Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Related References”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 307 records · Page 17
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2024

Model-Based Approaches to Generate Knowledge from Data in a Plant Reliability Context

One challenge that nuclear power plant system engineers are facing is that the amount of equipment reliability (ER) data being continuously generated are extremely large. These data elements come in different forms: textual (e.g., condition reports) and numeric (e.g., generated by monitoring systems) and they provide system engineers with valuable insights and information regarding the discovery of anomalous behaviors or degradation trends, the identification of the possible causes behind such behaviors and trends, and the prediction of their direct consequences. This paper directly targets the generation of knowledge from ER data by putting “data into context”. Here, we employ model-based system engineering (MBSE) models of systems and assets to represent and capture their architecture and functional (i.e., cause-effect) relations. ER data elements are processed by identifying first which elements of the developed MBSE elements they are referring to. This task is much harder for textual data since the information contained in issue or maintenance reports needs to “be understood” by a computational tool. Here we called this process “knowledge extraction” where our methods to extract knowledge from textual data. Lastly, once numeric and textual ER data elements have been processed and “understood”, we discover possible cause-effect relations among them. This is performed by observing if a logical connection through the MBSE models exists, and if there is a temporal relation among them. The logic and temporal are the two main ingredients to perform “machine reasoning” from ER data.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2020

International cooperation in age-dating uranium standards for nuclear forensics using the 231 Pa/ 235 U radiochronometer

During 2017–2018 Los Alamos National Laboratory, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and the China Institute of Atomic Energy collaborated in an interlaboratory 231 Pa/ 235 U radiochronometry exercise. The laboratories used different analytical methods to obtain a consensus model purification date for CRM U010 of December 28, 1958 ± 198 days and for CRM U850 of May 20, 1958 ± 363 days. These results agree with previously reported model dates using the 230 Th/ 234 U radiochronometer as well as the production histories of these materials. The concordance of interlaboratory data here confirms the ability of laboratories to make reproducible radiochronometry measurements using distinct analytical approaches.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
DOE OSTI2025

ν-point energy correletors with F AST EEC: Small-x physics from LHC jets

In recent years, energy correlators have emerged as a powerful tool for studying jet substructure, with promising applications such as probing the hadronization transition, analyzing the quark-gluon plasma, and improving the precision of top quark mass measurements. The projected N-point correlator measures correlations between N final-state particles by tracking the largest separation between them, showing a scaling behavior related to DGLAP splitting functions. These correlators can be analytically continued in N, commonly referred to as ν-correlators, allowing access to non-integer moments of the splitting functions. Of particular interest is the ν → 0 limit, where the small momentum fraction behavior of the splitting functions requires resummation. Originally, the computational complexity of evaluating ν-correlators for M particles scaled as 2 2M , making it impractical for real-world analyses. However, by using recursion, we reduce this to M 2M , and through the FastEEC method of dynamically resolving subjets, M is replaced by the number of subjets. This breakthrough enables, for the first time, the computation of ν-correlators for LHC data. In practice, limiting the number of subjets to 16 is sufficient to achieve percent-level precision, which we validate using known integer-ν results and convergence tests for non-integer ν. We have implemented this in an update to FastEEC and conducted an initial study of power-law scaling in the perturbative regime as a function of ν, using CMS Open Data on jets. The results agree with DGLAP evolution, except at small ν, where the anomalous dimension saturates to a value that matches the BFKL anomalous dimension.

Energy correlators↗
DOE OSTI2025

Extreme Ultraviolet and Beyond Extreme Ultraviolet Lithography Using Amorphous Zeolitic Imidazolate Resists Deposited by Atomic/Molecular Layer Deposition

Amorphous zinc-imidazolate (aZnMIm) resists show potential to meet the demands for next-generation high-numerical aperture (high-NA) metal-containing extreme ultraviolet (EUV) resist materials, given their ease of deposition by atomic/molecular layer deposition (ALD/MLD) at thicknesses of 20 nm and below. Here, this study demonstrates that aZnMIm thin films, previously identified as high-resolution electron beam resists, can also function as negative-tone EUV photoresists. Water development achieves high sensitivity (5 mJ/cm 2 ) but leaves significant residue, while acetic acid development results in poor contrast. A hybrid approach─water followed by acetic acid─enables residue-free development with a sensitivity of 181 mJ/cm 2 . Dry development using 1,1,1,5,5,5-hexafluoroacetylacetone (hfacH) is also possible but shows lower sensitivity (375 mJ/cm 2 ) compared to wet development methods. EUV photoelectron spectroscopy (PES), reflectometry/EUV absorption, total electron yield (TEY), residual gas analysis (RGA), and time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (TOF-SIMS) were used to investigate the effects of EUV irradiation on aZnMIm resists. Reflectometry experiments reveal an aZnMIm EUV absorption coefficient of 6.2 μm –1 , while PES and TEY analyses show that, compared to poly(4-hydroxystyrene) (PHS), a polymer-based reference resist, aZnMIm emits more primary and secondary electrons but generates fewer slow electrons relative to its primary electron emission; its total electron yield is similar to that of poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) resists. When exposed to EUV, aZnMIm predominantly outgasses H 2 , as determined by RGA. TOF-SIMS measurements demonstrate that high-dose EUV exposure only partially fragments the 2-methylimidazole (2MIm) organic linkers, unlike high-dose electron beam exposure, which is known to completely degrade them. Additionally, aZnMIm resists show promise for potential beyond EUV lithography (BEUVL) due to the presence of Zn, which provides higher sensitivity at a wavelength of 6.7 nm compared to other metal ions, such as Sn, that are currently used in the best-performing EUV metal–organic resists. TEY measurements demonstrate that aZnMIm emits nearly twice as many electrons as PHS at 6.7 nm. The BEUV TEY of aZnMIm also surpasses that of PMMA, poly(pentafluorostyrene), and poly(4-iodostyrene), with the latter two being known for their high EUV TEYs. This work provides insight into zeolitic imidazolate framework (ZIF)-based EUV and BEUV resists and highlights their potential for both wet and dry development.

lithography↗
DOE OSTI2024

Coherence in Chemistry: Foundations and Frontiers

Coherence refers to correlations in waves. Because matter has a wave-particle nature, it is unsurprising that coherence has deep connections with the most contemporary issues in chemistry research (e.g., energy harvesting, femtosecond spectroscopy, molecular qubits and more). But what does the word "coherence" really mean in the context of molecules and other quantum systems? We provide a review of key concepts, definitions, and methodologies, surrounding coherence phenomena in chemistry, and we describe how the terms "coherence" and "quantum coherence" refer to many different phenomena in chemistry. Moreover, we show how these notions are related to the concept of an interference pattern. Coherence phenomena are indeed complex, and ambiguous definitions may spawn confusion. By describing the many definitions and contexts for coherence in the molecular sciences, we aim to enhance understanding and communication in this broad and active area of chemistry.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2022

Stability of a Mixed–Valence Hydrous Iron–Rich Oxide: Implications for Water Storage and Dynamics in the Deep Lower Mantle

Incorporation of water into mantle compositions can have significant effects on the phase relations in the systems. Here, we synthesized an iron-rich hexagonal hydrous phase (referred to as "HH1-phase") under the high pressure-temperature (P-T) conditions of the deep lower mantle and determined the crystal structure of the HH1-phase at 79 GPa using the multigrain crystallography method. The chemical formula obtained was Fe 12.76 O 18 H x (x ~ to 4.5) in the Fe-O-H system. To demonstrate the role of HH1-phase for water storage in multicomponent systems relevant to mantle compositions, we investigated the stability of HH1-phase in both MgO-rich pyrolitic and SiO 2 -rich basaltic compositions. Our results indicate that the HH1-phase serves as major water storage in a pyrolitic composition, whereas the Al-rich CaCl 2 -type δ-phase and SiO 2 phase are major water storage phases in a SiO 2 -rich basaltic composition. Incorporation of considerable amounts of SiO 2 , MgO, and Al 2 O 3 into the HH1-phase expands its stability field from 98 GPa in the Fe-Al-O-H system to at least 108 GPa (corresponding to similar to 2,400 km depth) in the Mg-Si-Al-Fe-O-H system. Plumes of hot upwelling rock rooted at the base of the lower mantle have been proposed as a possible origin of hotspot volcanoes. The hydrous Fe-rich HH1-phase, if included into the material of upwelling plumes, will decompose on its rising to the upper part of the lower mantle and release water. Our results should provide constraints on water storage in the deep lower mantle and have implications for deep mantle dynamics.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

Noise limits for dc SQUID readout of high- Q resonators below 300 MHz

We present the limits on noise for the readout of cryogenic high-Q resonators using dc Superconducting Quantum Interference Devices (SQUIDs) below 300 MHz. This analysis uses realized first-stage SQUIDs (previously published), whose performance is well described by Tesche–Clarke (TC) theory, coupled directly to the resonators. We also present data from a prototype second-stage dc SQUID array designed to couple to this first-stage SQUID as a follow-on amplifier with high system bandwidth. This analysis is the first full consideration of dc SQUID noise performance referred to a high-Q resonator over this frequency range and is presented relative to the standard quantum limit. We include imprecision, backaction, and backaction–imprecision noise correlations from TC theory, the noise contributed by the second-stage SQUIDs, wiring, and preamplifiers, and optimizations for both on-resonance measurements and off-resonance scan sensitivity. This architecture has modern relevance due to the increased interest in axion searches and the requirements of the DMRadio-m 3 axion search, which uses dc SQUIDs in this frequency range.

Bosons↗
DOE OSTI2026

Altermagnetic polar metallic phase in ultrathin epitaxially strained RuO 2 films

Altermagnetism refers to a wide class of magnetic orders featuring magnetic sublattices with opposite spins related by rotational symmetries, resulting in nontrivial spin splitting and magnetic multipoles. However, the direct observation of the altermagnetic transition remains elusive. Here, by combining theoretical analysis, electrical transport, X-ray, and optical spectroscopies, we establish a phase diagram in hybrid molecular beam epitaxy-grown RuO 2 /TiO 2 (110) films, mapping symmetries along with altermagnetic/electronic/structural phase transitions as functions of film thickness and temperature. This features an altermagnetic metallic polar phase in epitaxially strained 2 nm films, suggesting a potential link between polar metals and altermagnetic materials. Such a clear signature of a magnetic phase transition at ~500 K is observed exclusively in ultrathin strained films, unlike in bulk RuO 2 single crystals. These results highlight the power of epitaxial heterostructure engineering to induce altermagnetism in systems initially nonmagnetic, opening avenues for realizing emergent quantum phases with multifunctional properties.

RuO2 thin film↗
DOE OSTI2022

Analysis of a Bulk 237 Np Oxide Sample for Trace Actinides

A neptunium oxide sample was dissolved and trace actinide constituents were measured by isotope dilution ICP-MS (for 239–244 Pu, 233–238 U, 237 Np, 241–243 Am) and alpha spectrometry ( 238 Pu, 242 Cm, 244 Cm). This material contained significant quantities of transuranic elements, notably americium and curium. The isotopic composition of the material will continue to evolve over time due to radioactive decay; the measurements reported here include all isotopes decay corrected to a reference date of 1/1/2022. These factors may be considerations in criticality studies of the related 237 Np sphere.

38 RADIATION CHEMISTRY, RADIOCHEMISTRY, AND NUCLEA↗
DOE OSTI2024

Standards Guidance for Electric Two- and Three-Wheelers and Charging Infrastructure in Pakistan

Electric two-wheelers (E2Ws) and electric three-wheelers (E3Ws) have reached upfront cost price parity as compared to their conventional counterparts in many markets (IEA 2022). Therefore, Pakistan has embraced E2Ws and E3Ws in their National Electric Vehicle Policy (Government of Pakistan 2019b). Specifically, this policy targets 50% of new two- and three-wheeler sales to be electric by 2030. In the short term, this policy targets five times as many E2Ws and E3Ws as cars, vans, and pickups. In order to meet these goals in a safe, reliable, and efficient manner, Pakistan needs to develop and implement standards related to E2W and E3W vehicles and charging infrastructure, including battery swap stations. Without standards, E2Ws and E3Ws can be dangerous, unreliable, incompatible with charging stations, or diminish the grid’s electricity quality (Goel and Singh 2019; Sasidharan 2020). Fortunately, there are several global and local efforts to establish standards that Pakistan can learn from or adopt. This document explains the purpose and process of standards development and introduces the international standards development organizations involved and relevant classification and testing systems. It then introduces and lists many standards related to the vehicles, batteries, and charging equipment so that Pakistan can adopt or reference these standards when developing its own.

33 ADVANCED PROPULSION SYSTEMS↗
DOE OSTI2026

Mesoscale Organization in Cumulus-Coupled Stratocumulus

Marine cloud systems cover a substantial portion of the world’s oceans. Most of these clouds form relatively close to the ocean surface, typically within one to two kilometers, a region referred to by meteorologists as the marine boundary layer. They are composed predominantly of liquid water, although ice particles can occur in mid- and high-latitude marine clouds during winter. In satellite imagery, these clouds appear bright against the darker ocean surface below, reflecting a large fraction of incoming sunlight back into space that would otherwise warm the ocean. Because marine boundary layer clouds cover such an extensive area of the ocean, they exert a significant influence on Earth’s overall transfer of solar energy absorbed by the surface and thermal energy emitted to space, a balance known as the planetary radiation budget. Marine boundary layer clouds are typically thin, and their formation and dissipation depend on a delicate balance between processes acting at the ocean surface below and the warm, dry air above. They are notoriously difficult to simulate accurately in weather forecast models, which often produce too few marine low clouds in midlatitudes and clouds in tropical regions that are excessively bright, meaning they reflect too much solar radiation. The marine boundary layer is frequently characterized by widespread overcast cloud cover that often transitions from a continuous, single-layer deck to more broken cloud fields toward the tropics. These transitions typically proceed through an intermediate stage in which shallow, broken clouds form beneath the overlying stratiform cloud deck. Once broken clouds develop below the overcast, they frequently self-organize into cloud clusters known as marine boundary layer convective complexes (MBLCCs), although the mechanisms governing the formation and organization of MBLCCs remain poorly understood. Accurately representing these transitions in long-range weather forecast models is essential because they influence the properties of air masses advected over the continental United States and Europe, and they become increasingly important for forecasts on seasonal and longer timescales. We employed two complementary approaches to investigate the processes controlling MBLCCs and their impact on marine cloud cover. Long-term observations from the U.S. Department of Energy’s Eastern North Atlantic (ENA) Observatory provided a unique dataset that allowed us to characterize fundamental properties of MBLCCs, including their typical size and frequency of occurrence. These observations were combined with high-resolution numerical simulations performed on supercomputers to examine the evolution of MBLCCs during cold-air outbreaks over the ENA region.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2026

PIE-Enabled Study of Aqueous Corrosion & Zr Hydriding in Cr-Coated Cladding: M3GV-23PN0101132

Chromium-coated zirconium alloy cladding is under investigation as an accident-tolerant fuel (ATF) concept to extend performance to higher burnups via improved oxidation resistance and reduced hydrogen pickup. However, hydrothermal corrosion behavior and hydrogen transport mechanisms governing in-service hydriding of these coatings remain poorly understood. In a collaborative study between Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), Idaho National Laboratory (INL), and the University of Huddersfield, cold spray (CS) and physical vapor deposition (PVD) Cr-coated Optimized ZIRLO™ cladding samples were characterized after exposure to PWR-simulated water chemistry under both in-core (neutron irradiation) and out-of-core (aqueous-only) conditions at the MIT Research Reactor. Multi-scale characterization was performed independently at PNNL and INL to evaluate coating integrity, microstructural evolution, Cr/Zr interface chemistry, and hydride formation. Both laboratories observed a consistent divergence in hydriding behavior: out-of-core CS Cr-coated cladding exhibited elevated hydride concentrations exceeding those of uncoated cladding, whereas in-core CS samples showed substantially suppressed hydriding. In-core specimens also displayed irradiation-specific features, including nanoscale voids within the Cr coating and radiation-induced segregation clusters in the Zr substrate. CS coatings retained an interdiffusion-free Cr/Zr bond with no intermetallic layer, whereas PVD coatings exhibited inferior quality with visible cracks and pores. An automated image-based hydride quantification method systematically overestimated bulk hydrogen content relative to inert gas fusion measurements, underscoring the need for standardized sample preparation and reference standards. Interpretation of hydride nucleation and growth is complicated by the open inner-diameter of the specimens, which provides additional hydrogen pathways. The results motivate further foundational studies to support predictive models of hydrothermal corrosion and hydrogen transport in unirradiated and irradiated Cr-coated cladding.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2021

Microstructure and water absorption of ancient concrete from Pompeii: An integrated synchrotron microtomography and neutron radiography characterization

There is renewed interest in using advanced techniques to characterize ancient Roman concrete due to its exceptional durability and low-carbon footprint. In the present work, samples were drilled from the “Hospitium” in Pompeii and were analyzed by synchrotron microtomography (μCT) and neutron radiography to study how the microstructure, including the presence of induced cracks, affects their water adsorption. The water distribution and absorptivity were quantified by neutron radiography. The 3D crack propagation, pore size distribution and orientation, tortuosity, and connectivity were analyzed from μCT results using advanced imaging methods. Porosity was also measured by mercury intrusion porosimetry (MIP) as a reference. Ductile fracture patterns were observed once cracks were introduced. Compared to Portland cement mortar/concrete, the Pompeii samples had relatively high porosity, low connectivity, and a similar coefficient of capillary penetration. In addition, permeability was predicted from models based on percolation theory and pore structure data to evaluate the fluid transport properties. Understanding the microstructure of ancient Pompeii concrete is important because it could inspire the development of modern concrete with high durability.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2022

Search for the Chiral Magnetic Effect via Charge-Dependent Azimuthal Correlations Relative to Spectator and Participant Planes in Au + Au Collisions at s N N = 200 GeV

The chiral magnetic effect (CME) refers to charge separation along a strong magnetic field due to imbalanced chirality of quarks in local parity and charge-parity violating domains in quantum chromodynamics. The experimental measurement of the charge separation is made difficult by the presence of a major background from elliptic azimuthal anisotropy. This background and the CME signal have different sensitivities to the spectator and participant planes, and could thus be determined by measurements with respect to these planes. We report such measurements in Au+Au collisions at a nucleon-nucleon center-of-mass energy of 200 GeV at the Relativistic Heavy-Ion Collider. It is found that the charge separation, with the flow background removed, is consistent with zero in peripheral (large impact parameter) collisions. Some indication of finite CME signals is seen with a significance of 1–3 standard deviations in mid-central (intermediate impact parameter) collisions. Furthermore, significant residual background effects may, however, still be present.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2023

Anomalous compressible mode generation by global frame projections of pure Alfven mode

Alfven wave is the single most important physical phenomenon of magneto-hydrodynamic turbulence and has far-reaching impact to almost all studies related to astrophysical magnetic field. Yet the restoration of the Alfven wave fluctuations from a given magnetic field, aka the local Alfven wave problem, is never properly addressed in literature albeit its importance. Previous works model the Alfven wave fluctuation as the perturbation along a straight-line, constant magnetic field. However, Lazarian & Pogosyan (2012) suggested that the decomposition of Alfven wave along a straight line, aka. the global frame decomposition, has a factor of discrepancy to the true local Alfven wave fluctuation. Here, in this paper, we provide a geometric interpretation on how the local Alfven wave is related to the global frame through the use of vector frame formulation. We prove both analytically and numerically that the local frame Alfven wave is an orthogonal transformation of that of the global frame and related by the local Alfvenic Mach number. In other words, when we observe Alfven wave in the global frame of reference, some of the Alfven wave will be mistaken as compressible waves. The importance of frame choices have a far-reaching impact to the analytical studies of MHD turbulence. Combining the frame formalism and the new techniques we can have accurate measurement to some of the fundamental turbulence properties like the inclination angle of mean magnetic field relative to the line of sight.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2024

Corrigendum: Simulations of stand-off runaway electron beam termination by tungsten particulates for tokamak disruption mitigation (2024 Nucl. Fusion 64 056019)

In the original article, we inadvertently omitted a reference which previously introduced the concept of tungsten injection for 'Disruption Mitigation in Tokamak Reactor via Reducing the Seed Electrons of Avalanche.' In that reference, the authors have proposed injection of a tungsten cylinder of 80 mm by 8 mm dimensions, by rail guns, to absorb the runaway seed population. This can be contrasted with another interesting idea of using small tungsten pellets coated with a low Z material for depleting the runaway seeds as an option for upgrade of the ITER Disruption Mitigation System. Interested readers are referred to those two papers on the tungsten injection for runaway seed removal/reduction, and the related issue of not shortening the current quench excessively. The application focus of was not on reducing the runaway seeds in the initial Ohmic-to-runaway current conversion phase, but on safe termination of a fully formed and likely decaying runaway beam that is about to scrape off against the first wall, which can be accelerated by vertical displacement events. This scheme thus serves as a last line of defense against potential wall damage. The choice here is locally released tungsten particulates, similar to the previous idea of using tungsten particulates as a dust shield for the divertor. The most significant finding of is that strong pitch angle scattering, in addition to energy attenuation and absorption, of high-energy runaways by tungsten particulates, provides a transport mechanism by which runaways damage of the first wall can be mitigated by reducing and spreading the runaway wall load. We regret the omission in the original article, and thank the authors of the cited article for bringing this matter to our attention. We also find the possibility of using the injected tungsten rod from to terminate the runaways, as opposed to the cloud of tungsten particulates in intriguing. In that context, it is of interest to mention another possibility of a retractable tungsten metal arm that can be swung out for deployment in runaway termination, which would remove the need for post-mitigation recovery of tungsten debris in injection schemes.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2025

RNAi and genome editing of sugarcane: Progress and prospects

SUMMARY Sugarcane, which provides 80% of global table sugar and 40% of biofuel, presents unique breeding challenges due to its highly polyploid, heterozygous, and frequently aneuploid genome. Significant progress has been made in developing genetic resources, including the recently completed reference genome of the sugarcane cultivar R570 and pan‐genomic resources from sorghum, a closely related diploid species. Biotechnological approaches including RNA interference (RNAi), overexpression of transgenes, and gene editing technologies offer promising avenues for accelerating sugarcane improvement. These methods have successfully targeted genes involved in important traits such as sucrose accumulation, lignin biosynthesis, biomass oil accumulation, and stress response. One of the main transformation methods—biolistic gene transfer or Agrobacterium ‐mediated transformation—coupled with efficient tissue culture protocols, is typically used for implementing these biotechnology approaches. Emerging technologies show promise for overcoming current limitations. The use of morphogenic genes can help address genotype constraints and improve transformation efficiency. Tissue culture‐free technologies, such as spray‐induced gene silencing, virus‐induced gene silencing, or virus‐induced gene editing, offer potential for accelerating functional genomics studies. Additionally, novel approaches including base and prime editing, orthogonal synthetic transcription factors, and synthetic directed evolution present opportunities for enhancing sugarcane traits. These advances collectively aim to improve sugarcane's efficiency as a crop for both sugar and biofuel production. This review aims to discuss the progress made in sugarcane methodologies, with a focus on RNAi and gene editing approaches, how RNAi can be used to inform functional gene targets, and future improvements and applications.

Brant, Eleanor [Agronomy Department, Plant Molecul↗
DOE OSTI2020

Cybersecurity for Distance Relay Protection

This project is a DOE follow-up effort on the CREDC workshop held on September 13, 2018 in Cambridge, MA to discuss cybersecurity of distance relays, which considered the benefits, vulnerabilities and risk mitigations for the use of communication systems in power system protection. The objectives of this project are to define the taxonomy of relay protection and associated communications; define use cases describing approaches to reduce the cyber-attack surface on those protective relays; and evaluate the loss of operational functional capability from changes to communication coverage. Mitigating controls will also be evaluated to understand if there are other approaches to reduce attack surfaces while maintaining communications or partial communications. Distance relays are used to protect transmission lines of approximately 10 to 300 miles in length, by detecting short circuits (i.e., faults) on the lines and then tripping circuit breakers in the substation. Such protection systems are a subset of the power system and they incorporate sensing, logic and communication functions. Protection system exposure to cyberattack could be drastically limited by disconnecting relays from all vulnerable communication systems, but this may adversely impact overall power system performance in the absence of cyberattack. This project began with a use case analysis of protection systems with communications, as summarized in this report. It continued with modeling, testing and evaluation in a miniature power system (MPS), located in the Western Area Power Administration (WAPA) Electric Power Training Center (EPTC). The project also incorporated feedback from two industry meetings held in February and September 2019. The suggested next steps account for and complement the work already underway with DOE/CESER funding: 1. Study the performance of LCD and PC vs. PUTT, which is less reliant on communication system performance and GPS timing references. The PUTT scheme could prove to be more resilient to cyberattack or communications-related disruption. It could also be more tolerant of message re-routing with SDN/SDR communication systems. On the other hand, it will be more vulnerable to false tripping during dynamic events or to loss of the voltage signal. The optimum choice of scheme may depend on the specific power system and risk assessment. This study could provide a new template for evaluation based on business functions. 2. Research and develop new methods to detect and monitor distributed physical attacks, possibly using drones, video sensors, thermal sensors, machine learning and other advanced techniques. This will help mitigate the impact of cyberattack on the protection system, and will also help mitigate the impact of wild fires. 3. Implement a scalable PKI for use in electric utility protection systems. This will encourage widespread adoption of secure authentication methods that are already available, but not widely used at present. This will help secure engineering access to the relays. 4. Investigate the use of SDN in combination with SDR to achieve better cybersecurity and electromagnetic security of the network, incorporating path variability. This would help secure both engineering access and peer-to-peer GOOSE messaging. 5. Perform additional testing, with operator evaluation of “red button” scenarios, PUTT vs. LCD, relay mis-operations, and other cyberattacks in the EPTC. This is an important advantage of testing in the EPTC rather than by computer simulation or even hardware-in-the-loop simulation; the EPTC is already dedicated to managing the situational awareness, operator response times and other human impacts. One of the project objectives was to settle on a common nomenclature for this problem space. We have concluded that the OSI layer model, supplemented by ANSI device numbers and other IEEE standards, is already well-accepted by the industry. The IEEE PSRC knowledge base provides a great deal of public information

24 POWER TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION↗