Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Entropy Stable”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 307 records · Page 17

A combined experimental and machine learning exploration of Ti 2-x Zr x MnCrFeNi high entropy Laves hydrides

A series of high entropy AB 2 -type Ti 2-x Zr x MnCrFeNi alloys (x = 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 0.9, 1.0, 1.1 and 1.2) were synthesized to investigate their potential for hydrogen storage and chemical compression. The influence of the Ti/Zr ratio was explored in terms of structural, microstructural and thermodynamic properties. The storage capacity together with the reaction enthalpy and entropy changes of the synthesized high entropy alloys were compared to predictions from Machine Learning (ML) to investigate changes in these properties across the explored composition space. The results revealed that a decreasing Zr content consistently lowered the hydride formation enthalpy and increased the plateau pressure from 8 to >90 bar H 2 at 25 °C, in good agreement with ML predictions. Selected compositions (x = 1.0 and 1.2) demonstrated reversible hydrogen storage capability over 150 cycles, with capacities of 1.34–1.40 wt % H 2 and remarkable reaction kinetics (<4 min) at ambient temperature. These experimental and computational findings highlight the potential of this Laves-HEA system as tuneable, stable, and cost-effective materials suitable for long-term operations in stationary hydrogen storage and compression applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Quantum mechanical dataset of 836k neutral closed-shell molecules with up to 5 heavy atoms from C, N, O, F, Si, P, S, Cl, Br

Abstract We introduce the Vector-QM24 (VQM24) dataset comprehensively covering all possible neutral closed-shell small organic and inorganic molecules with up to five heavy (p-block) atoms: C, N, O, F, Si, P, S, Cl, Br. All valid stoichiometries, Lewis-rule-consistent graphs, and stable conformers (identified via GFN2-xTB) were enumerated combinatorially, yielding 577k conformational isomers spanning 258k constitutional isomers and 5,599 unique stoichiometries. DFT (ωB97X-D3/cc-pVDZ) optimizations were performed for all, and diffusion quantum Monte Carlo (DMC@PBE0(ccECP/cc-pVQZ)) energies are provided for 10,793 lowest-energy conformers with up to 4 heavy atoms. VQM24 includes structures, vibrational modes, rotational constants, thermodynamic properties (Gibbs free energies, enthalpies, ZPVEs, entropies, heat capacities), and electronic properties such as atomization, electron interaction, exchange-correlation, dispersion energies, multipole moments (dipole to hexadecapole), alchemical potentials, Mulliken charges, and wavefunctions. Machine learning models of atomization energies on this dataset reveal significantly higher complexity than QM9, with none achieving chemical accuracy. VQM24 offers a rigorous, high-fidelity benchmark for evaluating quantum machine learning models.

Science & Technology - Other Topics↗

r-PROCESS NUCLEOSYNTHESIS IN DYNAMICALLY EJECTED MATTER OF NEUTRON STAR MERGERS

Although the rapid neutron-capture process, or r-process, is fundamentally important for explaining the origin of approximately half of the stable nuclei with A > 60, the astrophysical site of this process has not been identified yet. Here we study r-process nucleosynthesis in material that is dynamically ejected by tidal and pressure forces during the merging of binary neutron stars (NSs) and within milliseconds afterward. For the first time we make use of relativistic hydrodynamical simulations of such events, defining consistently the conditions that determine the nucleosynthesis, i.e., neutron enrichment, entropy, early density evolution and thus expansion timescale, and ejecta mass. We find that 10{sup -3}-10{sup -2} M{sub sun} are ejected, which is enough for mergers to be the main source of heavy (A {approx}> 140) galactic r-nuclei for merger rates of some 10{sup -5} yr{sup -1}. While asymmetric mergers eject 2-3 times more mass than symmetric ones, the exact amount depends weakly on whether the NSs have radii of {approx}15 km for a 'stiff' nuclear equation of state (EOS) or {approx}12 km for a 'soft' EOS. r-process nucleosynthesis during the decompression becomes largely insensitive to the detailed conditions because of efficient fission recycling, producing a composition that closely follows the solar r-abundance distribution for nuclei with mass numbers A > 140. Estimating the light curve powered by the radioactive decay heating of r-process nuclei with an approximative model, we expect high emission in the B-V-R bands for 1-2 days with potentially observable longer duration in the case of asymmetric mergers because of the larger ejecta mass.

79 ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS↗

A MUSCL-SCNI approach for meshfree modeling of shock waves in fluids

Here, a stable and nodally integrated meshfree formulation for modeling shock waves in fluids is developed. The reproducing kernel approximation is employed to discretize the conservation equations for compressible flow, and a flux vector splitting approach is applied to allow proper numerical treatments for the advection and pressure parts, respectively, based on the characteristics of each flux term. To capture the essential shock physics in fluids, including the Rankine–Hugoniot jump conditions and the entropy condition, local Riemann enrichment is introduced under the stabilized conforming nodal integration (SCNI) framework. Meanwhile, numerical instabilities associated with the advection flux are eliminated by adopting a modified upwind scheme. To further enhance accuracy, a MUSCL-type method is introduced in conjunction with an oscillation limiter to avoid Gibbs phenomenon and ensure monotonic piecewise linear reconstruction in the smooth region. The present meshfree formulation is free from tunable artificial parameters and is capable of capturing shock and rarefaction waves without over/undershoots. Finally, several numerical examples are analyzed to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed MUSCL-SCNI approach in meshfree modeling of complex shock phenomena, including shock diffraction, shock–vortex interaction, and high energy explosion processes.

42 ENGINEERING↗

The Two-Energies Turbulence Scheme Coupled to the Assumed PDF Method

An update of the two-energy turbulence scheme is presented, the 2TE + APDF scheme. The original version of the two-energy scheme is able to successfully model shallow convection without the need of an additional parameterization for non-local fluxes. However, the performance of the two-energy scheme is worse in stratocumulus cases, where it tends to overestimate the erosion of the stable layers. We have identified the causes: the non-local stability parameter does not consider local stratification, the scheme lacks an internal parameter that could distinguish between a shallow convection regime and a stratocumulus regime, and it uses an inflexible turbulence length scale formulation. To alleviate this problem, we propose several modifications: an update of the stability parameter, a modified computation of the turbulence length scale, and the introduction of the entropy potential temperature to distinguish between a shallow convection and a stratocumulus regime. In addition, the two-energy scheme is coupled to a simplified assumed probability density function method in order to achieve a more universal representation of the cloudy regimes. The updated turbulence scheme is evaluated for several idealized cases and one selected real case in the ICOsahedral Nonhydrostatic (ICON) modeling framework. The results show that the updated scheme corrects the overmixing problem in the stratocumulus cases. The performance of the updated scheme is comparable to the operational setup, and can be thus used instead of the operational turbulence and shallow convection scheme in ICON. Additionally, the updated scheme improves the coupling with dynamics, which is beneficial for the modeling of coherent flow structures in the atmospheric boundary layer.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗

Maximum entropy approach to fuzzy control

For the same expert knowledge, if one uses different &- and V-operations in a fuzzy control methodology, one ends up with different control strategies. Each choice of these operations restricts the set of possible control strategies. Since a wrong choice can lead to a low quality control, it is reasonable to try to loose as few possibilities as possible. This idea is formalized and it is shown that it leads to the choice of min(a + b,1) for V and min(a,b) for &. This choice was tried on NASA Shuttle simulator; it leads to a maximally stable control.

Ramer, Arthur↗

An adaptive identification and control scheme for large space structures

A unified identification and control scheme capable of achieving space at form performance objectives under nominal or failure conditions is described. Preliminary results are also presented, showing that the methodology offers much promise for effective robust control of large space structures. The control method is a multivariable, adaptive, output predictive controller called Model Predictive Control (MPC). MPC uses a state space model and input reference trajectories of set or tracking points to adaptively generate optimum commands. For a fixed model, MPC processes commands with great efficiency, and is also highly robust. A key feature of MPC is its ability to control either nonminimum phase or open loop unstable systems. As an output controller, MPC does not explicitly require full state feedback, as do most multivariable (e.g., Linear Quadratic) methods. Its features are very useful in LSS operations, as they allow non-collocated actuators and sensors. The identification scheme is based on canonical variate analysis (CVA) of input and output data. The CVA technique is particularly suited for the measurement and identification of structural dynamic processes - that is, unsteady transient or dynamically interacting processes such as between aerodynamics and structural deformation - from short, noisy data. CVA is structured so that the identification can be done in real or near real time, using computationally stable algorithms. Modeling LSS dynamics in 1-g laboratories has always been a major impediment not only to understanding their behavior in orbit, but also to controlling it. In cases where the theoretical model is not confirmed, current methods provide few clues concerning additional dynamical relationships that are not included in the theoretical models. CVA needs no a priori model data, or structure; all statistically significant dynamical states are determined using natural, entropy-based methods. Heretofore, a major limitation in applying adaptive controllers to LSS problems has been the requirement for accurate models. We feel that MPC coupled with the CVA identification scheme will resolve this limitation. The results are based on research performed under an SBIR grant, administered by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research.

Carroll, J. V.↗

Elevated-Temperature Tribo-Corrosion Response of Eutectic High-Entropy Alloy

The combination of elevated temperature and tribo-corrosion leads to the accelerated degradation of structural components used in many extreme environments. Recently developed high-entropy alloys (HEAs) with multiple principal elements have the potential for superior degradation resistance compared with presently used structural alloys. Here, we demonstrate the microstructural stability, pitting resistance, and superior tribo-corrosion degradation resistance of the AlCoCrFeNi 2.1 eutectic HEA in comparison with duplex stainless steel 2205 in deionized water (controlled low-ionic-strength electrolyte) at 25 °C, 50 °C and 100 °C. The AlCoCrFeNi 2.1 HEA showed excellent microstructural stability and tribo-corrosion resistance at all three temperatures, an order-of-magnitude lower wear rate, and a lower coefficient of friction compared with duplex 2205 steel. The lowest wear volume loss and wear rate for both AlCoCrFeNi 2.1 and duplex steel were recorded at 50 °C, which was attributed to temperature-assisted passivation and formation of a comparatively stable tribological surface condition. These results suggest superior performance of eutectic HEAs in tribo-corrosion applications compared with currently used dual-phase steels and motivate future evaluation in ion-containing industrial water chemistries.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Precision Structure Engineering of High-Entropy Oxides under Ambient Conditions

High-entropy oxides (HEOs) have unveiled a unique frontier in the realm of heterogeneous catalysis, taking advantage of the entropic effect and increased complexities to deliver ultrahigh stability and large tuning capability. However, current HEO synthesis mainly relies on high-temperature annealing approaches affording HEOs possessing no or low surface area, inferior active site exposure efficiency, and low controllability over the structure tuning. The grand challenge lies in producing high-quality HEO catalysts with high active site utilization efficiency, which relies on precision structure engineering, preferably under mild conditions. In this work, an in situ lattice engineering approach was developed to afford a supported HEO catalyst under ambient conditions. The HEO compositions (CuCoFeNiMnO x ) were uniformly integrated into the lattice of CeO 2 driven by cavitation-induced nucleation being generated via ultrasonication. The as-afforded catalysts were featured by high surface area, atomically dispersed HEO compositions, active redox properties, abundant oxygen vacancies (O V ), antiagglomeration, and high phase stability under harsh conditions. Compared with the ex situ introduction of HEO on the surface, the in situ method provides dual benefits to maintain the dispersity of HEO via entropic and lattice confinement effects. Engineering the complex HEO within the lattice of fluorite-structured CeO 2 also yields abundant defects (e.g., O V ) and active metal sites with strong reducing properties (e.g., Ce 3+ and Cu + ), which greatly improves the activity of the lattice oxygen and tunability of the adsorption behavior of the guest molecules, especially in the presence of impurities (e.g., water and propane). The catalytic performance of the supported HEO catalyst in oxidative procedures surpasses the pure dense phase HEO as well as the ex situ-generated catalysts. Further, the synthesis approach being developed in this work, together with the fundamental understanding in structure evolution and reaction mechanism, showcases a facile pathway under ambient conditions to generate stable catalysts capable of maintaining structural robustness in high-temperature conditions while delivering enhanced catalytic performance.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Density-functional theory computer simulations of CZTS{sub 0.25}Se{sub 0.75} alloy phase diagrams

Density-functional theory simulations of CZTS, CZTSe, and CZTS{sub 0.25}Se{sub 0.75} photovoltaic compounds have been performed to investigate the stability of the CZTS{sub 0.25}Se{sub 0.75} alloy vs. decomposition into CZTS, CZTSe, and other secondary compounds. The Gibbs energy for vibrational contributions was estimated by calculating phonon spectra and thermodynamic properties at finite temperatures. It was demonstrated that the CZTS{sub 0.25}Se{sub 0.75} alloy is stabilized not by enthalpy of formation but primarily by the mixing contributions to the Gibbs energy. The Gibbs energy gains/losses for several decomposition reactions were calculated as a function of temperature with/without intermixing and vibration contributions to the Gibbs energy. A set of phase diagrams was built in the multidimensional space of chemical potentials at 300 K and 900 K temperatures to demonstrate alloy stability and boundary compounds at various chemical conditions. It demonstrated for CZTS{sub 0.25}Se{sub 0.75} that the chemical potentials for stability differ between typical processing temperature (∼900 K) and operating temperature (300 K). This implies that as cooling progresses, the flux/concentration of S should be increased in MBE growth to maintain the CZTS{sub 0.25}Se{sub 0.75} in a thermodynamically stable state to minimize phase decomposition.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Neutron powder diffraction and difference maximum entropy method analysis of protium- and deuterium-dissolved BaSn{sub 0.5}In{sub 0.5}O{sub 2.75+{alpha}}

We propose a new method, a difference maximum entropy method (MEM) analysis of the neutron diffraction data, for revealing the detailed structure around hydrogen atoms in proton-conducting oxides. This MEM analysis uses the differences between the structure factors of protium- and deuterium-dissolved crystals. Simulations demonstrate that it not only provides the distribution of hydrogen atoms alone, but also improves the spatial resolution of MEM mapping around hydrogen atoms. Applied to actual diffraction data of protium- and deuterium-dissolved BaSn{sub 0.5}In{sub 0.5}O{sub 2.75+{alpha}} at 9 K, difference MEM analysis reveals that O-D bonds mostly tilt towards the second nearest oxygen atoms, and that the distributions of deuterium and oxygen atoms are probably insignificant in interstitial regions. - Graphical abstract: A novel method, difference maximum entropy method (MEM) analysis of the neutron diffraction data, is proposed for revealing the detailed structure around hydrogen atoms in proton-conducting oxides. This MEM analysis uses the differences between the structure factors of protium- and deuterium-dissolved crystals and improves the spatial resolution of the MEM mapping around the hydrogen atoms.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Atomic-Scale Design of Iron Fischer-Tropsch Catalysts; A Combined Computational Chemistry, Experimental, and Microkinetic Modeling Approach

This work focuses on (1) searching/summarizing published Fischer-Tropsch synthesis (FTS) mechanistic and kinetic studies of FTS reactions on iron catalysts; (2) preparation and characterization of unsupported iron catalysts with/without potassium/platinum promoters; (3) measurement of H{sub 2} and CO adsorption/dissociation kinetics on iron catalysts using transient methods; (3) analysis of the transient rate data to calculate kinetic parameters of early elementary steps in FTS; (4) construction of a microkinetic model of FTS on iron, and (5) validation of the model from collection of steady-state rate data for FTS on iron catalysts. Three unsupported iron catalysts and three alumina-supported iron catalysts were prepared by non-aqueous-evaporative deposition (NED) or aqueous impregnation (AI) and characterized by chemisorption, BET, temperature-programmed reduction (TPR), extent-of-reduction, XRD, and TEM methods. These catalysts, covering a wide range of dispersions and metal loadings, are well-reduced and relatively thermally stable up to 500-600 C in H{sub 2} and thus ideal for kinetic and mechanistic studies. Kinetic parameters for CO adsorption, CO dissociation, and surface carbon hydrogenation on these catalysts were determined from temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) of CO and temperature programmed surface hydrogenation (TPSR), temperature-programmed hydrogenation (TPH), and isothermal, transient hydrogenation (ITH). A microkinetic model was constructed for the early steps in FTS on polycrystalline iron from the kinetic parameters of elementary steps determined experimentally in this work and from literature values. Steady-state rate data were collected in a Berty reactor and used for validation of the microkinetic model. These rate data were fitted to 'smart' Langmuir-Hinshelwood rate expressions derived from a sequence of elementary steps and using a combination of fitted steady-state parameters and parameters specified from the transient measurements. The results provide a platform for further development of microkinetic models of FTS on Fe and a basis for more precise modeling of FTS activity of Fe catalysts. Calculations using periodic, self-consistent Density Functional Theory (DFT) methods were performed on various realistic models of industrial, Fe-based FTS catalysts. Close-packed, most stable Fe(110) facet was analyzed and subsequently carbide formation was found to be facile leading to the choice of the FeC(110) model representing a Fe facet with a sub-surface C atom. The Pt adatom (Fe{sup Pt}(110)) was found to be the most stable model for our studies into Pt promotion and finally the role of steps was elucidated by recourse to the defected Fe(211) facet. Binding Energies(BEs), preferred adsorption sites and geometries for all FTS relevant stable species and intermediates were evaluated on each model catalyst facet. A mechanistic model (comprising of 32 elementary steps involving 19 species) was constructed and each elementary step therein was fully characterized with respect to its thermochemistry and kinetics. Kinetic calculations involved evaluation of the Minimum Energy Pathways (MEPs) and activation energies (barriers) for each step. Vibrational frequencies were evaluated for the preferred adsorption configuration of each species with the aim of evaluating entropy-changes, pre exponential factors and serving as a useful connection with experimental surface science techniques. Comparative analysis among these four facets revealed important trends in their relative behavior and roles in FTS catalysis. Overall the First Principles Calculations afforded us a new insight into FTS catalysis on Fe and modified-Fe catalysts.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗

A collision operator for describing dissipation in noncanonical phase space

The phase space of a noncanonical Hamiltonian system is partially inaccessible due to dynamical constraints (Casimir invariants) arising from the kernel of the Poisson tensor. When an ensemble of noncanonical Hamiltonian systems is allowed to interact, dissipative processes eventually break the phase space constraints, resulting in a thermodynamic equilibrium described by a Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution. However, the time scale required to reach Maxwell–Boltzmann statistics is often much longer than the time scale over which a given system achieves a state of thermal equilibrium. Examples include diffusion in rigid mechanical systems, as well as collisionless relaxation in magnetized plasmas and stellar systems, where the interval between binary Coulomb or gravitational collisions can be longer than the time scale over which stable structures are self-organized. Here, we focus on self-organizing phenomena over spacetime scales such that particle interactions respect the noncanonical Hamiltonian structure, but yet act to create a state of thermodynamic equilibrium. We derive a collision operator for general noncanonical Hamiltonian systems, applicable to fast, localized interactions. This collision operator depends on the interaction exchanged by colliding particles and on the Poisson tensor encoding the noncanonical phase space structure, is consistent with entropy growth and conservation of particle number and energy, preserves the interior Casimir invariants, reduces to the Landau collision operator in the limit of grazing binary Coulomb collisions in canonical phase space, and exhibits a metriplectic structure. We further show how thermodynamic equilibria depart from Maxwell–Boltzmann statistics due to the noncanonical phase space structure, and how self-organization and collisionless relaxation in magnetized plasmas and stellar systems can be described through the derived collision operator.

Boltzmann equation↗

Effect of Zn Addition on Phase Evolution in AlCrFeCoNiZn High–Entropy Alloy

The addition of Zn to AlCrFeCoNi high-entropy alloy (HEA) poses intriguing questions as to how it would affect phase evolution. Herein, the phase evolution in AlCrFeCoNiZn is studied using a combination of experimental techniques (X-ray diffraction, scanning electron microscopy, energy-dispersive spectroscopy, and differential scanning calorimetry) and computational (density-functional theory [DFT], calculation of phase diagrams, and machine-learning) methods. Mechanically alloyed and spark-plasma-sintered AlCrFeCoNiZn assumes a metastable single-phase, body-centered-cubic (BCC) structure that undergoes diffusion-controlled phase separation upon subsequent heat treatment to form separate (Al, Cr)-rich, (Fe, Co)-rich, and (Zn, Ni)-rich phases. The formation of (Al, Cr)-rich phase, not reported previously in AlCrFeCoNi-based HEAs, is attributed to strong clustering tendency of Cr–Zn and Cr–Ni pairs, combined with the strong ordering of Zn–Ni pair, driving out Cr that in turn combines with Al to form a (Al, Cr)-rich phase. In the DFT results, the formation of thermodynamically stable L1 2 phase is shown wherein Cr–Fe–Zn [Al–Ni-Co] preferably occupy1a (000) [3c (0 ½ ½)] positions. Furthermore, the sluggish diffusional transformation to L1 2 phase from BCC precursors is attributed to the small stacking-fault energy of AlCrFeCoNiZn. The equilibrated HEA exhibits a high microhardness of 8.24 GPa with an elastic modulus of 184 GPa.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Stationary stability for evolutionary dynamics in finite populations

Here, we demonstrate a vast expansion of the theory of evolutionary stability to finite populations with mutation, connecting the theory of the stationary distribution of the Moran process with the Lyapunov theory of evolutionary stability. We define the notion of stationary stability for the Moran process with mutation and generalizations, as well as a generalized notion of evolutionary stability that includes mutation called an incentive stable state (ISS) candidate. For sufficiently large populations, extrema of the stationary distribution are ISS candidates and we give a family of Lyapunov quantities that are locally minimized at the stationary extrema and at ISS candidates. In various examples, including for the Moran andWright–Fisher processes, we show that the local maxima of the stationary distribution capture the traditionally-defined evolutionarily stable states. The classical stability theory of the replicator dynamic is recovered in the large population limit. Finally we include descriptions of possible extensions to populations of variable size and populations evolving on graphs.

60 APPLIED LIFE SCIENCES↗

A theoretical study of the thermodynamic properties of YMgX{sub 4} (X=Co, Ni, Cu) compounds

The stability, electronic structures, elastic and thermal properties of the ternary YMgX{sub 4} (X=Co, Ni, Cu) compounds are investigated by first principle calculations in combination with the quasi-harmonic Debye model. The three compounds are predicted to be stable according to the formation enthalpies (ΔH), elastic constants (c{sub ij}) and phonon dispersion models. The elastic constants and polycrystalline elastic moduli reveal the relatively low anisotropy of these compounds. The electronic structures and bonding characters are analyzed by the electron densities of states and difference charge densities in the (110) plane. The comparisons between the phonon density of state and the quasi-harmonic Debye model imply the heat capacities (C{sub v}) and vibrational entropies (S) are close for YMgCo{sub 4} and YMgCu{sub 4}, whereas large deviation for YMgNi{sub 4}. A possible reason is that YMgNi{sub 4} has the slightly strong directional bondings, relative to YMgCo{sub 4} and YMgCu{sub 4}.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Deep glassy state dynamic data challenge glass models: Elastic models

The idea of an “ideal” glass transition temperature has persisted at least since the work from Kauzmann when it was observed that the entropy of glass-forming liquids extrapolated to below that of the crystal, thus suggesting the need for a phase transition at a finite or non-zero absolute temperature. This thermodynamic paradox was also found to be related to the observations of a diverging of the extrapolated viscosity or relaxation times at a temperature near to this ideal glass transition. Recently, however, we have carried out experiments using both an ancient amber material and an ultra-stable amorphous fluoropolymer that challenge the ideas of the divergence of the viscosity or relaxation times at this ideal glass transition. In the present manuscript we have evaluated two theories of the glass transition that are based on ideas related to elasticity of the amorphous glass-forming material. We find that the models from both J. Dyre and his group and of K.S. Schweizer and his group not only show non-diverging behavior but are also in some agreement with the new data, though still showing somewhat slower dynamics than those observed in the experiments. The work shows that the data are good enough to distinguish between theories and it is suggested that other mechanisms may be needed to fully describe the non-diverging responses of the ultra-stable glasses.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗