High Speed Hybrid Reluctance Motor Utilizing Anisotropic Materials
With high cost and volatility driving continued efforts to decrease reliance on the critical heavy rare earth materials used in traction drive applications, General Motors developed three variants of heavy rare earth-free (HRE-free) electric motors. The variants focused on taking advantage of advanced magnet technologies and new rotor topologies to improve mechanical strength and achieve power targets. The three variants were a HRE-free permanent magnet reluctance motor, a synchronous reluctance motor utilizing small HRE-free permanent magnets, and an induction motor with inserted copper bars and cast aluminum end-rings. Motors were designed with the intent of primary or secondary traction applications, depending on the topology. Variant 1 achieved performance comparable to HRE-containing permanent magnet motors through optimized topology and validation of HRE-free magnets, focusing on achieving energy products and demagnetization resistance comparable to those of HRE-containing magnets. Demagnetization testing demonstrated the motor robustness to currents and temperatures exceeding expected vehicle conditions, a key challenge to the use of HRE-free magnets. The Variant 1 motor also showed the best capability of meeting the US Drive technology 2020 targets, due to the high power-density of the permanent magnet motor and the potential cost reductions enabled by the removal of heavy rare earth materials. Variant 2 exhibited high efficiency in high speed regions due to the low high-speed losses, an important consideration for secondary traction applications, and significantly thrifted on magnet mass to reduce cost. Variant 3 contained copper bars within the induction rotor to reduce losses compared to cast aluminum, while using cast aluminum end-rings to reduce the cost and mass of the rotor. Optimization of the Cu-Al interface were focused on, as the interface is prone to forming brittle intermetallic compounds during the casting process. Prototypes of each motor variant were built and tested for performance, mechanical strength, and demagnetization resistance (Variants 1 and 2 only), with torque and power resulting close to the predicted values.