Engineering Papers⌕ Search

SEARCH · Engineering Papers

Results for “anharmonicity”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 235 records · Page 13

Correlated Displacement of Dynamic Elastic Dipoles Produces Nonclassical Electrostriction in Zr-Doped Ceria

By combining experimental data with density functional theory-based ab initio molecular dynamics modeling, this work provides evidence that nonclassical electrostriction in isovalent Zr-doped ceria is due to the correlated anharmonic motion of dynamic elastic dipoles associated with multiple [ZrO 8 ]-local bonding units with a high Zr concentration (Zr 0.1 Ce 0.9 O 2 ). Introduction of 0.5 mol % trivalent or divalent codopants (Sc, Yb, La, or Ca) reduces the longitudinal electrostriction strain coefficient by more than a factor of 10, produces a 3-fold decrease in the relative dielectric permittivity, and increases the elastic modulus. Since these changes depend neither on the radius nor on the valency of the codopant, we conclude that the responsible species are charge-compensating oxygen vacancies (VO). For trivalent dopants (Do 0.005 Zr 0.1 Ce 0.895 O 1.9975 ), oxygen vacancies are present at a concentration ratio 1:40 with respect to Zr, giving, for random distribution, a characteristic interaction distance of ≤2.3 unit cells (1.2 nm). Oxygen vacancies participate in [ZrO 7 -V O ] local bonding units, disrupting the correlated dynamic displacements of the connected [ZrO 8 ]-local bonding units. Finally, such correlated motion of dynamic elastic dipoles may also explain the exponential increase in the longitudinal electrostriction strain coefficient with an increase in Zr concentration to <0.2 mole fraction and must be taken into account for further development of nonclassical electrostrictors based on Zr-doped ceria.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Leveraging Polymorphism in YbCuBi to Map Transport and Elastic Properties

AMX Zintl compounds with the hexagonal ZrBeSi structure have gained significant attention for their remarkable vacancy tolerance and low thermal conductivity. Their 2D honeycomb sublattice, composed of M–X covalent bonds, is believed to contribute to high anharmonicity and unusual thermal transport properties. In this study, we explore the temperature-dependent polymorphism of YbCuBi as a model system to investigate the relationship between the structure and elastic and thermal transport properties in AMX Zintls. YbCuBi undergoes a structural transition from the “flat” Cu–Bi layers in the ZrBeSi structure to corrugated layers in the LiGaGe structure below 410 K, resulting in a distortion of its centrosymmetric structure. To probe the effects of this crystallographic transition, we employ inelastic neutron scattering and temperature-dependent resonant ultrasound spectroscopy. These experimental findings, coupled with first-principles calculations and thermal conductivity measurements, allow us to elucidate a direct relationship between corrugation of the honeycomb lattice and the observed changes in elastic and thermal transport properties. These insights can be extended to other Zintl phases with similar structure types, providing a platform for the rational design of functional materials with tailored thermal properties.

Chemical structure↗

Beyond Idealized Models of Nanoscale Metal Hydrides for Hydrogen Storage

Metal hydrides are attractive for compact, low-pressure hydrogen storage, yet a foundational understanding of factors governing their thermodynamics and kinetics is still lacking. Predictive modeling from the atomic to the microstructural scale plays a critical role in addressing these gaps, particularly for nanoscale materials, which promise improved performance but are difficult to probe. In this paper, we summarize strategies being developed within the Hydrogen Materials—Advanced Research Consortium (HyMARC) for going beyond conventional models to incorporate more complex physics, more realistic structures, and better approximation of operation conditions in simulations of nanoscale metal hydrides. We highlight four beyond-ideal factors that influence predicted performance: (1) surface anharmonic dynamics, (2) interface and surface energy penalties, (3) mechanical stress under confinement, and (4) the presence of native surface oxide. Approaches for addressing these factors are demonstrated on model materials representative of high-capacity hydrogen storage systems, and implications for understanding performance under operating conditions are discussed.

08 HYDROGEN↗

Structure and Negative Thermal Expansion in Zr 0.3 Sc 1.7 Mo 2.7 V 0.3 O 12

A 2 M 3 O 12 -based materials have received considerable attention owing to their wide range of negative thermal expansion (NTE) and chemical flexibility toward novel materials design. However, the structure and NTE mechanism remain challenging. In this paper, Zr 4+ and V 5+ are used as a unit to compensatorily replace Sc 3+ and Mo 6+ in Sc 2 Mo 3 O 12 to tune its thermal expansion. Its crystal structure, phase transition, NTE property, and corresponding mechanisms are studied by high-resolution synchrotron X-ray diffraction, powder X-ray diffraction, ultralow-frequency Raman spectroscopy, and density functional theory calculations. The results show that Zr 0.3 Sc 1.7 Mo 2.7 V 0.3 O 12 adopts an orthorhombic (Pbcn) structure at room temperature, with V atoms occupying the position of Mo1 atoms and Zr atoms occupying the position of Sc atoms, and transforms to monoclinic (P2 1 /a) structure at similar to ~133 K (45 K lower than that of Sc 2 Mo 3 O 12 ). It exhibits excellent NTE in a broader range. Most of the phonon modes below 350 cm -1 have negative Grüneisen parameters, of which the lowest and next-lowest frequency (38.5 and 45.8 cm -1 ) optical phonon modes arising from the translational vibrations of the Sc/Zr and Mo/V atoms in the plane of the nonlinear linkage Sc/Zr-O-Mo/V have the largest and next-largest negative Grüneisen parameters and positive total anharmonicity, and contribute most to the NTE.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Electronic and Thermal Properties of the Cation Substitution-Derived Quaternary Chalcogenide CuInSnSe 4

Quaternary chalcogenides continue to be of interest for a variety of technological applications, with physical properties stemming from their structural complexity and stoichiometric variation. In certain structure types, partial vacancies on specific lattice positions present an opportunity to investigate electrical and thermal properties in light of these lattice defects. In this work, we investigated the structural, thermal, and electronic properties of CuInSnSe 4 , a material that belongs to a relatively unexplored class of quaternary chalcogenides with a defect adamantine crystal structure. First-principles calculations together with experimental measurements revealed a chalcopyrite-like structure with inherent vacancies and characteristic s–p and p–d orbital hybridizations in the electronic structure of the material. Cation disorder and lattice anharmonicity result in very low thermal conductivity with values significantly lower than those for related compositions. In conclusion, this work reveals the fundamental physical properties of a previously uninvestigated quaternary chalcogenide and may aid investigations of similar as well as other quaternary chalcogenide compositions.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Interplay between Cation “Coloring” and Stereochemically Active Lone Pairs in AgBiS 2 Thin Films

Solution-processed AgBiS 2 thin films were fabricated using novel thiol− amine precursor inks to investigate the stereochemical activity of Bi 3+ 6s 2 lone pairs and their impact on the structure. A dual-space analysis combining Bragg diffraction and hard X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (HAXPES) revealed a rock salt-like average structure with local distortions linked to cation coloring. Density functional theory (DFT) and crystal orbital Hamilton population (COHP) analyses confirmed that local Bi-rich and Ag-rich nanodomains amplify stereochemical activity, whereas more mixed and cation-order nanodomains are less stereochemically active. This local, nanoscopic mixing of segregated and ordered domains would indeed explain an average Fm3̅m structure that is rock salt-like and that does not manifest the full anharmonicity and noncentrosymmetry evidenced in canonical structures with stereochemical expression. These findings provide insights into the local structural and electronic complexities governing the optoelectronic properties of AgBiS 2 thin films.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Nuclear–Electronic Orbital QM/MM Approach: Geometry Optimizations and Molecular Dynamics

Hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) methods allow simulations of chemical reactions in atomistic solvent and heterogeneous environments such as proteins. Herein, the nuclear–electronic orbital (NEO) QM/MM approach is introduced to enable the quantization of specified nuclei, typically protons, in the QM region using a method such as NEO-density functional theory (NEO-DFT). This approach includes proton delocalization, polarization, anharmonicity, and zero-point energy in geometry optimizations and dynamics. Expressions for the energies and analytical gradients associated with the NEO-QM/MM method, as well as the previously developed polarizable continuum model (NEO-PCM), are provided. Geometry optimizations of small organic molecules hydrogen bonded to water in either dielectric continuum solvent or explicit atomistic solvent illustrate that aqueous solvation can strengthen hydrogen-bonding interactions for the systems studied, as indicated by shorter intermolecular distances at the hydrogen-bond interface. We then performed a real-time direct dynamics simulation of a phenol molecule in explicit water using the NEO-QM/MM method. Furthermore, these developments and initial examples provide the foundation for future studies of nuclear–electronic quantum dynamics in complex chemical and biological environments.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Mode-Selective Vibrational Energy Transfer Dynamics in 1,3,5-Trinitroperhydro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX) Thin Films

The coupling of inter- and intramolecular vibrations plays a critical role in initiating chemistry during the shock-to-detonation transition in energetic materials. In this work, we report on the subpicosecond to subnanosecond vibrational energy transfer (VET) dynamics of the solid energetic material 1,3,5-trinitroperhydro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX) by using broadband, ultrafast infrared transient absorption spectroscopy. Experiments reveal VET occurring on three distinct time scales: subpicosecond, 5 ps, and 200 ps. The ultrafast appearance of signal at all probed modes in the mid-infrared suggests strong anharmonic coupling of all vibrations in the solid, whereas the long-lived evolution demonstrates that VET is incomplete, and thus thermal equilibrium is not attained, even on the 100 ps time scale. Density functional theory and classical molecular dynamics simulations provide valuable insights into the experimental observations, revealing compression-insensitive time scales for the initial VET dynamics of high-frequency vibrations and drastically extended relaxation times for low-frequency phonon modes under lattice compression. Mode selectivity of the longest dynamics suggests coupling of the N–N and axial NO2 stretching modes with the long-lived, excited phonon bath.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

High-Accuracy Heats of Formation for Alkane Oxidation: From Small to Large via the Automated CBH-ANL Method

It is generally challenging to obtain high-accuracy predictions for the heat of formation for species with more than a handful of heavy atoms, such as those of importance in standard combustion mechanisms. To this end, we construct the CBH-ANL approach and illustrate that, for a set of 194 alkane oxidation species, it can be used to produce ΔH f (o K) values with 2σ uncertainties of 0.2-0.5 kcal mol -1 . This set includes the alkanes, hydroperoxides, and alkyl, peroxy, and hydroperoxyalkyl radicals for 17 representative hydrocarbon fuels containing up to 10 heavy atoms with various degrees of branching in the alkane backbone. The CBH-ANL approach, automated in the QTC and AutoMech software suites, builds balanced chemical equations for the calculation of ΔH f (o K), in which the reference species may be up to five heavy atoms. The high-level ANLo and ANL1 reference ΔH f (o K) values are further refined for even the largest of these reference species with a novel laddering approach. We perform a comprehensive quantification of the uncertainties for both the individual reference species (the largest of which is 0.15 kcal mol -1 ) and the propagation of those uncertainties when used in the calculation of ΔH f (o K) for the 194 target species. Here we examine the sensitivity of the predicted ΔH f (o K) values to (i) electronic energies from various methods, including ωB97X-D/cc-pVTZ, B2PLYP-D3/cc-pVTZ, CCSD(T)-F12b/cc-pVDZ-F12//B2PLYP-D3/cc-pVTZ, and CCSD(T)-F12b/cc-pVTZ-F12//B2PLYP-D3/cc-pVTZ; (ii) the zero-point vibrational energies (ZPVEs), where we consider harmonic ZPVEs as well as two scaling-based estimates of the anharmonic ZPVEs, all implemented for both ωB97X-D/cc-pVTZ and B2PLYP-D3/cc-pVTZ calculations; (iii) the particular CBH-ANL scheme employed; and (iv) the procedure for choosing the reference conformer for the analyses. The discussion concludes with a summary of the estimated overall uncertainty in the predictions and a validation of the predictions for the alkane subset.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Molecular Cage Reports on Its Contents: Spectroscopic Signatures of Cryo-Cooled K + - and Ba 2+ -Benzocryptand Complexes

UV photofragment spectroscopy and IR–UV double resonance methods are used to determine the structure and spectroscopic responses of a three-dimensional [2.2.2]-benzocryptand cage to the incorporation of a single K + or Ba 2+ imbedded inside it (labeled as K + -BzCrypt, Ba 2+ -BzCrypt). We studied the isolated ion-cryptand complex under cryo-cooled conditions, brought into the gas phase by nano-electrospray ionization. Incorporation of a phenyl ring in place of the central ethyl group in one of the three N-CH 2 -CH 2 -O-CH 2 -CH 2 -O-CH 2 -CH 2 -N chains provides a UV chromophore whose S 0 –S 1 transition we probe. K + -BzCrypt and Ba 2+ -BzCrypt have their S 0 –S 1 origin transitions at 35,925 and 36,446 cm –1 , respectively, blue-shifted by 174 and 695 cm –1 from that of 1,2-dimethoxybenzene. These origins are used to excite a single conformation of each complex selectively and record their IR spectra using IR–UV dip spectroscopy. The alkyl CH stretch region (2800–3000 cm –1 ) is surprisingly sensitive to the presence and nature of the encapsulated ion. We carried out an exhaustive conformational search of cage conformations for K + -BzCrypt and Ba 2+ -BzCrypt, identifying two conformations (A and B) that lie below all others in energy. Here, we extend our local mode anharmonic model of the CH stretch region to these strongly bound ion-cage complexes to predict conformation-specific alkyl CH stretch spectra, obtaining quantitative agreement with experiment for conformer A, the gas-phase global minimum. The large electrostatic effect of the charge on the O- and N-lone pairs affects the local mode frequencies of the CH 2 groups adjacent to these atoms. The localized CH 2 scissors modes are pushed up in frequency by the adjacent O/N-atoms so that their overtones have little effect on the alkyl CH stretch region. However, the localized CH 2 wags are nearly degenerate and strongly coupled to one another, producing an array of delocalized wag normal modes, whose highest frequency members reach up above 1400 cm –1 . As such, their overtones mix significantly with the CH stretch modes, most notably involving the CH 2 symmetric stretch fundamentals of the central ethyl groups in the all-alkyl chains and the CH stretches adjacent to the N-atoms and antiperiplanar to the nitrogen lone pair.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Ab Initio-Based Bond Order Potential for Arsenene Polymorphs Developed via Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning

Arsenene, a less-explored two-dimensional material, holds the potential for applications in wearable electronics, memory devices, and quantum systems. This study introduces a bond-order potential model with Tersoff formalism, the ML-Tersoff, which leverages multireward hierarchical reinforcement learning (RL), trained on an ab initio data set. This data set covers a spectrum of properties for arsenene polymorphs, enhancing our understanding of its mechanical and thermal behaviors without the complexities of traditional models requiring multiple parameter sets. Our RL strategy utilizes decision trees coupled with a hierarchical reward strategy to accelerate convergence in high-dimensional continuous search spaces. Unlike the Stillinger-Weber approach, which demands separate formalisms for buckled and puckered forms, the ML-Tersoff model concurrently captures multiple properties of the two polymorphs by effectively representing the local environment, thereby avoiding the need for different atomic types. Here, we apply the ML model to understand the mechanical and thermal properties of the arsenene polymorphs and nanostructures. We observe an inverse relationship between the critical strain and temperature in arsenene. Thermal conductivity calculations in nanosheets show good agreement with ab initio data, reflecting a decrease in thermal conductivity attributable to increased anharmonic effects at higher temperatures. We also apply the model to predict the thermal behavior of arsenene nanotubes.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Infrared Fingerprint and Unimolecular Decay Dynamics of the Hydroperoxyalkyl Intermediate (•QOOH) in Cyclopentane Oxidation

A transient carbon-centered hydroperoxyalkyl intermediate (•QOOH) in the oxidation of cyclopentane is identified by IR action spectroscopy with time-resolved unimolecular decay to hydroxyl (OH) radical products that are detected by UV laser-induced fluorescence. Two nearly degenerate •QOOH isomers, β- and γ-QOOH, are generated by H atom abstraction of the cyclopentyl hydroperoxide precursor. Fundamental and first overtone OH stretch transitions and combination bands of •QOOH are observed and compared with anharmonic frequencies computed by second-order vibrational perturbation theory. An OH stretch transition is also observed for a conformer arising from torsion about a low-energy CCOO barrier. Definitive identification of the β-QOOH isomer relies on its significantly lower transition state (TS) barrier to OH products, which results in rapid unimolecular decay and near unity branching to OH products. A benchmarking approach is utilized to compute high-accuracy stationary point energies, most importantly TS barriers, for cyclopentane oxidation (C 5 H 9 O 2 ), building on higher level reference calculations for ethane oxidation (C 2 H 5 O 2 ). The experimental OH product appearance rates are compared with computed statistical microcanonical rates using RRKM theory, including heavy-atom tunneling, thereby validating the computed TS barrier. The results are extended to thermal unimolecular decay rate constants at temperatures and pressures relevant to cyclopentane combustion via master-equation modeling. Furthermore, the various torsional and ring puckering states of the wells and transition states are explicitly considered in these calculations.

Chemical calculations↗

Discrepancies between Theory and Experiment in Determining the Ionization Energy of NF 3

High-accuracy ab initio thermochemical predictions for the ionization energy of NF 3 , the barrier height (to inversion) of NF 3 + , and the dissociative ionization threshold of NF 3 to NF 2 + + F are presented and incorporated into Active Thermochemical Tables. The adiabatic ionization energy of the first ionization band of NF 3 , calculated at 12.647 ± 0.010 eV, is at odds with previous experimental interpretations by nearly 0.36 eV due to unfavorable Franck-Condon factors associated with this transition. The barrier (to inversion) height is calculated to be about 0.6 eV lower in energy than the prior interpretation, which instigates a discussion of the supposed vibrational structure of the first ionization band of NF 3 . Updated assignments of the photoelectron spectrum are proposed, and the loss in vibrational spacing on the high-energy side of the experimental ionization band is discussed. Rudimentary anharmonic Franck-Condon simulations qualitatively reproduce the broad spectral features observed in experiment.

Active Thermochemical Tables↗

The Reaction Rates of Amidogen and Ammonia with Nitrous Oxide: Implications for Combustion Mechanisms

Pulsed laser photolysis experiments with laser-induced fluorescence detection of NH 2 set an upper limit to the rate constant for reaction with N 2 O of k < 1 × 10 −15 cm 3 molecule −1 s −1 at 513 K. Computations were based on geometries and anharmonic frequency analysis (B2PLYP-D3/cc-pVTZ) followed by coupled cluster calculations extrapolated to the infinite basis set limit, with corrections for core−valence electron correlation, scalar relativistic effects, and correlation up to CCSDT(Q). Species that showed multireference character were quantified with MRCI(7,7)+Q/cc-pVTZ theory. Rate constants were obtained for the dominant product channel H 2 NN + NO, along with HN 3 + OH, H 2 NO + N 2 , NNH + HNO, ON(NH) 2 and HNNH + NO. The last channel is slow even at 2500 K, contrary to an early empirical estimate and confirming recent suggestions. Modeling of literature experiments on oxidation of NH 3 by N 2 O shows that all channels are too slow to make a significant impact on the loss of N 2 O in ammonia flames. Similarly, the direct NH 3 + N 2 O reaction is found to be negligibly slow.

Ammonia↗

Characterization of Two Positional Isomers of the Cs + Gly Complex Using Two-Color, IR–IR Photobleaching of the Cryogenically Cooled Ions

Metal ion binding to amino acid residues is an important interaction motif that controls the tertiary structures of oligopeptides. Analyses of the vibrational band patterns displayed by the amino acid scaffolds are commonly used to characterize the local docking motifs. Here we carry out two-color, IR-IR photobleaching measurements to obtain isomer-selective vibrational spectra of the Cs + Gly ion-molecule complex isolated in a cryogenically cooled, radiofrequency ion trap. The distinct band patterns of two non-interconverting isomers are observed and traced to different bidentate binding motifs between Cs + and the glycine scaffold. In one isomer, the ion attaches to the oxygen atoms of the carboxyl group whereas in the other it docks to the amino nitrogen and the carbonyl oxygen. Attachment to the acid head group yields a very diffuse absorption associated the OH group engaged in a strong intramolecular H-bond that closes a 5 membered ring. Furthermore, the band assignments, rearrangement pathways and electrostatic distortion of the electron density distributions in the glycine scaffold by the proximal ion are explored with electronic structure calculations and anharmonic theory.

Infrared spectroscopy↗

Bond Dissociation Energies of the Actinide Halides AnX, An = Ac–Lr and X = F–I, Utilizing Relativistic Composite Coupled Cluster Approaches

Bond dissociation energies (BDEs) have been calculated for the set of actinide halides AnX with An=Ac, Pa, and Np-Lr and X=F-I. Two composite thermochemistry methods based on the Feller-Peterson-Dixon (FPD) approach have been utilized, one involving spinor-based relativistic CCSD(T) calculations where spin-orbit (SO) was included at the orbital level and another using scalar relativistic CCSD(T) with a posteriori SO contributions based on 2-component multireference configuration interaction calculations. The method that was chosen for a given actinide halide was based on which representation yielded the best single determinant reference determinant for the coupled cluster calculation. The spinor-based method was chosen for all cases except for AmX, CmX, and BkX. Both composite approaches included contributions accounting for basis set truncation, outer-core correlation, the Gaunt interaction, and QED. The scalar FPD results, as well as the spinor-based calculations for AcF, also included higher order electron correlation up through CCSDT(Q). In addition to BDEs, CCSD(T) equilibrium bond lengths, harmonic frequencies, and vibrational anharmonicity constants are reported for all species. Last, the FPD BDEs for the fluorides were used to confirm the trend across the actinide series previously predicted by Gibson using bonding models based atomic promotion energies that provide a single 6d electron for bonding. In particular the local minimum in the BDEs at AmF is confirmed in the present calculations. Furthermore, the BDEs for LrX are predicted to be slightly larger than those of AcX, making them the largest in the actinide halide series.

Actinides↗

Behavior of Long-Chain Hydrocarbons at High Pressures and Temperatures

Although long-chain aliphatic hydrocarbons are documented in meteorites, their origin is poorly understood. A key question is whether they are pristine or a byproduct of terrestrial alteration? Thus, to understand if these long-chain hydrocarbons are indigenous, it will be important to explore their thermodynamic and mechanical stability at conditions experienced by extraterrestrial objects during atmospheric entry and passage. Extreme pressures and temperatures experienced by meteorites are likely to alter the molecular organization of these long-chain hydrocarbons. These structural changes associated with extreme conditions are often documented via laboratory-based Raman spectroscopic measurements. So far, Raman spectroscopic measurements have investigated the effect of static compression on the aliphatic hydrocarbons. The effect of temperature on the structural changes remains poorly explored. To bridge this gap, in this study, we have explored the behavior of two aliphatic hydrocarbons at simultaneously high pressures and temperatures. We have used a resistively heated diamond anvil cell. On compression to moderate pressures, the appearance of new vibrational modes in the low-energy region confirms prior studies and is related to the bending of the linear chains. Upon heating to ~220 °C, we note that the new low-energy mode undergoes softening. The mode softening is likely due to the combination of unbending of the alkane chain and mode anharmonicity.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗

Correctly Assessing Defect Tolerance in Halide Perovskites

The notion of “defect tolerance” has often been invoked to explain the excellent performance of halide perovskites in optoelectronic applications. However, this concept has not been rigorously defined or assessed. A common interpretation is that all of the energetically favorable intrinsic defects are shallow. On the basis of examples in the prototypical halide perovskite CsPbI 3 , we show that this is not the case. The antisite defects Pb I and I Pb are energetically favorable, but also have levels deep in the band gap. Still, because of strong anharmonicity, they are not efficient nonradiative recombination centers. Here, our study demonstrates how to correctly evaluate the “defect tolerance” of halide perovskites.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗