Evaluation of electroformed nickel to 301 stainless steel resistance spotwelds at 78 deg F and minus 423 deg F
Evaluating electroformed nickel to stainless steel resistance spot welds at room and cryogenic temperatures
SEARCH · Engineering Papers
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Evaluating electroformed nickel to stainless steel resistance spot welds at room and cryogenic temperatures
Molten salt reactors (MSRs) have drawn considerable interest due to their favorable safety features, high thermal efficiency, and compatibility with different fuel cycles. Yet, the success of MSRs hinges critically on the performance of structural materials to be used in these aggressive molten salt environments, where corrosion and material compatibility remain primary challenges to long-term reliability. Additively manufactured (AM) nuclear structural materials prompt the use of novel geometries and compositions to enhance material performance and reduce costs of constructing MSRs. The rapid solidification conditions inherent to AM processing impart distinctive microstructural features, including cellular sub-structures, dislocation densities, residual stress, and oxide inclusions, which can influence material performance in MSR components. While the mechanical properties of AM stainless steels have been widely studied, their corrosion behavior, particularly in molten salt environments, has received far less attention. Addressing these needs, the Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technologies (AMMT) program provides a framework for systematically evaluating how unique microstructures produced by AM processes influence the performance of these materials in these demanding environments and for developing reproducible testing workflows that can support future code qualification efforts and standards development. Bridging this knowledge gap is essential for assessing the viability of AM alloys in MSRs and informing qualification strategies. A further challenge is the absence of standardized protocols for molten salt corrosion testing. Accordingly, this report provides an account of the corrosion evaluation of AM 316H stainless steel in NaCl 2 -MgCl 2 molten salt at 550 °C, with exposure times of 100 and 500 hours. It documents the experimental procedures implemented under the AMMT program, including salt preparation, exposure protocols, and post-test characterization methods, to establish reproducibility and transparency. Importantly, the study examines AM 316H samples in the as-fabricated condition, directly reflecting the surface state most relevant to engineering applications, and compares their behavior to machine-cut surfaces. Overall, preliminary evaluations have noted that surface conditions (e.g. morphology, contamination, etc.) have a noticeable impact on the corrosion resiliency. The impact of the corrosion is difficult to detect at 100h, unless, in the case of AM 316H, the specimen surface is decontaminated. After 500 h, as-fabricated surfaces of AM and wrought 316H display evidence of general versus preferential corrosion attack, respectively. Both AM and wrought 316H machine-cut surfaces exhibit a continuous Cr depletion zone, evident of general corrosion. While the estimated extent of corrosion appears within the same order of magnitude regardless of the surface condition, it is apparent that more predictable behavior is observed on machine-cut surfaces. Nonetheless, further investigation is necessary to fully elucidate the corrosion mechanism under these conditions.
Additive manufacturing (AM) tools are capable of applying overlay austenitic stainless steel (SS) claddings to carbon steel components. The benefits of this approach over arc welding include a smaller heat-affected zone, residual stress reduction, and material savings. In particular, wire-directed energy deposition is a suitable technique because of its low material cost and high rate of production compared to other AM methods. However, metallurgical variations in composition, phase fraction, and microsegregation can potentially influence the corrosion behavior of such claddings. In this work, 309L SS is clad on carbon steel substrates and electrochemical methods are used to measure their general and pitting corrosion resistance in simulated marine environments (3.5 wt% NaCl solutions). Two-layer claddings are fabricated with four laser powers to understand the effects of bulk chemical composition, austenite/δ-ferrite phase fractions, and individual phase compositions on corrosion behavior. The two-layer claddings are compared to a single-layer cladding, wrought 304 SS, and the carbon steel substrate for a comprehensive assessment of corrosion performance. The two-layer claddings are remarkably resistant to general corrosion in the 3.5 wt% NaCl environment because of their high Cr content (21.6 wt% to 23.3 wt% Cr). The single-layer cladding exhibits localized corrosion at unmixed Fe-rich peninsulas that originate at the dissimilar metal boundary and protrude into the first cladding layer. All two-layer claddings possess higher pitting corrosion resistance than wrought 304 SS, demonstrating their effectiveness as a corrosion-resistant barrier. Here, the pitting corrosion resistance is superior for claddings made with lower laser powers, due to low dilution and greater δ-ferrite contents.
The corrosion behavior of oxide films grown on Type 316L stainless steel (SS) in molten FLiNaK (LiF-NaF-KF: 46.5−11.5−42 mol.%) salt was investigated. The results show that the oxide film formed on Type 316L SS is unstable and can only temporarily protect materials from corrosion in molten FLiNaK salt. Based on the electrochemical impedance spectroscopy, the oxide dissolution rate is calculated to be 0.85 nm/h at 700 °C in molten FLiNaK salt. Finally, after the oxide film dissolved, Cr and Fe are selective dealloyed from the steel, leading to intergranular corrosion of Type 316L SS in molten fluoride salt.
Effects of cold rolling on mechanical properties of type 310 stainless steel at room and cryogenic temperatures
The Pacific Northwest National Laboratory undertook the Materials Characterization, Prediction, and Control Laboratory Directed Research and Development Project to advance understanding of nuclear material processing and enable multifold acceleration in the development and qualification of new material systems produced via advanced manufacturing methods, such as solid phase processing, for use in national security and advanced energy applications (Smith 2021). A motivation of the Materials Characterization, Prediction, and Control Project was to demonstrate ultrasonic testing as a nondestructive evaluation method to complement traditional destructive methods for characterizing material microstructure with emphasis on grain size determination using a method that may have future applications for real-time inline process monitoring. The objective of the work described in this report is to establish the process and an analysis method for measuring grain sizes of polycrystalline metals with ultrafine grains using ultrasonic shear wave backscattering, building on prior studies on coarser-grained material. The work involves five tasks: Measured ultrasonic backscattering experimentally for a series of 316L stainless steel specimens with various grain sizes made by friction stir processing. Calculated ultrasonic backscattering coefficients from experimental data based on a physical measurement model. Measured ground truth grain sizes of the specimens from electron backscatter diffraction grain boundary images using a generalization of the ASTM E112 (ASTM 2021) intercept method. Built a curve of ultrasonic backscattering coefficients versus the ground truth intercept-based grain sizes to determine the correlation between mean grain sizes and ultrasonic measurements. Demonstrated the ability of using the correlation curve to deduce grain sizes with measured ultrasonic backscattering coefficients for a few 316L stainless steel specimens whose grain sizes were unknown beforehand but were targeted to be an extrapolation to larger grain sizes than used to formulate the correlation curves. Experimental procedures and computational algorithms are developed and validated for these tasks. This work establishes an ultrasonic technique for characterizing material microstructure with ultrafine grains that are often resulted by solid-phase processing. The technique is nondestructive, and it has the potential to be used for real time inline process monitoring. This work successfully demonstrates the viability of an ultrasonic nondestructive evaluation method for microstructural characterization of material having ultrafine grain structure (as small as 1?mm) and produced by an advanced manufacturing method. This includes a demonstration of the method to extrapolate to other conditions. While not demonstrated here, the method is expected to be viable for in-line, or near-inline, process monitoring in advanced manufacturing applications with suitable consideration for access of instrumentation to the material being manufactured.
Following successful application of Coulomb-Mohr and interaction equations for evaluation of safety margins in Albemet 162 brazed joints, two additional base metal/filler metal systems were investigated. Specimens consisting of stainless steel brazed with silver-base filler metal and titanium brazed with 1100 Al alloy were tested to failure under combined action of tensile, shear, bending and torsion loads. Finite Element Analysis (FEA), hand calculations and digital image comparison (DIC) techniques were used to estimate failure stresses and construct Failure Assessment Diagrams (FAD). This study confirms that interaction equation R(sub sigma) + R(sub tau) = 1, where R(sub sigma) and R(sub t u) are normal and shear stress ratios, can be used as conservative lower bound estimate of the failure criterion in stainless steel and titanium brazed joints.
Repassivation behavior of Super 13Cr martensitic stainless steel was investigated using a one-dimensional artificial pit electrode in deaerated NaCl solutions at 85 °C. Critical potentials for pit repassivation (E crit ) were measured by downward potential scans. E crit and the final current density (i f ) at the end of the scan can be correlated to the pit repassivation, showing that repassivation is more probable with smaller i f and higher E crit . Pit repassivation at a constant potential was correlated with if and average current density (i avg ). A combination of lower i f and i avg suggests a higher probability for pit repassivation.
This study presents a method for designing a computationally informed gradient pathway to fabricate a functionally graded material (FGM) with terminal alloys of 316 stainless steel (SS316) and Ti-6Al-4V via directed energy deposition additive manufacturing with powder feedstock. In this work, the grading is accomplished through the introduction of intermediate elements and alloys (Ni-20Cr, Cr, and V) to avoid the brittle Fe-Ti intermetallic phases that form in the direct liquid phase joining of Ti-alloys and stainless steels. Using a combination of equilibrium calculations and Scheil-Gulliver simulations, a compositional pathway was designed to avoid deleterious phases. FGM samples were fabricated and experimentally characterized to determine the viability of the pathway. A change in phases from fcc to bcc was predicted to occur within the Ni-20Cr/Cr gradient region, and this was validated through experimental characterization. No detrimental phases (intermetallic, Laves, or σ phases) formed along the gradient path, demonstrating a successful computationally-informed design and fabrication of an FGM from SS316 to Ti-6Al-4V.
Here, post-irradiation evaluation was performed on a 316 stainless steel baffle former bolt harvested after 40 years of service in a pressurized water reactor. Microstructure analysis revealed the presence of defect-free dislocation channels and strain-induced twins, indicative of loading at a stress level close to yield stress at least once while in service. Primary radiation-induced Ni/Si precipitates were destroyed during channel and twin formation, and secondary, significantly coarser Ni/Si precipitates formed along newly formed Σ3 boundaries during the continued irradiation. Additionally, an elevated phosphorus level was observed inside the strain-induced twin. Complex chemistry inside the strain-induced feature may overlap with dislocation pileups and impact localized corrosion, material long-term performance, and safety.
The size evolution and phase composition of sigma phases were investigated for a 347H stainless steel subject to isothermal aging at 750 °C for up to 10,000 h. Scanning electron microscopy reveals that sigma phases are present before 336 h aging and they continue to grow for all aging times studied. Atom probe tomography shows little variation in the sigma phase composition with aging time up to 10,000 h, and only the C content decreases with aging time. The comparison of C concentration suggests that the sigma phase does not nucleate within the C-depleted matrix or precipitate free grain boundaries, leaving dissolving metastable M 23 C 6 as the only possible nucleation site. Based on the experimental results and thermodynamic simulations, the desirable Nb concentration is discussed to reduce the kinetics of sigma phase growth, and possible design directions are suggested to improve 347H.
Effect of surface roughness and spray powders on shear bond strength of plasma-sprayed alumina coatings on stainless steel
Structural materials used in the next generation nuclear reactors or other advanced energy systems are often required to withstand higher operating temperatures for a longer service life. Alloy 709 (A709), a Nb-containing and N-stabilized Fe-25Ni-20Cr austenitic stainless steel, has been recommended for high-temperature reactor constructions due to the better performance over the baseline Type 316H stainless steel. Here, in the current manuscript, for the first time, the microstructure evolution and tensile behavior of an A709 made by laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) is discussed. The as deposited and heat treated LPBF alloys are compared with a reference wrought alloy. Owing to the chemical segregation and a higher number of dislocations, the LPBF materials show a significantly higher density of precipitates formed during high temperature treatments when compared to the wrought samples. This is reflected when looking at the tensile properties, both at room and elevated temperatures, where LPBF samples show higher strengths compared to wrought materials.
Additive manufacturing of metal components enables rapid fabrication of complex geometries. However, metal additive manufacturing also introduces new morphological and microstructural characteristics which might be detrimental to component performance. Here we report the pitting corrosion properties of wrought and additively manufactured 316L stainless steel after atmospheric exposure to coastal environments and laboratory-created environments. Qualitative visualization in combination with quantitative analysis of resulting pits provided an in-depth understanding of pitting differences between wrought and additively manufactured 316L stainless steel and between coastal and laboratory-based exposure. Optical and scanning electron microscopy were utilized for visualization, while white light interferometry measured pits across approximately 5mm x 5mm areas on each sample. Post-processing of the interferometry data enables quantification of pitting attack for each sample in terms of both pit depth and pit volume. The pitting analysis introduced herein offers a new technique to compare pitting attack between different manufacturing processes and materials.
Microbial contamination obtained on stainless steel, aluminum, glass, and lucite surfaces after twenty days exposure to room air
The dynamic high strain rate tensile (spall) failure of additively manufactured (AM) materials is an area of great interest but much less understood than material failure under other loading regimes. The research presented here examines the effects of microstructure anisotropy in 316L stainless steel fabricated by laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) on its spall failure and properties. In this work, plate-on-plate impact experiments were performed using an 80-mm gas gun to investigate the spall behavior of AM fabricated sample discs with impact along the perpendicular and parallel orientations relative to build directions. Experiments were also performed on wrought 316L stainless steel as baseline material with uniform equiaxed grain microstructure for comparison with the AM material of same composition. The spall experiments involved free-surface velocity profiles measured using Photon Doppler Velocimetry (PDV) to capture the spall pull-back signals, combined with post-mortem analysis of the microstructure of soft-recovered impacted samples. In the case of AM samples, spall failure initiated preferentially at melt pool boundaries in both impact directions. The spall plane location and spall strength, however, were both heavily influenced by the orientation of the impact direction relative to the build direction in the AM samples. The spall behavior is also observed to be more complex in the samples impacted perpendicular to the build (through-thickness) direction, due in large part to the orientation of the microstructural features such as melt pool boundaries, laser scan tracks, and general grain morphology.
Effects of cold rolling on notched and unnotched tensile properties of type 310 stainless steel
Crack propagation, delayed failure, and residual static strength of titanium, aluminum, and stainless steel alloys in air, three percent salt solution, and sea water