Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “ultrathin”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 289 records · Page 16
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS1979

High temperature - low mass solar blanket

Interconnect materials and designs for use with ultrathin silicon solar cells are discussed, as well as the results of an investigation of the applicability of parallel-gap resistance welding for interconnecting these cells. Data relating contact pull strength and cell electrical degradation to variations in welding parameters such as time, voltage and pressure are presented. Methods for bonding ultrathin cells to flexible substances and for bonding thin (75 micrometers) covers to these cells are described. Also, factors influencing fabrication yield and approaches for increasing yield are discussed. The results of vacuum thermal cycling and thermal soak tests on prototype ultrathin cell test coupons and one solar module blanket are presented.

Mesch, H. G.↗
NASA NTRS1982

Ultrasonic seam welding on thin silicon solar cells

The ultrathin silicon solar cell has progressed to where it is a serious candidate for future light weight or radiation tolerant spacecraft. The ultrasonic method of producing welds was found to be satisfactory. These ultrathin cells could be handled without breakage in a semiautomated welding machine. This is a prototype of a machine capable of production rates sufficiently large to support spacecraft array assembly needs. For comparative purposes, this project also welded a variety of cells with thicknesses up to 0.23 mm as well as the 0.07 mm ultrathin cells. There was no electrical degradation in any cells. The mechanical pull strength of welds on the thick cells was excellent when using a large welding force. The mechanical strength of welds on thin cells was less since only a small welding force could be used without cracking these cells. Even so, the strength of welds on thin cells appears adequate for array application. The ability of such welds to survive multiyear, near Earth orbit thermal cycles needs to be demonstrated.

Stofel, E. J.↗
NASA NTRS2000

Structure, Hydrodynamics, and Phase Transition of Freely Suspended Liquid Crystals

Smectic liquid crystals are phases of rod shaped molecules organized into one dimensionally (1D) periodic arrays of layers, each layer being between one and two molecular lengths thick. In the least ordered smectic phases, the smectics A and C, each layer is a two dimensional (2D) liquid. Additionally there are a variety of more ordered smectic phases having hexatic short range translational order or 2D crystalline quasi long range translational order within the layers. The inherent fluid-layer structure and low vapor pressure of smectic liquid crystals enable the long term stabilization of freely suspended, single component, layered fluid films as thin as 30A, a single molecular layer. The layering forces the films to be an integral number of smectic layers thick, quantizing their thickness in layer units and forcing a film of a particular number of layers to be physically homogeneous with respect to its layer structure over its entire area. Optical reflectivity enables the precise determination of the number of layers. These ultrathin freely suspended liquid crystal films are structures of fundamental interest in condensed matter and fluid physics. They are the thinnest known stable condensed phase fluid structures and have the largest surface-to-volume ratio of any stable fluid preparation, making them ideal for the study of the effects of reduced dimensionality on phase behavior and on fluctuation and interface phenomena. Their low vapor pressure and quantized thickness enable the effective use of microgravity to extend the study of basic capillary phenomena to ultrathin fluid films. Freely suspended films have been a wellspring of new liquid crystal physics. They have been used to provide unique experimental conditions for the study of condensed phase transitions in two dimensions. They are the only system in which the hexatic has been unambiguously identified as a phase of matter, and the only physical system in which fluctuations of a 2D XY system and Kosterlitz Thouless phase transition has been observed and 2D XY quasi long range order verified. Smectic films have enabled the precise determination of smectic layer electron density and positional fluctuation profile and have been used to show that the interlayer interactions in anti-ferroelectric tilted smectics do not extend significantly beyond nearest neighbors. The interactions which are operative in liquid crystals are generally weak in comparison to those in crystalline phases, leading to the facile manipulation of the order in liquid crystals by external agents such as applied fields and surfaces. Effects arising from weak ordering are significantly enhanced in ultrathin free films and filaments wherein the intermolecular coupling is effectively reduced by loss of neighbors. Over the past four years this research, which we now detail, has produced a host of exciting new discoveries and unexpected results, maintaining the position of the study of freely suspended liquid crystal structures as one of most exciting and fruitful areas of complex fluid physics. In addition, several potentially interesting microgravity free film experiments have been identified.

Clark, Noel A.↗
NASA NTRS2004

Structure and Dynamics of Freely Suspended Liquid Crystals

Smectic liquid crystals are phases of rod shaped molecules organized into one dimensionally (1 D) periodic arrays of layers, each layer being between one and two molecular lengths thick. In the least ordered smectic phases, the smectics A and C, each layer is a two dimensional (2D) liquid. Additionally there are a variety of more ordered smectic phases having hexatic short range translational order or 2D crystalline or quasi long range translational order within the layers. The inherent fluid-layer structure and low vapor pressure of smectic liquid crystals enables the long term stabilization of freely suspended, single component, layered fluid films as thin as 30A, a single molecular layer. The layering forces the films to be an integral number of smectic layers thick, quantizing their thickness in layer units and forcing a film of a particular number of layers to be physically homogeneous with respect to its layer structure over its entire area. Optical reflectivity enables the precise determination of the number of layers. These ultrathin freely suspended liquid crystal films are structures of fundamental interest in condensed matter and fluid physics. They are the thinnest known stable fluid structures and have the largest surface-to-volume ratio of any stable fluid preparation, making them ideal for the study of the effects of reduced dimensionality on phase behavior and on fluctuation and interface phenomena. Their low vapor pressure and quantized thickness enable the effective use of microgravity to extend the study of basic capillary phenomena to ultrathin fluid films. Freely suspended films have been a wellspring of new LC physics. They have been used to provide unique experimental conditions for the study of condensed phase transitions in two dimensions. They are the only system in which the hexatic has been unambiguously identified as a phase of matter, and the only physical system in which fluctuations of a 2D XY system and Kosterlitz Thouless phase transition has been observed and 2D XY quasi long range order verified. Smectic films have enabled the precise determination of smectic layer electron density and positional fluctuation profiles and have been used to show that the interlayer interactions in antiferroelectric tilted smectics do not extend significantly beyond nearest neighbors. Freely suspended films played a pivotal role in the recent discovery of macroscopic chiral-polar ordering in fluids of achiral molecules. The interactions which are operative in liquid crystals are generally weak in comparison to those in crystalline phases, leading to the facile manipulation of the order in liquid crystals by external agents such as applied fields and surfaces. Effects arising from weak ordering are significantly enhanced in ultrathin free films and filaments, in which the intermolecular coupling is effectively further reduced by loss of neighbors. Over the past four years this research, which we now detail, has produced a host of exciting new discoveries and unexpected results, maintaining the study of freely suspended liquid crystal structures as one of most exciting and fruitful areas of complex fluid physics. In addition, a class of experiments on the behavior of 1D interfaces in 2D films have been pursued with results that point to potentially quite interesting effects in microgravity.

Clark, Noel A.↗
DOE OSTI2020

Broadening the Gas Separation Utility of Monolayer Nanoporous Graphene Membranes by an Ionic Liquid Gating

Ultrathin two-dimensional (2D) monolayer atomic crystal materials offer great potential for extending the field of novel separation technology due to their infinitesimal thickness and mechanical strength. One difficult and ongoing challenge is to perforate the 2D monolayer material with subnanometer pores with atomic precision for sieving similarly sized molecules. Here, we demonstrate the exceptional separation performance of ionic liquid (IL)/graphene hybrid membranes for challenging separation of CO 2 and N 2 . Notably, the ultrathin ILs afford dynamic tuning of the size and chemical affinity of nanopores while preserving the high permeance of the monolayer nanoporous graphene membranes. The hybrid membrane yields a high CO 2 permeance of 4000 GPU and an outstanding CO 2 /N 2 selectivity up to 32. Finally, this rational hybrid design provides a universal direction for broadening gas separation capability of atomically thin nanoporous membranes.

77 NANOSCIENCE AND NANOTECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2020

Freestanding Photoresist Film: A Versatile Template for Three-Dimensional Micro- and Nanofabrication

Ultrathin freestanding films with well-defined micro/nanostructures and robust mechanical properties are applied in many engineering applications including microelectronics, optics, filtration and separation, biomedical engineering, and nanotechnology. Although considerable efforts have been made toward the fabrication of freestanding thin films, it is still a significant challenge to develop a simple and reliable process for producing freestanding films with ultrathin thickness, well-regulated micro/nanopatterns, robust mechanical properties, macroscopic coverage area, and multi-layered composite structures. In this work, a significant advancement is reported in this regard. This study shows a new sacrificial-layer-free (SLF) lifting-off process, integrated with conventional micro- and nanolithography, enabling the release of micro- and nanopatterned photoresist (PR) films from the supporting substrate with unprecedented pattern coverage and structure characteristics. The freestanding PR film is resilient, can withstand significant bending and deformation, and is sufficiently flexible to be transferred onto substrates with 3D topography as a conformal soft stencil for further technological processing and applications. Moreover, the SLF lifting-off process provides a simple approach to prepare single-layered and multi-layered freestanding composite films. The results suggest that the novel SLF lifting-off process can significantly extend the capability of 3D micro-/nanofabrication.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Interlayer Exciton Polarons in Mesoscopic V 2 O 5 for Broadband Optoelectronic Synapses

Persistent photoconductivity and optoelectronic synaptic behavior are demonstrated in solution-processed mesoscopic α-phase vanadium pentoxide (V 2 O 5 ) thin films. First-principles simulations coupled with the two-site Holstein polaron hopping model show that vacancies at the terminal oxygen position lead to long recombination times because photoexcited electrons and holes reside on different layers separated by the van der Waals gap, forming a weakly coupled interlayer exciton polaron. Mid-gap polaronic states also significantly broaden the photoresponse of the films to span across visible and infrared wavelengths. By controlling the amplitude/intensity, duration, and/or number of optical pulses, tunable optoelectronic memory functions, such as short-term and long-term plasticity, are experimentally established in V 2 O 5 -based optoelectronic synapses. Furthermore, device fabrication was extended to mechanically flexible ultrathin glass substrates. Flexible optoelectronic synapses maintained high performance after 150 bending cycles.

Phan, Thanh Luan [National Renewable Energy Labora↗
DOE OSTI2022

Cold-Starting All-Solid-State Batteries from Room Temperature by Thermally Modulated Current Collector in Sub-Minute

All-solid-state batteries (ASSBs) show great potential as high-energy and high-power energy storage devices but their attainable energy/power density at room temperature is severely reduced because of the sluggish kinetics of lithium-ion transport. Here we first reported a thermally modulated current collector (TMCC), which can rapidly cold-start ASSBs from room temperature to operating temperatures (70–90 °C) in less than one minute, and simultaneously enhance the transient peak power density by 15-fold compared to one without heating. This TMCC is prepared by integrating a uniform, ultrathin (~200 nm) nickel layer as a thermal modulator within an ultralight polymer-based current collector. By isolating the thermal modulator from the ion/electron pathway of ASSBs, it can provide fast, stable heat control yet does not interfere with regular battery operation. Moreover, this ultrathin (13.2 μm) TMCC effectively shortens the heat transfer pathway, minimizes heat losses, and mitigates the formation of local hot spots. The simulated heating energy consumption can be as low as ~3.94% of total battery energy. This TMCC design with good tunability opens new frontiers towards smart energy storage devices in the future from the current collector perspective.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2022

All‐Printed Ultrahigh‐Responsivity MoS 2 Nanosheet Photodetectors Enabled by Megasonic Exfoliation

Abstract Printed 2D materials, derived from solution‐processed inks, offer scalable and cost‐effective routes to mechanically flexible optoelectronics. With micrometer‐scale control and broad processing latitude, aerosol‐jet printing (AJP) is of particular interest for all‐printed circuits and systems. Here, AJP is utilized to achieve ultrahigh‐responsivity photodetectors consisting of well‐aligned, percolating networks of semiconducting MoS 2 nanosheets and graphene electrodes on flexible polyimide substrates. Ultrathin (≈1.2 nm thick) and high‐aspect‐ratio (≈1 μm lateral size) MoS 2 nanosheets are obtained by electrochemical intercalation followed by megasonic atomization during AJP, which not only aerosolizes the inks but also further exfoliates the nanosheets. The incorporation of the high‐boiling‐point solvent terpineol into the MoS 2 ink is critical for achieving a highly aligned and flat thin‐film morphology following AJP as confirmed by grazing‐incidence wide‐angle X‐ray scattering and atomic force microscopy. Following AJP, curing is achieved with photonic annealing, which yields quasi‐ohmic contacts and photoactive channels with responsivities exceeding 10 3 A W −1 that outperform previously reported all‐printed visible‐light photodetectors by over three orders of magnitude. Megasonic exfoliation coupled with properly designed AJP ink formulations enables the superlative optoelectronic properties of ultrathin MoS 2 nanosheets to be preserved and exploited for the scalable additive manufacturing of mechanically flexible optoelectronics.

2D materials↗
DOE OSTI2020

Understanding the Reactivity of a Thin Li 1.5 Al 0.5 Ge 1.5 (PO 4 ) 3 Solid–State Electrolyte toward Metallic Lithium Anode

The thickness of solid-state electrolytes (SSEs) significantly affects the energy density and safety performance of all-solid-state lithium batteries. However, a sufficient understanding of the reactivity toward lithium metal of ultrathin SSEs (<100 μm) based on NASICON remains lacking. Herein, for the first time, a self-standing and ultrathin (70 μm) NASICON-type Li 1.5 Al 0.5 Ge 1.5 (PO 4 ) 3 (LAGP) electrolyte via a scalable solution process is developed, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy reveals that changes in LAGP at the metastable Li-LAGP interface during battery operation is temperature dependent. Severe germanium reduction and decrease in LAGP particle size are detected at the Li-LAGP interface at elevated temperature. As a result, oriented plating of lithium metal on its preferred (110) face occurs during in situ X-ray diffraction cycling.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Binder Effects on Processing, Mechanical Properties, and Performance of Thin Sulfide Solid‐State Electrolytes

All‐solid‐state batteries (ASSBs) offer enhanced safety and energy density compared to conventional lithium‐ion batteries by replacing flammable liquid electrolytes with solid‐state electrolytes (SSEs). Among SSEs, sulfide‐based electrolytes exhibit high ionic conductivity and mechanical deformability, making them promising candidates for next‐generation energy storage. However, their practical implementation is hindered by interfacial instability, mechanical brittleness, and challenges in fabricating ultrathin electrolyte membranes (<30 μm) with robust mechanical integrity. Here, this study systematically examines the influence of polymeric binders—polyisobutylene, hydrogenated nitrile butadiene rubber, and styrene–ethylene–butylene–styrene (SEBS)—on the structural, mechanical, and electrochemical performance of thin sulfide SSE membranes. Key findings reveal that SEBS enables the fabrication of ultrathin, uniform membranes, while binder elasticity significantly affects structural stability during cycling. Operando stack pressure measurements indicate that binder properties directly influence adhesion force for LPSCl particles, influencing their stabilizing cycling period. These results underscore the critical role of polymer binders beyond mechanical reinforcement, positioning them as essential design variables in sulfide SSE engineering. By linking binder chemistry to processability and electrochemical performance, this study provides insights into optimizing sulfide SSEs, advancing their commercial viability in ASSBs.

argyrodite sulfide electrolyte↗
DOE OSTI2022

Hydrogen Storage in Partially Exfoliated Magnesium Diboride Multilayers

Metal boride nanostructures have shown significant promise for hydrogen storage applications. However, the synthesis of nanoscale metal boride particles is challenging because of their high surface energy, strong inter- and intraplanar bonding, and difficult-to-control surface termination. Here, it is demonstrated that mechanochemical exfoliation of magnesium diboride in zirconia produces 3-4 nm ultrathin MgB 2 nanosheets (multilayers) in high yield. High-pressure hydrogenation of these multilayers at 70 MPa and 330 °C followed by dehydrogenation at 390 °C reveals a hydrogen capacity of 5.1 wt%, which is ≈50 times larger than the capacity of bulk MgB 2 under the same conditions. This enhancement is attributed to the creation of defective sites by ball-milling and incomplete Mg surface coverage in MgB 2 multilayers, which disrupts the stable boron-boron ring structure. The density functional theory calculations indicate that the balance of Mg on the MgB 2 nanosheet surface changes as the material hydrogenates, as it is energetically favorable to trade a small number of Mg vacancies in Mg(BH 4 ) 2 for greater Mg coverage on the MgB 2 surface. To conclude, the exfoliation and creation of ultrathin layers is a promising new direction for 2D metal boride/borohydride research with the potential to achieve high-capacity reversible hydrogen storage at more moderate pressures and temperatures.

08 HYDROGEN↗
DOE OSTI2024

Plasmonic Diamond Membranes for Ultrafast Silicon Vacancy Emission

Silicon vacancy centers (SiVs) in diamond have emerged as a promising platform for quantum sciences due to their excellent photostability, minimal spectral diffusion, and substantial zero-phonon line emission. However, enhancing their slow nanosecond excited-state lifetime by coupling to optical cavities remains an outstanding challenge, as current demonstrations are limited to ~10-fold. Here, we couple negatively charged SiVs to sub-diffraction-limited plasmonic cavities and achieve an instrument-limited ≤8 ps lifetime, corresponding to a 135-fold spontaneous emission rate enhancement and a 19-fold photoluminescence enhancement. Nanoparticles are printed on ultrathin diamond membranes on gold films which create arrays of plasmonic nanogap cavities with ultrasmall volumes. SiVs implanted at 5 and 10 nm depths are examined to elucidate surface effects on their lifetime and brightness. The interplay between cavity, implantation depth, and ultrathin diamond membranes provides insights into generating ultrafast, bright SiV emission for next-generation diamond devices.

Purcell enhancement↗
DOE OSTI2022

Removal of Surface Carbonate from Lithium-Ion Battery Cathode Materials via Vapor-Phase Fluorination

Herein, ultrathin metal-fluoride barrier coatings on the surface of lithium-ion battery (LIB) cathodes can improve cycling stability and prevent corrosion by acidic byproducts in the electrolyte. Atomic layer deposition (ALD) is an effective method to deposit ultrathin metal fluoride coatings on LIB cathodes. Although numerous studies have demonstrated the benefit of ALD metal fluoride coatings to LIB performance, comparatively few works have examined the effect of individual ALD precursors on the cathode surface. This paper uses X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) measurements to elucidate the surface chemical changes on LIB cathode material surfaces upon exposure to the ALD metal fluoride precursor, hydrogen fluorine pyridine (HFPy). We found a decrease in surface carbonate and an increase in surface fluoride after HFPy exposure suggesting the conversion of lithium carbonate (Li 2 CO 3 ) to lithium fluoride (LiF). This conversion is desirable given that Li 2 CO 3 degrades LIB performance, whereas LiF provides an excellent physio-chemical barrier against chemical attack during cycling. Scanning transmission electron microscopy, X-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy, and XPS measurements following HFPy exposure to Li 2 CO 3 powder revealed the formation of a conformal LiF shell around the Li 2 CO 3 particles. Finally, we confirmed the complete conversion of similar to 7 nm ALD Li 2 CO 3 films on silicon from HFPy exposure using XPS and spectroscopic ellipsometry. The elimination of problematic Li 2 CO 3 from LIB cathode surfaces and conversion into a protective LiF coating via a single precursor vapor treatment may provide a cost-effective method for enhancing LIB performance.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Small Molecule Inhibitor-Modulated Al 2 O 3 Atomic Layer Deposition on Monolayer MoS 2 for Controlled Nucleation

The integration of ultrathin dielectrics on two-dimensional (2D) semiconductors is essential for advancing beyond-Si electronics. However, the intrinsic inertness of van der Waals 2D basal planes remains a primary bottleneck to achieving uniform dielectric nucleation and growth. Here, in this study, we introduce a small molecule inhibitor (SMI)-modulated thermal atomic layer deposition (ALD) strategy, exemplified by aluminum oxide (Al 2 O 3 ) ALD on monolayer molybdenum disulfide (1L MoS 2 ) with acetic acid (HAc) SMI. The ABC-type sequence comprises HAc inhibitor (A), trimethylaluminum (TMA) precursor (B), and deionized H 2 O coreactant (C). In situ quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) studies reveal robust HAc adsorption on Al 2 O 3 and suppression of subsequent oxide growth on HAc-passivated surfaces. When applied to 1L MoS 2 , this inhibitory pathway enables HAc to selectively passivate nascent Al 2 O 3 nuclei formed on the MoS 2 surface, limiting their three-dimensional (3D) island coarsening and redirecting precursor adsorption toward the uncovered basal plane. Consequently, nearly continuous ultrathin (∼1.5 nm) Al 2 O 3 films are achieved on 1L MoS 2 with markedly improved uniformity compared to standard Al 2 O 3 ALD using TMA and H 2 O, as validated by atomic force microscopy (AFM), cross-sectional scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM), and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS). Density functional theory (DFT) calculations further provide atomistic insight into HAc-modulated Al 2 O 3 nucleation, corroborating the energetic preference of HAc for Al 2 O 3 over MoS 2 and attenuated TMA adsorption on HAc-passivated surfaces. Spatially resolved Raman spectroscopy also confirms that the HAc-modulated process preserves the structural integrity of 1L MoS 2 , with only minimal strain and doping perturbations observed after dielectric deposition. This SMI-modulated approach offers a broadly applicable framework for controlling ALD nucleation across various inhibitors, ALD chemistries, and 2D materials, opening opportunities for reliable dielectric integration in next-generation nanoelectronics.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Synergistically Chemical and Thermal Coupling between Graphene Oxide and Graphene Fluoride for Enhancing Aluminum Combustion

Metal combustion reaction is highly exothermic and is used in energetic applications, such as propulsion, pyrotechnics, powering micro- and nano-devices, and nanomaterials synthesis. Aluminum (Al) is attracting great interest in those applications because of its high energy density, earth abundance, and low toxicity. Nevertheless, Al combustion is hard to initiate and progresses slowly and incompletely. On the other hand, ultrathin carbon nanomaterials, such as graphene, graphene oxide (GO), and graphene fluoride (GF), can also undergo exothermic reactions. Herein, we demonstrate that the mixture of GO and GF significantly improves the performance of Al combustion as interactions between GO and GF provide heat and radicals to accelerate Al oxidation. Overall, our experiments and reactive molecular dynamics simulation reveal that GO and GF have strong chemical and thermal couplings through radical reactions and heat released from their oxidation reactions. GO facilitates the dissociation of GF, and GF accelerates the disproportionation and oxidation of GO. When the mixture of GO and GF is added to micron-sized Al particles, their synergistic couplings generate reactive oxidative species, such as CF x and CF x O y , and heat, which greatly accelerates Al combustion. This work demonstrates a new area of using synergistic couplings between ultrathin carbon nanomaterials to accelerate metal combustion and potentially oxidation reactions of other materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

Atomic Layer Deposition with TiO2 for Enhanced Reactivity and Stability of Aromatic Hydrogenation Catalysts

Hydrogenation of aromatic molecules in fossil- and bio-derived fuels is essential for decreasing emissions of harmful combustion products and addressing growing concerns around urban air pollution. In this work, we used atomic layer deposition to significantly enhance the hydrogenation performance of a conventional supported Pd catalyst by applying an ultrathin coating of TiO2 in a scalable powder coating process. The TiO2-coated catalyst showed substantial gains in the conversion of multiple aromatic molecules, including a 5-fold improvement in turnover frequency versus the uncoated catalyst in the hydrogenation of naphthalene. This activity enhancement was maintained upon scaling the coating synthesis process from 3 to 100 g. Based on the results from Xray photoelectron spectroscopy, X-ray absorption spectroscopy, and computational modeling, the activity enhancement was attributed to ensemble effects resulting from partial TiO2 coverage of the Pd surface rather than fundamental changes to the Pd electronic structure. Additional durability testing confirmed that the TiO2 coating improved the thermal and hydrothermal stability of the catalyst as well as tolerance toward sulfur impurities in the reactant stream. Using an economic model of an industrial deep hydrogenation process, we found that an increase in catalyst activity or lifetime of 2× would justify even a relatively high estimate for the cost of TiO2 atomic layer deposition coatings at scale

atomic layer↗