Modeling used fuel response to normal conditions of transportation package drops to access geometric sensitivities
The US Department of Energy Used Fuel Disposition program is performing research to determine the loading conditions that used nuclear fuel (UNF) experiences during normal conditions of transportation (NCT). This loading environment includes mechanical shock and vibration as the UNF is transported by rail or truck, and it also includes potential package free drop conditions, which are the topic of this study. NCT drop test requirements for UNF package designs are defined in 10 CFR 71.71. The free drop test height is 30 cm for the UNF packages considered in this study. Explicit dynamic finite element models of generic rail and truck UNF packages containing a highly resolved 17x17 PWR fuel assembly are used to estimate the potential range of loading experienced by UNF during NCT horizontal package drops onto an unyielding surface. There are many variables and uncertainties that can affect the loading of UNF during this type of free drop scenario. This study focuses on geometric variables, such as gap conditions and small adjustments to the angle of impact, in a number of analysis cases. The LS-DYNA finite element analyses calculate detailed results for all the components of the fuel assembly. The results show that the peak localized axial strain in the fuel cladding is estimated to be 0.006421 (nominal) with an upper bound of 0.014511, based on the peak instantaneous bending moment of 63.65 N-m and other uncertainty factors. For the assumed low burnup condition of the UNF, the cladding yield strain is 0.011027 and the failure strain is 0.015574, which means that the calculated upper bound strain approaches the cladding failure limit without exceeding it. The peak shear force on the cladding was calculated to be 7879 N. This could be significant to cladding integrity if applied to the UNF in a situation where the fuel pellets do not support the shear transfer. Further evaluation is needed to determine if this is a credible threat to cladding integrity for these 30 cm free drop scenarios.