Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “battery failure”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 289 records · Page 16

Unravelling electro-chemo-mechanical interplay in layered oxide cathode degradation in solid-state batteries

Solid-state batteries (SSBs) hold notable promise for advancing energy storage technologies. However, their commercial viability is limited by the poor cycle stability and complex degradation mechanism. This study underscores the pivotal role of electro-chemo-mechanical interactions in driving the failure of SSBs. Leveraging advanced x-ray imaging and spectroscopy techniques, we analyzed LiNi 0.8 Mn 0.1 Co 0.1 O 2 (NMC811) cathodes from cycled Li x In||Li 6 PS 5 Cl (LPSC)||NMC811 SSBs, uncovering the interplay between microstructure, chemical heterogeneity, mechanical characteristics, and electrochemical performance. Our results show that revealing electro-chemo-mechanical interactions is essential to develop strategies to suppress the degradation of SSBs. Particularly, we revisit a LiNbO 3 (LNO) coating layer to mitigate electrochemical degradation. The LNO@NMC811 cathode retains 116 milliampere-hours per gram after 200 cycles, showing excellent stability, while the uncoated NMC811 cathode keeps degrading over time, with suppressed chemical heterogeneity and mechanical failure. This work highlights the importance of synergizing advanced material design with coating techniques, ensuring uniform lithium flux and improving mechanical properties to achieve stable, high-performance SSBs.

Zheng, Xueli [SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory↗

Effect of H + Exchange and Surface Impurities on Bulk and Interfacial Electrochemistry of Garnet Solid Electrolytes

Contact loss and current constriction pose significant challenges at the Li metal interface of solid-state batteries. For garnet-structured Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 (LLZO), these effects are amplified by Li + /H + exchange and surface contamination reactions, which lead to conductivity losses and poor Li wetting. In this study, we utilize a variety of surface treatment processes across 37 cells to selectively induce proton exchange and contamination reactions in LLZO. The resulting bulk and surface chemistry is systematically characterized and correlated to changes in electrochemical properties. Additionally, we combine impedance analysis and finite element method modeling to deconvolute sources of impedance contributions at the Li metal interface. Specifically, we show that constriction impedance at the Li metal interface arises not solely from voids, but also from ionically-resistive surface contaminants. Further, these findings emphasize the connection between ionic conductivity and constriction, demonstrating that micron-scale ionically-resistive components increase constriction even with identical contact geometries. Finally, we leverage our comprehensive dataset to highlight unstable overpotential growth as a failure mechanism, additionally showing that the phase of a cell’s impedance is a sensitive indicator for the onset of interfacial instability. Overall, this study clarifies the impacts of proton exchange and surface contamination on electrochemical properties at the Li|solid electrolyte interface and elucidates insights that are generalizable to other solid-state battery systems.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Highly Reversible Sodium Metal Battery Anodes via Alloying Heterointerfaces

As a promising pathway toward low-cost, long-duration energy storage, rechargeable sodium batteries are of increasing interest. Batteries that incorporate metallic sodium as anode promise a high theoretical specific capacity of 1166 mAh g –1 , and low reduction potential of –2.71 V. The high reactivity and poor electrochemical reversibility of sodium anodes render sodium metal anode (SMA) cells among the most challenging for practical implementation. Here, the failure mechanisms of Na anodes are investigated and the authors report that loss of morphological control is not the fundamental cause of failure. Rather, it is the inherently poor anchoring/root structure of electrodeposited Na to the electrode substrate that leads to poor reversibility and cell failure. Poorly anchored Na deposits are prone to break away from the current collector, producing orphaning and poor anode utilization. Thin metallic coatings in a range of chemistries are proposed and evaluated as SMA substrates. Based on thermodynamic and ion transport considerations, such substrates undergo reversible alloying reactions with Na and are hypothesized to promote good root growth—regardless of the morphology. Among the various options, Au stands out for its ability to support long Na anode lifetime and high reversibility (Coulombic Efficiency > 98%), for coating thicknesses in the range of 10–1000 nm. Finally, as a first step toward evaluating practical utility of the anodes, their performance in Na||SPAN cells with N:P ratio close to 1:1 is evaluated.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Electrochemically Stable High Energy Density Lithium-Sulfur Batteries

Lithium-Sulfur batteries (LSB) have emerged as one of the strong contenders for high energy density rechargeable batteries in the Li-ion battery domain. The LSB system is considered as the most promising to achieve the next milestone in energy density of 500 Wh/kg. However, the LSB system is plagued with problems of polysulfide formation which are soluble in the organic electrolyte leading to loss in capacity and eventual cell failure. The problem is further compounded by dendrite formation on the Li anode during electrochemical cycling leading to puncturing of the separator causing eventual short-circuiting of the cell and consequent heat generation resulting in major safety hazards of flammability of the organic liquid electrolyte and impending explosion. This chapter describes various approaches developed to combat both cathode and anode issues. These involve synthesis and characterization of complex framework materials (CFMs) for confining the polysulfides and sulfur in the LSB cathodes. The CFMs include a CFM host and a coating applied to the CFM host, which includes one or more form of an electronic conductor, a lithium-ion conductor and a functional electrocatalyst for electrocatalytically converting the soluble polysulfides to Li 2 S. Further, sulfur is infiltrated into the CFM host creating a sulfur-carbon linkage serving as effective anchors for trapping the ensuing polysulfides. The systems have been tested in coin cells and pouch cells with metallic Li anodes under lean electrolyte conditions of 3-4 μl/mg of electrolyte (E) to sulfur (S) ratios showing promise and feasibility. New emergent dendrite-free alloys have also been identified to test against pure Li and CFM cathodes in coin cell and pouch cell configurations under lean electrolyte conditions. Results of these studies are described and discussed with thoughts on future directions.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

The Dominant Effect of Electrolyte Concentration on Rechargeability of γ -MnO 2 Cathodes in Alkaline Batteries

Achieving high cycle life rechargeableγ-MnO 2 cathodes in alkaline batteries face many challenges. Chief among these is the inability of theγ-MnO 2 polymorph to retain its structural integrity when cycled to high utilization of its theoretical capacity ∼300 mAh g −1 . In this paper, we investigate the root cause of failure of MnO 2 cathodes under deep cycling in the one-electron discharge range and establish a strong link between capacity fade and the amount of birnessite formed. We uncover the underlying cause of failure by cycling industrial scaleγ-MnO 2 cathodes at various levels of theoretical capacity utilization (100%, 50%, and 30%) and in different KOH concentrations (37, 25, and 10 wt%). To determine materials evolution the cycled cathodes were dissected, characterized and analyzed using SEM, XRD, FIB/SEM, EIS, and XPS. Based on our findings, we propose that one major cause of failure of MnO 2 cathodes stems from the solubility of Mn +3 formed during discharge which effectively results in destruction of theγ-MnO 2 phase and amorphization of the cathode. The results show that the bulk of theγ-MnO 2 phase is preserved only in ∼10 wt% KOH, which indicates the attractive range of KOH concentration for cycling of rechargeableγ-MnO 2 cathodes.

Electrochemistry↗

Atomic- and Molecular-Scale Interphase Engineering for High-Performance Solid-State Batteries

Solid-state batteries (SSBs) promise a decisive advance beyond conventional Li-ion systems, yet their development remains constrained by persistent solid–solid interfacial instabilities that degrade performance and durability. Interfaces between solid electrolytes and both cathodes and Li metal often exhibit poor wettability, limited physical contact, and high charge–transfer resistance, leading to chemical decomposition, mechanical failure, and impedance growth. Overcoming these limitations requires interphase engineering with atomic-scale precision—capabilities that conventional coating methods cannot reliably deliver. Atomic layer deposition (ALD) and molecular layer deposition (MLD) uniquely meet this need by enabling ultrathin, conformal, and composition-tunable films that stabilize reactive surfaces, suppress parasitic reactions, and regulate Li-metal morphology. Importantly, this Perspective highlights ALD/MLD systems that have already demonstrated effectiveness in liquid-electrolyte cells and discusses how these validated strategies can be deliberately translated to solid-state architectures. By grounding future directions in experimentally proven concepts rather than speculative hypotheses, we outline how atomic- and molecular-scale design principles can accelerate the development of robust, high-performance SSB technologies.

atomic and molecular layer deposition↗

Concentration‐dependent Cycling of Phenothiazine‐based Electrolytes in Nonaqueous Redox Flow Cells

Increasing redox-active species concentrations can improve viability for organic redox flow batteries by enabling higher energy densities, but the required concentrated solutions can become viscous and less conductive, leading to inefficient electrochemical cycling and low material utilization at higher current densities. To better understand these tradeoffs in a model system, we study a highly soluble and stable redox-active couple, N-(2-(2-methoxyethoxy)ethyl)phenothiazine (MEEPT), and its bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide radical cation salt (MEEPT-TFSI). We measure the physicochemical properties of electrolytes containing 0.2–1 M active species and connect these to symmetric cell cycling behavior, achieving robust cycling performance. Specifically, for a 1 M electrolyte concentration, we demonstrate 94% materials utilization, 89% capacity retention, and 99.8% average coulombic efficiency over 435 h (100 full cycles). This demonstration helps to establish potential for high-performing, concentrated nonaqueous electrolytes and highlights possible failure modes in such systems.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Mapping of fracture and ionic conductivity changes in ion implanted solid electrolytes: Insights from molecular dynamics

Ion implantation emerges as a promising technique to address the persistent challenge of lithium (Li) filament growth in solid-state electrolytes as it can induce compressive stresses inhibiting crack growth and deflect dendrites, de facto mitigating early electrolyte failure. In this study, we examine the potential paradox of ion implantation: while aiming to enhance electrolyte performance, the radiation damage associated with implantation might inadvertently compromise both the ionic conductivity and the intrinsic fracture toughness of the material, rendering the material unsuitable for battery applications. Specifically, we employed molecular dynamics simulations to examine the scope of the downsides of ion implantation, specifically: (i) reduced ionic conductivity (due to radiation-induced amorphization) and (ii) mechanical stability (due to radiation-induced embrittlement) in ion-implanted Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 (LLZO) solid-state electrolytes. We explore how radiation damage impacts LLZO’s crystalline structure, Li-ion diffusion, and fracture properties at various temperatures and radiation damage levels. The study aims to provide insights into the competing effects of ion implantation and suggest potential engineering strategies for developing more robust solid-state electrolytes with improved conductivity and dendrite resistance.

Conductivity↗

Fluoropolymer Aging Phenomena

This project aims to investigate structural and morphological changes in fluoropolymers induced by both processing and aging phenomena such as heat, time, and irradiation. Fluoropolymers are an important class of thermoplastics that are broadly used in industry as o-rings and seals when chemical resistance and thermal performance are important. They are also often used in thin film geometries as binders in batteries, insulation layers, water barriers, and anti-fouling coatings. For all of these applications, mechanical integrity and aging are important aspects of their use. Changes in the crystalline morphology are known to impact the mechanical properties of the polymer and can lead to failure. The broad goals of this project are to correlate compositional changes, morphological changes, and mechanical changes. report focuses on the morphological changes that are correlated with nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), calorimetry and mechanical testing. We plan to compare structure and morphology measurements across complementary bulk and surface techniques. We use in situ atomic force microscopy (AFM) to measure domain shape and crystallization kinetics; in situ NMR to measure crystalline composition; and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) to measure melting temperatures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Fast-Charging Aging Considerations: Incorporation and Alignment of Cell Design and Material Degradation Pathways

Fast charging of batteries for electric vehicles is seen as one of the most direct ways to enhance adoption. Currently, fast charging is limited by increased cell aging, which is primarily driven by Li plating and degradation of cathode materials. Here, using combined sets of experimental and computational analysis and a suite of different charge protocols, we begin to examine the interplay between failure mode, cell designs, and ultimately aging mechanisms. Slight variation in cell design and the subsequent impacts that charge protocols have on aging can create distinct cell-to-cell variation. As little as 2% difference in porosity change at the cell negative electrode during cycling due to early Li metal plating has been found to alter the aging pathway and either accelerate or inhibit the loss due to Li plating.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

On the dynamics of the fluoroethylene carbonate generated solid electrolyte interphase on silicon anodes during calendar life aging

Here, the widespread use of silicon (Si)-rich anodes in lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) is impeded by an unstable solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) incurring insufficient cell life. Fluoroethylene carbonate (FEC) additive in the electrolyte significantly improves cycle life. However, the gains on calendar life remain unclear; the SEI structure still undergoes detrimental alterations at rest. Thus, elucidating the SEI dynamics during calendar aging is critical to mitigating time-dependent capacity degradation. ATR-FTIR, XPS, and ToF-SIMS are used herein to investigate the SEI structure before and after calendar aging. Si cycled without FEC exhibits no notable SEI chemistry changes Pre- and Post-aging, leaving poor passivation as the main failure pathway. Conversely, the FEC-SEI starts as short oligomeric species from FEC/EC electroreduction prior to aging; after calendar aging, polymerized carbonates become consistently more prominent. Unexpectedly, the deposition of self-polymerized FEC species results from time exposure to the delithiated Si specifically as opposed to the lithiated surface. This unexpected finding is supported by another recent Si calendar-aging research, which albeit not investigating FEC, finds global failure of the SEI upon delithiation resulting in ∼247 fold more reactive surface compared to the lithiated.

Batteries↗

Improved Stability and Cyclability of Ceramic Solid Electrolyte by Coating Polymer

Rechargeable all-solid-state lithium (Li) metal batteries show better safety and energy density compared to commercial Li-ion batteries using liquid electrolyte. As the key component of Li metal batteries, ceramic solid-state electrolyte has attracted great interest because of its high ion conductivity and great potential in interfacing with Li metal. Ceramic electrolyte has a more stable interface with Li metal than liquid electrolyte, but chemical reaction and Li dendrite growth at the electrolyte/Li interface are still significant, which causes device degradation and failure by cycling of Li plating and stripping. Unlike ceramic electrolyte, polymer electrolyte has a relatively stable interface with Li metal and better mechanical flexibility. Therefore, we introduced a polymer electrolyte coating to protect the ceramic electrolyte from direct contact with Li metal. The galvanotactic cycling Li plating/striping data on the devices with (without) the coating illustrates increased (decreased) overall conductivity and cyclability of the test cell by the cycling. Nanometer-scale ionic-transport imaging, based on atomic force microscopy, shows that cycling degrades the ceramic-only electrolyte by partially blocking ionic transport in areas; in contrast, cycling on the polymer-coated electrolyte improves ionic conductivity. Compared with the ceramic-only electrolyte, this novel polymer electrolyte coating on ceramic electrolyte shows less degradation when in contact with Li metal.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Balancing Interfacial Reactions to Achieve Long Cycle Life in High Energy Lithium Metal Batteries

Rechargeable lithium (Li) metal batteries have attracted wide attentions as the next generation energy storage technologies. However, simultaneously achieving high cell-level energy density and long cycle life in realistic batteries is still a great challenge. Here we investigate the cell degradation mechanisms of Li||LiNi0.6Mn0.2Co0.2O2 pouch cells using different, but representative cell configurations to understand the fundamental linkage among Li thickness, electrolyte depletion and the structure evolution of solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) layers. Different cell failure modes were discovered when tuning the anode to cathode capacity (N/P) ratio in compatible electrolyte. With a thick-Li anode (N/P ratio = 2.5), initial stable cycling is obtained because of the abundant Li supply from the anode together with an artificially inflated high Coulombic Efficiency, followed by a premature sudden cell death appears due to the enrichment of “ineffective SEI” which does not participate in the electrochemical reactions but keep increasing cell impedance. The anode-free cell (N/P 0:1) displays a steady capacity decay because cathode Li loss dominates from the beginning to the end of cell cycle life. An optimized thin-Li (N/P 1:1) well balances the Li consumption rate with the impedance buildup by minimizing the growth of ineffective SEI layer, thus decelerates cell polarization increasing and extends cycling. Contrary to conventional wisdoms, long cycle life is observed by using ultra thin-Li (20 µm) in balanced cells. A prototype 350 Wh kg-1 pouch cell (2.0 Ah) achieves over 600 long stable cycles with 76% capacity retention without sudden cell death.

Niu, Chaojiang↗

Quantifying Thermal Output of Energetic Materials (LDRD Final Report)

We present the results of an LDRD project, funded by the Nuclear Deterrence IA, to develop capabilities for quantitative assessment of pyrotechnic thermal output. The thermal battery igniter is used as an exemplar system. Experimental methodologies for thermal output evaluation are demonstrated here, which can help designers and engineers better specify pyrotechnic components , provide thermal output guidelines for new formulations, and generate new metrics for assessing component performance and margin given a known failure condition. A heat-transfer analysis confirms that the dominant mode of energy transfer from the pyrotechnic output plume to the heat pellet is conduction via deposition of hot titanium particles. A simple lumped-parameter model of titanium particle heat transfer and a detailed multi-phase model of deposition heat transfer are discussed. Pyrotechnic function, as defined by "go/no-go" standoff testing of a heat pellet, is correlated with experimentally measured igniter plume temperature, titanium metal particle temperature, and energy deposition. Three high-speed thermal diagnostics were developed for this task. A three-color imaging pyrometer, acquiring 100k images per second on three color channels, is deployed for measurement of titanium particle temperatures. Complimentary measurements of the overall igniter plume emission ("color") temperature were conducted using a transmission-grating spectrograph in line-imaging mode. Heat flux and energy deposition to a cold wall at the heat-pellet location were estimated using an eroding thermocouple probe, with a frequency response of ~5 kHz. Ultimate "go/no-go" function in the igniter/heat-pellet system was correlated with quantitative thermal metrics, in particular surface energy deposition and plume color temperature. Titanium metal-particle and plume color temperatures both experience an upper bound approximated by the 3245-K boiling point of TiO 2 . Average metal-particle temperatures remained nearly constant for all standoff distances at T = 2850 K, ± 300 K, while plume color temperature and heat flux decay with standoff—suggesting that heat-pellet failure results from a drop in metal-particle flux and not particle temperature. At 50% likelihood of heat-pellet failure, peak time-resolved plume color temperatures drop well below TiO 2 boiling to ~2000 - 2200 K, near the TiO 2 melting point. Estimates of peak heat flux decline from up to 1 GW/m 2 for near-field standoffs to below 320 MW/m 2 at 50% failure likelihood.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Probing the Thermal-Driven Structural and Chemical Degradation of Ni-Rich Layered Cathodes by Co/Mn Exchange

The intrinsic poor thermal stability of layered LiNi x Co y Mn 1-x-y O 2 (NCM) cathodes and the exothermic side reactions triggered by the associated oxygen release are the main safety threats for their large-scale implantation. In NCM family, it is widely accepted that Ni is the stability troublemaker, while Mn has long been considered as a structure stabilizer, whereas the role of Co remains elusive. Here, via Co/Mn exchange in Ni-rich LiNi 0.83 Co 0.11 Mn 0.06 O 2 cathode, we demonstrate that, the chemical and structural stability of the deep delithiated NCM cathodes are significantly affected by Co, rather than the widely reported Mn. Operando synchrotron X-ray characterization coupling with in situ mass spectrometry reveal that the Co 4+ reduces prior to the reduction of Ni 4+ , and could thus prolong the Ni migration by occupying the tetrahedra sites, and hence postpone the oxygen release and thermal failure. In contrast, the Mn itself is stable, but barely stabilizes the Ni 4+ . Our results highlight the importance of evaluating the intrinsic role of compositional tuning on Ni-rich/Co-free layered oxide cathode materials to guarantee the safe operation of high-energy Li-ion batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

SISGR: Chemomechanics of Far-From-Equilibrium Interfaces (COFFEI)

Portable, reliable, and deployable devices for energy storage and conversion require fundamental changes in design of solid-state composites comprising ceramics and metals. These materials comprise the electrodes and electrolytes of next-generation solid-oxide fuel cells and all solid-state batteries, forming solid-state functional composites. The advent of solid-state batteries – which replace liquid electrolytes with solid electrolytes capable of lithium ion transport for reliable energy storage in portable batteries – and the increased demand space for all solid-state fuel cells capable of oxygen reduction at intermediate temperatures remain important challenges for improved material stability and decreased system cost. However, little is understood about three fundamental facets of materials that enable such solid-state energy applications. First, how do such materials deform, fracture, or delaminate under operando conditions? Second, how does such mechanical deformation limit or facilitate electronic and ionic transport within and across such material interfaces? Third, how we can predictably design interface-rich composites to engineer both structural and electrochemical stability? This COFFEI Group comprised expertise from Materials Science & Engineering and Nuclear Science & Engineering to integrate unique in situ experiments, simulations, and fabricated interfaces that address these fundamental questions in solid-state interfaces of nanoscale composites that will guide solid-state electrochemistry, transport kinetics, and mechanical deformation for nonstoichiometric materials that enable such applications. In particular, we built on COFFEI’s understanding of chemomechanical coupling among defect concentrations, ionic transport, electron transport, and stored elastic energy that is particularly acute in the far-from-equilibrium conditions typical of energy device applications. By tailoring our focus to solid-state interfaces, we addressed these important issues by (a) developing and applying advanced in situ and ex situ characterization tools to characterize model materials and interfaces synthesized with molecular-level control, under both laboratory-controlled and extreme environments representative of energy device operation; and (b) employing computational modeling and simulation frameworks to predict transport mechanisms, reactivity and stability of these model materials and interfaces under significant chemical strains typical of energy device operation. Recent progress provided insights to additional materials systems and electrochemomechanical fatigue and fracture that were not fully envisioned when the program was initiated. Specifically, in the final three years of COFFEI we pursued two integrated thrusts, with complementary focus. Thrust I focused on failure-resistant electrochemomechanical composites, while Thrust II focused on strain-modulated conductivity and reactivity across interfaces. In contrast to our initial COFFEI focus, these thrusts concentrated wholly on solid-state material interfacial interactions and included greater integration of multiscale visualization including in situ electron microscopy of strained structures/interactions and mesoscale simulations. Successful development of functionally superior and long-lived battery and fuel cell systems and stress adaptable oxides requires a deeper, fundamental understanding of the coupling among the historically important subfields of solid-state electrochemistry, transport kinetics, and mechanical deformation for nonstoichiometric metal oxide electrodes. In this program, the understanding and the application of chemomechanical coupling of defect concentrations, ionic transport, electro-catalytic activity and stored elastic energy, particularly acute in the far-from-equilibrium conditions typical of energy device applications, are being refined and implications for device operation clarified, including for miniaturized solid-state batteries and fuel cells.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

High–Energy Earth–Abundant Cathodes with Enhanced Cationic/Anionic Redox for Sustainable and Long–Lasting Na–Ion Batteries

Layered iron/manganese-based oxides are a class of promising cathode materials for sustainable batteries due to their high energy densities and earth abundance. However, the stabilization of cationic and anionic redox reactions in these cathodes during cycling at high voltage remain elusive. Here, an electrochemically/thermally stable P2-Na 0.67 Fe 0.3 Mn 0.5 Mg 0.1 Ti 0.1 O 2 cathode material with zero critical elements is designed for sodium-ion batteries (NIBs) to realize a highly reversible capacity of ≈210 mAh g –1 at 20 mA g –1 and good cycling stability with a capacity retention of 74% after 300 cycles at 200 mA g –1 , even when operated with a high charge cut-off voltage of 4.5 V versus sodium metal. Combining a suite of cutting-edge characterizations and computational modeling, it is shown that Mg/Ti co-doping leads to stabilized surface/bulk structure at high voltage and high temperature, and more importantly, enhances cationic/anionic redox reaction reversibility over extended cycles with the suppression of other undesired oxygen activities. This work fundamentally deepens the failure mechanism of Fe/Mn-based layered cathodes and highlights the importance of dopant engineering to achieve high-energy and earth-abundant cathode material for sustainable and long-lasting NIBs.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Critical minerals lists for low-carbon transitions: Reviewing their structure, objectives, and limitations

Critical minerals lists have flourished in the past decade, in particular linked to the importance of critical minerals for low-carbon transitions. We identified 27 critical minerals or materials lists across 15 countries and the European Union (EU). These lists are designed to attract public and private attention and investments to secure both domestic and foreign supplies. This review article fills a gap in the existing literature by analyzing the ways in which these lists are defined and utilized by countries engaged in a mineral rush. We focus our attention on three categories of minerals – battery minerals, platinum-group metals (PGMs), and rare earth elements (REEs) that are particularly important to energy transitions. We situate this research in the broader legal and administrative developments that have driven critical minerals policies in the past decade. We provide an in-depth analysis of the commonalities and variations in the raw materials included in these lists, and identify six core limitations of critical minerals lists: (1) unclear links between criticality assessments and mineral prioritization (2) failure to account for the full mineral value-chain; (3) limited strategic alignment between allied nations; (4) limited flexibility in dynamic environments (5) limited consideration for recycling and by-product sourcing; and (6) reliance on incomplete reserve and resource data.

Battery minerals↗