A Study of Ice-Crystal Icing Erosion Using the NASA Icing Research Tunnel and Propulsion Systems Laboratory
In ice-crystal icing, ice erosion can occur simultaneously with ice accretion. This paper presents a proof-of-concept experimental study that attempts to isolate and quantify ice erosion. The experiments took place at the NASA Icing Research Tunnel and Propulsion Systems Laboratory in 2017 and 2018. The test procedure involved first generating an ice accretion on various NACA 0012 airfoil models using a supercooled liquid water or mixed-phase icing cloud and, subsequently, exposing that ice accretion to an ice crystal cloud. The resulting ice mass decay rates were analyzed in terms of an erosion term, defined as the ratio of the eroded mass flux to impinging mass flux. The erosion term generally increased with airspeed with a value of 1.8% at air velocities of 270 knots and increasing to just over 6% at 360 knots. A preliminary correlation for ice erosion is developed for use in ice accretion models subject to the conditions tested. The study revealed several challenges, both experimental and analytical, including spray bar nozzle freeze-out as well as measurement of the cloud melt ratio to ensure freeze-out.