Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “Molecular simulation”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 289 records · Page 16
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2022

Capacitance of Carbon Nanotube/Graphene Composite Electrodes with [BMIM + ][BF$_4^–$]/Acetonitrile: Fixed Voltage Molecular Dynamics Simulations

The capacitance of nanoporous carbon electrode materials is dictated by the physical interactions with electrolyte ions and molecules at the accessible interior electrode surface. While significant progress has been made in designing and synthesizing carbon materials with well-defined and relatively homogeneous nanoporosity, the majority of materials remain heterogeneous, and the resulting properties reflect an average over this distribution. In this regard, computer simulations can be a valuable tool to predict or validate structure/property relationships by systematically investigating well-defined, model electrode morphologies. In this work, we utilize fixed-voltage molecular dynamics simulations to predict structure/capacitance relationships for five different model morphologies of carbon nanotube/graphene (CNT/G) composite electrodes with 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium tetrafluoroborate/acetonitrile electrolyte. The CNT/G electrode models are inspired by experimental “layer-by-layer” syntheses and strike a balance between realism and computational tractability. Comparison between different model electrode architectures elucidates important structure/property relationships. We find that CNT/graphene contact points serve as “hot spots” with significantly enhanced charge separation relative to the rest of the electrode. Furthermore, we demonstrate a specific nanoconfinement motif that provides substantial 3–4$\times$ enhancement of local capacitance, resulting in a ~40% increase of the total electrode differential capacitance. Because the accessible surface area of the model CNT/G electrodes is precisely determined, a comparison of per-area capacitance across systems is unambiguous. Our results thus complement a prior computational demonstration of capacitance enhancement in nanoconfinement while elucidating additional interaction motifs at CNT/G electrochemical interfaces.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Molecular Dynamics Simulation and Theoretical Analysis of Structural Relaxation, Bond Exchange Dynamics, and Glass Transition in Vitrimers

Vitrimers are a class of polymer networks featuring dynamic covalent cross-links that can undergo associative bond exchange. There has been recent interest in these materials due to their promise as recyclable thermosets or self-healing polymers because of the ability of vitrimer networks to rearrange at the molecular level and undergo macroscopic flow. However, the practical use of these materials often occurs in the supercooled regime or glassy state, where the implications of dynamic bonds are complicated by the interplay between slow activated segmental dynamics, cross-link (i.e., bond-exchange) kinetics, and ultimately material properties. Here, in this paper, we combine coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulation and microscopic statistical mechanical theory to understand how cross-linking kinetics affect material dynamics and how this couples to segmental relaxation of the polymeric network strands across a spectrum of length and time scales, especially in the supercooled regime. We characterize the Kuhn segmental alpha relaxation time and bond exchange time for vitrimer systems across various cross-link densities, temperatures, and bond exchange rates. Simulation and theory both exhibit a bending-up behavior for bond exchange time upon cooling, suggesting a coupling between bond exchange dynamics and segmental relaxation that intensifies with faster bond exchange kinetics. We also found bond exchange dynamics have an impact on Kuhn segment alpha relaxation time, which is most significant at higher cross-link densities. Both these effects are most prominent when the bond exchange time is similar to the Kuhn segment alpha relaxation time, and the resulting coupling of these two relaxation processes is tied to both the probability of a free end to find a bonded pair and the time scale of the constraints imposed by the dynamic cross-links. This relationship is reflected by a cross-link dependence of a theoretical parameter which represents the quantitative degree of coupling between bond exchange and segmental dynamics. Overall, the combination of simulation and theory clarifies the intricate interaction between bond kinetics and segmental relaxation and demonstrates the ability to provide molecular-level insights into vitrimer dynamics over a wide temperature range.

dynamic relaxation↗
DOE OSTI2025

Proton radiation effects in indium oxide using cascade molecular dynamics simulations

Metal oxide (MO) semiconductors, characterized by their wide band gaps and notable charge transport properties, are promising candidates for electronic applications in extreme environments, including near-Earth space. However, atomistic simulations of radiation–matter interactions in MOs remain challenging due to the limitations of existing interatomic potentials, which often fail to capture both the short-range repulsive forces essential for radiation damage modeling and the long-range electrostatic effects governing defect evolution. In this work, we develop a customized interatomic potential tailored for radiation damage simulations in indium oxide (In 2 O 3 ) as a model system, a representative MO material. Our potential integrates the Ziegler-Biersack-Littmark potential to accurately describe short-range interactions with Buckingham and Coulombic potentials to account for long-range forces. We perform molecular dynamics simulations of low-energy proton irradiation using this custom potential. We employ the primary knock-on atom (PKA) cascade method to study atomic displacements and primary defect formation. Simulations were conducted for 1 keV proton irradiation in four randomly chosen directions, and PKA-driven defect analyses at 5, 10, and 15 keV to examine the effects of direction and energy level on damage generation. Our results provide insight into the impact of irradiation direction and energy level on the cascade evolution and defect formation mechanisms.

Atomistic simulations↗
DOE OSTI2025

Reorganization of Water at Aqueous Aluminum Chloride (AlCl 3 ) Interfaces: Vibrational Sum Frequency Generation and Molecular Dynamics Simulations

AlCl 3 hydration states and complexation are not well understood both in solutions and at the air–aqueous interface despite their potential significance in natural waters and their industrial and energy-related applications. Here, we investigated Al 3+ and Cl – ion behaviors in an AlCl 3 aqueous bulk solution and at the air–aqueous interface using interface-selective vibrational sum frequency generation (SFG), Raman and infrared spectroscopies, molecular dynamics (MD) simulation, as well as molecular-informed reduced modeling. Our reduced modeling reveals relatively long-range effects for Al 3+ as compared to monovalent ions such as Na + indicating that the interfacial depth of trivalent ions can be significantly larger than that of monovalent ions at the air–water interface. MD simulations reveal interfacial stratification and multiple layering of the ions. Compression of the Al 3+ and Cl – distributions with increasing concentrations from 0.5 to 2.5 m is also observed in the subsurface regions. Significant SSP- and PPP-polarized SFG OH spectral intensity increases are observed from 0.5 to 1.5 m and 0.5 to 2.5 m, respectively, indicative of interfacial depth increases and a change in average orientation above 1.5 m. Extensive evaluation of SFG spectra, Fresnel-corrected using several approaches, shows the same trends. The nonmonotonic trend points to a changing structure in surface and subsurface water orientation and hydrogen bonding environment generally consistent with the MD simulation of stratification and water orientation changes. Furthermore, solvent-shared ion pairing is implicated with MD simulation radial distribution analysis and consistent with infrared spectral identification of the hexaaqua aluminum ion in the solution phase. Spectral evidence of a strong Al 3+ hydration shell and the acidic behavior of the Al 3+ ions is obvious in the Raman and infrared spectra of the bulk solution. In conclusion, we show that the MD dipole potential is directly related to the MD second-order susceptibility of the interface, χ SFG–MD (2) , both of which correlate up to ∼35 Å with the spectral observations of increasing and then saturating intensities, suggesting that both ion stratification and interfacial depth determine the water orientations at an air–water interface of 1-3 electrolyte solutions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Linear Discriminant Analysis-Based Machine Learning and All-Atom Molecular Dynamics Simulations for Probing Electro-Osmotic Transport in Cationic-Polyelectrolyte-Brush-Grafted Nanochannels

Deciphering the correct mechanisms governing certain phenomena in polyelectrolyte (PE) brush grafted systems, revealed through atomistic simulations, is an extremely challenging problem. In a recent study, our all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations revealed a non-linearly large electroosmotic (EOS) flow (in the presence of an applied electric field) in nanochannels grafted with PMETAC [Poly(2-(methacryloyloxy)ethyl trimethylammonium chloride] brushes. Given the lack of any formal procedure that would have directed us to identify the correct factors responsible for such an occurrence, we needed to spend several months and devote significant analyses to unravel the involved mechanisms. In this paper, we propose a Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA) based Machine Learning (ML) approach to address this gap. At first, we obtain data on certain basic features from the all-atom MD data. These basic features represent the number of atoms of certain species around one atom of another (or same) species. Here, we obtain such data on basic features for a reference case (case of an EOS flow in PMETAC-brush-grafted nanochannels with a smaller electric field) and a perturbed case (case of an EOS flow in PMETAC-brush-grafted nanochannels with a larger electric field) in bins in which the nanochannel half height has been divided into. These datasets are high-dimensional dataset, to which the LDA is applied. This leads to the projection of the data (between the reference and the perturbed states) in a highly separated form on a 1D line. From such LDA calculations, we are able to identify the relative importance of the different basic features in ensuring this separation of the data (between the reference and the perturbed states) on the 1D line. This relative importance of the different basic features is quantified as “importance scores” for the different features, which in turn tell us what to study and where to study. Such knowledge enables us to rapidly identify the key factors responsible for the non-linearly large EOS transport in PMETAC-brush-grafted nanochannels.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2026

Primary defect production from molecular dynamics simulations of high-energy displacement cascades in NbMoTaW alloys

In this work, we report on large-scale molecular-dynamics (MD) simulations of displacement cascades in equiatomic NbMoTaW alloys at PKA energies ranging from 0.15 to 150 keV. We find defect production to be strongly dependent on recoil energy, scaling sublinearly up to 10 keV, and linearly thereafter. We find the sublinear regime to be defined by low values of surviving Frenkel pairs, typically found as isolated point defects or small defect clusters, while at higher recoil energies dense cascades become more frequent, leading to splitting into subcascades and the production of relatively large prismatic-dislocation loops with ⟨111⟩ and ⟨001⟩ Burgers vectors. These loops immobilize large fractions of defects, leading to a rapid growth of the number of surviving defects in the linear regime. We also anneal post-cascade defect configurations using object-kinetic Monte Carlo (OKMC) simulations to account for intracascade recombination on time scales not accessible to MD simulations. Cascade annealing is strongly temperature dependent, with the OKMC simulations only showing significant recovery at 1000 K but not below. Our results are in general agreement with existing published data for refractory concentrated alloys.

Zhou, Xinran [Lawrence Berkeley National Laborator↗
DOE OSTI2022

Effect of different manufacturing methods on polyamide reverse-osmosis membranes for desalination: Insights from molecular dynamics simulations

Membranes are a key technology platform for a broad application of energy-efficient separations. To best serve the separation demands of industry, the manufacturing processes for these membranes are garnering increasing attention. In particular, for water desalination, the industry leading polyamide (PA) reverse osmosis (RO) membranes can be manufactured via molecular layer-by-layer (mLBL) deposition, interfacial polymerization (IP), and 3D-printing technique. However, the influence of different manufacturing methods on PA membrane’s properties is far from understood. Here, in this study, we present the high-pressure transport behavior of water and salt ions for PA membranes formed with IP, mLBL, and 3D-printing through non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. Studies show that membranes fabricated with 3D-printing have similar performances to those manufactured using mLBL, quantified by water permeability, rejection of salt ions, structural integrity, and porosity features. However, the membranes formed with IP exhibit faster water transport, lower rejection, worse structural integrity, and more inhomogeneous network pores than those constructed using mLBL and 3D-printing. The unconnected water-accessible space governs water transport for PA membranes formed with mLBL and 3D-printing, which offers the impermanent open-closed pores that enable water to jump through PA membranes. In contrast, the permeated water-enterable space plays a prominent role in water movement across the PA membrane formed with IP, providing a continuous transport channel at high pressure. Importantly, we observe the more significant compaction features at high pressure for PA membranes formed with IP than mLBL and 3D printing. In short, these findings provide a comprehensive understanding of existing membrane preparation technologies. It also provides a guide for developing the new membrane preparation process at the molecular level.

3D-printing↗
DOE OSTI2025

Molecular Origin of Nanoscale Anion Ordering of LiTFSI Electrolytes Revealed through SAXS/WAXS and Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Recent developments in “water-in-salt” electrolytes have precipitated a renewed effort to study imide-based electrolytes. While previous small-/wide-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS/WAXS) studies have attributed the emergence of a low-Q peak in the SAXS profile of aqueous LiTFSI electrolytes to nanometer-scale anion clustering, a molecular-level understanding of the root of these clusters remains unclear. Here, in this study, we combined molecular dynamics simulations and SAXS/WAXS to study the solvation structures of LiTFSI in acetonitrile, methanol, and water. We concluded that hydrogen bonding in water and MeOH stabilizes anion clusters, while nonpolar methyl groups on methanol and acetonitrile interrupt the nanoscale ordering of TFSI anions. This causes LiTFSI in water and MeOH electrolytes to exhibit two low-Q SAXS profile peaks while LiTFSI in acetonitrile exhibits only a single peak below Q = 1 Å –1 . These findings shed light on the underlying molecular origins of nanoscale anion clusters, which may help in the design of the next generation of electrolyte chemistries.

Trojanowski, Lucas [Univ. of Michigan, Ann Arbor, ↗
DOE OSTI2020

A coarse-grain force field based on quantum mechanics (CGq FF) for molecular dynamics simulation of poly(ethylene glycol)- block -poly(ε-caprolactone) (PEG- b -PCL) micelles

In order to provide the means to predict from molecular dynamics (MD) simulations the structures of copolymer-based micelles in solution, we developed coarse grain force field (CGq FF) parameters for poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) and for poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL). A key advance here is the use of quantum mechanics to train the parameters describing the non-bonded (NB) interactions between the CG beads. The functional forms are the same as the MARTINI CG FF so standard MD codes can be used. Our CGq FF describes well the experimentally observed properties for the polymer–air and polymer–water interfaces, indicating the accuracy of the NB interactions. Additionally, the structural properties (density, radius of gyration ( R g ), and end-to-end distance ( h )) match both experiment and all atom (AA) simulations. We illustrate the application of this CGq FF by following the formation of a spherical micelle from 250 chains of PEG 23 - b -PCL 9 diblock copolymer, each block with molecular weight of 1000 Daltons (10 500 beads, corresponding to 123 250 atoms), in a water box with 119 139 water beads (426 553 water molecules).

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2023

Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Calcite Fracture in Water

Calcite (CaCO 3 ) is one of the most common minerals in geologic and engineered systems. It is often in contact with aqueous solutions, causing chemically assisted fracture that is critical to understanding the stability of subsurface systems and manmade structures. Calcite fracture was evaluated with reactive molecular dynamics simulations, including the impacts of crack tip geometry (notch), the presence of water, and surface hydroxyl groups. Chemo-mechanical weakening was assessed by comparing the loads where fracture began to propagate. Our analyses show that in the presence of a notch, the load at which crack growth begins is lower, compared to the effect of water or surface hydroxyls. Additionally, the breaking of two adjacent Ca–O bonds is the kinetic limitation for crack initiation, since transiently broken bonds can reform, not resulting in crack growth. In aqueous environments, fresh (not hydroxylated) calcite surfaces exhibited water strengthening. Manual addition of H + and/or OH – species on the (104) calcite surface resulted in chemo-mechanical weakening of calcite by 9%. Achieving full hydroxylation of the calcite surface was thermodynamically and kinetically limited, with only 0.17–0.01 OH/nm 2 surface hydroxylation observed on the (104) surface at the end of the simulations. In conclusion, the limited reactivity of pure water with the calcite surface restricts the chemo-mechanical effects and suggests that reactions between physiosorbed water and localized structural defects may be dominating the chemo-mechanical process in the studies where water weakening has been reported.

Calcite↗
DOE OSTI2023

Molecular dynamics simulations of fission gas xenon (Xe) diffusion at UO 2 grain-boundaries (Rev.1)

The diffusivity of fission gas xenon (Xe) at UO 2 grain-boundaries is one of the most important parameters in mechanistic modeling of fission gas diffusion in UO 2 based nuclear fuels. In this report, we use molecular dynamics simulations to investigate the Xe diffusivity in UO 2 grain-boundaries, employing the many-body potential developed by Cooper, Rushton and Grimes for UO 2 . Three different types of grain-boundaries are investigated, twist Σ5, tilt Σ5, and a random grain-boundary. Diffusion activation energies in the range of 0.39 – 1.46 eV are obtained for the Xe diffusivity. Comparison to results for the uranium vacancy diffusivity from MD simulations employing the same methodology suggests a weak to moderate attractive Xe-uranium vacancy binding energy depending on the grain-boundary type.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2024

Assessing Melting and Solid–Solid Transition Properties of Choline Chloride via Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Choline chloride (ChCl) is used extensively as a hydrogen bond donor in deep eutectic solvents (DESs). However, determining its melting properties experimentally is challenging due to decomposition upon melting, leading to widely varying literature values. Accurate melting properties are crucial for understanding the solid–liquid phase behavior of ChCl-containing DESs. Here, we employ molecular dynamics simulations to compute the phase transitions of ChCl, testing a variety of atomistic force fields. We find that the results are sensitive to the choice of force field, but a melting temperature of 627 K and a melting enthalpy of 7.8 kJ/mol seem most reasonable, in good agreement with some literature values. Furthermore, we suggest these as the likely melting properties of ChCl, though the results are tentative due to limited experimental data for the liquid ChCl phase.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2021

Evaluation of Force Fields for Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Platinum in Bulk and Nanoparticle Forms

Here, understanding the size- and shape-dependent properties of platinum nanoparticles is critical for enabling the design of nanoparticle-based applications with optimal and potentially tunable functionality. Toward this goal, we evaluated nine different empirical potentials with the purpose of accurately modeling faceted platinum nanoparticles using molecular dynamics simulation. First, the potentials were evaluated by computing bulk and surface properties - surface energy, lattice constant, stiffness constants, and the equation of state - and comparing these to prior experimental measurements and quantum mechanics calculations. Then, the potentials were assessed in terms of the stability of cubic and icosahedral nanoparticles with faces in the {100} and {111} planes, respectively. Although none of the force fields predicts all the evaluated properties with perfect accuracy, one potential - the embedded atom method formalism with a specific parameter set - was identified as best able to model platinum in both bulk and nanoparticle forms.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Molecular dynamics simulations of displacement cascades in LiAlO2 and LiAl5O8 ceramics

Abstract Molecular dynamics was employed to investigate the radiation damage due to collision cascades in LiAlO 2 and LiAl 5 O 8 , the latter being a secondary phase formed in the former during irradiation. Atomic displacement cascades were simulated by initiating primary knock-on atoms (PKA) with energy values = 5, 10 and 15 keV and the damage was quantified by the number of Frenkel pairs formed for each species: Li, Al and O. The primary challenges of modeling an ionic system with and without a core–shell model for oxygen atoms were addressed and new findings on the radiation resistance of these ceramics are presented. The working of a variable timestep function and the kinetics in the background of the simulations have been elaborated to highlight the novelty of the simulation approach. More importantly, the key results indicated that LiAlO 2 experiences much more radiation damage than LiAl 5 O 8 , where the number of Li Frenkel pairs in LiAlO 2 was 3–5 times higher than in LiAl 5 O 8 while the number of Frenkel pairs for Al and O in LiAlO 2 are ~ 2 times higher than in LiAl 5 O 8 . The primary reason is high displacement threshold energies (E d ) in LiAl 5 O 8 for Li cations. The greater E d for Li imparts higher resistance to damage during the collision cascade and thus inhibits amorphization in LiAl 5 O 8 . The presented results suggest that LiAl 5 O 8 is likely to maintain structural integrity better than LiAlO 2 in the irradiation conditions studied in this work.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
DOE OSTI2023

Assessment of the impact of reactor residence time distribution on non-equilibrium product selectivity of polypropylene pyrolysis using reactive molecular dynamics simulations

Mass residence time distribution (RTD) is considered to be an important factor controlling the product selectivity in the pyrolysis of biomass and plastic wastes along with the pyrolysis chemistry. However, due to the complex pyrolysis chemistry of biomass and plastic waste, the coupling between the reaction chemistry, RTD, and product selectivity is challenging to understand. Here, we introduce a reaction molecular dynamics-based method to examine pyrolysis chemistry and species timescales to assess the impact of RTD on product selectivity and yield. To validate this method, reactive molecular dynamics simulations were conducted for polypropylene pyrolysis and its non-equilibrium product selectivity using 6 different RTDs. We find that the RTD and the reaction chemistry control the peak non-equilibrium product concentrations. The peak monomer (C 3 H 6 ) concentration during pyrolysis can be increased by up to 25 % by using a narrow RTD in the case of polypropylene pyrolysis. We also find that product selectivity is strongly affected by the average residence time and RTD. This coupling between the reaction chemistry, RTD, and product selectivity highlights the need to understand detailed reaction chemistry to control RTD and optimize non-equilibrium product selectivity during polymer and biomass pyrolysis. The present method provides a new way to design RTD for reactors to reach maximized product selectivity of plastic waste and biomass.

33 ADVANCED PROPULSION SYSTEMS↗
DOE OSTI2020

Deformation behavior of annealed Cu64Zr36 metallic glass via molecular dynamics simulations

In the present work, we investigate the isothermal annealing process of Cu 64 Zr 36 metallic glass (MG) by means of molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, and characterize the compression properties under different temperatures and compressive rates. The pair distribution functions, the bond-orientational order, and the cluster-type index method are modeled and analyzed to characterize changes in the structure. Results of the modeling and analysis reveal that the MgZn 2 -type Laves, MgCu 2 -type Laves and five-fold local symmetry structures can be formed during the isothermal holding at 950 K. Study on the compression properties shows that at a fixed strain rate, the yield strength and yield drop all increase with decreasing temperature. At a fixed temperature, however, the increase of the strain rate leads to a noticeable increase in the yield strength at 600 K, but has little effect on yield strength at 10 K. Moreover, the modeling and analysis of the structure at a temperature of 10 K and strain-rate of 5 × 10 7 s -1 demonstrate that the order-disorder transformation initiates the shear band.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Effects of Composition and Oxidation States on the Structures of Chromium-Containing Sodium Silicate Glasses: Molecular Dynamics Simulations using Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials

Chromium represents a significant challenge for the vitrification of high-level nuclear waste into silicate and borosilicate glasses due to its low solubility and variable oxidation states, which can limit the waste loading due to promotion of crystallization or phase separation during processing. In this study, we modeled chromium containing silicate glasses using molecular dynamics simulations with three machine learning interatomic potentials (MLIPs), MACE, CHGNet, and PFP were employed, to gain insights on glass composition and oxidation states on the structures of these glasses. One of the goals is to evaluate their ability of these MLIPs to accurately represent the general structure of silicate glasses and chromium local environments as a function of chromium oxidation states. Density Functional Theory (DFT) based calculations and experimental data such as neutron structure factors were used to validate the structural models. It was found that the foundation models of all three MLIPs are able to reproduce general structural features of the sodium silicate glass structure consistent with experimental and DFT data, but only CHGNet and PFP can accurately capture the oxidation states and local environment of chromium: tetrahedral for Cr6+ and octahedral for Cr3+. Furthermore, we studied the effect of varying Cr3+/ Cr6+ (Cr3+/Crtotal) ratio and total chromium content using PFP. Our results show that Cr6+ enhances network polymerization by reducing non-bridging oxygens through Na? charge compensation required due to the formation of chromate (CrO42-) species, while Cr³? acts as a network modifier that disrupts connectivity. System size effects on the structural characteristics and chromium environments were also tested using the PFP potential. This work highlights the importance of careful validation on the precision, transferability, and potential of MLIPs for modeling glasses containing transition metal elements that can exist in multiple oxidation states. It is also encouraging to see the foundational models are all three MLFFs are able to reproduce the basic sodium silicate glass structures, while suggesting additional training or refining is needed to improve the description of more complex systems containing transition metals.

Puga, Christina L.↗