Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Comparative Study”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 307 records · Page 17
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS1982

A comparative study of computational methods in cosmic gas dynamics

Many theoretical investigations of fluid flows in astrophysics require extensive numerical calculations. The selection of an appropriate computational method is, therefore, important for the astronomer who has to solve an astrophysical flow problem. The present investigation has the objective to provide an informational basis for such a selection by comparing a variety of numerical methods with the aid of a test problem. The test problem involves a simple, one-dimensional model of the gas flow in a spiral galaxy. The numerical methods considered include the beam scheme, Godunov's method (G), the second-order flux-splitting method (FS2), MacCormack's method, and the flux corrected transport methods of Boris and Book (1973). It is found that the best second-order method (FS2) outperforms the best first-order method (G) by a huge margin.

Van Albada, G. D.↗
NASA NTRS1997

Comparative study of energetic heliospheric electrons at wind and geotail

The current fleet of both heliospheric and magnetospheric spacecraft provides a unique opportunity of studying spatio-temporal plasma phenomena. Among the numerous topics that can be addressed by such a fleet, figures the 3D study of energetic (greater than 20 keV) solar electron) solar electron events. WIND and GEOTAIL are particulary interesting for such analysis: more than two years of data; up to 3/4 continuous days spent by GEOTAIL in the solar wind; and comparable experiments. During solar electron events, rapid electron flux changes can be associated with these structures. Sometimes they are seen at both spacecraft with a time difference corresponding to the convection time, but sometimes they are observed at one spacecraft but not at the other. Several preliminary conclusions can be drawn from such events: (1) there is direct evidence that, within distances lower than 1.5 x 10(exp 6) km at 1 A (approximately 7000 km at the sun), there are significant spatial variations of (a) the magnetic field line connections to the source region and probably of (b) the particle propagation features; (2) magnetic field lines inside and outside particle propagation structures can keep distinct access to the source region for more than one hour; (3) flux waves, of probable local origin, were observed; and (4) within one hour, spatial flux discrepancies, separated by magnetic structures, may remain or disappear.

Chaizy, P. A.↗
DOE OSTI2023

A Comparative Study of the Perceptual Sensitivity of Topological Visualizations to Feature Variations

Color maps are a commonly used visualization technique in which data are mapped to optical properties, e.g., color or opacity. Color maps, however, do not explicitly convey structures (e.g., positions and scale of features) within data. Topology-based visualizations reveal and explicitly communicate structures underlying data. Although our understanding of what types of features are captured by topological visualizations is good, our understanding of people's perception of those features is not. Further, this paper evaluates the sensitivity of topology-based isocontour, Reeb graph, and persistence diagram visualizations compared to a reference color map visualization for synthetically generated scalar fields on 2-manifold triangular meshes embedded in 3D. In particular, we built and ran a human-subject study that evaluated the perception of data features characterized by Gaussian signals and measured how effectively each visualization technique portrays variations of data features arising from the position and amplitude variation of a mixture of Gaussians. For positional feature variations, the results showed that only the Reeb graph visualization had high sensitivity. For amplitude feature variations, persistence diagrams and color maps demonstrated the highest sensitivity, whereas isocontours showed only weak sensitivity. These results take an important step toward understanding which topology-based tools are best for various data and task scenarios and their effectiveness in conveying topological variations as compared to conventional color mapping.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
NASA NTRS1982

A comparative study of the thematic mapper and Landsat spectral bands from field measurement data

Principal component and factor analysis techniques were applied to the spectral data collected over 27 field plots of various crops under varying agronomic conditions. The spectral data was integrated over the proposed thematic mapper bands and Landsat MSS spectral bands. The results were examined to compare the discrimination power of the thematic mapper. Previously announced in STAR as N81-33549

Badhwar, G. D.↗
NASA NTRS2011

Comparative Study of 3-Dimensional Woven Joint Architectures for Composite Spacecraft Structures

The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) Exploration Systems Mission Directorate initiated an Advanced Composite Technology (ACT) Project through the Exploration Technology Development Program in order to support the polymer composite needs for future heavy lift launch architectures. As an example, the large composite structural applications on Ares V inspired the evaluation of advanced joining technologies, specifically 3D woven composite joints, which could be applied to segmented barrel structures needed for autoclave cured barrel segments due to autoclave size constraints. Implementation of these 3D woven joint technologies may offer enhancements in damage tolerance without sacrificing weight. However, baseline mechanical performance data is needed to properly analyze the joint stresses and subsequently design/down-select a preform architecture. Six different configurations were designed and prepared for this study; each consisting of a different combination of warp/fill fiber volume ratio and preform interlocking method (Z-fiber, fully interlocked, or hybrid). Tensile testing was performed for this study with the enhancement of a dual camera Digital Image Correlation (DIC) system which provides the capability to measure full-field strains and three dimensional displacements of objects under load. As expected, the ratio of warp/fill fiber has a direct influence on strength and modulus, with higher values measured in the direction of higher fiber volume bias. When comparing the Z-fiber weave to a fully interlocked weave with comparable fiber bias, the Z-fiber weave demonstrated the best performance in two different comparisons. We report the measured tensile strengths and moduli for test coupons from the 6 different weave configurations under study.

Jones, Justin S.↗
NASA NTRS2011

Comparative Study of 3-Dimensional Woven Joint Architectures for Composite Spacecraft Structures

The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) Exploration Systems Mission Directorate initiated an Advanced Composite Technology (ACT) Project through the Exploration Technology Development Program in order to support the polymer composite needs for future heavy lift launch architectures. As an example, the large composite structural applications on Ares V inspired the evaluation of advanced joining technologies, specifically 3D woven composite joints, which could be applied to traditionally manufactured barrel segments. Implementation of these 3D woven joint technologies may offer enhancements in damage tolerance without sacrificing weight. However, baseline mechanical performance data is needed to properly analyze the joint stresses and subsequently design/down-select a preform architecture. Six different configurations were designed and prepared for this study; each consisting of a different combination of warp/fill fiber volume ratio and preform interlocking method (z-fiber, fully interlocked, or hybrid). Tensile testing was performed for this study with the enhancement of a dual camera Digital Image Correlation (DIC) system which provides the capability to measure full-field strains and three dimensional displacements of objects under load. As expected, the ratio of warp/fill fiber has a direct influence on strength and modulus, with higher values measured in the direction of higher fiber volume bias. When comparing the z-fiber weave to a fully interlocked weave with comparable fiber bias, the z-fiber weave demonstrated the best performance in two different comparisons. We report the measured tensile strengths and moduli for test coupons from the 6 different weave configurations under study.

Jones, Justin S.↗
DOE OSTI2016

Comparative study of neutron emission from a plasma focus device using two different anode shapes

The neutron emission from a low energy (2.2 kJ) plasma focus (PF) device operated with two different shapes (cylindrical and converging) of anodes has been investigated by employing photomultiplier tube and bubble dosimeter. The neutron emission with each anode is analyzed and the results are compared. It is found that the anode shapes strongly influenced the emission of neutron. The X-ray emission is found to be higher in case of converging anode, while neutron emission is found to be higher in case of cylindrical anode. The neutron yield and energy are found to be highly anisotropic in nature which indicates that the beam target mechanism plays a major role in the neutron emission in a PF device. The speed factor as well as the specific heat ratio of pinch column shows a good agreement with the experimentally observed results.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
NASA NTRS1983

Terrestrial versus Jovian VLF chorus - A comparative study

The relevant parameters of the magnetospheres of Jupiter and earth are investigated based on the wave-particle resonant interactions that are believed to be responsible for the generation of VLF chorus emissions observed on Voyager 1. Expressions are derived for the wave-particle interaction length and the nonlinearity parameter, and the values of these parameters are compared with those calculated for the earth's magnetosphere. It is determined that the typical interaction lengths are at least 2-5 times larger in the Jovian than in the terrestrial magnetosphere, and that the wave intensity necessary to reach the threshold of nonlinearity in the Jovian magnetosphere is 5-100 times lower. Measurements by Voyager 1 show that the inferred wave magnetic field intensities of the Jovian chorus are in the range of reported intensities for terrestrial chorus, probably due to the fact that the fluxes of few keV resonant particles found in the Jovian magnetosphere were typically two orders of magnitude higher. Growth rate measurements on Voyager 1 broadband wave data are employed to confirm that the temporal growth rates of Jovian chorus bursts are higher than for the earth.

Inan, U. S.↗
NASA NTRS2009

A Comparative Study of Randomized Constraint Solvers for Random-Symbolic Testing

The complexity of constraints is a major obstacle for constraint-based software verification. Automatic constraint solvers are fundamentally incomplete: input constraints often build on some undecidable theory or some theory the solver does not support. This paper proposes and evaluates several randomized solvers to address this issue. We compare the effectiveness of a symbolic solver (CVC3), a random solver, three hybrid solvers (i.e., mix of random and symbolic), and two heuristic search solvers. We evaluate the solvers on two benchmarks: one consisting of manually generated constraints and another generated with a concolic execution of 8 subjects. In addition to fully decidable constraints, the benchmarks include constraints with non-linear integer arithmetic, integer modulo and division, bitwise arithmetic, and floating-point arithmetic. As expected symbolic solving (in particular, CVC3) subsumes the other solvers for the concolic execution of subjects that only generate decidable constraints. For the remaining subjects the solvers are complementary.

Takaki, Mitsuo↗
DOE OSTI2024

Comparative Study of Data-Driven Area Inertia Estimation Approaches on WECC Power Systems

With the increasing integration of inverter-based resources into the power grid, there has been a notable reduction in system inertia, potentially compromising frequency stability. To assess the suitability of existing area inertia estimation techniques for real-world power systems, this paper presents a rigorous comparative analysis of system identification, measurement reconstruction, and electromechanical oscillation-based area inertia estimation methodologies, specifically applied to the large-scale and multi-area WECC 240-bus power system. Comprehensive results show that the system identification-based approach exhibits superior robustness and accuracy relative to its counterparts.

area inertia estimation↗
DOE OSTI2018

Microwave-assisted pyrolysis of Mississippi coal: A comparative study with conventional pyrolysis

Pyrolysis conditions greatly affect the structure-reactivity relationship of char during coal gasification. Here, this work investigated the effect of temperature and microwave heating on the structural properties of the chars generated during pyrolysis, as well as gaseous and tar products. Results showed that microwave pyrolysis of Mississippi coal produced more gaseous products and less tars compared to conventional pyrolysis. Higher CO/CO 2 ratio (>1) was observed under microwave pyrolysis compared to conventional pyrolysis (CO/CO2 < 1), which may be explained by a greater extent of gasification between solid carbon and the CO 2 formed during microwave pyrolysis. Additionally, in microwave pyrolysis, the oil tars generated exhibited lower concentrations of polar oxygenates, while the wax tars showed higher concentrations of non-polar alkanes, as observed from the intensity of CH vibrations in FTIR. The product compositions and FTIR analysis of the tars (oils and waxes) suggest that the microwave interacted preferentially with these polar species, which have relatively higher dielectric properties compared to alkanes. The structure–reactivity relationship of the chars produced was also investigated using a variety of characterization tools such as XRD, BET, SEM, EDS, and FTIR. Finally, the char reactivity towards combustion suggested that microwave-produced chars have a higher thermal stability, likely due to lower O/C ratios, and could be utilized in the metallurgical industry.

01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
NASA NTRS1988

Unstable resonator antenna properties in coherent lidar applications - A comparative study

The antenna parameters of a coherent lidar in the far-field diffraction-limited regime, where the lidar transmitter consists of an unstable resonator with a Gaussian reflectivity profile output coupler, are investigated. A figure-of-merit combining lasr transmitter energy extraction efficiency with the far-field attributes of a given cavity configuration has been used to compare the lidar performance and relative merits of such systems as they relate to those of conventional unstable cavities with diffractive output coupling.

Tratt, David M.↗
DOE OSTI2019

A Comparative Study of Two Widely Used Grid-Forming Droop Controls on Microgrid Small Signal Stability

Throughout history, two similar grid-forming droop controls are widely reported in literature—the single-and multi-loop droop controls. Although being very similar, the authors find that the dynamic performance and stability characteristics of each control method are very different in a microgrid. Compared with single-loop droop control, the multi-loop droop control is prone to be less damped and loses stability more easily under some circumstances. This paper provides a novel insight into the different dynamic responses of the two basic controls. It points out that the two similar controls adjust the angular frequency and voltage magnitude at different locations within the inverter, resulting in different coupling reactances that impact the dynamic response and stability of microgrids differently. The use of single-loop droop control results in a larger coupling reactance, which helps to improve dynamic response and stability. This novel insight is verified through full-order small signal analysis, offline electromagnetic transient simulation, and real-time hardware-in-the-loop simulation experiments. Results show that the microgrid has a larger small signal stability boundary when using single-loop droop control, and this difference increases as the value of an inverter’s inner filter inductance increases.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2025

Isotopic analysis of Nd nanoparticles using single particle MC-ICP-MS: A comparative study with single particle-ICP-TOF-MS

Single particle - inductively coupled plasma - mass spectrometry (SP-ICP-MS) is a powerful technique for characterization of the elemental and isotopic composition of individual particles. In this work, the capabilities of the newest generation of MC-ICP-MS with acquisition rates down to 50 ms were evaluated for single particle analysis, with a focus on isotopic precision achievable on a single-particle level. Nd (NdVO 4 ) nanoparticles (~120 nm in diameter) were used as case study and were first characterized in terms of mass (respective size) and particle number concentration by SP-ICP-TOF-MS and then by SP-MC-ICP-MS for isotopic precision. For the isotopic ratio measurements, the MC-ICP-MS performance was compared to the ICP-TOF-MS and it was found that the isotope ratio precision was increased (R 2 between 0.98 and 0.99) compared to ICP-TOF-MS (R 2 between 0.88 and 0.97). The accuracy attained on a single particle level, was compared to bulk digestion followed by MC-ICP-MS analysis, and the SP-MC-ICP-MS technique was able to determine the particle population average to be <4 %, percent relative differences for the 142 Nd/ 144 Nd, 143 Nd/ 144 Nd, 145 Nd/ 144 Nd, 146 Nd/ 144 Nd, and 148 Nd/ 144 Nd ratios The detection limit for the SP-MC-ICP-MS approach was also assessed. Here, when utilizing an all Faraday-cup based detection scheme the determined LOD for the measurements was 0.2fg for Nd, per particle. Based on these results, the newest generation of MC-ICP-MS has demonstrated its utility for performing SP measurement, particularly when high precision isotopic determination is warranted.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
NASA NTRS1992

LES versus DNS: A comparative study

We have performed Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) and Large Eddy Simulations (LES) of forced isotropic turbulence at moderate Reynolds numbers. The subgrid scale model used in the LES is based on an eddy viscosity which adjusts instantaneously the energy spectrum of the LES to that of the DNS. The statistics of the large scales of the DNS (filtered DNS field or fDNS) are compared to that of the LES. We present results for the transfer spectra, the skewness and flatness factors of the velocity components, the PDF's of the angle between the vorticity and the eigenvectors of the rate of strain, and that between the vorticity and the vorticity stretching tensor. The above LES statistics are found to be in good agreement with those measured in the fDNS field. We further observe that in all the numerical measurements, the trend was for the LES field to be more gaussian than the fDNS field. Future research on this point is planned.

Shtilman, L.↗
DOE OSTI2020

A comparative study of the effectiveness of empirical potentials for molecular dynamics simulations of borosilicate glasses

Despite their practical importance, atomistic modeling of B 2 O 3 containing glasses have been challenging due to the lack of reliable empirical potentials. Fortunately, a few recent developments have shown promises to simulate these glasses where the boron coordination has complex and non-linear dependence on glass composition. This work aims to provide an evaluation of the effectiveness of three recently developed potentials by a systematic study of a series (~20) of sodium borosilicate glasses with constant K (ratio of [SiO 2 ]/[B 2 O 3 ]) =2 and varying R (ratio of [Na 2 O]/[B 2 O 3 ] ranging from 0.1 to 4) values and several sodium boroaluminosilicate glasses. A comparative assessment was established on the basis of the short- and medium-range structure features, such as boron N 4 values, total correlation functions, bond angle distribution, oxygen speciation, and mechanical properties using experimental or well-established models as criteria. Furthermore, this work provides insights on the choices of empirical potentials for MD simulations of borosilicate glasses and gives directions of future potential development and refining.

12 MANAGEMENT OF RADIOACTIVE AND NON-RADIOACTIVE W↗
DOE OSTI2019

Comparative Studies of AlGaAs/InGaAs Enhancement/Depletion-Mode High Electron Mobility Transistors with Virtual Channel Layers by Hybrid Gate Recesses Approaches

Unlike the conventional GaAs- and InP-based enhancement/depletion-mode (E/D-mode) transistors, the improved gate characteristics of the AlGaAs/InGaAs E-mode high electron mobility transistors (HEMTs) by way of hybrid gate recesses to remove the n-AlAs/i-GaAs/n-AlGaAs virtual channel layers upon 2DEG channels are demonstrated. As compared to the D-mode device (sample A), the gate reverse currents are effectively reduced by 45 and 102 times for the E-mode devices with additional gate recess time of 24 s (sample B) and 30 s (sample C) to remove part of the virtual channel layers, respectively. Under gate forward bias, the hybrid gate recesses also enable the gate turn-on voltages to increase. Furthermore, the threshold voltages of –1.25, 0.09, and 0.22 V are observed in the samples A, B, and C, respectively. The maximum transconductances of 187.3, 209.2, and 243.4 mS/mm and saturation current density of 482.8, 410.6, and 347.4 mA/mm are obtained in the samples A, B, and C, respectively.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2020

Comparative Study of Differentially Private Data Synthesis Methods

When sharing data among researchers or releasing data for public use, there is a risk of exposing sensitive information of individuals in the data set. Data synthesis is a statistical disclosure limitation technique for releasing synthetic data sets with pseudo individual records. Traditional data synthesis techniques often rely on strong assumptions of a data intruder’s behaviors and background knowledge to assess disclosure risk. Differential privacy (DP) formulates a theoretical approach for a strong and robust privacy guarantee in data release without having to model intruders’ behaviors. Efforts have been made aiming to incorporate the DP concept in the data synthesis process. Here, we examine current DIfferentially Private Data Synthesis (DIPS) techniques for releasing individual-level surrogate data for the original data, compare the techniques conceptually and evaluate the statistical utility and inferential properties of the synthetic data via each DIPS technique through extensive simulation studies. Our work sheds light on the practical feasibility and utility of the various DIPS approaches, and suggests future research directions for DIPS.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗