the bands originating on the v-prime = 3 vibrational level of the excited state is found. Some weak N2 Birge-Hopfield bands and N I lines only marginally detected previously in the dayglow are confirmed.

Eastes, R. W.↗

Infrared Spectroscopy of Matrix-Isolated Polycyclic Aromatic Compounds and their Ions: Polycyclic Aromatic Nitrogen Heterocycles - 6

The matrix-isolation technique has been employed to measure the mid-infrared spectra of several polycyclic aromatic nitrogen heterocycles in both neutral and cationic forms. The species studied include: 7,8 benzoquinoline (C13H9N); 2-azapyrene (C15H9N); 1- and 2-azabenz(a)anthracene (C17H11N); and 1-, 2-, and 4-azachrysene (also C17H11N). The experimentally measured band frequencies and intensities for each molecule are tabulated and compared with their theoretically calculated values computed using density functional theory at the B3LYP/4-31G level. The overall agreement between experiment and theory is quite good, in keeping with previous investigations involving the parent aromatic hydrocarbons. Several interesting spectroscopic trends are found to accompany nitrogen substitution into the aromatic framework of these compounds. First, for the neutral species, the nitrogen atom produces a significant increase in the total integrated infrared intensity across the 1600 - 1100/cm region and plays an essential role in the molecular vibration that underlies an uncharacteristically intense, discrete feature that is observed near 1400/cm in the spectra of 7,8 benzoquinoline, 1-azabenz(a)anthracene, and 4-azachrysene. The origin of this enhanced infrared activity and the nature of the new 1400/cm vibrational mode are explored. Finally, in contrast to the parent hydrocarbon species, these aromatic nitrogen heterocycles possess a significant permanent dipole moment. Consequently, these dipole moments and the rotational constants are reported for these species in their neutral and ionized forms.

Mattioda, A. L.↗

Measuring Rocket Engine Temperatures with Hydrogen Raman Spectroscopy

Optically accessible, high pressure, hot fire test articles are available at NASA Marshall for use in development of advanced rocket engine propellant injectors. Single laser-pulse ultraviolet (UV) Raman spectroscopy has been used in the past in these devices for analysis of high pressure H2- and CH4-fueled combustion, but relies on an independent pressure measurement in order to provide temperature information. A variation of UV Raman (High Resolution Hydrogen Raman Spectroscopy) is under development and will allow temperature measurement without the need for an independent pressure measurement, useful for flows where local pressure may not be accurately known. The technique involves the use of a spectrometer with good spectral resolution, requiring a small entrance slit for the spectrometer. The H2 Raman spectrum, when created by a narrow linewidth laser source and obtained from a good spectral resolution spectrograph, has a spectral shape related to temperature. By best-fit matching an experimental spectrum to theoretical spectra at various temperatures, a temperature measurement is obtained. The spectral model accounts for collisional narrowing, collisional broadening, Doppler broadening, and collisional line shifting of each Raman line making up the H2 Stokes vibrational Q-branch spectrum. At pressures from atmospheric up to those associated with advanced preburner components (5500 psia), collisional broadening though present does not cause significant overlap of the Raman lines, allowing high resolution H2 Raman to be used for temperature measurements in plumes and in high pressure test articles. Experimental demonstrations of the technique are performed for rich H2-air flames at atmospheric pressure and for high pressure, 300 K H2-He mixtures. Spectrometer imaging quality is identified as being critical for successful implementation of technique.

Wehrmeyer, Joseph A.↗

MEAD In-situ Sampling and Testing at Haughton Crater

The Mars Exploration through Analog-site Drilling (MEAD) project is designed to demonstrate the feasibility and scientific value of robotic drilling missions to Mars in the search for evidence of past or extant life. MEAD conducts high-fidelity field simulations integrating drilling, autonomous operations, and in-situ life-detection and mineralogical instruments. The project tests the Signs of Life Detector (SOLID), proposed for the 2019 Discovery Mars Icebreaker mission, and ARIA (Astronaut Raman Instrument for ISRU and Astrobiology), which provides mineral identification and detects trace organics and volatiles, including indicators of organic thermal maturity. Because current and planned Mars drilling missions operate largely “blind,” MEAD also evaluates the use of drill-induced vibrations recorded by deployed geophones to enable local subsurface mapping for improved targeting of drilling and sampling. In August 2025, MEAD completed its first-year field deployment to Haughton Crater in the Canadian High Arctic, an established Mars impact-crater terrestrial analog site, bringing a Honeybee Robotics TRIDENT drill with applied automation, alongside ARIA, SOLID, and FleetSpace geophones.

Haughton Crater↗

Excited Vibrational Level Rotational Constants for SiC2: A Sensitive Molecular Diagnostic for Astrophysical Conditions

Silacyclopropynylidene, SiC2, is a known and highly abundant circumstellar molecule. Its spectrum has been established as a major component of lines observed toward the carbon-rich star IRC +10216 (CW Leonis). It has been detected in its low-lying v(sub 3) = 1 and 2 vibrational states as well as in various isotopic compositions. Increasing sensitivity and spatial resolution will enable many more emission or absorption lines to be detected. In order to detect new molecular species, unassigned lines of known species must be identified. This work uses established ab initio quartic force fields to produce data necessary for this classification of lines related to SiC2. Agreement between the theoretical vibrational frequencies and known rotational and spectroscopic constants is quite good, as good as 5 cm(exp -1) and 3 MHz, respectively in some cases. Additionally, experimentally unknown vibrational frequencies and rotational constants are provided for the first overtones and combination bands in addition to 3(sub v3), the second overtone of the low-lying antisymmetric stretch/carbide rotation mode. Frequencies of v(sub 3) = 3 low-J rotational transitions of the main isotopic species are also estimated from published data for v(sub 3) ≤ 2. Further, we determine rotational and centrifugal distortion parameters for which in most cases vibrational effects due to the v(sub 3) mode were reduced to first, and in several cases also to second order. These values may approximate equilibrium values better than the ground state values. The data produced herein will aid in the experimental and observational characterization of this known astromolecule in order to identify some of the unassigned lines for a known entity.

Astrochemistry↗

Computing rovibrational, vibrational, and cascade emission spectra for comparison to astronomical observations

Over the last several years, our group has been involved in developing approaches to compute highly accurate spectroscopic constants and vibrational frequencies for small transient molecules that may be used in the interpretation and assignment of high-resolution laboratory experiments as well as high-resolution astronomical spectra. Additionally, we have used the computed spectroscopic constants to simulate purely rotational and rovibrational spectra so that these may be compared directly with high-resolution astronomical observations, and we have worked on developing approaches that can be applied to much larger molecules, such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) molecules, where we can explicitly determine anharmonic corrections to vibrational frequencies as well as take into account intensity sharing due to resonances. In addition, for PAH molecules we have used the anharmonic data to compute a library of temperature-dependent anharmonic vibrational spectra, with proper inclusion of polyad resonances, which can then be used to model the cascade emission spectra of PAH molecules – the type of spectra directly observed by astronomers. Another part of our work in spectroscopic signatures involves computing highly accurate line lists for common molecules, such as CO2, SO2, and NH3, which occur in many astrophysical environments, including the atmospheres of exoplanents, and often need to have their lines identified in high-resolution observations in order to determine which lines are due to other molecules. In order to characterize the atmospheres of hot exoplanets, these line lists need to be very accurate and extend to very high energies. I will discuss our latest work in these areas of astrochemical spectroscopy research.

Timothy J Lee↗

Optical emission generated by collisions of 5 eV O(3P) atoms with surface-absorbed hydrazine

Optical emission has been observed corresponding to vibrational bands in the NH (A 3Pi - X 3Sigma(-)) electronic transition during collisions of 5 eV, ground-state oxygen O(3P) atoms with MgF2 and Ni surfaces continuously exposed to a beam of hydrazine (N2H4). The NH emission intensity is observed to be about five times greater for MgF2 than for Ni. No dependence on temperature was observed for either surface in the range 240 - 340 K, implying that the NH-producing intermediate species is tightly bound. The half-lifetime for desorption of hydrazine from each surface was measured. This was found to be 120 min for the MgF2 surface at 240 K, and less than 20 min for Ni. After exposure, the surface composition was measured using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy on the exposed and unexposed areas of both targets.

Orient, O. J.↗

Direct Measurements of Infrared Intensities of HCN and H2O + HCN Ices for Laboratory and Observational Astrochemistry

Hydrogen cyanide (HCN) is found in a wide variety of extraterrestrial environments within and beyond the solar system, and for that reason laboratory spectroscopists have studied this compound in many spectral regions, including the infrared (IR). However, one aspect that remains to be investigated is the intrinsic IR spectral intensities of solid HCN as opposed to relative band strengths, intrinsic intensities being needed to measure HCN abundances. Here we report measurements of IR absorption coefficients and band strengths, along with supporting refractive indices and densities, of both amorphous and crystalline HCN at two temperatures, one for interstellar work and one more relevant to the outer solar system. Spectra are presented at both temperatures, along with optical constants that can be used in numerical models. Despite widespread and longstanding interest in and investigations of solid HCN, this is the first time that the properties we are reporting have been measured in a single laboratory, avoiding the need for estimates or to combine results from various authors. We find that our measured band strength of ~1 × 1017 cm molecule1 for the CN vibration of HCN, in both amorphous HCN and in an H2O-rich ice, is substantially higher than an earlier estimate. Unless errors of 100% can be tolerated then our new value requires a rescaling of earlier work. Our results shed light on why HCN and other nitriles have been so difficult to identify in the solid state, in contrast to their many detections in the gas phase.

astrochemistry – methods: laboratory – solid state↗

Direct Measurements of Infrared Intensities of HCN and H2O + HCN Ices for Laboratory and Observational Astrochemistry

Hydrogen cyanide (HCN) is found in a wide variety of extraterrestrial environments within and beyond the solar system, and for that reason laboratory spectroscopists have studied this compound in many spectral regions, including the infrared (IR). However, one aspect that remains to be investigated is the intrinsic IR spectral intensities of solid HCN as opposed to relative band strengths, intrinsic intensities being needed to measure HCN abundances. Here we report measurements of IR absorption coefficients and band strengths, along with supporting refractive indices and densities, of both amorphous and crystalline HCN at two temperatures, one for interstellar work and one more relevant to the outer solar system. Spectra are presented at both temperatures, along with optical constants that can be used in numerical models. Despite widespread and longstanding interest in and investigations of solid HCN, this is the first time that the properties we are reporting have been measured in a single laboratory, avoiding the need for estimates or to combine results from various authors. We find that our measured band strength of ~1 × 1017 cm molecule1 for the CN vibration of HCN, in both amorphous HCN and in an H2O-rich ice, is substantially higher than an earlier estimate. Unless errors of 100% can be tolerated then our new value requires a rescaling of earlier work. Our results shed light on why HCN and other nitriles have been so difficult to identify in the solid state, in contrast to their many detections in the gas phase.

astrochemistry – methods: laboratory – solid state↗

Atmospheric Trace Gas Abundances and Stable Isotope Ratios via IR-LIF

We propose to develop new technologies with support provided by PIDDP that will enable the in situ measurements of abundances and stable isotope ratios in important radiatively and biogenically active gases such as carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, water, methane, nitrous oxide, and hydrogen sulfide to very high precision (0.1 per mil or better for the isotopic ratios, for example). Such measurements, impossible at present, could provide pivotal new constraints on the global (bio)geochemical budgets of these critical species, and could also be used to examine the dynamics of atmospheric transport on Mars, Titan, and other solar system bodies. We believe the combination of solid state light sources with imaging of the IR laser induced fluorescence (IR-LIF) via newly available detector arrays will make such in situ measurements possible for the first time. Even under ambient terrestrial conditions, the LIF yield from vibrational excitation of species such as water and carbon dioxide should produce emission measures well in excess of ten billion photons/sec from samples volumes of order 1 c.c. These count rates can, in principle, yield detection limits into the sub-ppt range that are required for the in situ isotopic study of atmospheric trace gases. While promising, such technologies are relatively immature, but developing rapidly, and there are a great many uncertainties regarding their applicability to in situ IR-LIF planetary studies. We therefore feel PIDDP support will be critical to developing these new tools, and propose a three-year program to combine microchip near-IR lasers with low background detection axes and state-of-the-art HgCdTe detectors developed for astronomical spectroscopy to investigate the sensitivity of IR-LIF under realistic planetary conditions, to optimize the optical pumping and filtering schemes for important species, and to apply the spectrometer to the non-destructive measurement of stable isotopes in a variety of test samples. These studies form the necessary precursors to the development of compact, lightweight stable isotope/trace gas sensors for future planetary missions.

Blake, Geoffrey A.↗

Analysis of Shockwave Radiation Data in Nitrogen

Data from test series in the Electric Arc Shock Tube Facility were previously reportedfor velocities spanning 6-12 km/s in pure N2 at a freestream pressure of 0.2 Torr. The testseries provided spectrally- and spatially-resolved data for validation of a number of modelsof physical phenomena, including vibrational relaxation, molecular radiation, nitrogendissociation and ionization, and atomic radiation and ionization. In the present workanalysis of data obtained at a nominal velocity of 10.3 km/s is discussed in detail. Spectraare analyzed to extract temperatures and the densities of excited states as a function ofposition behind the shock. The effect of different methods for calculating state populationsand ionization processes is assessed, as is a rigorous assessment of the atomic line lists, withboth missing and extra lines identified.

Re-entry↗

Laboratory Studies of the Photochemistry of Peroxynitric Acid

Observations of odd hydrogen radicals at high SZA in the lower stratosphere have demonstrated that our understanding of the HO(x) chemistry is incomplete [Wennberg et al., 1994a; Salawitch et al., 1994; Wennberg et al., 1999]. In particular, the concentrations of the HO(x) radicals are significantly larger than expected under weak photolytic conditions. Donaldson et al. [1997] have speculated that excitation of overtones of the OH stretching frequency in molecules such as HNO3 and HO2NO2 may be significant sources of HO(x) under these conditions. Although weak, vibrationally mediated photolysis may be important because it occurs in the near IR and visible and can provide energy in excess of the dissociation energy (D(o)): HONO2 + hv yields OH + NO (D(o) approx. 600 nm) and HOONO2 + hv yields OH + NO3 (D(o) approx. 735 nm) HOONO2 + hv yields HO2 + NO2 (D(o) approx. 1250 nm). In this project we developed instrumentation to characterize the photodissociation yields of hydroxyl containing compounds in the visible and near IR. This effort has involved coupling a tunable photolysis optical parametric oscillator (OPO) laser system with precise determination of the hydroxyl radical. The OPO system [Wu et al., 1997] was developed with support from the NSF Major Research Instrumentation Fund in a proposal entitled "Development of Novel, Compact Light Sources for Advanced Spectroscopy in Atmospheric Science and Materials Research" (Geoffrey A. Blake, P.I. California Institute of Technology).

Wennberg, Paul O.↗

MOPITT Mechanisms 16 Years In-Orbit Operation on TERRA

The 16th anniversary of the launch of NASA's Terra Spacecraft was marked on December 18, 2015, with the Measurements of Pollution in the Troposphere (MOPITT) instrument being a successful contributor to the NASA EOS flagship. MOPITT has been enabled by a large suite of mechanisms, allowing the instrument to perform long-duration monitoring of atmospheric carbon monoxide, providing global measurements of this important greenhouse gas for 16 years. Mechanisms have been successfully employed for scanning, cooling of detectors, and to optically modulate the gas path length within the instrument by means of pressure and gas cell length variation. The instrument utilizes these devices to perform correlation spectroscopy, enabling measurements with vertical resolution from the nadir view, and has thereby furthered understanding of source and global transport effects of carbon monoxide. Given the design requirement for a 5.25-year lifetime, the stability and performance of the majority of mechanisms have far surpassed design goals. With 16 continuously operating mechanisms in service on MOPITT, including 12 rotating mechanisms and 4 with linear drive elements, the instrument was an ambitious undertaking. The long life requirements combined with demands for cleanliness and optical stability made for difficult design choices including that of the selection of new lubrication processes. Observations and lessons learned with regards to many aspects of the mechanisms and associated monitoring devices are discussed here. Mechanism behaviors are described, including anomalies, long-term drive current/power, fill pressure, vibration and cold-tip temperature trends. The effectiveness of particular lubrication formulations and the screening method implemented is discussed in relation to continuous rotating mechanisms and stepper motors, which have exceeded 15 billon rotations and 2.5 billion steps respectively. Aspects of gas cell hermeticity, optical cleanliness, heater problems and SEU effects on accelerometers are also discussed.

Gibson, Andrew S.↗

Analysis of Shockwave Radiation Data in Nitrogen

Data from a pure nitrogen test series in the Electric Arc Shock Tube Facility were previously reported for velocities spanning 6-12 km/s at a free-stream pressure of 0.2 Torr. This test series provides validation data for a range of physical phenomena to investigate, including vibrational relaxation, molecular radiation, nitrogen dissociation and ionization, and atomic radiation and ionization. This paper details analysis of data obtained at a nominal velocity of 10.3 km/s. The spectra are analyzed to extract temperatures and the densities of excited states as a function of position behind the shock. The effect of different methods for calculating state populations and ionization processes is assessed, as is a rigorous assessment of the atomic line lists, with both missing and extra lines identified.

Nitrogen↗